[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/u/ - Yuri


Name
Spoiler?[]
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File[]
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • There are 120 posters in this thread.

05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
06/20/16New 4chan Banner Contest with a chance to win a 4chan Pass! See the contest page for details.
[Hide] [Show All]




File: hq.jpg (27 KB, 1024x575)
27 KB
27 KB JPG
Anything with the Auntie, please. I can't believe there's nothing about her actually exists.
>>
File: 72007206_p0.jpg (297 KB, 700x990)
297 KB
297 KB JPG
>>2826348
Pic related is literally the only yuri there is of her.
Such a shame, there are so many possible scenarios involving Auntie. Her seducing Shouko or that female police officer, her molesting loli Satou or even teen Satou, her fucking all the inmates and guards in prison...
>>
>>2826369

That's really sad when the best girl gets no attention at all. That is the absolute state of /a today: normies, normies and nothing but normies.

Anyway, thanks for this one, bro. Maybe someday I'll become a godtier /u artist and make a lot of stuff with her.
>>
File: 1504738732461.png (547 KB, 1280x720)
547 KB
547 KB PNG
>No doujin where Shio's mom gets arrested and meets Auntie in prison
>No doujin where Auntie repeatedly rapes Yuna until she enjoys it
>No doujin where they spend the rest of their lives passionately making love while the inmates and female prison guards watch

Bitter...so...bitter.
>>
>>2826399
This, so much this. They were made for each other. Yuuna absolutely needs Auntie's love to be healed from all the shit she went through in her life. There is no love more beautiful than the one between two milfs.
>>
File: smug_kyouko.png (390 KB, 498x710)
390 KB
390 KB PNG
>>2826377
>normies
Lurk more.
>>
File: 1531703009639.jpg (610 KB, 1350x1911)
610 KB
610 KB JPG
What happened to the scanlation?
>>
>>2831291
>YenPress. This title will be released on May 21, 2019.
Buy the book
>>
>>2831294
>Buy the book
>>
File: smug sayaka.jpg (110 KB, 817x817)
110 KB
110 KB JPG
>>2831294
>buying
>>
>>2831291
Shio looks so fucking smug there. I guess I'd be pretty smug if Satou was my waifu.
>>
>perfect body
>perfect eyes
>perfect char
>no doujins at all

Literally, what's so wrong with this world?
>>
>>2833242
Doujin artists don't care for anything other than meme waifus of the moment. And Auntie is probably too scary for them.
>>
>>2833254

Sometimes I really feel like I'm not belong to human race since I find her cute and sexy af.
>>
>>2833282
It's just natural. She combines the inconditional love of a mother with the temptation of uninhibited sexuality, with a taste of madness of course.
>>
>>2833287
>mother
>sexuality
>madness

She was made for usual 4chan user.
>>
File: large.jpg (54 KB, 750x818)
54 KB
54 KB JPG
>>2833282
>I find her cute and sexy af.
It's because she's cute and sexy, and as anon said >>2833287 I had not thought about that, but it makes a lot of sense.
Also, look at that smile, her prison adventures are necessary.
>>
File: 70649798_p0.jpg (202 KB, 1280x800)
202 KB
202 KB JPG
Reminder that Shouko did nothing wrong, and her love is what saved Satou in the end.
>>
File: 818.jpg (53 KB, 680x680)
53 KB
53 KB JPG
>>2840408
What a shit opinion.
>>
>>2842533
Not even an opinion, it's the cold hard truth.
>>
File: 1548988271845.jpg (103 KB, 291x388)
103 KB
103 KB JPG
>>2842550
>>
>>2842551
>>
>>2840408
Other than being a hetbitch that chose a homeless kid she just met over her best friend.
>>
>>2842621
It's okay because it all turned out fine in the end.
>>
>>2840408
Shitko singlehandedly ruined everyone's lives while trying to help them.
>>
>>2842800
It was meant to happen one way or another anyway.
>>
Shoukos death was when this show jumped the shark.
>>
>>2842976
not really, it was something that was coming.

