[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


Janitor application acceptance emails are being sent out. Please remember to check your spam box!


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1676710729848.jpg (3.91 MB, 5272x1905)
3.91 MB
3.91 MB JPG
>lose the bad and false opinion that these Aztec people were barbarian and uncivilized... although they showed blindness and diabolic self-deception in their rites and idolatries, in matters of government and good order, submission and reverence, majesty and authority, courage and fortitude, I have found no one to surpass them.

>we believe... by the aid of the interpreters who should plainly declare to them the truths of the Holy Faith...many... would very quickly depart from the their evil ways and would come to true knowledge, for they live more equally and reasonably than any other....which we have hitherto come across.

>they have talent for it [grammar, logic, rhetoric, astrology, and theology] and learn it and know it, and they teach it, and that there is no art for which they do not have the talent to learn and use it.
>>
believing every drunk sailor story. you the kind of bozo that would go on a treasure hunt after overhearing a conversation in a tavern
>>
>being civilized is when you build a city
>the skull towers really tie the whole place together
>>
File: 1758782584729.png (3.95 MB, 1920x960)
3.95 MB
3.95 MB PNG
>>18164002
And I would like to emphasize that, in fact, the narrative called the "Spanish conquest" is 50% exaggeration and 50% falsehood. It is a fact that the Spanish conquistadors used little armor, which led them to adopt local Mesoamerican armor. The stagnant political situation, leading Cortés to depend almost exclusively on Aztec support, also favored cooperation over direct conquest. This naturally allowed the Aztecs to obtain Spanish equipment and consolidate their power, making Spanish colonialism more gradual and based on influence over Aztec institutions.
>>18164010
That wasn't an argument. If your mental capacity is so deficient that you have the cynicism and arrogance to deny due credit to primary sources, it's best to ignore the topic, at the risk of being humiliated again; that's how history works,
>>
>>18164022
he was obviously overblowing it to motivate sending resources and reinforcements. every history noob would understand that but not 4chan dummies
>>
>>18164010
>I-its just a story!
You're jewish.
>>18164018
>skull towers with 6 gorilion bomes o algo
>biggest tzompantli ever found numbered less than 80 skulls
You're jewish.
You're jewish.
>>
>>18164029
>only the parts of the story that I like are real
>>
>>18164002
>BUT MUH SIX GORILLION SACRIFICES O ALGO
>>
Eurocopers seething
>>
>>18164002
This is far superior to any European rubbish.
>>
>>18164022
Still speaking of primary sources, Bernal Diaz del Castillo described the presence of bronze axes in the Tlatelolco market, and there was an Aztec tributary provision that produced bronze. Therefore, saying that "metallurgy" was introduced by Europeans is false. But it is a fact that certain regions of Europe stagnated in metallurgical advancements for a long time, for example.
See the tepoztli, for example, It likely penetrated the skulls of some Europeans during the campaigns, possibly used by high-ranking generals
>>
>>18164117
I know this is a thread about primary sources, yes, but let me educate you that bronze axes were most frequently used in woodworking and as currency, but also as weapons. Diaz talks about Huastec soldiers using them
>>
File: 1513406164748.jpg (333 KB, 1600x811)
333 KB
333 KB JPG
opulent, btw
>>
>artistic depictions again
This is getting sad. You may as well just start posting about your capital of Atlantis.
>>
>>18164010
this. /thread
>>
>>18164175
It's always funny to see nog and ameridian apologists say that Euros bulldozed their cities when historically no one restructured existing cities to the point claimed. We have hundreds of ancient Berber, Roman, Arab, Chinese and Persian city centers still standing despite being conquered dozens of times by competing ethnic and religious groups yet when Euros conquered le heckin brown and black cities they totally tore it down brick by brick lmao
>>
File: 1763070760857.jpg (196 KB, 800x646)
196 KB
196 KB JPG
>>18164175
>>18164189
>>18164018
Sameflag, Look, I know that Mesoamerican civilizations make Europeans sad, especially those from the north, for a reason that I personally understand, I would too. But let's be realistic, they had laws, literature, organized politics, a state, and armed forces. They were an extremely urban civilization, with city-states that were the basis of everything. If that's not civilization, then I don't know what is. if we're going to judge "reconstructions," which occur with Gothic cathedrals and other structures in Europe, then nobody would pass the test.

