Jason is the best ex-Robin.
>>156301201He doesn't have much competition
>>156301201So good he hasn't had any good stories post-resurrection.No, I'm not gonna pretend Under the Red Hood was good just because of the melodrama, it's a good concept at best.
Tim refuses to admit he's an EX-robin, dick is an abused wife who abandons his former family with the titans to drag himself home and be beaten once again by by bruce. Whats left, stephanie who only sticks around gotham because she is too dumb to actually consider that she has no positive connections to the city and that the only stable eras of her life were every time she established herself somewhere else?
>>156301201Does anyone deny it? Dick has gotten chance after chance and it never amounts to anything in the end because he's incredibly mid. Meanwhile, Jason has never gotten a fair shot because everyone from Judd Winick onward is too stupid to realize that Jason flops whenever he's not around Bruce and Gotham, and they try to make him into a mid-2000s bad boy that only losers who watch Hazbeen would find cool. >>156302254>No, I'm not gonna pretend Under the Red Hood was good just because of the melodrama; it's a good concept at best.UTRH is the blueprint for how to ruin a character. All of Jason's modern woes begin here.
>>156302372Dick may be mid at times, but I'd argue he's had a better track record than Jason, whether he's Robin, Nightwing, or Batman.
Where are tim stocks right now?
>>156302927they actually hit 0 and they canceled the stock
>>156302884>but I'd argue he's had a better track record than Jason, whether he's Robin, Nightwing, or Batman.I'd honestly say that Jason has had a more interesting time as Robin, especially since the narrative has shifted and he's been vindicated by time whereas everyone can agree that Bruce has failed him.Meanwhile, Dick is constantly being retrofitted as Robin all the time, and comes off as ingenuine because we actually know what he was like as Robin.
>>156303092It's over...
>>156304148No? Even right now we're still getting Robin Dick stories that shows how much actual trouble he gave Batman, you're talking about mostly a fandom thing.
>>156304148>because we actually know what he was like as Robin.Almost no one knows what he was actually like as robin. 80% of his runs can best be described as 'what if pre-crisis Jason Todd were actually a personality void who simply repeated plot points' and the other 20% are 'what if Robin were a psychopath who derived pleasure from delivering undue amounts of pain and torture to simple criminals (crazy quilt etc)'
>>156302254UtRH alone is still better than anything Dick and Tim have gotten.
>>156304419Ehh, more recognizable than Dick has had sure, but definitely not better than Tim's stuff. Despite what Dickfags and DC want you to think, Tim is the only Robin with a good solo run.
>>156304379I mean, that kinda proves my point, that they're just retroactively smoothing Dick as a character.
>>156304559You can't say that when we're still getting Robin Dick stories that show the opposite.
>>156304419Bender/Jake/Marcus Fenix as Joker rocked, worth it
>>156304657But instead of actually getting formulaic Silver Age Dick Grayson stories, we're getting something that makes him out to be this happy, bombastic, cheery little guy with a chip on his shoulder. Sounds familiar (Jason Todd).
>>156304706You say that as if Jason didn't copy that from Dick in the first place, why pretend like Dick has never been like that?
>>156304739The difference is that post-Crisis Jason was built with an edge to his character, whereas Dick wasn't that type of guy ever.
>>156304739See, the thing is Jason copied that from tv batman, not from comic dick.
If you cut out the obvious Dick Grayson copy-and-paste origin story, Pre-Crisis Jason felt more like an actual child than Dick did as Robin. I really have never been sold on child heroes until Jason and PAD's Young Justice. Most child heroes are just little adults.
>>156301201Let's not pretend most Jason's revived history is people complaining about how shit he is and that he should've stayed dead.
>>156304963Yeah, but those people are mouthbreathing retards who probably think Cass and NML were the shit.
>>156305004As opposed to Jasonfags, who have impeccable taste.
>>156305120Jason over Cass any day of the week sis.
>>156304473Tim had quantity over quality. Most of his stories are completely forgettable and have zero lasting impact on his character.
>>156305291Dick wishes he had anything as good as Tim did back in the day.
>>156305370They literally had the same writer back then, though.
