[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / r / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/ic/ - Artwork/Critique

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


🎉 Happy Birthday 4chan! 🎉


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: 1733115422285917.jpg (2.66 MB, 956x5863)
2.66 MB
2.66 MB JPG
Be sure to bother patch about registration to put your art in:
https://towergirls.booru.org/index.php

Post-free dice rolling tool that you'll ignore:
https://www.random.org/

Previous Thread: >>7422496
>>
File: 1733115538161527.png (2.67 MB, 956x5250)
2.67 MB
2.67 MB PNG
>>
File: 1733115570703772.png (2.73 MB, 1104x4970)
2.73 MB
2.73 MB PNG
>>
I will not draw i just wanna see what i get
>>
roll em
>>
towerboys?
>>
File: Crest.png (460 KB, 1250x1000)
460 KB
460 KB PNG
I got the head lol
>>
File: Crest.png (561 KB, 1475x1000)
561 KB
561 KB PNG
>>7717921
Tidied it up a bit.
>>
>>7717817
roll
>>
If I get a furry I'm out
>>
>>7718142
Coward.
>>
>>7717921
This is very ugly.

But very clean, I'm impressed. Didn't think /ic/ appreciated clean artwork
>>
>>7718280
Is she still ugly after the cleanup? :') >>7718065
>>
>>7718284
This looks better than what I usually see on /ic/ for sure I'm just not a fan of the nose and that Futurama- escque connection to the mouth. On the second one I'm not a fan of the pout muscles being accentuated on the contour of the face like that.

It's my personal taste though. Technically it's a solid drawing.
>>
>>7717817
Rollan
>>7718065
Really like the use of a round brush for the lineart, soft and kinda see-through so it doesn't get that typical harsh lineart look. Might create a similar brush and experiment. Very nice drawing anon.
>>
>>7718654
Thank you. Idk idk if you use Sai but if you do I can share the brush settings. It's a textured round brush with pressure enabled and about 85% opacity.
>>
>>7718806
Appreciate it! I'm on CSP but round brush with pressure works for me to figure something out.
>>
>>7717817
In the name of loomis
>>
>>7718880
I... Got the dragon?
>>
>>7718882
We all look forward to seeing your dragon :) (you better commit!)
>>
>>7717817
rollin
>>
>>7717817
rol1
>>
File: raptor1.png (168 KB, 941x1000)
168 KB
168 KB PNG
>>7719151
Not too big on raptor girls, so I did this one pretty quick.
>>
roll
>>
>>7719229
Aha, this is dope. I'd like to see it cleaned up. The shadow is dope.
>>
File: twinWIP.png (254 KB, 1185x1185)
254 KB
254 KB PNG
>>7719413
Thank you! I doubt I'll get to it, but I appreciate it.

>>7718065
I have really liked your art ever since I first saw it.
>>
>>7719963
Hehe, those posts are both me, and thank you. What's this next drawing gonna be?
>>
File: dfdsfsdfdsgfhg.png (141 KB, 1149x853)
141 KB
141 KB PNG
>>7720052
>Hehe, those posts are both me, and thank you.
:O
I rolled the twins on my last image, so it will be them in a POV cityscape, holding the knight's hands. I'm not sure I'll be able to do a whole illustration, but I'll at least do the line art.

Still have to figure out what to do with the outside hands.
>>
File: Moff..png (277 KB, 571x1000)
277 KB
277 KB PNG
>>7720959
>twins
Double the punishment lol, rip. Looking forward to seeing it though.

I rolled against and got moth.
>>
File: prism.png (1.16 MB, 1538x2000)
1.16 MB
1.16 MB PNG
Utterly troublesome roll. Let's hope the next one is something easier.
>>
>>7721467
Came out fantastic, lovely work on the stance of the splayed feet especially. What's the next one then? Gonna take the roll from your post?
>>
>>7721927
Thanks, bro. Though I feel like I could have come up with something more clever with the dress. I was too sleepy when finishing it.
>Gonna take the roll from your post?
That was the plan, or maybe I'll use this post >:)
>>
>>7721467
>>7721437
>>7720959
you guys are very good at art, why aren't you in other threads?
>>
File: twinWIP2.png (251 KB, 1000x1000)
251 KB
251 KB PNG
Decided to scrap the knight hands and blocked out some lighting + background.

