Was it over hated?
If anything it isn't hated enough
>>156301227What's your reasons? I mostly hear the sidelining of Eli and Tommy, although for me it just wasn't a fun read.
Hate for what?
>>156301227Why?
>>156301227It's a truly terrible comic and way worse than the original run. The worst part is with hindsight and actually having re-read it recently, the original Heinberg stuff isn't that good either and yet this is worse than that.
>>156301199>>156301768Comics looks so boring and ugly now.
>>156301199it wasn't, it was everything that came after.
>My whore is exactly what you are
>>156301309Besides forcing America Chavez onto people, Gillen explicitly loaded up the team with gays/turned everyone straight gay and explicitly stated he intended it to be 100% Faggot for faggots whereas Heinberg kept the faggotrty limited to Billy and Hulking and let the rest of the cast, but especially Kate Bishop, be straight as fuck
>>156306546>nowThis was 2014>>156308033My god someone remembers my edit
Heinberg's run was a super hero story that wove the anxieties of adolescence very nicely into the plot. Gillen's story, meanwhile, was more about how this is a cool comic for cool people and we're glib and fun and ebin, and it felt like it was more a fourty-year-old something trying to capture his idea of youth first and do a super hero story second.I don't mind if he wants to load the entire comic with characters that stray from the norm (mostly sexually in this case). But the comic's own smug aura and its lack of focus on what made Heinberg's run great is really not what I'm looking for in an Young Avengers comic.Probably the worst part is that all of the subsequent short lived attempts to do more with the team all drew on Gillen's run, but the fact they're all pretty much forgotten at this point says everything that is needed about it.
>>156308064I hadn't read America in anything else before this and actually quite liked her here. He 'shit my god is a dumbass thing' was one of the few beats that worked for me. As for the rest, I personally have no problems with everyone being gay or whatever. Messy teenagers being messy. I say this as someone who didn't really click with the comic overall.
>>156309612Rereading V1 now I find I don't care for the arcs that are just one long superhero fight. The bits in between are the ones that stayed with me over time and still work for me now.Gillen was very much trying to be cool, which I didn't like. Also I remember when it came out feeling like even though I'd been a teen when v1 came out with v2 I was Abe Simpson.
>>156309514I will never forget.I still giggle to this day
>>156310094I wish I still had it but I lost it in a great computer transfer.
>>156310164History is always preserved
>>156311508To you goes my firstborn.
>>156301199I don't get why anyone would read Yong Avengers besides wanting to fuck Kate
>>156310072When I was doing the storytime of that era of teen hero comics a few months ago, I said it then and I still believe it: v1 of Young Avengers doesn't hold up at all. I think people went into it with low expectations because the name and characters seemed lame and it was a TV guy but it turned out to be reasonably competent and the twist with Iron Lad was cool.But you read it and that Kang story should have been something seeded and built up to over the first year or so of the book instead of being truncated into the first arc because it leads to the characters all acting weird. Everyone acts like they're true companions, Cassie and Iron Land act like they've been in love forever and their parting is such a tragedy, Kate and Patriot are acting like a long time couple and Kate's a fully confident hero... but then you realize the entire story takes place over a few hours after they've only just met Kate and Cassie and it becomes ridiculous.Then after that is the story about Patriot taking MGH which is just a lame and ultimately forgettable story that I remember even people at the time feeling like it was a letdown. The special with their origins is forgettable outside of Kate being raped which I remember people back then rolling their eyes at. I guess unsurprisingly the Hulkling story to finish off that volume is the best one but again it feels like it's trying to be a big earth changing event done in a few issues when it should have been a logner term story.Children's Crusade is just outright bad. Gillen's run is both boring and annoying and I can barely remember what the story is beyond something to do with Wiccan and some cosmic monster. Basically, I feel like Young Avengers as a brand/concept has been coasting for 20 years on a reputation earned entirely from the twist of its opening arc and that it's never actually been all that good.
>>156311909Also the best thing ever written with the Young Avengers name was the Dark Reign mini.
>>156311508Hadn't seen this before, amazing.
>>156311909You're right. You're 100% right and yet I love that stupid team.
