[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/a/ - Anime & Manga



Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.



File: Winter 2018.jpg (1.51 MB, 3008x2000)
1.51 MB
1.51 MB JPG
You can't disagree with this ranking.
>>
>>168414574
Citrus should only be that low if you really hate yuri
>>
>fate/extra
>bad
piss off
>>
>>168415276
you mean if you really hate incredibly pointless and shoehorned high school drama. or to put it simple: if you have a tripple digit iq

>>168414574
beatless is not bad by any means. neither is gakuen babysitters. they are actually two of the stronger shows of this season. mitsuboshi colors can hardly be considered to be animated, hence it belong into dogshit. poptepipic and ramencunts belong into dogshit as well. yurucamp went downhill ever since ep4. correct your mistaked you imbecile.
>>
Drop Yuru Camp to good
Drop Dagashi Kashi to bad
Drop Pop Team Epic to dogshit
Up Citrus to good
Up Antarctica girls to AOTS potential
Up Franxx AOTS potential
Drop Hakumei to Mikochi to bad
Drop all the fateshit to dogshit
Up CCS to great
>>
Is killing bites shit?
Considering watching it
>>
File: tmtit2.png (292 KB, 728x466)
292 KB
292 KB PNG
Heavens feel is technically 2018 release as BDs come out in May. Sakura shits on all of those
>>
>>168414574
>Yuru Camp
>AOTS
>Fate
>bad
kys
>>
>>>/mal/
>>
>>168415438
No, just mediocre
>>
dagashi kashi s2 is shit, the first one wasn't that great in the first place but s2 somehow has worse animation even though the episodes are half as long
>>
>>168414574
Glad to know I'm not missing anything with the four shows I'm keeping up with.
>>
Yuru down to good/great
Pop meme epic down
Franxx up to good, borderline AOTS
Mitsubishi Cars down
Overlord up to bad
Dagashi down
>>
>>168414574
Darling, VEG and Fate Last Encore should be in the dogshit pile together.
One has good visuals but is boring like shit, the other killed the good MC and choosed a shit one to be the lead and of course had to do it with Saber face girl, so basically writed shat on the game fanbase right from the start to make things "interesting" for self-inserting male virgin fanbase, and last one had to have that idiotic moment in very first episode of boring male MC meeting special sexy girl who will now open his eyes and instantly fallen for hi mcause he does it for her while he has a childhood female friend who is jealous of her bullshit going, not mentioning enforced girl x boy pairing to pilot girly looking mecha in very degrading way for the girls, but it's ok it's ex-Gainax x Trigger man dream anime bullshit.
Pile of shits for different reasons.
I'm so glad so many better shows are airing this season for more mature fanbase.
But it looks spring season will be even worse with a lot of male MC harem shows.
>>
File: faito.jpg (41 KB, 348x444)
41 KB
41 KB JPG
>slow start above gakuen
>>
>>168415438
First episode was fun, the rest has been a slog.
>>
File: yuzu.jpg (109 KB, 1146x644)
109 KB
109 KB JPG
>>168415393
I have a degree in chemistry and I love citrus Read: Yuzu :)
>>
>>168415708
You can't love her that much if that's the best picture you can find.
>>
>>168415655
Sasuga ESL-kun you've done it again. That was the most disjointed horseshit I've read in a while.
>>
>>168415393
>yurucamp went downhill ever since ep4
Don't tell you're the "meme faces" faggot.
>>
>>168415438
It's really fucking trashy and stupid, but it's also one of the three shows this season I'm enjoying the most, so I don't know what that says.
>>
>>168415708
i read the manga the the anime does literally nothing for this show. the kissing scenes are atrocious because they stretch them for too long, the audio direction as lackluster as hell, the visuals are fair but generic nonetheless. this is either a) a piss poor adaptation or b) the manga simply wasnt meant to be adapted. as it stands: the anime is bad.
>>
>>168415824
>audio direction as lackluster as hell
I don't know, I love the overly dramatic piano music for some reason.
>>
>>168415755
Good, shit shows deserve disjointed horseshit posts about them.
>>
>>168414574
What kind of new shitposting is this? AOTS this, AOTD that. Am i even on /a/ right now?
>>
>>168415824
>a) a piss poor adaptation
Crunchyroll says hello.
At least it might be the first yuri drama manga adaptation which might get a s2 in some future.
>>
>>168415755
its hilarious how esl has become an insult that people unironically try to use in an attempt to win debates. what a sad state this board is in.
>>
>>168414574
>Overlord in dogshit tier
good taste
>>
fuck you man, kokkoku is good
>>
>>168414574
But I can.
>>
File: 1515712037832.png (1.38 MB, 1345x1615)
1.38 MB
1.38 MB PNG
>>168414574
I disagree with a lot of the placements, but your top 2 is correct so it's fine.
>>
>>168414574
Idolish7 is the best.
>>
File: imouto and oneesan.jpg (310 KB, 2048x1527)
310 KB
310 KB JPG
I like Saiki, Yuru Camp and Sora Yori but the rest is all fucked.

