>timeless lyrics about freedom of speech, justice, war, environmental destruction, mental illness, childhood trauma, and freedom of expression>their best song writing and riffs>godly drumming>kirk actually plays good solos>insane guitar tone >refused to turn up the bass track for the remaster>peak James vocalsGod damn I love this album so much and it is easily their best.
Tbh, take out Shortest Straw and Eye of the Beholder and it's a 10. The title track is one of their best songs IMO
>>122755437For me it’s kill em all, the only good, true Metallica record
>>122755771I love eye of the beholder. ‘Who decides what you express’ ‘you can do it your own way, if it’s done just how I say’ goated lyrics
>>122755437This was one of the only albums my Paps would listen to all the way through. 9/10 in my book, best Metallica album. DEAR MOTHER DEAR FATHER WHAT IS THIS HELL YOU HAVE BROUGHT ME TOO
>>122755789Was my fav Metallica album for a very long time >>122755812It's better than shortest Straw for sure. I like the song but I think the chorus is pretty weak. Just not as good as all the other songs on the album which are epic.>>122755821INNOCENCE, TORN FROM ME WITHOUT YOUR SHELTER
>timeless lyrics about freedom of speech, justice, war, environmental destruction, mental illness, childhood trauma, and freedom of expressionMuh freeze peach, muh both sides bad>their best song writing and riffsbloated, directionless>godly drummingpasted together from probably as many takes as there are bars in each songs>kirk actually plays good solosgood for his standards, ig>insane guitar tone like most 80s/90s guitar tones its barely listenable by todays standards>refused to turn up the bass track for the remastermaking it sound even worse for no reason>peak James vocalsshame he wastes it on chud lite shit
>>122755939Epic troll post. Thanks for wasting your time
>>122755939Imagine believing all of this. KEK. Any true Metallica fan knows that Justice is their masterpiece.
>>122755437This album always sounded to me like it was a more elaborate $5.98 E.P Garage DaysSame flat sound, no resonance, but worse songwriting and a whole lot of noodling
>>122755437>HARVESTER OF SORROOOOOWWWWWWWWWW
ok but I'd still rather listen to RTL
The quality of a Metallica album can only be measured on how many Mustaine riffs are on it. That’s why Kill ‘Em All is their only worthwhile album, as it’s 99% Dave. Lighting and Puppets are both barely passable but do contain Mustaine riffs, saving them from the trash heap, but And Justice For All is easily the worst of the classic era as it has ZERO confirmed Mustaine riffs, meaning it falls in with other low effort garbage like St. Wanker and 72 Shitstains. Simple as that.
COLOR OUR WORLD BLACKENED.BLACKENED.
>>122755771Shortest straw has some based riffs though. DO DE DO DE DO CHUGCHUGACHUGCHUACHUGCHUGCHUGCHA DO DE DO DE DO CHUGCHUGACHUGCHUGCHUGACHUG
>>122756360OPPOSISHAWWNN
>>122756358Hey man, just get the fuck out of here with that bullshit.
>>122756383Yeah I never understood why zoomers hate that song.
>>122756358>metallica thread>megashart gets brought uplike precision clockwork
>>122755789glorified demo album
>>122755437I love the theme of grief on the album that is always there, but never direct or obvious.James and Lars were obviously badly affected by the brutal loss of their friend, but because they’re repressed, they just wrote songs about war and injustice and stuff.
>>122755437it's the logical conclusion to metalanything more technical is pointless and not great for larger audience capturelars was absolutely based for realising this
>>122756358Kill ‘Em All is the weakest of the first 5, and it's not even close
>>122757110Megadookie fans have Metallica Derangement Syndrome.
>>122755939Both sides are bad…In fact, the whole system is bad. Why do people like you defend it, when it actively goes against the interests of the American people. I can only imagine you’re not American, and if you are you’re part of the problem.
>>122757358fuck you motherfucker cunt cocksucker fagtallica would still be playing dive bars in buttfuck nowhere if they didn’t steal all of Megadave’s mega riffs. As soon as they ran out, their albums got worse and worse as seen by Puppets and AJFA being certified sludge vomit compared to Dave ‘Em All and Ride the Mustaine.
>>122757408This is what Megadiarrhea fans actually believe.
>>122757435Fuck u bitch Megadave was the only person from Redditallica that had a smidgen of talent, bar Cliff of course god rest his soul. Caveman Hetfield and that danish retard wouldn’t know a good metal song if it came and smacked them across the fucking face with its fat greasy cock. Kill ‘Em All is the only Memetallica album that isn’t an instant 0 out of 10 and it’s purely because of those juicy Mustaine riffs and even those are ruined by Ramenhead Hammet wah-wahing the fuck out of them.