>>156305719Yeah, but Dick got Denny and Chuck long after they peaked in the early 90s.
>>156301201He's better than Tim, I'll give him that.
>>156305146They should have a team-up.
Is there a reason a decade-old comic suddenly got two reprints with exclusive variants?
>>156306893So they can sell it again.
>>156306965Why don¿t just milk the current book Jason is starring in, then?
>>156307018Old comics have nostalgia and historical value that they can exploit.
>>156307018red skies, based final crisis dc artists.
>>156301201Well, we can at least all agree that Damian is the worst Robin.
>>156308463NeverDamian best boy league of shadows best ninja group
>>156308463Timfag....
>>156308517>>156308603You can disagree all you want, but Damian being the worst is a FACT. He is legit a terrible character.
>>156301201He's like, 2nd or 3rd best.I'm just glad he's getting the helmet back.
>>156309914Nuh uh he’s the best
>>156310260Nope.
>>156309914I can't believe it took this long for him to get the helmet back
>>156305004>>156305146Why do I see so much beef between Jason fans and Cass fans? "Former Robin" and "Sometimes Batgirl" don't have a lot of overlap, and neither does "ex-child assassin who believes in the idea of Batman (especially the no-kill rule)" and "ex-sidekick who has become disillusioned with the idea of batman (especially the no-OK, I see it now that I'm typing it out. I still like both though.
>>156308463Yes. Damian did so much harm to the comics, and it was made worse because they had good writers to give him a fandom.
>>156308629I'll agree that his premise is obnoxious. Making him Bruce's biological child in order to make him more important than the others is lame, and the way Tim was kicked to the curb to make way for this new OC rubs me the wrong way to this day. However, most Damien appearances outside of his introductory arc (and that Teen Titans series where he builds supervillain gitmo) are enjoyable.
>>156301201The helmet looks fucking retarded and it's absurd that people are nostalgic for it. Might as well demand the green panties back.
>>156312811The helmet is kino and you're a faggot.
>>156305370And now, nobody remember him except for being the faggot batkid.
>>156312685My problem with him is the opposite of yours. I don't care about him kicking Tim out and Batman having a biological son was always going to happen eventually anyway. The problem is that his comics are so obnoxious with how much they glaze him up that if you don't already like Damian, his comics would absolutely not change your mind about him. It might be the reason why his solo books without Batman can't even last beyond 2 or 3 volumes.
>>156312685Tim had become so utterly unlikable and toxic and petty by the time that Damian came along, that people were willing to overlook Danian's flaws because he repeatedly beat the shit out of Tim and gave Tim his karmatic punishment by stripping him of the Robin identity It can't be overstated how much of a piece of shit Tim was in the early to mid 00s and how Damian became universally beloved because, from day one, saw what a piece of shit Tim was and put the faggot in his place and ended Tim's reign of terror as Robin
>>156313518See >>156313727DC already ruined Tim by turning him into an asshole and Damian gets treated like a golden gid by a chunk of fandom because he was the only one to stand up to Tom and give him a beating that was years overdue>>156313727
>>156313727>Damian >universally belovedLmao, what? He absolutely wasn't. He was super hated for the longest time and even now, no one can claim that he is "universally beloved". >inb4 timfanKek.
Jaybin is the only character that managed to make Batman or Robin interesting to me. I can't say the same about Red Hood.>>156313518> comics so obnoxious you start hating the character If this was a sport, Batfam would win the golden medal.
Superior Red Hood design
>>156301201Helmet needs a nose and mouth
>>156314714I'll say it needs at least some holes or grille around it.
>>156314691I think it's cool on a vacuum, but it doesn't fit Jason, specially with how he was introduced as being relatively against the whole villain theatricality.Also the logo is just too Punisher-like.I do like the red guns tho, they should bring those back.>>156314714No, it shouldn't have that many features, looks stupid.>>156314830That could... maybe work.
