Anonymous ## Mod
04/25/25(Fri)15:48:46 No.4409003

Anonymous ## Mod 04/25/25(Fri)15:48:46 No.4409003

Before starting a new thread, please check the catalog for existing threads.
>>>/u/catalog

>>4514935
People twisted the meaning (for their own convenience). Class S can be seen in a similar way to what tentacles were in the first place, an anti-censorship measure, but that was lost over time, since Class S was the only way they could show love between girls and certain people wouldn't complain about it.

>>4514935
Nobody wants to read stories where lesbians commit lovers suicides. This is a limitation of the era, not something the romanticize.

>>4514941
Class S is defined by censorship and Japanese society being garbage to women and especially lesbians. It doesnt matter if you consider it "twisted", it just reflected the reality of the situation. It's just depressing, unsatisfying, shitty defeatism. Lesbians who can only stay together as a "phase" and either have to choose death or marry a man after those youthful days are over.

It's good that Class S died and everyone who is trying to bring it back should be punched int the gut till they vomit up their organs.
Yuri exists beyond those limitations of the past.

>>4514948
>>It's good that Class S died and everyone who is trying to bring it back should be punched int the gut till they vomit up their organs.

The problem is when people confuse bait with Class S, when the latter can be considered a genre in itself, the former is simply bad writing and an author/director being a son of a bitch who pretends he is being intelligent or directly thinks he knows what he is doing.

>>4514951
Class S isnt bait, because the negative outcome was the default. Nobody reading a Class S work expected anything good from it, especially the more commonly popularized Class S garbage from the 60s-80s.
And I very much consider Class S badly and lazily written. You can only read "And then they gave up their 'childish' feelings for each other and got married to men" so many times until it becomes clear that there was no value to this expression. This doesn't address the struggles of lesbians in a meaningful way, especially when repeated ad nauseum. The main attraction to people who read that shit is that vague ephemeral feelings of a """"pure"""" relationship before moving on to reality.

Yuri is capable of doing anythingh Class S did without getting stuck in its stifling niche.

>>4515005
Class S uses the excuse of the era and that times were different, but the bait examples have no real justification. Why even suggest the slightest possibility of yuri if the Het route was the only true option all along? Any justification is just an excuse to pretend that it was something "good" and "necessary."

>>4515019
Volume 8 ended with the sex on Christmas chapter in their first year of college.
In the past people said the LN changes/adds stuff so I prefer to read that.

>>4515021
From what I have heard the LN doesn't change a lot, but it is true that it has bonus chapters. However, Angela translates those too and adds them to the WN translation.
But yeah going by your spoiler the WN translation is actually head to head with the LN right now. Which is impressive because Angela translated like 3 LN volumes worth of chapters in 2025 alone.

There is the machine translation of the WN which is nearly up to date, but I would never touch MTL garbage. But because of that one there are people who know some spoilers that make it annoying to avoid knowing some stuff. So I know some answers to your questions, like what happens with Maika.

Well knowing we are about at the same point I can actually properly reply now >>4515008
>the story keeps being all focused about Sendai and Miyagi wihout wasting time on unncessary stuff
While I sort of appreciate it, I also sometimes feel like this leads to circular writing. So much stuff just keeps repeating, so many inner monologues sound the same, because they are just repeating thoughts we hard 10 times before. It actually feels like a lot of the most relationship moving events take place when their relationships is challenged by an outside factor like Maika or work or hiding from Umina back in the high school volumes. Like there is no doubt that 70% of character development is fueled by jealousy or possessivenes between them...

Personally, while I don't need there to be a proper ensemble cast, I would like some more proper integration of the side characters. I never feel it's believable that Miyagi and Sendai have a social circle, because they basically are all non-entities (except for Maika). Also a lot of the fun of the early volumes was them navigating their social circles while hiding their relationship, but now they are always at home hanging out, so there is just no tension and no reason to have side-characters do much.

>>4515027
The parts when they're alone at home are my favourite ones so on the contrary I appreciate the story won't change its setting. I can go on living just by feeding my heart on those.

So at the moment there is enough material for at least other two volumes, right?
Now they are releasing one volume per season, so it should be fine until summer and in the meanwhile new WN chapters will be out but the question is how much time does it take to write chapters for a new volume?

>>4515033
LN Volume 8 ends around the 220s of the WN. There are still over 200 untranslated WN chapters left. So by that calculation, there is enough material for at least 8 more LN volumes.
Consiering the absolute snail's pace ShuuKura moves at, I guess it's not inconceivable that the WN isnt finished even after 16 volumes worth of chapters...
>I appreciate the story won't change its setting
I didnt say anything about changing the setting, but I am getting incredibly bored from being stuck in the same 3 rooms for 4 volumes straight. At least Volume 1-4 had some school chapters.
Are you seriously telling me you didn't like the aquarium date? Wasn't Miyagi fleeing to Maika's place and their confrontation with Sendai there exciting? What about meeting at the music classroom back in high school? Most of the good moments happen when they leave their monotonous circular cramped little world.

I am more interested in Maika disocevering their relationships than reading for the 100th time how Sendai traces Miyagi's lips with her fingers, kisses her, then pulls back and kisses her again.

Not that I'm not impressed by the author's skill to make a story where they are stuck in the same damn room for 4 volumes work. But outside stimulation is what makes these characters actually evolve. I think they would not have been stuck with this unhealthy unbalanced relationship for so long if they had confided in their friends and actually tried to get some outside opinions.

>>4515043
>there is enough material for at least 8 more LN volumes
Holy shit, you made my day.

