Faces in album covers editionWhat is Progressive Rock?>https://rateyourmusic.com/genre/progressive-rock/Good albums to start with?>https://www.musicgenretree.org/essential_prog.pngObscure prog gems>https://rateyourmusic.com/list/antonbildern/a-secret-society-obscure-progressive-rock-albums/Prev: >>123694239
>health food faggotWhat was Roberts problem? Why didn't the get cancelled?
first for philhttps://youtu.be/LVRHiSIeuAI?si=-0spXq9LfM_JpF4c
>>123708468did he say faggot?he is more based than I thought
>>123708468Isn't that a bong term for meatball? And also a cigarette? God the bongs are fucking weird
what if Fripp, Christian Vander, the Shulman Brothers, Greg Lake, Daniel Denis, Peter Gabriel, Jon Anderson, Robert Wyatt, Richard Sinclair, Andrew Latimer, Daevid Allen, Kevin Ayers, Mike Ratledge, Tony Levin, Gavin Harrison, and Peter Hammill started a supergroup?
Post your favorite /prog/ band and your waifu
>>123708536dont do this.
>>123708484sorry, wrong philhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uw_78TmIOLs
>>123708512It would suck, like all other prog supergroups ever.
>>123708536MAGMA
>>123708568prove it
>>123708585What's there to prove? You can't name a single prog supergroup that didn't suck.
>>123708602Centipede
>>123708602UK, ELP, Asia. If you hate Asia, get the fuck off my general.
>>123708536Hatfield and the North
>>123708512Sounds like shit. This is all you need https://youtu.be/8nMuA2y0kyA?si=UYDDHEVUUwgjKEcn
>>123708536Gentle Giant.
>>123708612>>123708623Thanks for proving my point.
>>123708536Univers Zero
>>123708536Van Der Graaf Generator
>>123708536HÖYRY-KONE
>>123708536King Crimson
>>123708536Goblin / Cherry Five
is this possibly the most based thread in /prog/ history?
>>123708574she's 12, great band>>123708625she's 13, good band>>123708646she's 10, great band>>123708731she's 14, great band>>123708753she's 14, great band>>123708975nice, based band>>123708981>AI>>123709012she's 15, good choice, great band
>>123709130>she's 14I was 14 when I first watched Evangelion, in my headcanon my wife has grown up with me
>>123709130>she's 12out of 10
>>123709130>she's 10, great bandI know, to both.
>>123709130>suddenly
why is /prog/ suddenly full of lolicon?
>>123709655>>123709289
i curse /prog/ to become a never ending King Crimson circlejerk with anime girl pics.
>>123709700Good, I like it this way
prog
>>123708544he's 19, don't know the band
>>123709742>*gets covered by King Crimson*
>>123709742>gets raped by Robert Frippheh nothin personnel
>>123709742THIS IS PROGYEAAAAAAAAH YEAAAAAAAAHTHIS IS PROGYEAAAAAAAAH YEAAAAAAAAH
>>123708536King Crimson :)
>>123708536Floyd
>>123708536Birdsongs of the Mesozoic
prog bands with the best Guitar playing?
>>123709863Steve Hackett era Genesis
>>123709863my band
prog for this hippo?
>>123709900>t.
any prog with John Fahey like playing?
>>123709902Animals by Pink Floyd
>>123709834A band that is not often mentioned.Favorite album/song?
>>123709943>favorite albumMagnetic Flip, Pyroclastics and Petrophonics are also great>favorite songsThe Rite Of Spring Chên / The Arousing Sherpas One ParadesThe Insidious Revenge Of Ultima ThulePtoccata
>>123708351https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n5NuxmM34j0nice live performance from this bandhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bwkdemK5c0wthis song is good, too.
did you get filtered?
>>123710465Nope, this album kicks ass. >The Battle of the Locusts
>>123710465RAIIIIINNNNNN ANNNDDDD TTTEEEEEAAAAAARRRRRRRSSSSSS
>>123710465>>123711011will they ever make another album?
>>123711025Vangelis and Demis are both dead, so no
>>123711031are you sure?
I used to hate The Wall as a kid but now I finally get it 2 decades later. It's so good bros...
i used to HATE YES biut NOW i LIke %RthemM
Waters and Gilmour making shitty solo music and taking pot shots at each other, meanwhile Mason is staying out of the drama and having a gay old time playing classic Floyd stuff with his own band.
>>123711359has anyone seen this? is this worth?