>>156312887>the gay Robin has better stories than the original RobinThe absolute state of Dickfags
>>156313727>>156313767>Tim had become so utterly unlikable and toxic and petty by the time that Damian came along, that people were willing to overlook Danian's flaws because he repeatedly beat the shit out of Tim and gave Tim his karmatic punishment by stripping him of the Robin identityThat's not even close to be correct, lmao. I don't think you realize this, but Batman's readers are known for being massive brainlets who blindly follow what is said in the comics. If the story paints Batman as being correct despite clearly not, the readers will come to his defence like good little bots. People were always going to bat for Damian whether he was right or not because he's Bruce's biological son. Despite what people want to think, blood comes before an orphan outsider, and the editorial knows this too, which is why they leaned so much on the blood-son angle. In short, you're a fucking idiot.
>>156301201Is Jason good in the new Teen Titans book?
>>156315933No, because they're trying to take him back to his Red Hood roots, which weren't that good to begin with.
>>156316231Still better than Jaybin
>>156316402You mean Jason's actual peak?
>>156315933Its three issues in and they havent fucked up any of the characters yet, so here's hoping. I'm still waiting until the resolution of the first art before i recommend it.
>>156316434You mean precrisis, or the six-ish issues between his revised origin and the Starlin run? Because most of the comics with postcrisis jaybin in them are him staring at batman in confusion while batman kills people and post-hoc justifies it to himself.
>>156316434Peak my ass. He’s just another generic good boy.
>>156316614Post-Crisis. Nobody but boomers like Mark Waid and Superfags remember pre-Crisis.
>>156316650Sucks because precrisis jason is the only time robin was good.
Protecting pimps and drug dealers is Jason's peak, according to fans of the character (they've only watched UTRH).
>>156315177>People were always going to bat for Damian whether he was right or not because he's Bruce's biological sonAre you people new or something? Damian was super hated and it took a long time for people to warm up to him and many of the casual fans still hate his gut after being exposed to him in his animated movies and injustice. Don't get tricked by his fangirls on Twitter because he is the least popular among the Robins.
>>156316727not even timfags like tim, they like the idea of what they thought tim represented back during the clinton administration
>>156316764Tim definitely get ruined, but some of you seem to forget that Damian can't even carry his own series either. The last Batman and Robin series only existed because of the announcement of the Brave and the Bold and it wasn't selling well.
>>156316690>says he protects pimps and drug dealers>posts a page showing him killing pimps and drug dealersSure, Jaybinfag.
How can we measure whether a character is popular or not? Social media engagement? Sales? Relevance?
>>156316912>>says he protects pimps and drug dealersHey dumbass, did you miss the part where it literally says he's still taking cuts from them and that he's wiping out his competition?
>>156316727>Are you people new or something? Damian was super hated and it took a long time for people to warm up to him and many of the casual fans still hate his gut after being exposed to him in his animated movies and injustice.Those people are literally outnumbered by the casuals and the defenders. Doesn't help that Damian was literally tied to Dickbats, meaning shitting on him also means drawing the ire of Dickfags who defend that run with their life.
>>15636950>How can we measure whether a character is popular or notGood question and it's hard to say to be honest. The problem with social media is that it filled with bots and we don't really have accurate information about sales. Though, I think it's safe to say Dick and Jason are the most popular by far and Tim and Damian are getting benefited by association. Still, DC isn't really treating them like a big deal so it makes you wonder.
>>156316975Doesn’t change the fact that he’s still killing pimps and drug dealers.
>>156317221While taking money from drug dealers and pimps. He's literally letting it happen while taking a cut. Jaybin would have murdered this fakeass OC wearing his nametag.
>>156316992I think you're confused by what casual means. Being casual means that you have a casual interactions with the fandom and not really involved like fans are. You are interested enough to comment on them and search for them in YouTube, but don't care enough to read their comics or be involved in the fandom. Damian didn't at all win casual viewers who saw the animated movies and played injustice compared to Jason who win many of them by watching UTRH. It's true that Dick fans were the biggest Damian's fans back then and the one who pushed for him until he started to have his own fans which is why you never see a Damian fan who hate Dick.
>>156317260>Jaybin would have murdered this fakeass OC wearing his nametagSo, how this makes him better than Red Hood?
>>156316764Tim was actually really popular to the point that his popularity even surpassed Dick's and his comic was a best seller. Damian saw a boost in popularity after Super Sons and WFA which only translated into increase in fanarts than actual sales since his comics didn't do well.
