I always hated seeing "character X effortlessly beats Y with total anti-climax", as if they were just swatting a fly>but it makes internal sensedont care, its boring and is too easily abused to set up the worf effecteven with a total mismatch of power, the weaker party should at least get one good hit in before being curbstomped
>>156281982Since you have a name for it, could you name 10 /co/ examples?
>>156282777>name 10 examples memeI will not engage with anything that isnt a discussion of the concept outlined rather than engagement baitingasking for more examples does not actually engage with the core argument that simply destroying another character is inherently uninteresting, regardless of how widespread or not it isbut, solely as a courtesy, any encounter with the hulk that ends with him simply one-shotting his enemieshow logical it is is irrelevanthulk spending 10 panels to defeat wolverine when powerscaling says he should just grab him and throw him into the next state was objectively the better narrative choice
>>156282777Not OP, but you're a faggot. It's common as fuck. Reminds me of Galactus 1-shitting Ultron in the original Secret Wars comic.
>>156282822>Reminds me of Galactus 1-shitting Ultron in the original Secret Wars comic.that is literally OP
>>156282777>Since you have a name for it,its actually called no-selling in wrestling lingo, and its seen as a cheap ploy to sell new talentnot that it has totally stopped the practice but if even wrestling is at least self-aware that it is just bad storytelling
>>156281982It's realistic. If you fought Olivier Richters he would knock your ass out with one smack to the face. Sorry.
>>156282871>It's realisticirrelevant, especially in a story that is unrealistic by nature
>>156281982Nah, it's fine. Like if someone tries fighting a cosmic force you wouldn't expect them to stand a chance. Galactus should be above powerscaling entirely.It sucks more when characters like him are reduced to being jobbers because writers have no fucking clue what to do with them.
>>156282942i can understand losing without any chance of victory, but simply stepping on them in one panel is boringeven if its daredevil vs galactus, at least have daredevil do something noteworthy like survive long enough to touch galactus's foot before being teleported to the moon for daring to do that
>>156281982nah characters like Ultron need a good humbling now and then
Is this the thread?
>>156282808"simply destroying another character is inherently uninteresting" is a retarded claim. I do not believe there is any narrative element that is inherently bad or good and that it all depends on context and skill of the writer.One-shotting an enemy effortlessly can be done well given the right setup and intent. Most obviously it works well as a joke or comic relief aspect. Looney Tunes does this a number of times and for a more serious subject matter, Hercule VS Cell works too.It can also be used to effectively communicate a sudden change to the character, often the recovery from a previous ailment or other problem that caused them to become substantially weaker. If Batman was temporarily blinded for an issue and had been struggling to fight the mook of the month, having the rematch when his sight has been restored be a one-sided stomp where the villain doesn't get a single hit in is a satisfying catharsis.Finally it can be used to show a dramatic improvement from a previous version/status quo of a character. This is the closest to what you have referred to as "the Worf effect" in that it demonstrates how much stronger or threatening the new character is relative to their old form, but Electro or Rhino getting some new suit/powerup and then no-selling Daredevil or Spider-Man CAN be done well to make readers take the threat seriously. That doesn't mean it is always done well and is often a cheap or lazy way to try and make a pet character 'serious' but your premise is set up in an absolutist way that I strongly disagree with.
>>156283609>but your premise is set up in an absolutist way that I strongly disagree with.take the absolutist pill and see the truth
>>156283683Okay."No-selling is always bad"is an objectively and 100% incorrect premise and only objective 100% faggot retards think otherwise.
>>156283714to say that it can be good implies that no-selling is objectively good, which is not trueand it cannot be sometimes good or sometimes bad, because that would imply it lacks objective value in itself
janny...
>>156282859Except comics aren't wrestling where all parties are roughly human level Comics are comics and have extremely large and defined gaps in power where sometimes a street level retard steps into a ballpark he has no place in being.Someone like ultron absolutely should not get "a good hit in" on someone like galactus because to do so undermine's Galactus' narrative presence. He is so far above some fucker like Doc Ock that he may as well be a god; to imply that octavius should give him a good one-two before losing is farcical. If otto ends up in a story alongside galactus then Galactus is above him in every possible way; if you don't want that outcome then don't put them together and remove that story from existing.
