[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Search] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/vg/ - Video Game Generals



Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.




File: TAHITI.jpg (108 KB, 599x755)
108 KB
108 KB JPG
ONE LAST WAIT edition

>> Red Dead Online will only be coming 'towards the end' of November: www.vg247.com/2018/11/08/red-dead-online-beta-release-towards-end-month/

>> All kinds of info and guides: rockstarintel.com/tag/red-dead/

>> RDR2 development background article: www.vulture.com/2018/10/the-making-of-rockstar-games-red-dead-redemption-2.html

>> Map with all collectibles *contains spoilers*: rdr2map.com

>> Locations of all hunting/fishing targets: imgur.com/a/QIX2uQQ

>> Previous thread: >>233747945
>>
File: arthur.png (43 KB, 578x542)
43 KB
43 KB PNG
first for autism gang
>>
File: SlowWest-619-386.jpg (39 KB, 619x386)
39 KB
39 KB JPG
Second for post your online inspo
>>
File: Coj4_quickshooter5.jpg (174 KB, 1071x583)
174 KB
174 KB JPG
we call of juarez gunslinger now
>>
>>233791808
triggerguard needs to be gold too
>>
Antagonizing dialog is gold
>>
>>233791804
Only YOU can prevent forest fires
>>
hi fellers
>>
>>233791903
>really want to see all the hilarious dialogue from it but too much of a pussy to hurt the feelings of virtual characters
>>
Where's the civil war shackles for that one trinket?
>>
>final mission of Chapter 3
That might've been the most fun to play, well-executed mission I've ever played.

Also, without spoiling anything, can anyone tell me if there are any Indian-related missions and characters that are coming up soon? I really liked the Native missions in the first game. So far all I've seen are the three Indians that stalk you while you move to Horseshoe Overlook.
>>
>>233792116
yes, the latter parts of the game heavily involve natives
>>
>>233792116
Yeah
>>
>>233792049
hahah this, but in the sense that it would break the character of arthur being a decent dude.
even when the antagonizing is used, the game reminds you that arthur's a good dude. when antagonizing the women they're all like: "why you do this? this isn't like you"
>>
File: sunset riders.jpg (41 KB, 480x360)
41 KB
41 KB JPG
>>233791804
I'm praying for ponchos.

>>233792116
Later, friend.
>>
>so h-how you doin?
>>
>>233791893
You can't do that without making the whole frame gold, unfortunately.
>>
File: file.png (287 KB, 400x500)
287 KB
287 KB PNG
Rough, hair pulling, questionably consensual sex with Mary Beth!
>>
>>233792116
>Also, without spoiling anything
Just leave the general until you're done if you're trying to not get spoiled, what is wrong with you.

>>233792218
a lot of the antagonise options are just ripping into someone, in the same way he constantly does in cutscenes
>>
>>233792253
Mary Beth looks like that?!?
>>
>>233792116
Anon, quick warning: steer away from this place if you're keen on not hearing about spoilers.
>>
>>233792218
He's not a decent dude he beats the shit out of people if they owe $5 to the gang
>>
>>233791903
> "Uh oh, Dutch is thinking. This can't be good!"
>>
>>233792253
>>
File: slouch hat.jpg (73 KB, 639x429)
73 KB
73 KB JPG
are there any hats with a side pinned like Bills?
So far all I've found is the military hat but I was hoping to find something brown or black
>>
can anyone link to the song that plays in the epilogue when john leaves big valley for beechers hope? the guy either is or just sounds a lot like neil young. it played for like 10 seconds before it glitched and abruptly started the normal ambient music
>>
>>233792230
>83k
what have you been doing
>>
>>233792491
Probably the dupe gold bar glitch
>>
>>233792253
My Arthur just spent an evening in camp standing over Mary-Beth sleeping, drinking whiskey, staring down at her.
>>
>watching meme '5million INSANE details in rdr2!' vids as background noise
>'arthur gets out of breath whistling!'
>try it out
>doesnt happen
>tfw pre-TB
wtf i hate this game stop making me cry
>>
>>233792547
oh, boring
>>
>>233792491
It's obviously the gold bar glitch there's no way he got that much legit.
>>
>>233791804
>>
>replaying RDR1
>bonnie is terrible at hiding how much she wants john's massive dick
>john is a married man and faithful to his wife
John is a true chad
>>
>when the mission is the title of the game
you know shit's about to hit the fan
>>
>>233792785
He's a good boy, no matter what anyone says. No one is as devoted to his family. He even puts up with Jacks bullshit NEET reading and listens to him talk about it like an autist.
>>
>>233792414
one of the two the rat hats at the fur trader
you can find a group of respawning rats in the shack with the fertility idol in it south of thieves landing. kill em with small game arrows and it is EZ pelts. Just ride up the hill and back down to the shack and they will respawn inside it.
>>
>>233792745
Pretty good, anon.
>>233792785
Why does everyone keep saying John has a magnum dong? Did I miss some dialogue in the first game?
>>
>>233792491
bar glitch, which I used for upgrades and clothes then decided to donate the remaining 80k to camp
>>
>>233792871
he's a former scumbag who turned a new leaf after a life of scumbaggery

he's not a good boy, though he is incredibly likeable and has a lot of good traits
>>
File: MG_0239.jpg (270 KB, 573x860)
270 KB
270 KB JPG
>>233791804
One friend is basically going to clone Sadie so I'm going to make a kawaii Mexican girl and put her in dresses and shit, the rest of our group is most likely going to make cowboys. I played a dude in GTA V so this time I'm unashamedly going to play dress up.
>>
>>233792895
no but it is fun to act like he has a huge dick because of how he is generally a quiet but strong type
>>
>>233792895
memes.
>>
>>233792414
Apparently there's a Hardee hat in one of the old forts but I haven't found it.
>>
>>233792993
>>233793015
I figured as much, but I just wanted ensure I haven't missed some lore about John's johnson.
>>
I wish I could pretend rdr1 didn't exist even if I like the game alot.

it just feels like Arthur his efforts kind of go to waste with John and Abigail dying.
>>
File: ricketts.jpg (253 KB, 1913x1071)
253 KB
253 KB JPG
>killing men is a strange kind of fame
>>
>>233793208
they got to enjoy years of happiness together before john's inevitable and deserved fate was delivered, considering all his misdeeds, I'd say he had it alright
>>
If someone hasn't made an RDR edit of the 'I implore you to reconsider' scene from Kung Pow, they need to make it immediately.
>>
>>233793208
> John married abigail with arthur's ring
>those few precious years of happiness for john and his family
>Jack is a scumbag but survives and carries on the memory of the gang
no one lives forever but Arthur got what he wanted, even if it was imperfect.
>>
>>233793305
if you talk to the old blind sage as john he says something along the lines of:
>"they will come for you and that will lead to the end, but you will have lived a better life than most"
>john: "thanks... I think?"
>>
does the game let you load animal bodies/pelts/etc onto wagons?
>>
>>233793208
Arthur helped provide a better future for Jack in the long run he inherits a big ranch and all John's money
>>
I miss Arthur so fucking much. I loved his quotes in the gunslinger sidequest, I love his attitude in general.
Honestly didn't think I'd ever be mad to be stuck as John in the postgame, but I fucking am
>>
>>233792218
>I've finally lost my mind, Mary-Beth.
>>
>>233791804
>>
>>233793519
I went into the game both assuming I'd end up playing as John in the end and longing to do so, but when all was said and done, Arthur is definitely my favourite of the pair
>>
>>233793375
Jack's not that bad. He just grew hard over the years taking care of himself and Abigail and the only real crime he committed was killing Ross in Mexico, another country and it was a fair duel.
>>
>>233793610
MOVE YA DAMN NAG
>>
>>233792880
There's another fertility idol spawn?
I haven't been in New Austin much, doing as much exploring in Lemoyne and the swamps I can, and still looking for the vampire.
There's one southwest of Annesburg, going up a road a little south of that guy's wife's home. It's a small caravan with a skeleton of some Madam (while you're Arthur) there. Years later as John, it's gone for some odd reason.
>>
File: he's right you know.jpg (106 KB, 1280x720)
106 KB
106 KB JPG
You accepted his pamphlet right /rdr/?
>>
File: 1541120708250.png (169 KB, 415x415)
169 KB
169 KB PNG
>that smalltalk with the bath whores
jesus christ Arthur is definitely autistic
>>
>>233792218
Just antagonize Micah, it's pretty in-character.
>>
>>233792871
He's not an autist, he's smart, Bill. The boy can read, so much for what can be said of you.
>>
>>233793730
a sperg wouldn't say yes to having a sexy woman bathe him, much less being able to form words during the act
>>
Fuck the 8th gambler challenge.
>>
>>233793730
I mean, what do you say at soaplands, anon?
same shit for Michael and Franklin's dialogues at the strip clubs.
god I hope there's cabaret in online.
>>
>>233793730
>ya know i used to take baths with ma dog?
based autist chad
>>
>>233793610
this is why people don't like jack

http://reddead.wikia.com/wiki/Jack_Marston/Quotes

>>233793680
pretty much
>>
is it possible to get legend of the east outfit as arthur?
from what i can see im gonna have some trouble with the ride from van horn to blackwater, should i bond up a new horse or is it likely it will survive?
>>
Why can't I have gay sex with other cowboys in RDR2? I thought it was supposed to be super realistic.
>>
>>233793956
not like you can fuck anyone anyhow
>>
File: velcro.jpg (368 KB, 1920x1072)
368 KB
368 KB JPG
>open velcro satchel
>all music stops
>>
>>233793924
>(After killing an animal) "I love natural selection!"
Coming from the same kid that was sperging out when his dog got bitten by a snake
>>
>>233793956
you kiss a man who is briefly cross-dressing, you degenerate
>>
File: 1439703502278.jpg (111 KB, 1280x720)
111 KB
111 KB JPG
>>233793924
>I guess I just miss Rufus
>>
>>233793956
The cowboy buttsex will be available in online.
>>
>>233793754
>>233792871
> Not believing that Jack is actually Dutch's spawn
>>
>>233794058
Was a joke, and a reference to an achievement you get from killing all the bison on the great plains.
John says the same thing, jokingly.
>>
who is the best duelist in the gang?
is it micah? he seemed pretty fucking fast in the epilogue
>>
>>233791614
>RDOnline trailer when???
>>
Never whistle for your horse anywhere near a train

Fucker walked right in front of one
>>
>>233794147
>Gavin
>>
I had a dream Micah lived down the street from me and was being a total git. I shot a bird at him and told him to get away from my yard. It was weird.
>>
File: Ocelot.png (161 KB, 350x383)
161 KB
161 KB PNG
>>233791804
>>
>>233791804
>>
>>233794208
My fucking Arabian died during the last cutscene with Rains Fall because I didn't notice he was at the train tracks
>>
>>233794208
I whistled for my horse in a mountainous area and its pathing got fucked.
Watched it slide down the mountain side to its death
>>
>>233794193
>caring about online
I just realised this general will turn to absolute shit the day it launches. A shame.
>>
is mexico being readied for online
>>
File: eastwood.jpg (106 KB, 1000x600)
106 KB
106 KB JPG
>>233791804
>>
>>233794406
ree idc about online i just wanna explore everything as arthur
>>
>>233793902
Does he really say that? That's adorable.
>>
File: Hamish_Sinclair_RDR2.jpg (21 KB, 440x334)
21 KB
21 KB JPG
I wish he was my dad
>>
>>233794809
He's similar to my dad
because they're both dead
>>
this track is too good, clearly inspired by "man with a harmonica"
such a shame it only plays once, but again RDR2 has so many great soundtracks its hard to pick
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zz9E4olGd6U
>>
>>233793730
>cheer for the snake charmer woman at the theatre
>"YEEHAW SNAKE LADY"
>>
>>233794930
i fucking love arthur
who else tried to make a move?
>>
I found a pocket mirror, now when does Molly ask you for it? Also, what's the best spot to find cougars?
>>
File: Pegasus DLC.jpg (14 KB, 450x336)
14 KB
14 KB JPG
>>
>>233794930
where/when is this?
>>
>>233795038
>cougars
it's in the OP, faggot
>>
>>233795220
The vaudeville theatre in Saint Denis, she's one of the acts, I've seen her twice so I think it's randomized?
>>
>>233795026
Can you talk to her after the show? On an unrelated note, the escape artist who appears next to you genuinely kinda stunned me.
>>
>>233795415
Never sit in the balcony seats, sure its classy but you can't interact with the acts
>>
What'll be the Boomer posse equivalent of Boomer juice and a ride on mower? Surely zoomers would ride trains and drink something like gin?
>>
>>233795497
You ever manage to beat the strong lady in the fist fight? I still had like 1/6 of my HP when I got hit and it faded to black.
>>
>>233795516
>boomer juice
you mean monster
>>
>>233795516
quick question.. CAN train engines be damaged enough to stop?
will a oil cart actually kill the engineer?
someone test this stuff out
>>
File: 6516516516848648.jpg (30 KB, 380x484)
30 KB
30 KB JPG
fellas why is arthur so CUTE!
>>
>>233795516
drinking the mysterious cauldron juice while using the manual crank train
>>
File: 51o-9-0xjML.jpg (33 KB, 500x334)
33 KB
33 KB JPG
>>233794427
Fuck Eastwood if they do an SAA with extended barrel and stock nothing would more Kino than Van Cleef.
>>
>>233795657
I pretty much live in St Dennis now, and have no plans to advance the story, why doesn't the hotel room at least offer free pomade and a shaving mirror?