>>168415708
Hello Citrusbro, I have a degree too. Asian languages, though.
>>
File: images.jpg (16 KB, 385x382)
16 KB
16 KB JPG
>>168416067
>debates
In a dedicated shitpost thread like this there's no such thing.
>>
File: 4258.jpg (93 KB, 1280x720)
93 KB
93 KB JPG
>Citrus and Dagashi Kashi that high.
>KB and VEG that low.
>Looking after a mummy that low.
What the hell is this list.
>>
>>168416067
nobody is debating anything, this is a place to share your opinion.
>>
>>168414574
You're wrong.
Enjoy not know why.
>>
File: 2.png (7 KB, 121x29)
7 KB
7 KB PNG
What is this hidden anime?
>>
>>168415972
AOTS shitposting isn't new though. It's just particularly intense right now because this season is stacked.
>>
Franxx is dogshit. teenage romantic drama #1000 but with mecha. only popular because of Trigger.
>>
>pop team epic that high
Dude, you had one job.
>>
>>168414574
I respect the fact that while having fist fucking retarded taste, you're still brave enough to put it out there for everyone to see. Though retards are known for pulling their dicks out in public, so I don't know how much that's really worth.

That being said, this is a just a list of contrarian autism. Sucks to suck I guess.
>>
>>168416684
VEG is shit, anon.
>>
>>168416628
>teenage romantic drama with mecha

Hey, welcome to anime! Let us know if you'd like some recommendations, it's daunting to be this new.
>>
File: 87656l.jpg (62 KB, 318x450)
62 KB
62 KB JPG
>>168416613
>tfw OP was too ashamed to post his real AOTS
>>
>>168415748
I like cute genki girls, the more embarassed the better
>>
>>168416755
OHHHHH
>>
>>168416714
Of course it is. It's lipstick on a pig. It's maybe C level so far.
>>
>>168416755
How did you catch that?
>>
>>168414574
Actually all anime is shit, it's nothing but trash.
>>
>>168416755
Nice
>>
>>168414574
It all looks like trash to me.
>>
>>168416818
By looking through the list of currently airing shows on anichart
>>
>>168414574
>>168416613
>>168416755
sasuga
>>
>>168414574
>>>/mal/
>>
>>168416739
>most anime are dogshit
I know
>>
>>168416755
kek
>>
>>168415276
I like yuri but I loathe Citrus, the story is fucking dogshit.
>>
>>168414574
The VEG is complete shit meme is so last month anon. Even if sakuga compilations turn out to be it's only lasting legacy, it's far from bottom of the barrel, sort your shit out. Everything else is fairly accurate.
>>
>>168416768
I'm mean the image quality.
>>
>>168415438
Oh it's hot garbage alright, but i watch it anyways because 23 shows this season is not enough to follow to keep me occupied with new material.
>>
The anime isn't even finished airing yet, you faggots.
>>
File: 1518469400851.jpg (2.77 MB, 3008x2000)
2.77 MB
2.77 MB JPG
This is the seasoned veteran's version.
>>
>>168415655
Go to bed tumblr.
>>
>>168417427
Worse taste than OP and OP has shit taste
>>
File: 1514805935775.jpg (835 KB, 1920x1080)
835 KB
835 KB JPG
>>168417427
Pretty accurate. I dropped Yuru Camp though,
>>
File: 1516988757729.png (254 KB, 444x720)
254 KB
254 KB PNG
>>168417613
Why?
>>
>>168417276
Oh I just capped it from E1 quickly cause I knew it had Yuzu looking embarassed in it
>>
File: 1509593131993.jpg (328 KB, 1449x2048)
328 KB
328 KB JPG
>>168417655
Show was going nowhere. I wanted to like the characters but the only characters I could stand was Rin. I dropped it on episode 3. The dog scene in the back of the van was a cute scene though.
>>
>>168417699
What the hell do you watch it on with that quality?
>>
>>168417655
I got bored after the fourth episode.
I don't hate the show or its fanbase, it's just not for me.
>>
>>168417759
That's nothing unusual in CGDCT. But oh well, it's your taste.
>>
>>168417763
Garbage streaming sites, it's not good quality I know but I don't really know how else to watch
>>
File: 1487969626928.png (901 KB, 1920x1080)
901 KB
901 KB PNG
>>168417890
You guys are alright. I can understand why you guys like it though.
>>
>>168416564
This is a thread to shit on OP's taste
>>
File: 1518368848990.jpg (173 KB, 1366x768)
173 KB
173 KB JPG
>Gakuen Babysitters that low
>>
>>168417655
I haven't dropped it but honestly it's a barely above average comfy CGDCT show with nice scenery and in no way AOTS contender
>>
Why the fuck would you put something as wholesome as Gakuen Babysitters under loli mahjong?
>>
File: 1518469400851.png (1.51 MB, 1920x1080)
1.51 MB
1.51 MB PNG
>>168417982
I appreciate the comment but I'm afraid I can't marry you.
>>
>>168416067
how the fuck am i supposed to debate with someone who doesn't know how to speak the language? laughing at ESLtards is like laughing at any other retard, you retard.
>>
>>168417655
it's as generic as a moeblob slice of life with 0 ambition can be
>>
>>168417244
What problem could you probably have with Yuri imouto rape
>>
>>168418147
>get BTFO
>b-but y-you made a grammar mistake!! s-so I WIN HAHAHAHAHA... *sob*
>>
File: ufobaby_2927.jpg (25 KB, 238x320)
25 KB
25 KB JPG
>>168418001
UFO Baby did it better.
>>
>>168417655
Look at the show he's posting.
>>
>>168415276
Citrus is damaging yuri by making it seem like porn for straight men with shit like orgasm kissing noises and extended groping scenes. The plot is also garbage and the production quality is hentai tier. If you're a fan of yuri you need to disavow it publicly and repeatedly for the sake of the genre, handing out copies of girl friends like it's a Bible.
>>
>>168418307
KoiAme is AOTS tier though.
As far as my taste in anime goes, Yuru Camp is an outlier that surprised me.
>>
>>168418377
>porn for straight men with shit like orgasm kissing noises and extended groping scenes
that's literally 99% of yuri out there faggot, and Citrus isn't even that obscene compared to many others
if anything it makes the genre look like a derivative of shoujo with its forced drama, NTR-bait and unlikable characters
>>
>>168417427
>VEG
>aots
>>
>>168418147
a language is nothing but a tool. if youre unable to understand the content of a post then its most likely you who lacks the mental capacity to properly converse. see this: >>168415655. which of his sentences are incomprehensible to you?
>>
>>168418453
99% of animated yuri or manga yuri? Cause the former's probably accurate if you include hentai but you're way way off with the latter.
>>
>>168418466
Keyword: potential.
It's really damn good but it's not there yet and the season is far from over, don't worry about it.
>>
>>168415438
It's extremely enjoyable trash, definitely worth watching
>>
>>168414574
Gakuen is good you faggot, it has cute babies, i agree with everything else though.
>>
>>168418535
The fact that you cant write two sentences without brainfarting just shows that you have brain damage and that it isn't worth debating you.
>>
What a surprise, the unambitious, unremarkable CGDCT of the season is at the top, for the simple reason that nothing happens so it's hard to shitpost.
>>
File: 1517270970944.png (977 KB, 1280x738)
977 KB
977 KB PNG
>>168415438
It's good 'ol dumb action fun with great ecchi. Surprisingly enjoyable and the threads are always top-tier
>>
>>168418646
highly advanced robutts are better than a lone, autistic 20th century robot
>>
>>168414574
darling is garbage
>>
>>168418730
but man, its comfy. dont you understand???
>>
>>168414574
Tutu camp isn’t actually good at all, putting easy cgdcts at the top of the least invalidates any and all opinions you have.
>>
>>168418956
Everyone seem to like Yuru Camp until it revealed by stalker thread that it's actually ranked #1 seasonal. Is this what you call being contrarian?
>>
>>168417427
Why did you move saiki down?
>>
>>168417427
Better only for actually putting meme show where it belongs.
>>
>>168414574
Special Tier:
Epic Trash: Pop Team Epic, Killer Bites.
>>
File: Sora.jpg (49 KB, 848x480)
49 KB
49 KB JPG
>>168414574
>There's more people defending Gakuen that KyoAni's Magnum Opus
At least we can agree that VEG is shit
>>
>>168415438
It's all you could want in seasonal action anime with tons of fanservice
>>
>>168414574
>Saiki that high
finally someone with good taste
>>
>>168418196
There's not enough of it and it's the absolute worst kind of NBR where two high schoolers meet for the first time and pretend they're siblings now.

