5'11 vs 6'0 editionWhat is Progressive Rock?>https://www.progarchives.com/Progressive-rock.asp#definitionGood albums to start with?>https://www.musicgenretree.org/essential_prog.pngObscure prog gems>https://rateyourmusic.com/list/antonbildern/a-secret-society-obscure-progressive-rock-albums/Previous: >>121564659
>WEST IS MIKE AND SUZY
>>121649379Manlets when will they learn. Also obscure prog MEGA:https://mega.nz/folder/IJAnGL6K#nScPa_rgxtygC53XFqmC2Q>>121649482For me it's Lemmings>What choice is there left but to live>In the hope of saving our children's children's little ones?
Acknowledge me
>>121649562The "we're sorry you didn't like passion play" album
>>121649562Do you think the Dredd Badge ('77) was inspired by the Warchild logo ('74)?
>>121649379>>121649482>>121649525Van der Graaf Generator is a trust fund band. Mike and Suzy too.
>>121651138Have you considered that maybe that’s just the band name
>>121651138I thought west is Mike and Suzy
In the battle of EFFING forest hahah
Abacab is my favorite Genesis album
>>121651254>>121651559These are good points
time to draw a bath, get the party speaker out and put on Asia
holy freaking crap lois
>>121651918brehs...
>>121651918Jame's solo album before he died of brain cancer was really good, shame because he was Magma's greatest guitarist. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IAd9FBXpe9s
>>121651629It's not perfect but I do love the sound of the album. You might argue it foreshadowed the style of a lot of the prog-revivalism meets synth-modernism of 80s neo-prog.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQtgWQHu2r8
A SPECK OF LINT
>>121649525from the mega link. Holy shit this is great
is Manfred Mann's Earth Band worth listening to? are they prog?
>>121652057Eh. Sounds like mediocre 21st century Magma. I like it because I like 21st century Magma, but it didn't blow my tits off or anything.
>>121654731I've only ever listened to the album that has Blinded by the Light on it, but it was pretty good.
>>121653467
>Invents ASMRhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_7pkOZ5n6PQ
bump
Sometimes you just have to listen to some prime prog wank schlock.
Listened to it in my car and thought it was kind of gay. Please tell me what opinion I should have to pretend to be cool infront of music people.
>>121659363If that was the first Genesis album you listened to, you're doing it wrong. Listen in chronological order, like you would any other artist.
>>121659423I bought it at a flea market and a CD box is broken so it was cheap
>>121659363To be fair, you have to have an understanding of English whimsy & humor in order to fully appreciate it imo
>>121659363If you can’t hear it, just walk away slowly
For the May Day is the great daySung along the old straight track.And those who ancient lines did leywill heed the song that calls them back!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gedXJ4LXVHk
>AOTYhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDzmRk0fbok
>>121663035Pass the word, and pass the lady, pass the plate to all who hunger!Pass the wit of ancient wisdom, pass the cup of crimson wondeeee-E-eeee-E-eeee-E-eeeeeer!
>>121654137I want to start a new prog subcategory called yacht-prog or mellow prog with this album and Camel's Breathless for starters.
>>121663840https://youtube.com/watch?v=s1bshJW_0Zs
>>121663748The last minute and a half of this song is god-tier. Eloy is an amazing band
>Ermmm... sir? Why aren't you listening to music approved for goym?why are xhey like this?
>>121664185What are you trying to convey? The onions likes pop prog or doesn’t like it?
>>121664201Commercial Slop = Good, worth listening toCommercial Flop = Super Low scores on Wikipedia
>>121664201I just hate Mossad agents, that's all
>>121664536https://youtube.com/watch?v=wmzE3-h2CxQ
>>121664248Fuck you.
>>121664248I still don’t get it. You’re mocking prog snobs, critics, basedsters, hipsters, what?It doesn’t even really make sense because pop Genesis was huge and is respected now for some reason, but ELP love beach is an obligatory meme album that no normie is allowed to enjoy or even listen to
>>121665198that image exists in response to a post about Supertramp (the album) not being well received when it first released
>>121665676To be fair, Richard Palmer-James does sing very terribly on a few songs
>>121665676'pedia status?