Wearing my classy stuff at night and painting the town red, putting on my swamp gear and roam the swamps by day
>>
>>233792489
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mEF9-_E1OXE

this one?
>>
>>233795796
I understand it's just game balancing, but dead man pedal hadn't been invented yet

so trains should keep going
>>
>>233795796
>boomer posse shows up to rob a train
>start preparing for the raid by drinking Monster Ultra Cauldron(tm)
>entire party passes out half way to the target, falling off their horses and the train slowly rolls to a halt
>dabbed on by zoomer posse whilst unconscious
>>
Uncle is literally impossible to beat at Poker.
>>
>>233796165
would be cool if he cheats
>game has no cheat feature, you can call them out on
>>
>>233795738
> Pretty boah
> Good at what he does
> Sentimental in his journal
> Autist around women
>>
>>233795862
>and have no plans to advance the story
ew
>>
>>233795738
He's Sean Bean
>>
M'fellers
>>
>>233796165
made him go bust twice about an hour ago, it's just RNG
>there goes my drinking money
>>
>>233796165
Cleaned Uncle out easily. Charles in SDenis on the other hand...
>>
>>233796310
just wish the game had more side activity, like extortion of businesses, smuggling, certainly needs high stakes poker in St D
>>
File: arthur wojack.jpg (187 KB, 1160x1099)
187 KB
187 KB JPG
>>
>>233796230
notice how arthur holds his cards when he plays with the gang, compared to how he holds them when he plays with strangers
with the gang he hides them, with strangers he holds them normally
>>
>he cute
>>
>>233795862
What do you wear in town? I like the Gambler's outfit with an added tie.
>>
>>233796492
I think the reason we don't have high stakes gambling is simply due to it being jarring if you're making heaps and heaps of cash from it, all the while the gang is still planning heists and shit to make the cash needed to be mango farmers
>>
>>233796683
>>233796492
I just then thought, they could have it as a post-game thing with John, on the same riverboat Arthur shoots up, given John wasn't involved in that mission and at that point, it wouldn't be jarring having stacks of cash building up
>>
who else /unionsuit/ chads
>>
>>233791614
your character sleeps sotting up with their eyes open
sky cutscene glitched out, just shows you still sitting there on the bed
pretty kino
>>
>>233796893
gotta stay alert in the life of a gunman
>>
>you did good girl
>thats my girl
you fags dont ride on a male horse do you?
>>
>>233796683
yeah, like you finding almost 10000 dollars worth of gold bars, excluding the duplication glitch. or john marston basically having infinite money at the end of the epilogue, sitting with 20k dollars after probably paying off all his debts etc, yet when you start red dead redemption 1 he runs around with 0 cash and has to work off 10 dollars.
most functioning human beings manage to suspend disbelief enough to realise that player cash doesnt = canon amount of cash
>>
T A L L T R E E S G A N G
>>
>>233796683
Arthur loses in high stakes, can't pay off debt
>Has to pay a mobster so much money a week or else he gets a bounty
>>
So do you think the online will take place before the story like GTAO did or after the story? If it takes place after then they can add more modern guns like the High Power Pistol, but before means all the gangs taken down in the story would still be around to fight. Cornwall, O'Driscolls, Grays, Braithwaites, Bronte, etc.
>>
>>233796957
not hard to imagine the gov't seized his funds when he was pseudo arrested pre-RDR1
>>
>>233796492
I know chess isn't casino or a frontier bar game but I'd still like to see it in a place like SDenis. By some cafe where you can play old frogs no money involved just leisure.
>>
>>233797027
to what end though, it would only make it harder for him to complete his mission, they knew he wouldn't bail when they had his family as leverage anyway
>>
>>233797032
I want horshoes back
>>
How the hell do I successfully rob a train if cops show up immediately?
>>
any way to be shirtless with John
>>
>>233796957
>after probably paying off all his debts etc
he says in a cutscene that he paid off the bank loan through his bounty hunting with saddie, so the 20k is just what he got from micah/dutch's stash; I guess he, charles and saddie split it, though
>>
How do you get rid of a bounty that's $1000+? Usually i'd just get arrested and pay it that way even if I didn't have enough, but now the police just shoot on sight no matter what crime I commit so I can't surrender peacefully. What do?
>>
>>233797097
climb on a moving train.. go to the engine, stop the train on a bridge. take your time looting it.
escape
>>
>>233797065
to pay off the longstanding price on his head, perhaps
>>
>>233797069
That too
>>
>>233797180
he sits with 20k after charles and sadie leave you, so presumably the take was much bigger than 20k, i mean just the savings you get throughout the story reaches numbers up to like 40k i think? cant remember
>>
>>233792020
something smells good, looks like
>>
>>233797194
Stopping a train in the middle of nowhere should not result in an immediately wanted level, this is bullshit.
>>
i want karens milkies!
>>
>>233797262
Arthurs price was 5k, even if Johns price was the same Abigail and Jacks would have been significantly lower, and again you sti with 20k when you resume control over John, presumably he would have paid the bounty if it was an option, I personally think the epilogue took a turn for the weirder with the money, and it almost seems noncanon cuz it most likely would have solved all of his problems removing the need for red dead 1 at all
>>
>>233797345
oh, I meant post-split, so 60k total. I'm in chapter 4 on my second playthrough atm, and I've got 4k on me and 1k in the camp fund, despite having bought all camp upgrades, so ye, not too taxing to amass wealth. Still, it does feel like it's intended as to not spam a single activity to amass wealth quickly, e.g. if bounties were still infinite or high stakes gambling etc.

but like I said, feels like those rules could be relaxed come the post-game, since there's no thematic reasoning to not allow it anymore
>>
>>233792020
would you motorboat her big sweaty titties?
>>
Do you ever think Jack became a writer and was in WW1
>>
>>233797440
arthur's price was 5k in chapter 2, before all manner of absolute mayhem, including blowing up a bridge, robbing a city bank, taking on the army, gunning down half of the police in saint denis etc. etc.
>>
>>233797538
maybe one high stakes game is available a day

and make sure the hotel is way far away from it in town. so you can rest spam
>>
where else are trappers located apart from st denis?
>>
>at the show with ben lazarus
>go up to shoot him and disprove skeptic
>cant draw gun
is this meant to happen?
>>
>>233797538
i already think too much content is locked behind john to be honest, it should just be an option as arthur period, suspending your disbelief to the point where player cash and canon cash are different is already apparent enough, given the amount of gold bars available in the game world for very little effort.
>>
>>233797650
all over the map
>>
>>233797650
west of Annesburg and way far west of Mt Shaun
and its all the same guy

also do butchers give you better meat prices?
>>
>>233797627
Dutch mentions having had a bounty on his head for 13 years, given Arthur was in his gang 13 years ago we can fairly safely infer that the 5k bounty isnt only for blackwater, but the several years leading up to it, with blackwater being the triggering event along with the train robbing which put loveticus on their backs
>>
>>233797553
yes but Grimshaw would be first pick for that
>>
File: GTA V.jpg (19 KB, 598x336)
19 KB
19 KB JPG
>>233797623
>>
>>233797714
doesn't the gold only amount to ~10k? We've already concluded the stash you get at the end ranges from 20 - 60k, so it's as if it's too outlandish

I can't say you're wrong, tho, very much just a subjective thing; I'm personally happier with it being more taxing to amass wealth whilst playing as arthur than just playing poker for a few hours

just a case of different strokes
>>
You can’t stop the US Army
>>
File: Pam or Karen.gif (499 KB, 399x227)
499 KB
499 KB GIF
>>233797432
Karen is western'd Pam
>>
>233797867
i can kinda see that, if you couldnt buy every single item in the game two times over with the money you amass from the gold bars + the bank robbery in chapter 3, id prefer they went all the way in either direction.
either remove the gold bars entirely or significantly reduce price so money is harder to come by, or just accept that ingame cash isnt related to story at all and give us more fun shit to do. right now everything other than the gold bars and some story missions yields very little money , while the gold bars completely makes any of those other money earning schemes completely pointless. its just a lame middle ground imo
>>
>>233797389
you just know camp smells like rank pussy and ballsweat
>>
>>233797995
sorry, didnt mean to rob you your (You)
>>233797867
>>
File: 1541708368829.jpg (66 KB, 1440x1416)
66 KB
66 KB JPG
>tfw your eating some berries and Arthur Morgan jumps off his horse with a scoped rolling block rifle in hand
>>
>>233797995
I'd settle for realistic pricing, a hotel room should cost more then a meal
>>
>>233797995
I agree, it does feel like it's in the middle ground. If you only got gold bars from bank safes and the german bloke, that would be alright. Or if /everything/ had a gang cut taken from you, so you could do high stakes gambling, but 75% goes to the gang, actually, that's a shit idea, but something along those lines, I guess
>>
>>233797650
also east of riggs station and in tall trees
>>
>>233797623
He asphyxiates from poison gas in trench warfare and die reminiscing on fishing with his uncle Arthur and last thought will be that he never really had a father figure
>>
>>233797725
not really at all
>>
does anyone have a save before they did the serial killer quest? saw someone saying that there's a poster of the missing princess in the hideout but I can't get back in there
>>
>>233798120
i appreciate the realism, but id rather not lose out on fun stuff like high stakes gambling, especially not when the currency is what it is.
on the playthrough i recently started ive opted to not get any of the gold bars at all
>>
Do you think at some point between 2 and 1, Jack realized he was kidnapped by Bronte and confronted John about it, only for it to be dismissed by Abigail as a sleepover. Fuck, now I want this drawn
>>
>>233797623
>>233798238
jackfags gtfo
>>
>>233798280
lacking from the far north that's for sure
>>
The level of autistic patience a man must have to go hunting for small/song birds is phenomenal. I just had to spend almost 3 hours hunting a perfect blue jay and 2 perfect robins for a hat.
But hey, I found out that you can sometimes force-spawn a bird by shooting at/near a tree.
>>
>>233798410
I was chuffed when I saw you could add feather decorations to his actual hat
>>
File: This counts as cheating.jpg (212 KB, 1920x1080)
212 KB
212 KB JPG
What Abigail doesn't know won't hurt her
>>
>>233798340
NO JACKFAGS REEEEEEEE
>>
>>233798356
Jack isn’t bad you damn nag
>>
>>233798452
is that a fucking transvestite
>>
who is the best gang member and why is it charles
>>
File: senior bob.png (559 KB, 1920x676)
559 KB
559 KB PNG
how r u imaginative niggers doing this morning /rdr/?
>>
>>233798498
just Arthur's luck that the only action he gets is with a syphilis ridden tranny
>>
>Your whole life, sir, you have followed the wrong star...
FUG
>>
>>233798510
>Actual bro
>Neither a moralfag like lenny or a violencefag like Micah - right in the sweetspot
>Goes out of his way to be a bro to Arthur at times
>Helps Arthur be at peace for his last few days
>Even buries him
>Later helps out John with his house and general company.
Man is good enough a character that he could have his own DLC, maybe explaining how he joined the gang, or what happens to him between the time of Arthurs death and Johns refuge.
>>
just looking through screenshots that I took, fuck, I forgot how much the snow effect blew me away when I first started playing