See buildings in Chichen Itza were better preserved, and other contemporary artistic representations of the architecture are concrete evidence of this:
>>
>>18164215
Im Mexican, you retarded chicano.
>>
>>18164002
>>18164010
/his/ is filled with retarded sub 60 IQ /pol/trannies
we have both the foundations of Aztec ruins under Mexico city and the ruins of the city of Teotihuacan which we know for a fact that the Aztecs based Tenochtitlan off, not to mention 16th century codexes depicting the city itself
Being an anti-intellectual retard that denies evidence when it's literally right in front of them is not admirable, you can only argue in bad faith
>>
File: 20251115_195851.png (3.96 MB, 2912x2037)
3.96 MB
3.96 MB PNG
>>
>>18164222
>a retarded spic mongrel is being fucking retarded
riveting revelation!
>>
>>18164215
Eurotroons BTFO'd
>>
>>18164215
Teotihuacan is older than Oxford, and the Aztecs used bronze metallurgy, something that Europeans didn't invent on their own.
>>
>>18164235
Lmao from white knighting shit tier civilizations to being racist because his white savior complex was bruised. Typical tankie lmao
>>
>>18164175
You are cancer and a bane on human civilization. Incredulous science denying scum need to fuck off back to >>>/x/
>>
>>18164251
>le hecking problematic racism
kill yourself subhuman spic animal, moor rapebaby admixture in the americas was the worst tragedy in human history
>>
>>18164262
>The raped seething this hard
lol, buckbroken manlet rage
>>
>>18164175
Provide a refutation a refutation for the academic reconstruction or shut the fuck up incredulity is not an argument.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argument_from_incredulity
>>
File: 1450288275186.jpg (3.24 MB, 2488x3056)
3.24 MB
3.24 MB JPG
>>18164215
Mesoamericans had an impressive infrastructure, superior to certain European cities, with various palaces, ball courts, acropolises, roads, walls, bridges, and advanced hydraulic systems, which is my focus. These hydraulic systems were networks of canals, aqueducts, reservoirs, filtration systems, dikes, and dams with even switching mechanisms, in addition to toilets, and obviously, it was present in Tenochtitlán.
>>
>>18164175
kek
>>
>>18164285
Its hilarious how hard they seethe when you reject their canned responses since all they know is how to copy and paste lol
>>
>>18164271
you're a disgusting triracial mongrel, an aberration of nature
>>
>>18164281
>superior to certain European cities
>>
>>18164295
Seethe more Chicano. The odds of you being a jeet or worse grow larger by every seethe filled (you) you give us
>>
>>18164228
I made a whole thread destroying these maggots.
>>18163313
They are ruining this board and historic discourse online in general I loathe them.
>>
>>18164002
BASED THREAD BROVVN BVLLS MAKE THE BEST CIVILIZATION
>>
>>18164317
saaarrrr
>>
>>18164317
Still being shitty reconstructions
>>
>>18164320
One day a Chinese scientist will find out what makes short stubby browns like Chicanos or jeets seethe as much as they do
>>
>>18164316
Even jeets unironically have infinitely more racial pride than spics, spics are literally just mongrel cattle whose entire purpose in life is to be slaves, thankfully they have low fertility rates and are fucking retarded apes who can't stop killing each other, we don't need this subhuman """race""" to exist anymore
>>
File: Schizo.png (129 KB, 495x275)
129 KB
129 KB PNG
>>18164324
Provide a refutation for the academic reconstruction of Tenochtitlan or shut the fuck up incredulity is not an argument.
>>
File: moi.jpg (7 KB, 228x221)
7 KB
7 KB JPG
>>18164330
this is now a self-portrait thread
>>
>>18164335
I'm literally ironanon I post threads about the Germanics and refutations to anti-white memes and propaganda. I care about the truth I'm not a braindead tribalist who will deny evidence of a Mesoamerican city for my whypepo team or whatever that's just retarded. I believe in science that's it.
>>
>>18164281
Cortés, the iyaya one describing Tlaxcala:

