Anybody watch this yet?
>>156357694Never heard of it
>>156357694oh its out today. very chinese...
the fuck is with this low quality post?you a bot?
>>156357694I'm sick of ironic post-modern deconstructions with millenial quirk chungus humor
>>156357694Do most modern parents respond well to Subversive takes on classic fairy tales? This won't exactly win over family audiences like, say, another legacy sequel would.
I love WMAF Shrekderella and I don't care who else does
>It's another Asian-American self-insert storyOh good. It's been a couple of weeks since the last one and I was getting worried.
>>156357694I wouldn't watch this even as a second screen background noise while I take a shit
>>156360157I haven't watched this movie nor do I intend to, but I predict this will be /co/'s favorite character by far.
>>156360264Well She does show her feet quite a bit, so probably
twitter is talking a lot about it and saying its actually goodis it true?
>>156360496It's decent. Better that the trailer made it seem at least. Has a few good jokes.
>>156360036Some claim that having MC drugged and sexually assaulted by the prince was a bold and daring metaphor for the expectations of female nobility, but I say if you have to add a rape scene for titilation your film was already uninteresting.
>>156359833Seriously? It's ANOTHER one of those?
>>156361001It's really only in the first few minutes and one joke later in the movie. It's there, but not as heavy handed as it could be.
Seems like it’s better than people expected.
>>156361467I knew it wasn't going to be bad, but I still dislike what the trailer showed in principle.I'm not a fan of Cinderella deconstructions that try to paint Cinderella herself as "privileged" somehow, when the whole point of the story is that she was basically forced into being a slave to her step-family in her own home.There are ways to subvert the story and redeem the stepsisters, specially since the actual villain is always the stepmother, but you don't have to villainize Cinderella or the Prince for that.
>>156360496>twitter likes itmeans its ass
Just watched it, its shit.Gotta love the racist townspeople who are only racist to chinese for some reason. There are just so many mean spirited things the story does for no reason.None of the jokes are funny (except the princes condition which was the only smart bit of writing in the film), the fucking dress scene was unforgivable and it just skips over it? Biggest crime is there is a huge amount of money spent on the visuals only for the art design to be utter shit. They spent a lot of money making a film thats both generic and ugly.Cinderella 3 shits on this.
>>156357694>NetflixWho watches Netflix anymore?
>>156360157hope people draw yuri of her and cinderella
>>156357694Why do they keep trying to make movies about the evil stepsisters?
>>156361001It's the only movie they make anymore
I know from the trailers they make a joke about how Cinderella isn't a real name, but do they acknowledge that it was the stepsisters who stuck her with that name because of her having to sleep next to the fireplace to keep warm at night?It just seems like that should be a big thing since the stepsister seems offended that she's called the EVIL stepsister.
>>156357694i was on Steps screenplay dump thread from perhaps earlier in the year.i've seen all i needed to see then.it was never worth watching from the very beginning.
>>156360345>>156360157Ok she's cute. Who's this one supposed to be? One of the other stepsisters?
Can someone post THAT scene that looks AI generated?
>>156361467The trailer set expectations pretty low. Honestly, a pretty good strategy all things considered. It's a gamble but it can pay off sometimes.
>>156362535Priscilla, she's another noble who is mean and racist and is the villain of the movie
>>156362539
Anything kinky happen?Hypnosis, bondage, drugging, vore, transformation, petrification, or even just something kinda weird like this?
okay... HOW OLD ARE THEY?! 18?!
Finished it. It was cute, but it felt like the story was written for a series rather than a movie, with more time for the characters to explore their storylines. There are fun ideas, but everything happens too fast, and very few moments feel earned because of it. Characters fight and fix their issues at the drop of a dime, and it sucks because you can see how they could have worked if they had more time to develop them. There's a big deal about the mom and how she's being treated at the start, and then she's a no-show for the rest of the film. And you'd think that would be more important, as Tremaine was the true villain of the real Cinderella story. They take so many liberties; they may as well be OCs. I guess the comparisons to Wicked are accurate.It's still not a bad movie and better than a lot of the nonsensical movies we're getting recently like Cat in the Hat. If the Wonka movie is a tighter version of this I'd be down to see the Netflix Animation Studios movies.
>>156362583Ah ok. So she's an original character to introduce a villain for the movie. Guess that makes sense. Do the other stepsisters show up?
>>156362840YuriThe romance subplot is basically between the sisters, with the boys as a near afterthoughtBut if you're asking for real freakinessThe aristocrat lady brainwashes everyone and turns them into porcelain dolls to worship and serve her too. Also the sister gets transformed into a frog and loses her mind and identity overtime until she's just an ordinary frog.
>>156363039Oh hell yea, dollification is my jam
>>156362583>"Villain Wasn't Actually Bad" story>Has to create a new main character who is the villain and is badA ponzi scheme. A pyramid scam, if you will.
>>156362901>it felt like the story was written for a series rather than a moviethat is literally the work flow for ALL media production nowis it netflix production money value no?make it into a movie!
>>156363103>A different movie with different characters is bad because it's differentDid you rant about Shrek because it had to make King Arthur a loser highschooler or the princesses different characters?
>>156357694Unironically I will take watching hexed over this
>>156363177This movie is way more /u/ coded than ironically the Owl House ripoffI don't have high hopes for Hex but we'll see
>>156357694>Fairy godmother is a horny hag I will now watch your film
WHAT THE FUCK WAS WITH THAT ENDING?So the entire movie was pointless? None of it ever happened?
>>156363224Cinderella got another chance and Lilith got a new perspective. Everything Priscilla fucked up got undone.
>>156363213You can't just say that and not post her. I need horny hags.
>>156363281But the magic reversed the timeline right?SO NONE OF THE EVENTS IN THE MOVIE ACTUALLY FUCKING HAPPENED. What a shit end
>>156359461Dude parents are stupid they don't notice what kind of evil agenda a kid's movie has so long as its not too disruptive to the ear and eyes meaning they will only bitch at swearing and things like homosexuality. The rest of the time parents don't care to notice the contents of films and what nasty ideas they will plant in their brat's brains. The generation that grew up on shit like Zootopia will be the one most murdered by immigrants and migrants, see France and the UK.
