[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/y/ - Yaoi

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • There are 57 posters in this thread.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor applications are now closed. Thank you to everyone who applied!


[Advertise on 4chan]


How come this board is called /yaoi/ and not /bara/? Whenever someone posts twink or trap jannies take it down and retards fill up the thread with meltdowns, even tho most yaoi has one or the other.

Doesn’t make sense me thinks.
>>
>>2991668
And before you say
>traps belong on /d/
Yeah but they belong here too if you don’t like them then just scroll past it and don’t enlarge the image. That’s what I do when I see fetish stuff I don’t wanna see like piss.
>>
>>2991669
And the rules on what’s an acceptable masculine twink and what’s a trap on this board are really unclear is picrel okay? Or is it too feminine?
>>
>>2991670
How about this one the rules say no dickgirls but yes clearly drawn with pectorals and before you say
>no boobless dickgirks
A human being with a penis and without boobs is male
>>
>>2991671
Last but not least how come feminine men are okay once they’re muscular? When someone posts like picrel nobody complains all the sudden.
>>
>>2991669
>Yeah but they belong here too
That's not for you or me to decide, the rules say they don't belong and until they're changed that will be the case.
>>2991670
What is a trap may vary depending on who you ask, especially considering that different artists may draw the same character in different ways, but something like OP's pic is clearly a boobless woman, look at that face and hand that's beyond just being a feminine guy, even Astolfo looks more like a man than that, that's stepping on Boku no Pico territory without having the shota excuse.
>>2991672
I don't see anything feminine in that pic just a weird face, but to answer your question muscles usually make them look less feminine, but again it depends on the artist.
I also disagree with this idea that muscles = bara, to me bara are muscles taken to an extreme and fat hairy guys, that kind of style. That said, yaoi is usually used as an all encompassing term, the board doesn't exclude anything not mentioned in the rules.
Lastly, I don't get people complaining about too much bara, you can find twinks and more feminine men in the board, just looking at the catalog you can see some pics used in OPs and you'll also find them across various threads, but if you can't find what you can you can always post it yourself as long as it's not against the rules.
>>
>>2991672
Anyways sorry to be a humongous bore & please don’t freak out this isn’t a bait thread I just want to enjoy my yaoi and all aspects of it including the twinks and traps without having to go to /d/ and sift thru giants getting fucked by bugs and shit like that lol
>>
>>2991673
A boobless adult human with a penis is a man
big hip + hairless + anime face ≠ woman
>>
>>2991675
Sorry but the first image looks like a flat chested girl. If there’s a dick, you can’t even see it, and the text doesn’t even hint that it’s a boy. And there’s been plenty of twink threads here — the fanart of other charas you’ve shared can be found in fandom threads. Just lurk moar.
>>
>>2991668
Long time gay poster here
Because trannies unironically weaponized traps/femboys. They intentionally seek out twinks in social circles and encourage them to either transition or hop on e to retain a youthful feminine appearance. Masculine gays/tops don't want this since majority of them prefer twinks and /pol/ also doesn't want this since a weak frail male is a perfect individual to radicalize. This sounds like schizo talk but it unironically happens a lot in echo chambers like Discord, group chats, card shops ect.

"Egg
Trans slang for a person who hasn't realized they're trans yet. Usually they show telltale behavior of a trans person despite not knowing, like 'ironically' crossdressing or writing shitty fanfiction about trans people. The word comes from the idea that they haven't "cracked out of their shell", like an egg."

https://www.reddit.com/r/egg_irl/

Basically crossdressing/looking feminine gives them an excuse to gaslight you repeatedly into transitioning fully, even if it was just a fetish like it has been historically and is the reason why it now causes so much discourse in the homosexual community. Fuck, look at /lgbt/ right now and you'll see that gays are confined to /gaygen/ now, anyone else not there jumped ship years ago and migrated to /fit/ unironically.
>>
>>2991673
>Astolfo looks more like a man
No
>>
>>2991673
>Astolfo
You sure senpai?
>>
>>2991715
Same shit
>>
>>2991720
If you're a str8oid coombrain maybe
>>
File: asttt.jpg (389 KB, 1920x1080)
389 KB
389 KB JPG
>>2991718
>>2991713
in the anime Astolfo has the body structure of a guy. it's the fanart that makes him look really really girly

>>2991696
yeah its the trannies trying to psyop people into liking their deformity, I thought it was a meme but it is real

also they are delusional thinking hormones will make them "retain youthfulness" or whatever, women dont age well and trannies age worse.
>>
File: Bye tranny.png (1.7 MB, 1920x1080)
1.7 MB
1.7 MB PNG
>>2991735
Wow, one out-of-context screenshot where he doesn't look like a flat futa. Sure showed us.
>>
>>2991691
>>2991696
>>2991749
holy shit take your medication

>muh trans conspiracy
this isn't /v/
>>
File: 1670645456596770.jpg (122 KB, 650x780)
122 KB
122 KB JPG
>>2991757
(You) first
>>
>>2991713
>>2991749
>>2991761
I'm the anon you first replied to. I didn't say he looks like a man in a vacuum, I said he looks more like a man than that guy in OP's pic , a comparison to point out that in no way that person in OP's pic looks like a guy no matter how much you stretch the definition.
>>2991718
See above.
>>2991675
I'm don't want to get into this kind of argument again, I already did in another thread, so I'll just say that just like what is or isn't a trap may vary depending on who you ask, the same is true in this case and to me that looks like a woman, not even a very feminine guy for the reasons I pointed out previously. If you mean biologically though, no boobs + penis isn't enough, if you don't have the rest of the male reproductive system inside your body you're not a man.
>>
>>2991749
yes I did show you, you're a memebrained dumbass

he looks exactly the same in the whole show, its called being on-model
>>
>>2991668
Bara its totally irrelevant outside this board (Myreadingmanga doesn't count).
You will never see people losing their shit over a "masculine/bishonen" character and even If the character its not that androgynous artists are going to make him look more girly anyways.
You literally should never care about this board, barafags are the most powerless niche ever and trapshit its everywhere.
>>
>>2991766
Only a few people constantly scream about traps, there's plenty of non-bara content in the board, plenty of different flavors for everyone. Truth is, most people who come here don't give a shit about these discussions, they just want to see porn they like and ignore what they don't like just like in every other place on the internet.
>>
File: 1670647869750506.jpg (739 KB, 1598x2260)
739 KB
739 KB JPG
>>2991762
>>2991764
That's not a man, this is. You're just memebrained.
>>
File: 1670641304788801.png (1.27 MB, 1433x2024)
1.27 MB
1.27 MB PNG
>>2991766
Aren't you the one going around every thread with this copypasta? Saying how everyone who doesn't like your tranny garbage is "lusting over neo-nazis" while typing racist remarks like it's 2016?
>>2991767
I wouldn't care if these fucking Karens learned to follow the fucking rules. Traps fall under strangegay and lean into shota territory. They don't fucking belong here.
>>
>>2991671
>>2991672
Honestly I think you just showcased the problem right there. Traps/femboys typically have a specific body type in porn. Small waist, wide hips/thighs, chest/nipples that look like small boobs. The people calling traps flat futas aren't wrong, that's usually exactly how they're drawn. There's a clear difference in body types between the two images you use as examples, and it's not just the muscle. I think traps can be drawn to have more masculine bodies, it's just rare to see art like that. Also it's just kinda obvious to me that a good portion of people who like men won't be attracted to characters who are supposed to pass as teenage girls.
>>
File: 1570064387224.jpg (397 KB, 1686x2411)
397 KB
397 KB JPG
>>2991668
>jannies
Jannies would actually delete stuff, what you see are faggots who don't make the cut even for being jannies raising a shitstorm whenever they see something they don't like.
>>
>>2991776
>look like boobs
go through this fucking board and take a shot every time you see ridiculous man boobs drawn on "gay" porn
you will die from alcohol poisoning

