>>41358256
I hope the fluttertrannies dont get to this one

File: 1723353584732.jpg (213 KB, 1000x1143)

213 KB JPG

>>41358256

File: IMG_0444.jpg (82 KB, 782x1021)

82 KB JPG

havent been on 4chan in many years
but i recently saw a stupid pony recommend on youtube
and well nostalgia got the best of me
bless you trixiefags for having a thread up

File: Spoiler Image (52 KB, 375x376)

52 KB PNG

>“Trixie looks amazing, immaculate, great AND powerful! You don’t need to keep going.”
“Look, just stop fussing for a single minute and I will finish this. You’re only making this harder for both of us.”
>You struggle to pull the brush through her tail as she fidgets and wiggles.
>Clearly she is nervous about the show, she hasn’t put one this big on in several months.
>As far as the performance goes you’re sure she can pull it off, but you know that she must be in the proper state of mind to maintain composure against the inevitable neighsayers.
>fuckin pon-speak
“Oka-“
>She swats you away.
>”OKAY! You are finished with Trixie now, correct? She will judge your work very harshly for making her wait so long.”
>She steps in front of her large gaudy mirror and looks herself up and down at various angles.
>”Look at her. She is stunning is she not. Trixie is the most beautiful, the most talented, most, most-“
“The most perfect mare in Equestria.”
>You coo in her ear as you adjust the final hair in her mane.
>You’ve also learned the best way to hype her up is to play into the worship aspect of her persona.
>As well as a little bit of sensuality keeps her focused on the reward of a successful show.
>”And you,” she jabs at your side with her hoof “are the most perfect assistant this mare could ask for.”
“Wow, pre-show acknowledgement?”
>”Yes well, I know this show is very important for us both, and you’ve done so much more to help Trixie prep for this. A-and well …”
>You place Trixie’s hat on her head and plant a little smooch on her cheek
>”Hmph. Thank you Anon.”
>God she's so cute when she's trying not to act flustered.
“You’re more than welcome. Now! Knock ‘em dead Trix.”
i-is writing still cool

>>41358628
>>41358983
Yes.

https://derpibooru.org/images/3428647

File: D36315F1-3117-43A3-978F-9(...).jpg (487 KB, 1806x3198)

487 KB JPG

i do not understand glimmerniggers

File: lol.png (381 KB, 1048x825)

381 KB PNG

>>41359759
Holy shit I recognize Starlight Fan LOL
When I used to browse the mlp subreddit he would constantly bitch about Trixie there and how so much better Starlight was. I just checked and he still does.

I wish Trixie could use her magic horn to make my virginity disappear.

>>41358983
very cool

>>41358983
Yeah, specially if it's as good as this

>>41359820
What did trixie do to him?

>>41360479
stole his waifu

>>41358256
ITS TRIXIE TUESDAY MOTHERFUCKERS
thread cant die today
post what makes trixie best horse
for me its her voice
i could listen to her talk about how great she is forever

File: TrixCute3.jpg (35 KB, 564x564)

35 KB JPG

she cute. I want to buy her

>>41360895
She’s great AND powerful anon, don’t forget

>>41361196
of course, my mistake
and she would never let me forget either

File: IMG_5004.jpg (19 KB, 320x320)

19 KB JPG

>>41359759
Link?
No reason in particular.

File: IMG_1596.png (331 KB, 955x951)

331 KB PNG

>>41358983
>>41360074
>>41360269
alright well i dont have much experience with writefaggery, but i am feeling somewhat inspired recently
so im gonna rewatch some of the show and see if i can cook something up soon
pls keep thread alive

File: 1696199231790591.gif (1022 KB, 506x506)

1022 KB GIF

>>41359759
>>41359820
>trixieniggers are so insecure they seethe over and snapshot anyone that dares speak against their waifu

File: 40keks.png (832 KB, 677x759)

832 KB PNG

>>41361398
>the fan of the manipulative whore is speaking
i would tell you to go back to your rarity thread, but your waifu is so shit she doesn't even have one

File: IMG_4941.jpg (11 KB, 153x144)

11 KB JPG

>>41361357
wait what the FUCK
there are 9 seasons of this show now
holy hell ive missed a lot since glimmer was introduced
how much does trixie appear in the later seasons
sh-should i watch the rest of the show
also fucking netflix doesnt have past season 4 im mad

File: 1696504741648715.gif (2.09 MB, 621x508)

2.09 MB GIF

>>41361505
Go for it! The show is worth watching to the end and there are some great Startrix episodes.

>>41361505
S5-7 are my favorite seasons, Trixie even gets to play an important role in a two parter. And remember to watch the FiM movie before you start s8 since it contains important context. But yeah, Trixie gets way more love in the seasons you missed.

>>41361536
>The show is worth watching to the end
Lie count +1

File: 1699866285822161.gif (1.09 MB, 786x600)

1.09 MB GIF

>>41358256
I only like Trixie for her cock tbqh

>>41361505
>how much does trixie appear in the later seasons
how do we tell him

>>41361317
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/535959/the-three-strike-rule

>>41362030
>all his stories are about starlight, twistar, or starlight cutting off her friendship with trixie
Of course.

File: IMG_3396.png (45 KB, 481x512)

45 KB PNG

>>41362027
this makes me fear something sinister
>>41361743
>>41361536
but ill give them a watch then
i cherry picked a couple episodes from season 1 so far and somehow the show is still entertaining, if not a liiiiitle cringe
also in boast busters trixie did nothing wrong

>>41362131
>boast busters
can't believe the hack writers tried to paint trixie as the bad guy while making the m6 look like sociopaths at the same time.

>>41361536
Glimmie should be shipped with my cock alongside Trixie

>>41362188
yeah i didn’t remember the writing being actually that retarded
>traveling performer puts on act at magic show
>magic is common so they have to be extra special at it to be impressive
>proceeds to do genuinely impressive things considering that all uni’s have magic
>is then considered the devil
like bro come on
sure she was a bitch
but she was boo’d from the very start of the show so that’s kinda valid

>>41361398
Are you seriously that retarded?
It wasn't posted because they don't like Trixie, it was posted because they're flat out wrong and delusional. If you actually watched the show you wouldn't come to that conclusion. They're glimmerniggers though, so I don't expect much from them.

Also, congrats on the new thread, enjoy it while it lasts.

>>41362388
Obnoxious, arrogant, and flippant I can understand, but selfish and cowardly are delusional.

>>41362388
Would it be better if it was a flutternigger or twinigger trashing Trixie?

>>41362397
no they aren't. she literally runs off afterwards instead of facing ponyville, she's a certified pussy.

>>41362501
You're trying too hard

>>41362515
???
are you saying that she doesn't run off like a pussy to escape consequences? twice?

does anyone have that one AI voice meme of trixie saying fuck jannies?

>>41362501
>>41362520
No? She tries to defend Ponyville from the Ursa by tying it's hands together, obviously it doesn't work, but she tried. She stayed around until the threat was gone. And when was the second time? Are you just making shit up?

>>41362601
she runs off before ponyville can confront her in boast busters. she does the same in magic duel. quit being disingenuous. she is a coward.

File: bait.jpg (57 KB, 451x448)

57 KB JPG

>>41362604

>>41362604
for what reason does she even have in "facing" ponyville
she didnt do shit besides brag about her ability, it was the two retarded children that actually caused the ursa problem
and trixie did actually try to solve it
so the only thing she would have faced was incorrectly placed accusation
to which i say yeah dodge that shit
thats not cowardice

>>41362612
She could have stayed to help clean up the mess, to show them that she means well and is really a nice pony, then the ponies wouldn't have any reason to ostracize her afterwards.
>and trixie did actually try to solve it
Her attempt was more to save face than to solve it, she knew she had no chance against the ursa. She wouldn't have tried if the colts weren't goading her.