>>2842621
>>2842800
being honest, she was just trying to help just one person, she was not really thinking about Sato's happiness.
>>
>>2842976
Quite the opposite, it was the highest point in the show. The scene was absolutely beautiful.
>>
File: 72314975_p0.jpg (221 KB, 1000x1000)
221 KB
221 KB JPG
Satou and Shouko would make a cute couple. Maybe they're together in the afterlife (aka Shio's soul) now.
>>
>>2848215
One sided loves never end up well.
>>
>>2853512
It never end up well for everyone. No one had to die, if this was avoided then Shouko would understood Satou love for Shio and try to bridge gapper on bring everyone close.
>>
Have any new chapters been scanned yet? It's been quite a few months so I wouldn't be surprised if the manga's ended by now.
>>
>>2855047
The manga is on chapter 46 currently, 7 chapters more than have been translated. There's no good raws in Japanese and the existing albums I found were downscaled, so I had to manually grab the chinese pages. Dropped the Missing Link chapters in in case people missed them, since they had some cute stuff.
https://mega.nz/#F!L7wklCgY!5jHo3GNfGmNDtlJN8Pk1iA
>>
File: 2342343734534.jpg (143 KB, 683x649)
143 KB
143 KB JPG
>>2826377

agreed, foxy grandma is where its at. though im not sure if this series even has much fan art in the first place.
>>
>>2842976

it was the guillotine gorilla of the series.
>>
>>2855249
Thanks!
>>
Some new chapters have been translated, I think.
>>
>>2840408
Not jumping into Aunty's love dungeon is wrong no matter how you look at it.

>>2833295
Can confirm. Satou and Shio's story is decent, but Aunty steals the show whenever she appears.
>>
>>2855254
I wish she would've fucked the female cop instead.
>>
>>2842621
Isn't auntie a bislut too
>>
>>2855255
I do not know what is worse, the reference or that I know what that same reference is.

>>2859354
>but Aunty steals the show whenever she appears.
Can you blame anyone? she is the combination of elements that I never thought they could put together so well.

>>2859507
Nothing says otherwise, I think... her adventures in prison deserve a Spin-off.

>>2859562
I'm not sure if she also falls into the category, "everything that moves"
>>
>>2859562
Let's go with omnifag.
>>
File: 1538930523806.jpg (153 KB, 480x303)
153 KB
153 KB JPG
I wonder what happened to Shio after the end of the series. I mean, she's pretty much a non-person, I don't think anyone besides her family and Satou even knew she existed.
>>
File: 70351620_p0.jpg (684 KB, 2480x3508)
684 KB
684 KB JPG
>>
>>2842800
>>2842621
>>2842533
The only thing Shouko did wrong was not running away as fast as she could immediately after taking the pic. In fact, she didn't even need the photo, Asahi would have believed her word.
>>
>>2861060
I assume that they have her on record now since they took her to the hospital. What they do with her afterwards is a good question. Does she go back to her mother? Become a ward of the state?
>>
>>2868202
Asahi obviously claimed her as family member but with a mentally unstable an poor mother theres no chance that the state don't take custody for her and Asahi.
>>
What would Auntie's pussy smell and taste like?
>>
>>2868436
Dead fish that's been rotting for several months.
>>
>>2868436
Let's just say the answer is not particularly /u/.
>>
>>2872579
After a few months in prison, that non-/u/ smell will wear off, and her fingers and mouth will probably smell very /u/-related.
>>
>>
>>2868142
>shoukofags wishing shouko was even more of a yuri-ruining hetslut
Can't say I'm surprised.
>>
>>2878698
She didn't ruin anything, in fact she made Satou find the truth she was looking for since the beginning of the series, the best possible ending.
>>
File: 70131099_p0.jpg (467 KB, 600x800)
467 KB
467 KB JPG
>>
File: 70882255_p0.jpg (2.41 MB, 2300x1851)
2.41 MB
2.41 MB JPG
>>
Why couldn't they die together? Why was Satou so selfish? I'm so fucking sad.
>>
>>2887279
Sacrificing yourself to save another life is the opposite of selfish. Satou understood this right before she died and decided that Shio should decide how to live her own life.
>>
>>2887292
But Shio wanted for them to be together in death. It was selfish of Satou to take that away from her. Shio ended up broken and all alone in a shitty world. Worst ending.
>>
>>2887292
>>2887309
And don't tell me Satou exists inside of her because that's retarded
>>
>>2887309
Shio has a whole life ahead of her. She's a stupid child who knows nothing about the world, she has no business wanting to die at her age. Over time she will come to undrstand that Satou did the right thing, and regret not saving her as well.
>>
>>2887326
I don't know, anon. It didn't look to me like Shio was going to be okay.
>>
>>2887353
She will be when she finds her own loli to love.
>>
https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/news/2019-05-22/happy-sugar-life-horror-manga-ends-in-june/.146965
.
>>
>>2890231
>Horror Manga
Is this the official classification or are the Westerners being whiny again?
>>
>>2890403