It's just a trashy shoujo that tries to cover for the contrived developments and empty characters by swapping the gender of the main love interest.
>>
I've noticed that nobody has mentioned Devilman.
>>
>>168421028
I thought the consensus was that it was good but dropping the whole season at once was a mistake, discussion dropped off very quickly indeed
>>
>>168421028
That's a consequence of it airing all at once at the start of the season. Plenty of people liked it but everyone forgot about it after a few weeks.
>>
>>168421028
Forgotten by most already.
>>
>>168421028
like they said discussions come and gone but its up there with great
>>
Killingbites is bad, but its fun to fast-forward through

Yowapedal and gauken babysitters shouldn't be remotely that low

im now realizing this is a bait chart
>>
>>168418377
>Citrus is damaging yuri by making it seem like porn for straight men with shit like orgasm kissing noises and extended groping scenes.
You're a retard.
>>
>>168414574
As an employed 31 year old hetero sexual male, I disagree with basically every aspect of this ranking. The only thing that I've watched this season that has been surprisingly not 100% dogshit is grancrest and garo (and fate/apo from last season), franxx is ok but the mechs are hideous, fate/extra has been very disapointing (fuck shaft action scenes are terrible), evergarden is ok, haven't seen Beatless yet. I'm into action anime so let me know if I'm missing out on anything worthwhile with sweet action scenes please
>>
>>168415443
I wish I could buy the blueray or upload or something besides driving 2 hours to sit with smelly weebs
>>
>>168421680
are you new to anime, trolling or simply having shit taste?
>>
>>168415708
are you a perma-virgin or a fag?
>>
>>168421783
Somewhere in between
>>
>>168415655
What the fuck are these better shows for mature fanbases you speak of? I'd really like to know. This season is very shit for adults I feel
>>
>>168421839
But VEG is good for mature 32 years old spanish mom.
>>
Why the fuck does nobody discuss the actual AOTS?

Mahoutsukai no Yome
>>
>>168416473
Kek, you couldn't be more of a cringe weeb if you tried. Holy shit, I hate modern anime fandom
>>
>>168421904
It's previous season and even more boring than VEG (amazing achievement)
>>
>>168416778
>>168416818
>>168416879
>>168417008
>>168417142
He's saying that idolshit is better than Yuru Camp.
>>
>>168421943
>even more boring

t. ADHD
>>
Gintama should be dogshit tier.
>>
>>168416714
not my cup of tea but its well done, can't argue that. Grow up, stop being a try hard contrarian fuckbaby
>>
>>168416739
would be cooler if the mechs weren't all feminine, some really bad design choices in that show
>>
>>168416615
stacked with garbage*
>>
>>168421943
The memes are real, you people really do have ADD.
>>
Itou Junji Collection is the only worthwhile show this season.
>>
>>168414574