>>156363302anon I don't know how to tell you this but none of the movie happened. It's just a movie.
it was shit the ending was bad but the worse part was the movie beating Cinderella over the head how bad her leaving her sisters trapped when they were kids while glossing over how badly Lilith treated Cinderella the only good part was the face blindness joke and noticing how many things existed solely to sell toys like the entire troll section
>>156357694I thought it was okay, nothing new from Netflix Animation Studios original films after GDT Pinocchio basically on the same par as The Sea Beast.Cindy's a cutie patootie tho
>>156363320There are more people that from prescription drugs big pharma and the American Medical Association push down our throats than murders from immigrants. Getting mad about some furryflick because it addresses racism is the bottom bitch pickme of argumentative address.And there's nothing really bad about this film's message. Be nice to your sister? Care for your family?
>>156363346> beating Cinderella over the head how bad her leaving her sisters trappedThey didn't really beat Cindy over the head at all about this.>while glossing over how badly Lilith treated CinderellaLilith didn't treat Cinderella that bad either desu.It's a valid critique in the opposite direction because the ending resolution feels powerful until you remember neither were even that mean or harsh towards each other and engaged pretty caringly throughout the film.
He just wanted to be Priscilla's dad
>>156363371Not when said family is abusive and isn't even actual blood either. And that's another thing because even if a family member is blood why should anyone forgive their shitty behavior? Its what made movies like Coco and Encanto unwatchable shit. Shitty members of a family deserve to be hated and cut out of your life, ideally take action to deal with them and make them rightfully suffer consequences.As far as Cinderella goes always liked the original tale's finale with the evil stepsisters getting their eyes gouged out by Cinderella's bird friends.
>>156363417>Not when said family is abusive >why should anyone forgive their shitty behavior? Isn't Christianity all about love, redemption, and forgiveness or whatever? Well not like they're all that abusive in this version. I don't think you need jesuscuck to believe its a better message than being a petty bitter cunt. And as far as actions go none of the characters do things that are irredeemable.That being said, Priscilla deserved way worse and they should've kicked her ass for abit more in the movie rather than forgiving her so quick, but it was retconned so whatever.>and isn't even actual blood either.Oh so you're one of those. If you think shit like that realistically matters you're a far worse demagogue for society than le funny netflix kid's movie.>As far as Cinderella goesYeah but that's not the media we're talking about here so who cares.
This movie might just have one of the most annoying casts I've ever seen
>>156363320Someone's dad never played catch with him.
its woke trash
>>156364066
>>156364066>>156364075im feeling very sleepy chinese man.jpeg
>>156364066>>156364075Best joke in the movie, unfortunately proves everyone is a born-yesterday tard
>>156357694mega?
>mc's character macguffin is a nure-onna doll with a bs "misunderstood shapeshifter" backstory>actual myth is a demon who lures sympathetic bystanders into holding her baby>the baby turns into a rock that the victim can't get rid of, dragging him/her down to drown or be eatenKino/10
>>156362901So this is better than Cat in the Hat?
>>156357694cute azn
>>156363039 Yuri Now I'll watch your movie!
>>156364066>>156364075What is the joke?
>>156365168Fairy Godmother Mel Brooks makes fun of Netflix for racebending, Twitter retards act like the characters have already always been Asian
>>156365199Not yuriPost the dress-groping scene and we're talking
>>156365227I need to see this.
>>156363224Another thing it ripped off from Cinderella 3
>>156357694Think I'd give this movie a B-. I liked the story and designs. Most of the jokes were landed for me (The face blindness joke really got me.). I liked Litlith and Cinderella's dynamic. I think some of the supporting cast was underwritten, especially Gef. I overall enjoyed this, maybe not a hard recommend, but I wouldn't discourage others from watching it.
>>156357694Ok, where are the yuri scenes?
>>156365505If they had marketed this movie as a sisters bonding movie with a yuri subtext , the reactions would have been more positive. Instead, they chose to focus on le strong boss girl who needs no man. Whoever is in charge of the marketing is an idiot.
>>156365555Imagine.
>>156362901>but it felt like the story was written for a series rather than a movieIs it chinese? Chinese people can't conceive simple stories that fill a movie they always need like 5 arcs and stuff happening even after the main villain/crisis is over, when they don't leave the heroes entierely for 20 minutes just to create some sort of OC in the movie with its own flashbacks and all just to drop it 2 minutes after it meets the main cast.
>>156365564I wonder if Disney would ever allow realistic scratches like these.Even as a gag
>>156365265https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iKfDTyE0zTA
>>156357694
>>156365662Thank you very much, anon.
>>156365662I expected a different type of "groping".
>>156365496Cinderella literally says 'because I love you' in one scene. There's more yuri crumbs than anywhere in Frozen.
>>156365548Also they needed to show more of the hot villainess in the trailer.
>>156365555SLAMPIG
>>156365722Why couldn't this have been a yuri movie? This was their chance.
>>156365745They settled for the most 34-begging production in recent memory, time will tell if it pays off(it better)
>>156362092>None of the jokes are funny (except the princes condition which was the only smart bit of writing in the film)I'm not watching this, care to spoil it?
>>156365745Mainstream movie made for normies, so unfortunately they can only p/u/sh the film to the absolute limit while minimizing the male love-interests. But for a family adventure film about Cinderella it's hella gay.
>>156365766He cannot tell faces apart, so the villain tricks him into thinking she's Cinderella by just shrinking her feet. The whole bit with him needing to find a glass slipper is because he literally has facial blindness as a running gag.
>>156365767What is going on here?
>>156365775Climax of the film. They're trapped in an underground prison while the rest of the city is turned into dolls so they're apologizing for years of neglect and sisterly angst and confessing they missed each other in their lives.
>>156365778Ok, now that looks a bit gay.
This movie looks like fruit island tiktoks
>>156365789You're thinking of Forgotten Island, which was a full length tiktok meme with nonstop social media baiting. This film was pretty beautiful to look at, and the concept art was gorgeous.
>Interracial step-sister yuri>Architect stepsis>Ara ara dommy sorceress noblelady villain>old fairy godmilf>Dollification, mind control, feral frog tf>All the makeover scenes where Lilith just fucks>Footkink tooIf this film doesn't launch a lewd empire than the internet will have failed us.