File: workscited.png (26 KB, 390x376)

26 KB PNG

>>41362729
>She could have stayed to help clean up the mess, to show them that she means well and is really a nice pony
1. She's a performer and is constantly going from place to place
2. Her wagon got destroyed thanks to two kids from said town, why would she feel the need to help "clean up" anything?
>then the ponies wouldn't have any reason to ostracize her afterwards.
There would still be no reason to ostracize her, if you genuinely think she did anything that warrants being ostracized you're a cunt.
>Her attempt was more to save face than to solve it
pic related

People have been so desperate to demonize Trixie since 2010, the fact that it's still going just as strong is baffling, if not worse.
Anyways, I think you're lost. Don't worry, I found the thread you're looking for >>41356061

>>41362761
>1. She's a performer and is constantly going from place to place
She's self-employed, not under any strict schedule.
>2. Her wagon got destroyed thanks to two kids from said town, why would she feel the need to help "clean up" anything?
Because her reputation is tarnished and she should want to correct the record, let the ponies know that they are wrong.
>There would still be no reason to ostracize her, if you genuinely think she did anything that warrants being ostracized you're a cunt.
Magic Duel proves you wrong, Trixie literally claims she was ostracized unless you think she was lying.
>pic related
The show.

>>41362791
>She's self-employed, not under any strict schedule.
This doesn't create obligation to clean up a mess that wasn't made by her in a town she has no connection to with ponies that actively hate her without genuine cause.
Also she isn't ever trying to prove that she is nice, that point was never up for contention, and it is strange to me that you are trying to argue about that.
>Because her reputation is tarnished
Again has nothing to do with cleaning up an unrelated mess. Furthermore these two retards just ruined her entire livelihood. If anything ponyville should be repaying her for the damages caused by its citizens.
>Trixie literally claims she was ostracized
She probably was ostracized as she claims, but it was never for a good reason so I don't really see how this is supposed to prove anything
Trixie was a simple showpony who got shat on mega hard for problems that she didn't cause because people thought she was a braggart
Sure she lied about a feat of power, but like that isn't at all related to the responsibility for the following situation

>>41362827
>This doesn't create obligation to clean up a mess
She still had a choice, she chose to run instead of confronting the problem. The problem being the town thinking she did anything wrong. But another way to look at it is her obligation to her show business as her financial success is dependent on her reputation.
>Also she isn't ever trying to prove that she is nice
The point is to prove to the ponies that she isn't at fault, that she is not who they think she is.
>Furthermore these two retards just ruined her entire livelihood. If anything ponyville should be repaying her for the damages caused by its citizens.
If she had stayed and made her case then Ponyville likely would have repayed her.
>but it was never for a good reason
Because she ran away without defending her reputation so she got cancelled on some bullshit. If she had addressed the allegations sooner then things would not have gotten to that point. It's a shitty situation made by the shitty writers, but it is what it is.

>>41362791
>Magic Duel proves you wrong, Trixie literally claims she was ostracized unless you think she was lying.
I wasn't saying she wasn't ostracized you dunce, I KNOW she was. I'm saying the ponies had no good reason to ostracize her, and yet they did anyways.
>The show.
What about it? It never implied she only helped fight the Ursa to "save face", though I to be fair, it didn't imply either.

>>41362496
At least twifags actually make sense, flutterfags are a different breed of retard.

>>41362827
im not entirely sure what point you’re trying to argue
trixie ‘could’ have done a lot of things that may or may not have made ponies feel differently
but i dont think any of that is relevant to the morality of her actions, which is what i am arguing
i would appreciate if you could succinctly state your claim before we continue

>>41358983
>”Just levitation? JUST LEVITATION!!?”
>”Do these FOALS not realize how difficult it was to fly Trixie’s wagon around like that?”
>”How can nop0ny, not a single one, understand the magnitude of her talent. Hrngh!”
>Crash!
>You dodge the shrapnel of the plate Trixie just shattered on the floor.
“Trixie-“
>”Fine, Perhaps they’re ignorant to the fact that she didn’t simply levitate her wagon around in circles.”
>”They didn’t grasp the nuance of the speed, the precision, the raw power and concentration it took to suspend it from a SINGLE contact point so her magic aurora didn’t distract from the wagon's design.”
>She magics the plate back in one piece and prepares to spike it again.
“Trixie it’s-“
>”Also it ISN’T even levitation. It’s NEVER levitation! IT’S KINESIS!!”
>the plate bounces with a loud thud and clatters about without breaking.
>”Levitation is a specific spell that is cast upon an object in order to suspend it at a predetermined height with predetermined weight capacity.”
>”Kinesis conjures a semipermeable softlight barrier that allows for manipulation of the encompassed object.”
>”Why is everyp0ny so uneducated about the most basic mechanics of magic!?”
>Trixie leaves the intact plate on the floor and magically grabs a fresh one from the cupboard.
“Uh, Trix-“
>”If they don’t know how magic works they won’t be awed by her incredible feats and creativity.”
>”Dear Princess Celestia, you put an absolute moron in charge of the department of education. Yours truly, the wise and scholarly Trixie.”
>…
“Trixie.”
>”Ngah!”
>She slams the second plate down onto the first, splitting them both.
>”And, and they’re completely unwilling to listen to Trixie explain why she is amazing. The least they could do is allow Trixie to enlighten them about their shortcomings and thank her for the lesson.”
>”Preferably with bits and worship.”
>”Trixie swears, sometimes her greatness is a blessing and a curse.”
>She lifts the pieces of both plates and fixes them, before smashing them together midair.
>”She can hardly believe that what those ponies enjoyed the most was the opening light show.”
>”Why even bother putting effort into other astonishing feats when small minds are entertained by the simplest luminescence.”
>”Next time Trixie will spare those peasants her sophisticated acts and save her energy.”

>>41363881
The origin of the argument is whether or not Trixie is cowardly. Her running away from problems are cowardly acts. The morality makes little difference, cowardice doesn't have to be unjustifiable. It's also possible for cowardly characters to be brave, it's a common trope even, which makes Trixie standing up to the bear and also sacrificing herself in the changeling hive so much more impactful. I think it makes her character better, part of why I like Trixie is she's not as much of a cartoon character like the m6 are.

>>41364379
then if the argument is about cowardice i dont think trixie exhibits that
she never makes it apparent that she was afraid of the citizens of ponyville or cares at all about their opinion of her being a showoff
she “ran away” because her house was destroyed and she has no reason to be there anymore
i just count that as leaving, though she did literally run
the only thing she was afraid of was the ursa, and rightfully so
and when she first saw it she ran away, but that was to dodge a direct attack
after that she did stand up to it
and regardless of the motivation, whether it was because she was goaded by the retards or because she genuinely wanted to stop it
that’s courage by definition: standing up to something scary

>>41364477
>cares at all about their opinion
Her business is kind of heavily dependent on their opinion, she should care about it.
>she has no reason to be there anymore
Other than clearing her name and demanding reparations so she can continue her work unimpeded, she should care about those things.
If she just left simply because she didn't care about the consequences that just makes her look more incompetent and entitled when she goes for revenge. I find it more endearing that she's too scared to confront the issue properly since she has trouble expressing herself.
I'd also mention s6, but I have a feeling you only consider the first two Trixie episodes canon.
>that’s courage by definition: standing up to something scary
A coward overcoming their fear to be brave when the situation calls for it is a beautiful thing, I always love seeing it, never gets old. I believe Trixie is a much more nuanced character than you give her credit for.

File: IMG_7311.png (397 KB, 554x554)

397 KB PNG

get your ass off the table

>>41364585
she definitely should care about how her audience views her because that is her income
but caring about consequences is a non factor given that she didn't bring the beast into town
she probably should have hung around to at least see if anyone would agree with her side
but given how the mane6 was up her ass frame 1 for her act I don't blame her for just dipping
btw dash literally does the same shit but catches no flak so
anyway I agree that social anxiety and the inability to drop her persona in order to properly communicate with the denizens of ponyville is endearing and while not clearly stated, I subscribe to that headcannon
but I don't think that necessarily constitutes as cowardice
though my definition of cowardice may just be more extreme than others

File: trixie.jpg (96 KB, 700x700)

96 KB JPG

>>41365034
and onto my "you know what" hehehe if you know what i mean...

and trixie did nothing wrong by the way!