>Enjoy Saiki inmensely.
>Takes a week to get subs

Feels bad man.
>>
>>168417427
>Toji no Miko and saiki that low.
>Colors bad
>Violete Everfarted in aots potential
Jesus Christ don't you ever dare to claim yourself as a veteran of anything ever again faggot.
>>
>>168421922
>modern anime fandom
I got my degree almost 10 years ago, and I chose that because my city is literally swamped with nips and chinks so that was the easiest way to get a job.
>>
>>168417244
its crazy how homo infested this place has become, same as anime in general I guess. I thought it was females fucking up my hobby but really it seems its the females and gay men ruining each season with their horrid taste and low standards
>>
>>168422138
Said the zombie.
>>
File: 1517845482285.png (3.21 MB, 960x2685)
3.21 MB
3.21 MB PNG
PTE belongs in its own Kuso tier. It's shitty on purpose. That's why it's great.
>>
>>168421896
Yea? Has your mom been keeping up in between mouthfuls?
>>
>>168422017
I'm a fate fag but fate extra has been real shit so far in my opinion..so stop generalizing
>>
>>168415438
I don't go for fanservice animes because I'm not a drooling fucking mongoloid.

But my dick simply couldn't ignore Killing Bites.
>>
>>168422061
holy shit I'd love to know what kind of hopeless cum basket would think this season is 'stacked'
>>
>>168422167
So are you implying that im homo because I like yuri, that doesn't add up.
>>168418196
Are you watching the same anime I was watching? All the plot points are stupid and bad written, for example Yuzu not knowing that she is part of another family and now she have an step sister.
>>
>>168415438
It's pretty good for a fanservice action series.
>>
File: 1495918446163.jpg (274 KB, 960x720)
274 KB
274 KB JPG
>>168422278
>>
File: 38.jpg (145 KB, 1280x720)
145 KB
145 KB JPG
>>168414574
> Homo anime as best anime.
> Killing Bites that low.

I think I'm onto something.
>>
>>168414574
Colors should go straight to the top right next to Saiki.
Gakuen should go higher up into the good category.
Beatless and Killing Bites can swap places.
CCS should be in great.
Tonkotsu is fucking awful.
Ramen and Takunomi line up with Darling.

There. Fixed your list.
>>
>>168415276
I love yuri and citrus is a pile of shit I dropped after ep 1.
>>
>>168415276
Citrus is a disgrace of a yuri anime. If you actually like yuri then it should probably be lower on the list actually.
>>
>>168415824
the anime makes the girls way cuter though.

The anime is bad specifically because the source material is bad desu.
>>
>>168422587
yuri on ice seems pretty darn gay
>>
takagi-san is so disappointing

it doesn't translate well from manga to anime at all
>>
>>168423374
it's just repetitive one dimensional and boring with extra boring point since it's 24 minutes instead of shorts.
>>
File: 1455071243546.jpg (40 KB, 500x294)
40 KB
40 KB JPG
This is solid bait. I commend OP for their ability to spark controversy so effortlessly.
>>
>>168423323
YoI is more of a 'will they or won't they' show. Nothing graphic. The fans make it seem like Yuri and Victor are fucking each other every episode
>>
>>168414574

I can and I will.
>>
>>168415708
I have a degree in chemistry too, anon. Maybe I'll check out citrus
>>
>>168423323
Is that a pun or are you being serious I like the yuri genre not Yaoi on ice.
>>
>>168425098
>Yaoi on Ice
More like Fujobait on Ice. True yaoi doesn't sell, actual homo isn't as exciting for fujoshits.
>>
>>168414574
>anime
>made after 2014
>good
>>
>>168414574
>AOTS: Yuru Camp and Sora Yori
We agree here, anon. The only thing I'd change is Toji no Miko, it's quite good actually.
>>
>>168414574
What's with the Yuru Camp shitposting lately? I thought that the purpose of VEG and Darling was to suck it all up and protect the other shows, it got too popular?
>>
>>168414574
sora yoi is mediocre as fuck
>>
>>168415438
You like boobs, butts, blood, good fights, good enough animation and boobs? Then it's the AOTS.
>>
>>168427699
VEG was so boring that barely shitposters were left watching it and Darling turned out legitimately good so it's hard to argue against it.
>>
>>168418587
Fucking this
I think whoever made that shitty chart just assumed it was pedob8 without even having watched the show.
>>
>>168414574
>Pop meme epic that high
>Miira and Toji no Miko that low
Watch me, fuckass.
>>
>>168416853
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Mz0trc-ZpY
>>
File: 1515833503520.png (184 KB, 628x487)
184 KB
184 KB PNG
Hi! I'm anon and I have exquisite taste. I will be your guide to the Winter season.
>AOTS potential
Darling in the FranXX
Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho
Kokkoku

>pretty good
Cardcaptor Sakura: Clear Card
Hakumei to Mikochi
Emiya-san Chi no Kyou no Gohan
Koi wa Ameagari no You ni

>fun things are fun
Killing Bites
Toji no Miko
Ryuuou no Oshigoto
Takunomi
Yuru Camp
Mitsuboshi Colors
Gakuen Babysitters
Hakata Tonkotsu Ramens

>wasted potential
Violet Evergarden
Karakai Jouzu no Takagi-san
Ito Junji Collection

>meh
Sanrio Danshi
Slow Start
Marchen Madchen
Basilisk
Fate/Shaft
Grancrest Senki
Death March kara Hajimeru Isekai Kyousoukyoku
Hakyuu Houshin Engi
Beatless
Ramen Daisuki Koizumi-san
Citrus
Miira no Kaikata

>kuso anime
Pop Team Epic
>>
>>168427699
>it got too popular?

Most likely.
>>
>>168415438
Don't believe anyone else.
Killing Bites is fucking great.
>>
>>168428495
Killing Bites is fun. Anons that didn't pick it up are really missing out.
>>
I'll just say that I truly believe Koi Wa Ameagari is on an entire different level than every other anime this season, and even most anime in the past year.