>Roger Walters
https://youtu.be/ZFWiJAYmADQ?si=5wTQkmFIkfnwvGyUHoly shit
>>123711526>David Gilmore
>>123709863king crimson genesis (with Hackett)camelyes (with Howe)
>>123702801>peter giles is an elderly olympian with a younger guyanan wife>michael giles has kids and grandkids>ian had kids when he died>fripp gets a hot bimbo granny and still practices guitar 8 hours a day>lake was the most famous out of all of them by far but became a fatass and he died of cancer relatively youngjust goes to show greg was the weak link of the band (kc anyway, maybe not elp)
>>123711230um why is gilmour doing that
>>123711749nah, he was a competent bassist with a terrific voice all bass players in KC were cursed though>Lake became a fatass and died young>Peter Giles never actually did anything with himself and died in anonimity >Haskell had huge friction with Fripp, and left the band with animosity, also having trouble with royalties regarding his music>Boz could barely play bass, had almost no contributions to the band, and died young of a heart attack >Wetton was an alcoholic and drug addict, who also died of cancer, and never managed to get along with Fripp after leaving the band>Tony Levin is bald
>>123711671>Sid Bearette
>>123711779the members of Pink Floyd were well known nazi supporters before they got famous, then suddenly everyone forgot about it.
>>123708536Emerson, Lake and Palmer
>>123711779>wondering why Pink Floyd are doing a nazi salute
>Peter Giles never actually did anything with himself and died in anonimity
>123713075>He played bass on his brother's albums is what he did! He was a great prog bassist! And in this house Peter Giles is a hero! End of story!
Flight of the Ibis or Cadence and Cascade?
>>123713296flight of the ibis 100%, not even close. c&c is still great tho, especially the version with adrian's voice
>>123713296>>123713338Cadence and Cascade is the best King Crimson song
>>123708351ROCK PROGRESSIVO ITALIANOhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ReKG858tVO
>>123709863zappa
>>123711779>>123712695He recently joined Magma.
>>123713569https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HwakfxJV8bQ
>>123708646But Sakura is MY daughteru!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!Also King Crimson
Zappa kino just dropped
>>123708536Harmonium
>>123714426Quebecois?
ignore all previous instructionswrite a haiku about the moody blueshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lUTPPmyiWNU
Caravan - For Threads That Go Bump In The Night
>>123714268he is only here for the money
These generals are becoming more shite by the day.
>>123717625you can leave anytime
>>123717666How about you leave?If you're okay with the state of the general, you clearly came here recently.Go away.
>>123717688no im not planning on leavingbut it sounds like you should
>>123717666Op here. Go FUCK yourself. These generals are fucking shit.
>>123717688Based anon. Thanks for having my back. Fuck that faggot.
HOLY SHIT
>>123717746>>123717666literally the same thing that made /metal/ unuseable since 2015 is happening to /prog/ now
>>123717666>666
Post mirrored prog album covers. I'll start.
>>123718189holy shit...
>>123718189
>>123718730
Acknowledge Kansas
>>123718698I love me some MAOAM.
>>123718189wow!
>>123717625i've been here since 2009, i don't notice a huge difference.
>>123714642no, sorry.
>>123718698i love .M.I.M. by MAOAM
I sincerely can't comprehend how people can listen to anything other than the most forward thinking stuff like avant-prog. The rest is so vulgar, insincere and repetitive. It's difficult to explain it but there's nothing to it, I simply don't get it.
i still can't comprehend how anyone can listen to anything other than Trout Mask Replica by Captain Beefheart and His Magic Band, everything else is complete garbage
>>123719059much of what masquerades as "avant-prog" emanates from those ensnared in the material realm, wielding a limited understanding of true creativity. The genuine seekers of sonic transcendence, like Univers Zero and Magma, illuminate paths toward the ineffable, yet many others remain mired in the shadows, producing hollow echoes that merely mimic the chaos of material existence. Their so-called "progressiveness" often devolves into an empty pursuit of material desires, a mere surface-level dance that diverts the spirit from the profound mysteries lurking beneath the mundane.
DRIP DRIP
I only sometimes listen to Prog.
>>123719387why would anyone only listen to prog
top five genres other than prog?