>>233798464
jack's alright until you have to play as him, then he's a cunt
>>
why the fuck isnt there a hotel in st denis
>>
>>233798669
It’s not like he had positive language and behaviors from Uncle, John, and Abigail
>>
>>233798675
there is, it's the bar with the black barkeep and the obnoxious drunk woman; can get food, lodging and baths
>>
>>233798498
>*rips your dick off*
is now
>>
>>233798675
There is, it's the fancy saloon. Also has a bath.
>>
>>233797957
lol at the image of Hosea as Krieger
>>
>>233798675
>paying for a bed for the night
look at this wannabe cowpoke getting cucked by the finger of society lmao
>>
File: DDD.jpg (212 KB, 1420x799)
212 KB
212 KB JPG
My online inspo
>>
>>233798841
dude i just like seeing arthur in the bath okay
>>
>>233798759
woman likes her cocaine
>>
>>233798754
john was never so mean to his horse, he didn't call it a dumb animal etc.

jack's just mean spirited, admittedly, I can't blame him, but I still think he's sort of a cunt
>>
>>233796096
>>dabbed on by zoomer posse
>implying zoomer posses won't exist because they'll all be busy with the zoomer royale mode
>>
>>233798892
oh, weekly baths are okay, sorry for the mistake, partner

>>233798907
I've not actually spoken to her, but that explains why she's kind of aggro
>>
>>233798649
>between the time of Arthurs death and Johns refuge
Indian moving DLC confirmed
>>
File: hey there pardner.jpg (78 KB, 494x363)
78 KB
78 KB JPG
Fellers answer me this, does Rhodes saloon ever return to it's former aesthetic?
>>
Ahhh it’s back
>>
>https://vocaroo.com/i/s1vQ07XUqGrs
based anon posted this in a thread that was praising dunkey for shitting on the game.
>>
>>233799124
is this poking fun at the RDR1 launch glitches where human and animal bodies would combine into nightmarish forms, or is it something I've forgotten from Undead Nightmare
>>
>>233798340
Jack barely remembers it, John mentions it offhand when they're fishing in 2 and he asks what he's talking about.
>>
>>233799181
this is now my ringtone
>>
File: amputee.jpg (269 KB, 1920x1072)
269 KB
269 KB JPG
how come no one's brought this up yet?
>>
File: Boat.jpg (254 KB, 1920x1080)
254 KB
254 KB JPG
How does it look on Xbox One X?
>>
>try to take a shortcut across train bridge
>two trains come minutes apart
>Want to throw some hogtied asshole on the tracks
>ten minutes and no train in sight
Fuck you cockstar
>>
>>233799103
Does the Van Horn Hotel open in chapter 3?
>>
>>233798452
>settling for a bath wench when you could have the finest hookers in Saint Denis's saloons
>>
Should I watch Deadwood?
>>
>>233799612
I prefer Justified
>>
>>233799612
Only for Ian Mcshane
>>
>>233799090
> Charles says he's going to Canada
> Rains Fall says his tribe is in Canada now
>>
>up elysian pool shootin rabbits
>set up camp
>fall through map
>fade to black
>this happens
>>
>>233799683
Charles riding a moose and wearing beaver fur while killing Quebecois separatists when?
>>
>>233799683
Every one of them should have fled to Canada or Alaska..or Hawaii
>>
>>233799778
I Insist they went to Tahiti
>>
>>233799778
or Tahiti
>>
>>233799778
>not Australia
>>
>>233799675
this 1000%
>>
>>233799846
Dude.. RdR 3, can take place in Hong Kong!
>>
RDR3 will take place to the west of new austin, with new austin featuring in the far east of the map

guaranteed
>>
https://youtu.be/fWDTw7IjeiI

Online inspo right here
>>
File: Camp.jpg (395 KB, 1920x1080)
395 KB
395 KB JPG
>Camp near Annesburg
>Wake up to this


Murfrees are fucking disgusting
>>
File: Brisco.jpg (140 KB, 589x799)
140 KB
140 KB JPG
My Online Inspo here
>>
File: WeirdAlienStuff.jpg (16 KB, 250x263)
16 KB
16 KB JPG
>>233800072
>>
Here's my online inspiration
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TgxSIFcTvLo
>>
>>233800175
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h6i9AAtuk8o
>>
>>233799338
Better than on the other three options. I don't even own a decent PC, but I can't wait for the eventual release just due to far nicer screenies
>>
>>233797189
They might be shooting because you are trying too soon after the bounty. Wait a bit and they should calm down and then just antagonise them.
>>
File: RedCrop.jpg (86 KB, 298x439)
86 KB
86 KB JPG
>>233791804
>>
File: 1475374587287.jpg (52 KB, 780x688)
52 KB
52 KB JPG
>refresh newswire
>still nothing
>>
>>233801101
>caring about online
>>
File: 651651332165.jpg (72 KB, 601x599)
72 KB
72 KB JPG
i love my girl!!
>>
hey
lets git
tch tch
yep
here
yeeeeep
>>
>>233798952
calling a horse mean things is probably just the wild west equivalent of being an edgy teenager online
>>
so why did they scrap gatlings from the game ?
>>
>>233798410
>getting 5 egret plumes for a tranny with a moustache in St Denis
>>
From the end of RDR1 and interacting with Jack here's what we know about how he turned out
>he looks up to the criminal past of his father and flaunts it
>he's a killer and happy about it
>he's extremely rude and impatient, especially with animals but also with people
>he resents the law
>he has no applicable skills besides bounty hunting
No I don't think he's a good boy like some of you are trying to imply.
>>
>>233802008
but they didn't
>>
File: introspection.jpg (121 KB, 346x231)
121 KB
121 KB JPG
>wear mask into indian reservation
>"Are you hiding your face from us, or from yourself as well?"
>>
>listening to RDR1 soundtrack
god damn the first games soundtrack was god tier aswell
>>
File: 1509612904474.png (106 KB, 304x324)
106 KB
106 KB PNG
>>233799258
Yep. It's a dead donkey lady.

Why is this game so spooky? It was literally a Halloween game.
>>
File: cum.jpg (14 KB, 426x240)
14 KB
14 KB JPG
>>233802919
https://youtu.be/4k4i0Tjo7J4
>3:00 onwards
>>
File: 1441524293043.jpg (181 KB, 827x891)
181 KB
181 KB JPG
>>233802823
>>
Mfw npc's hair can actually be burned.

Also putting a lot of people in a house and then burning them alive is pretty fun.
>>
File: K8P4VGg.png (772 KB, 901x687)
772 KB
772 KB PNG
Before Mango Farming
>>
>>233803289
I hope hair grows online but I have a feeling it won't.
>>
File: DrjlHMFXcAAvy40.jpg (87 KB, 1200x675)
87 KB
87 KB JPG
>>233803289
>>233803372

Forgot pic. Their hair was completely burned. Love the details.
>>
>>233803321
After Mango Farming
>>
>>233802259
i dont think hes a good boy but he had a pretty fucked up life, raised in a gang, all his role models die, leave or go crazy, finally gets to start a somewhat normal life for a few years but the mental damage is already there, then his dad gets exploited, fucked over and murdered by the government.
>"Go ahead! I got nothin' to live for anyway!"
feels fucking bad man
>>
>>233799330
I did wonder if this dude found a civil war jacket and found a way to peddle as a wounded vet
>>
>wound animal
>go up to mercy kill it
>it dies before i can
>-honour
fucking hell
>>
>>233803415
why am I seeing Kanye West in this pic
>>
>>233792557
yikes
>>
File: rike.png (338 KB, 359x485)
338 KB
338 KB PNG
>>233803807
>horse dies
>mercy kill it
>-honour

>horse dies
>don't mercy kill it
>-honour
>>
>>233793956
You can get fucked by a redneck in the swamp if you really want
>>
>>233803851
Holy fucking shit anon my thoughts exactly.

I guess it’s the fat cheeks, moustache and an actual kanye smile, which is more of a bare teeth grin. Not many people do that.
>>
>>233802570
really ? haven't found one yet , then during the saint dennis bank job the voice lines even specifically mention they have a gatling but it turns out to be a maxim anyway
>>
>>233804173
they're all maxim guns
>>
File: 07 - bB1b1BE.jpg (8 KB, 215x215)
8 KB
8 KB JPG
>>233803415
>>233803321
>>
File: 1537071927036.png (28 KB, 435x720)
28 KB
28 KB PNG
RDR2 Online news tidbit I saw: If a player is constantly killing you you can call the law on them.
>>
>>233804283
>source: my ass
>>
>>233804283
>trusting anything datamined ever as if it's word of god
just wait until they confirm stuff or we see it in action
>>
File: 2810995956_0f14cde8e1_b.jpg (544 KB, 900x1024)
544 KB
544 KB JPG
>>233804313
>>233804315
He saw it here.
>Dat Saintsfan
Take it with a grain of salt.
>>
Mangos, a poem by Dutch Van der Linde

No, Arthur, no
I’m planning a heist
MANGOOOOOOOS
TRAINS!
You’re being hysterical
Its the tuberculosis again
That never happened
I’m afraid I cannot be spoken to like that
No, no
TRAINS
I tell you
[horse whinnying intensifies]
>>
>>233804385
there was a datamine and it's supposedly shown that we can buy horse and carts, including carts with maxim guns, amongst some other stuff

but ye, never put all your faith in datamining, it could be cut leftovers, it could be bullshit, it could be anything, best to just wait and see
>>
File: 1423750472381.gif (1.13 MB, 260x195)
1.13 MB
1.13 MB GIF
>>233804512
>>
>>233804512
go away /gtag/, your time has come and gone
>>
makes me sad we need to go through amateur hour again with GTA VI before RDR3
>>
File: 1445127463399.gif (1.85 MB, 500x376)
1.85 MB
1.85 MB GIF
Even if lassos don't work on other players we better be able to lasso npc's. We could raid a town and steal their women, take them back to our camp.
>>
>>233804668
It's better this way, RDR gets to benefit from all the GTA tech and so on if it always releases towards the end of a generation.

>>233804685
It's gonna be like GTA:O where there's fuck all in the way of pedestrian activity, I'd wager.
>go to Saint Denis
>only 2 - 3 people on each street at best
>out in the wilds
>only see fauna sparingly instead of being jam packed
>>
>>233804801
you now remember that GTA:O didn't even have fauna
>>
>think about what a cool name for me would be when I started playing
>start the gambling challenges
>now I can choose from "the Domino Strangler" and "Blackjack 3 Hit Hitman"
I've probably killed 5 dealers and 10 or so domino cucks.
>>
>>233804983
Online achievements imply there will be animals, there's an achievement for selling items to the butcher. There's also achievements for crafting and camp upgrades, so all the outdoors shit will remain most likely.
>>
>>233805215
Mines "The Chinaman".
>>
>>233805272
Thank fuck. I hope it's not something hokey like the animals only spawn in if you interact with a clue ala the legendary animals.
>>
why do characters pronounce it San Denny when it's spelled Saint Denis

yes, I'm probably retarded
>>
>>233805552
Lemoyne is based on Louisiana and Saint Denis is New Orleans. It's that retarded swamp French pronunciation.
>>
>>233805642
cheers anon
>>
>>233805350
this would be shit
>>
>>233805303
absolutely based
>>
I'M GOING TO WHERE THE SUN BURNS
AND THE HEAT STAYS IN
COME IN
COME AND LAY BY MY SIDE
RIGHT HERE
>>
File: 1368731276127.png (7 KB, 590x322)
7 KB
7 KB PNG
>>233805303
Would someone explain how Chinaman is racist?