>le flat futa
Id tell you to take your meds but you shouldn't mix these kinds of pills with alcohol
>>
>>2991769
>They don't fucking belong here.
I know anon and I agree, but those discussions are pointless, all we can do is report and hope the jannies do their job.
>>
>>2991769
>Saying how everyone who doesn't like your tranny garbage is "lusting over neo-nazis"
Nowadays one of the major reason to be "masculine" its because you hate faggots and see homosexuality as a weakness, simply as that, every single man that you want to fuck probably hate you.
>>
>>2991876
Not even flamboyant feminine fags like others like them, most fags like masculine men that has always been the case.
>>
>>2991934
You can't be really masculine without hating gays.
>>
File: FC9-f_zaQAAFKdo.jpg (479 KB, 1384x2048)
479 KB
479 KB JPG
>>2991668
Traps aren't a part of yaoi. Bishounens and ikemen are.
>>
>>2991766
You hang around the male str8oid circle too much. Trapshit are irrelevant when it comes to yaoi and gay porn.
>>
>>2991955
>You hang around the male str8oid circle too much.
Its the only market that matters, fujos have a bit of power but nobody cares about gay men.
>>
>>2991668
>>2991673
>That's not for you or me to decide, the rules say they don't belong and until they're changed that will be the case.
>or me
except the "boobless dickgirl" patrol goes after anything popularrly known as a twink or bishonen in general, not just traps and makeup/crossdressing boob-implant trannies.
so anything that isn't a very specific type of men that the backseat jannies will instantly jump out of the wooodwork to state ITS NOT BARA ITS JUST NORMAL MEN will spam the strangegay rule to gatekeep everything but "totally not bara" and then complain jannies aren't enforcing his headcanon interpretation.
not much different from Karens on Twitter going on a diatribe over Bridget being called male and spamming reports to take down every artist who dares commit this sin.
fortunately, the persistence of non-bara content (as in, the absolutely criminal rule-violating content that jannies aren't cleaning up) is still uup and running, therefore proving that non-bara content dooesn't automatically fall under strangegay, and therefore proving said patrol wrong.
the only damage done are pathetic users who give up posting here because they got filtered by backseat jannies. they only got their own cowardice to blame for being intimidated by pretend cops and are probably tourists who would eventually post actual strangegay given further chance since they doubt their own judgement of what qualifies as actual strangegay despite being made aware of the content labels on what they fetch to post here.
>>
>>2992007
to make things even more ironic, threads about games like FF7R, Zelda, Genshin Impact and Nu Carnival go the extra mile of having fanart showcasing uber-masculinized versions of the cast in spite of their canon appearance just to appease said patrol, only to end up still having Karens calling the manager to burn the thread down since one or two outliers dared to post official art or at least canon-accurate versions.
>>
>>2992008
furthermore, bara content in this board usually showcases feminine traits and fetishes such as boobpecs, groping, paizuri and breastfeeding, to the point some of it even has lactation, not to mention the crossdressing and bikinis.
as such, it's pretty evident the strangegay rule doesn't work either way, despite the backseat patrol being so hellbent on dying on this hill.
>>
>>2991831
Jannies don't do shit if they're willing to keep this thread up
>>2991991
>it's more marketable therefore good
Futa and het are "marketable", doesn't mean they're relevant to yaoi and gay porn.
>>
All I want are lithe twinks like the dudes from Free! (or, in some art, the guys from Voltron) crossdressing and fucking each other. No huge muscles or big asses, no femininity. Swimmer's bodies, defined abs and pecs without looking like a washboard with tits, etc.

I find maybe six posts a month here that fit that description. It's wearying.
>>
>>2991668
>another draw a girl call it a boy thread
>>
File: 51_100_sakimichan_480.jpg (280 KB, 1280x1871)
280 KB
280 KB JPG
>>2992083
based
>>
Homosexuality its just a replacement for women, nobody cares about masculinity, this board don't count
>>
>>2992144
t.trapfag
>>
>>2992144
t.mentally ill
>>
>>2992144
it's only a replacement if you're just a coomer who can jump bertween fetishes on a whim. Even so, at least actual bis have standards, unlike "anything goes" coomers.
Actual homosexuality hates feminine traits, and while this doesn't lead to outright despise towards women, it's expected of gays to respect them as strangers but feel zero romantic and sexual interest on them.
As a consequence, feminine clothing / makeup / implants are a turnoff for gays. Nobody cares about femininity, not masculinity.
>>
>>2992209
>Actual homosexuality hates feminine traits
I agree, as I said before even feminine gays don't feel attraction to other feminine gays.
>>
>>2992210
Bulls do, however.
But they are either bi or degenerates.
>>
>>2991668
The only retards are those who don't keep their sissy fetish threads in /d/
>>
>>2992250
>>2992094
Go fuck yourselves
>>
File: 98555254_p3.png (320 KB, 800x1130)
320 KB
320 KB PNG
>How come this board is called /yaoi/ and not /bara/ Whenever someone posts twink
I'm 100% with you so far

>or trap
oh no

I'm a really really big fan of cute masculine and feminine guys, and I'm really disappointed in what I find here... but I don't think more drawings of women with penises would improve my experience.
>>
>>2992209
>it's only a replacement if you're just a coomer who can jump bertween fetishes on a whim
They are a rising market and probably surpass gay men at this point.
>>
>>2991696
Trans man here.

