[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Search] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/co/ - Comics & Cartoons



Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.



So apparently Infinity War ripped off the Naboo Battle from Phantom Menace for Wakanda. Defend this MCU faggots.
>>
>>101085826
>Sci-fi battle scene has formations and energy shields

This is really reaching for reasons to get mad.
>>
>George Lucas invented army formations
>>
File: Good goyim.jpg (66 KB, 349x353)
66 KB
66 KB JPG
>>101085849
>>101085883
>>
>>101085849
>Open Field
>Energy Shield & Barrier
>Giant army
>Enemy Get throw
>Cluster battle.
>Everything almost same cutsceens
This is called copying. Or now the new trend "tracing".
>>
>>101085883
More like standing in vague lines in the Phantom Menace
>>
>>101085826
That's racist. Pointing that out is racist. You're a bigot now.
>>
>Disney movie ripped off Disney (except not at the time of release) movie
>>
>>101085826
>LOOK AT THOSE BATTLEFIELDS! THEY ARE THE SAME! SOLDIERS ARE USED IN BOTH SIDES REEEEEEE HOW WILL THE MCU EVER RECOVER?!

Go fuck yourself DC drone
>>
>>101085826

I pointed it out the first time, but I also said it was reversed, the Nigros were cooler than the hound things, and in SW the droids where cooler than the Shitgans.
>>
>>101085968
Never go full retard.
>>
>>101085915
>Everything almost same cutsceens
Are you hoping that no one remembers PM?
>>
>>101086022
>D-DC drone

Faggot are seriously that asshurt about criticism? Anyone that has some to point out about the MCU automatically makes them DC? Kek. Fuck off Comiccast
>>
>>101086089
>i-im im not a DC fan, Marlel is bad REEEEEEEEEE

Cry more drone.
>>
>>101085826
Wakanda is so dumb
>>
>>101086127
>DC Boogyman.
>>
>>101086073
he's got good odds
>>
>>101085826
There were some shots that looked similar to the Man of Steel world engine scene
>>
Next you will sat that Narnia was a copy of Phanton Menace because the battle was on a open field.
>>
>>101086240
Faggot are you even looking at the images?
>>
>>101085826
I cant wait for this "MUH tactipoo" "muh saifai elements" era to end. I hope normies's discovery of Dr Strange ushers more magic capeshit.
>>
>>101086073
PM is pure kino thanks to nuWars.
>>
>>101086402
This.
>>
>>101085915
Could it be because they are both based on Roman battle tactics/formations? Hmmm...
>>
at this point, who even cares.
Artistic integrity is rapidly becoming more and more irrelevant
Chinese knockoffs are more successful than the originals
pubg was superseded by fortnite which might be superseded by "realm royale".
Industries are finally realizing that current generation doesnt give a fuck anymore
if its accessible and polished, then who gives a shit if it's "unoriginal"
media is a joke
pop culture and pop art is a joke
might as well stop clinging onto the "b-b-but [x] did it first" crutch and embrace the calarts style
I barely even care what the thread is about
>>
>>101085826
I mean, the biggest reason that this battle didn't really remind me of the Naboo one at all, besides outriders being very different in terms of combat style to droids, and the lack of mounts on the wakandan side, was how the Phantom menace battlefield was a practically featureless green field, with practically featureless green hills in the background.

That's what I'll always remember about that battle, the sterility of it. On the other hand, Wakanda gives a great sense of context with the city in the background, the clarity of how they are on the upper ground, the features of .the pond at the bottom of the hill, and the forested region higher up. Add to that how ferocious the outriders attacked, which defined how the heroes had to respond, and you have two battles that despite a couple of superficial sci-fi similarities, don't feel the same at all.
>>
>>101085826
nobody cares about Phantom Menace, so there's no problem
>>
>>101085915
>Open Field
>Giant army
Well there you're literally just listing things that movie war scenes have, especially fantasy and sci-fi ones. An open battlefield gives opposing forces a clear shot at each other, making for some clear imagery for the viewer of the scale of what's happening.
>>
>>101085826
The Gungans had better tactics. Stayed in formation and only got fucked because battle droids can go through forcefields.

Wakandans broke formation, made a choke point but charged in anyway instead of shooting them, then they were fucked anyway because of encirclement.
>>
>>101085826
>being this ignorant of history
>>
File: working class scum.jpg (17 KB, 302x302)
17 KB
17 KB JPG
>>101086619
>marvel comics
>history
>>
File: marvel mutt.jpg (89 KB, 741x649)
89 KB
89 KB JPG
>>
>>101086089
>DCshill with broken English
IMAGINE MY SHOCK
>>
>>101086810
so you're saying Wakbattle must have ripped off PM because MCU couldn't possibly know about how historical battle lines worked?
>>
>>101086581
Like how you ignored the other things.
>>
>>101086995
They had energy barriers in the Roman days?
>>
>>101086995
>historical battle
>marvel movie
You are literary retard. kys
>>
>>101085915
>thow

