[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


Was the Enlightment just Protestantism for faggots not men enough to openly transition into Evangelicalism, Lutheranism and Calvinism?
>>
Someone realized you could do experiments in the psychical world and build models of that instead of just studying Aristotle and then it went overboard
>>
>>17271512
How is that related to trashing hate to the Middle-Ages and the Church as Protestants did meaving behind a notion of "Middle-Ages le bad"?
>>
>>17271501
The French Enlightenment was the result of judaized Anglo poison being injected to France via Whig agents like Voltaire.
>>
>>17271516
People vilify those they replace, like catholics vilified pre Christian europe
>>
>>17271518
Interesting, I did not know about it

>>17271521
Yeah. As I said, Protestantism for faggots
>>
>>17271501
No. It has its roots in Papism.
https://youtu.be/vxNrCEqpwL0?si=ZJ3CSePamI7VlwyD
>>
>>17271546
They weren't protestants, they rejected the entire trivky talking snake axiom that underpins Christianity
>>
>>17271518
>Voltaire was a Whig spy
such totally unwarranted British importance can only come from a Russian or a Larouchian.
>>
>>17271556
>can only come from a Russian or a Larouchian
That text is from Michael E. Jones
>>
>>17271501
It's hard to understand these people's minds, I've been studying them for over a decade and still haven't quite gotten it, but they seem to live in search of anything that gives them a reason to act snobbish. Since protestantism became accepted by the unwashed plebs, they just needed something else to feel superior to others
>>
>>17271501
Protestants were just ultra-violent pre-LGBTQ+ with just as many "flavors" to chose from as them.
Was Calvin a jewish rabbi as some claims?
Luther was a tool for others to steal and get rich by stealing what the common people gave to the church they went to evey sunday.
Voltaire at least gave us funny quotes.
>>
>>17271555
They were still protestants deep down. Secularism is only a LARP, we still retain our religious convictions behind that
>>
>>17271582
>people that lived in Catholic countries, educated in Catholic schools, lived in Catholic societies were Protestant. Because they just were!
>>
>>17271586
Those ones were still Catholics deep down, ofc. I'm talking about the ones who came from a protestant background
>>
>>17271588
And even protestants are just Catholics who are angry at the Church for whatever reason and decided to create an entire fable centered around this hatred
>>
>>17271518
People who blame their ideological failures on conspiracies are silly in general but Tradcaths actually believe some merchants and bankers were able to beat Gods divinely ordained order
>>
>>17271501
>Evangelicalism, Lutheranism and Calvinism
>men
Pick one
>>
>>17271582
>we still retain our religious convictions behind that
Believing there's something greater or in ghosts isn't the same as believing in a taking snake or god talking to moses through a burning bush before trying to murder him
>>
>>17271596
lmao I've never seen a single "humanist" or "enlightened" person who doesn't have all sorts of wacky beliefs behind this stupid façade. One of them once confessed to me he believed he was the reincarnation of Jesus Christ. Another believed in astrology, etc, etc, etc
>>
>>17271602
You have no reading comprehension
>>
>>17271619
Your post really made no serious point
>>
>>17271623
Even if you're right about none being truly secular you're wrong about calling them protestants unless they believe in Christian dogmas.
>>
>>17271638
They may not have believed in all of them, but I'm pretty damn sure they didn't reject all of them either.
>>
>>17271640
So what christian dogmas did Voltaire believe in?
>>
>>17271642
He believe in God, and no, he didn't learn to believe that from some ancient egyptian occult priest, he learned it from his Catholic family and his Catholic neighbors
>>
>>17271642
>>17271645
Btw, Voltaire asked a Priest to come to his aid in his deathbed. In case you didn't know.
>>
>>17271645
Since the oldest jewish religious scrolls talk about God having a wife it seems reasonable Jews got that belief from somewhere else too at some point, So we're all pagan
>>
>>17271653
Never seen that in the Bible anywhere, that's on you
>>
>>17271649
That is according to his enemies
>>
File: 1724616073895151.png (3.37 MB, 1982x811)
3.37 MB
3.37 MB PNG
>>17271501
No the enlightenment was mostly about race, the heretical idea that all races are indistinguishable and unimportant to God. That strange blasphemy is what led to the protestant schism because for some strange reason the catholic church decided non whites were to be considered also people that the son of God came to save. You could say that later the americans who left were trying to establish a new colony which kept that vision alive also.
>>
>>17271658
>T-t-t-tha's according to his enemies, ok?!
>>
>>17271657
The oldest bible is from the 3rd century BC, jewish texts from the elephantine temple in Egypt of the 5th century BC refer to multiple gods. Those jews were on good relations with the temple in Jerusalem so it's hard to find a reason to view them as heretics
>>
>>17271671
That's on you, my faith doesn't teach me I'm the ultimate authority to judge the authenticity of canonical books
>>
>>17271673
And I've no reason to judge the authenticity of your holy book as more truthful than any other book
>>
>>17271677
That's fine. When we die, we'll find out who was right all along. I'm pretty confident on my beliefs, I hope you are on yours as well
>>
>>17271680
I really am and the majority of the world agree with my belief that you're wrong
>>
File: immigration 1790.png (524 KB, 1795x1063)
524 KB
524 KB PNG
>>17271663
>You could say that later the americans who left were trying to establish a new colony which kept that vision alive also.
>>
>>17271518
Just desserts for Normans trying to turn us into indentured servants.
>>
>>17271556
Italians, Irish and some others do that too. I've noticed at least. We are like the Jews in their eyes.
>>
>>17272322
It’s just Catholic seethe honestly
>>
>>17271518
Bro this so fucking much, so glas to see people is catching up far from the history as it is told from the perspective of the secularized Anglo-Germanic Protestant cultural hegemony that prevails today.
>>
>>17271518
lol
>>
>>17271518
>>17272921
>le anglo perfide brainwashed us into doing it
dumb
>>
>>17272921
See who benefited the most from the French Revolution and everything will start making more sense.
>>
Every time I think I'm becoming sympathetic to Catholicism I see threads like this and am reminded most modern Catholics are just spiteful Irish/Latinx mutts endlessly seething about Anglos. Even Anglo-Caths are almost always race traitors like Adrian Vermuele.
>>
>>17273069
I love that you say this as if all countries/societies/civilizations were perfect, didn't have their own shortcomings and as if we didn't have to sacrifice our pride and recognize our flaws as well
>>
>>17273079
Where did he imply any of that?
>and as if we didn't have to sacrifice our pride and recognize our flaws as well
If latinx tradcaths were capable of that we wouldn't have these same threads shitting up the catalogue over and over
>>
>>17273079
I don't think Protestant England or Germany were perfect, but the issue is e-Catholics just project such an insane amount of hate on Anglo society, even more than Jews in some cases. It's also incredibly safe too, no one will "cancel" you for hating Anglos, look at places like reddit where they talk about Anglos like /pol/ talks about Jews.
>>
>catalogue

BUTTHURT BONG ALERT
NIGEL IS ANGERY



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.