>>7721437
We love moth. Looking good, lol.

>>7721467
Looks great! I love the braid, I always struggle drawing those.

>>7722242
I used to post a bunch, but I've been pretty busy the past few months. I just got the itch to draw a tower girl, lo and behold, the thread was up!
>>
>>7722242
>>7721467
Idk what threads you're on but I post all the time in other threads, I just don't like posting WIP's so I'm not as active as some people.
>>7722276
Thanks, pal. I like the way you're doing the hair as well.
>>
>>7722242
I'm >>7721437 and usually frequent /alt/ and /salt/, sometimes the regular draw threads.

>>7722276
>I just got the itch to draw a tower girl, lo and behold, the thread was up!

That was meeeeee! I used to participate in the Tower Girls threads all time, but the person who was responsible for making new ones suddenly stopped. I checked the archives the other day and I realised that there hadn't been a new one since like February or something, so I think I'll try and be the one to maintain them going forward.

I love these threads as they provide a way to be able to relax whilst drawing whilst the rolls mean often you'll end up with a design that mean you get pushed into drawing things you're unfamiliar with. I really want to figure out a way to revive the Booru as well but I don't know about any alternative hosts.

(additionally, cannot believe I've never thought about drawing the knight into the pictures before. I'm gonna start copying you)
>>
>>7717817
roll
>>
I wanna fuck the book
>>
roll
>>
File: twinWIP3.png (503 KB, 1000x1000)
503 KB
503 KB PNG
>>7722344
>Thanks, pal. I like the way you're doing the hair as well.
B-)

>>7722376
>That was meeeeee!
My hero
>I'm gonna start copying you
:u no, my signiture! /s
>>
>>7718065
me when i put all the points on anything but appeal. also rol
>>
>>7723507
me when i'm wrong
>>
>>7723511
shut the fuck up
>>
>>7723543
wow, so you literally traced over another artist's work, flipped the canvas, and tried to claim your generic version is somehow better. maybe this would have been more impressive had you not plagiarized someone's work to create an inferior verison. try coming up with your own ideas, it'll help you improve as an artist.
>>
>>7723507
>>7723543
>rolls sword princess
>traces somebody else art instead

Did you think everybody would clap.
>>
>>7723551
>>7723553
>redline some trash to show appeal
"NOOO ANON U SUCK FOR TRACING HAHA"
Your next line is: you are one of the people that hates me because im a woman XD
You can go to aco if you don't like critique
>>
roll'n
>>
>>7723576
This thread is for drawing princesses.
>>
roll
>>
>>7723576
Your little act of plagiarism isn't appealing though, and you didn't even bother to colour it which is an essential element of the princess designs. You took another artist's work, overlayed it, traced directly on top of it, didn't even bother to change the perspective, orientation, or even the direction of the folds of the hair, completely bastardized what was a visually interesting design and replaced it with generic, sameface slop, and then tried to argue that it was a superior work. You lack creativity and can't even come up with your own ideas, so you piggyback off of others.

Incredibly, nobody's give a shit about the wet, fetid hole between your legs. Believe it or not not there are other women on this board besides you. Go away and dilate your stench trench, moid.
>>
>>7723543
this really isn't the win you think it is. you just look like somebody incapable of creating your own art.

why didn't you do your actual roll?
>>
>>7723623
I'm not the anon who drew that but ok, no one care about this thread, go back to aco nigger
>>
File: princs.png (243 KB, 512x512)
243 KB
243 KB PNG
>>7723580
It's so bad :|
>>
>>7717817
They see me rollin
>>
>>7724053
Me when I lie.