It's very close to reminding me of how I felt about Tsuki Ga Kirei, although Koi Wa handedly beats it in the animation department.
>>
>>168428235
Thank you anon with exquisite taste.
I agree with quite a few things on your list.
>>
AOTS is hakumiko. There is no arguing this.
>>
>see the three peaking into S tier
oh wow this is good
>see literally everything else
oh
>>
>>168423428
This. I was excited for it, but have pretty much dropped it now. It's a chore to get through. The jokes don't need that much time, they're simple and can be executed in five minutes. The better format would be 4 shorts. Maybe they're already doing this, I forget. It's just so slow compared to series with even less going on. The last episode of hakumiko was information on how to sharpen tools and build a wall, and that went by too fast almost and was also the first episode so far to only have one story, too. Either way, it's spending too much time on nothing at all, just sitting around, panning, stills, all that.
>>
File: 1517729016914.jpg (79 KB, 1271x711)
79 KB
79 KB JPG
>>168414574
Killing Bites is S-Rank
>>
File: mpv-shot0042.png (1.98 MB, 1920x1080)
1.98 MB
1.98 MB PNG
>>168414574
After the Rain is AOTY. This is a fact.
>>
>>168414574
nice reddit ranking faggot.
>>
File: IMG_4246.gif (328 KB, 1000x773)
328 KB
328 KB GIF
>>168414574
I already disagree with this ranking.
>>
>>168428235
add Dame x Prince to fun things are fun
>>
>>168430945
Haven't checked that one. I'm always in the market for weird schlocky otome game shit. Thanks for the heads up.
>tfw no Hatsukoi Monster season 2
>>
>>168414574
Awful list you huge faggot
>>
>>168429982
>shoujoshit
>>
Killing Bites, Franxx and Yurucamp are the only shows worth watching this season. I dropped VEG and overlord because they are steaming turds and I only watch PTE post ironically.
>>
first for takunomi
>>
I am the only person on /a/ watching Kokkoku.
>>
>>168431709
im watching it, its fun
>>
>gay

Yuru Camp
Sora Yori mo Tooi Basho
Hakumei to Mikochi
Toji no Miko
Takunomi
Mitsuboshi Colors
Citrus
Cardcaptor Sakura: Clear Card

>beta male mc
Darling in the FranXX
Killing Bites
Grancrest Senki
Fate/Shaft
Beatless

>boring
Violet Evergarden
>>
>>168431171
>post ironically.
I don't think you know what that means kid.
>>
>>168414574
Surprisingly fair ranking.
>>
>>168414574
overlord isn't dogshit, it's at least slightly good
>>
>>168431709
Kokkoku is criminally underappreciated. In fact, it has the potential to be AOTS. The direction is a bit stale honestly but /a/'s attention is focused elsewhere sadly.
>>
>>168421996
It's only well done on the surface. It shoots itself in the foot every goddamn step of the way.
>>
>>168414574
Mitsuboshi Colors is an AOTS candidate you stupid fuck.
Gakuen Babysitters, VEG, Killing Bites and Overlord are far from F tier.

>Pop Team Epic that high
Re-apply yourself.
>>
Actual Winter power ranking based on number of torrent downloads for latest episodes of the shows on Nyaa:

Taking latest episodes (DLs):
Franxx 17090
VEG 13551
Yurucamp 6633
Sorayori 5767
PTE 5120
>>
>>168414574
>Spic inferno AOTS
HAH. AOTS is Hakumei to Mikochi or baseball Ramens
>>
Sora Yori vs Yuru Camp, who wins aots?
>>
File: 1461014774473.png (258 KB, 648x402)
258 KB
258 KB PNG
>>168434360
>Spic inferno
>>
>>168434360
Baseball Ramens is entertaining but Hakumei is boring as hell. Nearly Slow Start levels of boring.
>>
>>168434351
Meaningless. Popularity doesn't inform opinion, many anons love to hate and Darling in France and Baioleto Ebagahden are prime examples of that.
>>
File: 1473596206563.jpg (51 KB, 1024x576)
51 KB
51 KB JPG
>>168428235
>>
>>168434640
Statistics show that " many anons " are actually vocal few shitposters
>>
File: 1518020493832.png (676 KB, 978x977)
676 KB
676 KB PNG
>>168434351
VEG is a special case because of how netflix is doing things.

Add the 4180 that downloaded the 720p fansub version and the 4323 that downloaded the 1080p fansub the day after. And no, the vast majority of those are not the same people.
That gives us around 22054 VEG DLs. And this is not counting the multiple netflix dub versions out there.

Where is your god now?
>>
>>168416067
/pol/ happened
>>
>>168417427
Was ok until PTE turned up in Dogshit category.
>>
>>168415708
even a brainlet can get a degree, though. a lot of my peers are cheating their way to a degree. also, that blonde girl is fucking annoying.
>>
>>168416628
Everyone say hi to Team Four Star.
>>
>>168418377
The absolute state of yurifags
Thanks for the kek though
>>
File: 1515885689073.jpg (316 KB, 894x894)
316 KB
316 KB JPG
>>168415429
This guy knows it
>>
File: 81.jpg (134 KB, 1280x720)
134 KB
134 KB JPG
>>168428235
This but unironically. Perfect list.
>>
File: 1518380548922.jpg (35 KB, 732x675)
35 KB
35 KB JPG
>>168414574
>Thinks Beatless is better then Overlord2
>>
>>168434978
>Can't defend against the fact that TRIGGER hasn't ever made a good show so brings up pointless e-celeb shit
>>
>>168418377

you need to disavow yuri in general because its fucking trash.
>>
Who's subs do I watch for Saiki S2?
>>
File: Inferno_Cop.png (660 KB, 1280x720)
660 KB
660 KB PNG
>>168435211
>Trigger hasn't ever made a good show
>>
>>168435251
Inferno Cop is banned in China.
Now Franxx is banned in China as well.