How is it not horror unless you want to pedantic in using thriller
>>
>>2890404
I personally think it is an exaggeration to call it "horror" for so few deaths, especially the way in which the Japanese make horror.
>>
>>2890426
Death is not the only thing that makes up horror.
>>
>>2890431
even so the general atmosphere seems too soft for that, it is basically a romance, although there are people who do not see it that way.
>>
Golden ending.
>>
So... how much puss will Auntie be getting in prison?
>>
>>2894388
All of it. All of the inmates and guards will form lines to receive her infinite love every hour of every day.
>>
Just finished watching this anime, I loved it. The ending sucked though. I'm assuming it ended differently in the manga?
>>
>>2896159
Last chapter June 22, and then the wait for the scanlation.
>>
>>2896159
The ending was the best part, and I see the manga ending the samw way.
>>
File: 1474678108382.png (142 KB, 401x522)
142 KB
142 KB PNG
What would happen if Auntie and Kuu-chan met?
>>
>>2896159
The ending made it a masterpiece and made my cry.
>>
>>2890403
I remember it was described (in Satou's voice) as psycho-horror in the anime trailer.
>>
>>2897726
Days of non-stop sex?
>>
File: 71540277_p0.jpg (836 KB, 1600x1200)
836 KB
836 KB JPG
>>
File: 72923547_p0.jpg (225 KB, 566x800)
225 KB
225 KB JPG
>>
File: 71802142_p0.png (2.92 MB, 1847x2481)
2.92 MB
2.92 MB PNG
>>
File: 71624017_p0.jpg (1.07 MB, 1389x1060)
1.07 MB
1.07 MB JPG
>>
>>
>>
File: 73233499_p0.png (1.15 MB, 878x1240)
1.15 MB
1.15 MB PNG
>>
>>2900476
The cycle continues?
>>
>>2900570
I think that's an age swap.
>>
>>2903020
not really, the fandom really took this position seriously >>2900570 >>2900476
>>
File: 70919992_p0.jpg (447 KB, 820x937)
447 KB
447 KB JPG
https://mangadex.org/chapter/640238/1
>>
File: 1556160745263.jpg (43 KB, 413x474)
43 KB
43 KB JPG
>>2906174
That's not the same as the anime. Hoo boy.
>>
File: 70919992_p1.jpg (424 KB, 800x1093)
424 KB
424 KB JPG
>>2906318
It's only slightly different for now, but it will be interesting to see where this is going.
>>
File: 70044020_p0.jpg (760 KB, 850x1200)
760 KB
760 KB JPG
>>
File: 70919992_p2.jpg (491 KB, 1000x887)
491 KB
491 KB JPG
>>
File: 70919992_p4.jpg (478 KB, 900x819)
478 KB
478 KB JPG
>>
Scans when?
>>
File: 70919992_p5.jpg (509 KB, 800x935)
509 KB
509 KB JPG
>>
File: 73938260_p0.jpg (392 KB, 1200x708)
392 KB
392 KB JPG
>>
File: 75658344_p0.jpg (585 KB, 739x1024)
585 KB
585 KB JPG
>>
File: Spoiler Image (129 KB, 900x1280)
129 KB
129 KB JPG
>>
File: Spoiler Image (189 KB, 900x1280)
189 KB
189 KB JPG
>>
>>2930886
>>2930887
Satou 2.0 confirmed?
>>
>>2896159
>Squeenix
>Anime sad
Well color me surprised. Anyone wanna spoil it for me so I avoid the BD?
>>
>>2930929
Just watch it, it's great and the ending is perfect.
>>
>>2930886
>>2930887
>>2930918
Hard to say without translations/context
>>
>>2930950
Yes, a perfect storm of plot convenient nonsense.
>>
>>2931010
Everything happened as it was meant to be happen.
>>
>>2931017
Shio failing to comprehend the meaning of a happy sugar life without Sato in the custody of whatever the Japanese equivalent of child protective services is is not "meant to be happen." "She lives on in my heart" is the stupidest copout. If there's supposed to be a mono no aware spin on the notion of a happy sugar life, kill them both and actually provide closure to the story. And the fact that Asahi of all people miraculously survives unscathed is just the fuck you icing on the bitter cake.
>>
>>2931036
The closure to the story is Satou realising that her happy sugar life just wasn't meant to be. Her sacrificing herself so that Shio may live is the point where she actually comes to understand love by performing a selfless action. You may not like it, but that is the conclusion of the themes introduced at the beginning of the story. Shio will eventually try to crate her own hsl.
Also Asahi is the best character and he deserved to live.
>>
>>2930918
Seems to just be Shio talking about and treasuring <their place>
>even if it's broad/vast
>even if it's narrow/cramped
>even if it's close
>even if it's far
>even if it's painful
>even if it's bitter/hard, it's fine.

