>>731905454
it always looked like this guy was giving a thumbs up

Aren't these games just FIFA or Madden 2k something? There's one every year and people forget about them once the next one drops.

>>731905631
its like gears of war at this point with their own spin offs and taking/giving away mechanics each iteration

>>731905454
Better than elden ring desu

>>731906039
Not much of a bar.

>>731905631
these dont come out for like 5+ years at a time now, are you fucking retarded?

>>731906039
one being open world and the other being the most linear souls game is quite the contrast for comparison

the whole time playin ds3 i just wanted to play elden ring

>>731905454
Funny, I went back and replayed it not long ago and found it better than I remember.

1 is good but outdated and tedious
2 is dogshit, clearly made by an experimental b-team
3 is very good but a little too streamlined
ER has good elements but its so much gayer than the Dark Souls aesthetic. Also the bosses are way too crazy and versatile for how many limits this type of game puts on the player.

>>731907101
3 was the start of the insane mob movesets with limited souls actions
then ER upped it for both parties so it got way too much.

>>731907315
>3 was the start of the insane mob movesets
True but it wasn't until quite a bit into the game. You got a nice comfy grounded experience in the first half and then it ramps up around halfway.
Pontiff is the first nu-age Dark Souls boss more or less. The Ringed City is basically proto-ER. Every other ER boss is Slave Knight Gael tier intensity.

>>731907987
yeah its crazy going form ER to DS3. Bosses seem to just fuckin die so quick and I have gotten away with estus drinking way too much with them expecting them to read inputs. on top of every bosses health aside from midir and gaels health being so fuckin small, shit is just melting before anything gets crazy

i remember why Straight swords were pretty meta and its because a lot of enemies just dont let you wind up much unless you abuse weapon art poise moves through shit. god thats another fuckin thing too, the weapon arts being so infantile so they are all mostly shit to use or have niche uses to abuse the npc ai

>>731905454
It's the best of the series but that isn't a high bar nor impressive given that the other games are trash. It's only mogged by Sekiro because Fromsoft somehow accidentally found out what decent gameplay looks like and never used it again.

>>731908172
>zoomer lingo
>sekiro
Checks out.

>>731908172
>no dual wielding
>extremely linear levels
>shallow covenants with no rewards
>nonsensical story with retcons aplenty
>birthplace of the lol anime style bosses that infest ER
In what universe is DS3 the best of anything?

File: file.png (2.42 MB, 1207x1190)

2.42 MB PNG

>>731908172
it did a lot of things right with a few things wrong unlike ds2 where it was more two steps forward, 3 steps back.

like it being super fuckin linear, even more vague and fickle questlines, and taking away powerstancing in favor of dual weapons. thats off the top of my head.
but i do appreciate the fanservice easter egg type shit littered throughout that isn't just "hey its solaires armor member that?"

Gonna 100% admit I'm a shitter and say that on my 3rd playthrough i actually just skipped Malenia and Promised Consort. It was a PVP build and after I got the last piece (dragon heart from Bayle) I saw no reason to throw myself into those blenders for shit that I'd never even use.
All and all, I'm washed

>>731908287
>no dual wielding
None of the souls game did this right.
>extremely linear levels
You can have your interconnected meme worlds but I prefer it linear than something like ER where the space is very empty and vastly boring.
>shallow covenants with no rewards
As compared to the others that never did them right. I would prefer it if they removed that system since they don't know how to use it.
>nonsensical story with retcons aplenty
Lore is always a clusterfuck or irrelevant in these games. Story is nonexistent as always so what's the point?
>birthplace of the lol anime style bosses that infest ER
They actually do something than flail around and die easily or walk slowly and die. I agree ER did it so over the top and slow ass player character gameplay is killing the series.

File: 1743773804120227.png (136 KB, 977x848)

136 KB PNG

Sister Friede is the most unfun boss in the history of vidya. Just thought you should know. Thanks for asking.

>>731908997
I beat her 2nd try and thought she was mostly fine as the dual-boss phase seemed fair (similar to Demon Prince). Her invisibility seems inconsistent. Often her 'puff' of snow when she turns invisible wasn't pointing to where she was. I found Gael to be the dumbest, took me ~12 tries and I still don't get why vocal people gush over him as a boss and for his lore. And sadly (as per From direction) Gael is a staple of ER's terrible boss design, and it only gets much worse from there. Direction of nuFrom is such a disappointment.

>>731908759
I could kinda understand radahn but malenia is so easy comparatively I can't say the same about her

All souls shit is bad.