>The city is indeed so great and marvellous.... It is much larger than Granada and much better fortified. Its houses are as fine and its inhabitants far more numerous... Its provisions and food are likewise very superior... There are gold, silver and precious stones, and jewellers' shops...as well arranged as in any market in the world. There is earthenware of many kinds...as fine as any in Spain. Wood, charcoal, medicinal and sweet smelling herbs are sold... There are booths for washing your hair... there are also public baths. Finally, good order and an efficient police system are maintained...and they behave as people of sense and reason.
>>
>>18164002
It couldn't have been that impressive given that Native Americans seem to average around an 85 IQ.
>>
>>18164175
He forgot to give us directions to Eldorado.
>>
>>18164353
Speaking of primary sources, Cassius Dio discusses Severus' campaign:

>There are two principal races of the Britons, the Caledonians and the Maeatae, and the names of the others have been merged in these two. The Maeatae live next to the cross-wall which cuts the island in half, and the Caledonians are beyond them. Both tribes inhabit wild and waterless mountains and desolate and swampy plains, and possess neither walls, cities, nor tilled fields, but live on their flocks, wild game, and certain fruits...They dwell in tents, naked and unshod, possess their women in common, and in common rear all the offspring. Their form of rule is democratic for the most part, and they are very fond of plundering; consequently they choose their boldest men as rulers....They can endure hunger and cold and any kind of hardship; for they plunge into the swamps and exist there for many days with only their heads above water, and in the forests they support themselves upon bark and roots, and for all emergencies they prepare a certain kind of food, the eating of a small portion of which, the size of a bean, prevents them from feeling either hunger or thirst
>>
>>18164364
We joke but he literally argued it before.
>>
>>18164222
Chicanos live rent free in your head because they don't have to heat their bathwater on the stove before they bathe LMFAO
>>
>>18164353
>The city is indeed so great and marvellous.... It is much larger than Granada and much better fortified
>>
Lol Didn't anyone notice the little insect subtly provoking Europeans? Are you all that amateurish? Most of these MesoboringAmerica threads are made to provoke Europeans haha.
>>
>>18164393
no one replied because we know it's (You), faggot
>>
>>18164240
>>18164248
OP sameflaging
>>
File: unnamed.jpg (101 KB, 512x344)
101 KB
101 KB JPG
>>18164371
All of that bullshit is refuted by archaeology spic.
>possess neither walls
You literally posted a pictish settlement with walls beaner lmao
>nor tilled fields
Um no? they most definitely had agriculture that's bullshit
>They dwell in tents
Absolute horseshit the Britons lived in roundhouses sometimes multistory or stone ones, they also built massive structures called brochs that had internal staircases.
>>
>>18164371
>cities
Ok lets go you may not consider picrel to be a city but the Gauls most definitely had cities gigantic and sophisticated ones.
>>
>>18164400
You SOB, I'm not the OP. This guy made this same thread last month. Look at desuarchive.org and stop being retarded.
>>
>>18164410
Looks crap when compared to Tenochtitlan
>>18164018
Another thread you ruined with your racism.
>>
>>18164412
>last month
sorry, I'm not a permaonline virgin so I missed that
>>
>sees a stack of rocks built by browns
>"th-this is supposed to provoke me o algo"
Severe level of depressive mental illness.
>>
>>18164371
Does this look like a tent to you? that swarthoid slimeball Cassius Dio was either deliberately lying or he is misidentifying the celts as the Fenni(iron age Sami) these kinds of mistakes would have been easy in antiquity.
>>
>>18164393
Most are made by jeets we know
>>
>>18164410
they built those on hills so when rain falls it takes all the shit to the lowest level occupied by autists, though I guess during summer the whole place must have STANK when steam began to rise in the morning
>>
>>18164018
>it's not a civilization when they were violent
Why do /pol/trannies always parrot this line? Pretty much every ancient eurotranny civilization was just as if not more violent. It's still a civilization.
>>
>>18164415
>Looks crap when compared to Tenochtitlan
Ok so what about Amsterdam you dishonest spic? yeah you wish this didn't exist do you? That's a fairer comparison because it's the same time period.
>Another thread you ruined with your racism.
You are the anti-white racist you started posting this shit >>18164371
>>18164157
>>
>>18164420
sources never lie
>>
>>18164432
>sources never lie
Are you claiming that iron age Britons didn't have agriculture? be careful now because I will utterly humiliate you. show me archaeological evidence of tents.
>>
And since I know it's mesofag or someone loser from the MLGBT+ community, I researched what "iyaya" meant. I thought it was some kind of Latin word or Mexican insult, means to "stink" even after Almost 504 years have passed since the conquest of Tenochcrap, and Cortez still harbors hatred among these people.
>>
>>18164430
He's a typical jeet and leftist who claims racism but when confronted by any opposition will result in using actual racism >>18164295 lmao
>>
>>18164371
Learn the difference lol
>>
>>18164438
of course not. sources are unreliable, as you say now yourself, and so are paintings. archaeology gives the final verdict
>>
File: Spic is scared now.png (273 KB, 947x684)
273 KB
273 KB PNG
>>18164432
What do these look like to you? they are British from the iron age.
>>
>>18164439
mesofag is so despicable with the arrogance of posing as
>I know everything about Mesoamerican, bro! I'm the best!