>>122757544someone let dave back on 4chan again
>>122755437the production is so dull, can't listen to it
>>122757358To be fair, so does Mustaine. 39 years and he still won’t shut the fuck about Metallica. He was in the band for a year and he was fired right before they even recorded their first studio album, he’s not even on it. His contributions and influence were mostly gone by RtL (except for the two songs he contributed to).
>>122757706The muted bass really dulls it. I still like the album but it sounds off. They really treated Jason Newsted like shit because he wasn’t Cliff. Trujillo is great but I still wish Newsted was in the band for his backup vocals alone
production on this album sucks
Redditallica, lol
>>122755437Their fourth best. Both battery and one are top 10 metallica songs though.
>>122757255>>122757331kill 'em all is a bunch of drunk 18-20 years olds that are basically just playing their favorite bands but faster and end up with their own original sound because of it. in other words: it's probably the closest you can get to the pure essence of metal. 100% raw unfiltered SOVL
>>122758519he shut up for a bit in the early 2010s especially when metallica invited him on stage for their 30th anniversary to play the four horsemen. you'd think the hatchet would be buried but i think a year ago or so i saw an interview on blabbermouth where he was once again bitching about metallica. he really honestly can't get over them.
>>122757331Jesus what a garbage opinion. I'm surprised you're apparently smart enough to use a keyboard.
>>122759014He really is the Axl Rose of thrash metal.
Let me spell it out for you cocksuckers GOD TIER: Kill ‘Em AllGOOD TIER: Ride the Lightning BAD TIER: Master of Puppets, Garage Days, And Justice for AllGARBAGE TIER: Black Album, Death Magnetic, Hardwired to Self Destruct UNLISTENABLE TIER: Load, 72 SeasonsWORST MUSIC EVER RECORDED TIER: Reload, St. Anger
>>122755437It sounds like it’s missing something
>>122756383>shortest strawlame as fuckthis shit mogs all of memetallica's songs combined:https://youtu.be/nuAqvHSi9vQ?feature=shared
>>122760036i hope you weren't serious with this post
>>122755437>easily their best.Wrong. Half the songs arent even memorable/good whereas every track on Master is a masterpiece.
>>122757331Completely wrong.
>>timeless lyrics about freedom of speech, justice, war, environmental destruction, mental illness, childhood trauma, and freedom of expression>Muh freeze peach, muh both sides bad>>their best song writing and riffs>bloated, directionless>>godly drumming>pasted together from probably as many takes as there are bars in each songs>>kirk actually plays good solos>good for his standards, ig>>insane guitar tone>like most 80s/90s guitar tones its barely listenable by todays standards>>refused to turn up the bass track for the remaster>making it sound even worse for no reason>>peak James vocals>shame he wastes it on chud lite shit
>>122757406>we should put all trans, gay, black, muslim people into camps and murder them>mmh, maybe we shouldn't?Ah yes, both sides are truly equally bad
>>122755437Any album from Kill to TBA can be considered their best and everyone will have a different favourite. They're all good as fuck. Master is easily their best for me. Ride is close behind.
>>122756360COLOR MY WIFE BLACKEDBLACKED
>>122757331fact! but people need to feel special about themselves and praise the earliest and most amateurish music a band did rather than their obvious improvement over time.
>>122757544fresh pasta?
>>122759084>WORST MUSIC EVER RECORDED TIERat least half of Megadeth's discography
>>122764981please stop watching porn
bass in a metal album is too gimmicky. metalica captured metal perfectly with the justice album
>>122765798Nah, Kill ‘Em All is still good. Dated production, unrefined, and the lyrics aren’t very good. But it sounds great. It’s the album I liked the least as a teen and listen to the most as an adult
>>122758564le bass. You can listen to it with enhanced bass on youtube, it adds nothing to the album. James wasn't being petty, the album legit sounds better with dull bass, jason didn't really add much and he just follows the riff
>>122760435how i feel when i see people on this thread discussing which album was the most "legendary" and then actually listen to it (it sounds like shit)metallica hasn't made a single good song in their entire existence, it's a band for balding poser boomers
>>122765825Real shit, after Youthanasia it took them until United Abominations to make a listenable record again. Then after Endgame, they never did again.
>>122755789Shut up Dave
>>122757331I'd put it slightly above MoP, but otherwise yes.
>>122767292agreed
>>122767304>putting the weakest above the strongest?
>>122767361It's easy to get caught up in the hype, this was Metallica's golden years, but it doesn't change that the album is 80% filler and only the title track and Orion are good
>>122767723holy contrarian batman!
>>122758904>>122757706I don't get this.. it is dry as hell yes but it has this blunt punishing sound that fits the songs really well. It sounds like they're playing in some shitty dry warehouse like the one on the "One" music video.
>>122769603based
>>122767723Filler? There are only 8 songs and they’re all good in their own way. MoP is widely considered to be their best album followed very closely by RtL which some out ahead of it but the consensus is that those two are their best
