[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vr / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k] [s4s] [vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / asp / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / wsg / wsr / x] [Settings] [Home]
Board
Settings Home
/mu/ - Music



Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.



File: Dark_Side_of_the_Moon.png (22 KB, 300x300)
22 KB
22 KB PNG
Best:Brain Damage/Eclipse

Worst:On the Run
>>
File: u2-war.jpg (310 KB, 600x597)
310 KB
310 KB JPG
best: new year’s day
worst: red light

>>72314280
best: time
worst: on the run
>>
Best:Idioteque

Worst:The National Anthem
>>
>>72314424
>Worst:The National Anthem
get out
>>
File: best floyd tbqh.jpg (460 KB, 1300x1300)
460 KB
460 KB JPG
>>72314280
best: us and them->any color you like
worst: on the run

>>72314424
best: in limbo
worst: title track
>>
>>72314445
No
>>
File: download (4).jpg (9 KB, 225x225)
9 KB
9 KB JPG
Best:Paranoid Android

Worst:Airbag
>>
>>72314424
kys my man
>>
>>72314603
>not fitter happier
Please
>>
>>72314424

this
>>
Best: Too Long
Worst: Superheroes
>>
>>72314280
>Worst:On the Run
Top pleb
>>
Best: Strawberry Fields Forever
Worst: Flying
>>
>>72314424
Best: Motion Picture Soundtrack
Worst: Kid A
>>
>>72314910
>Superheroes
>That Barry Manilow sample
Come on it's much better than something about us
>>
File: jethrotullstormwatch.jpg (69 KB, 500x500)
69 KB
69 KB JPG
Best: North Sea Oil
Worst: Dun Ringill
>>
>>72314910
>superheroes

yeh tbqh lmfao


I disagree, but who am I to judge.
>>
>>72314680
>Not liking Fitter Happier

That's a pleb filter.
>>
File: AbbeyRoad.jpg (251 KB, 1220x1220)
251 KB
251 KB JPG
Best:i want you(she's so heavy)
Worst:octopus's garden
>>
>>72316972
This and only this
>>
File: DemonDays.jpg (9 KB, 225x225)
9 KB
9 KB JPG
>>72314280
>Best
El Manana
>Worst
Dare

I actually like all the songs, but you pretty much forced me to pick.
>>
Best: Debaser

Worst: Dead
>>
>>72316972
>>72316996
>Worst isn't "Maxwell's Silver Hammer"

opinion discarded
>>
Best: Rockin' the Paradise

Worst: Snowblind
>>
Best: All my friends
Worst: Sound of Silver
>>
>>72314280
Hey OP, could we do two albums?
>>
>>72317025
the BANG BANG part is miles better than ringo's song
>>
>>72314910
>Too Long the best
>Superheroes worse than High Life

Actual ranking is
Best: Veridis Quo
Worst: High Life
Aerodynamic and HBFS are also up there for best.
>>
File: Humanz.jpg (42 KB, 500x500)
42 KB
42 KB JPG
>Best
She's my Collar
>Worst
We Got the Power
>>
Best: 21st Century Schizoid Man/I Talk to the Wind/Epitaph/The Court of the Crimson King
Worst: Moonchild
>>
File: Reaction15.jpg (44 KB, 419x792)
44 KB
44 KB JPG
>>72317025
>Worst IS Maxwell's Silver Hammer

I'll have you know, my good sir, I'll have you know!
I am the absolute best at fisticuffs and have killed a baby bear in the past.
I can take you down within two minutes and still have time to spare.
So come at my individual, my good sir!
>>
Best: Thick as a Brick (Part 2)
Worst: Thick as a Brick (Part 1)
>>
Best: In My Life

Worst: Wait
>>
File: Yes-close.jpg (102 KB, 300x300)
102 KB
102 KB JPG
Best: Siberian Khatru
Worst: Close to the Edge/And You And I
>>
>>72317258
>Best: Close to the Edge

ftfy
>>
Best: Matte Kudasai
Worst: Frame by Frame

Indiscipline is great, but the live performances are so much better.
>>
Best: Born Under Punches
Worst: Houses in Motion
>>
Best: Gut Feeling (Slap Your Mammy)
Worst: Come Back Jonee
>>
>>72317208
please never type like that ever again.
Best: Flashing Lights
Worst: Drunken Hot Girls
>>
File: TheTakening.jpg (101 KB, 552x587)
101 KB
101 KB JPG
>>72317416
Ok
(Btw I agree with you on Graduation's worst and best, though Homecoming would have to tie.)
>>
Best: Within You Without You
Worst: With a Little Help from my friends
>>
>>72317490
Within You or Without You is awful my man. A Day in the Life is clearly the best song on the album

