Anime vs manga comparisons Just for fun, post one manga scene alongside it's anime adaptation equivalent and let other anons decide witch one looks better
>>288587453Why was the manga censored?
>>288587453
>>288587453Source?
>>288587453The panties on her hand makes it hotter.
>>288587610comes out in a weekly manga mag kind of like jump but does less numbers so it's requiredif it gets volume releases it should have more of the good stuff
>>288587868
>>288587828Kanan-Sama episode 10
The anime was a travesty.
I thought this wouldn't just be another censored anime thread from the OP but oh well.
>>288587453Her ass is more angular in the manga, the anime made it rounder
>>288587453>>288588437Dumb brat needed correction
>>288587465Souless
>>288587722Anime version is too skinny
>>288587854Yeh
>>288588437depends on the drawing
>>288589743Damn
>>288588190From soul to souless
>>288587722Probably shocking for kids who read the manga because of the anime. Fanservice is way heavier in gunsou manga.
I knew /a/ would love this scene when it was finally animated, but god damn was I not expecting it to make the rounds to this extent.
>>288590507But, seemingly, Rumiko, herself, frowns upon ecchi elements of her past work.Some anon posted an image of some book where there was said comment.I didn't save it, though.
>>288592204We only care about about hotd. His other works may as well not exist
>>2885881901989 anime Ranma got cake
>>288588437Dumb brat needed correction
>>288592177That was only Inuyasha, anon for some reason she requested the anime staff to tone down the adaptation and removed the fanservice the anime had, Ranma's being censored is just MAPPA being MAPPA, they do the same to everything they ever adapt, Dorohedoro is another notable example
>>288594450the anime is so much better
You wouldn't slam your hand down on angular surfaces. That would be like hitting a box; it just hurts your hand.
>>288594534Yeah Chiba and the manga got more serious over time. Dezaki was locked the fuck in from the start.
>>288594431Too bad the anime wont get to adapt her other spanking
>>288587868Why do so many people clamor for remakes when it's abundantly clear they're ugly downgrades and censored every time?
>>288587453Anime version looks like she's farting
>>288594914Good
>>288594768Most people aren't coomers and don't care about fanservice.
>>288594628A shame
Apparently I only saved a colored version of the manga page, but have some Tomo. We got a lot more body in the anime and I'm not complaining!
>>288594768I don't know about in the case with Ranma but I at least want "remakes" (bad term) that more closely follow the source material where in the past the anime significantly diverged or was incomplete. I'm not an old good new bad fag so it not being identical to the previous adaptation doesn't bother me, and most of what I want has no reason to be censored so that's also not an issue.
>>288595091Gay
>censorshipschizo thread
>>288587868Nu-Ranma is too skinny
>>288595148Anime has a more fitting outfit
>>288596364It is like they kept the same weight but made her 4 inches taller.
>>288587453Ass too small
>>288587868Why would they remove the word China for? are Chinese THAT thin skinned or what? it ain't like it is saying "China fucking sucks!" or anything like that
>>288596308It's not schizo if it's all true.
>>288594914That's hot
>>288597495>are Chinese THAT thin skinned or what?Yes
>>288597495Their government is.
>>288587465Shame on them
>>288595040What a baffling change
>>288594450we should only animate low quality manga so that the anime will, by principle, be better than the source material
>>288587453Cute butt
>>288588945Agreed
>>288595148Top: Soul Bottom: Souless
>>288595148Top has better composition but nothing will top Nadeshiko's season 1-2 design. It's too perfect.
>>288596308Evidence to great to be ignored, he copes but he can't, so instead he lies.
>>288592204Triage x worth watching?
>>288587868>kiev gets renamed to kyiv>turkey gets renamed to turkiye>now china is renamed to smileLiberals have gone too far.
>>288588380Anime look fine
>>288601750NoMaybe if you miss his artstyle sure (i miss it too)
>>288595148I understand the problems, but considering that the anime was a camping and tourism ad in disguise, it makes sense that they used real footage for some backgrounds and shots.
>>288601771I like turkiye more...
>>288592204What chapter is this in the manga?
>>288595064huge improvement
>>288597525your base assumptions are incorrect which is what makes them schizo, you can say "the sky is blue" and then point up to a blue sky, the issue is that then you are following it up with "and its blue because the lizardjews are using weather control satellite lasers to spread 5g crystals on it which are blue colored" and when people push back you go "why are you denying the sky is blue"
A rare example where everything is of high quality
While anime adaptations often fail, manga adaptations rarely do—though there are exceptions.
>>288604228I don't think I've ever read a manga adaptation of a LN but manga adaptations of anime have a worse track record than anime adaptations of manga imo.
>>288602079anime looks like they weren't allowed longer than 40 seconds.
>>288604228It's a shame they had to change artists for SSH, the style just feels a bit lacking now.
>>288595040....but why?
>>288587453>>288588437Makes sense. The dumb brat needed correction but spanking a butt that pointy would hurt after the hundredth slap or so. So rounder is better for correcting dumb brats.
>>288604338>manga adaptations of animeI recommend this
>>288587465>>288587722We were robbed
>>288594534YYH or HXH?
>>288605132That's not an adaptation, that's a spinoff. And I'm already up to date on that. There are manga adaptations of the GuP anime but I haven't read them. I liked the manga adaptation of Healer Girl, but part of why I liked it was because it showed things from different perspectives. A lot of manga adaptations of anime are incomplete/abridged and some are missing key things from the anime because the mangaka I guess got a vague plot synopsis.
>>288597495I think it was more a dig at China to remove it. I always took it that Ranma was wearing it because he just came from China. Like wearing a shirt that says Chicago because you went to Chicago.
>>288605261because China might demand royalties for the use of the name
>>288588190Nice ass
>>288588190
>>288606217Lum a cute
>>288592051Oh yeah. Just go to any chapter and it probably has pantsu in it. Makes it a bit difficult to read at work.
>>288587453Very interesting
>>288605261Wasn't the second or third ED of the original anime a song about Ranma being a Chinese boy?
I'm still mad about it.
>>288609136
>>288609148
>>288609136>>288609148holy fucking W H A T. Almost as bad as GATE's. And I still love the gate anime, but even I know A-1 didnt even try.
>>288609136>>288609148The anime looks so much better
>>288594482>both written by womenchecks out
>>288587453By me
>>288604063And all different depictions of her too. I should probably read the LN someday.
>>288603529i pooped a nigger on this post
>>288592204Tummy
>>288610453Manga looks better here
>>288610339This is a good change
>>288589743Anons are always going on about brats needing 'correction', but what do you think you'll do when they're the one doing the correcting?
