Minnesota Aurora FC just signed Isaac Ranson, a transgender man and former Cal State Fullerton goalkeeper, to their women’s soccer team.And honestly… this story completely exposes how weird and performative the whole “birth sex only” sports argument actually is.For years, anti-trans activists have pushed the idea that athletes should only compete based on the sex they were assigned at birth. The entire argument has constantly targeted trans women, saying they “don’t belong” in women’s sports.Okay. So now here comes the real-world outcome of that logic:Isaac Ranson is a man.Lives as a man.Identifies as a man.Looks like a man.Moves through society as a man.And under the exact rules anti-trans activists demanded… he ends up on a women’s soccer team.That’s where their argument immediately starts collapsing in on itself.Because the second these policies are applied consistently, people suddenly realize this was never actually a clean, thought-out solution. It becomes obvious that these rules were built around controlling and policing trans bodies rather than understanding how real trans people actually exist in society.And what makes this even more important is that Isaac himself has openly talked about the complexity of playing in women’s soccer while being a trans man. None of this is black and white. Real life isn’t Twitter discourse.Meanwhile Aurora FC handled it with more maturity than most politicians ever could. They welcomed him, supported him, and made it clear everyone deserves the opportunity to play.This is the exact scenario anti-trans commentators never want to talk about because it forces the conversation out of hypotheticals and into reality.If your policy puts trans men onto women’s teams and suddenly THAT makes people uncomfortable… maybe the issue was never fairness in sports to begin with.
ok so here's the solution: treatment for gender dysphoria is death by lethal injectionany questions?
>>535741369Bone structure status?
>>535741369Ure gay faggot kys
>>535741369What? Anyways the solution is abolishing all women’s sports because it’s a money sink. Except gymnastics and volleyball of course.
>>535741369Don't women's leagues ban steroids?
>>535741369>Join team while on HRT which is legally a performance enhancing drug>Rules say you can't be on HRT or any other performance enhancing drugs and playShe'll literally have to detrans to be allowed to play ever. LMFAO.
>>535741561Yup. She'll have to stop taking them and test clean to play XD.
>>535741369just kill all trannies problem solved
All trannies should play in men's sports. Either they were born a boy and had the benefit of increased testosterone as their body was developing before they trooned out. Or they were born a girl and had the benefit of testosterone later. Either way, it's high test at some point in their life vs low test the entirety of their life.
She's a woman on a women's sports team. This is supposedly the unintended result?She can't take male hormones anymore.Also, lol, women's soccer, lol. Who cares?
I don't really see the anomaly in having a woman play a female sport like soccer.
>>535741369>trans manI have no idea about american culture. Is this a man who wants to be a woman, or a woman who wants to be a man?
>>535741369Looks more masculine than most /pol/ users tbf
>>535741743It's a woman who pretends to be a man
>>535741369Now ban her for roiding
>>535741369I don’t even know why you’re saying. Be more clear. Girl with vagina who dresses like a man and takes male hormones is playing on girls soccer team?
>>535741369Also no steroid use in any sport tranny
>>535741743it is a woman wtih amputated breasts injecting testosterone for years
>born a female>required to play against females>this is somehow inconsistent with their stated goal>of segregating sports by natal sex
>>535741369Only reddit is confused by this
>>535741369The entire "debate" is actually really simple. Here is a logically sound argument to the problem.1) "Men's sports" are essentially open to all genders based on their performance merit.2) Woman's sports only exist because woman can't compete with men at the highest levels.3) MtF have an unfair hormonal/phenotype then biological woman.4) FtM have an unfair hormonal/phenotype then biological woman.5) Therefore transexuals should either compete in the men's division or create their own. Woman's divisions should be reserved for biological woman not take what are essentially performance enhancing drugs (hormone blockers/hormones).
>>535741369IT will poojeet in womans bathrooms and yell "IT'S MAME on the field.
>>535741369>Isaac Ranson is a man.1. She's a woman.2. Disqualified from professional sports for using anabolic steroids.3. Dangerous perv, keep away from children.4. No one gives a shit about woman's sports anyway.
>>535741369Delusional tranny. Nobody cares because she's not cheating. She's playing with and against men. She's at a disadvantage. Now compare to this dude cleaning out the competition, because his male body is naturally stronger than the females he cheated against. https://www.breitbart.com/sports/2026/05/24/trans-high-school-athlete-sweeps-jumping-events-against-girl-track-stars-in-masters-meet/Stop trying to cheat, and people will hate you a little less.
>>535741766>>535741836Ah, I see, thank you.>>535741369What's the problem? Women's sports aren't real sports anyway, and nobody watches them. And since she doesn't have a penis, she can't rape anyone in the locker room.
>>535741852Seriously wtf is faggot ops prolapsed logic here?
>>535741369>mentally-disturbed foid is playing niggerball with other foidsThere is nothing weird or confusing about this.>b-but she had her tits chopped off and got a short haircutSo?
>>535741369>That’s where their argument immediately starts collapsingHow can people supposedly smarter than everyone who agrees with me be so unable to understand suvh simple things? Nothing falls apart here. A woman is on a womens team. Her lifestyle is irrelevant besides perhaps that she is taking performance enhancing drugs.Wild how theres no mention of any skill discrepancy ruining the game for others. The only issue is that this trans woman has to play with other women, which theyre in favour of anyway, so who cares?
if she's pumped full of testerone she shouldn't be allowed to play on the women's team
>>535741369How did anyone find out about this, no one watches womens sports
>>535741990I mean, don't all female footballers look like that?