>>731909168
Like I said bro, I'm washed

>>731908997
I think Midir is the worst

>>731908997
As a hardcore STR + FTH enjoyer, I find myself skipping her and Midir in my playthroughs. Just aren't worth the trouble for their boss soul items.

>>731909182
Trve Nvke.

>>731909162
You didn't beat her if you used a summon.

>>731905454
It's their only game that isn't complete dogshit compared the rest. If you want to play vidya you can pick up any other game not made by this shovelware company.

>>731905454
DS3 > ER
i'd take the linearity over the giant empty open-world everytime

>>731909347
Dunno why you reply to a single post with that. Wouldn't the post be "You didn't beat a boss if you used a summon."?

>>731906829
It's a very refined but less creative take on the concept. They were better at making games but worse at making me care about it. Meanwhile DS1 is a janky game that feels 5 years older than it is but has an engaging story and a coherent enough plot that you're happy when it progresses and excited about what comes next.

>>731909483
In what world does DS1 have a story or a coherent plot? You're on drugs and high off that Vaati sauce. All of that made up shit is headcanon.

>>731909584
You are a discaded Undead. By chance, you are freed from prison. You are told it is destiny to ring the bell(s) of awakening. Once you do, you are told that this was done to succeed the God of the world (Gwyn). You go to the city of gods and receive the ability to gain that power. One you reach the center of the world, you find out that Gwyn has gone crazy, and kill him. After that, you succeed to him, but you were tricked! You will now burn forever the same way he did!
This is the basic story of DS1. There's the second ending but this is the gist.

>>731909474
Used a summon confirmed. Didn't beat it. The only people that don't hate her are the ones that let someone else do all the work.

>>731909921
I play offline, anon, so no. It's instead evident you're upset that somebody didn't mind the boss.

>>731909821
That's nothing when the narrative isn't there. A story has narrative, well developed characters, and a protagonist. You get none of those here and left with "kill next big guy" until you die in the end or become firewood. Souls games are just theme parks with sticky notes found in them which doesn't have a beginning, middle, nor end to them and just blurt out mindless exposition.

how do I get past the knight with the fire sword? he's so up my ass

>>731909947
Yeah, sure you did, lol.

>>731906765
>DS2
2014
>BB
2015
>Deracine
2016
>Sekiro
2019
>Elden Ring
2022
>Armored Core 6
2023
>Elden Ring Nightreign
2025
>Duskbloods
2026

The way they balanced ER is way better than making everything garbage in DS3.

>>731910321
Too bad ER's world is so trash, boring, and empty.

>>731910321
I'd disagree, having seen those mega-long tier-list (inb4 >tier-list) videos by autists with 5k+ hours in ER (incase your very limited experience isn't enough) it evident that it's pretty imbalanced. All of the weapons, arts, spells, yeah, it's a mess. For the most part, if you aren't using FP, you're fucked, and it has to be something good that uses FP, because an awful lot of FP uses are shit. Why bother slapping an enemy with a melee weapon when a host of FP-using anime attacks do infinitely more damage and often with safety, too?

>>731910392
It has a better world than Spyro the Dragon tho

I literally cannot finish the game after beating it twice. I get to Cathedral of the deep and I just lose all motivation to keep playing. I do not have this problem with any other Dark Souls game, including DS2.

>>731910498
>Why bother slapping an enemy with a melee weapon
Because it's fun. Elden Ring isn't an excel spreadsheet game for weirdos with autism and OCD.

File: 1765034714730998.webm (3.91 MB, 960x540)

3.91 MB WEBM

>>731910498
Because I don't give a fuck about minmaxing a singleplayer ARPG? I just do whatever I find fun and it works.

>>731910498
Then try elden ring reforged where everything is balanced and BORING. Complaining about broken shit you don't need to use to clear the single player content is an example of lack of self control. And using FP to kill things in seconds has been a thing since demon's souls.

>>731910674
I hate Reforged so much

>>731910606
There's a point where the imbalance is just unfun, especially with how maliciously designed the bosses are.

>>731910913
Yeah it's maliciously designed because you can parry and jump over attacks and blocking is rewarding. They should dumb it down and force players to roll+r1 and nothing else.

>>731910913
No there isn't. The most fun I've had in the game was jump slamming and heavy R2ing the base game bosses to death with the spiked caestus. Every weapon type is fun and completely viable for casuals to use. That's a proven fact.