>listening to this 2005 version of Kobaia>do a double take because the first verse is sung in English instead of Kobaian>do a bit of digging realize that the original 1970 Kobaia is sung in English too but the french accent is so bad that it sounds like Kobaianwhat the fuck mind blownhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zhcos50EZ6I
Did you remember to remember the Alamo today?
>>121666448why does he look like Gandhi
Gentle Gianthttps://youtu.be/TT-3SAcsosI?si=3JuKmrkOr6l5fItW
AKcKnowledge KconstruKction
>>121667167have you ever seen phil and gandhi in the same room?
>>121668409adrian in his jammies is the best part
>>121667678I see you king
Favorite prog soundtracks? Two I love are Suspiria's soundtrack by Goblin and Caliber 9's by Osanna
>>121669027Gabriel's Passion.
>>121669027Pink Floyd's Zabriskie Point soundtrack is underrated, shame most of it got scrappedhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wZVWrh_oiHo
>>121669027https://youtube.com/watch?v=wSQOR8QWCmc
>>121669027These guys shoulda made a proper avant-folk album with some european chick singing over it.. woulda been amazinghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LPn9dcb5cIghttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkFraEKXwLA
>>121668571WELL CAN YOU PULL ME OUT OF THIS SLEEPLESS NIGHT
>>121649562Back Door Angels is one of their best songs
>>121669027Goblin's Suspiria soundtrack is great indeed! Also, I'd say this is pretty proggy.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LpVNNC52Q_o
holy shit bros...
>>121669794Now I remember Ant played on Camel's Single Factor
JOHN AND I ARE ABLETO FACE THE DOKTOR AT HIS MARBLE TABLE
>>121649379damn phil let himself go
>>121663759oh shit, new bondage fruitthanks for the heads upwith the new Present recently I'm eating good
>>121670576JUST FOR THE RECORD, I'M GONNA CHANGE MY LIFE AROUND
>>121668333What's Phil's stance on nuclear weapons?
it's kino
my autism made me "fix" Starless and Bible Black and turned it into the double album it shouldve beenIt would go like this:>The Great Deceiverhttps://youtu.be/-O5Yvvz8XY0?si=x10xxTjuQWNdCUkj>Lamenthttps://youtu.be/Rm5lDmY88jc?si=2H-F4_mZeKcy28Fc>The Law of Maximum Distress/The Mincerhttps://youtu.be/2vbFS1O_Cio?si=-lib-P0QzzvcsUY7>The Night Watchhttps://youtu.be/-qCXHghedxw?si=oshQHx6_en8FkpOk>Sharks' Lungs in Lemsiphttps://youtu.be/5iN_dmbdGvk?si=BkmAmD-lkpvKATxc>Guts on my Sidehttps://youtu.be/yTz1V4Dhaow?si=LtYHiYGYPt24N3tw>Tight Scrummyhttps://youtu.be/MaHOXTJSWeA?si=s_ExU7pRAjgyDPCI>We'll Let You Knowhttps://youtu.be/ZoL2UMIIcKk?si=Zo65Wb8neyLv9QcC>The Fright Watchhttps://youtu.be/BnBH7NHeVwQ?si=LIOoVkDgRGZPRNJW>Dr Diamondhttps://youtu.be/LdHRaALXO38?si=ukK90AbU0G2KW1Hl>Triohttps://youtu.be/FI5FWwFagFk?si=g_RAXHm-bBH0sHjx>Starless and Bible Blackhttps://youtu.be/T0F1jOZpQYQ?si=HvZP5k5Hrh6HkZN2>Fracturehttps://youtu.be/7gyBq8QJMjA?si=afxLrM6mLszKhSiWI changed the order of some songs and included others strictly from the 3 gigs they properly recorded in the last months of 1973 (amsterdam, glasgow and zurich) Did this for no reason at all but it already is a banger playlist
>>121672186This honestly sounds like a god-tier idea. I had actually never heard Guts on my side before. Very interesting
goodnight bump
>>121669794Big influence on me for rythm guitar
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qlEbUqOPWs8
>>121671475Correct
https://youtube.com/watch?v=atOsiuv1Pjkrip richard tandy
Imagine if KC put Cerberus on Red instead of Providence. As much as I love that track, Cerberus reaches max Crimson intensity and to have the album peak with that followed by Starless to close out it all out would have been kino af