>>156365767This is one of the few times we get to have female characters with pretty designs that don't have Elsa's face nor look like men. This was the time to have a girl-on-girl movie with designs that are easy on the eyes.
Sooooooooo..did Cinderella keep her memories of the movies events in the new timeline? She'd have to in order to free Lilith right? But doesn't that carry the implication she's now like a 20 year old in a little kid's body and has to relive her entire childhood over again?
>>156365841You say that like its a bad thing.
>>156365773>MLI #1 is faceblind to the point of social retardation>MLI #2 is a self-taught STEM hobbyist>MLI #(??) is a graying war vet surrogate daddy>Main flashback casualty just straight dies of yellow feverThe Chosen One of WMAF kino
>>156365830https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=78ITjNlrWZM>With original song by JENNIE
>>156365662Remembering her?
I have yuri fatigue
I heard there was a snake lady, is that true?I don't give a shit about anything else.
>>156366183Surprisingly, no. They hint at it for Lilith's character arc by calling her it and using the name to insult her early in the film based on the Snakelady myth she tells. It almost seems like they set something up for it later but just dropped it towards somewhere in development.
>>156365528And they they kiss
>>156366183See:>>156364524It's all setup for Steps 2: The Search for Snerson
>>156366304Cindy is for Lilith.
>>156365976she wants to be those girls
>>156365732That is a frog, anon
>>156366531I need lewds of that slamfrog
>>156366558This scene felt so odd, neither character has especially established themselves as an in-your-face-don't-care-what-anyone-thinks rebels.It felt like there were a lot of <scene missing> moments >never established why Cinderella betrayed her stepsisters when she never really seemed to care that much about popularity>why the fuck we should care about the sister after she ruined the dress>why the fairy godmother was so hyperfixated on making Cinderella's happy ending rather than just doing something minor>the film suddenly starting to use very short snippets of licenced songs in the second halfAlso "should I tell my dad to go see a doctor this time? Naaaaaaah"
>>156366547Best I can do
>>156366608Cindy didn't care about popularity, she was just too meek and passive to standup for her asian step-sister and Lilith resented her for that.The dress ruining was an accident.The Fairy thing, yeah they introduced a whole plotline about fate or destiny that they never really explained or followed up on. Pretty huge gap in the story.
>>156365636The writing is unmistakably Western, so no.
>>156366638Nah with the dress ruining she simply didn't care, she wanted to rip it off no matter what, reaction only changing when she realised it was her mother's (implying she didn't give a shit about ruining it before). The problem it being Cinderella trying too hard to please everyone is that it would make no sense for her character her not going all out to make things right (she only started the obsessive cleaning after her father died). It was a weak motivation that also relied on her being massively out of character just that one time.
>>156362901The frustrating thing was the Prince having face blindness was funny and a great way of acknowledging the plot holes which showed they could do smart funny writing. As you said, maybe it was a 6 * 30 minute series compressed down to 90 minutes so few of the arcs were allowed to develop and resolve properly.No excuses for the art design being dog shit though, it's a weirdly ugly movie with high production values.
>>156357694Can someone draw Lilith and Cinderella scissoring, pls?
>>156359461Shrek was pretty popular, so why not?
>>156366648>Animal Helper train-run scene calls back a bit to the Grimm Brothers ending where the sisters get the Hitchcock treatment from Cindy's birdslol>The kingdom is named "Alouette", which is a French song about dismembering a birdLOL
>>156363415Indirectly Lilith and Cindy made his wish come true >>156366818
>>156366965I'm surprised no one has latched onto him the same way they did Jerry from Hoppers
>>156366971Streaming films usually don't get much traction unless the timing is correct like KPOP or Swapped
Was there a pee scene in the movie?
>>156367024No but tons of feet shots
>>156367033Did they actually show her feet or was it covered?
I really love the foot scenes.
>>156367039Priscilla Feet
>>156367033>>156367039>>156367073Foot bros, we are eating good today
>>156367091there was also like the peeing pants/diaper stuff, size difference (not as bad obvi), the inanimate tfs, the goth makeover w purple lipstick and fetish raver costume stuff and many other things.
>>156367140I only got hard at the foot scenes, don't care for the rest. Need more barefoot women in cartoons.
Steps: The Series when?
>>156359461>Subversive takes on classic fairy tales? Yes
>>156363156Shrek 3 sucked though partly because of that
>>156365830>Architect stepsisAre you saying that cause she's fat or does she actually start trying to fatten someone up?
>>156367365The former, tho she's kinda freaky herself>Gets transformed into a frog>Literally just rolls with it and initially seems pretty into itWhy, would the movie be benefited by Cindi and Lilith taking their sister to a bakery and shoving her with treats til her stomach bulges?
>>156365830Patiently Waiting for the foot rule34.
>>156363039Wait, the sister never changes back and effectively dies? That's pretty fucking dark, even if she's into it.
>>156367392No but that would be hot. I just wanted to know cause I probably would've wasted my time skimming through the movie trying to find a scene like that.
>>156367441Yeah but they reverse the timeline like in the movie Shrek 4, so it ends up never happening. In the new timeline they're all friends again and live happily.
>>156367443She's not into it by that point, when she finally changes she's terrified
>>156357694let me guess the step sister dindu nuffin and Cinderella needs to apologize for whatever
>>156362092The prince jumping out the window was pretty good
>>156367547They both act like assholes towards each other because their dad died and mom is a workaholic absent widow. Cinderella has them locked in a cage as a kids and snubs them for the town bullies, the stepsisters ruin her gown and crash her ball gala for their own entertainment and they have to makeup throughout the film.
>>156363327Bet you eat your food like a dog
>>156367501wrong reply>>156367441>>156367474
>>156363453You can blame religion and God for all your problems anonHating Jesus doesn't make you coolAnd watering shit down to justify yourself is a shitty thing to do, which is what this movie does. It takes a terrible step family says "nuh uh this is what actually happened" and makes a completely different story while saying it's the same thing.