Besides having a bias, but I'm not sure if it's this monster, it could be his friends.
>>
>>18164430
I m not the OP
>>
>>18164443
Oh get fucked >>>/x/. If archaeology corroborates an ancient source for instance as it has with Tacitus then that source is reliable. Learn what corroborating evidence is nitwit.
Cassius Dio may have been misidentifying the Britons as the Fenni.
>Their villages are not arranged in our fashion, with the buildings connected and joined together; each man leaves a space around his house, either as a precaution against fire or because they are unacquainted with building in stone. They use unhewn timber for all their structures, without elegance or skill, but merely piled together to meet the needs of the moment.”
— Tacitus, Germania 16
Everything tacitus is saying here is almost 100% spot on and what archaeologists have found in excavations although they did occasionally hewn timber.
>>
>>18164453
I just performed an exorcism on you. So long, lil zoom zoom
>>
>>18164432
Did naked tent dwelling swamp monkeys make this? hmmm...
>>
>>18164458
they stole it from eldorado
>>
File: Johann_Liss_006.jpg (581 KB, 1280x1548)
581 KB
581 KB JPG
>>18164233
Mayans had high ANE ancestry, so this just proves biological determinism.
Its just like when southern europeans show that germanics weren't civilized like 2000 years ago, but at the end of the day romans and germanics were all from the same race.
That's why germanics have also produced things like this.
>>
>>18164453
Slave houses
>>
>>18164117
>See the tepoztli, for example, It likely penetrated the skulls of some Europeans
Orale
>>
>>18164371
So it seems like this comes from tropes and hearsay it's basically the equivalent of the modern "africans were all stone age hunter-gatherers cliche"
Cassius Dio never even visited the north of britain.
>>
POV:
This civilization is, like, unique, right? It developed in a totally different way from others, it's more fantastic and surreal than many fantasy races. Tenochtitlan and Teotihuacan are literally some of the coolest cities in human history. They had hardcore violent and luxurious practices, but also giant gardens, poetry, and high-level sanitation systems. But, of course, most people, and especially Europeans, don't even care. And when someone mentions it, it's only to discuss politics or cultural or racial war... here we are. People impersonating me, using Roman sources or something else.