>NOWHERE TO HANG MY GUN>NO TIME TO SAY HELLO>AND EVERY MOTHER'S SON>HE WANTS TO SEE YOU SWING>I TAKE THE JOB AGAIN>AND YOU WILL NEVER KNOW>I DREAD THE MOMENT WHEN>THE TELEPHONE WILL RING
>>121679568Kino album
Power To Believe time
GAZING QUITE VACANTLY INTO SPACEONE DAYSITTING UP IN MY BED SURROUNDED BY A FEW SUNDAY PAPERS AND THEIR COLOUR SUPPLEMENTS
I'm so used to counting out odd time signatures i end up getting lost when in 4/4 sometimes cause i subdivide it out of habit
>>121682855SUBDIVISIONS
sneed
>>121682997i keep counting it as 3+3+2 !!!! It works but its unnecessary for simple 4/4 !!!
Prog = odd time signatures is such a meme…i like apocalypse in 9/8, sure, but it’s about so much more than just the beat
>>121672186>>121679261coincidentally enough i'm making a mixtape of all my favorite wetton improvs right now... not sure whether to put asbury park in there or not
>>121683247Tell me about Fripp, why does he wear the cross?
>>121683300a lot of satanists like to wear them, i guess a mix of camouflage and irony
>>121669027https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VTJcLE_VVX8
>>121681333That's a big ass rat
>>121649562Mid, only redeeming thing is the cool front cover (looks like a Youtube Poop) and cool rear cover (nice moddish sense of style)
Damn, this is even better than octopus
>>121685622Forgot pic
HOLY SHIT, THIS WAS OUT OF COMMUNIST HUNGARY IN 1969, this mogs 95% of early prog from the UKhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kwhGj80nkys
>>121685941>communist hungaryof course they are, they don't got any food
>>121685973CARLOS!
>>121685941Listen to The Plastic People of the Universe from Communist Czechoslovakia. Start with "Passion Play." The band is legendary.
>>121686007not enough tony.
AcKnowledge Cat Food with John Wettonhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TiMXYeI_9WE
This is an honestly incredibly underrated album, I can't believe it's not considered one of the big ones of proto-prog. Structurally, I don't think there was anything quite like it at the time.
>>121686935>It's awfully considerate of you to think of me here>And I'm most obliged to you for making it clear>That I'm not here
>>121685941>>121686659while on the topic of USSR prog here's some yuri morozovhttps://youtu.be/FO9IRZjpQis?si=POYB55u3E2lMnOXK
>>121686915AcKnowledged
why don't you just drop in?
>>121686887
>>121686935DSotM eclipses a lot off their early work. May be a but hipsterish but I prefer the early albums.
>>121687684>dsotm>eclipseshehe
Think of Me With Kindness is a better piano rock song than anything Elton John or Billy Joel ever wrote and it didn't ever chart what the fuck
>>121687313Their besthttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G5Z4bma_tUM
>>121687730Gentle giant deserved a lot more recognition than they got
how many "new" king Crimson songs have been released in the last 15 years?my count is:>radical action/meltdown/radical action II>the light of day>scarcity of miracles and thats it, are there any more? (I don't count the drum only songs)
>>121688293i know this is 16 years old, but i count it for just that one sectionhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UeasfoQrnLI
Who has the best facial hair in prog
Why do people keep getting filtered by Providence?
Phil Collins' Genesis' Invisible Touch
Fish is actually 6'5
>>121688435Tony's moustache is classy and iconic, very hard to beat70s Robert >>121683247 is up there too
>>121688750>Considered a Phil album with Genesis as a backing band>Tony's songs are still the best
Neat interview with Steve Vai. He goes into integrating his own style into the song for the Beat tour and even having trouble playing a couple sections. This tour is going to be unbelievably kinohttps://youtu.be/Ci8UW5RQ7l0
>>121688435"I used to look like one of the guys in Spinal Tap!" - Steve Hackett.