>tadaima
>>
>>2931049
>spoiler
Opinion discarded. Although he did get what he deserved.
>>
>>2931049
And what exactly determines whose happy sugar lives are meant to be, and whose aren't? And by what means is Shio going to "crate" her own happy sugar life? What is the nature of her existence beyond mere survival? If she's meant to find a loli of her own to kidnap, then it should have been shown. And it's asinine to think the best character is the one whose motivation is that he thinks his life will get better if he sleeps under benches and begs for change alongside a loli who only knew him when she was too young to remember, instead of aiming for a life where he doesn't have to sleep under benches and beg for change.
>>
>>2931383
>It would have never come to fruition
Sure it could have. The series obviously depicts the world as running on crazy, so the plan was crazy enough to work, in theory.
>It's more effective if we don't know exactly what she will do
No, that's noncommittal bullshit when the writers are averse to fully embracing tragedy and opt for disingenuous bittersweetness. If they want to leave something to imagination, they can leave the audience guessing whether Shio continues or breaks the cycle with her hypothetical kidnapped loli.
>he's the noblest character of the series
It's made plain as day that his underlying motivations are selfish, that he, just like everyone else, wants to use Shio as an idol. Sato is the only one who learns to acknowledge her and her autonomy, and while you could make a logical argument against affording such autonomy to such a young child, you have to consider that their world runs on crazy and its logic is a few steps removed from ours.
>>
>>2931493
>But also cynically, so happy fairy ale endings just wn't happen.
The key difference being that no one else has a happy sugar life to live for. Perhaps that alone isn't enough, but to establish that, Shio should have died, too.
>ending that leaves absolutely zero hope of things getting better
If Shio actually had something to live for, then her survival would be preferable to double suicide, but as it stands, she has nothing and no one but a bleak and absurd quest for understanding why Sato defied her own wish to die together. You can't live a life off of nostalgia, fulfillment requires new experiences. This is what I mean by disingenuous bittersweetness: we're meant to believe that it's a better outcome simply because there's fewer deaths, while not providing any reason to believe Shio's life will be worthwhile.
>But isn't that exactly what they did?
No, because the story does not provide any guidelines for what tangible hope she has. If anything, Shio is more likely to be abused or raped or killed instead of finding her answer given the utter openness to possibility and the nature of her world. By giving an indication of high school Shio meeting a loli, you provide a meaningful direction to the story and maintain thematic relevance by limiting the possibilities to a more narrow region than pure speculation.
>he's still just an abused, developmentally stunted kid
Being less outright deranged doesn't make him more noble than the other abused, developmentally stunted kids. Almost all the characters sought happiness in one form or another, but Sato was the only one who learned not to impose her happiness onto Shio (which was arguably unlearned when she saved her). It is at best ignorant negligence, and at worst delusional selfishness, for Asahi to think he was capable of saving and raising Shio.
>>
>>2930887
So she frees the loli, but the loli comes back years after?
>>
File: IMG_20190725_000541.jpg (61 KB, 797x733)
61 KB
61 KB JPG
>>2933454
What's there to know?
>>
File: Spoiler Image (75 KB, 1280x720)
75 KB
75 KB PNG
>>2933591
>>
>>2930886
Just how far behind is the scanlation?
>>
>>2937866
A few chapters. We're near the end either way.
>>
File: 76093605_p0.jpg (423 KB, 1105x900)
423 KB
423 KB JPG
>>
File: 75990948_p0.jpg (294 KB, 800x480)
294 KB
294 KB JPG
>>
File: 76135228_p0.jpg (549 KB, 1200x846)
549 KB
549 KB JPG
>>
Does the manga end the same as the anime?
>>
>>2953467
Possibly Yes.
>>
Apparently this is getting a special one-shot chapter next month and will focus and a pairing that won some sort of popularity poll? Can anyone verify this? Especially the bit about the popularity poll, because the only english source for this is ANN.
>>
>>2887309

shio is literally a child
>>
>>
File: 76172622_p0.jpg (488 KB, 1200x780)
488 KB
488 KB JPG