>What do you call someone from England?
>An Englishman.
>And Ireland?
>An Irishman.
>What about France?
>A Frenchman.
>So someone from China is a Chinaman.
>RACIST!!!
>>
>>233806193
stigma from it mostly being used in a derogatory sense, unlike your other examples; it's the same as how you can acceptably shorten British to Brit, but not Pakistani to Paki
>>
>>233806285
Oh. My brain has a hard time coming to terms with it. I don't consider myself racist so maybe that's why it doesn't make sense.
>>
>>233805552
YA TALMBAU SAYN DAH-NEEY PARDNER?
>>
File: Boss.jpg (1.08 MB, 1920x1080)
1.08 MB
1.08 MB JPG
>>233791804
HE'S SO BAD
THEY CALL HIM BOSS
THEY CALL HIM BOSS
BOSS NIGGER
>>
>>233806383
Eh, tha ee.
>>
Gang rankings
Van der Linde gang>O'Driscolls>Leymone Raiders>Del Lobos>Murfree Brood>Night Folk>Bronte Family
>>
>>233806183
SEE THE FIRE IN YOUR EYES
SEE THE FIRE IN YOUR EYESAAAAHHAAHHHHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaaAAAAAHHHHHHAAAAAaaaaAAAAAAAAaaaaaaaHHHHHaaaaaaaHAAAahaaHHHAAAAaAAAAAaaahhHaaaaHaaa
>>
File: 1541764874385.png (794 KB, 1009x572)
794 KB
794 KB PNG
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ImsvAcxj_0Y
>>
>>233806569
>not mentioning the skinners
Those fucks are up to more evil shit than all the other forest-dwelling clicks combined
>>
>>233806569
>commies at the top
Here's your You. Now you take it and get outta town pardner, and don't never come back.
>>
>>233806620
your did your worst, you tried your best, now it's time to rest
>>
>>233793724
stop playing the game in Nazi, please.
>>
best game R* have made, holy shit
>>
File: giphy.gif (2.39 MB, 300x195)
2.39 MB
2.39 MB GIF
>>233804512
holy shit.
>>
>>233803720
You see him a couple days later by the Saint Denis gallows about to be hanged.
>>
>>233807428
kys namefag
>>
>>233807428
>this sickening name/tripfaggotry
No.
Post as anon or gtfo to where you came from
>>
>>233806569
>forgot that gang that shows up in the epilogue
Seems about right, lame ass "gang"
>>
File: me.png (489 KB, 470x469)
489 KB
489 KB PNG
>>233807451
>>233807532
oh sweet summer child
youre gonna have a bad next 6 years
>>
>>233806845
assmad pinkerton or Cornwall cockrider. upset at others that actually want to be free?
>>
>>233807618
Stop being a cringey turbo faggot and take the goddamn trip off like the rest of us you attention whoring fruitcake.
>>
File: 1541703708506.png (395 KB, 480x504)
395 KB
395 KB PNG
>Goat farm in the heartlands
>Man inside looks like he's crying
>Go inside to ask what's up
>Shoots at me
>Kill him and skin every three star goat
It didn't have to be this way
>>
>>233807618
just fuck off back to /gtag/'s circlejerk, dumb cunt
>>
>>233807618
you got bullied out of gtag too, i'm not worried

there's just no room for true autism
>>
File: callmeqt.jpg (54 KB, 498x430)
54 KB
54 KB JPG
>>233807618
>>
File: 1514167114736.png (13 KB, 650x650)
13 KB
13 KB PNG
>>233807642
>free
>unironically keep following a lunatic who talks about mangoes and Tahiti all day
>>
>>233807734
i am gtag
All Thats left there is this weird looking fat mexican with a bloody nose who people laugh at

i dont get it
>>
>>233807642
how the fuck are the van der linde's free in any sense? For one, they're still just chasing money like every other sucker, it's not like they're a self sufficient community, they're a collection of leeches
>>
>>233807854
>i am gtag

hahahahahaha

'tism in full effect

gtfo
>>
>>233807854
You're like a crazy raving old lunatic on a street corner, fucking neck yourself.
>>
>>233807854
>i am gtag
gtag is a PC general, you must be mistaken, you're actually a nobody. Now fuck off.
>>
>>233807897
I don't understand why they didn't find some land and build a community but I guess none of them know a thing about working outside of beating the shit out of passerbys for cash.

The Van Der Lindes are bad people.
>>
name field should unironically be disabled on /vg/ and signing off posts besides those LFG should be a bannable offence
>>
>>233807660
>>233807729
>>233807734
namefigs are only after attention. Just ignore them
>>
>>233807821
>American oil tycoon
>two old slaver families
>A ruthless gang akin to terrorists
>Wops and mafiosos
>Sugar plantation owner and some Cuban general
>Hired Security guards/detectives with unlimited supply of men and armaments
>all BTFO by mango spouting lunatic
there's just no recovering from the anal destruction Dutch's gang dishes
>>
File: indy-box.jpg (24 KB, 450x450)
24 KB
24 KB JPG
>>233791804
>>
>>233808207
Was fun dressing like Alfie Solomons dealing with Bronte.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXL4nNrvaqA
>>
>>233808010
you don't understand, just ONE MORE SCORE
>>
>>233808207
>all BTFO by a misguided loyal friend who ends up hating Dutch
ftfy
>>
This fucking dumb shit is why we're going to need multiple crews

the problem with gtag and its crew is that there was just an in crowd that everyone wanted to be a part of. No differing voices allowed and regular anons are snowed under by basement dwelling trap neets.

>>233808106
This was about setting a precedent; we have to make sure that name/trip/avatarfagging doesn't happen. It's what kills a general.
>>
you guys are ready to jump off the soon to be sinking ship that will be /rdrg/ once Online launches, right? Place will turn to shit within hours.
>>
>>233808415
that's why we just need a random new non-gtag anon to make the crew and if there really has to be a discord, it needs to be made readily available to anyone and everyone in the crew and not just a clique.

>>233808430
but this is probably more true.
>>
File: 1538335967305.jpg (259 KB, 1042x1157)
259 KB
259 KB JPG
>>233808430
I'm honestly worried it will end up like /gtag/. But maybe, just maybe we have a better player base here. I hope we all get to keep playing together though.
>>
>>233808605
it's /vg/, of course it's going to go the way of /gtag/ i.e. absolute shit
>>
>>233808430
>scrolls up
>WHERE'S X WHY CANT I X?!?!?!?!
>UM WHERE'S ALL MY STUFF WHEN ARTHUR DIES
>feels
>some decent stories
>memeposting
It's not a great already.
>>
>>233808430
gtag was really fucking cool the first few months; PLUS it doesn't have to be that way. Building a community doesn't revolve around a handful of faggots determining who's in and who's out.

>>233808524
I'm probably starting to sound like a broken record to people who actually read all posts; but multiple crews (not just different platforms) is the best thing to do. That way there will be a stronger sense of democracy, allows people to move around when they don't like the place where they're at, and a way to isolate faggots.
>>
>>233808670
all online game generals are trash. This is at least primarily on topic throughout atm.
>>
>>233808670
>people talking about the game
looks fine to me, call me when it devolves into retarded infighting and drama that has nothing to do with the game
>>
what was your favourite mission?

pic related excluded
>>
>>233809095
The Charlotte stuff.
>>
>>233809095
hot air balloon, valentine bank robbery and guarma in general
>>
>>233809229
>guarma
hahahaha wow i hated that from start to finish
>>
>>233809095
What's the name of the track that plays during this scene?

Also, the drinking mission with Lenny.

>>233809283
Really? I thought it was great. Was only brief (maybe even too brief) so it didn't overstay its welcome, and I totally didn't see it coming
>>
>>233809378
true, totally didn't see it coming; and it was a very unpleasant surprise.

not trying to knock your tastes and fun btw, just surprised how it could differ so much. but desu, don't know what the general consensus was on guarma.
>>
i helped a guy get to strawberry and he told me something about the mayor and then i helped this woman get to emerald ranch and she told me something about the owner and his daughter. am i supposed to do something with those informations? it doesn't show up in my log
>>
good goy edition lads, was the rhodes bank robbery any good?
>>
>>233809770
it was pretty fucking cool, and made a shitton of money for that point in the story.
>>
>>233809770
Yeah easy $10k made the getaway was nice
>>
File: 0_0 (3).jpg (197 KB, 1920x1072)
197 KB
197 KB JPG
Post your photos with Abigali
>>
>>233809987
johns love for abigail truely makes my heart melt
>>
>>233808712
>gtag was really fucking cool the first few months; PLUS it doesn't have to be that way. Building a community doesn't revolve around a handful of faggots determining who's in and who's out.

this. shame new /gtag/ went to shit instead of doing exacty what you said which is exactly how it started on ps3
>>
>>233809690
anybody?
>>
>>233810564
you're part of the problem, you mong
>>
>>233809690
Cut content or an easter egg mystery
>>
God I hope this never comes to PC
>>
>>233810738
so it's literally nothing?
>>
as someone who spends a lot of time in the bayou; i just want to say that literally every alligator snapping its mouth like a trashcan before it goes under when im passing in my boat sounds dumb as fuck

I'm no steve irwin, but not all crocs do this all the time
>>
HOLD IT
ya better get too nagpostin, pardner

coming through with some thiccness
>>
>>233809095
Last mission in chapter 6 for the feels or the last mission of the 2 pt epilogue for the kino music, setting, and revenge.
>>
File: Spoiler Image (837 KB, 1181x1400)
837 KB
837 KB PNG
>>233809690
It's a spooky Easter egg, the real mystery in this game is that one missing princess girl you find her toy box with her initials on it I.K.Z or something like that
>>
>>233811348
I feel like that is the same thing really as in I doubt they have answers to either one. Probably both are just there to make you wonder
>>
>>233810895
its just lore that adds depth and mystery to the game, not everything has to have a quest marker and a journal entry you zoomer
>>
File: Karen.jpg (118 KB, 627x675)
118 KB
118 KB JPG
>>233791804
i'm gonna make a total slutbuild and erp with other sluts.
>>
File: 0_0 (5).jpg (434 KB, 1920x1072)
434 KB
434 KB JPG
>>
>game doesn't have Remington
>>
File: m9vy6uyqrnw11.jpg (16 KB, 208x369)
16 KB
16 KB JPG
>>233811686
Probably, would be cool if something actually turns up out of all of this hunting though
>>
>>233812005
take a bath you hobo
>>
>>233812056
>game doesn't have LeMat
First one had it.
Why? Is it the inevitable DLC?
>>
>>233812076
Yeah, I've spent way too much time looking for something to do with her and even though I doubt there is anything to find I still enjoy looking just in case there actually is somethign
>>
>>233812005
imagine the smell
>>
>>233799181
Hehe Tone you heard what I said? Fock!
>>
Was I supposed to get Arthur's weapons and horses as John? Because I didn't..
>>
>>233811206
that's pretty thick, feller.

i likem shiny
>>
>>233812214
I think Arthur just knows cap amd ball is way past outdated by now.

Hell, the double shotgun seems to be a conversion kit.

On a related note, I’m hoping you can choose what weapons to keep in your horse from your home for online. Scrolling through every retard ass weapon rockstar decides to add for the one you want to use is goong to be a fucking pain.
>>
File: 0_0.jpg (335 KB, 1920x1072)
335 KB
335 KB JPG
>>
>>233797845
absolutely
>>
File: 0_0 (1).jpg (403 KB, 1920x1072)
403 KB
403 KB JPG
>>
>>233792491
Autist did the gold bar dupe glitch at least 6 full fucking times. Funny thing is, even 1 time is enough. I never did it once and still had more then enough money then I knew what to do with.

I bought every gun, maxed out all supplies, bought most clothing, had the fastest horse, etc and I only found like 6 gold bars + did all the missions. Never grinded at any point.
>>
>>233813279
>While on horseback I selected the guns I needed for the mission
>Arthur gets off and has a varmint rifle and bow when I had a Lancaster and Pump action shotgun selected
>>
File: 0_0 (4).jpg (442 KB, 1920x1072)
442 KB
442 KB JPG
>>
>>233812684
pls
>>
>>233792489
CRUEEEEL CRUEL WORLD IM GONE
>>
>>
>>233813828
Thumbnail looks like the terminator.
>>
File: 0_0 (3).jpg (580 KB, 1920x1072)
580 KB
580 KB JPG
>>
>>233812684
I got the weapons but I've heard horse are a no.
>>
>>233813521
nigga you need to get some style BRUH
>>
Anyone else rolling with /natsoc/ haircut? I never wear a hat because it looks so fucking cool.
>>
>>233814021
Finished the epilogue, never got my weapons. Guess I've lost my unique weapons for good.
>>
File: 0_0 (2).jpg (356 KB, 1920x1072)
356 KB
356 KB JPG
>>
File: Spoiler Image (292 KB, 1920x1072)
292 KB
292 KB JPG
>>233814319
Forgot pic
>>
>>233808010
This, John was dumb enough to buy Beecher's Hope, which was useless for farming and was only rescued by Uncle's advice
>Tfw Uncle saved the day in the end
>Tfw Dutch would have probably overthrown the Tahitian government within a year and fled the island
>>
Been playing Red Dead 2 for 2 weeks now and I haven't come across any scenario where previous decisions you make in the game affect the story in any way.
>>
>>233799330
You can find him being hung later on at the gallows in Saint Denis, I think he murdered a woman because she had an ugly face or something like that.
>>
>>233809987
Which jacket is that?
>>
File: jihadi john.jpg (233 KB, 1920x1072)
233 KB
233 KB JPG
>>233814319
no you dirty kuffar
>>
>>233814839
So?
>>
>LENNAH!

https://youtube.com/watch?v=DLLnVgtuGR0
>>
>>233815292
Well I'm pretty sure it was one of the games selling points
>>
Apparently there is kind of a secret quest to exterminate Carolina Parakeets. Fuckers are hard to find.
>>
File: 0_0 (2).jpg (235 KB, 1920x1072)
235 KB
235 KB JPG
>>
>>233814527
>uncle's advice
what? 'build a house' or 'you can't farm here'?

because I didn't hear 'grab dutch's gold and pay off your mortgage' coming from his mouth
>>
Why haven’t you joined the US Cavalry?
>>
>>233815553
>what? 'build a house' or 'you can't farm here'?
both those things are things that john wouldnt have done without him, he was seriously thinking of telling abigail to come back to that ruined piece of shit cabin that was left there
>>
Any tips for finding panthers? Saw one, poor pelt, tried to do the whole reload thing and nothing is nearby now.
>>
>>233815419
That's not really usually Rockstar's thing but I didn't follow the advertising too much. Your choices have a few consequences in the end game at least. So you can look forward to that.
>>
>>233813172
what hat is that? looks cool
>>
>>233813172
Hamish's hat. Non saveable, and loses the feathers after a day or so.
>>
>>233793956
18 NAKED COWBOYS AT RAM RANCH
>>
>>233816294
meant for
>>233816190
>>
File: IMG_7377.jpg (1.12 MB, 3024x4032)
1.12 MB
1.12 MB JPG
>>233816304
>>
Goddamnit I don't want to do any quests for Mary anymore but I can't stand it when there's an icon on the map.
>>
So are the coats really limited to the like 10-12 you can buy in shops and the handful of crafting ones?