So due to the behavior of a handful of loud, chronically-online trans women, you 1) demonize all trans people in general, 2) use what they do, supposedly, to justify not having traps, or shota, cunt boys/trans men on/y? Because what? It causes ~disharmony~ in the gay community? Like some of us aren’t also gay and on here?
>>
>>2992275
Try posting futas on /h/ or /e/ and see what happens.
>>
>>2992083
And that’s exactly why I don’t think there should be so many rules on here about what “counts as yaoi.” If the artist created the character or drawing and reasonably imaged the character to be a man/boy/male, I don’t see why it shouldn’t be on here.
>>
>>2992277
Why should what happens on other boards effect what we can and can’t post on here? If we’re going to be all anti-censorhip, don’t-like-don’t-look, why’s everyone trying to justify banning something they personally don’t like?
>>
>>2992277
Everyone outside this board considers traps gay (and again faggot, no actual straight men would prefer a dick over a pussy).
CURRENTLY homosexuality its turning into a alternative for women instead of really caring about "men's beauty", there is real dudes having sex with each other purely by this new concept.
>>
>>2992282
Can anyone actually explain the logic behind the posting rules that doesn’t devolve into weird ass conspiracy theories? Or is this board actually just making decisions to try to appease different factions of people?
>>
>>2992254
This anon gets it and his pic is a perfect example to compare with OP's pic, showing a guy with a slim body who despite the lack of or few muscles looks clearly masculine, as opposed to OP's pic that's looks too much like a boobless woman.
>>
>>2992275
No one needs to justify anything, it's the board's rules there's nothing more to that. Just like you don't post /y/ content on the other porn boards, you shouldn't post content meant to be posted in other boards here, the different boards exist for a reason.
>>2992280
>Why should what happens on other boards effect what we can and can’t post on here?
It's not about affecting what we can or can't post here, it's about seeing what happens when you break the rules of those boards. We're simply unlucky that this board's mods/jannies aren't very active otherwise this thread should've been nuked since it serves no purpose other than pointlessly arguing over something we users don't get to decide, we just follow the rules or break them and it should be a given that people would be unhappy about someone breaking the rules since they don't come here to see the infringing content, they'd go to the designated board for that if they wanted to.>>2992282
>Everyone outside this board considers traps gay
Correction, everyone except actual gays consider traps gay, just like they consider trans gay, lesbians gay, etc, they keep using it as an umbrella term when it's not, if you're not a biologically born male who likes other biologically born males you're not gay. No, trans men aren't men, even they know that otherwise they wouldn't call themselves "trans" men, they'd just call themselves men, but that doesn't get them the attention and special treatment they crave.
>>2992294
>Can anyone actually explain the logic behind the posting rules
Ask a mod or jannie, I doubt anyone here is a mindreader, at best we can offer our own logic for it, which may not be the one used to create the rule. My logic is that this is a gay board, for gay stuff, real men, not traps, not dickgirls, not cuntboys, not trans, not anything except biological men.
>>
>>2992275
Except it's not a minority when a vast majority of them behave like this. Look at /lgbt/ right now and tell me that behaviour is not cult-like, who also frequently raid other boards just as badly as /pol/
>>
File: 1641018496404 (1).jpg (106 KB, 850x860)
106 KB
106 KB JPG
I'd rather this be the Male board rather than the non-female board.
>>
>>2992308
okay but unless it gets deleted, it's not a woman. if we start banning things not for what they actually are, but according to personal taste and subjective definitions of what constitues a "real man" then it becomes a Karen championship of who gets to scream harder and scare off the most people with empty threats of banning for content that doesn't violate rules (i.e. doesn't get deleted by moderation).
longer hair, dick too short, muscles not so defined, not enough facial / body hair, and so on become the goalpost-moving standards for justifying eliminating everything that doesn't fit the checklist of Patrick Fillion's style.
Now, jumping in front of jannies to scream bloody murder about a male character who identifies as male and has a penis because he isn't "man enough" for you under the excuse of "at least I'm doing something" is an ironic move of comitting rule violations (impersonating staff / announcing reports) for the sake of enforcing another rule.
>>
>>2992312
>I doubt anyone here is a mindreader, at best we can offer our own logic for it
>My logic is that this is a gay board, for gay stuff, real men
>real men
Nope, this isn't justification for applying freestyle interpretations off what you personally consider a real man.
Being naturally male, identifying as male and having a dick are objective metrics for what defines a man.
There is zero need for being a mindreader or doing philosophical exegesis of the sticky. Like you said, no one needs to justify anything, so as long as it doesn't get handled by mods, then it qualifies as /y/-compliant. Simple as that.
>>
>>2992402
Trans ideology has no place in a literature that has spent decades revolving around biological male x male fiction and actively backed by forces that would discriminate against you at every turn. You already have futa and cuntboy depictions accurately representing what Japan views you as and neither are allowed on the board. Unless you can subvert the entire nation of Japan and not only their patriarchal views, but the cis women who rampantly draw the said yaoi who are probably TERFs in your eyes, you're fighting an uphill battle.
>>
>>2991668
I like to consider traps/femboys in the past couple years as a heterosexual/bisexual fetish. There was always a small niche of people who behaved like this but the last decade has been like another sexual revolution with all sexualities on the rise massively. It's now been geared towards men that would never publicly admit they were more than incidentally homosexual and are so introverted to the idea that the male bottom has to look like a female as much as possible for them to mentally cope. Borderline frat boy culture where "any hole is a goal", "as long as the balls don't touch it's not gay" and shit like "goth mommy tomboy gf (femboy)" has fried people's minds, and it doesn't help that porn artists capitalize on this seeing who can make the most effeminate/bimbo looking male possible for profit. These people do not respect the male physique and cannot tell the difference between a twink and a femboy, so they will flood the threads not knowing the difference. The only solution really is to draw clear lines of what is acceptable in the sticky and what isn't, kind of like a kinsley scale of masculine and feminine yaoi images and draw the line of what exactly is acceptable. Without a clear guideline there will always be discourse on this board with regards to what's a trap, femboy or futa.
>>
>>2992401
You say this when in this very thread there are people complaining about the board being dominated by bara, acting as if there's no space for anything else when you'd know it isn't true if you visited threads. You only ever see people complaining about traps, cuntboys and shota in general.
>longer hair
There is a thread for that up right now >>2971871 and you only see one complaint about a single post, seems like people like the thread.
>dick too short
There is a thread for that up now too >>2991420 and of the 3 people who wrote something, only one said it's boring while the other two like it.
>muscles not so defined
Though not specifically about this, here's a Link thread where OP's pic fits that >>2990481, it also has quite the variety of body types in the replies.
>not enough facial / body hair
Men with no facial or body hair are so common in art that you can probably find at least one in every thread.
>eliminating everything that doesn't fit the checklist of Patrick Fillion's style.
It's laughable that you think this is what people want when every single thread that the anon who keeps posting his stuff visits has people complaining about it.
>Now, jumping in front of jannies to scream bloody murder
Mentioning that something is against the rules, especially when asked why you're against something isn't jumping at the jannies, especially when it was already mentioned in this thread how they're not very active in this board.
>Being naturally male, identifying as male and having a dick are objective metrics for what defines a man.
There's nothing objective about identifying as something, it's as subjective as anything that only a mindreader could prove.
>There is zero need for being a mindreader or doing philosophical exegesis of the sticky.
That anon asked if anyone could explain the logic behind the rules, so yes there is a reason because we're not the ones who made then so we have no way of knowing without being a mindreader or asking the ones who did.
