Which one is the less harmful? Also, are they really THAT bad?
>>22291883>Also, are they really THAT bad?no not really, only in excess, like most things
>>22291883Avocado master race. Because I cook everything at max temp. Temperature regulation is for cowards.
>>22291883if u wanna slow down your metabolism, get skin cancer and risk heart disease its ur choice
>>22291883Unrefined (cold pressed and a little lesser extent expeller pressed) sunflower oil is fine. And should never be treated like the trash pictured here
>>22291883Is corn a seed?
>>22291883Yay, this thread again. No one cares here. Trolls trolling trolls trolling trolls. And yes, I know, you win.
>>22291885>only in excess, like most thingsLike all things you mean. Because excess literally means that its too much.But what is an excessive amount of any given food? Well its completely different for absolutely everything. An excessive amount of steak that causes harm to your body is going to be completely different to an excessive amount of water which is going to be completely different from an excessive amount of carrots. An excessive amount of poison would be very small. Basically just saying "don't eat an unhealthy amount of stuff" which is such retarded advice because you don't actually explain what an excessive amount of anything is, its not real advice its just another pseud masturbatory retardism.
>>22291883probably if they're heated too much. Like most commercial fried foods the frier oil is heated continuously for days or weeks on end. Can just use olive oil or butter at home and don't worry about it
>>22291972Yes.
Canola is the healthiest cooking oil. Nice larp.
>>22291883When compared to animal fats like butter and tallow, seed oils have much better health outcomes. It's just a meme for people to blame their problems on. We have studies all over the world showing improved health benefits with PUFA intake over saturated fat.
>>22292664High PUFA fats oxidize extremely easily compared to other fats so they are much more harmful in reality. Oxidized fats are very very unhealthy to consume. That is also why fish oil pills are a scam. Most of the oil is oxidized.A lot of the studies on seed oils were sponsored by companies that directly benefit from seed oil sales. I mean heart.org is a seed oil propoganda website.
>>22292730> oxidizedThen get unoxidized oils.By far, … I mean *far*.. flaxseed oil is #1 as far as being “healthy” that it’s not even funny.The recent co-ordinated nonsensical attack on “seed oils” was primarily against canola which is just mid as far as being healthy goes.>>22291972As far as I can tell the “seed oils” attack came from the corn producers who probably realized that nobody knows corn is a seed.
>>22292743Heat, sunlight, and time all oxidize oils, so simply cooking with them creates significant amounts of oxidation products. Those clear plastic bottles you buy oil in don't help either. Plastic is oxygen permeable. Heat exponentially increases oxidation which is why cooking with seed oils is so bad. Industrially processed seed oils have all their antioxidants stripped from them, so they are especially prone to oxidation. The only not unhealthy seed oil is a cold pressed seed oil that has never been heated.
>>22292743It was not an attack on seed oils, btw. There was a canola oil shill that was getting paid by the post to shill canola oil.
>>22291883They are fine. You shouldn't be eating fried shit all the time anyways. All the anti seed oil nonsense is brought to you by the same morons that ate horse paste and fish drugs because they were too dumb to get human grade pharmaceuticals
>>22292768>the government wouldn't allow it and stores wouldn't sell it if it was bad for you>but I did eat breakfastNot going to address your strawmen and false equivalencies because you're obviously gay and being a fag cuts 40 years off your life expectancy, which is twice as unhealthy as smoking cigarettes. Go eat your MSG neurotoxin too, retard.
>>22292762Canola is the best cooking oil by most metrics.
>>22292781See>>22292730The metrics you are convinced by were from studies paid for by seed oil companies or companies that directly benefit from seed oil sales. Canola oil isn't even cheap. You get exactly what you pay for. Industrially processed cattle feed made palatable for human consumption. Canola was initially used as a machine/engine lubricant and then demand dropped for it, so they rebranded it as a healthy cooking oil.
>>22292730>High PUFA fats oxidize extremely easily compared to other fats so they are much more harmful in reality. Oxidized fats are very very unhealthy to consumeOkay but we don't see that in human trials. Inflammation goes down. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34635132/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34527059/>A lot of the studies on seed oils were sponsored by companies that directly benefit from seed oil sales. I mean heart.org is a seed oil propoganda website.This is just cope and completely false, we have data from all over the world and several different medical organizations. How come there aren't ANY studies showing seed oils are bad then? Claiming seed oil studies are all fake and gay while not being able to show any contrary evidence just makes you look dumb. Especially when you look at the absolute massive amount of studies we have showing they are one of the best options for fat consumption.
>>22292786>he still can't argue at its superiority lolCanola for everything. It's the most versatile and healthiest of all the oils and fats. It's low in saturated fat, high in unsaturated fat. High in Omega 3 fatty acids which reduce the risk of heart disease. It also contains phytosterols which prevent cholesterol from being absorbed in the body. It's also a good source of vitamin E and K. Canola has a high smoke point too. Also it's neutral tasting. It doesn't go bad as quickly as lard and doesn't require refrigeration. I mean for Christ's sakes, the advantages go on and on. Did I also mention it's also very inexpensive? Care about doing the right thing for the planet? It's an excellent rotational crop the contributes to soil health and biodiversity such as bees.There's nothing better than going out to your garden picking some lettuce and vegetables, letting it chill and shaking it with some cold expeller pressed canola.It wins in like every metric. It's a miracle oil. It's like you want people to be unhealthy. Sick fuck.