And you'll forever know how incredible and underrated this civilization is, and you'll be frustrated by the lack of information and the poor treatment by pop culture, in short, KYS.
>>
File: 2486935.jpg (187 KB, 960x634)
187 KB
187 KB JPG
>>18164462
No that's a middle iron age settlement those are average Germanic houses with the big longhouse being the chieftains. You're thinking of the viking era but their architecture varied a lot depending on where you were in Germania in the Netherlands there were really impressive longhouses of enormous sizes as well as in Scandinavia picrel.
>>
File: Massive germanic house.png (656 KB, 1066x963)
656 KB
656 KB PNG
>>18164485
Colossal longhouse from the Netherlands.
>>
>>18164482
Its only the the creatures of the cold feminist peninsula who hate Mesoamerican history, mesofag is the best thing that ever happened here, I would bow down to him, and these spammers>>18164010
>>18164018
>>18164029
should be ignored, let's continue the thread the Mesoamerican community of /his/ is not haplotard>>18164461
or schizophrenic>>18164420
>>
>>18164491
Off topic, please
>>
>>18164496
molon lave, visicucks!!!
>>
>>18164496
Don't be a filthy smelly racist spic then ok spic? I derailed your thread because you started talking shit about the British and white people like a spiteful envious brownoid.
>>18164499
Talk shit get hit
>>
>>18164482
>it's only to discuss politics or cultural or racial war
>>
>>18164509
>your thread
I'm not the OP
Cope
>>
>>18164496
Is this schizophrenic did I imagine this into existence spic?
>>
>>18164002

This pathetic city, besides being smelly, was written on a disgusting river After ChristianCuckery, things only got worse.
>>
File: 1569758586260.jpg (3.6 MB, 5000x1951)
3.6 MB
3.6 MB JPG
>>18164516
>was written on a disgusting river
>written
ESL
Tenochtitlán was founded on a swampy, uninhabited island in the middle of a lake, a place no one wanted to occupy due to the harsh conditions. The argument that Europeans use about the climate and soil being unsuitable for the population apparently doesn't apply to the Mexica, right? It was precisely this lack of interest that allowed the Mexica to build their city there. It's interesting to note that the rest of the Valley of Mexico was already occupied by other city-states, but the specific island where Tenochtitlán was built remained practically deserted until the Mexica transformed it into a great city. This story of finding an "unsuitable" place and transforming it into something incredible is quite emblematic of the Mexica's capacity for adaptation and resilience, compared to northern Europe.
>>
File: azshrek.jpg (161 KB, 1132x789)
161 KB
161 KB JPG
>>18164002
>pialli, we are civilized monists
>everything is unified in origin and essence
>popular god cults are symbolism for the commoners
>now please ascend our blood-soaked pyramid steps, where we will rip your heart out, eat you, wear your skin, and display your skull so that the sun will rise tomorrow
>also the kids need to be crying when we kill them or the rains won't come
>but teotl is just an abstract energy permeating the universe o algo

uh
>>
>>18164518
What you don't mention is how shallow lake Texcoco was it wasn't the incredible feat you think it was.
>harsh conditions
Lmao explain them. It had a warm mediterranean climate like Italy where Rome was birthed. Absolute horseshit nothing was harsh about that region.
>>
>>18164521
I could spend hours showing evidence of European ritual sacrifice and even some aspects of ritual zoophilia, but I'll stick to refuting that partially, because I have to leave for now.
Yes, the Mexica people practiced human sacrifice, but it wasn't exactly as Hollywood or Reddit likes to portray it. They weren't sadistic monsters who found pleasure in the pain and suffering of others. In fact, the victims often received good care before the ritual, and there was a certain cooperation involved, showing that it wasn't all about senseless brutality.

And, contrary to what many believe, human sacrifices were not the foundation of Mexica society. They had a complex religious and metaphysical worldview that included this practice, but it ***wasn't***the center of everything. In fact, sacrifices were more common in state capitals than in smaller towns and villages.

And let's be honest: most sacrifices were of enemy warriors captured in battle, not random innocents. Yes, it was a violent practice, but it was part of a context of war and politics. And, apparently, not even Tenochtitlán, the capital, carried out sacrifices on an "industrial scale" as some like to say.