File: IMG_6807.jpg (445 KB, 1869x696)

445 KB JPG

>>41365076
>anyway I agree that social anxiety and the inability to drop her persona in order to properly communicate with the denizens of ponyville is endearing and while not clearly stated, I subscribe to that headcannon
I love interpretations of her character like this, it's subtlety hinted at in the show like in NSP and the end of Magic Duel, it makes her a much more interesting and sympathetic character rather than just seeing her as another Rainbow Dash.
She's just a pony who wants to entertain others and wants friends, and she conveys that in the only way she knows how.
If you like that take on her character, you might like these stories, they're some of my favorite interpretations of her, though be warned, they're both kinda sad, especially the latter.
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/298790/start-of-a-new-life
https://www.fimfiction.net/story/532898/final-performance

>>41365142
thank you friend, I will definitely check these out
>both kinda sad
I wouldn't have it any other way

File: tr1.png (38 KB, 607x265)

38 KB PNG

>>41365252
ik you're trolling but c'mon

File: 1647866526176.jpg (715 KB, 2549x1459)

715 KB JPG

>>41365449
Just because you don't like and/or disagree with my post does not make it a troll

>>41364235
>You both stare down at the mess she made.
>Trixie huffs and puffs, clearly tired from her performance and her post show tantrum.
>You let her catch her breath for a moment while you consider where to start.
>Carefully avoiding the shrapnel, you kneel down next to Trixie and wrap an arm around her withers.
>”Trixie is sorry … she did it again, huh?”
>She avoids eye contact with you, clearly ashamed of her outburst.
“It’s alright Trixie.”
>She begins to weakly piece the plates back together.
>As you watch the shards slowly combine and seal together, Trixie lightly taps your thigh.
>She reveals a small cut on the bottom of her hoof.
>”…I stepped on one.”
>You can’t help but smirk a bit at her directness.
“Would you like me to grab a bandage?”
>”Yes please. I’m too tired to heal this right now.” Her eyes begin to water. “Fixing those plates was hard.”
“Okay, give me one second Trix.”
>Thankfully, you were able to convince her some time ago that a simple first aid kit was worth putting together, in case of small injuries that she was unable or unwilling to fix up with magic.
>A few minutes later Trixie is resting with a tended wound, the plates are back in their home, and the remaining ceramic dust has been swept up.
“Alright, I think we should talk about how the show went.”
>”mmmpf, do we haaabe do?” Trixie complains into a pillow.
“We have to address some issues, Trixie. Preferably sooner than later.”
>”Trixie has no issues, her performance was flawless, ‘tis everyp0ny else who has the problem.”
“You know I’m not trying to pick on your performance. And I would never doubt your skill,-”
>A smug smile slowly creeps across her face.
“-but-“
>It fades.
“-there are more factors that go into a successful show than the performance itself. And I would like to share my thoughts on it.”
>You motion for her to sit up.
>She does.
>”Fine, you have Trixie’s attention.”
i have to be up for work in a few hours and im spending time writing this shit
feels like home

File: thej.png (113 KB, 892x417)

113 KB PNG

place your bets, trixiefags
is this ever gonna happen?

bump

>>41363518
we aren't. a few autistic outliers that you think are multiple people is not representative of the whole group. you should know that mr.oh-so-intelligent.

>>41366144
If he doesn’t do anything then I will, getting sick of seeing it myself too and it wouldn’t hurt to try

>41365888
Then that's even worse. I'm afraid you're retarded and a faggot. Your faggoty list has two other mares on there. Fuck you. Wasted trips.

>>41366436
yeah you are, pipe down.

I want to suck Trixie's huge crotchboobs
https://derpicdn.net/img/view/2022/6/6/2880620.png

>>41366144
betting 3 dollars that the mad lad does it

>>41367542
betting my left kidney and a bag of chips

>>41366699
keep us updated if you do

File: Gamer tixie.jpg (334 KB, 1600x1200)

334 KB JPG

Trixie is, in fact, a pro gamer

>>41367373
incredible rebuttal, retard. concession accepted, please carry on without your incorrect beliefs holding your IQ down.

File: 1618934713965.gif (306 KB, 520x293)

306 KB GIF

>>41368294
>calls someone retarded
>immediately resorts to concession posting
The irony lmao

File: 1675115313379843.png (189 KB, 1024x1024)

189 KB PNG

>>41368294
Be quiet for mommy, pumpkin.

>>41365142
All this images tells me is that Trixie owns and likely dominates Starlight and if given the chance she'd do it in front of twilight and Starlight would let her.

Trixie is more based than I ever though

File: D780643B-D553-4967-8E21-3(...).png (222 KB, 1010x791)

222 KB PNG

I hate how much I relate to this silly mare. I’m plagued by my smallness, everyone around me is better at what we do. I’m slowly making friends but there’s a deep bitterness there. Maybe one day the world will see how GREAT and POWERFUL I am.

>>41368876
I get that. As I was growing up, every time I thought I was special in some way, or uniquely good at something, one of my few friends would unintentionally 1-up me. At first I thought that I just needed to persevere and find my one thing that I could prove to them was mine alone. But cutie marks don’t exist in real life, and I had to accept that I’m just dumber and weaker than everyone I know.

>>41362131
Just rewatched magic duel. I kinda forgot how powerful magic is in this show.

>>41368876
>>41369269
Guys, we're all gonna make it. Even Trixie got a decent pencil pusher job in the education-industrial complex. She's probably not even homeless anymore.

>>41369629
There's no way Starlight didn't invite her to live in the castle with her when Twilight left.

>>41370206
>key item
give her more credit
trixie is my great and powerful traveling companion

>>41370566
What do you mean? Key items ARE important, you can't get rid of them. They're important and you shouldn't ever want to throw them away, like Trixie.

File: 149.png (364 KB, 1149x977)

364 KB PNG

>>41358256

File: large (2).png (448 KB, 576x1024)

448 KB PNG

hi :)

>still replying without a hint of introspection
>expecting me to read or reward your bitching, whining and revisionism with a (You)
not likely. replies hidden, go be a nigger somewhere else.

>>41368876
>>41369269
crossposting from the other thread >>41371056
>tl;dr
What's important isn't what you're capable of doing, it's what you actually do that matters.
Someone else might be smarter or stronger or more creative than you, but they aren't going to do every possible thing. There are better writers in the world than Lauren Faust, M.A. Larson etc., but only they wrote MLP.
>t. "gifted" child who ended up doing nothing with his "talents" and jealous of the fags who actually make stuff people enjoy

>>41371104
that was an adorable comic

>41370999
what is this schizo on about

File: 1804 - crying sad Trixie.jpg (205 KB, 950x1100)

205 KB JPG

>>41371104
It's absolutely important what you're capable of doing, because you might be incapable of doing anything that matters. You can't write a new MLP if you can't make yourself write, for no observable reason, regardless of how good at writing you could be.

>>41371181
Trixie when I show her my penis and it's bigger than hers

>>41370936
They look like gourds.

File: trixie shaking head.gif (23 KB, 95x96)

23 KB GIF

>>41371181
Pony doesn't really matter in the long run. You think people 200 years from now will think of pony as anything more than a footnote in a book about a fad during the early days of the internet?
You'll probably think this is pretty hypocritical coming from someone who's "capable", but what "matters" is all a matter of degree. That said, it's important that your work interacts with other people. If it all stays as ideas in your head or notes in a secret journal somewhere, then yeah you'll just float through life and your memory will die with you.
Have you tried finding intrinsic motivation in your work? Trixie is braver than any of us, because even if ponies don't like her work, she still continues to perform and travel. Although on a certain level she needs attention and validation from others, I think at her core Trixie is motivated to perform for the love of performing.

>>41371508
unf
https://derpicdn.net/img/view/2024/8/24/3428647.png

>>41373108
>dykeslop ship
ewww

File: IMG_7322.jpg (67 KB, 1099x844)

67 KB JPG

>>41373116
do you just complain on every thread about literally everything and anything

File: 1685763263768014.jpg (40 KB, 556x667)

40 KB JPG

tixie :)

File: 1723194227019971.jpg (1013 KB, 2636x2154)

1013 KB JPG

Glimmerniggers keep moving, this is a Trixie thread.

File: 1534676120960.gif (2.56 MB, 720x720)

2.56 MB GIF

>>41374171
>Glimmerniggers keep moving
As they should. As for Glimmerfags though they're welcome, Trixie and Starlight are best friends!

