[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip / qa] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/co/ - Comics & Cartoons


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


The Road by Cormac McCarthy is getting a comic adaptation by the guy that drew BLAST and Ordinary Victories, as well as some Donjon.
How do you feel comic book adaptations of prose? Any favorites? Any comic book adaptations of prose you'd be interested in seeing?
>>
File: gregor.jpg (322 KB, 1027x1529)
322 KB
322 KB JPG
>>
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eisner_Award_for_Best_Adaptation_from_Another_Medium
>>
No thanks, wake me up when All The Pretty Horses or No Country is adapted.
>>
>>143336019
Oh look the shill posted it again. Nobody cares, blast sucked and the road is McCarthy’s worst novel.
>>
>>143336019
sounds like the kind of meme comic that's taylor-made for reddit
>>
>>143336282
Tailor-made you retard. The term is tailor-made. As in made by a tailor.
>>
>>143336019
I'm sort of interested in Chaboute's Moby-Dick, but there's no way it's properly adapted. I'd imagine it would need prose sections like Watchmen when Ishmael gets into the whale facts.
>>
>>143336333
I can see it being done in the style of an anatomy book.
>>
>>143336306
Why would a tailor make a comic book? moron.
>>
>>143336282
No, it's not capeslop.
>taylor-made
kek
>>
>>143336397
Nta but why would Taylor Swift.
>>
>>143336333
I’m not that big a fan of it but much better than Larcenet’s Blast! and likely this.
>>
>>143336019
there's a comic of Book of the New Sun
never been able to find scans
jolenta wanted the tbc btw
>>
>>143336511
Bite the bullet and buy it. You can't wait for everyone to scan everything.
>>
>>143336511
No need to buy it but definitely read it for free eventually
>>
>>143336589
i dunno where to cop it if i'm being honest
i will if i can
>>
>>143336019
Comic adaptations of prose are huge in Europe, and they usually do it pretty well. The ongoing Elric adaptations from 2014 have been very popular and the og author even said it was a superior version to the prose.
>>
File: 30334197.jpg (367 KB, 800x1124)
367 KB
367 KB JPG
Another one I'd like to read, but I haven't read Paradife Loft yet.
>>143336351
Yeah, some pages would be anatomical diagrams, and some of the others I can't picture any visual presentation other than text with a couple of images.
>>
>>143336019
The Road is depressing and will probably be depressing in comic format too
>>
i've never read mccarthy
if you storytime it i will read it
>>143337037
prolly has a lot to do with it
>>
>>143336019
Heard good things about Slaughterhouse-Five, but the art is kinda shitty and Ryan North is an awful writer based on his other comics.
>>
Anyone read this?
>>
>>143337766
i enjoyed slaugherhouse five because of a throwaway childdsh gambino line
>>
>>143338894
It's not for me, then.
>>
File: 1652217287656.jpg (41 KB, 700x394)
41 KB
41 KB JPG
>>143339695
>>
>>143339733
I like the book. The comic seems too gay for me.
>>
>>143339933
i'm talking about the book too?
>>
>>143340031
I thought you meant there was a Childish Gambino reference in the comic.
>>
>>143336019
>any comic book adaptation you'd be interested in seeing

animorphs (for mature readers because of the violence)

Scorpion Shards (a book, but i haven't read the sequel)

Gun, With Occasional Music

Crooked Little Vein

the same people who liked Daytripper would love Tuesdays with Morrie and those line of books by the same author

The Bat In My Pocket, and proceeds could go to Bat World Sanctuary and Bat Conservation International
>>
>>143340630
>animorphs
b a s e d
>>
File: EcjUEc0XsAE68sI.jpg (1.52 MB, 1438x1000)
1.52 MB
1.52 MB JPG
Dracula by Georges Bess
it's a faithful adaptation of the novel
masterfully Illustrated, you'll hardly ever find a better one
>>
>>143336148
I’ve noticed this too
>>
>>143336019
Cooke’s Parker adaptations are the pinnacle for me. I really liked the Ted Adams and Jorge Coelho Gatsby as well.

>>143337766
I genuinely hated this adaptation.
>>
Any and all of the William Gibson trilogies: sprawl trilogy, bridge trilogy, blue ant trilogy or jackpot trilogy.
>>
>>143336019
I'm still hoping for a scan of Shakespeare in Comics.
>>
File: DELUCAshakespeare.jpg (201 KB, 763x630)
201 KB
201 KB JPG
>>143340842
>Dracula by Georges Bess
>>143340873
>Ted Adams and Jorge Coelho Gatsby
Interesting.
>>143341078
Is it OOP already?
>>
>>143341078
>>143341576
oooo nice
>>
There was a short lived series of Fafhrd and the Grey Mouser adapted pretty faithfully from some of Fritz Lieber's stories by Denny O'Neil and Howard Chaykin.
https://desuarchive.org/co/thread/80029677/#80029677
There were also short-lived, accurate comics for some of Michael Moorecock's other Eternal Champion characters, Hawkmoon and Corum.
>>143336333
It was posted back on 2018. I liked it, but much like The Road, I haven't read the original book yet.
https://desuarchive.org/co/thread/103125328/#103125328
https://desuarchive.org/co/thread/103149654/#103149654
>>143337766
Haven't gotten around to the original on this one either.
https://desuarchive.org/co/thread/118408171/#118408171
>>143340873
I loved those Parker comics, though I've still only read the original book of The Hunter because they came out with that print with some of Cooke's illustrations.
https://desuarchive.org/co/thread/76617130/#76617130