She's cute!
>>
>>7724053
This is excellent anon.
>>
roll
>>
>>7723543
I think you're just mad he didn't draw tranime.
>>
File: Saurus princess.png (1.79 MB, 1395x1513)
1.79 MB
1.79 MB PNG
>>7718654
Kinda gave up on this but atleast it got made.
>>
>>7725440
The addition of a background is a nice touch, it looks great :D
>>
File: neymar-soccer.gif (1.35 MB, 220x220)
1.35 MB
1.35 MB GIF
>>7717817
Rolling
>>
>>7725672
Thanks anon! Hopefully more princesses are to come.
(also roll)
>>
File: tower.png (1.69 MB, 2000x2000)
1.69 MB
1.69 MB PNG
>>7721467
>>7722220
>>
>>7717817
rolll
>>
roll no furry pls
>>
File: twinWIP4.png (338 KB, 1000x1000)
338 KB
338 KB PNG
I never do urban environments, does anybody have any advice for those? Feeling a little out of my depth lol.
>>
File: afrozenheartmelted.png (282 KB, 784x1000)
282 KB
282 KB PNG
>>7723505
A quick princess so this thread isn't flooded by my WIPs
>>
Roll
>>
Rolling Rolling Rolling
>>
File: rust_menace.png (359 KB, 733x1000)
359 KB
359 KB PNG
>>7727317
>>
File: Scorpion princess.png (488 KB, 1931x1681)
488 KB
488 KB PNG
>>7726362
Might ink later but fun to draw a princess I've not drawn since 2017
>>
>>7728605
The realistic scorpion hurts me (good job). Looks good!
>>
>>7728062
Cute princess! Adding a story-telling scene was also a smart idea, gives the piece some identity. Having a story in mind really gets my creativity going when drawing a character.
>>
>>7717817
I'm not good enough to make anything decent as a beg but trying can't hurt

Rolliiinnn
>>
File: 1729570381916.jpg (1.21 MB, 1800x4000)
1.21 MB
1.21 MB JPG
>>7729332
Here is my go at the halfling princess, as a total /beg it didn't come out too bad?
>>
rrrrrrOOOOLLLLIN
>>
>>7729167
Thanks! Focused more on the scorp rather than the human part but atleast it was fun.
>>7729339
Now keep rollan! Try out some more portraits or even full body if oyu feel like it.
>>
>>7729501
I'll give another roll tomorrow, I'm not good enough for full body, but some bad portraits I can manage lol
>>
>>7729277
Thank you!

>>7729339
Not bad for a total /beg, the face is in proportion and in-line. Keep it up!
>>
>>7730082
Let's roll another one.
>>
>>7730082
Let's roll another one....
>>
File: 1742310447792.jpg (1016 KB, 1800x4000)
1016 KB
1016 KB JPG
>>7730222
Turned out very awful, but I'm not even sure how a moth girl is supposed to look
>>
File: Moth2.png (427 KB, 686x1000)
427 KB
427 KB PNG
>>7730232
It's cool, I rolled Moth too and I'm thinking about just scrapping it altogether cause I hate how it came out. It's a tricky design to be fair, and the colour palette is one of the more difficult I've ever had to work with.

You should try a fullbody sketch next time. Have you ever considered investing in a tablet as well? The Wacom Intuos are very accessible and affordable. I use one in Medium for my own art.
>>
>>7730332
Wow this is amazing! I have a graphic tablet but I mainly draw in lunch break at work and I'm not using it.... Even at home until I get better lol
>>
>>7730332
dam how do you draw this fast? Been drawing for a while and this kinda of stuff takes me ages hours. I got the twins and im barley though the sketch and youv already done 2.
>>
>>7717817
Fun exercise
>>
>>7730332
>>7717921
>>7718065
Blog?
>>
>>7717817
idk man i just think the jews
>>
>>7717817
Couldnt bring myself to draw something more elaborate, tomorrow ill try a better draw because absolute radiance is beating my ass and i spend all my energy into that
>>
File: oracle1.png (244 KB, 677x919)
244 KB
244 KB PNG
>>7728062
Late night fill

>>7730332
Love how you did the wings

>>7730427
Nice on the angle. The crown looks especially good.