>>
>>2992426
Why you fags can't give up and accept that your precious "men's beauty" its totally outdated and the new thing is discount women?
Worst of all, you don't do shit to change this, trapshit its probably the standard now.
>>
It seems that trannies manage to have a bigger influence in just a bunch of years than fags in decades
>>
>>2992406
>Trans ideology has no place
I agree, but what does it have to do with my post?
A natural male who identifies as male and has a dick is a full cishet. There is zero space left for interpretation into trans ideology.
>You already have futa and cuntboy depictions accurately representing what Japan views you as and neither are allowed on the board.
None of this is what I just described tho. My beeef is with people who look at artstyles they don''t like and call it "not real men" just because they like a different artstyle. However, the very nature of this board as yaoi, as in, fictional depictions of men, relies on the artstyles of a bajillion different artists.
Once we step out of the boundaries of objective metrics such as the ones I described, it boils down to a matter of not liking shit therefore it doesn't comply. Not only it's absurdly subjective and elitist, it goes against the very notion of trying to filter ffemininity out of the board considering the bear counterparts have a free pass for crossdressing, boobs, milking, pregnancy and a lot of other trans bullshit.
>>
>>2992437
>You say this when in this very thread there are people complaining about the board being dominated by bara, acting as if there's no space for anything else when you'd know it isn't true if you visited threads
Not my problem anon, I'm not responsible for other people's complaints even if you disagree with me and them simultaneously, turning this into a faction war. I don't represent or speak for them. In fact, I completely agree with the sentiment of wiping out any and all shit like implants, feminine apparel, makeup, identifying as a girl and so on, both for bears and twinks.
>Mentioning that something is against the rules
"mentioning" and "lecturing" have completely different meanings anon. browbeating people for posting twinks in any shape or form under a catch-all goalpost-moving term of "boobless dickgirl" is something that has been happening for years in this board and all it takes is a single ctrl-F to find it at least once in almost every thread. it's a veiled attempt to steer the board into eliminating twinks by calling them "not real men".
Want realistic men? Go to /hm/, there you'll find all the realism of IRL men. Fictional characters don't have to adhere to realism
>There's nothing objective about identifying as something, it's as subjective as anything that only a mindreader could prove.
>we're not the ones who made then so we have no way of knowing without being a mindreader or asking the ones who did.
What you're doing is muddying the waters by saying there is no way to determine what is a real man or not, but since you are so adamant in enforcing this board needs "real men" so much, you'll do the noble sacrifice of deciding it for everyone else.
As such, I can only expect you to apply for moderation. Enforcing a requirement of realism goes above the mod staff's intent and consequentially operates as backseat modding aka staff impersonation. And not knowing the staff's intent isn't free grounds for reinterpreting it and enforcing that
>>
>>2992451
oh and please take the "you" as a rhetorical device, before you take offense with it and say "whoa why are you accusing me of doing all that".
This applies to whoever is trying to pull this shitty stunt, not you personally.
>>
File: 1654517596758.jpg (87 KB, 810x1430)
87 KB
87 KB JPG
>>2992447
Because they will never be able to emulate it in their life, the best they can do is degrade it to a point where their abhorrently low limits are the standard. The biological male physique will always trump anything trans creatures will put out, no amount of prescription medication will change this
>>
>>2992454
>The biological male physique will always trump
Again, nobody cares about "men's beauty", at least not for homoerotic reasons, the only people that worship masculinity are neo-nazis that want to fucking kill you.
>>
File: irc logs.jpg (381 KB, 1638x912)
381 KB
381 KB JPG
Trapfags like to gaslight /y/ and even /c,/ and say trap/femboyshit was always allowed despite /d/ being made around the same time for this very fucking reason. They used to post this irc chat in a desperate bid to prove their boobless dickgirl fetish totes belongs in /y/ until someone told them @Asuka, the janny in question, isn't a /y/ janny and doesn't even know /y/ culture. Inb4 "don't need to be a chef to say the food sucks" or some retarded ass grade school comeback.
So if you see someone tell you traps were always a gay male fetish or fujo fetish and were always part of /y/, call them the fuck out and point out the fact they were traditionally deleted on the spot or spammed with pics of bara, gore, trapshit abuse and superior twinks. Don't let them get away with their historical revisionism.
>>
>>2992320
You're posting this FTM shit on purpose, aren't you?
>>2992460
>whining about "neo-nazis"
>calls anyone and everyone the n- word like it's going out of style
>>
>>2992451
>browbeating people for posting twinks
I at least haven't done that, I even shared that twink Link thread, unless you're implying something like OP's pic is a twink, in which case we'll have to agree to disagree. I have nothing against twinks and I just ignore the fetishes I don't like that aren't against the board's rules.
>What you're doing is muddying the waters by saying there is no way to determine what is a real man or not
No, I'm not. I singled out your "identify as male" comment because that's a thought and as such can't be objective. As for the second quote, it's talking about not knowing what is the logic behind the board's rules, it has nothing to do with determining what a real men is, only with the fact that we don't know the thought process the mods had when they created them, that's all.
>but since you are so adamant in enforcing this board needs "real men"
I'm not trying to enforce anything, if you go back to my post where I said "real men", I explicitly said it was just my thoughts on why the rule exists to give a possible answer to that anon's question. I didn't claim it is the true reason, it's just my opinion and I didn't say people should agree with it, I even said before that that if one wishes to know the true reason they should ask the mods, so I don't know where you got the impression I'm trying to enforce anything. You're the one who seems to be trying to mud the waters by mixing parts of my posts that are not related and either misunderstanding me or making things up to fit your narrative, so to clarify, I'm just participating on the discussion, sharing my opinion, not pushing anything on anyone, I even said multiple times in this thread that it's not up to us to decide (or push if you will) anything since we're just users, not mods. I'm also not turning this into a faction war, again I'm just sharing my views on different points made by different anons.
>>
>>2992460
guys are hot, and you don't need to fall for the 'wanting to be a woman' dreck to like your same gender. Unfortunate if this bothers you or you're otherwise incapable of understanding it.
>>
File: trapfag butthurt.png (320 KB, 1603x1097)
320 KB
320 KB PNG
>>2991668
Hey OP is this you?
>>
>>2992498
What are you doing whining to the entire site for, OP?
>>
File: trapfag butthurt prologue.png (377 KB, 1607x1959)
377 KB
377 KB PNG
>>2992499
The fact you've been at this for at least a year is very sad, OP. Please get help.
Forcing fujos and gay men to accept your sissy tranny fetish will not fill the void in your heart,
>>
File: 62753117_p0.jpg (413 KB, 600x848)
413 KB
413 KB JPG
>>2992253
Cope and seethe. Traps and femboys aren't yaoi or gay
>>
>>2992255
You could say that hetporn surpasses and is more marketable than trap/femboyshit
>>
>>2991671
Shota
>>
File: 86141423_p64.jpg (2.01 MB, 1742x2332)
2.01 MB
2.01 MB JPG
>>2991672
That's a bishie/ikemen/twink which has always been a staple in yaoi and is still loved and popular with fujos to this day. They don't look like chicks with dicks because of their toned bodies and handsome faces.
>>
>>2991991
Trap/femboyshit aren't marketable towards gay men and fujos. They don't care or want to see drawn boobless girls being called boys in their male focus content.
>>
God I love you /y/. Don't ever change! I lost a friend to the trans bullshit, and they used to be a perfectly normal gay at first. After that they ended up hating me just for not following down the same stupid rabbit hole. Even when I tried to be supportive. Also purged their friends list ect. to a bunch of others. It is definitely a mental thing.
>>
>>2992523
I also lost lost a friend that way, though they developed a mean case of TDS and started getting political, what once was actually fun conversation became lectures on the left wing boogieman of the day or arguments over her believing left wing conspiracies (it was 2016.)
She was less interested in me over time and it was clear she was spending so much time with her new internet twitter crowd.