File: Untitled.png (2.32 MB, 3000x1456)

2.32 MB PNG

all im saying is is that i think trixie and starlight are really cute and attentive friends

She gimmer on my starlight

File: IMG_6852.png (335 KB, 1220x2302)

335 KB PNG

>>41374793
qts

File: IMG_7342.gif (2.39 MB, 480x640)

2.39 MB GIF

imagining a trixie version of this

bump

>>41375394
>>41374793
Lossbians

File: 139097__safe_artist-colon(...).png (635 KB, 2850x4000)

635 KB PNG

There is something so sad about her character that I can't help but feel the utmost sympathy for Trixie. We don't know what she went through before she stepped hoof into Ponyville, we don't know why she is the pony she is, yet I feel sadness for her that remains inexplicable. She has her sad moments throughout the show and some ponies have worse lives to face (Applejack's family), yet it feels she has the saddest tale of them all. Why is this? I feel the need to give her the greatest support one could ask for. Trixie feels like a suffering friend I can't help; a friend in need who feels trapped and can't/won't reach for help in escape. But, Trixie isn't even real. I have never known anybody like her. And yet, I feel so deeply entrusted with her plight. Why is this?

>>41376257
Feels like how the show was accidentally written to be much better than intended, so did her character.
>she needs to be a boastful one off character
>she's also a travelling performer
>which explains her boasting
>also she can't have close friends due to travelling so much and playing a stage character
Her personality is comparable to Pinkie in some ways.

>>41368876
I am quite the opposite. successful, talented and look like the saver of aryan race, but Trixie is also my numer 1 soul mate. She seems more intelligent than an average mare, is very cute and quirky and would definitely make a great friend.

File: 3419537.png (2.4 MB, 1550x1365)

2.4 MB PNG

>>41376858
She isn't more intelligent, she's more bullheaded than most and brute-forces her way through problems, provided someone else hasn't solved the problem for her on account of her good looks.

File: 21950809-DF3C-4293-B409-2(...).jpg (73 KB, 640x719)

73 KB JPG

>>41376310
I don't think she was ever intended to just be a one-off character, she shows up in the show bible which predates the show by a whole year. They definitely wanted to do more with her even early on.

File: cachedImage.jpg (100 KB, 1887x335)

100 KB JPG

>>41376257
I think this guy put it best.

File: 3304390.jpg (152 KB, 1000x1000)

152 KB JPG

>>41377031
Lauren Faust just needed any character that was boastful, and originally wanted it to be a guy since she's a misanderist. Fortunately, Savino (pre-allegations) was able to push for Trixie as we know her now. Thiessen and Miller kept trying to find a way to bring her back, which first happened in S3. It wasn't until S6 that she was able to become a semi-regular character, which goes to show just how bad S1-5 were since they couldn't find a way to keep someone as great and powerful as her a permanent resident.

>>41377045
As much as I like Trixie being kept from dying in obscurity, let's not pretend her return wasn't a dumbed down mischaracterization of her and an attempt to prop up poochie.

>>41377187
>faustard brainlet
Trixie was finally given some actual depth to her character. She was a one-note clown in the Faust era.

File: 3187186.png (415 KB, 1851x1539)

415 KB PNG

>>41377187
Nobody is arrogant for no reason, and in a show that tries to explain why people are the way they are, having Trixie be a one-note is boring.
>hurr durr flim and flam
>hurr durr iron will
Shut up.

File: 1666947248550.jpg (779 KB, 1170x884)

779 KB JPG

>>41377307
The thing is, even then the show didn't really explain all that much about her. We know she's never had any friends which explains why losing Starlight utterly destroyed her, but that's really it. Anything from her childhood would've been nice.

File: 1726793.png (617 KB, 500x2814)

617 KB PNG

>>41377337
We know her father is a failed stage magician and her father abandoned their family. So she's simultaneously trying to live up to fantastic musings of what her father might be like while also struggling with daddy issues (which would logically make her gay and/or date earth ponies).

>>41377337
Trixie 100% tapped that

>>41377369
That's her mother.

but you're probably right

File: image_2024-09-01_210706102.png (155 KB, 483x483)

155 KB PNG

>>41377370
Lesser ponies would call it taboo, Trixie is great and powerful, she knows the only law that actually matters: Game is game.

If her mom is down, she was all up in that like Celestia on an unattended cake

File: 1714105089345552.png (518 KB, 1000x1029)

518 KB PNG

>>41377187
Don't bother, you'll never get through to those retards.

>>41377349
>>41377337
shouldnt there be a distinct canon
i dont get how people can disagree on trixies backstory
is it just that people dont want to acknowledge content that was published after a certain year
cause thats what it feels like

>>41377398
Where is the contradiction? Trixie has been a life-long loser since she's a unicorn who didn't know how to do magic, and even prestidigitation was too difficult for her since she's actually a moron. The only thing she has going for her is that she's genuinely too stupid to know when to quit, which smart people find incredibly endearing.

>>41377398
Yeah, there's a faction that only considers the first (or two) Trixie episode canon. It's a problem with /mlp/ in general, show discussion suffers a lot in this board.

File: 2800059.jpg (705 KB, 2048x2048)

705 KB JPG

>>41377490
>only seasons 1 and 2 are canon
>only seasons 1 through 5 are canon
>season 1 through 9 are canon, but the comics aren't
>everything is canon
What a disaster...

>>41377499
>horsewizardart
can you stop posting this fag's ugly ass "art"

File: 2800060.jpg (241 KB, 1280x1280)

241 KB JPG

>>41377513
I'll get right on that.

>>41377521
yeah i see, you're a loser who sees nothing wrong with sharing art from these kinds of people. just further endorse them by sharing their art.

File: Untitled.png (2 KB, 648x508)

2 KB PNG

>>41377523
Here, I'll post some of your artwork instead.

>>41377523
fuck off its funny

>>41377641
>Coffee Mate
ok now thAts disgusting

File: 2506426.png (2.11 MB, 1500x1429)

2.11 MB PNG

>>41377672
There's two kinds of artists. Those who make Trixie out to be a filthy, crass, incorrigible, insipid, stupid vagabond, and everyone else.

>>41377478
>she's a unicorn who didn't know how to do magic
She was able to do magic plenty fine until Glimmer showed up.

>>41377683
Those were just illusions, not real magic.

>>41377685
Really? That thundercloud seemed pretty real when it zapped Dash on the ass. She was also able to manipulate rainbows and fireworks.

>>41377709
>>41377685
yeah actually rewatch boast busters
trixie does some real shit
especially that rainbow manipulation i thought was very cool
also “illusion” is a rather nebulous term while literal magic exists

>>41377709
Even Rarity can manipulate clouds, it's not that special.

>>41377716
Illusions are her specialty, it's her cutie mark. Magic Duel reveals some of the tricks behind the illusions from Twilight's side, it's how she "beat" Trixie. Just because she is good at illusions doesn't mean she isn't completely void of magic, it's clear she can do basic magic early on, but not high level magic like teleportation and transfiguration.

>>41377763
TEACUP
TEACUP
TEACUP TEACUP TEACUP
T E A C U P
E
A
C
U
P

File: 1714325185473559.png (2.11 MB, 1920x1080)

2.11 MB PNG

>>41377772
Talking about early Trixie, but yeah, she eventually becomes impressively good at magic after training with Glimmy.

>>41377749
That's just simple telekinesis.

File: 1698622622215756.png (160 KB, 430x438)

160 KB PNG

>>41377528
>shitty art style
>the same "lol weed!" and "trixie's a loser" jokes for the 30,257th time
>trans activist
oh man, i can't imagine why you shouldn't endorse this tard
>>41377617
it's funny if you're mentally below the age of 14, sure.

File: 2195330.png (23 KB, 659x443)

23 KB PNG

>>41377820
You are posting on /mlp/.

>>41377824
What does that have to do with anything? There's still people here with functional brains, even for as little as there are.

>>41377820
just because you have experienced the same thing multiple times and become unsatisfied with it does not mean its wrong for others to continue to like thing
little bitch baby

File: 1925991.jpg (3.79 MB, 8890x6285)

3.79 MB JPG

>>41377828
You aren't personally providing any exceptions to the rule, so I find your assertions dubious.

>>41377716
Trixie was the most powerful unicorn in the show discounting Twilight and Shining Armor before Magic Duel happened. The spells she did in Boast Busters are more than what the average unicorn can do.
>>41377749
Cutie mark magic gave her that ability. She wouldn't have been able to do it without Twilight's fuckup.
>>41377763
>teleportation
https://youtu.be/4r2yKpeYXi0?si=1wCOjPv2k_i8sqgB&t=183
>transfiguration
https://youtu.be/4r2yKpeYXi0?si=1KZnSQpO6BvYHPde&t=524

>>41377882
>Cutie mark magic gave her that ability.
It didn't. Cutie marks explicitly do not grant ponies any abilities. This was quite literally part of what the plot of MMC was built off of.