>>7730895
Cute
>>
Last roll
>>
File: 1734302340126.jpg (1.48 MB, 1800x2143)
1.48 MB
1.48 MB JPG
>>7730987
Not feeling very lucky with my rolls but they make you draw things I would never think about lol

There's something really wrong with the drawing but I back spot it exactly
>>
>>7730989
Dawg she's cute af what are you talking about!
>>
First ever roll on this thing give me a cool one.
>>
>>7730906
Thank you I tried
>>
File: Illustration22.png (3.52 MB, 2667x3334)
3.52 MB
3.52 MB PNG
This pose almost made me surrender but I pushed through.
Cute stuff is not my style so that was a challenge in itself
Anyway let’s roll again
>>
>>7723620
Wont finish it. It had potential though.
>>
File: cantbefucked.jpg (840 KB, 1254x1473)
840 KB
840 KB JPG
>>7731726
FUCK.
>>
File: 1014-harpy.png (51 KB, 1250x1092)
51 KB
51 KB PNG
>>7731014
>>
File: princs2.png (638 KB, 600x800)
638 KB
638 KB PNG
>>7724053
These are kinda fun
>>
>>7731699
Couple of cuties, nice work on pushing through!
>>7731728
Damn that's some big potential right there. I get it tho sometimes the princess you get don't hit.
>>7731751
Really like the style of your harpy, nice use of colour and implied texture.
>>7731836
Awooooga, great character acting in the pose and look.
>>
File: princs3.png (866 KB, 1024x1024)
866 KB
866 KB PNG
>>7731836

>>7731751
This is really cute
>>
File: roll.png (148 KB, 1000x1000)
148 KB
148 KB PNG
>>7717817
Drawings here are insane but this thread needs more mob face sexo
>>
roll
>>
roll
>>
File: twinWIP5.png (444 KB, 1000x1000)
444 KB
444 KB PNG
>>7731699
Woah. Twins! I like the difference in character between them, very cute.

>>7731751
I love how you draw. The composition is great.

>>7727301
Backgrounds are kinda hard ngl.
>>
>>7724053
Are you NotFuji?
>>
>>7733714
Yeah, that's probably obvious
>>
File: dancewithdeath.png (1.03 MB, 777x1000)
1.03 MB
1.03 MB PNG
>>7730906
Quick late night skeleton.
>>
File: Cave princess export.png (1.76 MB, 2250x2000)
1.76 MB
1.76 MB PNG
>>7729501
Feel like I could work a bit more in this one but at the same time I wanna go back to practicing
>>
>>7733740
>>7733994
These are both excellent, well done.

Love the line work on the skelly, and the rendering on cave princess is superb.
>>
roll
>>
File: sfup.png (142 KB, 681x487)
142 KB
142 KB PNG
>>7734995
>Love the line work on the skelly
Thank you!

>>7733687
>>7733740
>>7735789
Doodling out a few I didn't care for.
>>
File: Selkie.png (554 KB, 1000x1000)
554 KB
554 KB PNG
>>7732722
I got her, right? First time doing this.

Another roll also.
>>
>>7734995
>the rendering on cave princess is superb
Thanks for the kind words!
>>7735810
Lmao I also skipped a few rolls.
>>7735900
Yeah you got it right, Very cute scene while also staying true to the original style good work!
>>
>>7717817
rollllll
>>
Roll
>>
roll
>>
File: t.jpg (78 KB, 424x600)
78 KB
78 KB JPG
>>7736485
>>
File: IMG_0886.jpg (103 KB, 1290x1355)
103 KB
103 KB JPG
>>7718065
This looks really good but this here is throwing me off. It looks like a side-eyelid.
>>
File: IDUNO.mp4 (364 KB, 1474x1000)
364 KB
364 KB MP4
>>7736632
Not the artist, but I didnt see anything wrong there. The issue I saw was with the other eye, though its extremely minor I think, since the face is squished on its right side from touching the ground. I dunno.
>>
File: gargirl.png (771 KB, 692x1000)
771 KB
771 KB PNG
>>7735810