I want a really smart suit.
>>
>>233816889
Fuck why am I doing this quest?
>>
>>233808414
>Lone autist with bolt action rifle annihilates hundreds of army men
Arthur was reincarnated as Simo Häyhä
>>
>>233816889
>>233817291
So you can read Arthur's journal entries and have your heart broken.
>>
Any place I can find hungarian halfbreeds to break for horseman 10, other than the southern no go areas?
I lost hundreds trying to grab a horse from there.
>>
>>233816889
>Not just refusing to help her when she asks a second time
Don't let her do this to you my man.
>>
>>233817383
>>233817658
Following her deadbeat dad, listening to bitching fuck I hate this.
>>
I told her no right away in chapter 2, which I still havent finished. Is she going to ask me to help her brother a second time?
>>
Post more spooky stuff, I love it.
The swamp ghost lady legit spooked me.
>>
Awwww yes, that bank heist in saint denis is gonna end the chapter in a bank, t's about time the team got themselves a win, i cant wait to have arthur and sadie start their own apricot farm in tahiti or something
>>
>>233818095
>>
>>233818673
obviously the ending is dutch bill and javier wasting their money for john to start a farm while the rest of the gang ships off to tahiti, good ending for everyone
>>
>>233817754
Probably not. Even if she does ask for help again, you can refuse again.
>>
how do you reasonaby beat gambler 10, you cant back out like you can with 9
>>
just did the aberdeen pig farm, but when i returned to their house, they weren't there. big disappointment, wanted to hogtie the bitches and throw them in the pit they left me in.
>>
File: holden.jpg (11 KB, 194x259)
11 KB
11 KB JPG
>>233791804

Whatever exists without my knowledge exists without my consent.
>>
>>233819827
They should be there. Didn't they take all of your money?
>>
>>233819947
yep. but i just walked in, took my money back, took all of their stuff... never saw them.
>>
I really REALLY want to sniff mary-beth's unwashed asshole!!!!
>>
what about fancy moves where you keep your hand on the hammer of the gun; kinda expected the double action revolver to be a faster shooting gun but its not much of a difference
>>
>>233791804
>>
what is the best one stop wiki type site for rdr2? Or is it all boomer cash grab blogs with “tips”. It’s hard to find a reliable one with everything. Ty dutchgang
>>
>>233791614
why didn't dutch just send sadie to get the money from blackwater?
>>
>>233792389

> pack up Mary Beth and a bunch of supplies
> head up into the north county
> spend the days hunting in the mountains and the nights making love beneath the stars
> kill and skin her
> take her pelt to the trapper
> have him make a girl suit out of real girls
> put it on and work as a hooker in Saint Denis
>>
>>233815832
Managed to do it. For anybody curious or willing to share this to others in the future:
Head South of Braithwaite Manor, stay on the east side of the small woodland area down there. Run in to the woods, then back to the road. It seems to force a Panther spawn, just jeep trying.
Save the same way you do with Cougars, shortly before you encounter one to reload if it isn't a perfect pelt.
>>
>>233821315
that went dark pretty quickly
>>
>>233821249
Piggyback official game guide
>>
>>233820790
Fanning the hammer? Just fire from the hip
>>
>>233792993

Having fucked men with all sorts of tools, I can tell you that the big boys are the most annoyingly loud of the bunch. Guys with average/short cocks are usually pretty humble.
>>
File: 1532622304371.jpg (45 KB, 637x358)
45 KB
45 KB JPG
>fishing with dutch and hosea
This is the most boomercore game of the millennium.
>>
>>233821308
Same reason he couldn’t just hang out in lemoyne until everything cooled down.
>>
File: 0_01.jpg (577 KB, 1920x1072)
577 KB
577 KB JPG
Hate playing as john, just has such a faggot aesthetic compared to arthur
>>
>>233821750
was dutch the only one who knew where the money was?
>>
>>233821371
Yeah. He should have separated the whole Days and Nights bit into 2 meme arrow texts to keep proper pacing.
>>
>>233820883

I went with Kilmer in Tombstone. Black vest, grey pants, white shirt, red puff tie and a Big Valley hat.

I really was aiming for William in Westworld, but I could never make it work.
>>
>>233816749

There really needs to be a mod for wearing chaps with no pants.
>>
>>233809189

Same here.

When I woke up and she was gone hunting and didn't come back I freaked out and spent days spiraling around looking for her. Then I came back and found her on the porch and I was so relieved.
>>
When is Marko Dragic at his lab?
>>
>>233822616
At night.
>>
Anyone else fine Bonnie MacFarlane's husband as he dies?
>>
>>233822616
at night between 10pm and 3am roughly
>>
>>233822683
yes
>>
File: 1531686952757.png (257 KB, 1012x790)
257 KB
257 KB PNG
>going fishing with hosea and dutch
i seriously hope you didn't skip this
>>
>>233822683
Why would you fine a woman for having a dead husband?
>>
File: 1541573521213.png (325 KB, 430x365)
325 KB
325 KB PNG
>>233821752
zoom zoom
*sip*
>>
Oh shit I wasn't expecting tha O'Driscoll attack
>>
File: Cairn Lake.jpg (337 KB, 1920x1072)
337 KB
337 KB JPG
Where are my huntsman bros at?
>>
>>233823446
Being a window is against the law.
>>
>taking Buell on the final mission
>>
>building a house
nigga, your nails aren't doing anything
>>
>>233824172
Just snagged my perfect beaver pelt, best hat coming soon. Speaking of hunting, is tracking outside of eagle eye supposed to be absolute ass everywhere but Roanoke or at night?
>light yellow footprints on
>bright white snow
>bright yellow grass
>bright light greens
>>
File: 1482411449118.jpg (29 KB, 292x257)
29 KB
29 KB JPG
>Greeting people at the Saint Denis party
>LIterally holding L2 and mashing square
>Arthur just yells "MADAM"
>>
John his little scribbles in Arthur his journal are cute.
>>
>>233824665
I used that mission to HOWDY MISTER my honor back up quite a ways.
>>
File: shock.jpg (84 KB, 937x721)
84 KB
84 KB JPG
>getting suddenly body-slammed by random animals like bucks in first person mode
>>
>>233824556

Yeah it's pretty shit, they should have really chosen a different colour since the yellow blends so easily into the environment.
>>
>John and everyone disappeared even though I never used a checkpoint

What is with this mission
>>
Just finished DLing Rootin Tootin Cowboy Shootin II. Thanks for making me break down anons
>>
I saw a couple of posts a while ago of some person being chained up whole wearing an animal mask or some shit in a house with torture devices. Where the hell can I find it? I have absolutely no idea what it is but I haven't managed to find it.
>>
Oh no the very unpredictable snake in the group is talking about how they need to cut some of the group off. How surprising.
>>
>>
>>233825817
enjoy, try to avoid spoilers and go in blind as much as you can
>>
is the panoramic map an unsolved mystery?

I found it from the frozen couple like anyone else, I left for a while and when I came back 30 mins later their bodies were gone, is that a glitch or part of the event?
>>
>>233799612
when has a good drama ever had a shitty name
>>
I WANT MY HALFBREED REEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
>>233826847
t. mutt
>>
>>233799884
kys
>>
>>233826847
>expose woman to demonic energy via hot monstergirl on girl action...or just drop her near some high level monsters or in the corrupted lands or something if you wanna be a fag about it
>enjoy succubus woman who is now half monster half human via corruption
Problem solved.
>>
File: sam-axe-nbcu.jpg (19 KB, 250x315)
19 KB
19 KB JPG
>>233800072
shut it down
>>
File: 1507487643390.jpg (28 KB, 619x453)
28 KB
28 KB JPG
There must be a way to cure TB. I mean it was so common back then someone had to know something, clean fresh air, mercury or whatever...
>>
File: 1531150540804.jpg (36 KB, 671x541)
36 KB
36 KB JPG
>>233819940
Shit, now I have to go read this fucking book.
>>
>>233826914
>>233827218
the horse you fucks, i cant find it outside of rhe south and its driving me insane
>>
File: 1517865787740.jpg (49 KB, 600x400)
49 KB
49 KB JPG
did i
hear a thunder?
did i
hear you break
>>
find some moldy bread to eat
>>
>>233827538
meant for
>>233827384
>>
>>233827521
Yeah...I entirely forgot what thread I was posting in.
I swear theres a horse map online that tells you exactly where to go for what.
>>
File: 1260375_orig.jpg (8 KB, 250x276)
8 KB
8 KB JPG
>>233804512
cool daddio
>>
>>233827384
>Tfw holding out hope that there's a secret hard-to-get Easter egg that saves Arthur
>>
>>233824374
Nobody cares about your horse you autist
>>
>>233828210
I do
>>
>>233827532

Unshaken > So Far Away > Every other song in RDR2
>>
>>233827521
https://www.gamerevolution.com/guides/449957-red-dead-redemption-2-horse-locations-guide
Here use that while I find the damned map in my bookmarks...
>>
>he didn't get the secret ending where Arthur cures his TB, survives and shows up at the end of RDR1 to save John from the army
>>
>>233805552
you don't usually pronounce the last consonant of a word in french unless it's followed by a vowel
sous = sue
paris = pear-ee
saint = sohn
denis = den-ee
>>
Heard there were some BIG BOYS on this boat.
>>
>>233828424
My bad.
Nobody else than you cares about your horse you autist*
>>
>>233806193
It's not racist.
>>
Jesus, Dutch is a fucking psychopath.
>>
>>233825632
Train?
>>
File: Spoiler Image (2.9 MB, 1280x720)
2.9 MB
2.9 MB WEBM
>mfw fishing with tomahawks
>>
>>233825632
Nah the one with Uncle and the girls in chapter 2
>>
File: 1532018397718.jpg (73 KB, 960x960)
73 KB
73 KB JPG
>OFFICIAL GUIDE TO GAMBLING CHALLENGE 8

So, you wanna play Blackjack stupidly and not go crazy huh? Well God help you. First, a little on how this challenge is worse than Lumbago:
1. In single deck Blackjack, the odds of having an opening hand that can hit three times is astronomically poor. Even with double aces and just you and the dealer playing, the odds of hitting a 9 or 10 is about 38% (always assuming the dealer has 20). Your hit after has a 36% chance of getting you to bust or to 21. And this is just you and the dealer, let's not include the NPC players who can fuck everything up themselves.
2. NPC Bullshit. These morons have been programmed to absolutely fuck with your cards. They do not play "to the odds", specifically on their soft 17s. Normally this would not matter, but since you're trying something terribly stupid, every advantage you can have helps.
>But Anon, this doesn't help me against the worst challenge since winning dominos, what's the point?
I'm glad you asked.