>>156312725I also blame Gillen for gaying up the Academy X generation of characters. He's the one who made David gay for literally no reason and the explanation he gave would barely even qualify as a handwave. Now Mercury, Loa and Pixie have all been made into lesbians and I wouldn't be surprised if a few more from that generation have been turned gay with equally stupid non-explanation. All thanks to Gillen.
>>156309514Marvel Now! began in 2012, so not far off.
>>156312892Ah well I don't care much about that one. Make everyone gay IDGAF.
>>156308064For someone that allegedly likes pussy, Gillen is incredibly obsessed with faggots. The utter state of bisexual "men".
young avengers always looked really gay so I never bothered with it
>>156312946All the Brit writers from that time period are obsessed with blacks and gays. Cornell is maybe the exception and he's the one who seems to have largely left comics.
>>156312892They squeezed in Indra and Specter from the Corsairs during Krakoa Elixir is part of the Five and people joked that they were like a polyamorous pod, but I don't think they confirmed if any of them were actually banging
>>156313750I think they should make every character gay.
>>156313750It absolutely sucks how badly my favorite generation of X-Men characters have been utterly ruined over the last 20 years.
>>156311909I think it's important to take into account the era in which Young Avengers v1 was released. In mid-2000s Marvel amongst all the edginess and misery and suffering we got a likeable teen hero team that was more upbeat and positive than most of what Marvel was doing at the time. It's not perfect in that regard, there's still the Patriot on PEDs story and Kate's rape backstory, but I can forgive them for speedrunning some of the plots considering it was written by a TV guy who probably wasn't going to be around for the long term.Gillen's run is just boring, obnoxiously smug, obnoxiously "everyone is gay now" and obnoxiously "Hello, fellow teenagers" from a middle-aged writer. And like others have said, that garbage has defined how these characters are written ever since.>>156311936It wasn't as bad as Gillen but I didn't care for that mini either.
>>156314127>It wasn't as bad as Gillen but I didn't care for that mini either.I enjoyed it as a commentary on how the genre had been going in that decade and "dark" superhero comics. Also Sylvie and Coat of Arms were pretty enjoyable characters.Also, the Academy X book was generally not depressing and did perfectly fine in sales and they completely destroyed it to make it a miserable book to match how Teen Titans had been since its relaunch all for maybe an extra 4000 per issue. The post-HoM run is a big reason those characters are so ruined. I'd also argue that Runaways, while it cold get dark, wasn't an edgy or miserable series either. In that respect there wasn't really much that tonally set Young Avengers apart from the other teen books Marvel had been producing. Fuck, even something like NYX was ultimately a fairly positive book by the end.What it did have was the art which I think was the real selling point. Jim Cheung's art looked nice and and Justin Ponsor was probably the best colorist of the era so it was a real nice looking book which elevated what was an otherwise humdrum story and a writing style that often felt like it was badly aping Bendis.
>>156314266I liked Sylvie a lot and Lisa got character development and seemed to be going in a good direction but otherwise I just didn't care for the Dark YA. Alas.
>>156314315I said it in one of those storytime threads when I did that series but Coat of Arms and Big Zero should have been part of Kamala's rogues gallery. Coat, being the superhero/supervillain fangirl and pretentious artist seems like such a natural foil to Kamala the superhero fanfic writing fangirl that I'm surprised it's never happened.
>>156314315I don't think there's much depth to Big Zero or Egghead as charactersBut they have fun designs and could make for decent crowd filler And their powers are straight forward so they make for good fight scenesIt's Executioner who has basically nothing going for him. He's like a lame Punisher cloneIf you want to fix him you'd have to completely redesign him from the ground up, frankly its just not worth the effort
>>156314127>I think it's important to take into account the era in which Young Avengers v1 was released.This will likely go over like lead but I'd say that's also true for Billy/Teddy. A lot of people in this thread are mad about too much gay but at the time there was far, far less and it was kind of a big deal. Hell wasn't it the same year Marvel had that Freedom Ring PR disaster?>>156314357Oh shit yeah they would work great for her.
>>156314450>He's like a lame Punisher cloneI think that's the point. He idolized the Punisher and then went full Punisher because Kate turned him down and he thought it would make him seem cool. He's supposed to be a giant loser.
>>156314604I get that but it's just an extremely limited character.There's not much you can do with someone like that, and not a lot of appeal in using him in future stories unless all you want to do is make fun of straight white incels