>>22292777The evidence out there points to seed oils having modest-moderate benefit over whatever trendy oil you shove down your obese gullet, now go eat your horse paste goy
>>22292793Neither of those studies look at oxidized oils, lmao. In the garbage they go.>>22292794>cannot refute the oxidation problem with canola oilNice shill post, and not an argument. Looking forward to your inevitable meltdown.>>22292801>animal fats and olive oil, trendyRetard. Last seed oil thread we had the canola shill calling it the "oil of the future" and engineered for performance. LOL
>>22292816>still can't refuteLol!
>>22292819>still seething, coping, and projecting weeks later.KEK! Consolewarsfags are beyond mentally ill.
There will be zero good faith replies to the oxidation problem with seed oils. Just watch.
>>22292824>still can't refuteLol!
>>22292816Flaxseed oil does oxidize>>22292826Okay, how about you tell me the side effects of "oxidized seed oils" and show me via studies people who eat more seed oils suffering from those symptoms more compared to people who eat other fats.You can mechanistically speculate all you want. But it's pointless if we don't actually see those outcomes in people.
>>22292835Yes. Flaxseed is extremely high in PUFA. It is a highly unstable oil. Do people cook with it? How is flaxseed oil normally extracted when consumed for health benefits?Do you think that aldehydes and free radicals are considered part of a healthy diet?Please readhttps://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10252270/
Alsohttps://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2422990/
>>22292816>the canola shill calling it the "oil of the future" and engineered for performancetechnically he's right, in a pilpul waycanola aka RAPEseed oil is a modern soientific invention engineered for performance (as an industrial lubricant)
>>22291883Get a hobby
Here's an interesting article talking about a study where they looked at seed oils vs. saturated fats and how lowering cholesterol may not actually reduce CHD.https://naturalhealthresearch.org/does-a-diet-high-in-linoleic-acid-prevent-coronary-heart-disease/
>>22292858As you can see that poor guy was completely and utterly mindbroken in the last thread. Pay him no mind.
>>22291883From my unprofessional ass can tell, there at least 3 things to be concerned of: trans fats, saturated/unsaturated, and oxidationExcess saturated fats are worse than unsat. in the long run. Heart disease is the biggest killer of people thats also preventative and more saturated fat consumption increases risk of heart disease. The literature here is solid; anyone saying otherwise is not trustworthy like people who promote animal fats as healthier. In this sense, FOR THE AVE GUY, stuff like coconut oil should not be consumed regularly over other seed oils. Theres asians who smoke into their 90s without any lung cancer. Woaw good for them. On ave, smoking increases risk of cancers, no doubt about it. If you think ur in the small minority who won't suffer, by all means consume what u want. But saying others should do it reg. is just unethical and asshole behavior. Animal fat also contain trans fats, like butterThere are *at least* hypothetical pathways for which stuff in oils can break down into certain products and may react with other stuff that also become detrimental to you in the long run. I don't remember if those pathways have confirmed to exists, again not a professional. But theres nothing wrong with being precautious, and wanted to consume less oils that oxidize and make it halfway along the chemical pathway. However, there is some misconception about "smoke point". Smoke point is not necessarily when the oil breaks down into "halfway mark" products; it's the breakdown into a completely different product people actually don't care about. Specifically, the dehydration of glycerol -> water + acrolein. This isn't the potentially scary oxidation. Oils oxidize more over longer cooking time and with higher heat like deep frying, and those with antioxidants will oxidize slower. Refined oils contain less antioxidants. The two best oils to deep fry IF this is the only concern is EVOO and coconut oil. Obv this shouldnt the only concern
>still can't refuteLol!
I win
>>22292730If oxidation is the issue, then shouldn't refining the oils render them healthier? Refined, bleached, and deodorized oils have lower peroxide values and superior oxidative stability.
>>22292873Oxidation rate is increased after industrial processing even if it starts from "zero" after processing because the oils are stripped of their naturally occuring antioxidants that prevent oxidation during storage and cooking. It's why olive oil is actually a good cooking oil from a health perspective. Better heat stability from antioxidants even though it has a lower smoke point.Protip: if you insist on using canola add some rosemary to the pan. Rosemary has fat soluble antioxidants that will help prevent oxidation. :D
>>22292848>https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10252270/This isn't a human trial. Where is the human outcome data? AGAIN>Okay, how about you tell me the side effects of "oxidized seed oils" and show me via studies people who eat more seed oils suffering from those symptoms more compared to people who eat other fats.