>>121688435Levin's is the most iconic, but Hackett's actually looks good.
>>121688176They certainly didn't deserve to get cherry bombs and beer bottles thrown at them by Black Sabbath fans
>>121691281>GG playing with Black SabbathNot quite on the level of Jimi Hendrix opening for Monkees but definitely up there
>>121669476This, the album is just alright but damn, that track made my jaw drop the first time I listened to it
>>121685592Sorry, "Mid" is not a proper descriptor. You have to be 18 to post here.
A
>>121692250B
>>121686977it's made worse by the fact that when Roger Waters wanted to visit Syd his sister told him he's better not trying to do that because Syd's past brought him nothing but pain and discomfort, and that fans kept pestering and stalking him anyways up to the day he died
Asia - Time Again
>>121685622>>121685675we know lol
>>121651902Fuck yeah, Asiahttps://youtube.com/watch?v=DqHDFIKk4Ak
You losers still listening to old prog.This is science, technology, AI prog.You olds are envious of this new prog.You can't have such splendor with old prog.YadayadaMagma is not good band.AI prog is better than that.Magma is bad bad band.AI prog is better than that.YadayadaHey, loser! Yes you! No? YES!https://suno.com/song/3416c453-7783-475a-8141-caf7801fc7c5
>>121651138Aren't most Prog bands trust fund bands? Lots of educated musicians who went to private schools?
>>121692786Imagine an alternate timeline where crusty punks in sleazy squats lug around their Hammond B3s and mellotrons, playing 30 minutes epics instead of 2 chord pop songs
>>121692937Never Mind the Balderdash!
>>121688293Scarcity of miracles and light of day are from an album called scarcity of miracles from 2011. It isn’t considered a crimson album by Robert despite having 5/8 of the final lineup. They only played those to fill out setlists early on. So technically the “new” ones are>radical action/meltdown/radical action 2>suitable grounds for the blues>the errors
I'm try to ruin my fav prog songs as best as I canhttps://suno.com/song/77e1bd0b-7ee1-45fc-b864-57a2ea28d953any tips/requests?
>>121659363https://suno.com/song/cf98d383-651e-4a1f-9f02-f96b86296885
Wheres the Toyah to my FrippI'm feelin pretty down about that one eh
>>121693655>requests>>121665676
the rare, elusive vanderstache
>>121693929riphttps://suno.com/song/2d8184bc-31de-4906-8d62-ff52222224db
>>121688435
>>121694144classic
remember the time I proved without a doubt that Magma's drummer Christian Verhoeven was a dirty nazi in one of these threads? remember everybody was saying "good job anon" and "wow, so revealing, I'm never listening to this shit hitlerite magma crap ever again!" and you all were cheering me?im just here to say that im glad i saved you from becoming nazis through music. what do you owe me? probably your sanity
>>121694036damn he sings terribly on this song
>>121694386>blogus-focus-hocus-pocus.jpgus
>>121694399sus
>>121694302That just made me appreciate them more
Robert Dripp
https://suno.com/song/a8dcc80c-971a-4922-8b33-9857844e066d
Damn I just found out Beardfish are back and recording a new album
>>121694302
i like themhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jV8a9hTRAKothem lyrics be very burger dystopia feelhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4JLbfPiuNLw
Any other prog musicians that are confirmed Fagmasons?
>>121694302Wtf I love Magma now
>>121692937
>>121694801Based
>>121694801kinda lame that he had to understand on a personal level that Vander is a retard to get a hint that the music is kinda gay too
>>121694801There's more schizo shit by the same guy on the same wiki page where he somehow blames Vander for indirectly killing his brotherScroll down to the comments, it's a fucking schizo goldminehttps://honest-music.fandom.com/wiki/Magma
>>121696092And the guy who he claims to be actually exists and looks the around the right agehttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ByhkRURqX2s
>>121696092>the music from magma is so powerfull that it is dangerous to some people. and cristian likes that. one day at his home we listended to maahnt and there was a lady with a dog (i cant remember wether it was stella or someone else)the dog was frigthned to death from the music and cristian liked that too. he was completly fascinated by watching his music working so good on this poor dog grining with a look of triumph and stuff.sick,man. i want this to be real
>>121696183Dude won sorcery battles, yes it’s real
>>121696357>sorcery battlesCan he beat Sukuna?