>no death nor battleThis is not the thread
>>156281982>>156282808It's better to do it this way because western artists absolutely suck at drawn out fights. It's still boring, but now it's boring for more pages.
>>156284426Infinitely layered stealth hax too strong
>>156284214I'm inclined to agree, but I'd say it depends on the nature of the story and characters (I'm the anon who gave the Ultron/Galactus example). I think Galactus should be one-shotting (or better yet, ignoring figures) due to his nature, setting, and function; he's the world eater; individual figures, regardless of their "power" should not be capable of going toe-to-toe with him because of his very nature as a cosmic "being/function". He should be faced more indirectly (such as the Ultimate Nullifier), or by other cosmic beings that are above physical concepts like him ("he's not actually a guy in purple"); it's not his "function" to brawl. That said, with rare exception, characters like Galactus and Ock shouldn't be in the same sentence (though I quite like Secret Wars usage of characters and their power levels; X-Men/Spider-Man fight excepted). However, I wouldn't say that about his heralds, despite their "power". My go-to example for fucking off scaling is the fight between Firelord and Spider-Man. "Power-Scaling" wise, he should one-tap Peter, but the heralds are more "human", they are meant to function as characters, though incredibly powerful. Relying on that reputation to give one of the longest and most awesome character-testing brawls, even if it "makes no sense", is 110% worth it for a character that is rarely used, and power isn't his primary function (though it is one of them).Power levels should be considered in the context of a character's function above all else. Power is secondary.
>>156284426>the HALLS
>>156285089The HALLS are the vehicle and the landfill is /co/ btw
>>156284426as they should be
ROBINTOS
>>156282777In theory, it should be possible using only Galactus.
>>156285058>However, I wouldn't say that about his heralds, despite their "power".Well yeah, not only is the gulf in power far, far narrower than between him and galactus but also it serves narrative purpose on both sides. The heralds are the fallible humanity of galactus that still pokes out, they're arrogant in their might where the Hunger stamps out that emotion. Meanwhile spider-man is a hotheaded loudmouth who will always jump into a fight no matter what, and has such conviction in benevolence that he refuses to quit. He should get some blows in while he's at his peak not just because you can swing it between how their powers interact but because well written peter won't quit while billions of of lives are on the line and most heralds are deserving of being humbled by the 'insects' they thought to step on.
>>156282822Pretty good bait
>>156286704there's gotta be more examples of characters actually inconveniencing Galactus or standing up to his attacks than there are instances of him unceremoniously swatting motherfuckers at this point
>>156282777I cant
>>156284370Fuck you.
>>156281982Stupid.
>>156287741The thing knocked him off balance in their very first appearanceIt didn't do lasting harm and galactus didnt even hit the ground because he demonstrated floating capability but it at least shows that the thing is actually quite strong, just not strong enough to stop galactusMore interesting than if the thing simply bounced off of galactus
>>156283536sybau
>>156282839Shit like this just dilutes the narrative. If you make a character a joke then he will be a joke and I will not take him seriously as a reader.
>>156285101The vehicle is the janny
>>156295460>If you make a character a joke then he will be a joke and I will not take him seriously as a reader.a character can just play revolving door as a joke, be as serious or as unserious as the plot demands
>>156295476Nah. Once you punk him a few times then he's just a joke and he can't be taken seriously.
>>156286352SuperBITCH
>>156281982Yeah, it is pretty disrespectful. It's okay for villains to get swatted though.
>>156283683I HATE Mr. A!!
>>156296802That's entirely your problem for not understanding frames of reference.
>>156284214>Except comics aren't wrestlingYou don't understand comics *or* wrestling.
>>156298131It's your problem for eating shit.
>that time Galactus squidwarded Hercules.