[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/a/ - Anime & Manga


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: ss.png (57 KB, 600x600)
57 KB PNG
>Eizouken
>Yojouhan Time Machine Blues
>Ghost in the Shell
>Tenmaku no Jaadugar
>Heike Monogatari
Is Science Saru the new Shaft? Almost everything they make is at least an 8/10
>>
>>289906651
Rubber animation just doesn't mesh well with anime aesthethics
>>
File: 1748195612305158.webm (3.92 MB, 1920x1080)
3.92 MB
3.92 MB WEBM
>>289906651
Their animation is pretty shit
>>
>>289906651
Not a single good anime in that list.
>>
>>289906793
looks good to me. but I'm a little smarter than most anons.
>>
>>289906651
Is Saru is the new SHAFT, who is the new KyoAni?
>>
>>289906937
Saru is not the new Shaft, the two studios have nothing in common. OP is a retard.
>>
>>289906651
as they're half korean owned I don't consider them an anime studio. they make cartoons.

But there is one interesting thing I want info on. Their wiki says they use Adobe Animate. I find this profoundly difficult to believe. I realize they probably use many tools down to pencil and paper, but that line is so striking and weird that I need more info on it.
Adobe animeate isn't even stable on MacOS. Seriously. Is there truth in this?
>>
>>289906820
yeah I know right? none of those anime have cute girls doing sexy things so i can masturbate to it. good anime needs lots of sex so i can masturbate
>>
>>289907070
Piss off Gookfaggot
>>
File: 1764184081286299.png (236 KB, 739x415)
236 KB PNG
>>289906937
CloverWorks
>>
>>289907070
Half the industry uses Adobe Animate.
It made big news when they announced it was going to EoL.
>>
>>289906651
Shit.
A big disappointment.
Shit
Shit for real
What?
>>
>>289906937
>>289906937
The new SHAFT is GoHands.
The new Kyoani is Dogakobo.
>>
>>289907196
>half the industry
you mean half the cartoon industry
it's rarely used in anime, where typically pencil and paper, clip studio paint and custom pipelines will be used
science saru is very different in this respect, and their use of adobe animate is an argument that they aren't an animation studio
>>
>>289906793
cool Gainax throwback
>>
>>289906793
Don't bother, the fans of this studio are deranged
>dude I swear Ping Pong looks good
>dude I swear Sanda looks good
>dude I swear Jaadugar looks good
>>
>>289906651
even after shaft implosion years ago this is straight up disrespectful, after yuasa they don't have the creative vision that shaft have.
>>
>>289907070
>I realize they probably use many tools down to pencil and paper
most do but comparatively saru uses papers less, atleast when i read years ago. I don't remember much but their softwares and hardwares being dogshit to the point of losing work on it was bought up when they were getting flamed for poor conditions at the studio back in 2021 or 22.
>>
>>289906651
They're good and all but to be like old Shaft they would need to be willing to have more eros in their anime
>>
>>289906651
it's pretty clear at this point that science saru uses Ai for backgrounds on GITS
personally, i don't care about that too much but they're not open about it. would be a major PR debacle if it leaked
>>
File: abenobashi.gif (293 KB, 309x170)
293 KB GIF
>>289907624
There's nothing even remotely Gainaxy about it. If it was a Gainax throwback the girls would have their tits flopping all over.
>>
File: 1753399935213238.webm (2.88 MB, 1920x1080)
2.88 MB
2.88 MB WEBM
>>289906793
There's something about the motion in this one that's a little Ghibli to me
>>
>>289907945
AI sleuths are smoothbrains
>>
File: 1763436663822579.png (2 MB, 1920x1080)
2 MB PNG
>>289907709
Jaadugar does look good.
>>
>>289906793
Is /a/ really still so ignorant about animation they think is the same kind of thing as QUALITY
>>289908046
It does but horrible example
>>
File: forced seizure.webm (2.35 MB, 1440x1080)
2.35 MB
2.35 MB WEBM
>>289907971
It strongly resembles a bunch of moments from FLCL actually
>>
File: 1710818156785393.png (52 KB, 694x402)
52 KB PNG
>>289908095
>it's not QUALITY because it's meant to look like shit
so basically picrel
>>
>>289908147
imagine comparing dogshit like dandadan to flcl
>>
>>289908151
The Science Saru classic
>it looks like shit ON PURPOSE so that makes it good
>>
>>289908194
it looks similar and now you're mad about it kek
>>
>>289908330
Tons of anime utilize a cartoony artstyle during certain sequences. Your "this is a gainax reference" just indicates how little anime you have watched kek.
>>
They made trash like Japan Sinks so I can't really bring myself to like them
It is kind of strange how GITS of all shows managed to attract its very own schizo though
>>
>>289906651
>sells out to netflix
Immediately taken off the artistic roll call forever.
>>
>>289907971
THAT'S SASHI'S GRANDMA
>>
>>289906651
Shaft is still Shaft.
Why can't Science Saru just be Science Saru?
>>
>>289906651
The evil eye fights in season 2 of Dandadan were so fucking good. Can't wait for season 3.
>>
File: 20260731_020526.jpg (97 KB, 720x666)
97 KB JPG
>>289906651
>>
>>289906793
That looks really bad. The background is nothing but cgi from the 90s.
>>
>>289910918
Science Saru is just peak anti-anime.
>>
>>289911229
>>289911161
>>289911099
took you a while to show up friend
>>
File: 20260804_215140.jpg (10 KB, 165x153)
10 KB JPG
>>289906651
> everything they make is at least an 8/10

