Rank `em
Sonic 1, Crash Bandicoot, N/A
>>724503327crash 1, sonic 1, smb1
>>724503327Crash's physics and level design are dogshit
>>724503653SPBP. Unlike the other two, Crash 1 still holds up compared to its sequels.
>>724503327Sonic > Crash > Super MarioThese are all good games.Also, I think dismissing the first Sonic game just because Sonic 2 is better is highly retarded.
>>724503327Super Mario Bros. >>>>> Sonic > Crash Bandicoot
>>724504943Sonic 2 is an abortion
>>724505719Why?
>>724503327>compare apples to oranges to grapesNo.
>>724505775Terrible level design made either to railroad you or punish you for going fast. The last third can't even be considered a functioning video game.
>>724505809>apples or Led Zeppelin IV
>>724505809Nobody is asking you to objectively evaluate these games. Merely which one do you like the most.>>724505916I can see that.
>>724503327Crash 1 > Sonic 1 > SMB 1
Crash was a 3D rails tech demo.
>>724503327The original Mario trilogy doesn't hold up at all. Last place against any of the Sonic/Crash trilogy games. Now if you had World or the New Soup games vs post- trilogy Sonic/Crash it might actually be a tough choice.
>>724503327>God TierSonic 2, Crash 2, Mario 3, Mario 4>High TierSonic 3, Crash 3, Crash 4>Mid TierSonic 1, Crash 1, Mario 2 (US)>Shit tierSonic 4, Mario 2 (JP)Wrath of Cortex was known as Crash 4 in Japan. It's also shit tier.
>>724507618>Sonic 2 higher than 3 and 1Explain
>>724503327Sonic 1 > SMB1 > Crash 1
>>724507730The entire post is the default opinion. He doesn't know why it's that way, he just parrots the norm.
>>724505916>punish you for going fastgoing fast is a reward for good gameplay, not a de facto state
>>724503327Mario 1 >>>> Sonic 1 >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Crash 1
They're already in order.
>>724507730Sonic 3&K is bloated in content and has garbage pacing.In Sonic 2, I felt like the game was working towards an epic climax: Metropolis -> Sky Chase -> Wing Fortress -> Death EggBeacuse Sonic 3&K was split into two, it had one fake climax in the middle (Launch Base/Big Arm).I remember feeling extremely underwhelmed as a kid with Launch Base in vanilla 3. It was nowhere near as epic as Sonic 2's endgame.Then came the Knuckles part, and Sonic 3&K did have an epic conclusion with Lava Reef -> Hidden Temple -> Sky Sanctuary -> Death Egg -> Doomsday.However, I still feel the Launch Base -> Mushroom Hill transition was awkward and anitclimatic. Probably because I beat vanilla Sonic 3 so many times.
>>724507857Really? I though I was alone in ranking Crash 4 as high as the original trilogy,
Crash 1 > SMB1 > Sonic 1Crash 2 > SMB2 (USA) = Sonic 2 > SMB2 (JP)Sonic 3 (& Knuckles) > SMB 3 > Crash 3Whatever game you want to think is SMB4 > Crash 4 > Sonic 4 (Ep 2 is alright, Ep 1/Metal suck)
>>724503327Sonic > Mario > CrashNot only the games. This is also the general ranking
SMB > Crash 1 > Sonic 1SMB is still an all-time classic, Crash is a very fun game whose only flaw is invalidated by the existence of savestates/N-sane trilogySonic 1 is just blegh, once you beat GHZ, the game is a slog.
>>724503327crash > haven't played > haven't played
>>724503327Sonic 1 is the best of the 3.Crash 2 is the best of the SequelsSonic 3 is the best of the 3rd games.