>>22292861The Sydney Heart Study and the MCE are both heavily flawed and old studies. There is a reason their results have not been replicated in over 50 years. I wrote a copy pasta for it years ago:Sydney Heart Study: >Was not even a significant cholesterol difference, only 12 mg/dL>It should be noted that the SDHS was a secondary prevention trial(it says so in the title), which means that the subjects had already had a single CVD event at the time of enrollment, which greatly increases the chance of a secondary one regardless of diet.From the study itself: >The SDHS also had several important limitations. Some control participants began substituting polyunsaturated margarine for butter—leading to substantial, but comparatively modest, dietary changes in the same direction as the intervention group. These changes may have attenuated the observed differences in mortality between the groups, leading to an underestimation of the adverse effects of the intervention. Consistent with other trials investigating the secondary prevention of coronary heart disease, both groups made healthy lifestyle modifications (for example, smoking reduction), probably from personal reassessment that accompanies a coronary event.MCE:>Participants were able to enter and exit the trial at their leasure>follow up time was only 1.5 years>Again...Margarines back then were all hydrogenated. Meaning they were high in trans-fats, meaning you could say these events were caused from the trans-fat increase.
Butter for bakingCanola for everything elseSimple as.
>>22292883Answer my questions. You really need a population study to prove that free radicals are unhealthy? Are you retarded?
>>22291883>Also, are they really THAT bad?I don't really know. There is some evidence that they easily become oxidized which probably isn't great to consume in large amounts. Some people claim PUFA is inherently bad for you even if it's not oxidized but I'm not sure about that.But at the same time, people are just consuming too much added fat in general which is going to cause problems no matter what type of fat you consume. Advice used to be "limit added fat altogether" but it seems like that's not what a lot of people want to hear anymore.
>>22292898Correct. We got a guy in this thread that drenches iceberg lettuce in canola oil and calls it a healthy gourmet meal. Imagine a bowl of cereal, but the milk is canola oil and the cereal is pre shredded iceberg... People want a guilt free oil and there is no such thing all things considered.
>>22292786>Canola oil isn't even cheapWhere I live it's the same price as "vegetable' (soybean) oil at Sam's Club
>>22292932Cheap vs. Inexpensive
>>22291986>But what is an excessive amount of any given food? Well its completely different for absolutely everything.No fucking shit you tryhard. That should be common sense. If people want to consume seed oils, or whatever, they can find out themselves what an excess of it is.
>>22292786>Canola was initially used as a machine/engine lubricant and then demand dropped for it, so they rebranded it as a healthy cooking oilEh, this is a misleading oversimplification. Yeah rapeseed oil is as lubricant but canola oil is made from a strain of rapeseed in the 1970s that removed the erucic acid which made regular rapeseed unsafe for consumption. The rapeseed oil they use industrially and canola oil are different chemically.
>>22292897I'm not saying they aren't unhealthy. What I'm saying is human bodies are much more complicated than simple observational mechanics. Seed oils also contain antioxidants which help protect against free radicals. The population study is important because it shows us if the amount of free radicals are actually causing harm to us AFTER you factor in things like antioxidants and the body's natural defense systems. I don't think there is a single marker that gets worse when you replace animal fats with seed oils.
>>22292950>No fucking shit you tryhardNo fucking shit? The guy said DURR DONT EAT EXCESSIVE AMOUNT OF ANYTHING BRO how is that not the most common sense thing? Don't consume a dangerous amount of any substance!> they can find out themselves what an excess of it isThe literal question of the thread was asking how safe it is you fat fucking idiot.
>>22292955Hot/solvent extracted seed oils have their antioxidants stripped away during processing. Im all for cold pressed seed oils and think many are healthy and some are even medicinal.
>>22292816Olive is fine, animal fats and dairy will give you a modest-moderately early death. Eat away tho, see if I give a fug, you tards are good job security for the industrial medical complex
>go on pubmed>hundreds of human trials on seed oils>numerous health benefits that come from the higher omega 3 content and lower saturated fat compared to animal fats>inconclusive or negligible evidence showing more systemic inflammation effects >animal fatties rest on this one single thing that is still unproven, along with falsely claiming food grade seed oils are industrial lubricants>they dance around thinking they won, deflecting and dismissing every piece of evidence that they are wrong, and boldly claim you will die or get a serious condition before them while they shove 150% the limit of saturated fats down their gullet on a daily basis
>>22292966People that talk like you are just projecting their gluttonous and unhealthy lifestyle onto other people. A tbsp of animal fat or an ounce of cheese a day is totally health neutral. You assume everyone consumes multiple cups of oil per day because that is what you do.Oh yeah, enjoy cancer from the oxidation byproducts created through easily oxidized oils like all seed oils. I hear cancer is really good job security for the industrial medical complex. Kek
>>22292976>yes, I am too scared to engage with the discussion in a good faith manner.>projects>copesLmao. Typical seedlet behavior.
>>22292979I can outrun and out lift you fatty go slurp down your animal fats because it's heckin healthy
>>22292976The anti seed oil crowd has neither the brain power or the education to critically appraise research literature
>>22292976The results of the largest most comprehensive and best administered Coronary study in history was buried for decades.Minnesota Coronary Surveyhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rQmqVVmMB3kIt's obvious that you won't watch it, so this is for the benefit of others.
>>22292984You just proved my point exactly. Thank you. :)>>22292987>brainrotted consolewars generalization.Hilariously low IQ take bro.