The breaking point for me was when at that point we had very little common ground to actually talk on but she lit up on some guys project on the aids epidemic. She was acting like some historian of LGBT and was talking with the presenter for too long. At some point she got a pulse nightclub tattoo and the last time I saw her she was using the men's room during graduation when I was waiting to use the urinal, of course she had to wait for the toilet. We looked at each other for a second, and said nothing.
>>
>>2992505
>>2992509
I never see a "bishonen" character getting any attention
>>
>>2992537
Then you've never seen yaoi or even fujobait
>>
>>2992506
By trapfag logic, hetshit should be here too since it's more "marketable" than yaoi. After all, if these gluttonous Karens don't get their way and never have their dickgirl fetish validated, then everyone else is "lusting over neo-nazis"
>>
File: 80232795_p2.png (666 KB, 945x720)
666 KB
666 KB PNG
>>2992537
Because they don't appeal to male str8oids like you. Look at big bishie series like Free! or Touken Ranbu
>>
File: 1.jpg (585 KB, 1436x1786)
585 KB
585 KB JPG
We are truly living in hellish times.
>>
>>2991668
/b/ was taken. sorry
>>
File: IMG_20211216_184115.jpg (33 KB, 385x340)
33 KB
33 KB JPG
>>2992454
>>
>>2992537
This has to be the most ridiculous comment I've seen on this board.
>>
>>2992491
Mods are useless. They'll keep trapshit and cuntboys up despite them both breaking the rules but god forbid you make posts to complain about them or the inactive mod team themselves.
>>
>>2992402
So all those weird fetish threads and cuntboy shit are allowed to stay despite them breaking the rules because mods won't do anything about it? That's good to know, anon. Real good to know you don't care about the quality of the board.
>>2992450
There is nothing natural about a man with birthing hips and budding breasts
>>
>>2992642
>>2992643
Give up.
>>
File: 1672135603685671.png (72 KB, 1024x1050)
72 KB
72 KB PNG
>Give up.
>>
Yaoi and Bara are narrative genres. Anyone making visual associations is retarded.
The mods are not referees. Your personal engagement is not content, it's nobody problem but your own.
>>
>>2992663
It's a problem when the board state has massively devolved due to this discourse, resulting in archived/derailed threads and borderline spam behaviour
>>
>>2992537
Everytime I see someone behave as ridiculous as you I'm just going to coin the phrase troonjoshi from now on
>>
>>2992663
Agreed. Trapfags complain about bara tits spouting breast milk all the time, not understanding the irony that they fap to underage girls with dicks.
>>2992672
Blame trapfags.
>>
>>2992673
>>2992639
I really never see a "masculine/bishonen" character get any attention, its always traps
>>
>>2992681
You've never read yaoi or watched fujobait anime
>>
>>2992672
>borderline spam behaviour
I wouldn't call dozens of barafag seethe pics every single thread borderline
>>
>>2992683
Just doujins
>>
>>2991696
>they hated him because he spoke the truth
>>
>>2992537
is this bait?
>>
>>2992687
That explains so much
>>
File: males only.png (757 KB, 1356x554)
757 KB
757 KB PNG
>>2992655
Where are the "real men"?
>>
File: yaoi.png (221 KB, 1335x396)
221 KB
221 KB PNG
>>
>>2992693
>>2992694
>straggot porn sites
>>
>>2992695
Who knows myreadingmanga?
>>
File: 1655943849630.jpg (57 KB, 563x797)
57 KB
57 KB JPG
>>2992696
Gay men and fujos. Those who love and appreciate 2D/fictional men and yaoi.
>>
File: EpMKpTBW4AEL4mF.png (910 KB, 881x849)
910 KB
910 KB PNG
>>2992681
See >>2992556