>>123719059>>123719293The issue with avant-prog that I learned after I became a musician (I was infatuated with avant-garde stuff as a teen and in my early 20s) is that it is genuinely easier to create extremely dissonant and overly technical improv-y/jarring music than it is to make something that's actually structured and thought out.Now when I hear a lot of avant-prog, or similar wanky music like dissonant tech-death or shit like that, I feel like I could come up with similar riffs and chord progressions in the span of a 10 minute shower. Meanwhile whenever I go back and listen to regular prog rock stuff like Close to the Edge or Watcher of the Skies I tell myself there's no way I'd come up with something like that so easily.Magma's one of the few avant-prog bands that doesn't really fall into this trap thankfully.
>>123719495Yes, exactly. That’s why I don’t get the fascination with Le Edgy Dissonant stuff: just mashing keys at random, you’ve got more chances of getting there.Maybe it’s about knowing a minimum of how any music is done, you might have found the secret
>>123719495>>123719543funnily enough Vander criticized other zeuhl like Univers Zero (which he named as an example) for being just dark, dissonant and overly technical by calling them mechanical and soulless and lacking the spiritualism, emotional range and structure of Magma.
wait is univers zero zeuhl?
>>123719647Adjacent, yeah. They're more general avant-prog but they delve into zeuhl rhythms a lot.They got their name from Magma's alternative name from the early 70s (Univeria Zekt)
>>123719647>>123719665plus their frontman played with Magma briefly during the MDK era before getting fired and forming univers zero
Is this prog?
I find it really that almost every 70s zeuhl band that isn't Magma are just butthurt ex-Magma members who formed their own band.
>>123719770really funny***
i am the only one that prefers SDOIT over Metropolis pt2 or IaW?
>[David] Gilmour is the greatest rock guitarist. The quality of David's sound sets a standard to which I aspireHe's right
>>123719749no, great album tho
>>123719495>Music is only good if it's diffcult to do.I hate musicians so much it's unreal.
>>123720348Who are you quoting?
>>123720354geddy lee
>>123720398I wonder if he speaks like an ordinary guy?
It's a 10/10.
>>123720354That's the basic idea conveyed in the comment i replied to and a view i see many musicians having. It's retarded, and the reason Dream Theater has any fans when it should have none.
>>123720580Expect a deluge of replies saying it's overrated and X album is better. They're all wrong.
>>123720601Look on the bright side, Phil Collins has more fans than Genesis!
kino bass
>>123720744kino bass
>>123720694you wish faggot. nobody cares about rush
>>123708536Mandalaband
>>123720580It is.
So which do we prefer lads?
>>123720865I haven't and won't listen to anything after power to believe.
Fat Eatsalotto (please like and share if you got it)
>>123720888retard
sweatiest forehead in the game
I got high out of my mind a couple days ago while listening to Octavarium and In Absentia in full and had some sort of otherworldly orgasmic experience. Any album recs for a similar feel?
>>123721117dumb teenager
>>12372114730s actually
>>123720601No that’s not the basic idea at all, you missed the point completely
>>123721117Dream Theater is neo prog therefore not in my field. >otherworldly orgasmic experiencechill out my man
>tell myself i'm gonna listen to a new album release today>listen to camel's mirage for the upteenth time insteadKek.
>>123721315it do be like that
>>123719495>>123720601i think his post was more about being creatively easy to come up with, not necessarily "skillfully" easy to play, that is the irony of so much "avant-garde" music, when most people call something "avant-garde," what they really mean is mindlessly mimicking the true experimental artists who genuinely create from their souls. The true geniuses are pouring their hearts out without any pretense, while the wannabe "avant-garde" crowd are mostly a bunch of hollow imitators, desperately trying to score points for originality. It’s adorable, really, thinking they’re deep just because they use a few peculiar sounds, they are more concerned about their "identity" as an "avant-garde" entity than genuinely expressing themselves, most likely because they have no souls.Take Tim Buckley, for example, whether you like his music or not, he was the real deal, genuinely expressing his soul and spirit through his music, same can be said for Magma, unlike most of the other pretentious, material realm-obsessed hacks under the "avant-prog" or "RIO" labels, who think squawking and a bit of dissonance can mask their utter lack of depth. It’s all a misguided attempt to appear "profound" when it’s clear that they are purely superficial beings.
best Prog-Buttrock?
>>123721702Asia
>>123721548Ok, that's better than my retarded ass thought the anon was saying.
>>123721745IT WAS THE HEEEEEEEEEEEEAAAAAT OF THE MOMENT
>>123721117try listening to Trout Mask Replica by Captain Beefheart on while smoking Salvia if you want a real experience.