>>41377882
Abilities weren't transferred in MMC, only their jobs, that's why Rarity was doing weather stuff and not racing or whatever, and also why they sucked at their jobs. So it wasn't really cutie mark magic being swapped at all, just their jobs while their memories were changed.

>>41377911
Cutie marks do grant abilities. MMC was more about everyone's career paths.

>>41377932
>Cutie marks do grant abilities.
They don't. If they did then the mane six would've had no problem doing what their other friends did in MMC. They weren't able to, therefore cutie marks do not grant abilities.

>>41377882
>teleportation
>transfiguration
Those were illusions skillfully performed by Trixie's sleight of hoof.

>>41377938
It was only their jobs that were swapped with some sort of mind control or memory manipulation from Starswirl's spell, not their actual innate cutie marks. The marks were changed/painted over only to represent which job they inherited.

mmc is not canon

>>41377954
MMC is kind of like BB where the writers intended Trixie to be more of a standard villain but due to incompetence in writing ended up making her a blameless victim.

>>41377952
>It was only their jobs that were swapped with some sort of mind control or memory manipulation from Starswirl's spell,
Except Pinkie's job isn't stand up comedy, it's baking. Also, Pinkie grew up on a farm yet is incapable of doing any farm work.
>not their actual innate cutie marks. The marks were changed/painted over
>okay their cutie marks were changed, but it wasn't really their REAL cutie marks, it was just illusory cutie marks
The whole episode is predicated on the cutie mark switch, but you're trying to say that wasn't really what happened contrary to absolutely everything we see and know. Following this line of logic we could argue literally anything to "actually" be the case against every bit of sense. For example I could say that cutie marks don't grant abilities but rather that Celestia can manually turn on an off different abilities for different ponies at any time. Cutie marks could be entirely fake if we're just expected to believe anything in the show could be a lie. It's absolutely ridiculous religious rationalization that you're coming up with as though you're reading the word of God and it must be completely infallible so it's up to you to figure out how to make it make sense no matter how many leaps of logic it takes.

>>41378004
>Except Pinkie's job isn't stand up comedy
Party planner / clown can be considered one of her jobs, but that's besides the point.
>The whole episode is predicated on the cutie mark switch
If that was the case then why did their memories change to make them do each other's jobs (along with the townsponies)? As we all can agree on, cutie marks don't represent a pony's career path, neither do they represent their memories. If it was truly their cutie marks being switched then Rarity would be speedrunning dressmaking, Fluttershy would be throwing a party for her animals, Applejack would be doing farm work in style, etc, they'd be encountering trouble from that conundrum instead of the other way around and they also wouldn't be oblivious to their change.

Because the cutie mark switch didn't have the expected result it is fair to assume the spell did something else as taking it at face value conflicts with the lore therefore it cannot be the inherit characteristics of the cutie marks that was changed. The only explanation that makes sense is that they (and the town) were under a powerful memory changing hypnosis, in which reminding them of their original memories breaks the spell. So essentially, it has little to do with cutie marks other than showing who's memory was switched with whom.

>>41378274
>it is fair to assume the spell did something else
Also switching their memories.
>taking it at face value conflicts with the lore
It causes logical conflicts no matter what. There is no making it make sense, only twisting it to be slightly less nonsensical with certain other parts of the show. Also, the only lore that MMC conflicts with is the strongly implicit "no fucking with cutie marks" rule that had been established. Anything that comes after MMC conflicts with it, not the other way around.
Every single instance of cutie mark switching in the show conflicts with every single other instance. Cutie mark switching as its own idea distinct from an outright body swap is fundamentally flawed and just never works.

>>41366128
“You drew in a decent crowd tonight, but as you pointed out, they weren’t so impressed by the finale. I think we need to start tailoring the show to appeal to the audience in front of you. Consider what earth ponies, pegasi, and other unicorns are used to and what would feel novel for them.”
>”You know Trixie incorporates a variety of acts in her show to display her vast knowledge and talents. That should cover appealing to all kinds of ponies.”
“Generally I agree with the whole ‘jack of all trades’ thing, but tonight showed that you can’t only rely on that. Did you notice that there were hardly any unicorns in the crowd? It’s not very surprising that no one appreciated the mechanical aspect of your magic. I don’t imagine the average earth pony or pegasus spends their time studying unicorn magic.”
>”Trixie ... didn’t really notice, but everyp0ny should be impressed regardless.”
“I think you need to shift your goal from impressing to entertaining, at least for less discerning crowds. As you said, they all enjoyed the light show the most, and you’ve made it clear that those spells aren’t particularly difficult. We could probably take advantage of that and put on a much longer performance mostly focused on just your lights and pyrotechnics.”
>”Mhmm ...”
“Also we should consider venue. When was the last time you performed indoors on a proper stage? And that birthday party at that Chuck-E-Cheese rip off doesn’t count.”
>”Wha-! You-! “ Trixie struggles to form words through her indignation.
>”Trixie told you to never speak of that again.”
>You two were desperate for money and the clown that family had hired canceled last minute.
>It was tough getting Trixie to agree to it, but the family couldn’t disappoint their precious snooky-gookums on their special day, so they paid out the ass.
>Totally worth the two week silent treatment.
>And Trixie did a great job despite her whining. You didn’t expect her to be so good with kids.
>”Furthermore, how dare you imply that Trixie’s wagon stage is improper.”
“I know you’re really comfortable on your stage, and I can’t think of anything more stylish and convenient for a traveling magician. However it does come with some downsides to exclusively perform on it. You and your audience are at the mercy of the weather and terrain, plus we need an up to date public performance permit when we roll into larger cities. Also we both know that it's vulnerable to have to find a spot to park and sleep if our welcome has been worn out.”
>”…Trixie acknowledges these limitations. But she would like the record to show that she has made great strides in improving ponies' opinions of her.
“Noted.”

>>41378398
>It’s true she has done a much better job at not pissing ponies off. She keeps her challenges few and harmless, the bragging toned down, and she takes brief intermissions to keep her head cool.
>Things are certainly going better now than when you first joined her. She thought you would be an exotic attraction for her show, and your wanderlust fooled you into believing that.
>Who knew ponies would be unwelcoming to an ex-tyrant braggart and an extra-dimensional alien. Thank god Celestia was willing to perform some damage control and smooth things over for the two of you. Unfortunately you owe her big for that, and she won’t let you forget it, and you have no idea what her ulterior motive could be haha.
>But that's not important right now, what is important is-
>”Are we finished talking about this yeeeet? Trixie is exhausted and famished after her show and your lecture.”
>Trixie limply slides off of her seat and splays out onto the floor.
>You let out an exaggerated sigh.
>No real point in continuing if she’s decided to act like a slug.
“Alright, we can wrap this up for now. We WILL come back to this later though so don’t think you’ve completely won little miss.”
>You intentionally bump your foot against her flank as you step over to the pantry.
“So what do you want to e-“
>”OATMEAL!!”
>She jumps up and excitedly dashes to sit at the table.
“Oatmeal is a b r e a k f a s t item. What would you like for dinner?”
>You look over to find her staring deeply into your soul. Chin resting on her hooves, eyes half lidded, lips slightly pursed as she slowly breathes the first syllable of the dreaded word.
>”Oat…meal”
>This fucking mare.

>>41378325
>the only lore that MMC conflicts with is the strongly implicit "no fucking with cutie marks" rule that had been established
That has never been established. Applebloom's shenanigans prove the opposite when she was receiving abilities from random cutie marks.
>Every single instance of cutie mark switching in the show conflicts with every single other instance.
Only MMC taken at face value which I explained is actually just memory manipulation so that is covered. Or you can consider MMC retconned if you want, its writing was botched so hard that it has no legitimacy in its lore anyway. All other instances are consistent with the lore.

>>41377349
>struggling with daddy issues (which would logically make her gay
No? mommy issues would make her gay not daddy issues.