>>7735900
Looks great

>>7736626
CUTE
>>
File: CANDY.png (340 KB, 869x978)
340 KB
340 KB PNG
>>7736807
I think this has taught me that I need to learn how to paint lol
>>
>>7736632
>>7736675
Original artist here. squished into the floor is exactly what I was trying to do. Heads are heavy things without support :>
>>
File: IMG_0889.jpg (170 KB, 800x1028)
170 KB
170 KB JPG
>>7736675
Look at the side of the eye. You see how it gets darker as the skin goes further into the eye socket (because not as much light reaches it), and the skin only gets brighter at the eyelid, as it's closer and not as far back into socket?
In this drawing >>7736632 you see skin at the side of the eye that's brighter than what's further right, and so it looks like there's "normal" skin that's not the eyelid, which isn't something humans have.
>>
>>7736970
Ahhh, I get you now, I was looking at the left side. I'd say artist is going minimalist on these, so little misses to be expected.
>>
File: fox.jpg (168 KB, 1285x1000)
168 KB
168 KB JPG
Gave it a try, feels pretty unfinished but i dont really know what to do anymore
>>
>>7717817
Rollin'
>>
File: IMG_4243.jpg (1.99 MB, 1248x1751)
1.99 MB
1.99 MB JPG
Lost interest half way :(
>>
>>7738093
OH MY LOOORD LEMME GET A PEICE OF THAT CHICKEN
>>
>>7717817
woll
>>
Roll
>>
File: IMG_4246.jpg (1.98 MB, 1380x1988)
1.98 MB
1.98 MB JPG
I cheated a bit
>>
>>7738093
>>7739307
Can I have your socials? These are lovely.
>>
File: 20250927_195915.jpg (144 KB, 1005x1657)
144 KB
144 KB JPG
>>
Roll.
>>
File: Illustration23.jpg (865 KB, 2667x3334)
865 KB
865 KB JPG
>>7731699
Ok this what I got for imp
Turned out ok, I gotta get my colors a lot better. I think it looked better before I added them and was just line work
>>
File: GpKAVPtW0AAoB1A.jpg (229 KB, 1362x2000)
229 KB
229 KB JPG
>>7739808
this is the art style id like to get to but boy do I feel far off
>>
>>7717817
rollan
>>
File: 1728973255249198.png (1.37 MB, 2313x2113)
1.37 MB
1.37 MB PNG
>>7739823
>>
>>7717817
Roll!
>>
File: Screenshot_1.png (1.15 MB, 675x903)
1.15 MB
1.15 MB PNG
>>7740576
:p
>>
File: witch.jpg (1.5 MB, 1760x2488)
1.5 MB
1.5 MB JPG
>>7717817
i was gonna do the thorns but fuck spending 8 hours on that
>>
>>7718948
I was prepping for exams lol
Took a break
I hope it's alright
>>
Roll
>>
File: mum.png (640 KB, 600x800)
640 KB
640 KB PNG
>>7732668
>>
File: uuiouiyyuiyuiuyi.png (1.84 MB, 1538x1700)
1.84 MB
1.84 MB PNG
>>7730895
>>7717817
I came back
>>
>>7742105
>>7739916
>>7738093
>>7736626
>>7731836
Blogs?
>>
>>7741663
>>7743480
These are brilliant.

This might actually be the best Tower Girls thread I've participated in, so many great fills.
>>
File: Day Elf.png (642 KB, 811x1500)
642 KB
642 KB PNG
Might have taken a few liberties with this one, but I like the idea of an elf being surrounded by annoying woodland animals whilst just trying to get through their shitty day job.
>>
>>7743822
pretty nice but looks like tr00n a bit
>>
>>7743877
Look man, some of those patients get heavy.
>>
Roll
>>
roll
>>
>>7743822
Hello Mr. Scotland sir, I think you should indicate some separation between her hair and her hand, to a avoid a tangent that at first glance makes it unclear that the bird is the one lifting her ponytail.
>>
>>7743822
Honestly, what's the trick? before i would claim that your lines are good and that you have some sort of fundies, but i realized that you probably just put the stabilization on 100%.
Every decision on this piece is bad, redlining this would mean re-doing the whole thing but here are some points.
-That creamy color on her eye really becomes an ugly contrast because the eyebrow is almost the same tone.
-The nose is too low, making you put less space for the mouth, this translate to the leafy chin who looks funny, the eyes are misaligned and the whole proportions of the face are weird.
-The hat colores are too saturated
-Arms proportions are all over the place,
-Tits hanging from the end of the ribs instead of the pecs
-Ass have the shape of a male, if that's your thing ok, but the blush on the cheeks make it look like she has a brush from sitting more than cute, the cut of the ass line on the panties is atrocious
-Legs are weird shaped and i doubt this will make any sense if you try to finish them
>>
>>7744310
man shut the fuck up and post your work nobody asked for your opinion
>>
>>7744310
Anons will just say anything to hate on this guy.
>>
>>7739808
How do I get lines like this? What am i doing wrong?
>>7743822
>>
>>7744316
Yes orta, tell him, how dare he critique in my critique board
>>
i'm not good enough yet, i just want to know which maiden it would be if i were to rescue one. i'd give it a go after october though
>>
>>7744630
Ntayrt but make your lines way thinner, compare to your goal where the lines are about the same color as the surrounding material, much subtler and more variation in line width.
>>
File: Day Elf (1).png (1.71 MB, 2162x4000)
1.71 MB
1.71 MB PNG
>>7744697
That isn't me, but it is somewhat refreshing that other users see this for the parochial, end-of-the-pier chimp-out disguised as unsolicited critique that it is.