>>731907315
I just played bloodborne recently and the main issue of elden ring is that the enemies move like bloodborne bosses while you don't have a reasonable answer to their movesets so you gotta wait for your turn. If you had access to the bloodborne moveset you could keep getting hits in during their retarded circus acts.

>>731910671
based fun-having spellblade

>>731905454
>more mid than i remember

most of life is hype and bullshit

for example there is a YouTube channel where sit-coms laugh tracks are removed

F R I E N D S tv show without laughing FX


you probably only liked it because you were brainwashed with hype jumped on the bandwagon of everyone pretending like they like it

or maybe you're deepressed

>>731911292
The fuck is wait your turn? In ER if you are doing worse than someone spamming jump r2 or charged r2 maybe your strategy is trash.

It's FOMOslop just like Elden Ring, Dubai Chocolate, Labubus, any Starbucks drink fad, latest CoD/GTA/FIFA, fidget spinners, etc... They usually come and go.

The problem with DS3 is it has no balls. It doesn't really do anything interesting, it just plays it extremely safe. There are never any terrible consequences for the player. You can warp from minute 1, you can re-smith your weapon, you can respec, you can't lose any vendors. DS3 has the best bosses in the DS trilogy, but overall playing it feels like a trip to wallmart. Everything is cheap and convenient, when the thing that made DS1 popular was not giving a shit about making things convenient.

>>731911357
What are you talking about? Most p

>>731911510
What are you talking about? Most people already know that sitcomes are dogshit, and I doubt there are many people on 4chan today who actually watched and liked FRIENDS when it was popular.

>>731905518
i've played this game for 300 hours and your post is unironically the first time i realise this isn't what's happening

>>731909947
what? there's summons offline. i beat sister friede with the guy you summon

>>731905454
It's the most bland Souls game

>>731911707
its also the least bullshit

File: ringed-city-i.jpg (43 KB, 616x353)

43 KB JPG

Still the best DLC, and Slave Night Gael is still the best Fromsoft boss next to Isshin

>>731911778
And bullshit is what made DS memorable. So stripping away the bullshit completely makes DS3 bland in comparison.

>>731911470
please go and jump attack margit while he is doing his spastic flip flop attacks, you still have to wait for the entire combo to stop

File: shira_npc.jpg (13 KB, 300x169)

13 KB JPG

>>731911923
I didn't care for it. More than any other DLC From's ever put out, Ringed City just felt like "Let's put in all the content we cut from the base game or shit we couldn't fit elsewhere." It has some cool ideas, but the story just kinda...stops before it gets anywhere.

>>731909993
>narrative
Already explained
>characters
So Solaire, Frampt, Gwyndolin, the crestfallen, Siegmeyer etc etc aren't characters?
>protagonist
So silent protagonists aren't protagonists?

Just because a game doesn't have half its runtime in custscenes doesn't mean it has no story.

>>731908083
literally every other game in existence:
don't heal when enemy is attacking you

elden ring and only elden ring:
don't heal unless enemy is attacking you and missing

>>731912698
He has one "spastic" attack. You can be aggressive for the rest of the fight just fine.

>>731909993
Anon, you don't seem to understand that stories in interactive media work differently than stories in non-interactive media.

>>731913876
anon, you are just making excuses. Those videos you've been watching are not exploring the story of the games, they are CREATING the story from the games. You are consuming good narrative media and attributing it's qualities to another media with bad narrative.

>>731914015
I genuinely don't know what you are talking about.I haven't watched any videos about the story of Dark Souls. The narrative of Dark Souls is that you are some undead hick, try to fulfill a prophecy, and get tricked into burning yourself.

>>731914295
then idk where you got such pretentious ideas. Gameplay story can exist, but it doesn't replace the non interactive story, it enchances or clashes with it.

>>731905454
DS3? moar like SWAMP souls 3!

>>731914412
>Gameplay story can exist, but it doesn't replace the non interactive story, it enchances or clashes with it
Yeah, like it does in Dark Souls. I don't understand what you mean by "pretentious ideas", my first post in this thread was this one: >>731913876

>>731909162
Demon Prince more annoying since the focus of phase 1 is to just rush the 1 until it's de-powered and avoid the others poison shit. Especially since their claw attacks can attack through each other and you can get stuck on their feet/wings. Phase 2 different versions are fine but the small fireballs rng is also shitty.
Funny they made a worse version fight in Elden Ring with the Duo Gargoyles.

>>731905454
As someone who plays thease games for music, bosses, lore and atmosphere, DS3 was definitely the highlight of the trilogy

>>731915470
I understand that, it had the best bosses, and the most bombastic soundtrack. Atmosphere and lore, I don't know, but I'm probably biased.