>>156367638I'm assuming you're talking about Cinderella, the Fairy Tail, as publicized by Disney. Am I wrong Christcuck?You do know that that particular story was already fanfiction and literally, a completely different story from the fairytail while saying it's the same thing? But I don't see you criticizing that, even when there are literally hundreds of versions of the Cinderella story. Hell there are already versions where Cinderella acts like a huge bitch.But you don't really care about the metacanon of a fictional princess nor sucking Disneycock, do you? Then why are you going NOT MUH CINDER RELLY like a pathetic cuck redditor?
>>156367678
>>156367694>I am so random XDWe get it. You're 12 and mom loves that you go to Sunday school while you shout the N word online like a naughty boy. So special. Now shoo.
I like that the prince despite the face blind gag immediately clocked something was wrong the next day.also yeah this story definitely felt like it was planned for a longer runtime or even a show.
>>156367752>zoom! That'll show him
>>156367678The Disney version keeps all of the important details and story beats and doesn't water down the abuse elements in the story. The only real change of note is the ending for the stepsisters, who either get married off to the Prince's cousins or have their eyes plucked out by birds. Saying that Disney version is completely different when it's probably one of their more faithful adaptations is just misleading.
Margot is cute....CUTE
>>156359097Seem to be a lot of those going around.
>>156368044Got any more?
Anti-white garbage
>>156368103
>>156367073>foot growth>attractive female>really big but not clown big>she does it to herself and is pleasedThis is pressing a very specific button for me.
>>156357694This movie is highly satanic because it has fairies and trolls aka DEMONS
We need more hair horns
The reception for this movie feels incredibly astroturfed.
>>156367073Okay, I'm convinced, gonna watch the movie.
>>156363453>Gaytheist brings up religion out if nowhereYou fags can't help yourselves, can you?
>>156367594Cinderella ditching them once was a bitch move, but it was silly to have Lilith hate her just because of that one moment. It would have been better to show more of her "kindness" act being negligence toward her sisters.The book saying she had evil sisters also made no sense when Margot is just as pure of heart as Cinderella is, and the only bitch is Lilith.
>>156367594>mom is a workaholic absent widowI was wondering about the stepmother because none of the marketing was about her.Even though the most obvious thing to do in a reimagining like this would be to make her a more obviously abusive mother towards all her daughters, by making them fight amongst themselves.>Cinderella has them locked in a cage as a kids and snubs them for the town bulliesHonestly the more I read about this the less it sounds like Cinderella.
>>156368311But it's also about forgiveness, which is a biblical value.
>>156360345Is this another case of them making the original villain good so they make a new villain that basically serves the same purpose as the original one?
>>156368185>>156368044>>156368345Now the blondie
>>156368404
>>156368374>but it was silly to have Lilith hate her just because of that one momentit's a good thing the movie established that she didn't hate her then.>The book saying she had evil sisters also made no sense That's kind of the point.
>>156368410Row 2 for the expressions is how people thought she was going to act pre-release
>>156368389The stepmom is barely in the film.>>156368389She doesn't lock them in, the bitchy bully Princilla does. Cindy could've let her stepsisters out but the point of them movie was she was too meek and passive to standup to someone pressuring her and didn't stand up for her sisters when they needed her.
>>156368438she needs correction by penis.
>>156368703That shit was the most phoned in comphet scene for the parents watching at home, holy shit. Literally rushed by like a stealth bomber.
>>156368742American still not ready for full stepcest
>>156368742>comphetAnon, this is Cinderella.She's supposed to get with the Prince.
>>156368969>*Record scratch*
>>156357694The quirky lampshading humor fucking killed it for me. Which is kinda a shame because the animation was pretty fun and it had some genuinely funny moments (any scene with the main villain's henchmen/adoptive father was genuinely great) but Lilith herself being "le quirky self-aware girl" dragged down every scene she was in.
>>156368517NTA but it definitely could've been written better. They seemed afraid to have Lilith actually be a dick to Cinderella which made the whole one-sided conflict seem like an overreaction to one insensitive moment. Especially since by all accounts Cinderella was still very nice to her after that.Personally I would've preferred if she just let resentment from that slowly turn her into a legitimate bully and then later she realized she was treating her step-sister like shit for one mistake she made as a child.
>>156357694Thoughts on Steps (2026)?
>>156359461 as a parent no this shit is a plague on children's innocence. Everything has been subverted for so long that being genuine and honest has become a subversion.I do, however, recognize that my opinion isn't a great sample size, considering where we are.
Sequel where Margot meets and falls in love with the Frog Prince, but the witch who cursed him snatches him before they can kiss, so the sisters go on an road trip adventure to rescue him.
>>156369151Looks like Lady Tremazn had way more of a villain arc at early planning. Also any personality and scenes beyond>Excited but graceful newcomer>Somehow rolled "overworked Asian seamstress" despite everything>Now a mob in the last stage of Bioshock InfiniteI kind of assumed Priscilla was Cindy's mom and in kahoots with TFG from the promos, maybe they had that idea (with "Tremaine" being the one to die or get shoved out of the picture) and just swerved to make Priscilla a backup Evil Stepsister and "Li Mei"(lol) a non-character.
>>156367594>Cinderella has them locked in a cage as a kids and snubs them for the town bulliesyep it's exactly the trash I thought it was
>>156368742I wholeheartedly agree, they should've cut all of Lilith's scenes to give enough time to flesh out this romance
OOOOOOOH... it's a YURI love story
>>156369544Princilla's roastie hands typed this post
>>156366859Shrek wasn't as subversive as you'd think at the end of the day.
>>156369189I feel the same way. It feels like we've taken for granted how well everyone knows the classic stories but it's been so long that they've been told classically that I don't think it's as true as it was anymore. People are being raised on the sarcastic self aware versions or the parody without even know what's actually being parodied.
>>15636965110th kingdom did what shrek did better
>>156366811Yes, please.
>>156363039>gets transformed into a frog and loses her mind and identity overtime until she's just an ordinary frog.Why is this kinda thing hot to me?
>>156369059We were on the verge of greatness, we were this close.
>>156369736Never ever yurifag
>>156369059Where is the fanart?
>>156369204I love how she takes the dorkiest route to Instant Goth by just leaving the bustle uncovered
>>156357694Is it any good?
>>156370409>>156362901
>>156365133I watched it today and yes, it was, I can't believe the cat in the hat movie turned out to be hot trash
>>156370741Dang it, I was looking forward to the cat in the hat.