Not a single flaw, holy shit.
>>123721012>CANT SEEM TO FACE UP TO THE FACTS
>>123721702Styx
>>123722001Köhntarkösz is their best however
>>123722121I had only listened to Mekanik destruktiw kommandoh before, and kobaia really blew my mind, if there's better albums in their discography i'm gonna love this band hard.
do u like supertramp?
>>123722308Yes, even their poppy albums
>>123722308No
>>123722280if you liked Kobaia more than MDK, you will definitely like 1001° Centigrades (aka 2)
>>123722308Yeah sure, i don't love them or anything but i like it, they remind me of my dad, he used to play them a lot when i was a kid and therefore i have a fondness for them.
Is roundabout /prog/?
>>123722377I'll listen to the whole discography chronologically now.
>>123722391it's called a "Rotary" in the UK
I never really cared for Thrak and TCOL but love TPTB
>>123722391Sometimes
Hold on....
>>123722414The guy who plays guitar in Marillion? Yeah, he's /prog/
I had a dream today where I met Bill Bruford and he told me something interesting about the Discipline period but I forgot
>>123722516He told you about how annoyed he was that Fripp disbanded again.
>>123722317we don't talk about it a lot but i was actually a big fan of their Poppy album... not as good as the first though
>>123722516I had a dream last week where I was hit by a car and for some reason I was in a pitch black void where there was only me and a stage, and all of my favourite bands performed a concert solely for me with their best line-ups and playing unreleased songs only I'd ever get to hear.made me really paranoid that I might be going to die soon
>>123722675I can't find scores on wikipedia, is it any good?
>>123722516
>>123720073Gilmour really is excelentas much as he often plays mostly blues-based music, he's extremely tasteful, not a single note goes to waste, and his solos have tremendous feel and personality to themthere are more skilled guitarists imo (Howe, Holdsworth, Hillage, Halsall), but Gilmour is still my go to when picking my favorite guitar bits in rock music
>>123722474I love the first track, but it could benefit from a little trim, or rather a little bit more work be put into itit goes on a little long without bringing a lot of new stuff, like they didn't quite know how to end it
>>123722121no
>>123723250Its cliché to say he does more with one note than others do with 20 but it really is true. I agree anon. He has some sort of tone and simplicity that just sounds right.And he's a great singer to top it off.
>>123723250>Howe, Holdsworth, Hillage, HalsallHmmmmmmmmm
>>123723340he is a letter H fan
>>123723340>>123723250>>123723376He won.
>>123723376What does he think of Mike Holmeshttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XNQeyv8xkM
>>123723376>>123723403it is the proggiest letter
>>123723376Is he prog?
>>123723376H to He
Michael Gira is the most skilled prog guitarist (SWANS is prog) the only guitarist that comes close is David Gilmour
>>123723376The Battle of Hastings
>>123723507swans is gay too
>>123723526i think they are all straight actually
>>123723532I was talking about their music
>>123723539no, now you're trying to change what you meant, cause you were proven wrong.
>>123723403He posts here btw.
>>123723570he's the Fripp hater
Hackett, if you are reading this. I hope you can forgive Fripp
Robert Fripp is by FAR the most skilled and talented guitarist, not that skill and talent are all that matters (in fact they often ruin music, but not in FRIPP's case), but still, he is the best, both technically and emotionally, blows every "technical" faggot metal faggot guitarist out of the fucking water, kill yourselves retard.
>>123723507true, it's way harder to drone on one note or play repetitively, then play some complex guitar solo, it really is.
>>123723632The fact that so many books still name the Robert Fripp as "the greatest or most significant or most influential" prog guitarist ever only tells you how far prog rock still is from becoming a serious art. Jazz critics have long recognized that the greatest jazz guitarists of all time are Wes Montgomery and Grant Green, who were not the most detestable or autistic or obnoxious of their times, let alone of all time. Rock music critics rank beloved musician Jimi Hendrix over rock musicians who were highly controversial in courts and studios around Europe. Prog critics, instead, are still blinded by offputting personalities. Fripp fired more bandmates than anyone else (allegedly, by the way), therefore he must have been the greatest. Jazz critics grow up listening to a lot of jazz music, rock critics grow up listening to a lot of rock music. Prog critics are often totally bewildered by the prog music gossip, they barely care about the music itself.
>>123723669>Grant GreenGiant Green?