I wouldn't say it's a bad game, but I just dislike how uninspired most of the game is, and how many "hard moments" are you getting ganked by 5 enemies on the way to some pickup (Pitiful Soul of a Forgotten Nobody (20 souls)).

2 > 1 > 3

>>731915881
1 > 2 = 3

>>731910321
They didn't balance ER

>>731915869
I see alotb of people who played ds1 back in the day who can't seem to enjoy ds2 or 3, funnily, people who started with demons souls don't seem to have that problem.

>>731910321
true

>>731915946
I do enjoy both DS2 and DS3, just to a lesser degree.

>>731916109
I think its a nostalgia thing

>>731905454
its way better than elden ring and ds2 but ds1 still reigns supreme

>>731909267
if youre skipping friede than youre skipping the whole ringed city DLC since you can’t access it before defeating her.
you faggots really need to study a lil better the games youre trying to shitpost against.

>>731916151
I played DS1 when DS2 released, and played DS2 right after, and I already held that opinion. DS3 released, what, 2 or 3 years later? I was an adult man when I played these games. While I admit there might be a slight degree of nostalgia involved concerning DS3, there is a noticable difference in the game design approach between all three of these games.

>>731905454
almost entire game is "fuck i hate this area"

>>731909821
>go through tens of hours of annoying trial and error gameplay and finally get to the ending
>perform the only action that the game allows
>um actually you fell for a heckin trick, did you actually think you would get a good ending? go fuck yourself :^)
Sounds like cheap shock value

>>731916350
>you can’t access it before defeating her.
??? You can also access the ringed city dlc when you reach the final boss in the base game.

File: pvnLSySjgZ.jpg (1.21 MB, 1920x2160)

1.21 MB JPG

>black witch hat loses the attunement bonus
this is when I draw the line, fuck this game

>>731905454
Goyslop that retarded teenagers fellate because they think it's le hidden 4chan gem

>>731917283
Yeah that was the final insult. I could tolerate the dumbed-down spell system, the neutered poise, hell, even the swamp zones every five feet-but taking away the attunement bonus from my fashion piece? Unforgivable. Miyazaki really said "no drip for casters."

>>731905518
I think therefore I exist aah post.

>>731917547
Poise being hyperarmor only was one of the best things this game did.

>>731912947
Demon Prince is the only cut content, I believe. It was supposed to be the boss of Smouldering Lake (Crimson Bat, there's even a cut music track), but they ran out of time and put another Asylum Demon there instead lmao

>>731917547
The other anon already told you about the poise, DS1 poise was retarded, just infinite passive super armor like you're a boss character, super dumb in what's supposed to be a high skill action game. Get Wolf Ring plus a couple high poise armor pieces and you can play it like Skyrim.

But I also hated the DS1/2 spell system. The limited spell casts meant you were encouraged to hoard multiple copies of the same spell or you felt like you're missing out, which really bothered my OCD. In DS3, Demon's and Elden Ring you just buy ONE copy of a spell and that's it, it's unlimited use, MP based.

>>731905454
I never realized that Friede is wearing pants under her robe until I played Nightreign and tried to look up it to see panties while playing as the revenant skin for it. Now I'm disappointed that you can't see panties. Do nuns even wear pants?

>>731905631
People don't know how to move on. Gamers are even worse. They beg companies make sequels and remasters and remakes. They can't get enough even if it all just ends up the same thing over and over again. And then some youtuber points that out to them and they start repeating the shit youtuber said about how gaming is dead and everything is a franchise now with no original games.

>>731905454
Yeah, all souls games suck. Sheeps are just brainwashed because other sheeps said the games were good.

File: FKJwTDy09J.jpg (232 KB, 1391x2400)

232 KB JPG

it's just me or Ariandel DLC is discount Eleum Loyce

>>731905454
Yeah. It was hard to top ds2 but 3 is still nod bad. 6-7 out of 10

>>731919713
Everyone always says this game is Roll Souls 3, but nobody tells you how useful a shield actually is. Just killed Oceiros and it's hilarious how even a heater shield cucks the fuck out of him. His charge is pure physical damage, even if blocking guard breaks you he's so far away he can't follow up. It's free. The fight becomes free. There's so many attacks in this game that are like that. Dogs? Just block them. Thralls? Just block them. Snakefaggots? Just block. Hold up a shield. The game is so much more chill now.

>>731911292
Malenia literally has a Sekiro leftover moveset.