>>156363346>>156363383The conflict between cindy and lilith was pretty clear desu, cindy felt bad about leaving her stepsisters inside the cave and lilith learned to only trust her sister/direct family, as a result cindy did everything in her power to please lilith and regain her trust but lilith saw all that as cindy being muh perfect and gifted girl so she simply ignored her, never really tried to actively harm her until the ball, the ending going back to their kids days is a way to mend this but it's also funny that cindy now had a decade-long headstart and knew what would happen to her eventually.
NBR yuri is always a good and legal thing in my eyes>But stepsisters/stepbrothers are family!NotBloodRelated
>>156370885I'll pretend they're real sisters to keep it hot.
>>156370885WeakSteps is acceptable but a true Yurisseurs would accept them together even as blood siblings.
>>156357694No, I’ve been trying to avoid it. I’ve been kind of sick of classic fairy tale subversions, and especially tired of people who willfully misinterpret Cinderella in particular. I was planning on ignoring it completely, but now I’m getting slightly curious because it’s getting more traction than I was expecting. Why is that?
>>156369059They cute.
>>156371247Because it subverts the Stepsisters having to be an abusive dick and having to be 1-note cartoon bullies, and instead manages to build a relationship between sisters that doesn't promote the "females have to hate each other or be vain and defined entirely by how materialistic they are" propaganda disney pushes.
>>156371283>"females have to hate each other or be vain and defined entirely by how materialistic they are" propaganda disney pushes.Disney hasn't made anything that fits that description for 40 years. Doing gags about female vanity or intrasexual competition is a big no no these days.
>>156366859Shrek is an originally story that at its very heart, is a pretty sweet fairy tale on its own. All of the fuckery it plays with of classic pre established tales is just background set dressing to the story of Shrek himself.
>especially tired of people who willfully misinterpret Cinderella in particular.>Classic version: Graceful, kind, feminine, generous and patient>Steps version: Graceful, kind, feminine, generous and patientThe only thing they portray as subverted in this film is Lilith. Cindy stays pretty true to who she is.>>156371298Name a single positive female-female sisterhood, hell even non-family friendship throughout Disney media then. List as many as you can. Because before shit like Frozen or Encanto, there was literally 0 thought that anything like that even needed to be done.
>>156371283But Disney themselves already did that by giving Anastasia two redemption stories.Also they made Frozen, a movie about sisterly love, because you can just do that without having to shit on Cinderella.
>>156371298>Disney hasn't made anything that fits that description for 40 yearsyeah but you have to understand...When everyone gripes about not adhering to the holy sacred canon of Disney 'classics', they are almost wholly referring to films made before 1986.
>>156371310Yeah people really overstate just how much the first Shrek relies on fairy tale/disney satire. Once we leave the swamp in the beginning third and get into the meat of the plot there's virtually no popular fairy tale references at all
>>156371325Sometimes I say “Cinderella” to mean the story of Cinderella and not always the character, and I’m sorry that that’s confusing.
>>156371340Nobody under 25 cares about Anastasia or sees themselves in her. Her getting to marry some random baker is kind of a consolation prize at best.And Steps is arg/u/ably a much better yuri story than Frozen. Anna and Elsa barely even interact for 90% of the film, they have like 3 or 4 scenes together and that's it, and we're just told that Elsa loves Anna so deeply despite mistreating her and ignoring her for the entirety of the film.
>>156371325Easy, Lilo and Nani.
>>156371373How does making the step-sister able to bond with her sister shit on the original story of Cinderella? There are so many adaptations that maybe I'm not seeing this as some unholy betrayal like everyone else is.It kinda creeps me out because the more I read antis, the more they are obsessed with the singular element of Cinderella getting abused as her defining story trait, like it's her batman origin story or something. They want her to be an abuse victim so bad and I couldn't tell you why.
>>156371386So you have 1. That's good, the agegap makes them abit parent-y/child coded but they're still sisters. There can be more stories like that. The elements in Cinderella were already there so I'm surprised it hasn't been done more or sooner.
>>156371376I’m not gonna go to bat defending Frozen because whether or not it’s a good movie is besides my point. Which is: studios can just make new stories or adapt different stories if they want to do something different. A Snow White and Rose Red yuri story, for example, would be really cool, imo.But a Cinderella subversion about how the stepsister is actually cool and totally not mean sounds both boring as fuck and also disrespectful to a fairy tale I already like and which I hate to see repeatedly dumped on.
>>156371389I’m gonna reiterate that I have not seen Steps. I’m more defending my initial decision not to watch it at this point. But I did come in here basically to ask you: what’s the appeal?
>>156365164>>156365555She should've been the protag
>>156371424Why tho? The Stepsisters were barely characters in the disney adaptation, they were one-note cartoon bullies and 1-dimensional. I don't see how giving them an actual identity or spin is the worst adaptation choice ever.
>>156371389Because the original Cinderella story was about having grace in the face of adversity and the hope that there will be brighter tomorrow if you remain diligent and true. (A message which resonated with Walt's own humble origins so much that he famously named Cinderella as his favorite fairy tale) If you remove the adversity from Cindy's life by having her reconcile things with her abusive family then you take away what makes her story compelling. Cindy escaping her abusive family and marrying the prince is no longer satisfying because you made her previous life less hopeless. It's also insulting because in real life, most victims of abuse don't have the option to just talk things out with their abusers.
>>156371435I stated the appeal.>>156371394>>156371325Female friendships in disney are rare. Sisterhood friendships even rarer, to where you couldn't even count on 10 fingers. Seeing cute female characters blossom and develop together in a way that isn't just "Mission to get a date for the Ball or get married into an easy life" is honestly refreshing.Like if Frozen even had Anna do the movie adventure with Elsa instead of her just being paired with Kristoff for 90% of the film, we might not even be having this conversation, but I think it's enough of a tired, annoying trope that Steps is, well a good step.
>>156371439I actually kind of like simple stories and one note characters, and that’s why I am drawn to both fairy tales and cartoons. I mean, I love some nice complexity sometimes in its own place too, sure. But I do think it’s really easy to fuck up a good thing that was working perfectly fine by trying to give it depth it never needed. Cinderella isn’t broken, so I don’t like seeing people try to fix it.
