call it now, /v/hit, dud, or mid?
>>732421134Mid.
>>732421134A cult classic, that never breaks out into the mainstream the way Issac did. Small, but intensely autistic fanbase.Also the furries will be there, but they will be less weird than the game fans. Game is modestly profitable.
>>732421134MidJust like Mina The Hollower
>>732421134low brow, derivative, jewish wikisloppa
>>732421134hit, but in the stupid way where it gets a ton of sales every time a DLC drops moreso than a gigantic initial bunch of release copies sold
>>732421134It will be a hit for most people, but for me it will only be a hit in theory, because I love the concept but wish the cats were slightly cuter. Just like sliiightly.
>>732421134>90 on metacritic, only negative point in some reviews is the "outdated humor"It's a hit.
>>732421134Dud
>>732421134>Steakmund wonWe have truly lost
>>732421475>outdated humorWhat does that mean?
>>732421475I meant opencritic.
Hit. Edmund only makes kino. This will be the third pillar up there with Meat Boy and Isaac
>>732421475Same energy as critics glazing jay z for decades of trash music. Steakmund is too sacred of a cow in the industry to receive accurate reviews.
>>732421134It's a hit
>>732421678bullshit, if that were true then bumbo and fingered would've been revered masterpieces.
>>732421224This.>only appeals to a small crowd due to the genre>fanbase is dedicate>nowhere near the same success as TBoI>some youtuber makes a video on it 2-3 years after its release that gives it a popularity bump>50% chance that said popularity bump pushes out the previous fanbase
At worst it will plateau with twice the sales and reviews as Bum-Bo. At best it will surpass Meat Boy many times over and nearly reach Isaac levels of popularity. However, this won't be instant, it will take bare minimum 5 years to truly assess Mewgenics's quality. Unironically, this thread won't have a clear answer until 2030.
>>732421134Mid. It'll be exactly what it was supposed to be, but nothing worth waiting 15 years for.
>>732422882Considering how much the steak was whoring for cameos, we could end up getting multiple spotlight videos month one. Still won't ever top the charts, but I'm predicting it'll at least break even. Not having east asian languages day 1 is stupid though, the concept of a turn-based cat breeding rpg seems like it would do better over there than here.
>>732421603It's like when you aren't allowed to say on 4chan that the Portal games were funny because it was so influential that it caused the creation of "Reddit humor".
>>732423646>but nothing worth waiting 15 years for.the original teaser dropped 12 and a half years ago
If it's easy to make mods for, it'll go from dud to hit in 2 months
>>732425974they said they're going to add workshop support
>>732421134any indie game that has a review embargo is a bad sign
>>7324211343rd most popular game he's made after isaac and meatboy, more than most other devs could ever hope for, but kinda eh for Edmund
>>732421603its when you go *holds up spork* in 2026
>>732428420not really Silksong had one as well