>>156317303Because he took out a dangerous individual who endangered Gotham City and profited from the suffering of others?
>>156317260He takes their cut and uses it to buy the bullets that put them in the ground.
>>156301201--said no one ever.
>>156317151>The problem with social media is that it filled with botsI have noticed that every Comics place besides Twitter is pretty much dead. This place, CBR forums and reddits are all dead which makes me wonder how much of the engagement in Twitter is real.
>>156316665Pre-crisis jaybin is the best if you like your Robin campy. Post-crisis Jaybin is the best if you like your Robin psychological and tragic in a munbane way. >>156317260> he takes money from them therefor he protects themRH extorts all the criminals he kills because he can. He protects nothing, fights for no one, and doesn't plan to build anything (his last dialogue with Black Mask spells it out). RH is an arsonist who hates Gotham. Plain and simple. I agree that Winick ignored everything about Jaybin or his relationship with Bruce to write about his crazy OC obsessed with Batman.
>>156301201Reminder before her fags invade this thread like they're going to so this is a warning: Bettefags get the rope. Bettefags are not protected by the USA constitution. She should've been killed by the hook man and had her body burned and the ashes pissed all over while Kate refused to care because she's that irrelevant. She's worse than Jason, and that's saying something. Some characters aren't meant to have good stories or be great characters. Stephfags should learn that too.I look forward to Sophie Campbell using the name Flamebird on someone else in her comic so I can laugh at your salty, pathetic tears.
>>156313727>t. what Stephanie Brown apologists believe
>>156301201No. Only edgelords like Jason. They have "im not like other girls tee hee" syndrome where they just MUST be against anything mainline or mainstream
>>156320134I like jason because he is the only batfamily allowed to lose
>>156318849OP just said it.
>>156317385>his comic was a best sellerNo, it wasn't. People just buying the book for being a batbook, the same way Catwoman lasted for so long in the 90's.There are not a single memorable story of the Robin vol 3, but you could say the same about Nightwing and basically most of the trash that Dixon was putting out on those books.
>>156321477The Bat name didn't have the power to carry until the dark knight trilogy. Using this excuse when he was selling better than Nightwing is quite funny.
>>156321477>There are not a single memorable story of the Robin vol 3theres the time lady shiva jobbed to a smart kid with 3 years of combat training
>>156316950A healthy mixture of all three.
>>156301201Could have been cool, but Batman comics fell apart by the 00s.
>>156323647
>>156301201They created a character who has the purpose of questioning the milk cow of the company and favorite pet of the winters. No wonder he gets fucked over all the time
>>156301201Jason got downgraded when he stopped being an antagonist to Batman or fucking off to Outlaws. The Batfamily cutesy shit is so boring
>>156323875
>>156324863
>>156321532>Using this excuse when he was selling better than Nightwing is quite funny.that just proves the point. go ask people in the streets, no one knows what a night-wing is. the people want batman and robin
>>156301201Literally just Slade with both eyes.
>>156326641I was thinking of Batgirl and Spoiler.
>>156302319Is Stephanie having teen pregnancy and giving birth still canon?
>>156308463I want to agree but even as a brat as he is his teen titans run still miles better than whatever trash that is new 52 Tim's teen titans run. It was so bad they made him a faggot.
>>156314714Thank God they ditched that shit. Their defense back then was that it would help convey his emotions, which is a pretty dumb argument. You can convey emotions perfectly fine with an ordinary helmet if you know what you're doing.
>>156327691I can't blame Rocafort for trying something new, the problem was that every other artist missed the memo and just drew Handsome Squidward
>>156316231>they're trying to take him back to his Red Hood rootswhich is?
>>156302254Task Force Z was good, fuck you guys.
>>156326802>Cass went back to wearing a full face mask>Jason finally got his helmet backThe ball is in your court Steph.
>>156327691I wonder if he's gonna change his whole costume, or if he's just gonna start wearing the helmet again.
>>156327962Hopefully we'll get a new costume. As good as Nicuolo is at fixing Spokes' bullshit, the costume is still fundamentally flawed.
>>156302121.