Anyway, please stop stalking me. I promise you that if you take all of that time you waste gooning over me and redirect it into your art, you might actually have a slim chance of improving! There's a sticky for beginners pinned at the top of the board, I think you'll find it quite useful. No need to thank me btw, I like being helpful :3c

>>7744630
I've attached a higher res copy of my linework if you want to look at it closer.

I use a custom brush in Sai, but it's pretty easily replicable in other programs. It's just a pencil brush with a chalky/graphite texture with pen pressure applied and some blur. I also practice line weighting, so I spend a lot of time with the eraser cleaning up lines, making them thinner in places, thicker in places etc.

>>7744770
Looking forward to it.
>>
>>7744280
Sorry, I'm dumb and I can't see it. Can you redline it for me? :')
>>
>>7744310
Pretty much every element of this is just you complaining about stylistic choices. "Legs are weird" is not proper critique. Either pyw or gtfo.
>>
Rollin
>>
>>7744697
not the artist i just fucking hate unsolicited critique disguising shitting on someone's art

notice how literally no one else is getting critiqued like that ? weird i thought this was the critique board

>>7744869
i've noticed some people have a hard on for you which i guess is a complement but really annoying when you don't ask for it

good art btw
>>
>>7744869
how do you make the color not bleed out when using the magic wand or bucket fill?
>>
>>7744869
Very amateurish, the coloring is all wrong.
-It really messes with the eyes when the skin and hair are the same color.
-I also feel it was bad judgement on your part to then also make the background the same exact color.
-You even made her colothes the same color!! White!! Very embarrassing.

-I suggest you make her skin a brownish color while making her hair whiteish to create a nice contrast.
-You should then color her hat and shirt in pink to create a beautiful trigonometry of colors; with accessories colored in dark blueish.
>>
>>7743822
Please start posting your works on one of your blogs, I love your stuff, but I'm not sure if I love it as much as I hate this board
>>
>>7744948
>>7745085
discord trannies think they are not noticeable lmao
>>
>>7745418
cope
>>
>>7744869
why you crying about crits on critique board
>>
>>7745848
It is a crit board, but artist was valid since this samefag is giving "crit" without being asked and without knowing how to give crit properly. "Oh this is graffiti, but it should really be more formal realistic figure study ... because its atrocious" - what the fuck is someone meant to do with this kind of statement? Is that crit to you?

>"Every decision on this piece is bad"
The artist has a unique style that some enjoy seeing. This dude, rather than simply saying "I hate your style", tries to dress up whatever the fuck complex emotion they're feeling as a list of fixes to make the picture objectively better, but most of the points are just things they'd personally like changed for a better jerk off session.
>>
>>7745881
it's a polarizing style, some people seem to like it, just as many people dislike it. stylefags always hide behind "it's just my style". it looks objectively ugly to me so I get why he gets critiqued for it. wasted potential since the rendering is good.
>>
>>7745902
I hope that one day you get to a level where you'll understand anon. That's all I can say, and I promise you that i'm not being a pretentious "stylefag" in saying that.
>>
>>7745919
it get it, it's still just an excuse to reject all crit
>>
>>7745923
Was gonna say PYW but you'd never do that, so have a good night.
>>
>>7745923
The thing is, it's not really crit. Crit isn't just listing out flaws. You have to understand what the artist was going for and weigh their decisions based on their own intentions for the piece. Otherwise it's irrelevant nonsense. That the artist didn't make something to your personal taste is not a valid critique.