>>121696860wow some anime reference how humorous
>>121694943Not strictly prog but John Entwistle is the only rock freemason I know of. Apparently Pete and Roger didn't even find out until he died.
I never realized that the original 45 of In the Air Tonight came with a little comic booklet about Phil's life up to that point. Pretty cool.
>>121697158>me me mewhat is this? explain to me right now
>>121697367I WILL FOLLOW ME, WILL ME FOLLOW ME
>>121697367A pun on the do re mi scale and Phil secretly hinting he wanted to replace Peter
>>121696883You're right, I was out of line, prog is serious business
>>121696183Reminds me of that one guy who used to comment on a lot of Youtube videos of anything King-Crimson related that Robert Fripp raped him and was leading some sort of pedo dungeon.
Robert Fripp (or as I like to call him Rapist Freak) actually raped me as a child when he announced that he will compose Microsoft Windows music. I was a huge Linux and King Crimson fan at the same time and then Freak had to rape my child soul.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W7qz1LRCPPw
>>121697603he does have a cult leader vibe to himhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YmCcbZVZH9A
Yes > your favorite band CttE > your favorite album"CttE" > your favorite songSimple as.
>>121688947
>>121698117No
>>121697837Someone on Reddit once mentioned that you can hear the Windows 10 error sound in TCOTCK at 4:53 and now I cannot not hear ithttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ukgraQ-xkp4
>>121698165Maybe
>>121698117But anon, what if Yes is my favorite band, CttE is my fave album and CttE is my favorite song?
>>121698639Then you fell for my ruse. Yes is the best band, CttE is the best album, but "Heart of the Sunrise" is actually the best song.
>>121698117>Yes > your favorite bandlol. not even close>CttE > your favorite albumpossible, but siberian khatru really brings it down>"CttE" > your favorite songBut that is my favorite song. It is literally perfect.
>>121698804>"Heart of the Sunrise"Sound Chaser**Gosh darn auto correct
>>121698804>Heart of the SunriseFunny way to spell Tempus Fugit
>yeah, my favourite band is Yes>Close to the Edge?>Heart of the Sunrise?>Sound Chaser?>wtf are you talking about, sounds gay lol>Siri, play Owner of a Lonely Heart
>>121698917>Relayer >>121698945>Drama>>121699098Now there's some good taste.
>>121698836>not even closeEh, I'll allow disparaging comments against Yes simply because they have enough less-than-great albums to drag their overall discography down. But by that metric it would be harder for me to come up with an alternative because few bands have perfect discographies unless they just have two or three albums.
>>121699098Not even the best song on the albumhttps://youtube.com/watch?v=OeVgcIFEh3I
the secret best Yes song... Shhhh!
>>121699139>few bands have perfect discographiesname them
>>121699261Unironically KC>LizardYES>ConstruKction of LightYES>Toyah & Fripp's Sunday LunchYES!
>>121699261Neutral Milk Hotel
>>121699261Buggles
>>121699261UKi mean, it was only 2 albums but still...
>>121699261magmainb4 >Mercimerci's only looked down on for being jarring
>>121699261Is Gong prog?
>>121699284>>121699351nah, Magma can't innovate for shit, KC steered away from its core thrust too much>>121699329>>121699321>>121699300this is a progrock thread>>121699378yes, and their disco ain't perfect
>>121699139Yes has two good albums. CttE and CttE2: Electric Boogaloo.I never hold it against bands when they churn out shit album after shit album. Even if they release a double album with one great disc and one shit disc, I still consider that to be a great album. If, however, they release a double album with good and shit tracks all jumbled up, I consider that a bad album. All I want are good discs.