great post, great thread, I'm so happy the mods let /tv/ faggots on our board
>>
>>101086402
shit doesnt become gold just because someone takes a bigger shit
>>
>>101087080
He said "throw", not "thow".
>>
>>101087080
Not even quoting correctly.
Kek. Retard.
>>
>>101087011
Because it was stupid for you to list those two at all. Just padding out a list that would look petty and superficial if you were honest about it.
>>
>>101087223
Cry more.
>>
>>101087238
No u
>>
>>101087265
>N-No
>>
>>101087852
Cry more.
>>
>>101085826
I just came here to say that the Phantom Menace is a much better film than Black Panther, Infinity War, or any other MCU film
>>
>>101086585
Exactly. Every military decision the Wakandans made was wrong.

>putting your entire army in one position and literally leaving no one to guard your rear or flanks
>army is only a couple hundred people
>using weapons that have no sights and need to be eyeballed to aim (this is like the Jaffa staff weapons in Stargate - they are explicitly called 'a weapon of terror [meant to] intimidate the enemy' whereas guns are 'a weapon of war, designed to kill the enemy', Of course, the Jaffa are a feudal-age civilization given guns and told to suppress nations weaker than themselves, or kill each other for the pissing contests of their rulers. The Wakandans have no excuse.
>no artillery, one gunship for air support, no armour for fire support
>not attempting to fire on the transports to suppress/kill emerging troops
>seeing the enemy flanking them and creating a chokepoint - that's good! But... nothing stops the enemy from STILL flanking you while you're engaged with their primary force.
>having the enemy come through a chokepoint and giving up range and position to charge (and wear down your stamina from running) to engage melee monsters in melee.

In the Wakandans were fighting an enemy that could shoot back, they'd be fucked. Say, an enemy that could roll APCs through the shield and let their troops out, hale and hearty. The Wakandans did everything in their power to lose the battle and until Thor arrived, that's exactly what happened.
>>
>>101088093
anon, we cant really understand what you are saying with that big cock in your mouth.
take it out and try again
>>
Prequelfaggotry is making me like Disneywars more.
>>
>>101085910

Not an argument.
>>
>>101085826

>Having battles in a field
>Using shields and turtling

This isn't new, that's very old. That's how the vast majority of dickhead generals chose to do 'honorable' battle for millenia, ignoring the great success achieved when coming up with something a bit more tactical.

WWI was literally such a bloodbath because our mentally deficient hierarchy literally thought we could run from one side of the field to the other, in the age of the automatic machine gun. For THREE years. THREE WHOLE YEARS.
>>
>>101086089
>Stating wars have soldiers and ear in it is criticism
Wow
>>
>>101088754
STautist this asshurt about being irrelevant. St is so shit not even the shit toys are making money from kids. Kek.

Seriously ST toys are like 3 dollars. Shirts like 4-5
>>
>>101088882
>source: my ass
Summerfaggotry is in full swing.
>>
>>101085915
>really generic characteristics
>vague unsubstantiated claim
Wow, you really showed him
>>
>>101087034
>>101087037
So you're just going to complete ignore what he actually said?
>>
File: maxresdefault (33).jpg (128 KB, 1280x720)
128 KB
128 KB JPG
>>101088907
Here you go.
https://www.google.com/amp/amp.timeinc.net/fortune/2018/03/28/hasbro-star-wars-toys
>>
>>101088950
The images speak for themselves.
>>
>>101085826
if you are trying to find something to hate about this movie or the mcu as a whole, this is a stupid thing to care about
>>
You can probably take the same shots from LotR and Narnia. What a retarded thing to get mad about.
>>
File: file.png (2.99 MB, 1280x958)
2.99 MB
2.99 MB PNG
>>101089224
The non-comparable images of devices that have existed in the marvel canon since the 90s? About two scenes that look absolutely nothing alike beyond the fact that they draw influence of historical war formations that are still used today
>>
>>101085826
Yes, your argument shows that MCU thinks the prequels are better than the Disney Trilogy.
>>
>>101085826
Allegation denied. Reason: no combined arms use on either side of the Wakandan battle.
>>
>>101085826
I don't have a problem with it looking like Phantom Menace, I have a problem with the fact that the big battles in both Infinity War and Black Panther were on wide flat open plains. Trying too hard to be Game Of Thrones. They're superheroes, I want to see more one on one shit.
>>
>>101085910
Don't have an argument? Blame the Jews!
>>
>>101085826
>mfw someone spent time of his life making this thread.
>>
>niggers steal an idea and claim it as their own

why are you suprised
>>
>>101086402
PM was always pure kino you are just contranian pleb
>>
>>101087080
that's not how you greentext newfriend
>>
>>101088882
he didnt say he was an ST
he said prequelfaggotry made ST look better.
He just likes your tears




Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.