>>156371394You said name a single example.
>>156371501He walked it back and wants ten now.
>>156371451So the original promotes grace and humility. That's not a bad message inherently, however I feel putting it as the end-all of Cinderella's character doesn't really challenge her, or help her, nor the story grow much. Part of the problematic that Steps tries to introduce is that sometimes, humility isn't enough. Cinderella being so humble and graceful she cannot even tell off some psycho or lift a hand to help people who looked up to her previously feels like an interesting challenge to that classical notion, because then as a deconstruction those virtues can become the stories detriment. >It's also insulting because in real life, most victims of abuse don't have the option to just talk things out with their abusers.I understand what you're saying. Have you considered maybe the type of abuse that Cinderella (50's and classic fairy tail), speaks far more to the type of relationships that woman struggled with and faced back then, and that sort of obscenely evil cruelty and unfairness is so unacceptable or highlighted nowadays that it doesn't exactly make sense to tackle today?Take Lilith's treatment of Cindy in Steps. Is it abuse? I don't know about that, it comes off more like neglect. That's kind of a younger, weaker stepchild to abuse- lack of trust, communication, intimacy and opening up. Frozen did it, but in Elsa's case her neglect was because she was too anxiety-ridden, and in Lilith's case the neglect was spurred when she couldn't reach an understanding with her sister. There is still an adversity there that can be fought with the same tools that Cindy has, just on a less extreme level. I feel that a weaker movie would've squandered that opportunity by making Cinderella too, modern? Making her a wacky quirkchungus to contrast with Lilith's rude punk attitude who just wins her stepsister over with her pluckiness. But she doesn't do that here, it's largely the same character put in a different situation, which demands different nuances.
>>156371501I acknowledged that. So because we have Lilo and Nani females never need to interact in any fairytail or film ever, except as villains or stepmothers?
>>156371466Sorry but “they improved Cinderella by making it…. Not Cinderella.” Isn’t appealing to Cinderella fans.
>>156371528*younger, weaker, stepsister to abuse
>>156371543How is it "Not Cinderella" by changing a seperate character? Are you saying that Cindy is so defined by having a bitch stepsister who mistreats that she loses her identity without having her? Because anon, that's pretty fucking gay sounding, not gonna lie
>>156371539No one said that?
>>156371563Once again, Cinderella is the name of the story, not just the character.
The real elephant in the room that people don't really want to acknowledge is that people primarily like Cinderella because she's a passive, super marysue-ish indulgent fantasy that makes her really appealing to self-insert into. She's some housemaid who is so framed around fenestration that the story hands her a dream life and all her desires, and affirms how special and great she really was.It's to the point where a version of the story where she's not the centerpiece and they have to compete with any other character, just rubs them the wrong way. Repeating the logic of the original Cinderella that lead to the type of abuse. The audience is literally just made up of stepsisters and Princilla's IRL wishing they could be Cindy.
>>156371572Okay. But can you recognize that maybe some people like different stories? About different characters? And maybe utilizing Cinderella in them isn't some betrayal, just like putting Cindy as a Cameo in shrek didn't ruin the holy sacred authenticity of Cinderella? Like you can just go back to the original doey film if you want.
>>156371595No. You're not getting it chum.The REAL elephant in the room, is that cindy relly is a super heterosex story, for both girls and boys who waifu her and making a whole lesbian girlboss yuri story with Cinderella and her sister is like KISS moonwalking into a church choir and playing bass while everyone inside gets the vapors.
>>156371539That is not what the arguement was about though. You said that Disney pushes this idea that women have to hate each other or be materialistic when there really hasn't been a strong "wicked witch" type villain in a Disney movie since Tangled.
>>156371620I can also complain about the superfluity of this fanfic trash movie and the creative bankruptcy that allowed it to be made.
>>156371528>I understand what you're saying. Have you considered maybe the type of abuse that Cinderella (50's and classic fairy tail), speaks far more to the type of relationships that woman struggled with and faced back then, and that sort of obscenely evil cruelty and unfairness is so unacceptable or highlighted nowadays that it doesn't exactly make sense to tackle today?I think it's misguided to think that we've outgrown or waned in our capacity to cruel to each other. That's what Cinderella (and most fairy tales really) are about it's to let kids know that there's evil out there so watch out. It's not that adding in more complexity is a bad thing, but if it comes at the cost of instructing children about the evils of life then that's a problem. And to be fair to Steps it's not as if there aren't evil, self-serving people still in its story but it just seems a bit redundant. Like Pricilla's character essentially serves the exact same role that the step-sisters/Tremaine did the original story but with extra steps (heh).
So what I'm getting is that in this tale-The stepmom is now an absentee mother-The stepsisters got bullied but Cinderella didn't stand up for them because she was too meek-They still ruined Cinderella's dress-The villain is the bully that turned the stout sister into a frog and now Cinderella and her sister must go on an adventure to fix things
>>156371651Let's refine the argument abit. The 'woman should hate each other' tropes are pretty tired and old, so they're not really visible or that strong anymore. They've weakened enough that we can have films like Encanto, which is relatively recent in Disney history. But even if we've come that far, for most of Disney's history the idea of strong female friendships or female-female relationships, be it for siblings or other types weren't strongly encouraged or promoted. Getting out of the "Girls can develop in positive ways by making female friends instead of getting material gain" has been a very slow, crawling thing that's only taken off the last 10-20 years or so, and still can be seen as starting even in things like Frozen or Brave (Brave with a positive daughter-mother relationship, instead of the mom being the villain.) Thus, Steps feels like a continuation of that progress. It goes even farther with the interracial aspects but I'll probably attract shitheads by talking about that, so I'm not gonna touch that. But at its core, I feel like the problematic is that the film tries to encourage a strong female friendship, at least amongst girls who aren't born sisters or related by blood. Even sisters that are very different personality wise.