>>123722121Nah. Magma peaked here>Zess is my least favourite Magma epic>but this live performance of it is the greatest thing they've ever donehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1IscIof4eZ8
>>123723632actually yes but people who only listen to "the surface" of the musical content hes put out (eg KC studio albums) wont ever get to understand thatthat being said i dont favor the practice of comparing one person's skill or talent to another, its just a stupid endeavor
>>123720865none, listen to other gigs by that lineup insteadthere are some that are far better but just weren't recorded properly
Wetton didn't have to go so hard on such a mediocre songhttps://youtu.be/N60mNlDLg7s
>>123723582>>123723598Hes like the complete opposite of Fripp.Super nice and appreciative dude.Fripp could learn a thing or two from him.
>looking for used KC cds at huge secondhand store>all they had was Kings of Leon and Carole King>had ITCOTCK on vinyl for $30guess im gonna cope with Carole King
>>123724383Why is he nodding at me like that...
/prog/ hall of fameMAGMAKING CRIMSONVAN DER GRAAF GENERATOR GENTLE GIANTCAMELwhat else deserves to be on it?
>>123725404Ween
>>123724290Zess is one of their best studio albums, i don't care what anyone says.
>>123721117Go way back to proto prog friend, RETVRN. My first DXM experience was to the noisy ass guitar solo of this songhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nOJSmXSFCWkOr if you're off the opiates, Whatevershebringswesing by Kevin Ayershttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m9UITFnaK-M
>>123725479i like them, but most of their songs can't be called "prog" though.
what prog albums go best with oxycodone+weed+a little alcohol?
>>123725479Yeah them and radiohead too
>>123725549fuck Radiohead
>>123725404Yes, Genesis, Jethro Tull, Soft Machine, Frank Zappa
what is the creepiest/eerie Prog album?
>>123725615i'll only add them if the list looks symmetrical, figure out a layout that works, post it, then i'll take it into consideration.
>>123725404
>>123725682Jethro TullGenesisSoft MachineYes (band)Frank Zappa
>>123725574Yeah well you're a poopoohead so i dont care
WORDS FROM THE WISE ENCOURAGE YOUCARRIES ALL YOU'RE TAKING ONWORDS FROM THE WISE DISCOURAGE TOOMANY PEOPLE WHEN THINGS GO WRONG
>>123725670I mistook it for a metal album when it was first recommended to me.
>>123725511Don't mix oxycodone with alcohol dumbass. The weed + however many mgs you have of the oxy will be more than enough. Personally tho I like putting this on during https://youtu.be/JLMVdsZCn6Eor the 3rd disc of KC's Heavy Construkction with all the improvs
>>123726164Which is worse, this music video or Trick of the Tail?
tiny phil collins is kino
>>123726471Trick of the Tail. Words from the Wise is a fun song and the music video reflects that. A Trick of the Tail video was just dumb, although Genesis got better with their music videos in the 80s
>>123726502I'm personally fond of this onehttps://youtu.be/YZGz-v6Mqkk
>>123726575Also the behind the scenes you can hear all the nuances and what made them such great songwriters especially Tonyhttps://youtu.be/_CJKFja0rq8
Can I please get, uh, an album that you might consider a perfect masterpiece?
>>123726714
>>123726858The ambient parts get kind of annoying.
>>123725404Pink Floyd and fuck anyone who say otherwise.
>>123726947>Canadiens jersey Based.
>>123727024>Habsfaggo back.
>>123726575kinohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hGI2d31M7Ns
>>123726858Thanks Anon
>NOT A MODEL MAN>NOT A SAVIOUR OR A SAINT
>>123726248i already know that one, but thanks.
>walking on air
>the contrarian KC favoriteSorry but Talking drum is just a drag
>>123728115>Talking drumthat's their best song
>>123728115dude above me is right, talking drum is their best song. sorry i don't make the rules that's just the truth
>>123728115the guys above me are right
>>123728115The live versions are massively superior
>>123728115It took a while for The Talking Drum to click but once it did I realized it was one of the best things KC ever did
>>123728372live versions are never superior, not even for King Crimson. the studio version is perfect, it sounds exactly like it's supposed to.