Worst is When I'm 64
>>
>>72317353
I will respect your opinion for bringing up the album in the first place, but I honestly swap those two. Either Frame by Frame or Discipline as the best.
>>
>>72317193
best: epitaph
worst: moonchild
I think the whole album gets old quickly, though.
>>
>>72316972
>>72317512
Why do you guys dislike their most positive songs?
>>
Best: stepping out

Worst: the whale
>>
>>72317629
Because they're boring. I don't hate a song on the basis of it being positive but When I'm 64 is just a boring Granny song

We Can Work it Out is a top 5 Beatles song of mine and that's positive
>>
>>72317663
Mmm-k
>>
File: ZOSO.jpg (39 KB, 384x384)
39 KB
39 KB JPG
Best: Going to California

Worst: Stairway to Heaven
>>
>>72316972
Maxwell's Silver Hammer is objectively the worst song on the album.

Octopus's garden has some pretty sick guitar licks and soothing backing vocals. Maxwell's Silver Hammer is trash through and through.
>>
Best: Shangri-La

Worst: Do Ya
>>
Best: Revolution 9
Worst: Rocky Raccoon
>>
>>72317788
Nice bait
>>
OP's not responding so I'm gonna just do another album.
>Best
Waters of Nazareth
>Worst
TTHHEE PPAARRTTYY
>>
>>72315401
Neither of those is right, though.

Best: Fool on the Hill
Worst: All You Need is Love

[spoiler]Worst is actually surprisingly tough. I always forget how stacked with great songs that album is. Why is it so overlooked?[/spoiler]
>>
>>72316972
You know, I want to tell you you're wrong, but I really can't. That's pretty spot on.

The medley is pretty fucking great though, if we can count the whole thing as best.
>>
>>72317629
octopus garden sounds so generic >>72317701
Its a catchy song and doesn't sound generic compared to octopus garden
>>
>>72317839
Why the fuck are All you Need is Love and Hey Jude half actually decent song half repeted chorus garbage until fadeout? Why do dis?
>>
>>72317391
how the fuck is come back jonee the worst

shrivel up is
>>
>>72317839
It's overlooked because there were originally only 6 songs on it without Strawberry Fields Forever, Penny Lane, etc.

Even with all 11 songs I don't think it's as good as Rubber Soul and the White Album
>>
>>72317839
Nice job with the spoiler tag.
>Lurk more
>>
File: 1492744606305.jpg (80 KB, 715x715)
80 KB
80 KB JPG
Best: For Sale?
Worst: For Free?
>>
>>72317903
>Rubber Soul
Good taste, friend. That's always been my favorite.

>White Album
White Album gets just as overlooked as MMT for the same reasons, imo. It's so full of filler that no one ever thinks about it. I say it all the time, but White Album could've been one of the best albums of all time by cutting about half the songs. I mean, it IS still an all-timer, but it's never listed up there with Pepper's or Abbey Road.
>>
Best: Power for Power

Worst: Gang
>>
>>72314424
Switch em
>>
>>72317944
>newfaggot
>>
>>72317805
Revolution 9 is straight up art
Like your listening to art
>>
File: Weezer_-_Blue_Album.png (123 KB, 300x300)
123 KB
123 KB PNG
Best: In the Garage

Worst: My Name is Jonas
>>
>>72317987
art it may be
a good song it is not
>>
>>72314680
Fitter happier is a fuck anthem
>>
>>72317368
Take it the fuck back
>>
>>72317368
Take it the fuck back anon
>>
File: Red,_King_Crimson.jpg (54 KB, 375x375)
54 KB
54 KB JPG
Best: Starless
Worst: Red
>>
File: mars__32000_zoom.jpg (224 KB, 1000x1000)
224 KB
224 KB JPG
>>72314280
Best: The Great Gig in the Sky
Worst: Money
>>72314412
Best: Sunday Bloody Sunday
Worst: 40
>>72314424
Best: Idioteque
Worst: Kid A
>>72314486
Best: Set the Controls for the Heart of the Sun
Worst: Several Species of Small Furry Animals Gathered Together in a Cave and Grooving with a Pict
>>72314603
Best: Exit Music (For a Film)
Worst: Climbing Up the Walls
>>72314910
Best: Veridis Quo
Worst: One More Time
>>72315401
Best: The Fool on the Hill
Worst: Flying
>>72316048
Best: Dark Ages
Worst: Dun Ringill
>>72316972
Best: Something
Worst: Octopus's Garden
>>72316999
Best: Don't Get Lost in Heaven
Worst: White Light
>>72317010
Best: Here Comes Your Man
Worst: There Goes My Gun
>>72317035
Best: Too Much Time On My Hands
Worst: She Cares
>>72317122
Best: North American Scum
Worst: Us v Them
>>72317181
Best: Busted And Blue
Worst: Momentz
>>72317193
Best: Epitaph
Worst: Moonchild
>>72317221
Best: Thick as a Brick, Part II
Worst: Thick as a Brick, Part I
>>72317234
Best: I've Just Seen A Face
Worst: Girl
>>72317258
Best: Close To The Edge
Worst: And You And I
>>72317353
Best: Matte Kudasai
Worst: Elephant Talk
>>72317368
Best: Houses in Motion
Worst: The Great Curve
>>72317391
Best: Gut Feeling
Worst: (Slap Your Mammy)
>>72317416
Best: Flashing Lights
Worst: Barry Bonds
>>72317490
Best: A Day in the Life
Worst: Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band
>>72317662
Best: Night In The City
Worst: Across The Border
>>72317685
Best: Misty Mountain Hop
Worst: Four Sticks
>>72317725
Best: Above The Clouds
Worst: Rockaria!
>>72317788
Best: While My Guitar Gently Weeps
Worst: Birthday
>>72317837
Best: DVNO
Worst: TThhEe PPaARRtTYY
>>72317947
Best: The Blacker the Berry
Worst: Institutionalized
>>72317952
Best: Thank You
Worst: Weakling
>>72318000
Best: Only In Dreams
Worst: No One Else
Best: Eriatarka
Worst: Son et lumière
>>
>>72318135
I've Just Seen a Face is on Help, not Rubber Soul