>>156371714I agree, however isn't the solution that Cinderella, classic Cinderella presents to addressing that abuse and cruelty, somewhat idealistic? Like you or whoever anon said, you cannot always just get around abuse by talking your way out of it, but I'd turn that around that you cannot exactly always heal it by just waiting impatiently either. Could Cinderella have dealt with someone like Gothel for example given the formalism of the aesop? Gothel is like, the emotional equivalent of Maleficent, and facing that kind of evil with idealism isn't exactly the most instructive or helpful nowadays. Maybe it's hopeful, but in a super naive way.What I'm trying to get at is Steps doesn't try to tackle some, Steven King-esque crazed evil, it re-contextualizes Cinderella's best trait, instead of "Waiting demurely with grace and kindness, I can snag a rich Prince and dream barbie castle", the film has the bold audacity to suggest Cinderella can use her generosity, patience and understanding to help others who have been misunderstood or who I've even hurt and has hurt me. Which you very rarely, ever saw in classical Disney stories because the idea of this type of therapyspeak wasn't even on the menu. The idea that Cinderella's personality can help others and not just be a tool for personal gain I think is a prettygood one. It also shows that she had a part in the dilemma because she's flawed and that social toolset isn't always perfect, but Disney moving away from perfect archetypes isn't always necessarily a bad thing. It just allows characters to show more growth. If you're dealing with Norman Bates or David Duke, sure I'd say that classical Cinderella is the more relevant tale, and there was far more of that when it came out. If you're just trying to solve the neglect and social ills and lesser evils (The banality of ignorance, overcoming differences) a regular girl would approach nowadays in your day to day life I'd say Steps is more appropriate.
>>156371718Priscilla is the villain. But she's not the catalyst for the movie's events, as we see at the end the whole film could be avoided if Cinderella just talked to people more and tried to do more than passively conform and tit-up a little.
>>156371720To be honest, I think that's more of function of the kind of relationships Disney tends to focus on more than anything else. The emotional core in most Disney movies tends to be either romantic love between a man and a woman or the love between a parent and child. I don't think it's really a gendered thing. I mean you can count on one hand the amount of Disney movies which focus on strong male friendships or brotherhood for instance. >Fox and Hound >Brother Bear >Big Hero 6 >Onward and I guess Jungle Book if you really wanna twist my arm.
>>156357694No but I want to see the sisters kiss
>>156359461The biggest problem with most attempts at "subversion" these days is the people writing them don't understand or usually even like what they're supposed to be subverting, so they don't actually know how to do it properly.Plus the fact that the "subversions" outnumber the original works so much these days that it's not really even a subversion anymore.
>>156371781>El Dorado>The Lion King>Monsters Inc>Aladin>Luca>Toy StoryBro-duo comedies were pretty common, altho males aren't as prominent because obviously Disney has kind of a female media bais.
>>156371785Everyone does.
>>156359097Yeah it's a bot. It has all the earmarks of one, they don't even try to mask it anymore. Probably cheap-asses paki programming. The 5th or 6th thread today about this racist piece of crap.
>>156371718>>156371720>>156371772>>156371781>>156371528Don't care.The 2 don't kiss onscreen so film is shit/10Jury dismissed.
>>156371785Artists are taking their time.
>>156371820>The thread with actual discussion is bots! You needed to pay attention to MEMEME in my shitposting /pol/ thread!Is this the type of gaslighting from St. Petersburg they pay you for now?
>>156371804 >El Dorado Dreamworks, not Disney unless you meant to say Emperor's New Groove then fair. >Monsters Inc >Toy Story those movies were made before the Disney aqquisition so I don't count them >Aladdin eeeeeeeeh kinda, Al's main focus is still winning Jasmine's heart at the end of the day >Luca I'll give you that one
>>156371720There already is an answer to this.It's called the Descendants franchise. Though I'm sure most Cinderella stans don't exactly super care for it either since its not classic rella.
>>156371844>Forgot to address Lion King (oops) That one's more Father-Son. Timon and Pumbaa's influence on Simba is framed as a negative coping device that Nala (a woman) has to snap him out of.
>>156371810Well, I DON'T!
>>156371874Same
>>156371824>yurifag ferociously defending this>they don’t even kissGeez you are a thirsty fuck.
>>156371810I do, too, anon.
>>156371720female villains rule though
>>156371874Yes you do!
>>156371895Well obviously But you cannot make a good yuri series out of them without it just becoming lesbian momdom porn/ll/ is the rarest of any relationship type
>>156371647This movie didn't have any of the usual girlboss "I need no man" bullshit tho, lilith just wanted cindy to fuck off because she didn't want to be near her, and the moment she met Gef she fell in love and spilled her spaghetti like any other teen. Unlike Frozen 2's Elsa, who turned into an insufferable girlboss, to give an example.
>>156372043Lilith doing a whole punk-goth makeover isn't "I'm a girlboss" moment for you? And she didn't really want Cindy to fuck off.She was cucked by Princilla when Cindy chose over over her own step-sister, and always wanted to fuck Cindy. She states at one point she loves her, and despite whatever she says she always did.
>>156371325>>156371466Tiana and Charlotte, Pocahontas and Nakoma. And you'd also have fingers left over for male Disney main-character friendships where the #2 isn't a mentor, a servant, or a drag to the mc's moral journey.Bechdel-Testing has been more destructive to modernity than the atom bomb desu.
>>156372083>She states at one point she loves her, and despite whatever she says she always did.Kinda gay, I like it.
>>156369168Imagine the blowjobs
>>156372104>Tiana and CharlotteNot bad, but not entirely superfocused or at the forefront. She could've easily joined Tiana and the prince on their journey rather than being a very minor character. I think Charlotte is a great character that's utterly underused because they'd rather Tiana hang with a random firefly or alligator than her apparently.>Pocahontas and NakomaNever seen this one, so cannot speak on it.But nah imo we need more good female-focused stories and adventures.
>>156357694Watch Cinderella 3 instead, this fucks with the plot to the point where nothing makes sense.
>>156372213It's not a Cinderella movie.It's a movie with Cinderella in it that uses it to tell a yuri incest immigrant story with some spoilt thot brainwashing a kingdom that's solved with time-travel. Getting mad it fucks with the plot of an entirely seperate adaptation is silly.
>>156372234Get Cinderella's name OUT OF YOUR FILTHY YURISLOP MOUTH
>>156372234>yuri incest storySay no more. I'm in.
>>156372303They're step sisters, so they're not actually biological incest.
>>156372326They had one job, one job.