>>41377523
life can be enjoyed without constantly being a moralfag y'know. Just enjoy the funny art

>>41378470
But it's not funny.
And wasn't there an entire discussion about this in the previous Trixie thread?
https://desuarchive.org/mlp/thread/41236887/#q41269433

File: 1704932849908168.png (1.05 MB, 1920x1080)

1.05 MB PNG

>>41378418
>That has never been established.
Call of the Cutie.
>Applebloom's shenanigans prove the opposite when she was receiving abilities from random cutie marks.
Unlike your stuff about fake cutie marks with MMC, the cutie pox is explicitly something that merely mimics the look of cutie marks. Cutie marks don't make a pony perform an associated action nor do they appear anywhere but the flank of a pony, both of which the cutie pox does do.
>Only MMC taken at face value
What you mean is that if you assume something entirely different then you can change it to make it fit.
>All other instances are consistent with the lore.
Cutie marks cannot grant powers because it creates a paradoxical situation with ponies attaining cutie marks. They need to be able to perform a certain action to be able to get their cutie mark, but if the cutie mark is what gives them their power to do those things then they'd lack the power to be able to do the thing to get their cutie mark. So if cutie marks grant powers then no one could ever get cutie marks. If your answer is that cutie marks are static intrinsic things that grant powers without being there this creates other problems later.
In Twilight's Kingdom when the princesses lose their cutie marks their personalities aren't affected. In The Cutie Map when the mane six lose their cutie marks they do lose part of their personalities and who they are. Except they also sort of don't but only partially because they're entirely aware of how they've been affected and they can all act the way they normally do but then it doesn't count because reasons. Fluttershy's kindness doesn't come from some magical entity imbuing her with power, it's just who she is. Pinkie Pie wanting to make others smile doesn't come from some magical entity imbuing her with power, it's just who she is. The way they all act and behave isn't because of some magical force making them that way, it's just who they are. And if your answer is to try to make some distinction between their "unique" or "intrinsic powers" versus their elements or personalities, that also doesn't work because Rarity doesn't have a special power in being able to identify if something looks good and Applejack doesn't have a special power in being a country pony.
In The Cutie Re-Mark the whole plot is predicated on preventing ponies from getting their cutie marks. If they're so intrinsic then this would be meaningless because the ponies would just get their same cutie marks anyways. There would be no preventing the mane six from getting their cutie marks, there would only be delaying when it happens. This renders the central plot of the episode impossible. In fact there would be no such thing as "getting" a cutie mark at all, only unveiling it.

>>41378479
Its funny to me, therefore its funny. The world is not centered around you, anon.

File: 1703041312123988.png (406 KB, 1280x905)

406 KB PNG

>>41378418
>>41378580
The only way to make The Cutie Re-Mark work is for cutie marks to be dynamic things, not preexisting. But this leads back into the cutie mark acquisition paradox. These are mutually exclusive. If cutie marks grant powers they have to be preexisting, but if cutie marks are preexisting then The Cutie Re-Mark can't happen.
In A Royal Problem the cutie marks have zero impact on the princesses' personalities. If one of your explanations for The Cutie Map was the equals sign being its own cutie mark and so doing cutie mark things, this would debunk (or "retcon") that notion. It was established both before and after The Cutie Map that removing a pony's cutie mark does not alter their personality. Additionally, in one episode Luna's butt splotch is treated as part of her cutie mark and in another episode it is treated as not being part of her cutie mark.
There is zero consistency in cutie mark fuckery. It is arguably the single least consistent thing in the entire show. To say that only MMC is inconsistent with other parts is to admit either that you have not watched the show or that you are literally incapable of performing logic.
I just have one question for you: Why are you a corporate bootlicker?

File: IMG_5511.png (31 KB, 1862x436)

31 KB PNG

>>41376257
I feel the same way. It's been almost a year since I posted this, it stills pops up in my mind every now and then. I really shouldn't care this much about a fictional blue horse.

File: 1695570949549462.png (237 KB, 598x544)

237 KB PNG

>>41368876
Trixie is the waifu for losers because it's the only mare that their ego can associate with and not feel shame.

File: 1719039882852361.png (426 KB, 1280x720)

426 KB PNG

>>41370708
This is so hot

File: 2004758.jpg (2.35 MB, 4000x5602)

2.35 MB JPG

>>41378890
Trixie is the waifu for the overly-competent who have lost their humanity because of their natural superiority and need a beautiful sub-human to keep themselves "grounded" and remain morally sound.

New rule for Trixie threads
No glimmerniggers (or glimmers in general)
They always fuck shit up for everyone

File: 1916302.jpg (134 KB, 1024x768)

134 KB JPG

>>41379053
That's like having just a peanut butter sandwich, or just a chocolate sandwich, instead of a peanut butter and chocolate sandwich.

>>41379053
yeah the dykeshippers are trash, they and the troontards

File: 1694635172445555.png (190 KB, 1060x1024)

190 KB PNG

>>41379066
>That's like having just a peanut butter sandwich
I do that.

>>41379072
then you don't have autism lmao

wait

>>41379053
what is fucked up
trixie is cute, glimmer is also cute, trixie and glimmer together is also cute

>>41379079
suicide is always a option dyke

>>41379066
It's more like having caviar and potato chips.

File: 1710054917162539.jpg (779 KB, 1600x2326)

779 KB JPG

>>41378580
>>41378583
>Call of the Cutie.
All this showed is that Twilight can't force a natural cutie mark to appear before AB realizes it herself, not that cutie marks can't be swapped/taken.
>cutie pox
I'll grant you that it isn't real.
>What you mean is that if you assume something entirely different then you can change it to make it fit.
You're only right if looking at MMC in a vacuum. But when you know the context of what cutie marks are throughout the entire show, then it tells a different story.
>Cutie marks cannot grant powers because it creates a paradoxical situation with ponies attaining cutie marks.
Everypony is born with cutie mark magic, the visual mark just doesn't appear until they realize their calling. This is why Dash is magically able to do a sonic rainboom as a young untrained filly when no one else can.
>In Twilight's Kingdom when the princesses lose their cutie marks their personalities aren't affected
Personalities aren't really part of the equation so that checks out.
>In The Cutie Map when the mane six lose their cutie marks they do lose part of their personalities and who they are.
It's the equal sign mark that's causing that, similar to the cutie pox. It's part of the joke of equalization.
>If they're so intrinsic then this would be meaningless because the ponies would just get their same cutie marks anyways.
Right, though the mark itself doesn't have to be the exact same picture. The significance of changing the rainboom is that it changes their paths in life, not the cutie marks themselves. Twilight fails the entrance exam, and though she wouldn't give up on magic, Celestia's school and mentorship is no longer a path to her even after she realizes her mark later. This by itself drastically changes the timeline. Fluttershy, Dash, and Pinkie may never have moved to Ponyville either. So they don't all meet up in Ponyville to become friends thanks to delaying their marks which was Starlight's goal, well it was to specifically fuck with Twilight but the rainboom was like a 6-for-1 deal.
>equals sign being its own cutie mark and so doing cutie mark things
Correct
>Luna's butt splotch is treated as part of her cutie mark and in another episode it is treated as not being part of her cutie mark.
That was just for the sake of the animation so we can see Luna's moon on Celestia's fat butt. I wouldn't really call it an inconsistency, but it's certainly a thing that can be nitpicked.
>There is zero consistency in cutie mark fuckery.
You're clearly biased to a certain staff member which blinds you to the obvious logical conclusions right in front of you.

I just want to see Trixie and Starlight team up and torture Twilight and her retarded friends to death.

>>41379222
I just want to see Trixie and Twilight team up and torture you and Starlight to death.