>>22292990Typical of the retard crowd, he does his research by listening to unqualified literal who's from YouTube and Facebook. Toppest of keks to you good sir. You're right I won't watch it, good intuition
>>22292995You're fat and stupid, fix one or both of those please
>>22292996>he does his research byMan, so you read the MCE already?Sophist piece of shit.
>>22292976>>22292996Scumbag sophist.
>>22293002Yeah im not going to the doctor for advice about my car and I'm not going to the mechanic for fitness advice. We also don't make medical decisions from a single study btw, I know this is a confusing concept but decisions to go in any one direction require more thorough approaches
>>22292998>melts down and has temper tantrumYikes! Not a great look for the seedboys!
>>22293010If you're so worried about your heart health go for a jog tubbo, all that extra lard you're carrying around will be the death of ye
>>22293013>concedes>projects again!LOL thanks for the easy win. Sorry I got you so incredibly upset. I was just having an adult conversation with other adults before you stumbled in and started crying and screaming. Kek
>>22293027Listen tubby I gotta run but you sound real mad - here's some good advice for you, start couch to 5k it's made for fatties. you can eventually work your way towards actually running distance and you'll probably live longer. Swing by the roon thread on /fit/ people there are reasonable. Good luck with your weight loss journey!
>>22293027more like conSEEDS wahahaha
>>22293033>runs away cryingAs expected. Lmao
Usually canola except for butter in a few situations or sesame if making Asian stuff.
>>22293007>>22293002>>22292990see:>>22292889Quoting the MCE is just bad faith. Why have the results never been replicated? Why do you have to rely on 50 year old research?Quoting a fucking Youtube video is hilarious btw. Just shows you had someone else tell you your opinion.
>>22292963Not all of them. Enough remain that we do not see negative health outcomes in humans.
Canola has made peoples lives better and the European Union leads output (~10.8 million tons). Also compared to 33 million total output, olive oil (an inferior and less sustainable oil) only creates 3.2 million tons and declining while Canola is the fastest growing oil with globally hit a record global output breaking 100 million metric tons of raw seed just this year. Canola is rightfully in the best restaurant kitchens worldwide.
I don't care about using seed oils or not, I use vegetable oil and canola semi-regularly. I also use olive oil, avocado oil, butter, lard, and fat left over in meat drippings if it's a good enough amount. I think fretting over seed oils themselves is unproductive, the foods that use them that cause the most harm are the ultra processed types, you shouldn't be eating those anyway desu
>>22293095Study plz.
Hey guys, mcdonalds sells the most hamburgers in the world, so surely they are the BEST hamburgers in the world! 12 mcdonald's certified flavor scientists confirm this to be true!
Mcdonalds sells 6.5 million burgers every single day, which is roughly 75 burgers per second making it the most popular hamburger worldwide by a wide margin. Yep, it's the best burger by far but everyone already knew that. McDonald's primarily uses a canola oil blend for frying their food, particularly their famous french fries. This blend is specifically formulated to achieve the desired crispiness and flavor. Superior by a wide margin. If a winner like McDonald's uses canola, so should you.
jews dont eat seed oil
>>22293151>he thinks he can just come on the internet and lie
>>22293151israel has a fairly high rate of heart disease which some people theorize is because they consume a lot of seed oil, or at least it disproves saturated fat as being a major cause because it's higher compared to france consuming more animal fat
>>22293139>seedlet confirmed fastfood addict tasteletLol. Lmao even
>>22293110>https://www.nature.com/articles/1600621>https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34527059/>https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34635132/>https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/13/7/2436/htm>https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/01.ATV.0000163185.28245.a1>https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIRCULATIONAHA.114.010236>https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00394-021-02507-1>https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/01.ATV.14.6.892>https://academic.oup.com/jcem/article/89/4/1641/2844241?login=false>https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0163782708000593?via%3Dihub>https://academic.oup.com/jcem/article/104/12/6207/5540968?login=false>https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8048052/>https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6121943/>https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38501177/>https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39133482/>https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000291652200778X?via%3Dihub>https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S000291652200778X>https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/2831265
>>22293139>McSlopald's fries its slop in industrial lubricantCool, still not using it, jew
>>22293184Hey fucktard I just went through the first 10 of these and they're all fucking garbage. 40 polynesians is my sample size/population, fuck off. We aren't talking about cold pressed flaxseed either, obviously. Quality of evidence low to very low was the last thing I read before calling out your stupid bullshit.
>>22293208OK faghttps://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2422990/
>>22293212>seedoil fags confirmed pro male genital mutilation and obsessed with baby genitals. The truth finally comes out.
I thought sunflower was one of the good ones.