>>2992687
Yikes. Probably never watch shonen anime or play video games with handsome male characters. Just straggot coomshit.
>>
>>2992695
>borders on pedoshit
>one of them is a canon tranny
Not doing a good job of hiding your futa fetish are you Karen?
>>
File: 1673363728450.jpg (17 KB, 275x275)
17 KB
17 KB JPG
>>2992480
>@Asuka, the janny in question, isn't a /y/ janny and doesn't even know /y/ culture
>source: my ass
newfag detected, jannies are universal for all boards you fucking moron
Go back to derailing cm and y threads on lolcow you filthy tourist
>>
>>2992693
>>2992694
I'd show some, but I don't want people like you anywhere near the things I like.
>>
>>2992724
Bridget is tagged as a male, If not as a shemale or a rule 63 version, just a few artist care about Strive.
>>
File: Fjv_NmtWQAcPkYU.jpg (84 KB, 680x680)
84 KB
84 KB JPG
>>2992778
>porn tags dictate canon
>>
>>2992776
Oomfie, what were you doing in /vg/ and /trash/? I thought you said you were better than boards like that. Hmm?
>>2992498
>>2992499
>>2992501
>>
>>2992788
Porn isn't canon, If it were then yaoi can't exist because the 200% of japanese male characters are straight without a second thought
>>
>>2992794
That's... what I was saying anon. Do you not know how to read?
>>
>>2992796
Canon doesn't matter in porn
>>
>>2992798
So women with dicks are men now because it's the author's headcanon?
>>
>>2991668
>retards
It's a single deluded samefaggot with a backseat janny complex. He even got banned early in this thread (https://archived.moe/y/post/2991715/) but immediately evaded his ban to continue sperging out.
>>
>>2992987
Shouldn't you be crying to random boards?
>>
>>2992987
>traps are loved by everyone!
>it's only one hater
Retard and delusional
>>
>>2992987
>>2992789
>>
>>2991668
I hate barafags so much so for shitting up the gay boards incessantly. Unironically worse than femboy and trap trannies. Nobody knows how to do anything moderate when it comes to fag porn anymore, its either femboy uwu bullshit or full on hard gay faggotry to "keep the straggots out". None of this shit is grounded in reality and it pisses me off. God forbid someone likes an actual realistic looking male these days that isn't a trap-like femboy or full on beefcake with sixteen pack and a beard that looks like he is pushing 40.

>hurr durr you posted a man that isn't gachimuchi-tier buff guy STRAGGOT, TRANNY, MODS MODS MODS
literally the cancer that killed /y/ and turned it into a husk, and the jannies being complicit in this bullshit need to shotgun blast kurt cobain style.
Can't have a normal, human looking male that most of the world's gay or bisexual population finds attractive, only femboys in dresses and barashit. I can barely find yaoi anymore that doesn't fit these two archetypes. Fuck all of you. This is why all of you are single, lonely losers because you only like the most extreme of body types.

Also having to post sample sized images because this board only allows 4mb max uploads fucking sucks too. Its not 2007 anymore, up the fucking filesize
>>
>>2993045
Don't let the door hit your ass on the way out now
>>
ITT: gluttonous staightfags that think they're bi because they fell for a literal meme pissing and shitting themselves they can't take one of the few andro-sexual boards/forums/spaces there even are and flood IT with pictures of women, too; embittered trannies, their chasers, and degenerate, psy-opped sissy fetishists dilating they can't co-opt yet another gay board/forum/community for their disgusting, execution-worthy fetish
>>2993045
I'd definitely say the trapfags are even worse than the "MUST BE HUMAN BALOON ANIMAL, OR IT'S PEDO" bara schizos, but other than that this here is exactly the fucking take
especially with not being able to find anything good of actual, normal dudes because of this shit, you absolutely nailed it, anon
>>2993046
faggot
>>
>>2993056
>writing all that
>calling other people shitzoids
Okay anon
>>
>>2993064
>calling others "lusting over neo nazis"
>uses the n word
Okay anon
>>
>>2993045
I can understand your complaint about the other extreme, but why do you people keep talking as if one or the other is dominating the board and there's nothing else to look at? Even by just looking at the catalog you don't only see either trap or bara content and if you actually enter threads about themes you like you'll most often than not find enough variety.
Out of curiosity, where do you draw the line between a normal looking guy and bara?
>>
>>2993056
They are the biggest non-straight market right now, "gay men" have null power and no company cares about them, you can call me a consoomer but money and buyers are the only thing that matters.
>>
>>2993112
Traps aren't gay and only straight men care about them. They are not part of the yaoi market. Gay men and fujos don't care about them.
>>
File: trapfags irl.jpg (44 KB, 720x710)
44 KB
44 KB JPG
>>2993112
>t. only browses str8 sites to know this
>>
>>2993112
Women don't care about traps, gays don't care about traps, only a small handful of straight/bi guys care about them. No matter how much you try to deny it the amount of people who consume that kind of content is smaller than those who consume gay content, maybe even smaller than those who consume furry content.
>>
>>2993133
Okay who fucking cares? I’m not insecure about how many people jerkoff to the same thing as me (unlike you obviously) I just wanna see them cuties on this board instead of the disgusting fetish board lol
>>
>>2993133
>only a small handful of straight/bi guys care about them
That "small handful" outnumbered "gay men" at this point.
>>
Traps legitimately don't belong here in my opinion. But bara spergs melt down over literally anything that isn't a deformed blob of meat and hair.
>>
>>2991668
Awful tricksy way to get a twink thread going
Good job
>>
>>2993154
>Okay who fucking cares? I’m not insecure about how many people jerkoff to the same thing as me
It's actually funny how you can shamelessly say that when your post that I replied to was talking about how popular your fetish is.
>>2993183
Yeah sure, straight guys stopped liking pussy, humanity is doomed because everyone likes dick now.
>>
>>2993187
The twinks you're thinking of aren't the "twinks" OP's thinking of
>>
>>2993183
This is the equivalent of saying trannies outnumbered girls
>>
>>2993074
Sorry anon, haven't checked the thread since I posted (didn't think anyone would respond or care)
>Out of curiosity, where do you draw the line between a normal looking guy and bara?
A normal looking guy is just that, a normal, usually skinny but not exclusive guy with slight muscles or an average body type. Not ultra muscular beefcake and not femboy twink bullshit.
I guess something like this (just pulled a random image off danbooru). Someone you would actually see or be with in real life, and not some hypersexualized version of a person that fetish fags push on people with bara and trap shit.
Sure this guy in pic related has anime like fantasy stuff but the body type, hair, etc is mostly normal, believable, and to me hotter than fucking bara or trap uwu shit. If I wanted to see bara, I'd just look at a boomer on facebook's pictures. And if I wanted to see twinks I'd just look at twitter attention whores. But I don't want to see that, I want to see cute boys and men who don't hide their masculinity in dresses or over-emphasize their masculinity. But shit like that is impossible to find on gay boards that aren't sfw. /cm/ I can find somewhat of what I'm looking for but its also pretty difficult.
>>
Skimmed through the thread but all I know is that if you enable trapfaggotry once the entire board would start getting flooded with trapshit. It's also a bit why the fucking yaoi tag on sadpanda is like mostly trapshit and real actual yaoi (some YGO doujin or twisted wonderland) gets downvoted or gets shit ratings.
It's like this board just completely hates the notion of fujoshi existing though.
Can't have trapshit because that's for straight normalfags, but have to assert this is a GAY SEX BETWEEN *REAL* ANIME MEN BOARD not UGLY TWINKS because that's for WOMEN we like MEN here. Just feels oddly like as if the main reason why yaoi exists isn't even because of fujos but because of barafags in some revisionist attempt
>>
Probably cause if they allowed femboys and traps, it would flood the board.
It can be annoying when you want twinks though, which should be allowed
>>
Do you fags even have sex with men to begin with?
>>
>>2991668
You're confusing thinks with obviously underage trash and confusing traps with with obviously underage cross -dressing trash