No shill everything they make is shit.
>>
>>289907624
Hell no don't even compare this gook shit to Gainax.
>>
very organic posts itt
>>
>>289906793
Momo wears very lewd underwear
>>
>>289911478
She wants to make herself more attractive to ojisans
>>
File: 20260804_222348.jpg (180 KB, 720x1308)
180 KB JPG
>>289906651
Eunyoung Choi is a gook and Science Saru is a gook studio.
>>
>>289911099
>science saru got its start making cartoons
wrong right off the bat
>>
File: np_file_21526.jpg (119 KB, 1032x1328)
119 KB JPG
I'm going to make gook shit and call it anime.
>>
>>289906651
All their works are ugly eye cancer.
>>
>>289911950
It's because it's gook shit that's why it looks so bad.
>>
>>289906793
This is so ugly. Utter dogshit animation.
>>
how come you're replying to your own posts
>>
Is there anything on this website that doesn't have a dedicated schizo samefag?
>>
>>289912044
you sound frustrated
>>
>>289912044
All the good posters left for Twitter after the hack and didn't come back. The schizos are the only ones left
>>
>>289906651
Why you left out Dandadan?
>>
>>289906793
>>289908151
>>289908297
>>289911161
>>289912011
Just saw the episode today and it looke okay. Explain why its's bad.
>>
>>289911275
See>>289912541
>>
>>289906651
>Almost everything they make is at least an 8/10
All the trash you listed is a 3/10 or below.
>>
>>289906793
>pretty shit
That looks extremely shit. Clearly lazy garbage that doesn't animate shadows. And it's all retarded and off model for the sake of cringe too.
>>
>>289906820
/thread

It's all cartoons or cheap flash tier animation. The GITS is less bad comapred to the rest though.
>>
>>289911099
>GITS was chosen to give the studio credbility
this
both their series this summer GITS and Jadugar stink of "look! We're doing anime!"
See, we're doing old style 90s anime like boomer OVAs!
And see we're doing Ghibli style shit with vaguely leftist, anti-american leanings!
But all the amazon money in the world can't buy credibility.
>>
>>289907235
Eizouken is really ugly and a lot worse than their GITS.
>>
>>289911099
GITS is being received extremely well in Japan better than the west actually.
>>
>>289906778
I wish Zoomies would understand this, but all they do is deepthroat this kind of animation because: more movement = better, I guess. Then again, it’s hard for them to have a sense of aesthetics when not even anime and manga creators care about it anymore. I mean, many of the most popular anime and manga from the last 5-10 years are shit with super bland character designs, like Chainsaw Man and Frieren.
>>
>>289908194
Both are dogshit. Flcl is easily the uglier out of the two though.
>>
>>289906778
"Anime aesthethics" just means the characters have big eyes and small noses.
>>
>>289911099
>>289911942
>cartoons
>gook shit
>>
>>289908016
It's just the high knee form she's using to run. Ghibli works loves animating people running like that.
>>
>>289908330
You are correct and you made the subhuman seethe.