>>22293208>Hey fucktard I just went through the first 10 of these and they're all fucking garbageNice detailed analysis. Weird how every cardiovascular/dietary organization on the planet is okay with these studies but anon here obviously found something they all missed. >We aren't talking about cold pressed flaxseed eitherMost of these studies include hot/solvent seed oils.https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6121943/> Unsaturated fatty rich oils like safflower, sunflower, rapeseed, flaxseed, corn, olive, soybean, palm, and coconut oil were more effective in reducing LDL-C (−0.42 to −0.20 mmol/l) as compared with SFA-rich food like butter or lard. LDL-C predicted differences based on their fatty acid composition showed that each 10% of dietary energy from butter replaced by unsaturated fatty rich oils (−0.31 to -0.22 mmol/l) were in line with findings from the NMA>https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38501177/>The consumption of rapeseed oil instead of ghee caused improvements in liver steatosis and enzymes, glycaemic variables and anthropometric measurements among individuals with NAFLD.>https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8048052/>Substituting corn oil, canola oil, or olive oil for equal amounts of butter and margarine was related to lower all-cause mortality and mortality from certain causes>https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullarticle/2831265>Primary exposures included intakes of butter (butter added at the table and from cooking) and plant-based oil (safflower, soybean, corn, canola, and olive oil)
I'm gonna try out canola. Sounds based
>>22293305>spammed 30 shit studies>gets called out for it>cherrypicks 4 shitty studies What next?Study 1: despite limitations in data. TRASHStudy 2: 110 people, too many variables. TRASHStudy 3: based off a questionnaire. TRASHStudy 4: food frequency questionnaire every 4 years. Lumping olive oil and canola in the same group. TRASHI do not think those questionnaire studies are useful at all.
>>22293305coconut oil isnt unsaturated rich lol
>>22292880So what I'm getting from this is that as long as the oil is refined, bleached, and deodorized, and has added tocopherol for storage and heat stability, it should be g2g.
>>22291883high oleic safflower or sunflower oil is the best oil
>>22293894You can pick this oil and that oil and say for this single purpose it beats other oils but canola beats them all in overall usability, health effectiveness and price. If I only had to choose one oil to use for the rest of my life it'd be canola.
>>22293897they're both high in monosaturated fat that's the most important thing. Keep you oil in the fridge also.
>>22293913Yes, canola also has plant based omega-3. Replacing butter, olive oil etc or other saturated fats with canola oil can help lower LDL “bad” cholesterol.
>>22293922sure but consuming fats is not a good idea in general. You do not consume oils to receive a health benefit. You do not need pure fat in your diet.
Can you guys believe there is someone on /ck/ that consolewars for canola oil? Of all the things to get absolutely btfo and utterly mindbroken over. Lol
Can you guys believe there is an assblasted fatass that seethes day in and day out about superior canola oil and refuses to admit any of it's well documented advantages in culinary use? Lol what a loser.
>>22293976He probably started out as a troll and then slowly started to actually believe his own lies. The path of cuckold spammers.
>>22293325>Weird how every cardiovascular/dietary organization on the planet is okay with these studies but anon here obviously found something they all missed.Really don't care on your opinion considering I know you have never taken a statistics course in your life and are just parroting whatever YouTuber of the week regurgitated into you. >I do not think those questionnaire studies are useful at all.What evidence do you have for that? Just what you "think"? There is a reason we use them in epidemiology, tons of studies have been done showing they are accurate. It's very easy for people to recall their dietary habits as people mostly eat the same things and any margin of error usually corrects itself due to the sheer mass of data we have.
>>22293976>can you believe someone would follow the dietary recommendations of every cardiovascular and dietary organization in the world? They should all be mindlessly following social media trends and influencers.
>>22293104Says someone that has no fucking idea how olive trees grow and give olives, which given the shit precipitation for exampme in Many áreas of Spain, and yet its not necesary even to give them water...very unsustainable surely. For fucks sake.Canola needs a ton of fertilizer, and rolling. Once you got the olive trees going they just keep making olives without needing much.
>>22292957Because common sense is not common anymore. When you tell someone maybe it's not a good idea to order takeout everyday they get upset. When you tell someone maybe stop ordering door dash everyday then they would have more money they get upset. An excessive amount of food really isn't different for a lot of people. Ultimately don't consume the same thing so damn frequently and you're fine. A meal with one of these oils in it once a week won't do shit to anybody. But perhaps a meal with one of these oils in it every single day will probably have an adverse effect on you. Much like eating out every day, door dashing every day, eating ice cream or candy or drinking soda every day. All of those things will fuck your health if it's consumed that much. That's why we have this fancy thing called a balanced diet.
>>22294164>two non-arguments>weConcession accepted. :D I like the study that showed ice cream is a superfood. That one was a questionnaire also.>>22294169>fell for it>believes their own liesSad.
>>22294219I think that anyone who watches the videos on how hot/solvent extracted seed oils are made should never want to eat them. It's a disgusting process that uses all sorts of nasty chemicals. Now watch people with very little common sense intensely cope over this.
>>22294251Sure but you could show slaughterhouse footage or diseased livestock and get the same reaction. How something is made alone really doesn't impact its health on us either.
>unironic schizo thread
>>22294247You didn't make any arguments to respond to. Just "I don't like the studies...because I just don't" And you didn't articulate what is wrong with epidemiology or any of the specific criticisms you have and called them "shit" while having nothing to provide yourself besides hypothesis that has no human data supporting it.