>>156328041Tactigore
>>156328041It looks excessive, and using only black and red makes it look even worse.
>>156328041This looks like Twitter artist incarnate
>>156327962It looks like he is just going to put on the helmet and call it a day. I wouldn't bet on a new design any time soon since his current costume is very recent.
>>156330322Slade’s ex-wife and Bernard?
>>156328041>the costume is still fundamentally flawed.True, too many details. His UtRH and Rebirth Outlaws costume is the best.
>>156321532The Catwoman, Robin, Nightwing, and ultimately Batgirl solo books were launched in the first place because of the mega-hit of the 1989 Batman film. Which did not even feature them.No, Tim Drake was not such a revolutionary character in 1989 that only then existing audiences suddenly demanded a Tim Drake solo. It was the other way around: Robin, any Robin, was artificially pushed by the influx of Bat-money to sell collectibles and grab a youth market.The Dark Knight trilogy marked the DC comic line's aggressive transition to "movie synergy" that resulted in most DC books floundering, and the oversaturation of Batbooks to this day. Take off your horse blinders for historical revisionism. The level of millennial manchild cope is embarrassing.>>156301201Some of the lowest lows but at least this character tends to be less forgettable than the Robins tend to be.
>>156331148Yeah, the costume only works under Nicoulo because he's streamlining it a bit, but there is only so much you can do.
>>156315933Wait or ask that again in one or two chapters. It's surprisingly decent for now, but we have yet to see where the story wants to go with that and how the writer will handle the situation when the goody-two-shoes learn about the skeletons in the closet.>>156327741Deeply flawed but interesting. Jason being a special zombie and working with C- or D-list villains is a niche I hope to see exploited again.
>>156334560You have no idea how much it bothers me they didn't include the RH/A costume there
>>156333224Mega Cute
Fatson Todd carried Jason hard these past few years.
>>156302884Of course he does. Dick Grayson is one of the best characters in comics. Let OP have this, Jason doesn't have much going for him right now. Just playing angry babysitter in a mediocre Teen Titans title.>>156304148I don't think you've actually read Dick's time as Robin or know anything about the original 28 years of comics with Robin the Boy Wonder.
>>156336702>Of course he does. Dick Grayson is one of the best characters in comicsYet he doesn't have a good run under his belt.
>>156314714too much like red skull>>156314691i dig it
Remember The Hill?That was a story that happened.
>>156337470Strike had a fat ass so I tolerated her. Don’t know why they made Jason pull a McNulty and fuck a waitress.
>>156314691>HEY DICK, I'VE TURNED MYSELF INTO A LITERAL RED PILL TO SHOW HOW REDPILLED I AM, WHAT DO YOU THINK ABOUT THAT?!>I'M RED PILL JASON!!!!!
>>156314863The Morrison/Quitely design matched the story they were looking to tell. Bruce was dead and Jason wanted to structure himself as Batman's replacement, reading marketing and branding and self-help books. It was embracing the theatricality of the Batman because he was DickBats' dark mirror. It's the most thought any creators have put into Jason since he came back. So of course it's the one the "fans" hate on the most.>>156315177No no he's on to something. I was rooting for Damian from the moment he knocked Tim off the dino. Post Dixon Tim was insufferable.
>>156338690>It's the most thought any creators have put into Jason since he came back.It’s just another attempt to turn Jason into Dick’s villain.
>>156338690> Damischizo is a brainlet who thinks 00s Batman is peak or had anthing to sayThat tracks.
>>156338690>It was embracing the theatricality of the BatmanAhh yes, Jason the theatrical one. Jason, the showboat that he is, makes the perfect foil to the secretive and severe Dick Greyson. Jason, who was robin for Brave and The Bold and Worlds Finest and other bombastic batman and robin stories, as opposed to the haunted Dick who was robin for 10 Nights of the Beast and The Cult and who throughout his run as robin kept more personal secrets from batman than he shared.
>>156339581Why Jasonstroke has child bearing hips?
>>156313727>Damian became universally belovedDamian was the most hated Robin for decades. He was carried hard by fujos when super-sons kick-started turning him into a misunderstood cinnamon roll
>>156340092such a cool Robin costume wasted on a faggot
>>156337470>>156337798literally what's the point of The Hill?