Firstly, you're going to want to sit at first base (the first seat). This takes away the NPCs from the equation, at the cost of adding more cards to the deck. However, it also allows you to see NPC's cards, which might clue you in to what's still in the deck. Example: you have 3/2, Cleetus has 17, Fetus has 20, dealer has a face card showing. There's now only a 27% chance of you hitting into a face card. With your newfound knowledge of how to poorly count cards, let's move on.

You're going to split any doubles that aren't aces, twos, threes, or fours. Doing this allows to fuck with math in a lot of ways. I don't have statistics for this one, just experience. I'm assuming the odds are close enough that you could have two 14s as well as two 4/2s.
3. Hit the 20 at 4 cards. You have nothing to lose, you're close enough, and the money doesn't matter. Gotta get lucky eventually, right?
4. Turn on something else to do. This takes forever.

Good luck!
>>
I just got killed by some creepy facepainted guys after shot a corpse down from a tree in the swamp area.
>>
>>233828518
Found it. Literally called rdr2map...not sure why I couldn't remember that...
https://rdr2map.com
>>
File: 1532628192816.png (143 KB, 672x434)
143 KB
143 KB PNG
>>233828824
I found myself enjoying Dutch more and more as his insanity progressed. He went from wannabe goodboi to twisted fucking psychopath, which I felt was much more fitting for a gang of outlaws.

>Letting the Braithwait whore crawl into a burning building
>Killing that Mexican whore in a cave
>Throwing the spaghetti man to the gator
>>
>>233829067
>talked about multiple times
>still have yet to see anyone else just shoot a rabbit or frog or something small, put its corpse in shallow water, then just pick up any fish that come to try and eat it but get stuck instead
Plebs, all of you.
>>
>>233829159
Thanks man, I'm working on this right now. 1/3 so far
>>233829272
You just met the night folk
>>
Fellow huntsmen, where is your favorite hunting ground? I'm loving the woods near Annesburg right now.
>>
>>233829067
I Like to fish by just picking up fish that jump on the ice
>>
what's the best horse that isn't an arabian? the arabian is so small it looks like a pony when you ride it
>>
>>233829625
Last night I pushed twice against the dealer with 5 cards, I murdered everyone in Van Horn, then looked up some statistics into single deck. I actually have kind of a bad gambling problem and I love "normal" Blackjack, my butthurt helped me look into it. I wanted to know why it was so bad, now I kind of know. It's an awful challenge, especially with the dealer paying out so terribly slow and no turn skip. I fucking hate it.
>>
File: 1498984959839.jpg (125 KB, 1280x720)
125 KB
125 KB JPG
>>233792414
>Why does a dishonorably discharged soldier share similar hat to a military one?
>>
>>233813656
I'm not him but here's your cookie you sad faggot who gives a shit about a single player game
>>
So how does the buck trinket work? Does it just add a star to the quality of whatever you skin?
>>
>>233829625
>night folk
Are they a gang or related to some quest?
>>
File: fishing.webm (2.75 MB, 1920x1080)
2.75 MB
2.75 MB WEBM
>>233829067
>not just having all the fish come to you
>>
>>233830527
Gang, there's also a stranger quest where you go clear a dudes cabin out of night folk
>>
>>233829959
I love Big Valley, WE and Roanoke Ridge
>>
>Hatchets don't show up on Arthur
>he just pulls them out of his coat
Lame
>>
>>233830624
Whut?
>>
>>233825831
New austin
>>
>>233830865
i was hunting something and those 3 fish just swam onto the path and died
all 3 star bass
>>
>>233830864
>Pistol belt
>Bandolier
>No quiver for arrows
>>
>took a dude to a doctor
>actually saw his arm getting amputated
I love the details
>>
>>233808524
newfag to /vg/ here
long time gtao veteran
will be starting a crew for online
not doing it to whore for attention, don't really want the responsibility, but don't want to miss out on the fun of playing with a large group like i did with gtao early on
there will not be a discord unless there's serious numbers that really require it later on, and even then it's a big if
expectations of gang members will be low, no applications or mandatory meetups or any of that bullshit
confirmed redditry, tumblry, fortnitery, breakaway factions and any other forms of intolerable faggotry will all result in an instantaneous and irrevocable permaban
turbo-autism is fine so long as it's not significantly and regularly impeding gameplay for others in the crew
women will be tolerated, as will reasonable sexism against them
coloreds will be tolerated, as will reasonable racism against them
we'll have blackjack and tahitian hookers and more mangoes than you could ever imagine
thoughts?
>>
File: Owanjila.webm (2.89 MB, 854x480)
2.89 MB
2.89 MB WEBM
Post favorite locations
>webm related
>>
>>233829959
Area surrounding pronghorn ranch
>>
>>233831541
Fuck off, we'll all be better off just meeting and letting namefags circlejerk this general into oblivion while we have fun with people we like.
>>
>>233829959

I really love the snowy region up in the Grizzlies but there’s hardly anything to hunt out there except for rams. I’ve been looking for a moose up there but have yet to find one.

I mainly love hunting in the Grizzlies because I get to wear the winter clothing that I crafted using the legendary bear’s fur without getting hot. That outfit looks so badass in the snow. Except for the goofy ass bear hat.
>>
How do I give this pocket mirror I found to Molly?
>>
>Everyone going on and on about how the fairly regular folk of lemoyne are inbred hillbillies
>travel north east
>find actual inbred hillbillies all sharing their mispelled last name of Murphy

Welp, at least they are a great source of shotgun ammo.
>>
>>233830624
The rare American suicide fish.
>>
>>233831729
Probably Lake Isabella. The entire snowy area is comfy as fuck desu.
The area you posted is my 2nd favorite area though.
>>
>>233821308
dutch doesn't trust anyone but himself
>>
>great grandfather was born in 1899

that weird feeling when you realise you've lived among people who were alive during this age
>>
>>233832502
Dutch don’t trust no Dutch. There is a reason he killed Dutch.
>>
>decide to go beaver hunting along the Upper Montana River
>I’m wanted dead or alive on the other side of the river
>can’t get rid of the bounty
>after a few hours of searching, finally find a three-star beaver
>shoot at it with my Varmint Rifle
>I hit it, but it doesn’t die
>it dives into the river
>I chase it to the other side of the river
>kill it
>skin it
>suddenly realize that I’m on the wrong side of the river
>five lawmen spawn a few feet away from me
>I try to run away
>they kill me
>I lose my beaver pelt

God damn it.
>>
>>233832758
outplayed
>>
Can I do the Hamish missions as John even if I started it as Arthur?
>>
File: TRUE_MANGO.jpg (230 KB, 1100x1196)
230 KB
230 KB JPG
THE WAR WAS LOST
THE MANGO IS DRY
TAHITI IS THERE
I CROSSED THE LINE
(NEVERMIND)
>>
Alt universe mango farmer sim with RTS elements when?
>>
>>233833076
>>233833263
haha lol mangos xDDDd ;p
>>
>>233831964
>bootyblasted for no reason
not an argument
>>
>>233833426
>Implying you don’t want to play a resource management RDR game where you send your faggots on one last score to make up for poor seasons
>>
why is the arabian SO much better than the other horses? just found a leopard blanket appaloosa and while it looks cool, its stats are hot garbage by comparison.
>>
>>233833492
>hey guys, check out these rules i made up for how to play together!
yeah fuck off
>>
>>233829067
>not using dynamite
>>
Jesus christ. Did Arthur just get fucked in the ass by an inbred swamp redneck?
>>
>hunt legendary bison
>put like 5 bullets in his head
>somehow still alive enough to turn and run
>only gets about 100 feet before he jumps in a lake and dies
>body just out of reach to skin
Fuck
>>
>>233831541
Sounds like a decent plan; far better than reply-anon and just letting the circlejerk faggots create the one and only crew

When the time comes, make sure to have the balls and mouth to make other faggots wanting to make the rdrg crew fuck off
>>
>accidentally run over a snake with my horse
>look to see what it is
>it’s a three-star snake
>get a perfect snake skin off of it
>just what I was looking for
>can’t kill snakes any other way without small game arrows which I don’t have access to just yet
>try to replicate the conditions that led me to stomping a three-star snake to death
>keep getting poor-quality snake skins
>have stomped over a dozen three-star snakes to death without success
>still need just one more perfect snake skin
>>
>>233833612
>Caring about stats
>>
>>233833619
>women, coloreds, and intolerance for them all allowed
>being a faggot isn't
those were really the only rules
if you have a problem with either you should probably kys irl
>>
>>233833737
have you tried the lasso?
also dynamite
>>
>>233832758
Pelt wouldn’t have been three stars anyway, on account of taking two shots to kill
>>
>>233833870
Lasso didn't work, never thought of dynamite
>>
>>233833757
>make sure to have the balls and mouth
noted
>>
>>233806823
Where's that picture from?
>>
>>233833857
Unironically go away.
>>
>>233833857
>creating rules at all for an essentially lawless videogame
nigger
not even the same anon, I just hate you, you pinkerton fuck
>>
>kill a three-star deer
>it ends up dying in the water
>can’t lasso it out of the water for some reason
>can’t skin it in the water
>use Arthur to gently “push” the deer carcass out of the water and onto the shore
>success

Fuck yes!
>>
I tried to help a crying woman but it was a trap by the crazy swamp people and I got stabbed to death instantly. It's just like with the Murphy guys. What do I do against sudden knife attacks?
>>
>>233834030
>>233834063
still not an argument
sounds like you're gearing up to be the sad "competition"
stay mad cucks
>>
>>233833612
Most NPCs ride morgans, walkers and saddlers. You can use anything and outperform them.

Additionally, due to speedy horses having like half the stamina of slug horses, it takes about the same ammount of time to get anywhere but close by locations.

There is no real point in stat hunting.
>>
File: 1523611552248.png (2.12 MB, 1462x1462)
2.12 MB
2.12 MB PNG
At the bottom of the waterfall near Bacchus Station you can find a barrel. Inspect it.

>mfw Arthurs notes regarding this
>>
>>233831541
sounds cringe and bluepilled to be honest
fuck off
>>
>>233834183
at least your trip is off
>>
>>233834183
the argument that you're being a faggot was implied
if you'd like, I can actually go into detail
>>
>>233834167
hip fire
>>
>>233800580
>Bruce Campbell
Well, I'm sold
>>
>>233834190
the fox trotter and turkoman are worth it imo
>>
>>233791804
Hopefully online will have more bandana options
>>
>>233834236
>>233834257
>>233834354
>samefagging this hard
like i said, sad
>>
>>233834127
>kill a rare pelipper i need for a quest
>its across a river and im playing as john so swimming isnt an option
>rush around to a bridge
>birb is already rotting

Im glad you had a good experience, anon
>>
>>233832616
It really wasn't that long ago relatively. Kinda depresses me to think just how recently (((They))) ruined everything
>>
I'm trying to make a list of special animals not included in the compendiun, so far i have:
>Zebra (painted mule)
>Tiger (painted cougar)
>Lion (dog)
>Lion
>Green turtle
>White cougar

Anything else?
>>
>>233834689
It's pretty obvious no one likes your idea man. Not like it matters, online is still weeks away.
>>
>>233793221
>tfw va died so no rickets in 2
>>
>>233834879
it's pretty obvious you're the only one upset about it and purely out of envy
>>
>>233832758
You'll find way more beavers down the river in Roanoke

>>233832923
Yes. John comes in and says "Read about you in my friend's journal. He died though. Figured I'd come pay you a call"
>>
>>233835015
>envy
Of what? You had an idea and anyone who cared to respond said it was shitty.
>>
>>233794887
it's rdr1 theme that was composed by this one old dude that did a bunch work with older western movies iirc.
>>
>>233833736
I assumed the zipper noises were them stealing all my shit. Arthur didn't have a funny walk when I sprinted full tilt back there kick down the door and blow their heads open
>>
Is there a way to check which side missions you've done?
>>
File: real human bean.png (390 KB, 503x388)
390 KB
390 KB PNG
the epilogue has such a nice, bittersweet ending.
>>
Can you put those feather charms from the trapper on any hat, or just Arthur's default?
>>
>>233814475

how do you unbutton the shirts
>>
>>233835068
wrong. there was another anon with actual constructive criticism, and then you samefagging against it out of a place of deep seated envy
>>
My friend says he was giving some woman a ride, when wolves attacked and he shoved her off the horse to buy himself time. Can you actually do that?
>>
>>233834190
my horse is perma drugged if i dont want to stop. and i need a fucking stable upgrade, theres not enough room by far.
>>
>>233835698
the wolves or shooting at them probably triggered her to get off
>>
>>233835450
Just arthur's shitty default
>>
>>233835473
X/Square while in your wardrobe
>>
>>233798452
That sneaky frenchman is at it again.
>>
>>233835631
>accuse others of samefagging
>"constructive" post was yours
No one is listening to you besides me. This is for (You), now go shit up somewhere else.
>>
>>233814889
Oh man, that was him? I didn't even realize.
>>
>>233835904

thanks bro
>>
>>233834875
niggers
>>
>>233806193
Chinaman is not the preferred nomenclature. Asian-American, please.
>>
>Finished the epilogue but Pearson's satchels still aren't showing up at the Fence
Welp
>>
>>233836557
stfu ya dink
>>
>ride around
>random guy says "Mmh I'd kill a man for a horse as fide as this..."
>Arthur "errrm...thanks I guess"
>>
>>233836016
>i'm samefagging
>(((accuse your enemy of what you yourself do)))
wrong again. seems to be a pattern developing
>>
just had a nice burger it was very good!
>>
Met the swamp nigga who got bitten by a snake a third time already.
>>
>>233809987
I kept it casual
>>
>>233793724
don't try too hard to make him look like hitler, r*
>>
>>233793956
john can
>>
>>233837093
It was either the super static next to eachother one or your pose to pic.