>>22294312Industrial slaughterhouses are disgustinf and you should not eat that meat. It is unhealthy. Shooting an animal, eviscerating, skinning, etc is not disgusting. You have been conditioned to ignore the obvious truth you can see with your own eyes.>>22294323They're stupid because they aren't really saying or showing that butter is unhealthy. It is saying people who eat butter are possibly less healthy. People who eat butter use it in much different ways than liquid oils, so who is to say the way it is used causes the increased CHD rather than the butter itself.
>>22292898Fpbp(43rd post best post)
>>22293106Yeah, if you’re cooking at home and not consuming too much UPFs i think it’s fine to use what suits the dish best. I don’t deep fry in butter or lard lol i don’t use canola for a scrambled egg or pan roast vegetables. I just use what makes sense and keep it mostly fresh
>>22293139You’re being obtuse.Mcshart is convenient and cheap, not the best
>>22292976>science frogbro effortlesly makes the meat slurpers project, deflect, seethe and cope>it's so bad they turn to the minessota-half-the-participants-quit-midway studyabsolutely savage
>>22294414>samefags after getting severely btfoRemarkably pathetic, but also hilarious
I don't thinks it schizophrenia, I think the anti seed oil fag is just ignorant to the research, is a zoomer/gen a caught up with retard influencers or just making absolutely crazy claims that deny all modern research to get a rise off people. Or maybe he is truly deranged. I bet he just loves us playing into his idiocy though since he is always here. So which is it?
>>22294350>Shooting an animal, eviscerating, skinning, etc is not disgustingI think most people would find that pretty unsettling and could turn them away from eating the food. Either way it doesn't really matter food isn't inherently healthy or unhealthy based on how disgusted we feel watching it get made.
>>22294350>They're stupid because they aren't really saying or showing that butter is unhealthy. It is saying people who eat butter are possibly less healthy. People who eat butter use it in much different ways than liquid oils, so who is to say the way it is used causes the increased CHD rather than the butter itself.You're just proving you didn't read any of the studies and are very uninformed on the topic. It doesn't matter how you're "using" the fat source. The studies are based on calories from the fat source.They control for socioeconomic status, alcohol, smoking, BMI, marriage, exercise, age, diet, gender and prior history of illness. Can you tell me which magic variable isn't being controlled for that would consistently influence the results that people who consume more seed oils over butter have better health outcomes?
>>22294470Most people are completely disconnected with the food they consume.>>22294466>too scared to even argue anymore>cries and whines to his "team" insteadYour post is such a beautiful distillation of pure seethe and bizarre projection. I'm not even anti-seed oil, retard. Work on your reading comprehension a little, bucko. Oh wait. It isn't reading comprehension you do that one low IQ tell where you instantly group everyone who even mildly disagrees with you into the most extreme version of that category. Only intelligent people recognize nuance and you have FAILED at that in a huge way. HAHAHA DUMMY.
On second thought it probably is some form of mental illness/schizophrenia. My bad. How sad.
>>22294477Yeah, I don't like the questionnaire and how they just estimate total amounts of oil used based on prior survey data. >Portion sizes for individual oils/fats were estimated based on the 1994–1996 USDA Continuing Survey of Food Intakes by Individuals (CSFII) [14] and intakes of cooking oils/fats were then calculated by multiplying the frequency of consumption with the corresponding portion size derived from CSFII. Just seems like a bad way to get accurate data imo.
>>22294484>totally and utterly mindbrokenSorry about that seedlet.
>>22294498Classic loser projection and reverts to gay meme language. Pathetic.
>>22294502>no uSeethe harder. :)
>>22294506We won. ;)
>>22294513>not an argumentKek. The adults are having a discussion right now lil bro. Your temper tantrum is not appreciated by either side. Cute, but also kind of embarrassing.
Total seed oil domination. You lose again :) too much BTFOing lately. HAHAHA!
>>22294523>Stratospheric levels of obsession and an utterly mindbroken consolwarsfag desperate for any imagined win they can scrape up. A truly remarkable thing to witness, and changing subjects like that is objectively a concession. Thank you! :DNow see >>22293112 and tell everyone just how much you love mcdonalds, my champion!
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12105547
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2422990/
>>22294525You lost again kid. Suck it up. ;)
ai imageop is a fag
>>22294523I didn't expect palm oil to be that high
>>22294559All anti seed oil fags are secretly drama queen queers.
>>22294555>cannot refute>concedes>ignores the study on why seed oils are bad.Seems like you are projecting again. XD>>22294564Nice projection. Lol
>>22292801>horse pasteThis phrase definitely proves you are just a propaganda parrot and have nothing of value to say.It's long been proven, and admitted by governments, that Ivermectin was effective (even congress was taking it in secret) but that knowledge was deliberately suppressed to protect the legal justification for the covid mrna shots emergency use authorization.
>>22295242No it has not.
>>22295242Seed oil shills in absolute shambles.
>>22294608>still can't refute>still lost>perpetual losing from now on Rofl.