File: 1717571665699338.gif (940 KB, 640x360)

940 KB GIF

>>41379146
>All this showed is that Twilight can't force a natural cutie mark to appear before AB realizes it herself, not that cutie marks can't be swapped/taken.
>okay well it did say no fucking with cutie marks, buuuuuut technically it didn't explicitly say no fucking with cutie marks in all these other ways that it didn't show
>You're only right if looking at MMC in a vacuum. But when you know the context of what cutie marks are throughout the entire show, then it tells a different story.
I.e. if you don't look at the later cutie mark lore in a vacuum it requires very liberal use of headcanon in order to try to make it not be in contradiction with preestablished lore.
>It's the equal sign mark that's causing that, similar to the cutie pox. It's part of the joke of equalization.
>>equals sign being its own cutie mark and so doing cutie mark things
>Correct
>Personalities aren't really part of the equation so that checks out.
Therefore incorrect. It wouldn't be able to affect their personalities.
>You're clearly biased to a certain staff member which blinds you to the obvious logical conclusions right in front of you.
Extreme projection.
You have to keep jumping through hoops to avoid acknowledging the obvious, that being that the lore doesn't make sense. When I find a contradiction in the writing, I can simply call it out as such and say the show is wrong. When you're presented with a contradiction in the writing, you start your process of rationalization where you become determined to find out why it must secretly be correct, contrary to everything saying otherwise. The only reasons for doing this would be either having ulterior motives or viewing Hasbro as a divine, infallible authority. Neither option is good.
Under your framework the show must have never actually contradicted itself in anything. So either you claim the show to be perfectly logically sound or you're choosing to arbitrarily say it can be fallible in some parts and infallible in others wherever you feel like. Basically "I like this thing so it must be correct."

File: 1721913600576948.png (244 KB, 1024x1028)

244 KB PNG

>>41379237
>okay well it did say no fucking with cutie marks, buuuuuut technically it didn't explicitly say no
Your mistake is conflating two completely different concepts as the same thing. Twilight failing to force AB's mark to appear has no bearing on whether cutie marks can or can't be swapped.
>contradiction with preestablished lore
MMC is a fucked up disaster, but at least the incompetent writers accidentally left some wiggle room to work with due to how nonsensical it was.
>Therefore incorrect. It wouldn't be able to affect their personalities.
Equals sign isn't an authentic cutie mark so it's not the same. It is a bootleg manufactured to suppress ponies, its effect is not indicative of the real thing. You already said as much with the cutie pox, so you're contradicting yourself or just being a contrarian.
>presented with a contradiction in the writing
It's not a contradiction until verified to be. When I'm presented with a piece of information I first check to see if it's logically consistent and if its context reveals anything new before I confidently make a judgement.
>Under your framework the show must have never actually contradicted itself in anything.
More strawmanning in your tirade. Under logical reasoning there still exists contradictions such as Twilight being afraid of ladybugs. And I admitted long ago that MMC is the only one with inconsistencies in the cutie mark lore. Your all-or-nothing attitude is quite frankly childish.
>Basically "I like this thing so it must be correct."
Saying this is very telling of your mindset, because you don't like thing it must be incorrect.

>>41365252
>>41365888
>>41378936
jannies not doing their jobs as usual i see

>>41379494
>Under logical reasoning there still exists contradictions such as Twilight being afraid of ladybugs.
Nope. Twilight developed a fear of ladybugs.
This is the type of logic you use. There is a way to explain it away therefore it can't be a contradiction. This is far more reasonable than any of the arguments you've had to use regarding bullshit with cutie marks.
If telling you the consequences of your beliefs constitutes strawmanning it means you've not thought through what you're saying.

File: 1704641137541238.png (535 KB, 967x903)

535 KB PNG

>>41379548
>This is the type of logic you use.
Nope, that is your strawman of my logic. Twilight fearing ladybugs makes no sense because there is no evidence supporting it. In MMC there are literal clues such as the town-wide brainwashing and Rarity taking on Dashie's job, so evidence does exist there although not conclusive.
It looks like you've ran out of substantial arguments so you've been resorting to attacking my logic for the last two posts.

File: 1701000805813238.png (171 KB, 720x722)

171 KB PNG

>>41379615
Your failure of logic is at the core of your entire faulty argument. There's no point going over the same things again and again when you just repeat your failing argument each time no matter how much everything points against it.
>Twilight fearing ladybugs makes no sense because there is no evidence supporting it.
Cutie marks being switched or removed makes no sense because there is no evidence supporting it.
Things didn't happen, until they did. Either both are okay or neither are. Picking one and not the other is arbitrarily applying logic only when you want to.
That you are too stupid to follow your own logic does not make you immune to the consequences of it. That you resort to crying strawman when someone shows you what happens when following your logic shows only that your logic is completely absurd.

File: 1719350755012307.png (1.02 MB, 1920x1080)

1.02 MB PNG

>>41379665
Ah you're the type that erroneously says Shining Armor and Cadance are contradictions.

I'll try to help you understand.
>Twilight fearing ladybugs makes no sense because there is no evidence supporting it.
There is a scene explicitly showing Twilight smiling at a ladybug flying right in front of her. This sets the precedent of Twilight's feelings towards ladybugs, that of positivity or at the least neutrality. This is the information that is later contradicted by Twilight fearing them. Understand?

There are no scenes showing that cutie marks cannot be switched or removed so there was no information to be contradicted.

File: IMG_7138.jpg (603 KB, 1170x1031)

603 KB JPG

>>41377835
When it's actively contributing to a larger problem? Then yeah it does, retard.

>screencapped himself in a different thread while using a mobile device
>calls everyone else the problem
yikes...

>>41380100
yeah the troon stuff sucks and kills the character
the glimmerniggers are no help too

File: 1697713408695392.jpg (162 KB, 970x823)

162 KB JPG

>>41379222
Based trips.

File: 1708230826212230.png (459 KB, 752x752)

459 KB PNG

>>41377820
I will continue to monetarily support LGBT artists and there's nothing you can do about it

File: 1697693392043405.gif (95 KB, 188x270)

95 KB GIF

>>41380140
There's nothing we need to do about it when they'll just kill themselves.

>>41377996
read "BB" as "breaking bad" at first and thought i ran into a rare waltuh apologist in the wild

>>41380140
You're right, there is nothing we can do about it because natural selection is a thing.

File: IMG_7355.png (1.16 MB, 1920x1080)

1.16 MB PNG

>>41380119
>"The schizophrenic is talking to himself again!"

>>41377373
homeless chads rise up

>>41380140
Based tru trixie enjoyer

>>41379079
Best mares best ship

>>41379085
Gays exist. keep crying about it kek

>>41380811
>>41380823
>>41380825
holy mother of samefagging

>>41380828
Occasionally have to come back in and stir the pot

>>41380825
Glimmerfag confirmed tranny.

>>41373108
https://derpicdn.net/img/view/2024/9/1/3434167.png

>>41380981
Now this is what I like to see, show us some trixie on Twilight too Anon

>>41380989
you're gonna have to ask t72b on derpi for that one, i saw someone suggest this in his replies a month or so ago and he ended up doing it.

bump

>>41380981
Unf yes please

>>41380884
You’re surrounded, surrender or become cucked

>>41378580
too much word

>>41366144
>>41366699
this will never happen

File: 93568769.jpg (361 KB, 1170x647)

361 KB JPG

>>41376257
I've seen more and more people say she wasn't a victim and deserved what she got, and it's starting to make me question myself to where I shouldn't feel bad for her either and that she isn't someone worth feeling sorry for. Am I being gaslighted or are they right?

File: 2925510.png (795 KB, 1280x694)

795 KB PNG

>>41383018
You're not supposed to feel bad for her, since she's so inherently worthless. That being said, some of us can't help but feel bad for her regardless, because she's so incredibly incompetent she loops back around from being unlikable to totally lovable.

>>41383029
This just made me even more miserable, thanks.

File: 1512990092488.png (821 KB, 1280x720)

821 KB PNG

>>41383018
You're being gaslighted. She already suffered her punishments, and their vendetta against Trixie is completely irrational and unjust, which shouldn't be shocking.

>>41383018
>another glimmernigger
Anon, the only thing they do is gaslight. Why would you listen to them?

File: 701E8971-37CE-4A7D-89EA-B(...).jpg (1.08 MB, 3464x2969)

1.08 MB JPG

>>41383438
nta but are these glimmerniggers?

bump

File: 1695241272995034.jpg (302 KB, 1920x1080)

302 KB JPG

>>41383100
Trixie and Glimmy are naturally the most misunderstood ponies since they're more complex than the m6.

>>41384641
The real challenge is convincing purists and semi-purists that S6-S8 are worth watching, a nearly impossible endeavor on account of them being incapable of understanding why Starlight Glimmer needed to take over the role of protagonist to keep petrol in the show’s tank.

>>41384184

File: 3002988.jpg (59 KB, 1334x380)

59 KB JPG

I just think she should be publicly flogged and hanged. She's a net negative on society.