At least give reasoning for why certain decisions don't work. "The hat is too saturated". Ok, on what metric? Compared to what? Why is that bad? It's complaining for complaining's sake. Those who actually want to help give help, they don't just tear people down.
>>
>>7745966
you're describing high effort crit, low effort crit is still crit. the artist can decide if it's valid or not but based on his reaction, he won't take any advice. you see where someone is coming from by their crit, but you don't have to take their advice if it's not what you are going for.

>At least give reasoning for why certain decisions don't work. "The hat is too saturated".
he did for 4 of 7 of those points, you're cherry picking. just cause some of them are low effort crits doesn't mean the whole thing is invalid.
pointing something out can be useful even if they don't offer a valid reason or solution since we can be blind to our own mistakes until someone points it out.
>>
i'm the one who told that guy to pyw and stfu, i don't really care about how valid the criticism was (which was not at all it was retarded) i just hate when you get shitty criticism that you didn't ask for

the argument that it's a critique board is also retarded, there's 20+ artists in this thread and only ONE is getting shit on let alone "criticised" it's so clear that you have a hard on for that artist that you have another anon>>7745881 calling you out and all you can respond is how it's the artist and samefag, holy fucking cope

also the fact that i had no idea that artist's name and you did, if they want criticism just fucking ask them like maybe they just want to draw and aren't looking for criticism
>>
>>7746300
It's rage bait. Why get angry on behalf of the artist who's fine ignoring it? I doubt they even care anymore.
>>
>>7746314
i'm too autistic to notice
>>
>>7746317
Same. I always have to try with these retards, but its also always a waste of time.
>>
File: unicorn.png (1.05 MB, 1545x2082)
1.05 MB
1.05 MB PNG
I changed some things. The hands are bad.
>>
>>7746300
those weren't me, you seem confused
but imagine getting mad at crit on crit board
>>
Rollin'
>>
File: IMG_3071.jpg (1.96 MB, 2201x4032)
1.96 MB
1.96 MB JPG
>>7747094
Damn first time ITT and I get the retarded ice cream cone black girl.
>>
>>7746929
This isn't a crit thread though, and the op never asked for it in the first place. Notice how there isn't a single other piece in this thread that got "critique", and instead only one of the best ones got singled out. It's a vendetta and nothing more. No wonder all the good artists leave this board.
>>
>>7747150
it's a crit board on 4chan of all places, not sure what you expect. if you post your work or anyone else's work it's up for crit. even da Vinci and Michelangelo aren't immune. almost every X appreciation thread has people critiquing it too.
the better artists get singled out because beginners aren't worth critiquing. seems there is a vendetta against that guy, wonder how that started. it's disproportionate but blaming it all on that is dishonest. polarizing styles attract crit, he shouldn't post on a crit board if he can't handle crit.
>>
>>7747191
>it’s a crit board
You do realize the board is called “Artwork/Critique” not “Artwork Critique.”
>>
File: Bugbear1.jpg (802 KB, 1050x1661)
802 KB
802 KB JPG
Anyone heard of a fucking bugbear before? Christ...
Anyway, another 1 I wont finish.
>>
File: Bugbear.jpg (699 KB, 1050x1661)
699 KB
699 KB JPG
>>7747332
Sketch was cuter.
>>
>>7747299
yeah that makes it a critique board
>>
>>7747336
>>7747332
idk what a Bugbear is either but this is cute. Socials?
>>
Roll
>>
Roll
>>
>>7747332
>>7747336
You're right that is a nice ass sketch. I think the colourful one just suffers from not being finished though, and maybe a couple too many wrinkles in the brow. Otherwise the palette and eyes and hair look really good so far.
also bugbears are a thing in DnD usually so yeah heard of em before.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.