>>156301201It became less of a competition once they decided Tim likes to suck dick and get fucked up the ass.
>>156319877>Bettefags are not protected by the USA constitutionjej, checked
>>156339581Armored bodysuits are so cool. I wish I had a toy of that Nightclaw and Red X.
>>156343023Fatson is the best
>>156301201DC needs to bite the bullet and finally do a "Jason turns fat" issue.it will sell a million copies.
Anyone attend Cole's funeral?
>>156344654Fatson Todd will make some fangirls happy, and others seething about fatphobia like that one dude who tried to make that "HE NUKED BLUDHAVEN" misinfo a forced meme everywhere. And if he's in this thread: how's your Jason transitions into a Martha to troll Bruce AU going?
I still remember this.
>>156346459This event was incredibly lame since it was more of the editorial's bad takes.
https://x.com/xxupdates2000xx/status/2123216723428155759Higgins sure loves ARGsHe did this a lot in Radiant Black and No/One
>>156346459People were so mad Duke was bald lol
>>156345870God dont remind me about that. The idea of Jason Todd looking out at the red sky over gotham and saying "beautiful" is the single most out of character moment in any comic. The red sky (and catwoman) fucking killed his adoptive mother, some of pre-crisis Jason's last moments were just sitting down hugging his knees and staring out into an empty red sky in silent anguish.
>>156346459Should Jason have a son or a daughter? I think a son would be better.
>>156346811Sons, Dick works better as the dad with only daughters
>>156346521Kek, didn't even notice that>>156346811both could work, daughter is cute. But I'm iffy that Rose as the end game for Jason.
>>156346514It's cool. I mean I couldn't really careless about red hood stuff, but I love the other teen heroes that's in there chiming in. Need more Sideways and Flatline.
>>156347488I've seen people crossing fingers this means the teens are getting VAs if this arg is for the long runYou think something like Runaways or PAD's Young Justice would've done something like this if they could have?
>>156347474I don’t see any better options
>>156340092>>156342061Since deadend Tim is always going to be a little boy in a red onesie while Jason is aged up to be a tortured veteran hunk, DC should just go all the way and make Jason whip out his big honkin pecs to breastfeed suckling Tim. This will boost sales.
>>156347946Jayfag...
>>156347946An anon after my own heart
>>156347474>I'm iffy that Rose as the end game for Jason.It really was just Williamson pushing the ship, he's one of a handful writers at DC who really like the ship for some reason.
>>156348601Never understood why some writers try to to pair Rose with Bat-family men
>>156345159It still bugs me that the kids don't give a single shit about Cole.
>>156349062Did they even know him beyond just hanging out on discord?
>>156348796Because.
>>156348796Because they can't fuck Slade.
>>156349571>>156350369>Slade rejects fucking batboys to avoid drama>fucks his daughter as revengePower move
>>156351358Hoodincible?
>>156304148>>156304559Just read post-crisis batman. Every author wrote their own Jason.And after he became Red Hood, every author wrote their own Jason.Tim may been sorta boring and now gay, but at least the editors care enought to tell the writer how is the character(or the writers cares enough to remember 2 or 3 thing about the faggot)
That Jason soundclip was hot ngl.
>>156351435Which one?
>>156351970This >>156346514It is weird to hear Troy Baker's voice from Nicoulo's Jason tho
>>156346514Huh. It's deeper than I imagined
>>156347946but that would be gay
>>156353415How could you sense such subtle indirect faggotry, Sherlock? Of course it's gay, manly would be to suck Batman's Bat-tits
>>156301201Harpersisters...
>>156301201Jason is the exact definition of wasted potential. He is the most universally hated incarnation of Robin, to the point where the readers voted to have him killed off, and every single comic he has ever been in as Red Hood has been complete dogshit. The writers have absolutely no clue what direction to take the character in nor what to do with him.