>>41379046
This, this is literally me and my current gf
>>41378890
Also this, at some point I felt like an extreme loser, like I wasn't a genius at all and never gonna become the next US president or whatever

Trixie has always been my favourite, but I think the anon who compares waifuing Trixie to wanting a sub-human is correct, since my current relationship with an extremely dumb girl is actually my healthiest and most long lasting one

File: 1475361.jpg (110 KB, 1011x490)

110 KB JPG

>proudly admits to dating a retard
who's the retard now, retard?

File: Untitled.png (286 KB, 500x2814)

286 KB PNG

>>41385619
It's almost like I know what it's like to date and then trick into marriage a dumb girl myself!

File: 1721722078798196.png (227 KB, 726x519)

227 KB PNG

>>41384641
>since they're more complex than the m6.
Fuck I wish this was just bait. Holy shit I hate knowing this post is sincere.

File: 1830010.jpg (74 KB, 942x500)

74 KB JPG

trixie superiority makes faustlusters seethe
moar GREAT and POWERFUL news at 11

>>41385674
Glimmer's should be no boxes for anyone.

>>41385674
Did Celestia actually do that? I don't recall anything about her being particularly effective for the commoners as a politician.

>>41385701
Equestria seems to be a pretty good place to live for everyone.

File: Trixie.jpg (35 KB, 565x800)

35 KB JPG

Anyway, gonna share this picture, have this saved from years ago, and despite purging my devices many many times, this pic of her always remains. Trixie is easily my top 3, maybe even top 1 when I feel sad. She is just lovely, no other female characters in fiction feels like her, even the mane 6 have characters in other media similar to them, but I have yet to watch or read about other Trixie-ish characters, she is unique.

File: 3139186.jpg (1.46 MB, 1980x2872)

1.46 MB JPG

>>41385725
I find it a bit unusual that Trixie's first response to being heartbroken is to kill herself. It's like she never learned how to emotionally mature or anything.

File: 1699489006071375.gif (498 KB, 483x504)

498 KB GIF

>>41385653
twiniggers are even more insufferable than their shitty waifu

Trixieniggers why half of this thread is about the glimmerXTrixie ship?

File: 1692352766210436.png (295 KB, 2532x1558)

295 KB PNG

>>41385781
The trisket well is forever poisoned by the pink snake

File: 1708601159061093.png (989 KB, 2000x2000)

989 KB PNG

>>41385781
Because Glimmer is a parasite who leeches off and steals from others, it's no surprise that glimmerniggers would do the same. As far as they're concerned Glimmer never has enough, and whatever she does have she needs to be more important in. They're not content to let other people just like other characters, you have to like Glimmer too. They see other characters as nothing more than vassals for Glimmer.

File: 1626218.png (813 KB, 2048x3072)

813 KB PNG

only the best deserves the best

File: 1702413117900491.png (1.17 MB, 1024x1024)

1.17 MB PNG

>>41385781
They're easily the best duo and most popular ship in the fandom.

File: 3430399.jpg (439 KB, 2048x1423)

439 KB JPG

>>41385871
i like them because they bring the worst out in each other

>>41385781
Lessbians can't like any character without projecting themselves
>>41385871
Trash

File: 3407512.jpg (170 KB, 2250x1960)

170 KB JPG

>>41385879
The perfect pair

>>41385801
>get called out
>start passive aggressively sperging
Nice way to prove this completely correct.

File: 3387840.png (208 KB, 734x902)

208 KB PNG

>>41385947
You are superior, do not descend to their level.

>>41385969
I was saying this post >>41385801 was correct.

File: 2654898.jpg (219 KB, 1573x1200)

219 KB JPG

>>41385981
Too late to undo it, we all know what you meant.

>>41380825
Less than 1% of the population if you don't include groomed porn addicts.

File: 1496329045314.jpg (72 KB, 800x800)

72 KB JPG

>>41386138
silly ponies!

File: GM3KtpLbgAEbtus2.png (664 KB, 1280x720)

664 KB PNG

>>41385751
In a world where friendship is magic, and means everything to ponies, it is not a surprise she would take it that hard, especially when you remember that she said Starlight was her first friend EVER.

File: 3074199.jpg (1.47 MB, 3508x5083)

1.47 MB JPG

>>41386216
I felt the same way when I lost my first true friend after they found out that I was putting so much effort into doing things they liked doing and going to places they liked visiting even though I just wanted to stay underneath my comforter because I wanted to lose my virginity to them. It was the darkest period of my life.

File: 1703769090595430.png (5 KB, 310x230)

5 KB PNG

>>41386225
>try to cozy up to someone just so you can get in their pants
>be surprised when they don't like it
Anon, you're a sociopath.

>>41386274
Yeah I'm sorry this is nothing like what >>41386216 said at all. Trixie was lonely and wanted a friend. You're just a weirdo.

>>41386300
meant this as a reply to >>41386225 mb

>>41386274
>>41386300
>>41386303
No it was the exact same because I came to actually like them and putting my balls in their butt would have been a bonus but actually liking them didn’t matter to them anymore because they thought I just wanted their butt just like how Starlight thought Trixie only wanted to one-up Twilight

File: skodwerd.png (1.01 MB, 946x709)

1.01 MB PNG

>>41386161
THIS ARTIST IS A TRANNNNNY!
STOP POSTING HIS ART!

>>41385751
>have miserable, lonely life
>never learn social skills
>make first friend
>lose that friend very quickly over something you didnt really notice was bad
Nah, makes sense to me. Character development isn't gonna be from an asshole to a perfect well-adjusted individual overnight.

>>41386335
How do you know it was miserable?

>>41386406
A unicorn who can’t do magic isn’t a happy unicorn. Scootaloo is a pegasus who can’t fly, and even with her friends supporting her, she was still upset about it sometimes. Since Trixie never had friends, she never got emotional support for being a genetic failure, hence why she became boisterous and narcissistic. Since no one else would tell her how great and powerful she is, she started doing it herself, hence the third-person speaking.

>>41386423
bro
you can’t just download somepony like that

>>41386423
That is an interesting outlook on Trixie, though would you say this makes her a more interesting and/or sad character? Do you sympathize with this or do you think it brings her down? Genuinely just curious on your view of her, I always love discussing her.

>>41386423
>A unicorn who can’t do magic isn’t a happy unicorn.
I don't know about that. She seemed more competent than any other unicorn besides Twilight/Starlight even if most of her tricks were illusions.

>>41386500
Yeah, she was originally a pretty above average unicorn.

>>41385801
I thought you were overexaggerating about glimmerniggers until I scrolled up and saw >>41359759 >>41359820


I strive to be as delusional as these people

>>41383029
>>41377478
>>41386423
wait why are we belittling trixie and calling her a worthless loser i thought this thread was for the opposite of that

>>41387062
I love Trixie even though she has no value. If you’re willing to watch past season 5 then she at least starts becoming a better, healthier pony, and I think it’s that pony everyone fell in love with.

File: 1725481277867394.jpg (360 KB, 1600x2048)

360 KB JPG

>>41387079
>past season 5 then she at least starts becoming a better, healthier pony
>I think it’s that pony everyone fell in love with.
Wrong as fuck and kill yourself.

>>41387103
Make me faggot come make me choke to death on your sweaty balls bitch

File: 1706785625653153.png (159 KB, 683x522)

159 KB PNG

>>41386982
It's just one person. Most glimfags love Trixie and vice versa.

bump (again)

>>41387583
That is not one person.

>>41387583
3 at least. me and 2 other nibbas

no offense but if guys like this ship so much why not ya'll make a thread about the ship?

>>41388182
It’s illegal to talk about mares and sex unless it is prefaced with the phrase “I want to cum inside…” and none of us want either Trixie or Glimmer to cum in the other because trans bad.

>>41388174
Anon recognized him as one person. Far far more trixiehaters come from twifags and the other m6 anyway.

>>41388232
>Anon recognized him as one person.
Yeah, how though? That's clearly two different people on Fimfiction. Granted a lot of glimmerniggers just seem like palette swaps of each other but still.

>>41388232
twiniggers are definitely the worst
>>41388320
other one looks like a shimmernigger

>>41388197
I want to cum inside Trixie and Glimmer while they compete over which of them is the better lover until they lose themselves in pleasure and start making out.

>>41388610
nsp made me realize just how much twilight sucks

>>41388637
I realized that back in boast busters.

>>41386330
Womp. Get over it, let ppl make art