>>22295475I was wondering if it was still you or if you left out of sheer embarrassment when everyone started ignoring you earlier in this thread. Thanks, seedlet. :)
>>22295502>still can't refuteTrip up so I can filter your embarrassing posts. At this point it's just spam when you got BTFOed so hard. ;)
>>22295505You sound incredibly angry. Can you show me where in the thread this btfoing happened? I don't think that repeating yourself constantly means you won.
>>22294562They use it in a lot of diet/sugar free drinks as an emulsifier
>>22295518>got btfoed againHow quaint. Lol XD
>>22294527Does anyone on the pro seed oil side have anything to say about this study? It links seed oil consumption to cancer and diabetes. It's quite damning.Is that why every seed oil consumer only focuses on heart health?
>>22295526I've said it before, and I'll say it again. You are acting completely mindbroken. You have just been repeating yourself over and over and over again for 3 whole threads now. Last reply from me unless you choose to produce a good faith argument or reply. You won't. You will just continue repeating yourself and acting foolish. Totally fine btw. I'm more amused by it then anything really. :)
>still can't refuteSo shut up then fatass :) hahaha
>>22294495>>22294527These two posts are the anti-seed oil posts that have remained ignored. I have another criticism on the large questionnaire study as well. None of the studies took the quality of oils into account. Grass fed animal fats are objectively healthier than grain fed ones.
>>22295528I'm not pro seed oil, I think they're not great to consume but I dislike bad arguments about why. I looked at a decent chunk of the study.It mentions that normal weight people and athletes develop insulin resistance. This may happen, but they're still a lot less likely to develop it. 90% of people who become diabetic are overweight. It says our saturated fat intake has remained stable while diabetes has increased, and it attributes this to an increase of seed oils, yet increasing any fat intake is known to raise the risk of insulin resistance. If everyone switched right now from seed oils to butter/lard/tallow you'd still see obesity and the increased health risks from that. It mentions that the act of refining seed oils removes a lot of beneficial nutrients which is closer to the real issue. Refining food to remove nutrients and making it easier to overeat is generally the problem. It's the same thing with fruit, fruit itself isn't bad and consumption is really only associated with improved health and lower disease risk, but consuming refined sugar is the opposite. It talks about comparing eating seed oil to smoking dozens of cigarettes which just seems like unnecessary fearmongering and it's not related to the topic anyway. It downplays the harm of smoking and is more focused on drama while masquerading as scientific.We need to stop eating so much processed food in general instead of arguing about which processed food is healthier. We aren't seeing the same level of risk in people who just eat more whole foods even if they have PUFAs, omega 6, saturated fat, etc.
>>22295560Those questionnaire studies also mention how people who eat more butter are married less and take more aspirin. Idk why they do that lol.
>>22295528One the first things she says is that insulin resistance was non-existent in the 1950's. According to the internet, they couldn't measure insulin resistance in the 1950's. I'm an "all things in moderation" kind of guy, I'll use seed oils, I'll use butter, I'll use whatever fits the bill for me in terms of flavor and heat management. That said, I don't trust the woman that did that paper, she seems questionable.
Vehetable oil is good for you and solves nearly all the health related problems involving animal fats.
>>22295587Diabeetus tracking started in 1958 and has seen a 7x increase since then according to google and the cdc.
>>22295598Cool. Insulin resistance wasn't measured in a standard way and recorded until the 60's. She's making very questionable claims. If your religion is to distrust seed oils, nothing anyone says will matter. But she's using numbers to lie about it. I don't trust her paper.
>>22295603She did say practically nonexistent to be precise. Less than 1% of the population had diabetes back then. Diabetes and insulin resistance are not the same metric, but go hand in hand. There isn't much actual data on insulin resistance until the 1990s apparently lol.I just want some good studies that aren't funded by people directly benefiting from seed oil sales lmao. You know the people getting actually upset are the seed oil guys, right? It's sacrilegious to question their holy science priests and their great temple of heart.org lmao.
>>22291883The one to really avoid is castor oil.
>>22295659Castor is not on that list. If we are just saying any oil then I'd avoid conventional or synthetic motor oil. For cooking purposes I choose either canola or butter depending on the need.
Seed oil cult been real quiet the past couple days.
>>22291883I just learned that you're not supposed to store opened oil bottles for a year...
>>22295528It doesn't though. We have actual human trials. No reason to rely on theories when we have data showing replacing animal fats with seed oils decreases cancer, cvd and all cause mortality. See:>>22293184
>>22296527Anti seed oil troll is dead and admitted to being a troll in defeat. It's over. Jsid. Canola won. Seed oils took over our world and it's only going to make us healthier.
>>22296707That huge list of studies are all really really weak, and most of them admit to having weak evidence, or using ridiculous sample sizes/populations as I pointed out earlier. How helpful is a sample of 40 polynesians when making broad claims about diet? The large questionnaire studies also have some pretty huge flaws to them that seem to have gone unaddressed in this thread. Mechanistic studies at least point to real world causes that can be proven rather than just hoping people fill out a questionnaire correctly, and that the scientists account for the huge amount of different variables that should be accounted for when studying human health. One of the largest flaws in those studies is that they did not account for the quality of the oils used. Grass fed butter is objectively better than ultra cheap slop butter from corn few factory farmed cows. The other point is that there are real studies that demonstrate how bad oxidized oil is. Whether that be from poor storage conditions, cooking methods, or how it was processed. Almost all of "bad" seed oils come from ultra processed foods and re-used frying oil. Those questionnaires only asked about what people cooked with. Over time seed oils have become one of the largest calorie sources for populations and you can see how those populations have become less healthy. That one study points out how diabetes has risen 7 fold since the 50s. You don't think the massive increase in seed oil consumption has something to do with that? >>222967083/10 cope post. You can do a lot better than that.