My autism couldn’t imagine couples around that time posing for a photograph while embracing or even kissing
>>
>>233836823
At least they acknowledge it
>Pard'ner, you won't believe what just happened again
>>
I love the janky platforming. Climb up an abandoned broken down brick house, get a flower at the top.
>>
>>233836630
>t. zoomer
>>
File: yeet2.jpg (75 KB, 700x818)
75 KB
75 KB JPG
>>233837463
>>
>>233837468
My favorite is the hooker that keeps killing johns in Valentine
>>
>>233837463
I just thought it looked stupid to have the table and chairs in the background without them using them, so I went with a seated pose.
>>
>>233838189
It happens again?
>>
>>233838189
You can actually tie her up and bring her to the sheriff for 12 bucks
>>
>>233836823
Yeah I've met him quite a few times too, but every time after the first he says it's the 2nd time. Probably a bug.
>>
>High honor grips are only on the cattleman and double action
>>
>>233834689
Guess I'll go into detail, then.
Attempting to bring order in a game about outlaws and fighting against the steady ascension of civilization (popular structured order) to a group of people that generally don't want order (internet outlaws playing a game about outlaws) is folly. Not realizing this speaks to your character, as does your general faggotry within the thread and replies, and doesn't bode well for your proposed plan.
>game about freedom
>lol here are 'rules' that everyone can agree on xD :)) roflcopter
do you not get how reddit you are? seriously.
some srs incognisance goin' on 'round here, pardner
>inb4 samefag or something equally retarded
also, p.s. (You) sound like a liar based on the first post and the way it's written.
>>
File: 1496937098921.jpg (26 KB, 388x443)
26 KB
26 KB JPG
Post favorite guns of each category and why you like em.
>Revolvers
Cattleman.
Looks the best out of all the revolvers imo.
>Pistols
Semi-auto.
Breddy fun to use desu.
>Repeaters
Lancaster.
I hate repeaters so I just picked the one that doesn't look like shit.
>Rifles
Bolt Action.
Feels really satisfying to kill with.
>Shotguns
Double-barreled.
Aesthetics, and like the Bolt Action Rifle it's satisfying to kill with.
>Snipers
Carcano.
Able to hold more bullets than the Rolling Block while also looking pretty good.

Bonus weapon
It's not a gun, but the bow with dynamite arrows is the most fun I've had in a while
>>
>Arthur never liked revenge
>Called it a fools game
>Died to keep those he loved alive and away from danger
>John, Sadie and Charles leap on the first chance they get to kill Micah out of revenge

Good job fellers. Just shit on your brother's grave and what he died for why don't ya
>>
>you take an honor hit if you assist someone that got sold viagra and he kills the swindler in shit
I mean that was enjoyable to watch but why did I lose honor for something someone else did, and for killing a lying swindler at that
>>
Did Jewstar subtlety set up future DLC with Charles going to Canada and Sadie going to South America? Are we getting a GTA4 expansion like ballad of gay Tony and sons of Liberty?
>>
>>233839820
Highly unlikely, they can make more money by shitting out crates of silver bullion as microtransactions. If we get any single player dlc it'll be set in the existing map with the existing player characters.
>>
>>233839820
You wish. Those days are long over. The only thing we'll get is online stuff.
>>
>>233839407
>Revolvers
Cattleman
>Pistols
N/A
>Repeaters
N/A
>Rifles
Bolt Action
>Shotguns
Sawed-Off
>Snipers
N/A
>>
>>233839820
I'd rather go back to Mexico as Javier.
>>
>>233840080
speaking of, when is online?
>>
>>233839820
>single player DLC
not gonna happen, anon
>>
>>233839407
>Revolver
Cattleman
>pistol
Mauser
>Repeater
Carbine after you doctor it up
>Rifle
Bolt Action
>Shotgun
Da pump
>Sniper
Carcano I guess, I don't really like either
>Bonus weapon
Throwing knives, absolutely kino hitting someone with them or just running up and stabbing them
>>
>>233838069
Cute af
>>
where can i cook on the ranch?
>>
>>233839820
>>233840025

100% the existing map will be reused + maybe Mexico added to online; we might see:
> Blackwater Chronicles with Arthur/John as protagonists during the Ferry heist
> Mexico Epilogue with Javier as protagonist
> Undead Nightmare 2
>>
Guys, am I realistically missing out on a lot with John, Abigail, Sadie and Jack being missing from my camp?
>>
>>233840410
yes
>>
>>233840163
End of the month, probably with a trailer dropping next week.
>>
>>233840408
>>233840160
>Javier as protagonist

Why would we play as someone that opposed John and Arthur siding with Micah and dutch, the two playable characters and who we know Worked for the corrupt mexican government

He's a slimeball
>>
>California Valley Coyote
>Florida Cracker Cow
>two species found along completely different coasts of the US

Jesus. This game’s setting really is all over the place. So many states covered, and condensed into a tiny virtual world.
>>
>>233840367
You can't I think since you can eat Dinner instead. There might be a campfire outside, don't remember.
> John has to eat Abigail's cooking for the rest of the epilogue and you sometimes see him making faces
>>
>>233840367
The fire anon
>>
>>233840367
cooking is for women
you can burn things on a campfire
>>
>>233840516
Should i wait till its patched you think?
>>
I like that Arthur doesn't act like he's higher and mightier than a lot of people, as opposed to John, who always poked fun at people in a passive-aggressive manner in the first game.
The photographer dude, for instance, Arthur seems pretty willing to help, and he is pretty friendly with him.
>>
>>233840724
i tried, all i can do at the fire is drink coffee and sit
>>
>>233840602
It would help bridge RDR1 and RDR2, and set up how Dutch, Bill and Javier changed
> Javier was cool in RDR2
> Total jerk in RDR1
>>
>>233840809
no, just replay it later
>>
>>233840836
John's family was held captive by the gov, I don't think he cared to help people pick flowers and shit. He had a job to do
>>
>>233840809
>>233840274
>Tfw RDR2 will never be patched by Rockstar, and there will never be single-player DLC
>>
i would love to play as javier and understand what exactly his thought process was after siding with dutch
he was a cool fucking dude, perhaps my favorite member, but he just sides with dutch knowing the guy's going crazy
the story in RDR is that he left shortly after and started doing his own thing in Mexico, but John found him because he allowed Bill over
i want to see everything that happened, maybe give him some sort of redemption
definitely would play a javier in Mexico DLC
>>
Why is the wreck of the Serendipity not where it should be
>>
>>233841023
True enough. It's just a better game feel.
>>
>>233827384
It was resting up and letting your body fight it off, some medicine - Arthur was probably able to fend it off but he didn't have time. He had to get tugged along by Dutch and save everyone he cared about from going down with Dutch's sinking ship. Getting beaten the hell out of on a mountaintop definitely didn't help.
>>
>>233841053
It'll have to be patched. We just don't know when because rockstar never fucking talks
>>
>>233839407
>Revolvers
Cattleman
>Pistols
Volcanic
>Repeaters
Carbine
>Rifles
Bolt Action.
>Shotguns
Double-barreled.
>Snipers
Rolling Block
>>
>>233827384
Arthur could have held it off for a few years, but Dutch pushed him, and he pushed himself, with no medicine.
>>
>>233839407
>Revolvers
Schofield Revolver
>Pistol
Semi-auto
>Repeaters
Lancaster
>Rifles
Bolt Action
>Shotguns
Pump Action
>Snipers
Carcano, but there's not a lot of competition

>Bonus weapon
Hatchet
>>
>>233841278
It couldn't be cured until the 50s, but only slowed by dry air and rest. That's what Doc Holiday did and he lived for 15 more years after his TB diagnosis.
> Tfw no alternate ending escaping with Mary after the theatre and living out the rest of Arthur's remaining days in New Austin
>>
GUYS! GUYS! GUYS? GUYS!

I JUST SAW A UFO! UFO! UFO!

NO IT’S TRUE
>>
>>233799124
Where is this? Lone mule stead?
>>
>>233839407
>Revolvers
Schofield (chad)
>Pistols
Volcanic (chad)
>Repeaters
Lancaster (chad)
>Rifles
Springfield (chad)
>Shotguns
Double-barreled or repeating (both are chad)
>Snipers
Viking hatchet (chad)
>>
>>233839407
>Revolvers
Schofield. Feels like the only one remotely useful compared to rifles or shotties.

>Pistols
high power pistol

>Repeaters
idgaf about repeaters and never use them. might in online

>Rifles
Bolt Action
Absolutely based, beefy and actually poweful. Without the faggy scope attachement, in spite of the stat difference.

>Shotguns
Semi-auto
Ease of use; and it looks cool too. All shotguns are cool though, except for the repeating.

>Snipers
Idgaf about snipers, never use them, might in online.
>>
are the animals from guarma part of the compendium? if you missed them, does that mean you can't 100% the compendium?
>>
John's aim is way shakier than Arthur's. Takes longer for him to steady his shots with every weapon as well.
>>
>>233842092
bingo
>>
>>233842095
huh so it's not just me, I felt like my accuracy went down as john as well
>>
>>233842095
>>233842214
Fuck I'm playing right now and was just wondering this.
>>
>>233842214
Well, everyone comments on how Arthur's the best shot in the gang, so it makes sense.
>>
>>233842202
frick
>>
File: IMG_7380.jpg (22 KB, 618x238)
22 KB
22 KB JPG
> Oh Arthur
> Oh Mary
Why is this couple so autistic for each other?
>>
Why is my aim so awful? It wobbles all over the place like Arthur's having a seizure even when I'm standing still. And this is before TB.
>>
I don't get horses. Do war horses have more health and race horses have more stamina? Or are they faster and work horses have more stamina? I bought a horse in a stable and it was tiny. I was mad because Arthur looked like a faggot on this tiny horse. Are there some proper horse guides or do I have to go to wikipedia and read up on horse races to figure this shit out? My horse now is ugly greyish but I don't want to accidently buy another dwarf horse again.
>>
>>233842612
Is your Deadeye core empty?
>>
Why can’t I,

find any mooses—er, I mean, meese. No, wait. Moosii. Baaaah!
>>
>>233842540
they're young lovers that got hung up on each other, pretty simple, it happens all the time irl
>>
Is there a way to get the repeating shotgun early instead of having to play most of the game first?
I've restarted after beating it but I miss it
>>
Is there any way to trigger the item requests or do they just happen randomly?
>>
What happens to the money if i don't go back and get it?
>>
>>233842862
Go back and find out
>>
>>233842856
I sure hope so. I have dutch's pipe but he's never around so far in chapter 4 so I can't give it to him.
>>
ITT we discuss how the flat cap is the best hat in the game.