You would do wonders in conservative politics and/or journalism with your ability to get so offended over words you don't know the meaning of
>>
>>2993461
Traps are tranny trash and OP is the type to lump twinks in with them
>>
>>2993461
>>2993463
"Real men" don't sell
>>
>>2993471
Real men are the selling point of yaoi, something you annoying straggots forget
>>
>>2993472
Traps still sell more
>>
>>2993473
Traps are irrelevant to actual yaoi. You'd know this if you bothered to look at sites like myreadingmanga
>>
>>2993474
myreadingmanga doesn't count
>>
>>2993475
>yaoi site that disproves my narrative doesn't count, only hentai sites for straggots do
Your opinion doesn't count.
>>
>>2993479
Its the only one?
>>
>>2993473
Wow great journalism Tucker Carlson.

That unrelated point totally invalidates using the word wrong.

If I call sorbet ice cream it is totally okay if more ice cream is sold.

Get an education
>>
>>2993475
Tucker Carlson in again with another journalistic slam dunk: things that contradict him "don't count".

Go back to /pol with all of the other rural shit for brains incels
>>
>>2993501
Its don't count because its just one website, check any other website, check Twitter, Pixiv and so on, nobody cares about bishonen and bara.
>>
File: 85004839_p10.jpg (636 KB, 1220x1838)
636 KB
636 KB JPG
>>2993519
Bishounen and bara are very present in Twitter, Pixiv, Gelbooru, etc. You just follow straggot shit and get reccomended to them more. Plus you never look up or touch yaoi/male content for gays and fujos.
>>
Fuck traps, shit tier straight fetish, but do people really complain about twinks here? I feel like I haven't really seen that. Unless people mix twinks and femboys I don't see why anyone would complain about twinks. Pic rel is what i would consider a twink.
>>
>>2993519
You're delusional if you think no one cares about bishounen.
>>
File: numbers.png (140 KB, 872x974)
140 KB
140 KB PNG
>>2993519
>nobody cares
Now you can stop with the lies.
>inb4 bara has less than trap in one site and bishounen in two
Trap still has less than yaoi in all of them.
>>
>>2993519
Are you one of those people who think your shitty rural town of 7000 is an average?
>>
>>2993522
Trapfags complain about actual twinks, no different from the ones on /cm/ accusing shotas of being titless tomboys to defend their dickgirl fetish
>>
>>2993475
>a site for yaoi "doesn't count"
I accept your concession. Off you go now >>>/d/
And don't let the door hit your ass on the way out now <3
>>
>>2993519
By going to a book store, you don't see trap manga in the bl/shounen ai section but bishies instead. Therefore, traps are irrelevant and the general don't care about them.
>>
File: pixiv.png (52 KB, 388x169)
52 KB
52 KB PNG
>>2993521
>>2993534
Traps get more attention than quantity, also traps having sex with men its tagged as yaoi too.
>>
File: attention.png (5 KB, 418x51)
5 KB
5 KB PNG
Average trap vs average bara/bishonen consumers, this also applies to Twitter, Pixiv, boorus, doujin sites and so on.
>>
File: 1671850900979033.png (620 KB, 1196x1763)
620 KB
620 KB PNG
>>2993643
>these titless tomboys have sex with men thus it's yaoi guys!
https://www.pixiv.net/en/tags/%E7%94%B7%E3%81%AE%E5%A8%98%20%E3%83%88%E3%83%A9%E3%83%B3%E3%82%B9%E3%82%B8%E3%82%A7%E3%83%B3%E3%83%80%E3%83%BC
Fun fact: 男の娘 is considered a tranny term in Japan
>>2993647
>my dickgirl fetish is sooper common thus it should be allowed here
We should allow futa and hetshit by your logic too?
>>
File: popularity.png (2.17 MB, 1229x1934)
2.17 MB
2.17 MB PNG
>>2993643
>Traps get more attention than quantity
Moving goal posts I see, what happened with your "Real men don't sell" and "Traps still sell more" argument seen here >>2993471 and here >>2993473?
>also traps having sex with men its tagged as yaoi too.
The same is true for bara (because where the line between bara and non-bara is varies for each person) and bishounen, plus I threw you a bone previously by showing crossdressing tags which don't only include male crossdressers.
>>2993647
>this also applies to Twitter, Pixiv, boorus, doujin sites and so on.
Are going to continue making claims without backing it up?
Since the argument now is how much attention something gets see picrel.
>inb4 MRM and Mangago don't count
MRM may be an exclusive yaoi site, but Mangago isn't, yet every single time I go there the featured manga, popular mangas and some of the non-yaoi top 5 are filled with yaoi.
>>
File: dj best match.png (2.02 MB, 1063x3978)
2.02 MB
2.02 MB PNG
>>2993647
Here's some additional data, this will take a few posts so please bear with me. You mentioned djs so let's see what fan works are popular on mangadex.
>>
File: dj highest rating.png (1.94 MB, 1062x3841)
1.94 MB
1.94 MB PNG
>>2993706
Keep in mind the filters remain the same. So far not a single trap dj.
>>
File: dj most follows.png (2.09 MB, 1060x3787)
2.09 MB
2.09 MB PNG
>>2993707
Finally some trap content shows up. We shouldn't limit ourselves to fan works though, let's see what professional works look like next.
>>
File: bl best match.png (2.31 MB, 1061x3918)
2.31 MB
2.31 MB PNG
>>2993708
As you can see I simply removed the dj filter.
>>
File: bl highest rating.png (2.35 MB, 1059x3828)
2.35 MB
2.35 MB PNG
>>2993709
Again, no trap content so far.
>>
File: bl most follows.png (2.39 MB, 1061x3877)
2.39 MB
2.39 MB PNG
>>2993710
Trap content shows up. Now let's recall what your arguments were.
>>2993471
>"Real men" don't sell
>>2993473
>Traps still sell more
>>2993475
>myreadingmanga doesn't count
>>2993519
>Its don't count because its just one website, check any other website
>nobody cares about bishonen and bara.
>>2993643
>Traps get more attention than quantity
>also traps having sex with men its tagged as yaoi too.
This last point is important because it validates this data on general BL/yaoi content which is including trap content as you claimed. I also included a site other than MRM, I checked "any other website" as you asked, it's not just one website anymore. I shouldn't have to say it, but I'll point out that mangadex isn't a yaoi site, it's a general manga site.
With that out of the way, let's analyze the data. No trap content when sorted by best match and highest rating with and without the dj filter. Though the work with the most follows with and without the dj filter is a trap manga, given that your arguments were about popularity, attention and nobody caring about non-trap content, let's add up the numbers to determine that.
With dj filter: 4 trap djs out of 32 with a total number of 3.840 bookmarks. The other 28 BL non-trap djs have a total number of 8.470 bookmarks.
Without dj filter: 8 trap manga out of 32 with a total number of 103.714 bookmarks. 21 out the other BL manga have a total number of 182.171 bookmarks. I didn't count Zettai BL because it's a manga about BL tropes and I don't remember if they did a chapter on traps. I also didn't count the two shota mangas because while being shota they look girly so I was unsure which side I should place it. Regardless, even if I added those 3 to either side who has the most bookmarks wouldn't change.
Keep in mind that I simply looked at the covers (except for Shimanami Tasogare which I read the summary to confirm) when counting, so their stories weren't taken into account when dividing them.
>>
>>2993711
Now then, the conclusions we can reach with this data are:
1. Real men do sell as proven by the number of professional and dj non-trap works shown, their ratings and the total amount of bookmarks they have.
2. Trap works don't sell more as proven by the number of professional and dj trap works shown, their ratings and the total amount of bookmarks they have.
3. People do care about non-trap content as proven by the number of professional and dj non-trap works shown, their ratings and the total amount of bookmarks they have.
4. Traps works don't get more overall attention than non-trap works as proven by the number of professional and dj trap and non-trap works shown, their ratings and the total amount of bookmarks they have.
That wraps it up. Of course, this data is only of the first page out of 46 (with the dj filter) or 297 (without the dj filter), but since it was sorted in 3 different ways I believe that's enough data to reach a valid conclusion. If someone else is willing to check all pages and add all numbers then by all means, share it with visual evidence, I'm not that bored to do that though.
>>
>inb4 "nooo you were only supposed to look at mainstream sites that cater to straggots like me!!"
>>
>>2993713
I can see him saying that, but I think mangago and mangadex are mainstream enough and cater to all kinds of readers so that argument goes out of the window.
>>
File: tears-of-joy-clapping.gif (105 KB, 220x273)
105 KB
105 KB GIF
I applaud you anons who actually put in the effort in compiling and doing research on non-trap content/works
>>
File: nhentai.png (815 KB, 1157x507)
815 KB
815 KB PNG
>>2992693
I remembered this post and after checking nhentai I wonder why you showed just that first row, could it be because it's not just trap works in there? Maybe I should do that too and claim shota and bishounen are more popular because that's what's been uploaded recently as you can see in picrel. If you really wanted to push trap works popularity on that site you should've showed the all time popularity, though even with that non-trap works still get uploaded and make it to the today and week popularity lists, so much for "where are the real men?" and "no one cares about them" huh?
>>
>>2993721
It's not that much effort, just takes a bit of time. Besides, who knows, maybe I'll find some good manga I haven't read yet while doing that so it's all good. Thanks for the support though, it's good to see others also not just quietly accepting with some want to push.
>>
This is now a BL recommendation thread. Real BL, not the tranny shit straggots and closet lesbians try to force on everyone.
>>
>>2993725
I haven't read much in the past 3 years so I don't have anything new to recommend. Going by the lists from mangadex posted earlier I'd recommend Blue! Blue! Blue!, the art is very pretty, that dj is a sequel to the actual manga if it's not obvious by the title. Zettai BL if you want simple comedy. Honto Yajuu has really hot sex scenes from what I remember. I only read a few chapters from Semantic Error but I liked where it was going. Dangerous Covenience Store I read only until they had sex for the first time and I thought it was hot. That's it from those lists.
Checking my browser history the last thing I read was Yuutousei wa Unmei no Akai Ito ni Sakaraitai by Igari Peko, it's a clueless high schoolers story, I thought it was cute and most of the chapters are pretty short so it shouldn't take long to read. Going a little further back, if you don't mind animal characteristics I'd recommend Ookami-sama no Koiwazurai by Tobi Washio, the sex was really hot and I think the MCs have great chemistry. If you like needy big muscled bottoms I'd recommend Sokuochi Yarichin Yankee by Namako, specifically the first story (I don't like the other two), if for nothing else for the bottoms hot body and the sex.
I think that's enough, if you want something specific I'll see if I've read anything like that.
>>
>>2993712
When I'm saying that traps sell more I'm referring specifically to the porn market, nobody can't deny that BL niche its plot and not hentai but personally I don't like BL because I just want to jack off and not read a 500 pages essay about "muh feelings" and badly drawn sex scenes.
>>
File: Fibq9JoVsAIaSDV.jpg (411 KB, 1226x2048)
411 KB
411 KB JPG
>>2993773
Congrats on coming out as straight ig but you know you don't belong here
>>
>>2993775
>but you know you don't belong here
Mods don't care
>>
>>2993776
Mods are useless
>>
>>2993773
Bara, bishies and non-traps still sells and have always get a lot of traction in the porn market too. Some purely for porn, some with feelings and plot and some with all of it together. Be it doujinshis, original works, art, animations, visual novels/games, etc. I believe figures are growing too as well.
>>
>>2993773
Are you implying there isn't BL heavily focused or exclusively focused on porn? Are you ignoring all the yaoi artists that draw non-trap content and sell it?
Where are you pulling that data from anyway? If it's just your opinion then say so, but you kept saying traps are more popular, get more attention, that no one cares about non-trap content and posting number of content in different sites, I did the same and now you're moving the goal posts, again. The difference between us is that I posted evidence to back up my claims, so where's yours?
If you want to talk about sales numbers now then post the data for both trap and non-trap content, get it from all artists and all companies, if you can't provide that then you have no argument, it's just your opinion. And don't even think about cherry picking just a few artists from both sides that fit your narrative, that won't prove anything other than your clear bias.
>nobody can't deny that BL niche
No one did, no one says BL sells more than straight content and guess what, the same is true for trap content, it's also niche. Dislike BL all you want, what you jack off to is none of my business and I couldn't care less, that has nothing to do with this discussion though. If all you want is see the content you like then go to >>>/d/, you can post trap content all you want over there, there's no need to try to change this board to fit your tastes.
>>
File: mods rules.png (5 KB, 264x100)
5 KB
5 KB PNG
>>2993776
Is that why they created and pinned those rules? Because they don't care? If they don't then why not just let people post whatever they want, why create those rules? Them not reinforcing it frequently enough is a problem, but one not exclusive to this board, it's just worse here.
>>
>>2993045
>Can't have a normal, human looking male that most of the world's gay or bisexual population finds attractive, only femboys in dresses and barashit.
If you want "normal human looking male", go to >>/cm/ or >>/hm/
Here is a place for 2D. It isn't supposed to look like those you are talking about.

But I agree with you in one thing:
Barafags are shit.