>>289908399
>Tons of anime utilize a cartoony artstyle during certain sequences.
Not him. That's pretty much only on the faces, and usually only in specific comedic moments too. Anime is known for being on model most of the time. Dandadan does resemble gaynax and trigger shit since their animations are usually more cartooney than the average japanese animation. Dandadan is noticeably more cartooney than average just like trigger and gaynax shit. Cartoon garbage has been out of style in japanese animation since the around the start of the 80s.
>>
Man the Science Saru shitpost is surely take off the season. Is it Jaadugar or GITS?
>>
>>289913278
>Cartoon garbage has been out of style in japanese animation since the around the start of the 80s.
Those westaboo studios you mentioned have made hit shows though...
>>
I'm beginning to believe that the "Muh cartoon" poster is a Korean
>>
>>289913328
What? This been like this since 2014.
>>
>>289913278
>Anime is known for being on model most of the time.
>Cartoon garbage has been out of style in japanese animation since the around the start of the 80s.
Zoom zoom post.
>>
>>289913278
I actually don't know where to start with this one, so you kind of got me.
>>
>>289913328
Both,
>Muslim
>Releasing GITS when Old Good New Bad shitposting is reaching critical mass
They cannot escape the fate. Maybe if Jaadugar and GITS released on different season, it would have been less deranged but still
>>
>>289912983
>means the characters have big eyes and small noses
That's part of it. Anime is a 2D style. Other characteristic of the anime style are being anatomically correct and having "cel shading". Here is an example of an anime styled character.
>>
>>289913332
Sure but they aren't the zeitgeist. They're not the norm or the trend. That's the point.
>>
>>289911099
diabolical westaboo studio
>>
>>289911229
This. They clearly detest japanese conventions and would rather make ugly westernized schlock.
>>
>>289913328
It's GITS. GITS will be the AOTY.
>>
>>289913481
It's art is not as ugly as any of Saru's other works it has very little animation.
>>
>>289906778
This.
>>
Is the Muslim anime actually good or is it just popular with certain demographics that have gained internet access in the last decade or so and now show up everywhere in large numbers, including on /a/?
>>
>>289914324
>Is the Muslim anime actually good
It's boring shit. I wouldn't call it an "anime" either since it looks like a repulsive saturday morning cartoon.
>>
>>289914324
it's not good, even ignoring it's directed by a spanyard
>>
>>289913481
even if it were popular (it's not) that would not make GITS AOTY
if you don't know that you plainly don't belong here
>>
File: Kimi no Iro.webm (1.76 MB, 1920x1036)
1.76 MB
1.76 MB WEBM
>>289906651
Good thing Yamada escaped Kyoani so she could create her masterpiece.
>>
File: 1784507087794281.png (609 KB, 810x641)
609 KB PNG
>>289907070
Based.
>>
>>289915534
wtf is that face? lol. fugly
>>
>>289906651
No, Monkey and Mappa represent everything that's wrong with anime today, them being sellouts and traitors is also the cherry on the top.
>>
File: 1594431654364.webm (2.02 MB, 1280x720)
2.02 MB
2.02 MB WEBM
>>289906793
>posts good animation
>"Their animation is pretty shit"
>actually worked as bait
this webm is what i feel about your post
>>
>>289916170
what is that kino from?
>>
>>289907534
see >>285776978

Shingo Yamashita and his team at Studio Chromato, who famously used the software to create Cosmic Princess Kaguya, expressed deep shock at the announcement. The sentiment is shared across the industry; Nakaya Onsen, director of the Fate/Samurai Remnant opening movie, lamented:

"I spent ten years side-by-side with Flash. Without this tool, I wouldn’t be able to create animation. It's not as simple as 'all you need is paper and a pencil.' As a result, I must downsize my animation business even further. Adios!"

Takahito Sakazume, director of Fate/strange Fake, echoed this sense of finality, stating that he now feels he has "only three years left" before being forced into retirement from animation production.