>>
File: 76234966_p0.jpg (551 KB, 1200x964)
551 KB
551 KB JPG
>>
File: 71199424_p0.png (1.38 MB, 825x880)
1.38 MB
1.38 MB PNG
>>
File: 76668554_p0.jpg (770 KB, 1200x1200)
770 KB
770 KB JPG
>>
How much puss do you think auntie is getting in jail?
>>
>>2978905
All of it, from the inmates, and the guards, and hopefully Yuuna's too.
>>
>>2959121
Very insightful observation, anon.
>>
>>2956746
Is it Auntie and Yuuna prison chapter?
>>
File: 76521781_p0.jpg (737 KB, 779x900)
737 KB
737 KB JPG
>>
>>2984263
We can only hope
>>
>>2894266
If only Sato won the argument
>>
>>2991099
The argument with Shouko after she catches them at the apartment.
>>
Did the manga end in Japan?
>>
>>2992993
Yeah, it ended in July, but no scanlations for the last few chapters.
>>
>>2993083
Fuck. Same ending as the anime?
>>
>>2993124
Of course. The entire thing was building towards that end.
>>
There's a final extra chapter released in September with the tankoubon but no idea what's, about
>>
File: 77079456_p0.jpg (513 KB, 800x594)
513 KB
513 KB JPG
>>
File: 77266605_p0.jpg (473 KB, 720x1064)
473 KB
473 KB JPG
>>
File: 77125136_p0.jpg (336 KB, 1200x1118)
336 KB
336 KB JPG
>>
>>2996637
Any news on this?
>>
File: 1566845144928.jpg (97 KB, 689x750)
97 KB
97 KB JPG
>>
Manga scanlation is finally complete, barring some apparent BD extras.
https://waterflamescans.tumblr.com/post/189000237861/happy-sugar-life-43-48end-is-out-you-can-read
>>
File: f39.png (1.19 MB, 1782x1280)
1.19 MB
1.19 MB PNG
>>3016037
I already liked the ending in the anime, but the manga had a lot more good stuff:
-Climatic final battle between Satou and Asahi.
-An actual conclusion to Shio's amnesia arc, and the reasons for her mother abandoning her.
-Taiyo having more closure and a slightly better ending.
-Beautifully done double suicide scene.
-Flashback to Satou and Shio's first day together.
-A small glimpse of teenage Shio.

Waterflame said they'll translate the extras, so I'll keep this thread alive until then.
>>
So is this anime really yuri? Alot of people are saying the 'love' is mother and daughter not romantic?
>>
>>3016344
Well it's kind of a twisted love because MC is insane and the kid is mentally broken.
I wouldn't recommend it for the yuri though, I consider it a dark comedy.
>>
>>3016344
it's yuri but people don't like the fact that girl in question is like 5 or 8yo
>>3016364
bad ending so a lot of people are not watching it
>>
>>3016394
the love is Platonic the anime director said so cope.
>>
>>3016416
>Director
>Above author
>On a anime with little to no change with the source material.
Are you that stupid
>>
>>3016422
their relationship was mother to daughter or at the very least sisters.
>>3016430
you have to go back
>>
>>3016444
>mother-daughter yuri
Hot.
>>
>>3016444
Their relationship was obviously romantic, the entire theme of the story is about the nature of romantic love.
>>
>>3016455
No yuri if you think that your delusional.
>>
Why did the artist ended the same way as the anime?
If Satou got arrested it would only be kidnapping and she would been out in a few years
>>
>>3016458
Indeed, it was shoujo-ai.
>>
>>3016465
Most YouTube reviews would say the opposite it's left open to your interception.
>>
>>3016416
Remember the time when an Episode Director turned Ayaya straight? Yeah Directors spill all kind of bullshit.
>>
File: 1497771160697.jpg (69 KB, 498x482)
69 KB
69 KB JPG
>>3016548
>>
>>3016518
I've never seen the source of that.
>>
>>3016462
Did not have the balls to do it.
>>
>>3016474
The joke just flew straight over your head, didn't it?
Also
>youtube reviews

>>3016576
Making a boring happy ending is not a ballsy thing to do. Ballsy is staying true to one's vision and tone of the story until the end.
>>
>>3016462
Because that was the intended ending from the beginning, which the anime got to first.
Akuma no Riddle did the same thing.