Shows trigger fags shit taste. In before China is shit - they funded Luluco, the actual good Trigger show.
>>
>>168417427
pfftt, more like "hey look at my supperriorr taste" chart

just kidding, i would agree with you if you up that darling in franxx to great.
>>
File: 1517760944446.gif (1.54 MB, 230x230)
1.54 MB
1.54 MB GIF
>>168435285
>not in China means it's bad
What is this reasoning?
>>
>>168435397
vulgar = shit

If you can't make decent anime without trying to sell it with sex, vulgarity and toilet humor - you deserve to be banned.
>>
>>168414574
Sora yori is one of the worst shows of the season. Yuru Camp, however, deserves its' high place.
>>
>marking Colors as bad
fuck you OP you dog shit eating mother fucker
>>
>>168435470
What if sex and sexuality is an important theme of the show like Eva or Crybaby?
>>
>>168435872
then it has shit themes
>>
>>168417427
Much better.
>>
>>168417427
Move VEG down one tier and we're good.
>>
>>168435599
It is bad. I wanted to like it, but it is not new Ichigo Mashimaro. The humor is much weaker and animation is non existent.
>>
>>168418564
>potential

It is not even good right now and I agree with OP. It is a wasted potential. No kyoani show is worse than VEG right now.
>>
>>168428235
Houshin Engi is 100% wasted potential. The manga is genuinely great and well-written. It's almost amazing how the anime managed to fuck it up.
>>
>>168436034
it's not bad. you just have shit taste
>>
>>168428235
Very close, but Death March and Killing Bites should swap.
>>
>>168436034
It's one of the funniest shows this season you shiteater.
>>
I've yet to see a valid reason why Violet Evergarden is getting shit on other than filters.
I'm entirely convinced it's just contrarianism.
>>
>>168435937
Just like your taste and reasoning
>>
>>168436329
It is kind of a letdown from the expectations it set with the LN PVs. A lot of it was simply the hype train crashing. The following shitposting is only kept up by a really vocal minority spamming threads and falseflagging.
>>
File: 1495595472074.png (1.01 MB, 1280x720)
1.01 MB
1.01 MB PNG
How can anyone hate Gakuen Babysitters?
>>
>>168422044
Its just what's in at the moment. Masculine is out and feminine is in.
>>
I can't, but that's mostly because I haven't stayed up on the season. Though seeing Gintama in the bad category makes me sad.
>>
>>168414574

That's not what Killing Bites is!
>>
I for one can't wait for DarliFra to be over, so that /v/ crossboarders can return whence they came.
>>
File: 1516903865218.png (184 KB, 200x400)
184 KB
184 KB PNG
>>168427787
>Darling turned out legitimately good
>>
>>168436769
Did you watch the latest episode?
>>
>>168414574
>PTE
>great
If this is a shit-eating ranking, I agree with you.
>>
>>168436774
Yeah it was pretty dreadful, just like the rest.
>>
>>168436782
You didn't make it past episode one, did you?
>>
>>168436803
Why do you continue to watch it then?
>>
>>168436816
Hoping it will get better. I like some other TRIGGER shows but this is hot garbage. If the MC dies it could be redeemed maybe.
>>
>>168436844
You're one crazy masochist.
>>
File: 1488140930858.jpg (54 KB, 664x610)
54 KB
54 KB JPG
>>168436844
This is not a TRIGGER show.
>>
>>168434747
just like the force spam amrite
>>
File: salute.gif (83 KB, 350x272)
83 KB
83 KB GIF
>>168428235
Just wanted to acknowledge a patrician post.
Thank you for your service.
>>
>>168414574
Very weak season. No anime deserves AOTS.
>>
>>168415429
Forgot to put Ryuuou to bad-dogshit, and I agree.
>>
>>168436844
Tfw all franxxfags are blind triggerfags who dont even know that it's not a trigger anime, but A1 kek
>>
File: 1517806583876.jpg (110 KB, 1280x720)
110 KB
110 KB JPG
>>168436742
Hope you enjoy waiting for 6 months since its 2 cour.
>>
>>168437279
No I don't enjoy having such a huge influx of crossboarders for half a year, but that's how life is.
>>
File: 1518238408656.jpg (158 KB, 1280x720)
158 KB
158 KB JPG
The Reimu and Marisa show is my AOTS
>>
File: 1507463657296.jpg (98 KB, 996x720)
98 KB
98 KB JPG
>Cute n comfy tier
Takagi-kun
yuru camp
colors
mummy
>Trash but I enjoy it tier
Killing Bites
Death March
>Okay/Good Shows tier
Overlord
Franxx
Kokkoku
Fate
>Watch for the memes tier
Franxx
PTE
>Please get better tier
Evergarden
Beatless (or go full trainwreck)
>AOTS with little competition
Sora yori
>>
>>168428982
damn you for saying it's like Tsuki Ga Kirei