Obviously I liked the aquarium date like any other of their dates beucase they're still moments about them and only them, what I like less (but it's not like I dislike them either) is when there's someone else between them, like the moments when they are with Maika because they can't act naturally since they have to hide their relationship. It's still good because even in those moments the story is still about them, like how they're jealous of each other (that's why the series is so good) but I still think those moments where they have to put on an act are less interesting then the moments when they can hit each other with their feelings.
One scene I disliked in this volume is the one in which Sendai had to lie and tell Maika she bought the earrings herself. I was so glad when Sendai openly told Mio the truth about her earrings so when she had to lie, and in front of Miyagi, it let me down.

>reading for the 100th time how Sendai traces Miyagi's lips with her fingers, kisses her, then pulls back and kisses her again
I love it. This added to their internal monologue when they're doing that.

>>4514870
SakuRei has far too much fanart at this point for that.

File: Nononbi 3.jpg (31 KB, 192x452)

31 KB JPG

>>4515009
There are so many wrong things with this posts.
First of all, there is no proof that men don't exist at all in MahoAko, that's just a fanon assumption.
Second, even without men, most other vertebrates have dicks of their own.
And third, you don't even need to know about dicks to come up with the concept of a dildo, knowing that vaginal walls feel good when stimulated, so something made to fit their shape and size would naturally stimulate them better than fingers.

>>4514832
The anime was really good. The novels got more inner monologue for Renako which is usually not a good thing tho.

>>4514832
>>4514844
I disagree with that, Renakos inner monologue adds a lot. Especially reading her gay thirst makes her "I swear I don't like girls" even funnier.
It also fleshes her gamer and insufferable parts out more.

>>4514921
Seeing even more of her gamer girlfailure and insufferable side is exactly why the less narration we get from this autistic self-denying lesbian the better.
Honestly, the "I'm not into women" coming after she started dating two girls actually gave me an aneurysm.

You forgot that the biggest reason to Mai and Ajisai accept Renako confession is because she was a cosplayer
Cosplayer can had dozen of girl if theie tried

>>4515000
Sure Kaho now try to become the new member of Renako's harem or just settle with Serara before she becomes part of Haruna's harem.

>>4514972
I mean what Fubuki says implies that if there were men in the base things would be different which is definitely not very yuri.
Also I didn't say Ruka was interested by men either since she already said she wasn't interested in them either, it feels more like she's asexual than anything.

>>4514973
something dropping soap in prison

>>4514976
I am sorry, but you really are just moving goalposts because you can't get anywhere with your bad arguments.
Fubuki acknowledging that if men were around then attraction to men could be an option is just completely irrelevant to your original claim. And there is nothing particularly wrong with that view. I am sure some of the women at the base really are bisexual. Ruka isn't though, so it doesn't matter.
>Ruka is asexual
You are basing this on literally nothing, while ignoring hundreds of hours of Ruka showing explicit attraction to girls. Once again, this is not a claim someone who plays HBR could possibly make. Nobody gets into a random bond episode 300 hours into the game and suddenly changes their entire perspective on a dime because of some extremely dubious misinterpretation of a single exchange. In the same chapter in which she actively shows sexual attraction to another woman no less!

For fucks sake, I hope I diverted your bait now and we can move on from this brainless topic.

>>4514979
>In the same chapter in which she actively shows sexual attraction to another woman no less!
If your takeaway from the chapter after finishing it is that Ruka was feeling horny when she was doing all those shit to Tezuka then I can't do anything for you because you clearly don't have the cognitive capacities to understand very basic narrative.

>>4514983
Oh now I get your game. You are just gonna pretend absolutely any moment of her being sexually attracted to girls is just a joke. This is the same old homophobic shit that's always used to descredit yuri. For fucks sake.
But lets pretend you werent a dishonest piece of shit.
-In the early chapters Ruka has internal monologue about how she wants to kiss and lick Karerin's face while she is sleeping, because she is attracted to her. There is nobody to make a joke to, this is her internal thoughts
-Swimsuit 2: Literally hitting and oggling Yukki the entire time, staring at her asscrack etc.
-Ichigo's and Yunyun's early bond episodes where she stares at their tits and even wants to touch them (says she finds Yunyun sexier with the Chinese dress on, which is pretty funny though)
-Yunyun memory episode where her and Yunyun go around discussing which girls are the sexiest at the base and Ruka points to Yukki that she is a sexy beast without even trying (Yukki is literally the least lewd person around, Ruka is just attracted to her)
-Ruka being flustered when Koju tells her to undress her body in Koju's event
-Ruka molesting Yuina in Swimsuit 2
-Ruka getting swooning for Aoi in her memory episodes and having her heart race from her acting girly
-Ruka wanting to kiss Yukki in several scenarios
-Ruka licking Isuzu's ear in her bond episode and being flustered by being hit on by Isuzu
-The sexual scenario with Tezuka exciting her in 5.3
-Ruka admitting she wanted to make Higumin more feminine just to serve her own preferences in her memory episode


Comment too long. Click here to view the full text.

File: G-SHTEzaIAAn0Dd.jpg (979 KB, 1447x2046)

979 KB JPG

>>4514965

>>4512634
scene0

>>4512967
rape in that case

>>4512370
That's not a real thing though and not supported by anything. So if MadoHomu gets axed, Madoka loses its only canon yuri.

File: 1723624078125697.jpg (69 KB, 443x602)

69 KB JPG

>>4514222

File: __original_drawn_by_cjr_c(...).jpg (860 KB, 2400x3500)

860 KB JPG

>>4514205
>>4514215
Who cares

>>4514327
I do.

>>4514327
>who on the yuri board cares about yuri
Are you retarded? There is an entire fucking board for you to just post generic ecchi shit.
>>>/e/

>>4514215
You need at least a year off the Internet