Seed oils (especially canola) have a stronger case than butter on cardiovascular risk markers and mortality data, and a practical edge over olive oil in several measurable lipid effects, cooking versatility, cost, and accessibility. The argument rests on fatty acid composition, randomized trials on cholesterol, large observational substitution analyses, and real world use not on internet myths about “toxicity.”Butter raises LDL relative to essentially every common liquid plant oil. A 2025 analysis of over 221,000 adults followed for decades linked higher butter intake to higher total and cancer mortality. A higher intake of plant oils (including canola and soybean) was linked to lower mortality. Substituting 10 g of butter per day with plant oil was associated with 17% lower overall and cancer mortality risk. Concerns that seed oils drive inflammation via linoleic acid (omega-6) do not hold up in human trials. The anti seed oil failed troll essentially just wants more people to get unhealthy like himself. It's a common thing for deranged people to do. The mechanism for superior miracle oil canola is straightforward: lower saturated fat intake reduces hepatic production of LDL particles. Among many seed oils, the miracle oil canola delivers superior or comparable cholesterol lowering effects in controlled trials, useful omega-3 content, better high-heat handling and a plethora of other tangible benefits including cost. Healthiness for all through modern canola superiority and technological advancement.
>>22296718>That huge list of studies are all really really weakExplain>or using ridiculous sample sizes/populations as I pointed out earlier. How helpful is a sample of 40 polynesiansOr you could look at the others which have over 100,000 participants instead of cherry picking. It's the overall body of evidence as a whole.>The large questionnaire studies also have some pretty huge flaws to them that seem to have gone unaddressed in this thread.Provide these flaws with evidence. Studies have been done constantly showing they are reliable. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23206381/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26753989/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18435934/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28744912/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26653304/https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30121379/>Mechanistic studies at least point to real world causesThey can, but most often they do not. You know how many in-vitro studies have shown random stuff to completely kill cancer or only there to be zero effects when given to humans? The human body is incredibly complex and often our theories are wrong. >Grass fed butter is objectively better than ultra cheap slop butter Still high in saturated fat, which these studies control for>Those questionnaires only asked about what people cooked withThis is completely false. The most common one used and the one that was used in most of the studies I posted was the National Cancer Institute Diet History Questionnaire. Which does include processed foods. https://epi.grants.cancer.gov/dhq3/dhq3-past-month-with-serving-sizes-questionnaire.pdf>You don't think the massive increase in seed oil consumption has something to do with that?I think hyper palatable foods rich in fat and salt caused that. I don't think seed oils have anything uniquely bad about them. If we never invented seed oils and instead created all of our hyper palatable foods with butter and animal fats I think we would see the same obesity if not worse.
Anti seed oil troll status?
>>22296738Im not going through 30 studies and pointing out how they are not even relevant to the discussion in this thread. I already did that with 10 of them. The evidence points to what specifically? That oxidized seed oils are still healthy? You can just as easily say that because of the complexity of human health population studies are just as unreliable as mechanistic studies. Oxidized oil byproducts have an effect on the whole body, and you can look up specific compounds and see studies on them specifically. Studies on free radicals, studies on aldehydes, etc. That is more reliable than a flawed questionnaire that doesn't account for all variables like I have specifically pointed out. They just used an arguably arbitrary number for serving size. It's totally unrealistic.>higher quality fatsReally stupid to dismiss this because, just like cold pressed seed oils, they are more than just the fat. That's why cold pressed, aka higher quality oils, are better than highly refined seed oils. My only claim is that highly refined seed oils easily oxidize and that the oxidation byproducts are unhealthy in many different ways. Maybe they don't kill you, but they have been show to cause cancer, brain damage, gut damage, cellular inflammation, etc. Real published studies show this. >this questionnaire said more people died who ate butter and it was worse for your heartFirstly that is not my claim, and secondly just because something is allegedly heart healthy does not make it unhealthy for other organs.
>>22296744The adults are talking, kid. Stop projecting for a second.
>>22296765Btfo'ed hard day after day after day lol loser. >he still can't refute my posts Hahahaha!
>>22296768>said it againIt's like I have complete control over your posts. Hah
>>22296771>he still can't refuteCompletely a outed troll and retard anti seed oil fag. It's over for you buddy. ;) No damage control can ever fix you now. Trip up please this is too good XD
>>22296775>really angry replySay it again!
>>22296775>Replied to a bait post in 6 minutes >calls others obsessedKeklmao
>still can't refute any of my posts >he knows he lostHow does one lose so much? Anti seed oil poster btfo'd repeatedly lol!