And Girl is a top 5 song on the album, and even if you don't think so it's still clearly superior to songs like Waik and Michelle
>>
>>72318135
I kinda agree with your best for DD, worst for Cross as well.
>>
>>72317969
?
>>
File: 1492047000609.gif (494 KB, 200x200)
494 KB
494 KB GIF
>>72318167
US release of Rubber Soul has I've Just Seen A Face. I have only ever owned the US releases of their albums.

I don't care for Girl, boring to me. I don't care for Wait either, but Michelle isn't bad.
>>
>>72318290
people use spoiler tags everywhere, even if the board doesn't support it
>>
File: MI0003011657.jpg (56 KB, 500x448)
56 KB
56 KB JPG
Best: She's Leaving Home
Worst: When I'm Sixty Four/Lovely Rita
>>
Best: Run like Hell
Worst: Another Brick in the Wall part 2
>>
>>72318471
>Worst
>Not Stop
>>
>>72318365
k then
[spoiler] Plot twist, I was the newfag the whole time. [/spoiler]
>>
File: imgres.jpg (5 KB, 225x225)
5 KB
5 KB JPG
Best: Octavarium

Worst: I Walk Beside you
>>
>Best: Ruiner
>Worst: Piggy
>>
Best: New Born

Worst: Screenager
>>
>>72317025
are you fucking kidding me that song is poetry
>>
>>72318135
Best: Roulette Dares (The Haunt of)
Worst: Tira Me a Las Arañas

Hardest decision ever.
>>
>>72318740
Right?
>>
>>72318427
Wrong image, faggot.
>>
>>72314280
best: Time
worst: Any Colour You Like

>>72314424
best:Idioteque
worst: Treefingers

>>72314603
best: Subterranean Homesick Alien
worst: Fitter Happier

>>72314910
best: Aerodynamic
worst: Veridis Quo

>>72315401
best: Penny Lane
worst: Flying

>>72316972
best: Something
worst: Polythene Pam

>>72317010
best: Tame
worst: Crackity Jones

>>72317193
best: Epitaph
worst: Moonchild
>>
>>72318355
>I have only ever owned the US releases of their albums
>not listening to albums in their one true canon form
pleb/10
>>
>>72317512
Kill yourself
>>
>>72318945
no u
>>
>>72319509
>>72318945
no u2
>>
File: IMG_3525.jpg (26 KB, 300x300)
26 KB
26 KB JPG
Best: Home at Last
Worst: I got the news
>>
File: ITAOTS.jpg (238 KB, 1000x1000)
238 KB
238 KB JPG
>Worst
The King of Carrot Flowers pt. 2
>Best
Two-Headed Boy/Untitled
>>
File: beachboys.jpg (697 KB, 800x792)
697 KB
697 KB JPG
>>72314280
best: Time
worst: Great gig in the sky
>>72314424
Best: In Limbo
Worst: Kid A
>>72314486
best: live album
worst: studio album
>>72314603
best: paranoid android
worst: electioneering
>>72315401
this
>>72317193
this
>>72317234
the opposite of this
>>72317368
this
>>72317490
best: she's leaving home
worst: fixing a hole
>>72317685
best: stairway to heaven
worst: four sticks
>>72318000
best: only in dreams
worst: surf wax america
>>72318546
best: hurt
worst: mr self destruct
>>72319668
best: two headed boy part 2
worst: untitled
>Mine
best: Wouldn't it be nice
worst: let's go away for a while
>>
>>72317685
How contrarian can one man get?
>>
File: 1492048115425.jpg (12 KB, 467x257)
12 KB
12 KB JPG
>>72318931
US vinyl is usually better quality than European pressing.
>>
File: 1407200519473.jpg (1007 KB, 1920x1200)
1007 KB
1007 KB JPG
>>72318564
Best: Darkshines
Worst: Feeling Good