>>156355189>He is the most universally hated incarnation of Robin, to the point where the readers voted to have him killed offLiterally DC propaganda
>>156355189not anymore
>>156349571I feel bad for Rose and Roy
I'm not saying it's not warranted but as someone who's more familiar with Higgins and Di Nicuolo for their Power Rangers and Massive-Verse work, it's so fucking weird seeing them embrace having fans of early 20's to late teens go nuts over their Teen Titans run that isn't even an arc done yetThen again it was also weird for me to see Dan Mora skyrocket to stardom since I just thought of him as the guy who did art for Go Go Power Rangers
>>156355189Its because his fanbase is divided.Half the fans want him to be part of the overall Batfamily, while the other half want him to be Punisher.So of course these two sides are mutually exclusive so no one knows what to do with Jason.
>>156355189>>156356200DC editorial hands typed these posts.
>>156355189Main problem in retrospect was at the height of his popularity just before New52 they shoved him in a Lobdell book that in various forms ran for going on a decade. In the time of that his fandoms scattered all over the place DC and the industry as a whole is barely on life support and its well past to late to build him towards a stable character with an ongoing now
>>156356181So you're saying here that, the key to success is to start from Power Rangers?
>>156355122What site is this?
>>156356898Affinity Analyzer
>>156356571>at the height of his popularity just before New52 they shoved him in a Lobdell booklol, lmao even.Before N52, the character was already falling of and doing dumb things like being a full redhead and fucking Talia. If anything RHATO was a lifesaver.
>>156356181Jasonfags are carrying this book hard, and that is because Higgins is the first writer since Lobdell to not treat Jason as a reckless, emotional retard
>>156356571>the height of his popularity just before New52 The height was Arkham Knight, around the end of N52 with RH/Arsenal. >Main problem in retrospect was Editorial mismanagement and Batfags turned writers. Always was.I don't know why fags pretend otherwise. DC let Lodbell be? My ass, he was a yes-man while Rhato was a low-priority book that was constantly derailed by events from start to finish. I don't remember if it was Snyder or Geoff who changed Jason's origin for N52 to make him some dark chosen one according to Joker's keikaku. Rhato was a nothing burger at the end of the food chain, and DC never mismanaged the character more than outside Rhato.>>156356894Or maybe the Power ranger editorials are good at their job.
>>156357365>If anything RHATO was a lifesaver.It really wasn’t. Lobdel had that book for years, and it kept Jason in a cycle of aggressive mediocrity. Nobody liked Morrison’s handling of Jason, so Lobdel’s RHATO should have been his Tom Taylor moment where coming in after a bad run elevates it. Instead, what Jason got was something worse than being badly written: his time as a main character was wasted and his credibility to sustain himself as a draw eroded because Lobdel doesn’t write for the sake of the game, he does it for his check and it shows in both runs.
>>156357463Except Lobdel DID treat Jason as a reckless, emotional retard.
>>156357613>it kept Jason in a cycle of aggressive mediocrityDC is aggressive mediocrity with rare exceptions here or there. They were never thinking about credibility or sustainability with Jason. He's a character that they only value as a dead soldier who isn't worth praising, or the wayward son Bats must cull time to time. This is why Higgins got the fans sitting on the edge of their seat now. Thanks to his artist mostly, who is also a much better PR than him. We'll see if that still holds in a few issues.
>>156356571>its well past to late to build him towards a stable character with an ongoing nowIt’s never too late, but it’s all up to luck now
>>156356200>Half the fans want him to be part of the overall Batfamily, while the other half want him to be PunisherSo female vs male fans?
>>156358282Nah, dumb vs smart fans.
>>156358306The people who want Jason to be a bootleg Punisher are the past people I’d call smart, considering Punisher isn’t supposed to be praised or emulated.
>>156358637Still far smarter than those who want Jason to be redeemed. Ask them what they’d do with Jason if they redeemed him, and they wouldn’t come up with anything better than what he already is as Red Hood. Same goes for those Winick haters. Ask them what they actually want Jason to be if not Red Hood, and they wouldn’t have a better answer either.
>>156358795>it’s actually smarter!It actually isn’t considering Punisher deconstructed the character; the retards pushing for the Jason Punisher angle want Punisher MAX but without the lesson at the end. And thats boring.