>If Satou got arrested it would only be kidnapping and she would been out in a few years
It wouldnt be as impactful or interesting.
>>
>>3016754
Shit taste confirmed.
>>
>>3016948
>>
File: 1505426040686.gif (2.69 MB, 513x640)
2.69 MB
2.69 MB GIF
>>3017031
>>
>>3016462
What if instead of being arrested they actually escaped together? That would surely be impactful.
>>
>>3017053
there would still be people complaining that "Sato did not deserve the happy ending" or crap like that, especially from people who have not even read the manga or watched the Anime and have not passed the synopsis.
>>
>>3017053
But that's exactly what they wanted to do. There's nothing more boring than a plan that goes exactly as planned without a hitch.
>>
>>3016556
>>3017043
Could you please go back to /a/?
>>
>>2933255
No she dead
>>
>>3017083
Welcome to 4chan GTFO
>>
>>3017061
Well at least it did not end darker.
>>
>>3017150
You're trying too hard. Lurk more.
>>
>>3017181
are you really that retarded?
>>
>>3017152
I think this is as dark as it gets anon.
>>
>>3017602
no it could of ended with satou losing her love for shio when she grows up because she no longer a child.

or shio would of been the one who died and satou actual kidnapped a loli that looks like shio.and pretending she never died.
>>
>>3017152
I would have preferred a double suicide over this halfhearted middle-of-the-road crap.
>>
>>3017792
I don't see what's so "middle of the road" about the ending. If anything, a double suicide would have made for a less dark ending.
>>
>>3017792
>a character killing herself is middle of the road
>>
File: 1505426414958.jpg (38 KB, 362x346)
38 KB
38 KB JPG
>>3017796
Because the author kept the ending the same as the anime.

Was this really the intended ending, or did the manga author just liked anime ending and decided to keep it the same for shock value?
>>
>>3017796
>>3017884
One side of the road is a happy ending, where Shio and Satou get away with everything, the true manifestation of a happy sugar life where has come to respect Shio's autonomy and Shio has her own agency rather than being puppeteered at the whims of her elders. The opposite side is the tragedy of a bitter and twisted world snuffing out their lives right as they obtain their ideal selves, that they like the greatest stars shone brightest but burnt out the quickest, with some aware no mono that nips are fond of. Splitting the difference yields this result: Satou dies, Shio is largely unscathed, but she's an unhinged nutcase, but she still has her happy sugar life. It isn't darker than the double suicide because all things considered, Shio is relatively 'fine' and the whole sequence of events was more inconsequential than it ought to be.

There are a number of factors that make it even worse. Satou would have lived had she not jumped. Asahi lived. The implication that Shio somehow grows up after severing ties with her family somehow completely independently. The alternative- that she flounders around in foster care for several years muttering to herself is equally boring and pointless. That latter bit is the worst aspect: there's no narrative point to keeping Shio alive. It neuters the sense of tragedy. Hell, it's outright counterproductive since Satou once again defies Shio 'for her own good' despite going through an entire arc to grow out of it, and Shio having a happy sugar life with a dead Satou undermines the whole damn thing. If, at the very least, we had a panel of a teenage Shio finding an abandoned pink haired loli crying "nigai nigai", then there's something to be said about a cyclical narrative and the perpetuation of the deranged parts of human behavior, but as it stands the story just kind of aborts.
>>
>>3018071
I think it would been darker if satou stop loving shio and replaced her with a new loli.
>>
>>2896245
Fuck you
>>
>>3018083
Yes, darker in the sense of being a M. Night Shyamalan-tier shocking tweest.
>>
>>3018068
The ending was obviously planned ahead, the anime just adapted it before it appeared on the manga. This isn't even the first series to do this.
>>
File: umadsis.png (156 KB, 690x424)
156 KB
156 KB PNG
>>3018086
>>
>>3018071
A truly boring ending is one in which all characters die without accomplishing anything. A succesful double suicide would diminish the tragedy because it could be taken as a "together in death" scenario. Shio being alive by herself is more tragic, and it also ensures that something was accomplished by the story. She's not the same person she was at the beginning, and her life took a direction it wouldnt't have had she not met Satou.
If Shio had died, her development would have been meaningless, nothing would have changed. Satou saving her is in turn the climax of Satou's own arc, learning that love should be selfless and not posessive.
>>
>>3018181
Keep telling yourself that the author did bother to change it and kept the same as the anime to fuck with the readers.
>>
>>3016456
No its family love anon prove me wrong.
>>
>>3018188
How much of the anime ending did the manga copy?
>>
>>3018192
85 percent you get to see a a glimpse of teenage Shio
>>
>>3018167
Name some of them and two the ending of the anime and manga are exactly the same only a handful of scenes are different.
>>
File: 1397865619268.jpg (2.7 MB, 1656x2277)
2.7 MB
2.7 MB JPG
>>3018201
...you serious?
>>
>>3018068
>>3018188
>>3018192
The author didn't "keep the ending the same as the anime". They were obvioulsy involved with the anime and told the writer/director the ending so the series could have a conclusion without having to wait for the manga to finish.
I don't see how anyone could see that the source material has the same ending as the adaptation and somehow conclude that it got it from the adaptation rather than the other way around,
>>
>>3018209
anon try harder it was still different only thing in common was they all lived.
>>
>>3018220
you forget that the author finished the manga one year after the anime there is no way he had the ending planed that early. also what was the point of continuing the manga if the ends were the same?
>>
>>3018231
The manga's story isn't very long or complex, it's not hard to imagine that it was all planned out from early on its run.