These fucking links better work.
>>
>>143336333
It's a condensed version of the story obviously but I thought it was all right. Not his strongest comic.
>>
>>143341576
I don't know if it's still in print or not, but Italy has the most obscene import/export taxes you could possible imagine. With all the extra bullshit you have to pay, it's like $70 total!
>>
File: Hobbit.jpg (278 KB, 974x1500)
278 KB
278 KB JPG
>>
>>143340957
>>143342501
I didn't know these had comics.
>>
>>143341576
Highly recommend that gatsby. Great art, solid adaptation with no “modernizations” or alterations but very well showcased.

But Parker is the gold standard.

>>143341634
I own all four and read at least one of the Parker books every summer at the beach.
>>
>>143342872
The Hobbit even got a reprint recently, although the new cover art isn't as soulful.
>>
>I want to read McCarthy but I do not want to read his prose
deranged
>>
>>143342501
>>143342872
>>143343223
The story of how The Hobbit was adapted into a comic is actually really interesting.
>>
>>143343477
I'm reading both.
>>
>>143343635
Details?
>>
>>143343635
Nobody cares about a Chuck Dixon tale. God I’m so sick of that fucking faggot
>>
>>143344134
Eclipse Comics had a guy who's job was to trawl copyright archives and look for public domain shit they could adapt. One day he discovered that the original draft of The Hobbit (which was publicly available) was never copyrighted, thus making it fair game for adaptations. Eclipse rushed a comic version of it into production, but then one of the company's owners got an idea. He called up the Tolkien estate and told them what they were doing and gave them an ultimatum: Either hand over the official license to adapt the The Hobbit into comic form FOR FREE (though Tolkien's estate would share profits, of course) or they were going to go through with adapting the original draft and they would get NOTHING, plus they'd have to deal with there being an unlicensed comic version of one of their books on the market (the Tolkien estate famously HATED comics and had already denied Marvel adaptation rights to Lord of the Rings back in the 70s [which indirectly lead to them making Conan comics instead, but I digress...]). With no other option, they relented.

And that's why there still hasn't been another official Tolkien comic before or since.
>>
>>143344566
Wow.
>>
>>143344566
Weird ballsy move. Splitting profits just to get a practically blackmailed endorsement.

I guess you have to respect the hustle of it.
>>
>>143344156
What's wrong with Dixon?
>>
>>143345426
That poster is a faggot.
>>
>>143336019
The Forever War is good. Because Haldeman himself decided he wanted to make it a comic. He wrote the adaptation and went looking for an artist personally. As far as I'm concerned, that's the way to adapt a comic. All the other stuff is just merchandise.
>>
>>143336397
You are the moron, he is just pedantic.
>>
This is the only graphic novel based on literature I’ve read, but I would recommend it.

Uses surrealist imagery to represent figurative language.
>>
I've been checking in on the Classics Illustrated storytime threads on the weekend, they're alright
>>
>>143346264
There’s nothing pedantic about telling someone how to spell.
>>
>>143345705
Sorry you need to choose a different word, anon already called you a faggot, Chuck. Even your 4chan posts lack originality.
>>
>>143346295
That's a good one.
>>
>>143346032
>All the other stuff is just merchandise.
Huh?
>>
File: x.jpg (291 KB, 1479x1005)
291 KB
291 KB JPG
These two are getting released in my country, are they worth buying?
>>143336019
Larcenet also did Brodeck's Report which is based on a novel
>>
>>143348712
>Larcenet also did Brodeck's Report which is based on a novel
Right. I don't think that one has been translated to English.
>>
>>143344566
Whoa
>>
>>143336148
>Road is McCarthy's worst novel
I think you mean Child of God.
>>
Decent thread.
>>
>>143336148
t. didn't have a father
>>
>>143336148
>the road is McCarthy’s worst novel.
That's All the Pretty Horses.
Still not bad though
>>
>>143336333
SPLIT YOUR LUNGS WITH BLOOD AND THUNDER
>>
bump
>>
>>143336019
I liked both Blast and The Road so I'm gonna buy the shit out of it if I can manage.
>>
>>143351177
Why?
>>
>>143344566
The more I hear about Eclipse's business practices, the weirder and shadier they sound as a company. I'm not quite sure what to make of it, as someone who admires a lot of the comics they were publishing. As a case in point, the Eclipse Hobbit was a really well made comic. I suppose that if merit alone isn't enough to convince someone, then it shouldn't be a surprise that skulduggery becomes the next resort.
>>
>>143352232
why not?
>>
>>143348712
Quixote looks interesting.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.