So perhaps it's time to revise the cope, isn't?
>>
>>18164518
Mesoamerican are to superior than eurozoos
>>
File: White people.jpg (379 KB, 1200x800)
379 KB
379 KB JPG
>>18164549
Lmao this level of cope while using a phone designed by Europeans.
>>
>>18164425
its not civilized when they eat people, its barbaric. A barbaric civilization, not a civilized civilization.
>>
>>18164022
I really want this to be like google earth so I can fly around and have a look at everything
>>
>>18164541
Ok sorry
>>
>>18164573
they eat people in Serbia
>>
>>18164585.
OK. Western europe didn't really become civilized until the enlightenment. Eastern europe still not really into it
>>
>>18164425
>Pretty much every ancient eurotranny civilization was just as if not more violent
No they weren't and when Europeans tortured people it was because of an extreme sense of justice not the same as pulling that heart out of an innocent child to bring the rains and do the same barbaric sadistic shit to tens of thousands more. The Spanish did a good thing wiping out these savages, I can see their blood still flows through the veins of modern Mexicans with all that evil cartel shit.
>>
>>18164585
>they eat people in Serbia
Source?
>>
>>18164592
>No they weren't and when Europeans tortured people it was because of an extreme sense of justice not the same as pulling that heart out of an innocent
See>>18164541
>>
>>18164600
Eurocuck is coping
>>
>>18164600
Would you be ok with having your heart ripped while fully conscious? if you're not ok with that you wouldn't want to live in this evil society. The Spanish described Tenochtitlan smelling like death honestly what a hellish place this was.
>>
>>18164541
>they practiced such innocent gentle human sacrifice that every single one of their neighbours rallied around 500 spaniards on the run from the law to topple them
>>
>>18164604
There's no coping we tortured people because they did something wrong and we never tortured children.
>In 1581, the German serial killer Christman Genipperteinga remained conscious for nine days on the breaking wheel before expiring, having been deliberately kept alive with "strong drink"
See it was about justice not cruel ogga bogga shit.
>>
>>18164599
https://www.lemonde.fr/en/international/article/2022/05/20/the-serbian-mafia-s-house-of-horror_5984146_4.html

haven't read this specific article, but in case it doesn't mention, they minced some of them into sort of mini burgers and ate them
>>
>>18164609
Yeah he's full of shit. Tenochtitlan was cool and impressive but not even he would want to live there it was a society obsessed with death and torture.
>>
File: 970_01_2.jpg (113 KB, 725x526)
113 KB
113 KB JPG
>>18164615
>comparing random rare example of criminals being degenerates to a common practice in aztec society
Yeah makes sense.
>>
>>18164197
>yet when Euros conquered le heckin brown and black cities they totally tore it down brick by brick lmao
Nobody says that except for when it comes to very specific buildings like temple pyramids, which they did usually tear down for fairly obvious reasons. Most cities and towns in Mexico and Peru today are built upon a pre-columbian population center, with many, including Mexico City itself, having very visible traces of its pre-columbian buildings still standing, to about the same extent any modernized middle eastern city does. A handful, like Cuzco, are basically intact,buildings with Inca foundations in active use being everywhere over there alongside the famous Sacsayhuaman fortress on its outskirts, just search for any picture of an old cuzco street really, it's not hard
>>
>>18164609
The Spaniards having allies had absolutely nothing to do with human sacrifice, though. After all, all virtually culturally and religiously identical to the Aztecs and practiced human sacrifice themselves, in fact some of Cortez' men who would later join rival factions even accused him of allowing said allies to continue sacrificing and eating people until after the conquest. Long story short, in reality, it was a matter of politics and nothing more (the idea that their neighbors all just immediately rallied around the spaniards the way you think they did isn't accurate either), If you desire, i will talk about it in detail just for you, it's pretty interesting actually
>>18164619
There was nothing to fear if you were just a random aztec citizen living in Tenochtitlan. they didn't randomly drag people off the street to be sacrificed. Really the only way you as a Mexica citizen could be sacrificed by your own people is if you managed to somehow become a slave



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.