I'm already watching to many anime this season
>>
>>168414574
Swap Violet Evergarden with Pop Team Epic and we're all good bro.
>>
>>168438091
Don't worry, unlike TgK, nothing actually happens. You can binge it later when it's finished.
>>
>>168432561
I think the production value is to low to be AOTS the directing also isn't super amazing. Best OP and super interesting story though.
>>
File: 1511737714877.jpg (18 KB, 600x600)
18 KB
18 KB JPG
>>168414574
>Yurucamp
HAHAHAHAHAHA
>>
>>168432561
>>168438132
Kokkoku feels like that old C-tier movie D-Wars or some shit. It's just bad and low quality.
>>
>>168431709
I think it's more fit to be binged later on 2-3 episodes at a time instead of being watched weekly.
>>
File: 1516969723708a2.png (64 KB, 395x251)
64 KB
64 KB PNG
>>168437579
Yeah and crying about it in meta threads won't do anything so it's pointless but most of everything we do on /a/ is, so carry on I guess...
>>
>>168438063
best categories
and I agree mostly, with the one's I've seen
>>
>>168414574
I really tried to like VEG because /a/ kept hyping it but I just can't get into it.
>>
>>168414574
That's some real shit taste.
Saiki should be #1.
>>
Can someone post a template. Just one without the anime posters.
>>
Slow Start should be rated lower.
>>
template please
>>
template
>>
>>168439607
>>
I tried Sora Yori after seeing it hyped here a lot. I don't get it. The show isn't very interesting, and nowhere near as good as a lot of the other shows this season.
>>
>>168440494
Watch Ep 2
>>
>>168440513
I've seen the first four, but I'm probably gonna drop it.
>>
>>168415380
it should be dogshit
>>
>>168440513
I watched 6 episodes and they all were shit.
>>
>>168440646
Then drop it. Because episode 2 was the best so far and it is unlikely to become better.
>>
File: 1518522962526.jpg (2.46 MB, 3008x2652)
2.46 MB
2.46 MB JPG
Patrician taste, coming through.
>>
Detective Conan is AOTS, every season.
>>
>>168441032
your well-lined design is so ugly, fuck off.
>>
>>168441100
I couldn't fit them all when I tried scrambling it.
>>
File: 1352226815751.png (43 KB, 622x471)
43 KB
43 KB PNG
I don't even know what's the point of these threads.
It's all just one massive shitpost.
Not like anyone cares what you like or don't.
>>
>>168441100
The whole thing looks like shit anyways, faggot.
>>
>>168441203
>It's all just one massive shitpost.
You literally just described /a/.
>>
>>168441064
Unironically true. I need to catch up with current season.
>>
>>168441229
Not really, we got plenty good discussions and OC generated, but these ranking threads stick out like a sore thumb.
>>
>>168441203
to provide thread where everyone can voice their opinion about current anime season.
>>
>>168435470
This is pitiful.
>>
>>168441514
>You can't disagree with this ranking.
That's a great way to start a thread where you discuss opinions.
>>
>>168441229
It's not and you know it
>>
>>168441667
You must be new here.
>>
>>168415438
you have to have less brain cells than a bony eared assfish to enjoy it
>>
>>168414574
I'd put Fate/Umu at least at Franxx tier cause its at least mindless entertainment, other then that this is correct.
>>
>>168428235
Move Koi to the top and this would be passable.
>>
>>168414574
>YoriMoi that high
>>>/trash/
>>
File: Gakuen-Babysitters.jpg (103 KB, 1280x720)
103 KB
103 KB JPG
It's amazing how by simply being homo a new perspective on the quality of things opens to you. You automatically filter all the moeshit and meme shows that cover their stupidity with cute girls, and instead get to enjoy the truly comfy and healing shows that put off normies simply because they feature male protagonists.
>>
>>168442296
>normies
>>
>seasoned veteran
>watching more that 3 shows a season
Pick one. And that would be a great season, unlike this one. I guess I just burned out a bit. Or level upped to seiyuu bantz.
>>
>>168434836
Prove it.
>>
>>168414574
here's a you
>>
>>168438466
This.
>>
>>168414574
>two pedophile shows
>up top
audibly keked
>>
>>168442983
Fuck off normalfag, a seasoned veteran watch every show of the season and his backlog at the same time.
>>
>>168444810
>having backlog
you are not veteran.
>>
>>168415276
I love yuri but I hate Citrus
>>
>>168417427
Better than OP but still wrong
>>
>>168428235
Seems about right
>>
>>168444991
Started watching anime in the 90, I have tons of anime of the 90, 80, 70 to watch so ofcourse I have a backlog
>>
>>168445372
true veteran (like me) watch anime since toddler and already watched everything within scope, which means no longer having backlog and the only new content to watch is all currently airing seasonal.
>>
File: 1511746716169.gif (249 KB, 480x270)
249 KB
249 KB GIF
>>168445545
>>
>>168417427
>saiki
>dogshit
nigger
>>
>>168414574
>some moeshit on top
yeah, you are trash
>>
>>168415429
this
>>
>>168422044
I think we're going to see much different looking mechs next week
>>
>>168417427
Move citrus to good and we're good.
>>
>>168442296
>You automatically filter all the shows that cover their stupidity with cute girls, and instead get to enjoy shows that cover their stupidity with pretty boys
ftfy
>>
>>168417427
>Seasoned veteran
What? You are just watching anime, kiddo.
>>
>>168449557
He wanted to be a big boy.
>>
Is anyone else actually watching Grancrest Senki?

It's written badly, but it has actually a decent amount of well animated action. If only it had writing that made me care about any of these battle shonen stereotypes, it would have been pretty ok. It would have been probably best video game adaptation if it just said fuck it and just acquired Fire Emblem license.
>>
>>168438063
Only person with good taste i've seen here.
>>
>>168414574
I love everything on that picture equally.
>>
File: 1517272816301.jpg (22 KB, 320x320)
22 KB
22 KB JPG
>>168418377
>Citrus is damaging yuri by making it seem like porn for straight men with shit like orgasm kissing noises and extended groping scenes.