>what was the point of continuing the manga if the ends were the same?
Because why leave a work unfinished? It doesn't matter if the ending is foregone or not, it should be concluded.
>>
>>3018231
Any decent writer knows the ending of the story they write before they even write the very first sentence.
>>
>>3018231
point was stomping on hopes of the readers that manga would taken a different turn and shock value.
lets hope we get a manga sequel/alternate ending like Mirai Nikki did.
>>
>>3018231
>you forget that the author finished the manga one year after the anime there is no way he had the ending planed that early
Are you serious? Not everyone has the brain of a goldfish.
>>
>>3018234
well that means half of mangaka suck then someone get title Kubo on the phone.
>>
File: 1493047389942.png (87 KB, 698x658)
87 KB
87 KB PNG
>>3018238
Trying this hard
>>
>>3018238
you give to much credit my friend some writers keep changing their minds or decide to scrap the idea's
>>
>>3018246
True the writer had to know how much people did not like the ending maybe we will get a alternate ending or something in a few years.
>>
>>3018236
>>3018248
And why should the author change the story just because a few idiots didn't like it? Artists shoud stay true to their vision rather than pandering to the lowest common denominator.
If you didn't like the ending, that's on you, but don't act like everybody hated it, or like everybody thogught the manga would be different.
>>
>>3018253
Anon are that retarded? Go read the Japanese boards.

Also many writers have done that for their fans look at future diary.
>>
>>3018254
>Also many writers have done that for their fans look at future diary.
That's the sign of a real hack writer, who only cares about pleasing and not about fulfilling their artistic vision.
>>
>>3018253
> a few
like what anon said >>3018254

hell the author notes said he would of not finished with out some help of the editor I think he did not have the balls make a darker ending or happy ending.
>>
>>3018256
>hack writer
Coping much.
>>
This feels like a romcom series thread and non maingirl fags complaining about the ending
>>
>>3018256
most writers do like to please their fanbase and some who don't but do it anyway because they know without the fans they are SOL
>>
>>3018261
most people hate tragic yuri endings I guess.
>>
>>3018242
Speaking of Kubo, he's still planning to have Burn the Witch serialize full time.
>>
>>3018265
no he never ended Zombie Powder
>>
>>3018266
Was Zombie Powder ever yuri in the first place?
>>
>>3018269
Board have been talking about manga writers having the ending plan of a series before they start and don't change it because of artistic vision
and Kubo failed to keep his artistic vision keep making the manga to completion
also I don't think it had yuri?
>>
>>3018189
The entire thing about Shio being their own persona was about how real love is respecting your partner as equal, it's nonsensical to think thata's about motherly love because it was never portrayed like that.
>>
>>3018286
anon its because of bunch of people saying the reason satou saved shio from death is she discovered her love of her was Platonic not Romantic
>>
>>3018297
I read about that basically they did not like Satou being a Pedophile and they pretend it's love between a mother and daughter or sister's not helped by director of the anime Saying family love
>>
File: 5dhv0ebkgs621[1].jpg (319 KB, 1080x1330)
319 KB
319 KB JPG
>>3018307
https://manga.tokyo/interview/exclusive-interview-with-happy-sugar-life-general-director-keizou-kusakawa/
also >director is not the mangaka
only mangaka can say if the love is romantic or not, has anyone know if he said anything about that?
last they had a pretend wedding with real wedding rings so no its yuri tell said otherwise.
>>
>>3018297
>>3018307
What about Westerners who can't accept that this is romantic love? if this were Het nobody would call it platonic, even if it really is platonic (there would only be complaints of "pedophilia" but I would not deny that it is romantic)
>>
>>3018324
it's the west they don't like loli works so they make it sound bad then it really is and pretend they are not in love making stupid excuses why it is not.
>>
>>3018335
how would the west deal if master and me from Itou Hachi got a tv series?
>>
>>3018345
but those same people are perfectly fine with Lolicom het or even Shotacon, you can see Accelpedo in Index as an example.
>>
>>3018343
they lose their shit call it a "dark and creepy twisted romance" not helped, that lolicon is a woman in her early thirties and is implied have a sexual relationship with said girl.
>>
>>3018181
Shio dying on her own terms would be the culmination of her character development of taking control of her own fate. Satou falling back into her habits of lying to Shio 'for Shio's own good' isn't development, it's regression. At the climax, Satou once again failed to respect Shio's agency.