Lookin’ like a Peaky Blinder.
>>
>>233842768
Yes. Go to Watson' Cabin
>>
>>233842612
I think it gets worse if he's hungry
>>
>>233843069
Oh I'm sorry. You wrote the repeating shotgun and not semi-auto.
>>
>"Some of you cowpokes are alright. Don't come to St. Denis bank tomorrow.
>>
>>233841832
Everyone knows about it already.
>>
>>233843224
They should've made him more likeable so that him ratting to the pinkertons wouldn't have been so obvious.
>>
>>233838909
>gtao is about crime so crews don't work and are bad
wrong again, what do ya know
>ad hominem
>ad hominem
>ad hominem
(((you))) can get out
>>
>>233843378
He's a scumbag degenerate, but I never pegged him for a rat
>>
literally who thinks that gambler 8 could ever be fun to do
>>
>>233843224
>>233843378
I've seen Micah creepily hit on Abigail multiple times when John isn't around he reminds me of Trevor the way he talks
>>
>>233843549
Who thinks any of them are?
>>
>entire epilogue bridges the gap between rdr1 and 2 and leads to the start of the first game
Remaster or RDR1 campaign for RDR2 DLC imminent.
>>
>>233843549
followed anon's advice here
>>233829159
not sure about his math but sitting in the first seat made me feel better about the npc thing. got it in about 30 minutes
>>
Can't seem to get John to gain weight lads, he stays underweight and fluctuates between -7.5 and -6.25. What do
>>
>>233844104
Just keep eating meat until he does
>>
>>233844104
Eat motherfucker, EAT. You must understand that John needs twenty meals a day. MEALS. Not whimpy ass snacks from the eating wheel. MEALS from your satchel and fireplace. In this game, just eating like a normal person ain't enough. EAT EVERYTHING. If you find food on the floor? Eat all of it. You must make Toriko blush with your food intake.
>>
>>233843378
did he really rat, i don't think he did, and yes i did the Sadie Abigail rescue
>>
>>233844104
go hunting for an hour, cook the acquired 70 rump steaks
eat 20, continue eating 10 every ingame day
>>
>>233844024
yeah i'm sitting on the first seat too and getting up every time i bust so i don't have to wait for the hand to finish to play again, still it's mind boggling that they force us to do this to complete a challenge
>>
>>233844104
Go milk the cow and drink the entire bucket. If that doesn't work, then go and do the same to with the bull.
>>
i think mary beth wanted to talk to me in chapter 2, i was doing something and by the time i came back she was gone, i literally have no idea what she wanted, i don't know if it would have lead to a sidequest or something... i hate this feeling that i'm always going to miss out on something in this game. i'm really taking my time with the game and don't really plan on doing a second playthrough (at least not any time soon) so it would really suck to miss out on things...
>>
>>233844104
eat balanced meals
meat, dairy, grains, fruits and veggies
been underweight whole game until that
>>
WHY MUST I EAT SO MUCH TO KEEP MY WEIGHT IN THIS GAME?!?!
>>
File: django.jpg (14 KB, 474x266)
14 KB
14 KB JPG
>starts up RDR2
>starts with Arthur looking over Annesburg from high ground
>suddenly, a heavy boot starts stomping to a beat
>banjo tunes starts playing
>harmonica join in

when you know it's going to be one of those days
>>
File: Tesla3.jpg (38 KB, 389x495)
38 KB
38 KB JPG
Just when I thought this game couldn't get any better, I find Tesla's Wardenclyffe Tower.
>>
File: 1529269612475.gif (1.97 MB, 258x258)
1.97 MB
1.97 MB GIF
>just finished gambling challenge 10
who /luckyducky/ here?
>>
>>233844407
>This post

God damn zoomers
>>
I did the quest to help the widow with hunting. I went there back as John in the epilogue and she's dead on the floor. What the fuck? Is that supposed to happen?
>>
>>233844363

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Rb2r7rBKLY
>>
>Pearson has a picture of his old gang on the wall of his store

You IDIOT do you want the whole town and government to know you filled with Dutch van der Linde!?
>>
>>233845213
Fuck. Someone here did tell me about her stalker

Welp
>>
>>233843879
I would honestly fucking buy that so quick
>>
>>233845213
there are 3 quests that you do with her as Arthur. if you don't do them all, she dies
>>
Goddamn game tricking me into thinking there might be a romance plot with Mary, but instead it just left both Arthur and me feeling like shit.
>>
>this credit

JESUS HOW LONG IS THIS!? I HAVE SHIT TO DO

>Can't pause it

FUCK looks like I'm gonna have to watch this on YouTube later
>>
>Hey, ma'am.
Hello
>How's it going with you?
Not too bad.
>Sorry to hear that. All the best.

Is Arthur autistic?
>>
>>233803415
>>
>>233845541
Arthur was doomed to live in celabacy and die with aids
>>
>>233845248
i mean Ross already knows and it's not like Pearson could be accused of any crimes the gang did
>>
>>233845501
What chapter does the first quest unlock?
>>
>>233845569
it's about 35 mins I think
>>
>>233844785
Mary-Beth and Karen have little therapy sessions for Arthur just like Michael in GTA V. If you ever see a small question mark in camp that's what it is.
>>
>>233845056
>10
>hard
9 is more difficult and just because it's so fucking long, also fuck 3 blackjack hands with 3 or more hits FUCK that
>>
>>233845541
>Tfw Abigail and Dutch's son saved John from Arthur's fate
>>
>>233845764
>35 min

God, not even animu is that long
>>
>>233845783
Tilly does too. It just seems to fucking make Arthur a bad guy no matter what he does
>Kill a bunch of O'Driscolls
>Go hunting and always bring a corpse back for Pearson or sell it to a butcher
>I-I BEEN KILLIN' ALL THESE INNOCENT ANIMALS.. FOR NO REASON!!!
>INNOCENT PEOPLE TOO!!!
what the shit
>>
>>233844843
Because you're big guy and big guys need to eat big.
>>
>>233845745
i did all of them during chapter 6 but they might be available in late chapter 5/even before that, idk
>>
>>233845707
Information is a big deal though
>>
>>233845569
>>233845993
t. zoomer
>>
>>233844407
why wouldn't the pinkertons lie and what did micha have to gain.
he could have been killed just like the rest of them, i personally think the pinkertons were just that good and the gang that sloppy.
for gods sake, they kept doing the same thing over and over
>>
>>233846613
for>>233845097
>>
>>233845248
They probably need someone who could actually get to Dutch- Micah was probably already working for the government when he got shot, so John was the next lowest-hanging fruit.
>>
>>233842617
So you faggots don't want me to have a nice horse, huh?
>>
>>233846857
Turkomans are the best you can get that aren't horselets
>>
>>233842617
war horses have more health and don't get scared as easily. race horses have higher speed and acceleration. However the differences are so minor it's really hard to tell a difference in their handling. just pick one you like.
>>
>>233846613
Micah's a snake you probably noticed him trying to get Dutch to go after the Blackwater money multiple times cause the place is locked down and the law would get him. He set up the meeting with Colm O'Driscoll where Arthur gets captured too.
>>
>all that shitty farm work barely gives you any honor
>get more honor by going to saint denis and greeting people
Really makes you think.
>>
>>233847243
yes but he also shot at cops and pinkertons, if he was the rat why would he kill the people offering something to turn for?
>>
>>233847841
you ever seen infernal affairs
>>
>>233848140
no
>>
Milton says he picked up Micah after they got back from the island. There's really nothing to suggest he was working with them before then.
>>
>>233847841
or the departed the scorsese remake
>>
>>233848227
no
>>
>>233847841
Undercover cops or informants in a gang have to do bad shit sometimes to blend in and it's 1899 so there's not a whole lot of regulations for informants.
>>
>>233848227
>>233848140
also, lets not forget the marshals found john on their own and the pinkertons were on them before micha joined
>>
What is the online cancer meta going to be? Everyone longdistance headshotting each other with rolling block/snipers and hurling fire bottles?
>>
>>233846027
I’ve been leaving animals around to rot and killing people without remorse ever since those. Why should I care if the game can’t tell the difference between self deffense and murder? Game doesn’t seem to tell the difference between sustenance hunting and just killing all them animals.
>>
>>233848336
i think you want micha to be the rat because you hate him.

i hate him too but i also think the pinkertons were good enough to keep tabs on that sloppy gang
>>
>>233848498
Probably. I'm not sure how far you can actually hurl a firebottle but expect rampant sniper niggerdry just like any other online game. Probably people climbing on top of houses/cliffs and just spamming cover fire.
>>
Can you RP in RDO like in ARMA. Or is RDO going to be a battle royale game? Asking for a friend.
>>
>>233848556
It's a fact that Micah told Dutch about the ferry job before the start of the game and that job was a total setup by the Pinkertons. Why would Milton lie when he thought he had the upper hand?
>>
File: sad benny.jpg (6 KB, 200x200)
6 KB
6 KB JPG
>Ross and Fordham tracking down John in the ending credits
>>
wtf there's a dude outside lagras who knocks you out and rapes you if you go into his house
>>
File: brendan.gif (3.35 MB, 500x500)
3.35 MB
3.35 MB GIF
>>233849239
HOWDY MISTER
>>
>>233848459
I never played in public lobbies (world map) in gtao, and structured play wasn’t that bad when I played it.
>>
>>233849457
RDR1 online was cancer.
>>
my honor is so fucked from doing bandit challenges, really not looking forward to greet people for 3 hours straight.
>>
>>233849361
Lol, i already got raped by the o’driscols, might as well get raped by swamp niggers.
>>
>>233794930
>"YEEEEEEAAAAAH, FIRE LADY!"
>>
>>233848459
the scopes suck cock, they're blurry shit past short range scopes, i doubt they'll be used like in GTAO.
>>
>>233849303
abigail wasn't gonna be hung so she could write to john and let tell him, this breaks up the gang.it's easier to catch people one by one that a full force
>>
Fucking phychic witnesses and cops
>>
>>233849573
rdr1o was different in structure from gtao. gtao got you into separate rooms/lobbies for playing missions. the way i remember is that rdr1 had you go to locations in the map to trigger them.
>>
>rescue captured lawman from getting cut up by gang members
>"Thank you citizen" *leaves*

Should have left the ungrateful cunt there
>>
>>233849634
just do stranger missions and do the nice things, you get plenty of time for redemption in the final chapters
>>
>>233849932
he said thank you
>>
>>233849634
If you're in chapter 4 find the monk near the market in St. Denis. He offers you plenty of opportunties to gain good boy points.
>>
when john says "I'm proud of you, girl"

:3c
>>
just finished the epilogue, now i don't wanna play anymore
>>
>>233850096
that's how I felt too, I think it's just "post-series depression", after a couple days I felt like playing again
>>
>>233850029
Freedom ain't free

Welcome to America
>>
>>233849634
Surrendering to the police after a crime and going to jail raises your honor you could have done that during the bandit challenges to balance it out.
>>
Not able to sell (legendary) pelts from time to time. They're in horse's inventory, but don't show up when I want to sell them. Anybody else have this problem? I'm on ps4
>>
>Charles was loyal to the end

My nigga
>>
>>233850825
Based black man meme come to life in video game form.
>>
>>233850096
I strictly did stranger missions and main missions, and now that I'm done I'm gonna start the challenges and hunt legendaries.

By the time that's all done, online should be here. I fucking hope
>>
>>233850823
are you at the trapper?
he's the only one who will buy them.

if you are then i can't help, sorry partner
>>
>>233842092
Late reply but don't worry. They're part of the compendium but they're not required for the achievements relating to it
>>
>that quest you get from the plant collector (or whatever he is exactly) in Saint Denis

Damn, that must be the most difficult quest in the entire game. Exceptionally frustrating too.
>>
File: 1506017955414.jpg (48 KB, 498x456)
48 KB
48 KB JPG
>mfw after finding all the rock carvings for the guy near strawberry
>>
>tfw years later after John and Abigail are dead, Rufus still roams the ranch by his lonesome

;__;
>>
>>233850823
Get your horse closer to the trapper
>>
>>233807428
>qt outside of /gtag/
Get fucking looooooooooooost you tranny
never posted bulge or feet, now gon' git
>>
Gonna rp as Ed Harris (william) from West world and murder NPC's left and right
>>
>mexican guy overly friendly invites to the camp
>tells about a treasure and then leaves
Is it a bad idea to follow him?
>>
Legendary fox carcass worth it to haul back to camp?
It's this or a perfect alligator hide I can use to make shit.
>>
>>233828210
>t. giant boar
>>
>>233852238
All legendary go to the trapper
>>
>>233852219
Last time I followed someone talking about a treasure I got knocked out from behind and had $300 taken from me.
>>
>>233852332
I mean the actual corpse of the fox. Is it gonna feed my camp or am I hauling its corpse back home only to find the butcher won't take it?
If I keep it I'm dropping a perfect alligator hide I want for the camp as well.
>>
>>233852238
The legendary carcasses (where small enough to transport) are just sold for money, so take the gator hide. Also learn to look for the small gators, their skins stack on the back of your horse so they are a lot more efficient.





Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.