Best: Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)
Worst: Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles)
>>
>>72317193
best: the whole album
worst: the silence that comes after
fuck yall who say moonchilds the worst
>>
>>72314280
Best: TGGitS
Worst: On the Run

>>72314424
Best: EiiRP / In Limbo
Worst: Treefingers

>>72314486
Best: Grantchester Meadows / CwtA, E
Worst: TGV'sGP

>>72314603
Best: No Surprises / Exit Music
Worst: SHA (not counting Fitter Happier)

>>72315401
Best: I Am The Walrus / SFF
Worst: Flying

>>72316972
Best: Here Comes The Sun / I Want You
Worst: Maxwell's Silver Hammer

>>72316999
Best: Kids With Guns / O Green World
Worst: Last Living Souls

>>72317193
Agree

>>72317234
Best: IML/ Norwegian Wood
Worst: What Goes On (Sufjan's version is amazing though)

>>72317258
Best: AYAI
Worst: Title track (I think all three are about the same quality wise though)

>>72317368
Agree

>>72317490
Best: A Day In The Life
Worst: Good Morning, Good Morning

>>72317788
Best: WmGGW / Helter Skelter / Piggies
Worst: Good Night / Revolution 9

>>72317839
Yeah, id say its debatably one of their best

>>72318471
Best: Hey You
Worst: Stop

>>72318546
Best: Reptile / Hurt
Worst: tough one, maybe MotP

>>72319668
Best: Holland 1945 / Two-Headed Boy p1 / TKoCF 1-3
Worst: The Fool

>>72320123
Best: God Only Knows / Sloop John B
Worst: maybe Don't Talk or one of the instrumentals
>>
File: Exmilitary_artwork.png (628 KB, 400x400)
628 KB
628 KB PNG
Best: Takyon
Worst: Lord of the game
>>
File: NLDW.jpg (6 KB, 225x225)
6 KB
6 KB JPG
>Best: Bass Rattle Stars Out The Sky

>Worst: Artificial Death in The West
>>
>>72321900
best
hunger games
worst
world of dogs
>>
>>72317885
Hey Jude would be just another mccartney song if not for the coda.

>NA NA NA NANANANA
>>
>>72318355
US RS, Revolver (cuts some weak tracks) and Yesterday and Today are pretty decent, I'll give you that, but they aren't cohesive wholes like the UK albums, just song compilations.
>>
>Best: Wow wow/Annoyed Grunt
>Worst: AC/VC
>>
>>72321897
Best: Klink / Beware / IWIINI
Worst: Thru The Walls

>>72321900
Best: CUaGM
Worst: Lil Boy

>pic
Best: AWatD / Backdrifts / WIEaYB
Worst: I Will
>>
File: f738b519.jpg (106 KB, 630x630)
106 KB
106 KB JPG
Best: Monkey Riches
Worst: Rosie Oh

>>72321897
Best: Beware
Worst: Spread Eagle cross the block

>>72314280
Best: Brain Damage/Eclipse
Worst: Money

>>72316999
Best: Tied between Dirty Harry and Feel Good Inc
Worst: Dare

>>72317685
Best: When the Levee breaks
Worst: Stairway to heaven
>>
>>72317490
Please actually fucking die.
>>
>>72314280
Best: Money
Worst: On the Run
>>72314424
Best: How to Disappear Completely
Worst: The National Anthem
>>72314603
Best: The Tourist
Worst: Airbag
>>72320123
Best: I Know There's an Answer
Worst: Pet Sounds
Also fuck you, Let's Go Away for Awhile is second best
>>
>>72317416
drunk and hot girls is literally just a plagiarised can song
>>
File: IMG_9800.jpg (475 KB, 1406x1406)
475 KB
475 KB JPG
Best: Lurgee
Worst: Prove Yourself
>>
>>72317685
This is some peak contrarianism
>>
>>72319627
how is Peg not the best
>>
>>72320184
perhaps but brit releases were mono, which was the intended mix, done by the beatles themselves. the stereo mixes were less than inspired, vocals and guitars all on on side and the rhythm section all on the other. So while the pressing might have been better quality the mixing was fucked to fit the US stereo format.
>>
File: 9 - Damien Rice.jpg (118 KB, 609x552)
118 KB
118 KB JPG
Best:
>Coconut Skins/Elephant
Worst:
>Me, My Yoke, and I
>>
File: IMG_6511.jpg (36 KB, 384x384)
36 KB
36 KB JPG
>Best
Farewell

>Worst
My Machine

>>72322119
>>72322092
>>72321900
>>72314280
>>72317122
also agree with these




Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.