China, The Apothecary Diaries Season 2 Opening 2 Director, commented:
"Flash has come to an end immediately following Yamashita's latest project (Cosmic Princess Kaguya). Perhaps we are entering an era of yet another paradigm shift..."
>>
>>289907709
>>dude I swear Jaadugar looks good
dude watch episode 1 I swear it does look good
>>
>>289916264
you can post whatever cherry picked garbage you like, but if you're honest you'll admit adobe flash (so called animate) has never been commonly used in anime.
Its use by science saru has been one of their defining characteristics and ties them more closely with western cartoon production.
>>
>>289916337
you're not being very honest right now
>>
>>289916337
Flash was the software of choice of the so called "webgen animation", that has been the most significant shift in the industry production practices since the early 10s. What was once limited to self taught independent animators is now common practice. If you pick any sakuga heavy show of the last 15 years there is a good chance it's led by webgen animators who use Flash.
>>
>>289915534
That studio wasnt going nowhere with all those flops
>>
File: IMG_0436.jpg (332 KB, 1125x817)
332 KB JPG
>>289906793
It's drawn like that in the manga tho
>>
>>289916883
Nah. Clearly looks uglier and more off model in the Saru cartoon.
>>
>>289917160
Yeah if you have vision problems or something
>>
>>289917276
You're projecting.
>>
File: 1783684762640030.png (1.76 MB, 1920x1080)
1.76 MB PNG
>>289914324
It's good but you are probably too bigoted to enjoy it
>>
>>289915436
>even if it were popular (it's not)
kek
>>
>>289906793
>nooo, why does a gag look like a gag!?
retard
>>
>>289916337
NTA but they're right and it did make big waves. I'm pretty sure they just copy pasted verbatim from one of the news articles that interviewed a bunch of directors about it (not cherry picked).
>>
File: Bocchi the Rock.gif (653 KB, 640x360)
653 KB GIF
>>289906793
I thought that was only as "bad" as this
>>
>>289906651
None of them are 8/10 or above.
>>
>>289916883
>IT LOOKS LIKE SHIT ON PURPOSE I SWEAR!
Uh huh.
>>
>>289913278
>and usually only in specific comedic moments too
such as the one in the webm, dumbass
>>
>>289916261
If I’m not mistaken it was Japan Sinks
>>
>>289918436
Just because it's a gag doesn't mean the backgrounds have to be so godawful, retard
>>
>>289906651
I only like Heike because ancient Japanese h i s t o r y
>>
>>289921558
Read the book because it wasn't a good adaptation
>>
Science Saru is the next Trigger and I'm fine with that.
>>
File: 57589322.jpg (136 KB, 1200x900)
136 KB JPG
>>289906793
Retard.
>>
>>289906651
Studio Bind is closer to being the new Shaft I would say
>>
>>289907278
...
You might be right.
>>
>>289906651
Eizouken is their only good show.
>>
>>289906651
Dandadan too, which is great
>>
>>289906651
without yuasa they're nothing
>>
File: ride your wave.jpg (100 KB, 566x800)
100 KB JPG
Why nobody post about Yuasa's actual best movie?
Story fumbles a bit, but hits all the right places like the surfing.
>>
>>289906651
They're outside the production committee MLM aren't they? Also Yuasa functioning as both an editor and creator means they have a good filter for quality. Even this muslim wank show is watchable but on principle I won't.
>>
>>289914324
This is the worst possible thread to ask this question in
>>
>Gookfaggots are desperately trying to claim Saru Gookshit
Why are Koreans so desperate to make people like them?
>>
>>289923207
Yuasa is no longer at the studio
>>
>>289923861
>Yuasa left in 2020 but still works with SS sometimes
holy fuck what that's an end of an era
>>
>>289923703
Koreans are the worst human beings on the planet. Every single korean person I've ever known has tried to get me to do stuff for them every single time. They're extremely conniving and soulless.
>>
>>289925594
>Every single korean person I've ever known has tried to get me to do stuff for them
Oh my god that sounds awful, literally demons in human skin
>>
>>289908194
>imagine comparing a 7/10 to another 7/10
>>
>>289927751
Is a 6/10 to a 5/10.
>>
>>289912890
No don't even try shit on flcl.
>>
>>289927892
What do you mean? Nobody likes FLCL anymore, it's been like that since progressive aired.
>>
>>289928066
Ova still good.
>>
>>289928066
>Nobody likes FLCL anymore, it's been like that since progressive aired.
Shit on the sequels, not the original.
>>
>>289928288
This.
>>
>>289922916
You're joking right
>>
>>289922916
Used 3d models that's not real animation.
>>
>>289928288
It made everyone realize it was always bad.
>>
File: 91cVcNTVUIL.jpg (299 KB, 884x1347)
299 KB JPG
>>289924524
Not even that. After he decided to step down as CEO he basically just stuck around to finish Inu-Oh, after which he fully left and took a long break to recover from burnout (which is understandable, they worked him like a dog and as such the quality of his output suffered greatly). But now he has a new studio, Ame Pippin, and he's directing a movie based on the book Daisy's Life
>>
>>289917929
>no hair covering
Shitty brat needs correcting
>>
>>289922916
This is the worst thing he's done if we ignore Japan Sinks for being co-directed.
>>
>>289928583
Ping Pong > Tatami Galaxy > Night is Short > Kaiba > Mind Game > Inu-Oh > Devilman Crybaby > Lu Over the Wall > Eizouken > Ride Your Wave >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Japan Sinks

I only started watching Kemonozume yesterday so no opinions on that one as of yet
>>
>>289928913
tatami galaxy was done by madhouse not this gook studio.
>>
>>289929035
Reading comprehension isn't your strong suit huh buddy
>>
>>289928913
Not a bad ranking but for me the top 5 is

1. Tatami
2. Mind Game
3. Ping Pong
4. Night is Short
5. Cat Soup
>>
>>289906793
>>
>>289929111
Cat Soup was only written by him, not directed, but if I had to include it I'd put it between Kaiba and Mind Game
>>
>>289906793
I had a chuckle at this so the animation was right on the money
>>
>>289929223
He also drew the storyboard, frankly if you look up the other works of the guy who namely directed it it's obvious who to credit for Cat Soup.
>>
>>289928913
Mind Game > Kaiba > Eizouken > Inu Oh > Arukeyo Otome = Tatami Galaxy > Kemonozume > Ping Pong > Ride Your Wave > Lu > Japan Sinks



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.