>>121699389>UK isn't prog
>>121699407UK is a country. this isn't /int/
>>121699409You'll do yourself a mischief troll !
>>121699409Well Genesis is a book and Magma is ro... okay, Magma can stay
>>121699261XTC
furippu
>>121699764vander-sama
>>121699409>Yes? What a stupid name...
>>121699764>>121699803Your kungfu ain't shit
>>121699261>writes 12 great albums in a row in your path
>tfw tony levin with adrian's hair https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PeeeoPKZBuo
>>121699396>he doesn't like The Yes Album or FragileWhy are you even here?
>>121700001Literally unrecognizable. Great jam tho
>>121699958Hope you aren't including ItWoP.
>>121700149just cause he ripped off most of the album from previously existing songs doesn't mean he didn't "write" it
>>121700149Just cause he ripped off most of the album from previously existing songs doesn't mean it isn't great
>>121700324I agree he wrote it. I don't agree that it's "great."
>>121699261Roxy Music
Post more great albums with bad singing.
>>121700001i had no idea there was footage of him with hair and/or without a mustache
The Simpsons theme song is my favorite prog song
>>121701748literally any 2010s kc album
>>121659423nta but this was my first genesis album and i didnt get filtered
>>121698274Good news, it's not quite the same, but it is surprisingly close. And considering Brian Eno composed the startup sound for Windows 95, I can only assume the team responsible for the sounds in Windows are and always have been those kinds of nerds. I can't rule out that they were listening to that and decided to use a similar sound instead of sampling it outright. Honestly, I would feel just slightly less hopeless about the direction Microsoft is trending if that kind of silly shit still happens.
>>121694801vander probably has some cognitive disorder adjacent to severe autism or schizophrenia. even the way he talks about music in some interviews just seems like he's drank a little too much of a superstition-laced kool-aid. I think he's a talented drummer and composer but his nazi fixation just seems so irrational and out of nowhere, especially with how much he worships john fucking coltrane of all people.it's also funny seeing him shit on michael brecker, an objectively insanely talented sax player. seems threatened that there's someone else who could be on the same level as coltrane.>>121694302>you can't listen to nazi musicians without being le heckin sympathizer!!i'm not religious and i adore coltrane. cope and mald.
>>121697158And the comic was drawn by Phil's brother. I have a copy.
>Walking in the supermarket>Hear a familiar song over the PA>Hey is that Genesis>It's just Follow You>It's not even the original just a cover>Not even a cover of the original but the Ray Wilson versionGot to fulfill that CanCon quota I guessAlso I found this exists:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p9_YNrgtLsU
>>121703638He's a walking contradiction>calls africans a bunch of degenerates in a french interview>got kicked out of a venue for making a racist remark at some black employeebut>has literally called himself "a black man born in a white man's body">has literally said that Magma is black music and makes a distinction between black people music and white people music
fugazi > the resttired of pretending
>>121707981fugazi but if it was shoegaze it would be shugazi
>>121692279>take me to the breathe and BEchrist I haven't listened to this album for over 10 years.
>>121701782https://youtube.com/watch?v=amxDkP_0gxsHere you can see Tony bald but no mustache
hi. is this sbb-allowing thread? yes? here is sbb thenhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iq2WKo5s8e8
>>121708952i've never been able to get into them. don't know what it is. i give it a shot every few years.
MY HOUSE
post chill weekend /mu/https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iePV2WXMsq8
>>121709102https://youtube.com/watch?v=k32wQc4zAxc
>>121709102https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nGJ6YPdtSE0
>>121702337fuck you
>>121710808fuck you too Jakko
>>121710853
>>121709535>absent lovers... absent lovers...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sdnBHAac9VM
big funhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ggifg9GD180
>>121693975dave grohl looking ass
Asia-era John Wetton
>>121714062Tony Levin
is this the photo thread
>>121714191Rick Wakeman
>>121714293Neil Peart
>>121714430pat mastelotto
Roger Waters
bumphttps://youtube.com/watch?v=CdpbiscUpB8