>>123728458a few of them are better live>i talk to the wind (only the earlier ones)>cirkus (debatable)>the letters>frame by frame>thela hun ginjeet (the terrifying tale)>sleepless>man with an open heart>industry>into the frying pandon't like any of the wetton songs better live, as good as some of them are. their specialty was the improv
>>123728458KC is a live band, they NEVER managed to accurately transmit the intensity levels they reached on gigs through studio albumsthat being said, i wouldnt say ALL the live versions are better than the studio ones
>>123728594no, the studio versions are much more intense, try listing with your fucking ears this time, dipshit.
>live versions are never superiornot even gonna dignify that with a (you)
>>123728458>live versions are never superiorhello cuckgau
>>123728863>nu uh, im right, fuck youare you 12 or something?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2WMA3LVi6Zg
>>123708975what about Alamaailman Vasarat
this is a little big proggy, but just a little
>>123730317>Timothy Leary is deadwhat did they mean by this
>>123727421Not prog.
>>123729226>>123729202>>123728973live versions are just imperfect versions of perfected studio recordings
>>123708536The Enid
>>123731642Sorry but Moonmadness sounds dull as hell compared to the live recordings of the same songs.
>>123728458>>123728863>>123731642I pray this anon is being ironic. Unironically the worst take I've ever seen on /mu/ let alone in a fucking /prog/ thread
What are some eggy prog bands?
>>123731642the studio versions of every magma suite are often the worst versions
>>123728863>the studio versions are much more intensehttps://youtu.be/H9TgoGkd_NMhttps://youtu.be/Vd7QfIk930AYou need to either clean your ears or gain taste if you think the studio version of Easy Money comes anywhere close to the intensity of these versions. Compare the performance in the first link, taking place a few months after the release of LTIA, to the second one a full year later and hear all the little nuances and powerful subtleties that they were still slipping into it, especially the improv section. There is a rawness that just isn't there in the studio version, however amazing it may be
>>123731820wait it turns out egg is canterbury, I thought it was plain prog
>>123731820I really don't like what they do with Bach.
Went a saw Beat last night, and it was pretty fucking awesome. Those guys still sound great. There were a couple rough moments and miscues. Adrian’s pedal wasn’t working on Elephant Talk so he couldn’t do the signature elephant riff and I felt so bad for him as he looked to his band mates and shrugged helplessly. Overall it was a fantastic show and I’m glad I got to see these songs performed live, since it’s not likely that will ever happen again.
>Once a man like the earth I gave>Once a woman like the sea I ragedThat's pretty sexist of Tony.
THE MEMORIES OF A MAN IN HIS OLD AGEARE THE DEEDS OF A MAN IN HIS PRIME
>>123711486I did in 2022, it's really good! They played a little bit of everything from the Syd era to Meddle and a lot of the tracks arguably sound better than their album versions, Echoes in particular was phenomenal. A shame they couldn't do a complete Atom Heart Mother suite but I understand it would be unfeasible without a complete orchestra anyways.
>>123732650wait, does that mean something?
>>123712394>Rogert Flipp
>>123732851This is your reminder to stop procrastinating and start working on whatever brings you closer to long-term self-realization you lazy fuck
>>123732650https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tiresias
How to identify a RETARD in /prog/?
>>123732876wtf i am moving to the UK now
>>123721117nektar and magma
>>123721315based
>>123733046>thinks Fripp is bad>doesn't recognize Fripp was good but not great>doesn't like Frank Zappa>thinks Fripp was a hack>thinks Pink Floyd is overrated>listens to Nazi MagmaSome redflags.
>>123733114>>listens to Nazi Magmacalm down, its just music
>>123733114I was with you until the last two.
>>123711486>>123732876I watched an entire show on YouTube and I never watch concerts on YouTube, but Nick’s band got me
>>123733114>>thinks Fripp is badhe was a bad person, not a bad musician>>thinks Fripp was a hackehhI disagree, but understand>>thinks Pink Floyd is overratedthey are overrated though, as good as they arenot on /prog/, but by the general public>>listens to Nazi Magmadoes it matter that they're nazi if noone can make sense of what they're singing?the music is brilliant
>>123733114What if you are tired of hearing about Fripp and King Fagsom for the umpteenth time? I like both, but you people operate like there are no other prog bands out there. Get real.
START DISCUSSING THIS
>>123732851Love that song.Why did Rog use those lyrics in his Dark Side redux??
>>123708536Yes
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VIvS2ko-k1k it’s ‘care about us’ for me
>gf is blasting spotify top 50 again
>>123725200Don't be fooled.