I blame the end of Barachan, which triggered this migration of barafags into /y/
>>
>>2993355
>showing tartaglia body type as an example
So, you want more Twunk 2D porn?
This ain't difficult to find at all.
There are threads around here with these types of body.
Or you could simply open your own thread and have as much as twunk porn as you desire.
>>
>>2993816
Do you mean twink? Because I don't think neither he nor most of this thread is going to like most of the content in the twunk thread.
>>
>>2993817
No, I meant twunk.
>A boy from late teens to early twenties with the slim structure of a twink. The primary difference is that they work out a bit and have slim muscle.
Tartaglia is a good example of twunk.
>>
>>2993815
There's nothing wrong with twinks, twunks, bara, as they all display male/masculine characteristics. Femboys display feminine characteristics under a male guise which isn't what yaoi is about. Crossdressing is pushing the limit as long as male characteristics are the predominant feature, and not made to look like futa, which much of femboy/trap art has become nowadays. My personal pet peeve is twinks being called femboys even when they're displaying masculine characteristics. Femboys/trap lovers are the blight not bara fags.
>>
>>2993823
You might wanna say that in the twunk thread then, doesn't seem like they got the memo.
>>
>>2993804
>Are you implying there isn't BL heavily focused or exclusively focused on porn?
You really can look at this and feel appeal?
Trap doujins its actual hentai with penises, BL sex looks like made by a 12 years old.
>>
File: Jounetsu2BShindo_p11.jpg (168 KB, 800x1135)
168 KB
168 KB JPG
>>2993922
>BL sex looks like made by a 12 years old.
That's how I know you've barely read BL manga, maybe you should try looking at different kinds of manga.
>>
>>2993922
>>
File: cn-Rickshaw-Boy_21-1.jpg (378 KB, 1000x1391)
378 KB
378 KB JPG
>>2993922
>>
File: Priapus_2_7.jpg (383 KB, 1350x940)
383 KB
383 KB JPG
>>2993922
If you can look at these and not feel the appeal I'm afraid you're either not gay or like very specific things.
>>
File: 00_DKip.jpg (2.73 MB, 2150x3035)
2.73 MB
2.73 MB JPG
>>2993957
Only this one
>>
File: 1654525286973-1.png (124 KB, 768x1024)
124 KB
124 KB PNG
>>2993922
You really can look at this and feel appeal?
Trap doujins its hentai with penises, BL sex is actual yaoi.
>>
>>2993210
NTA retard
>>
>>2994241
Then you should work on your wording or better yet, should've made it clear you weren't the same person if you didn't want to be mistaken as him. Btw, it should be a given that your disgusting fetish is only allowed in the disgusting fetish board, just accept it. lol
>>
File: 01.jpg (1.2 MB, 1000x1413)
1.2 MB
1.2 MB JPG
>>2994187
>Trap doujins its hentai with penises
Thats what I want, I just want to jack off, not read a 500 pages muh feelings with badly drawn sex scenes.
>>
>>2993805
It's worse here because they'll ban you for calling them out for allowing this tranny shit to fester
>>2994321
Then go to >>>/h/ instead of spamming the board with borderline hetshit
>>
>>2994321
See >>2993955
>>2993956
>>2993957
>>2993958
They're all exactly just that, you don't need to read the story at all. Sure, Priapus is a series but each one is standalone and it doesn't matter anyway if you only want to jerk off. Picrel is another one. Really, there's plenty of BL out there that is just jerk off material, so stop pretending it's a "I don't want to read a long story" problem and admit that you can only get off to traps.
>>
File: Haiki-FANBOX24-MRM.jpg (402 KB, 900x1252)
402 KB
402 KB JPG
>>2994321
Also
>badly drawn sex scenes.
You really haven't read much BL to keep saying crap like that. Check Haiki's works and you might change your mind, his sex scenes are great.
>>
>>2994250
Lol you are not smart
>>
>>2992987
Holy shit are you telling me /y/ has it's own Barry?
>>
>>2994321
*I just want to jack off to anything that looks like a submissive and breedable girl.
FTFY
>>
File: 21-Warriors-Outdoor-Bath.jpg (404 KB, 1000x1159)
404 KB
404 KB JPG
>>2994321
Straggot keeps parroting "500 pages muh feelings with badly drawn sex scenes" believing all yaoi for fujos/gays is vanilla with light sex scenes. Oblivious from other yaoi pages/material being posted here and doesn't bother to look up porn focus yaoi without trap dickgirl shit. Goes to show that straggot brain is mushed of old crusty cum who jacks off to anything that doesn't involve a good-looking handsome man.
>>
>>2992275
Gonna cry? Transmen are pathetic.
>>
>>2994367
Anon's making shit up
>>
>>2994422
>>2994429
Real men don't sell
>>
>>2994463
See >>2993700
>>2993706
>>2993707
>>2993708
>>2993709
>>2993710
>>2993711
>>2993712
and >>2993804
You can keep saying that all you want, it won't magically become true. As I said in the last post I'm still waiting for data that proves your claim.
>>
>>2994333
>so sayeth the trapfag who refuses to accept data that proves him wrong
>>
>>2993355
>>2993815
/cm/ is being taken over by annoying trapfags. Thankfully mods there are actually active and delete any and every active trap thread on sight.
>>2994367
>>2994454
Anon's been going around the entire site whining to anyone who he thinks will listen about the big bad barafag strawman in his head making fun of him for beating his meat to tranny shit. He's even whined to boards he's supposedly above.
>>2992498
>>2992499
>>2992501
He's been at this shit for at least a year.
>>
>>2994463
Fake men don't sell
>>
>>2994463
>accepting that trap/femboy shit aren't real men
Therefore they shouldn't be allowed on this board and don't fit in with yaoi
>>
I'd like to use this thread to thank the mods/jannies for deleting the trap schizo threads and two other spam threads, keep up the good work.
>>
What the christing fuck is all this terminology and why aren't people just posting SLIM FUCKING TWINKS THAT AREN'T BARA OR TRAPS
>>
>>2994485
Still more than "real men".
>>2994593
Mods don't care
>>
File: 1805 - SoyBooru.png (233 KB, 1000x1000)
233 KB
233 KB PNG
>>2994612
Seethe and cope
>>
>>2994608
Why would people post it here instead of one of the other threads where it fits the theme?
>>2994612
>Mods don't care
You said the same thing in that blacked thread and we all know what happened to it.
>>
>>2994628
>You said the same thing in that blacked thread and we all know what happened to it.
Mostly for the controversial topic than the traps
>>
File: 0016bcd7af7977ea221 (1).jpg (281 KB, 860x1214)
281 KB
281 KB JPG
>>2994608
>why aren't people just posting SLIM FUCKING TWINKS THAT AREN'T BARA OR TRAPS
On it
>>
File: 1599981744400.jpg (1.24 MB, 1240x1754)
1.24 MB
1.24 MB JPG
>>2994657
>>
File: 1632321656822.png (258 KB, 844x1200)
258 KB
258 KB PNG
>>2994658
>>
>>2994660
>>
>>2994665
>>
>>2994666
>>
File: ONK-137-D (1).jpg (402 KB, 1000x1422)
402 KB
402 KB JPG
>>2994667
>>
>>2994668
>>
File: _025-MRM.jpg (402 KB, 1000x1412)
402 KB
402 KB JPG
>>2994669
>>
>>2994657
>>2994658
>>2994668
>>2994669
Great taste anon.
>>
>>2994679
Some of these are more twunk than twink, but it's better than nothing.
>>
>>2994669

why is legs scissoring around waist so fucking hot
>>
>>2994479
femboys are literally cute males retard
>>
>>2994686
"Femboys" are trannies in denial
>>
>>2994686
If the mods delete femboy threads on sight then it's clear they disagree.
>>
>>2994690
idc if the jannies agree or not it's still bullshit
>>
File: 1674183710545547.png (707 KB, 720x718)
707 KB
707 KB PNG
>this entire fucking thread
>>
>>2991674
That is literally the dumbest reason for traps. I hate you.
>>
>>2991674

the top, whoever he is, is what I want more men to look like on this board. He's not bara-swole, he's not a tiny little femboy, he's an obvious male with clearly defined muscles, a masculine twink.
>>
>>2994720
Twunk
What you want is a twunk.
Twinks have no muscle or any body fat, they're these twiggy looking guys.
>>
>>2994721

Interesting. Would these guys be twunks?
>>
>>2994727
Needs a tad more muscle definition but definitely closer to twunk than twink or bara.
>>
>>2994727
Those would be twinks. More "twink" than what trapfags claim,
>>
I'm glad nobody outside this board have this mentality
>>
>>2994740
Same. So glad trapfags earn nothing but scorn and mockery.
>>
>>2994745
The only relevant male-focus content
>>
>>2994761
If by relevant you mean popular with normalfags, then I hope non-trap content remains niche, everything touched by normalfags goes to shit quickly, just look at games and anime.
>>
This is just what I was thinking. Haven't been on here for years - last time I was here it was all Bleach and Code Geass and Gundam 00. Just clicked out of curiosity whilst looking at /pol, was expecting the modern equivalent of Suzaku/Lelouch or whatever , and oh my god the bara.
>>
>>2994951
>oh no, the board has a variety of threads for different tastes, but that includes bara too so it's ruined for me
All you have to do is ignore the threads you don't like, that's what I do.
>whilst looking at /pol
Alternatively you can take your snowflake ass back there.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.