>>156358637If you use fictional characters as reference to what you should do in real life you're retardedfemale fans wants him to be the misunderstood tsundere of their domestic fanfics, male fans want him to be an independent antihero and do cool shit. The problem is that writers can't do both without switching his personality every issue
>>156358925The problem is that neither are that good, and the character’s foundation has been built on sand since Winick got his hands on the character.
>>156357613>credibility to sustain himself as a draw eroded because LobdelOr the character can sustain a solo because nobody had it clear what they want him to be. Not even his fans.
>>156358985*Can't sustain
>>156358985Everyone wanted a Red Hood solo; nobody wanted the shit that Lobdel was serving them. Nobody gives a shit about Srarfire or Arsenal, or Bizarro or temu Wonder Woman. They wanted Jason.
>>156358909The problem is that you take “be like Punisher” too literally. People just want Jason to have more edge and be less restricted by the usual PG-13 stuff.>>156358972So, what do you want Jason to be, then?
>>156359052>The problem is that you take “be like Punisher” too literallyBut that’s literally what they want; they want 24 pages issues of Jason grimacing while he kills fifty drug dealers and rapists. Shit is no different than boomer slop like Death Wish, which ironic considering how these same fans also love to talk about Jason’s underclass status and how Bruce oppresses him.
>>156359006>Everyone wanted a Red Hood soloConsidering that Lost Days was selling in the lows 30k even at that time when the animated movie was being hyped around, and the RHATO go and went to do the same numbers... One could said that the people interested on Jason Todd stayed the same.
>>156359173Killing criminals isn’t some exclusive Punisher trait, dumbass. If that’s all it takes to make someone a Punisher clone, your understanding of both characters is embarrassingly shallow.
>>156358909>Punisher MAX but without the lesson at the endThe moralfag lesson hasn't been done because not even Punisher shit was decently attempted in comics, only in animation and video games.The general script is drama for working against the no-kill rule he will always lose by opposing Batgod or skip to rubber bullets, go gun blasting for the plot then have a flashback to whine about his death.He will never go solo as a vigilante without regressing back into sales booster or backup for Bat-family. He's stuck as a secondary character without independent development, unlike Dick.
>>156359411But that’s the point; Jason becomes an incredibly shallow character because they want him as a pseudo character.
>>156359611Jason doesn’t need to go solo; going solo is more of a hinderance than anything he would be leaving the most lucrative real estate in DC Comics. It’s no different than having John Stewart stop associating with the GLC to go solo.
>>156359709Then write him better. A character concept doesn’t become bad just because someone doesn’t like its execution. Jason had more going on than just killing criminals.
>>156359052Nta. I'd put him on a team of low-key villains a la TFZ and play with the idea of his immortality, or continue what Titans is doing, but without the Titans.> Underground detective who will look for missing people for a resonable price. He's however very picky about his cases and because it's not too different from hiring a hitman, he only appeals to desperate clients.
Batman is always wrong and needs the writers to manipulate reality around Batman to make his insane ramblings on morality and ethics become correct. The Joker still consistently murders innocent people every time.>"I'll see a billion innocents killed before I let The Joker be brought to Justice!" ~ Batman.
>>156360010It’s more that Judd Winick is a terrible writer, and that Bob Schreik should have told him to fuck off after Winick pestered him with his terrible script.
>>156359730John has earth and whole galaxies to have stories in. Jason only has criminal areas of Gotham and bat-related places. Compare it to Dick having Bludhaven, Titans and being free to wander beyond depending of the story arc.>leaving the most lucrative real estate in DC ComicsHe's equally fucked over by it
>>156360215>John has earth and whole galaxies to have stories in.But without the GLC assication, he’s much more boring. > Compare it to Dick having Bludhaven, Literally Diet-Gotham City. Bludhaven has been around for thirty years and most interesting thing to happen to it was getting nuked.>Titans Peaked pre-Crisis and hold Dick back.>and being free to wander beyond depending of the story arc.Like Dark Crisis,
>>156359896Of course, but it’s because shit like UTRH that it shifted focus and made him into this edgy little shit complete opposite of who he was as Robin in 1988.Like Jason circa 1988 would have murdered Jason circa 2005 because Jason circa 2005 is everything he saw wrong with Gotham’s seedy underbelly.