>>535741369An insane and unjust act to put that biological woman in a men's professional soccer team. Next they'll threaten to shoot us all if we don't give in to their insane demands.
>>535741369>1pbtidall fields
>>535741369>preddit screenshot>OP thinks it means somethingTrannies are desperate for attention, no one here has ever doubted that
>>535741369Might be a fraud aka a larper pretending to be why jeff c caught shit like this all the time
>>535741743If you're confused about a "trans" term, you can generally replace "trans" with "not". So a "trans man" is not a man. Note that this does not apply to chemistry.
>>535741852They just need to add that a female taking male hormones isn't allowed for the exact same reason doping/performance enhancing drugs aren't allowed.
>>535742164Good mnemonic device, thank you.
He/She is welcome to join men's team. He/She is welcome to use men's room. Nobody cares. There is no such thing as men's-only space. That'd be illegal. We just call it men's to make women feel equal. There are women's-only spaces, created to protect a weaker subgroup of humans. Butchers don't belong there either.
>>535741894This violates their axiom that men and women and equal, and all gender arguments must be symmetrical.
>>535741369ftm trans man in female space is not the problem that person isn't getting aroused by autoggynephilia. that person likely cannot rape a child by forcemtf in female spaces aroused by autogynehilia will rape a child by force
>>535741559And mudfights, do not forget about the mudfights.
>>535742164Trans is the latan word for beyond or "on the other side of"So a trans man is on the other side of man, which is woman
>>535741369FtM pisses me off, what's the point of a dickless twink?
>>535741369Blah blah blah. She is a woman. I'm glad my state did this.
>>535741369Lol all that cope for you will never be a real woman.. kill yourselves trannies.
>>535741369After trans-identifying men (TIMs, i.e. biological men) and trans-identifying women (TIFs , i.e. biological women) both underwent 12 months of cross sex hormone therapy, TIMs still ended up being stronger than TIFs, in both absolute and height adjusted valueshttps://academic.oup.com/jcem/article/105/3/e805/5651219TIM retain greater muscle strength than women even after 36 months of hormone therapyhttps://bjsm.bmj.com/content/55/15/865The biological advantage that TIM have over women is only minimally reduced when testosterone is suppressed as per current sporting guidelines for transgender athleteshttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7846503/"Trans-identifying men still had a 9% faster mean run speed after the 1 year period of testosterone suppression that is recommended by World Athletics for inclusion in women’s events."https://bjsm.bmj.com/content/55/11/577.full?ijkey=yjlCzZVZFRDZzHz&keytype=ref“[Biological] women have smaller conducting airways than men, even when matched for lung size. This is important when considering the principles of airflow [...]"https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/advan.00118.2006“Men have significantly greater left ventricular mass and chamber size than women. Because the left ventricular ejection fraction is the same in both sexes, the stroke volume is larger in men than in women.”https://journals.physiology.org/doi/full/10.1152/advan.00118.2006
>>535741369this is good and you should encourage it, they are the ones voting for it
>>535741743>trans manThe politically correct term is zippertits And yeah it’s a tomboy or dyke that has been convinced that they are really a boy and get their tits lopped off, take T until they are as horny and acne pocked as a 16 year old boy, and end up begging old daddy types to dick them down when the horny gets too bad and dildos and twink or dyke fuckbuddies don’t scratch the itch that kicked in when the T did
>>535741369>And under the exact rules anti-trans activists demanded… he ends up on a women’s soccer team.Because she competes against women, and has a woman's physique rather than a man's.
>>535741369All the other women on field are blasting steroids too
>>535741369>This zipper tit, hairy stump troon pedo is on the women's teamlol lmao, who cares.
>>535741369This Isaac person is literally a biological woman. This perfectly lines up with anti-trans logic. Are you fucking retarded? You know they're not allowed to take their HRT shit while being on the team too, right?
>>535741369so he can take hormones since hes trans?? no antidoping for trannies??? she could have more test than a ufc fighter with that excuse
>>535741369>Isaac Ranson is a man.>Lives as a man.>Identifies as a man.>Looks like a man.>Moves through society as a man.Does he have a penis, like a man?Hmmmm?
>>535746467Yes there are surgeries for that.
>>535741369or in other words a roided female
>>535746526> there are surgeries for that.An Addadicktome, it’s a hairy procedure…
THANK U WHITE FAGGOT
>>535741369Mirin that jawline n g l. Think (s)he uses Clav’s routine or is this the power of masculinization surgery?
>a woman has to play on the womans team>doesn't this MAKE YOU MADno? Are you fucking stupid?
>>535741369>This is the exact scenario anti-trans commentators never want to talk about because it forces the conversation out of hypotheticals and into reality.This is the exact situation we talk about and it's what we wanted. Kill yourself.
>>535741412fpbp
If shes taking T does that count as doping?
>>535741412Can we use the same treatment for people affected with judaism or niggerism?
>>535749254No, it's for her federally protected medical condition.
>>535741369Ok is she/he taking steroids?
>>535749439I believe the tennis joggers did that as well
so they signed some 5'4" manlet tranny to be a goalkeeper, let us know how that works out in men's soccerlol. lmao.pretty sure even voll anon's girl was taller than that. its just a PR stunt. theyll never let that tranny play
>>535741369it's OK. in america, football (soccer) is a fag sport
>>535741369tranny SPORTS LEAGUE, END OF.