And even if you take the 'together in death' angle, the actual ending presents a 'together in half-death' angle. That's exactly the kind of middle-of-the-road crap I was alluding to earlier. If Shio had been crippled by the fall and stricken by despair, then that would have been more tragic than a successful double suicide. But the fact that the ending portrays Shio as having attained a happy sugar life despite Satou's death absolutely unequivocally undermines the tragedy of it. Shio staying alive accomplishes the regression of Satou's character and takes away the autonomy she had gained together with Satou: she once again gets left to the mercy of those who would control her.
>>
>>3018281
Kubo had the "ending" planned from the start. Ending here meaning the part were Rukia's kid meets Ichigo's one. Everything else, though? Who knows.
>>
>>3018540
Shit can't believe people this.
>>
>>3018234
>>3018238
>>3018253
>>3018256
if Happy Sugar life ending was plan we would of had a scene like the first ep of the anime when they were on top of burning building.

Also if the mangaka told the ending to the anime studio they would of animated teen Shio and shown her closing the window on her mom.
>>
>>3018856
I don't see how any of that proves the ending was not planned. Showing the rooftop scene at the beginning was simply a director's choice. Probably the same with not showing teen Shio (since it doesn't really make any difference, what we've been shown is enough).
>>
>>3018856
>>3018858
Both shut up it's obvious the ending is kept for shock value or writer's block.
The manga continued because of money.
>>
>>3018858
I think the teen Shio kinda undermines the ambiguity a little bit. In the anime it was completely ambiguous as to whether or not Shio would break the cycle of abuse and live a filling life, but the timeskip and manga exclusive scenes before then heavily leans towards her breaking the cycle.
>>
File: Are Yuu dumb.png (178 KB, 217x578)
178 KB
178 KB PNG
>>3018863
>>
>>3018865
Actually look at the last panel in the manga Shio is missing Satou wedding ring she only as hers.
>>
>>3018868
>Me can't come up with argument
Cope
>>
>>3018870
I've already adressed your points several times:
>>3018253
>>3018220
>>3018167
Now could you please fuck off back to /a/ or /v/?
>>
>>3018209
Riddle anime ended all girls alive and haru delivering diplomas
Manga ends with the girls alive and some hooking up.
Try harder anon they both different
>>
>>3018869
You can't really tell it looks like she has both.
>>3018865
she is still in the cycle of abuse she has to back to her mom and brother, unless the state takes her in.
>>
File: 1506426447575.png (245 KB, 365x765)
245 KB
245 KB PNG
>>3018876
Hey stop getting mad when people have good arguments.
>>
>>3018877
Still the same basic ending with stuff added. The diploma thing even happened in the manga still, iirc.

>>3018885
>Going back to a dysfunctional family that already failed at raising you once
>>
>>3018887
You said it basic ending but still different HSL had almost exact ending only certain scenes added or changed.
>>
>>3018888
So just like Riddle then
>>
Can anybody answer this was the show really yuri Satou was in love with Shio as in romantic or was it family love? because Japanese director and voice actors don't know.
>>
>>3018889
https://rorymuses.wordpress.com/2017/08/19/thoughts-on-akuma-no-riddle-riddle-story-of-devil-volume-5/
Same ending right whatever you say.
>>
>>3018890
It has kisses and a simbolic wedding, besides the entire theme of the show is about the nature of romantic love. The only reason they say that is because they need to protect Amazon Prime from dumb US law, maybe even the reason of why they changed the anime of Rifle is Beautiful to Chidori RSC is because of the US market.
>>
>>3018923
But why say the something in Japan?
I understand when released internationally.
>>
>>3018932
It has no other way to do it without making it bigger. If someone wants to complain about the show Amazon just need to use the director declarations to avoid social media drama.
>>
>>3018941
I think that if this had explicit sexual violence (mainly het) there would be no complaints, but apparently love between a teenager and a loli is going too far.
>>
>>3018954
Maybe Amazon purged all the loli related content (with the exception of Wasuyu and Yuyuyu S2), because, I think, Nanoha is not available in the west anymore.
>>
>>3018984
In the end they are just a bunch of cowards and flawed laws that are unable to do something with true pedophilia and attack this type of content to say they are really working.




Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.