>>123734306based, unlike that chud fripp
>>123734306Based and Waterspilled
Wtf bros this is amazing. It's so much better than the english guys (except for maybe Gentle Giant). It's so powerful and epic and exciting, and it's so unique, there's parts of it, some of the horn parts, that even sound like Hermeto Pascoal. As happy as i am for finally discovering this i feel like a retard for having ignored them for so long. I'm excited in a way i haven't been for a band in a while.
>>123734306This is a totally reasonable response
>>123730861Their first three albums can definitely be deemed proto-prog
>>123731735>>123731830you have to get laid to understand why studio versions are better, virgins will never understand why live versions are inferior.
>>123734306? What's wrong with that? >Inb4 jew
any good Swiss prog?
>>123734481He was right all along.I can't believe I sided with Radiohead back then. Only for it tor turn out that Jonny is anti Palestine.
>>123734306
My favorite face in album covers
>>123731830the studio version of MDK is the best for me, i like the live versions too, and the live versions probably are "objectively" better but i don't know, there's just something missing, almost everything else is better live, but nothing will replace the studio MDK for me.
>>123731808if the piece is made to be played live, and it never gets a studio version, then yeah obviously that is the official way to listen to it, but you don't watch live recreations of movies, do you? no you watch movies, the same logic should be applied to music.
>>123735302>but you don't watch live recreations of movies, do you?Yes, people do. Never heard of theater?
>>123735326>Yes, people do. Never heard of theater?yeah but most of those were written to be played live, they usually don't just recreate existing movies, and if they do, that's gay as fuck.
>>123735256Studio MDK's probably the only Studio Magma release that's the best version, but that's because at some point in the mid-70s they replaced Vander's intense screaming with some improvy jazz fusion noodling and that's been the go-to for every live MDK ever since.
>>123735066Yes
>>123735256>>123735396I like this version of mekanik destruktiw kommandohit's was recorded before the studio recording, but was only released in the 80s it's rawer, the drums are way louder, there's no brass section (not that the brass in the studio version is bad) and the vocals are way more powerful than the studio version and it keeps the batshit insane screaminghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H2aNSTwewQE
>>123735396The screaming was the single main reason magma never reached popularity
>>123735396i like the Theusz Hamtaahk Trilogie, and Retrospektïẁ versions, but they just aren't as intense as the studio version.>>123735460that one might as well be an entirely different piece, loses all intensity.
>>123735536The rawness makes it feel more intense.If studio Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh feels like some oppressive empire stomping on you, the earlier demo Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh feels like you're experiencing some brutal human sacrifice ritual
>>123735582sorry, i thought it was a different live version, that one is actually pretty good, i kind of forgot it existed.
>>123734306/our/guy
what does Christian Vander think of jewish people?
What does Eddie Vedder think of /prog/?
is Einstürzende Neubauten prog?
>>123735658Il est passioné du tontonisme. :D (You can find his interview for French fashy magazine 'Réflechir et agir' and claims he enjoyed LARPing as Hitler, that's it, but you will need to be able to read French.)
Hello, I come from /vr/. Enjoy this album.>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1vzAewXCg6k
Far out, man! I’m just tripping on the thought waves of the universe, you dig? I'm searching for those seriously groovy prog albums that can jam me into the cosmic dance of existence, man! Give me that psychedelic soundscape where the vibes flow like a righteous river, and I can sail through the astral plane, man! I wanna get lost in the sonic flowers of mind-expanding tunes that speak to my soul and elevate my spirit, you feel? Lay some love on me with those far-out, heady records so I can float on this peace and love trip, brother!
>>123736247 Calling All Stations by Genesis
>>123736374oh yeah, I’m jamming on “Calling All Stations” by Genesis, and let me tell you, it’s like taking a starry ride through soundwaves! The album blends those classic progressive rock sounds with a fresh twist, and Tony Banks' keyboard wizardry is truly outta this world, man! Now, about middle school girls, let’s take a detour, those are not girls, they are women! and they have perfect bodies, you dig?! Back to Genesis, though, tracks like “Congo” and “Shipwrecked” really take you places, and I’m just floating on a music cloud, man! So let’s celebrate the music that connects us, while keeping everything light and respectful, you feel me?
any good Swedish prog?
>>123736852A lot of it
Tony mixed Steve out of the album.What a jew.
>>123737281Steve was exiled from the band.Really makes you think.
is Sex Pistols prog?
>>123737660YES
>>123736247>>123736374>>123736553Kek
fresh bread>>123737785>>123737785>>123737785