>Yurifags actually think their shit is "purest love"
>>
>>168451617
To be fair, you need a high emotional intelligence to understand real yuri.
>>
>>168428235
Pretty accurate
>>
>>168451744
To be fair you also need androphobia
>>
This season is season of autism. Are there non autistic mc in popular shows at all right now?

VEG, SoraYori, Franxx, KoiAme, Yurucamp, Fate Extra - human beings that are no neither side of the spectrum are nowhere to be seen. Even death march MC that was normal initially, got fucked up by his MND stat raising with level ups.
>>
>>168451889
>Franxx
>Autistic
>>
>>168451889
But none of the MCs you listed are autistic except for Violet.
>>
>>168427751
take out good fights
>>
>>168452137
>>
>>168418377
>female author
>shoujo magazine
>majority female audience
>porn for straight men
what did he mean by this?
>>
>>168422312
I dont fucking understand this show why is there two of the same thing played back to back?
>>
>>168452610
He's actually such a manlet/brainlet he is completely incapable of the empathy required to consider citrus from the female perspective - so he processes it the only way his walnut brain can, as if he were the center of the universe

It's tragic really, not understand a young maidens heart is a sad state indeed
>>
>>168415429
How very reddit of you
>>
File: Actual List.jpg (1.11 MB, 2000x600)
1.11 MB
1.11 MB JPG
>>168414574
The true list.
>>
>>168428235
This is the objectively correct ranking.
>>
File: 1517272816302.jpg (9 KB, 210x240)
9 KB
9 KB JPG
>>168452780
Yeah when I was fourteen and just discovered anime I liked every show I could get my hands on too.
>>
>>168416613
Shit
>>
>>168414574
opinion discarded at sora yori and redditeamepic being that high
sage
>>
>>168452936
I watch every anime every season since 2006, and most of time i love all of them.
>>
>>168452604
I agree, Kimari is pretty autistic for not understanding her friend's hints of backstabbing her.
>>
File: 1502407913333.jpg (827 KB, 1280x2880)
827 KB
827 KB JPG
>>168438063
I really like your categories. They make a lot of sense to.
>>
>>168453123
I actually meant to post Shirase, who genuinuly is autistic, but could not be bothered to find apropriate picture.
>>
>>168452936
What's bad about having 14 AOTS every season? Am i supposed to be obsessed only with one anime?
>>
File: 1513411738803.png (208 KB, 398x297)
208 KB
208 KB PNG
>>168428235
>>
File: 1515765214189.jpg (199 KB, 1280x720)
199 KB
199 KB JPG
>>168438063
This is a respectable list
>>
File: 1516168789923.jpg (99 KB, 548x860)
99 KB
99 KB JPG
>>168428235
Somebody fucking gets it
>>
>>168414574
VEG isn't that bad.
>>
>>168453557
it's that bad though. Visual is the only good thing and even it's not that good compared to other Kyoani shows.
>>
>>168421680
Please never have kids
>>
>>168453629
For you.
>>
>>168453629
You clearly have not watched Tamako Market.
>>
>>168453760
>Tamako flopket
>>
File: 1517793902950.png (62 KB, 512x512)
62 KB
62 KB PNG
>>168453713
And a bunch of other people too. VEG is a victim of its own hype collapsing under it's own weight of nothing happening
Doesn't help they squeezed two major western markets out of their airing schedule
>>
>>168453812
>squeezed two major western markets out of their airing schedule
It'll get released in NA after it's done airing, I don't see how this is a problem. And don't shit post with Phos.
>>
>>168453760
Well, I don't even like most Kyoani stuff. Maid Dragon is the only Kyoani stuff that I like.
>>
>>168436034
i hate nu-/a/
>>
>>168453933
>nu-/a/
I bet you are even not old enough to remember Mashimaro, so it is understandable why would you find trash like Colors exciting
>>
File: 66960491_p0.jpg (335 KB, 921x945)
335 KB
335 KB JPG
>>168453911
>Australia
>NA
And it is a problem, because it's still a major market they're missing out on. People who give a shit about VEG are still going to watch it regardless and that's money they're never going to see because once this is over I'm sure as fuck never going to rewatch it
> And don't shit post with Phos.
You can't stop me
>>
>>168414574
Sure I can. It's a bad ranking.
>>
>>168414574
Is that K2?
>>
>>168421680

Devilman Crybaby is uncensored action. Check it out. https://nyaa.si/view/993367
>>
>>168414574
the only undeniable fact I see here is death march's placement
>>
>>168421839

Only Devilman Crybaby
>>
>>168414574
What a good climber that dog must be to have shat near the top of the mountain, explains why Poputepipikku is there
>>
>actually watching all that garbage
>>
>>168416074
not them but it was one of the very few I was hyped about. ended up very dissapointed.
on the bright side the opposite happened with another title
>>
>>168454748
a lot of great anime
>>
>>168454376
Yes it is.
>>
File: 1518557182751.jpg (28 KB, 480x480)
28 KB
28 KB JPG
>>168414574
I wish flamewar threads would earn you a permaban.
>>
>>168457702
>IP based posting
>permaban
Anon there's a reason ban evasion no longer gets you 30 days.
>>
>>168457702
nobody is flaming anyone though, there isn't even the infamous war of VEG vs Franxx here.
>>
File: 1517610222076.png (65 KB, 355x328)
65 KB
65 KB PNG
>>168427787
>Darling turned out legitimately good
>>
shit ranking
>>
>>168414574
Yeah I can.




Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.