[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/co/ - Comics & Cartoons


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: GDMFSOAB.jpg (643 KB, 4396x2744)
643 KB JPG
Why don't we do a /co/'s top 100 comics list every year? Not of the year, but what /co/ thinks are the best comics of all time, updated annually.
Is it not possible anymore? Are we too far gone?
>>
>>155664483
>Is it not possible anymore? Are we too far gone?
Yes to both
But also because not a lot of anons read like they used to so the pool of comics will be small
>>
File: 1785077731416656.jpg (109 KB, 475x609)
109 KB JPG
>>155664483
We don't read comics son
>>
>>155664483
God mother son damn fucking of a bitch?
>>
I think you will find that avid comic readers are a minority on this board.
>>
>>155664564
Unfortunately, yes
>>
>>155664483
1. Cerebus
2. Sin City
3. Detective Comics #469-476
4. We3
5. The Far Side Gallery 2
6. Sandman
7. Amazing Fantasy #15, Amazing Spider-Man vol 1 #1-38
8. Hip Hop Family Tree
9. Clyde Fans
10. Captain Marvel Adventures
11. Spider-Man (1990) #1-16
12. Ghost World
13. Simpsons Comics
14. Fantastic Four vol 1 #1-102, Annual #1-6
15. Watchmen
16. Stardust the Super Wizard
17. Shock Suspenstories
18. Warrior (1996) #1-4
19. Tintin
20. Youngblood (1992) #1-5
21. Naruto
22. Captain Victory (1981)
23. Calvin and Hobbes
24. Heathcliff
25. Star Brand (1986) #1-7
>>
>>155664657
26. Prince Valiant
27. The War That Time Forgot
28. Liberty Meadows
29. La Prensa's Spider-Man comics
30. King City
31. Planet Terry
32. Planetary
33. Scout
34. Jon Sable, Freelance
35. All Star Superman
36. Tales From the Crypt (1950)
37. Little Annie Fanny
38. Neutro
39. Sojourn
40. My Hero Academia
41. Phoenix: Endsong
42. Martha Washington
43. Big Guy and Rusty the Boy Robot
44. Hellboy
45. Corto Maltese
46. Street Angel
47. Druuna
48. Boof
49. Deathmate
50. Richie Rich
>>
>>155664657
No manga, son.
It's great, but it's unrelated.
>>
>>155664668
51. Gene Colan era of Daredevil
52. Spumco Comic Book
53. The Sons of El Topo
54. Kirby Manga Mania
55. GI Joe: A Real American Hero
56. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (Mirage)
57. Warlock by Jim Starlin
58. Copra
59. Little Lulu
60. Amazing-Man Comics
61. Iron Man #1-332
62. Donald Duck: A Christmas For Shacktown
63. Casper: The Friendly Ghost (1958) #1-260
64. Captain America (1996) #1-13
65. Adolescent Radioactive Black-Belt Hamsters
66. Stan Lee/Jack Kirby Thor
67. Roy Thomas/Neal Adams X-Men
68. Futurama Comics
69. Blacksad
70. Chainsaw Man
71. Justice League International
72. Kamandi (1972) #1-40
73. Spider-Man: Life Story
74. Daredevil: Born Again
75. Sonic the Hedgehog
>>
>>155664678
76. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (Archie)
77. Savage Dragon
78. Shade the Changing Man (1990)
79. Lone Wolf and Cub
80. Cyberforce
81. Batman Incorporated by Grant Morrison
82. Metabarons
83. Ro-Busters
84. Nick Fury, Agent of SHIELD by Steranko
85. Punisher MAX by Ennis
86. Snot Girl
87. Chamber of Chills (1951)
88. 1963
89. Tarzan by Burne Hogarth
90. Peanuts
91. Love and Rockets
92. Azumanga Daioh
93. Minus
94. Stray Toasters
95. Crime Does Not Pay
96. Gantz
97. Domu: A Child's Dream
98. Legion of Super-Heroes by Jim Shooter and Mike Grell
99. Biden's Titans vs Trump's Titans
100. Greb Comics
>>
>>155664692
Needs work.
>>
uncanny xmen omni 1-5 mutant masscre to apocalypse

conan 1 - 8 omnibus'
>>
>>155664483
The issue with making a top is that you get tourist like this >>155664657
>>
>>155664483
To even think about making a top 100 list, you'd have to have read 200 comics minimum.
>>
>>155664483
The American comic industry is way too small for that. We could do top 10, possibly.

That's one of the reasons when people talk about "splitting comics and cartoons into separate boards" it's always stupid, because the cartoon board would just be slower and the comic board would be basically dead. God help you if the mediums ever cross over.
>>
>>155664483
If someone wanted to organize it then it could happen but it would be extremely tricky. Just figuring out how to delineate superhero runs would make my head spin. Honestly a lot of nonsuperhero comics have the same problem. Then arguments about what should count in the first place as if a meaningful list could exclude the output of any country or different style of comic. I'd say it would be worth trying to do top 100 single issues but I bet that would end up being annoying as well.
>>
>>155665510
A dead board is perfect for comics. Reading shit takes time.
>>
>>155665533
No board has ever benefited from being slower
>>
>>155666028
Comics would.
>>
>>155666028
At how many spam threads and low effort threads /co/ has, slower might be a bit better compared to the damn light speed that new threads pop on here.
But I'm not making the argument to split comics and cartoons/animation, since I too, think there's just so little to draw from.
>>
>>155665533
>Listen to an audiobook version
>Nullify the one "benefit" of a dead board.
>>
>>155664692
No vampire Knight? Weak list.
>>
>>155667452
>Listen to an audiobook version
That's for fags and women. They tend to ruin boards regardless.
>>
>>155667475
It's shit. Sonic the Hedgehog and Heathcliff are better.
>>
>>155665470
Tourists wouldn't have read or heard of 90% of the comics of that list, and that's being charitable
>>
>>155664483
It would require people to actually read comics instead of bitching about them
>>
>>155664483
It would just be the regular top 100 except with more retarded choices like more Bendis. /co/ loves Bendis.
>>
>>155668436
Hell, I don't even think the vast majority of /co/ has ever read at least 1/4th of that list
>>
>>155664657
>21. Naruto
Are comics so bad that a shitty manga that wouldn't make top 200 almost makes top 20 in comics?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.