The problem with these "modern retellings" is that they have unilaterally decided that they loved every aspect of the original story except for the actual message, so they all dress up in period pieces while having incongruous sensibilities. A true modern retelling would attempt to adapt the original message of the story to a modern setting. Afterall the stories only have the time period settings they do because that was when they were written. They were modern stories upon creation.Modern people want to leapfrog of what was told in the past rather than attempt to create equivalent stories in their modern setting.A modern cinderella story would realize what the purpose of Cinder Ella's story is. Elanor gets her name because she fell asleep while cleaning the fire place, getting a face full of ash, or cinders, leading to a cruel nickname where she is called Cinderella to belittle her.Ash however can be used to blow glass, so what others throw away can also be used to make something beautiful. Cinderella was not just handed her happily ever after, beyond the fact that she made her own dress with scrap fabric only to have it destroyed by her step sisters, all of the things the fairy godmother gave for her would have come from he stuff she cleaned up. Ash from the fire place? Glass slippers. A pumpkin carriage? It comes from the exterior of the pumpkin she threw away after having to dig through it's gooey innards to collect the seeds. The mice who become the horses for the carriage are again something discarded that Eleanor has to be the one to interact with because everyone else just ignores them, much like how they are trying to discard and ignore her.The message is thus that it is in the things we overlook and try to ignore that beauty can be found.
>>156372348Cinderella has no real shot of decent marriage prospects, because at the time marriages were arranged often with a dowry provided, and because her father died leaving his estate to his second wife, she is attempting to use the estate for the dowry of her own daughters, rather than use Cinderella's father's estate for her own dowry. Reasonably, had her father NOT remarried, Cinderella would be widow-rich instead of her step-mother. Her father might have made provisions in his will for her, but the step-mother has control of the estate until Cinderella comes of age or marries into a different family who would become her guardian instead. So by all accounts, Cinderella SHOULD be an attractive marriage prospects but something the step-mother is doing is making that impossible. Perhaps the will states that when Cinderella gets married the estate passes through her and the step-mother only has control of it so long as she is Cinderella's guardian, so the step-family for their own economic well being might be preventing her from getting married.Regardless of the circumstance, Cinderella is being cast aside, like mice, or a emptied pumpkin, or ash, and it is up to the fairy godmother to make something beautiful ought of what is being thrown away.A broader societal message is that by arranging marriages like this, beautiful girls in less than ideal economic circumstances of being cast aside and prevented from living full lives. The commentary might be against the dowry system in general in terms of marriage instead of marrying for love (which is to say, finding someone attractive)Once you TRULY understand what it is trying to say you could begin to attempt to create a REAL modern retelling.
>>156372407I don't think you can tell a modern story about, European 16th century Dowrys or inheriting a large estate and still have it relevant or make much sense to girls today. I'm not sure who that would even be for.Even the Disney version kinda glances that all over because they realized that even in 1950 these elements were outdated for women.
>>156372201Pocahontas is a great movie with a 0% chance of meeting your standard for positive female social representation. And at this point, there is nothing on the list for "healthy, equivocal, runtime-dominating male relationships" where one or all of the characters are not a talking animal for most or all of the feature.
>>156372407Much of the complaints over these stories centering on marriage comes from the fact that those events are of significantly less importance than they used to be. In the original story the step-family is likely fighting over some kind of dowry, so marriage is the escape likely because it truly is an escape from the legal conditions Cinderella has been placed in due to the wording of her father's will, where her inheritance is under he control of her step-mother until Cinderella gets married.That doesn't exist anymore, ironically because of what is called "feminist progress". The step-mother has power over Cinderella because of the patriarchy. Gasp!That doesn't mean we still don't have important milestones for our futures an uncooperative step-parent might be to get in the way.The obvious modern analogue would be to get into a prestigious university. Perhaps the same one her father attended, but the step-mother is trying to get her own daughters into the university instead, trying to schmooze her way into their good graces as her father's widow.This is kind of upper-class so it actually isn't any more relatable to your average person as something set in the seventeenth century, but in the original tale the family is well-to-do, but treat Cinderella like a common servant, despite them all living in her father's house.The key would be to recreate that in a way which wouldn't invoke the "why aren't child protective services get involved?" so one needs to be subtle, but they also need to make the audience aware that they are trying to belittle Cinderella and cast her aside by making her do tasks that cast stuff aside. Getting her to decorate the house for a Halloween party such as by getting her to scoop up the gooey innards of the pumpkin but then figuring out some reason why she needs to be kept away from the actual party works, particularly if it is BECAUSE she had to get dirty preparing "you stink like pumpkin!" etc
>>156372671I don't care if they're an animal or talking pet lol.But it is lame when they introduce a fun relationship and sideline it or utterly neglect to develop it. That's why Ruby Gillman was such a hopeful film that got many excited developing the friendship of its characters, only to throw them away for some dumb shitty twist.One thing I've heard from a youtuber critiquing the movie is you don't to punch down and lower a character to make another better, because their first instinct was thata positive depiction of the stepsister automatically meant Cinderella would get written like shit.She didn't! But more important I think is to acknowledge that goes both ways. You don't have to turn characters into caricatures, twist villains or cut them out of the film just to build up the other character.
>>156372711The idea is that the stuff they make her do, like scoop out the pumpkin should be call backs to the eventual "magic" that saves the day for her. The pumpkin becoming the carriage is just one example.Obvious we have cars now, so if you want to get tomboy points you can have her fix the car for the family by doing an oil change or something, but she is so overworked that she gets cargunk all over her face when they discover her sleeping in the garage. Thus going off some top girl names the hurtful nickname might be -Oilivia instead of Olivia-Carlot instead of Charlotte-Enginly instead of Emily-Awheelia instead of Amelia-Sofaia instead of Sophia if instead they just catch her sleeping on the sofaor if you want to keep the Cinderella name you could make it be referring to CinderblocksPerhaps she is fixing her father's old car, as it is the last thing she has of him, and it is up on cinderblocks, so they call her Cinderella to mock her for always being in the garage messing around with a car that doesn't even work and is resting on cinderblocks, or cinderwheels. In this idea for the story, the parts she needs might be magically created for her at the last moment so she can take the car somewhere.Regardless, she needs to be made to feel separate from the family and that the step-family is in some sense trying to take her life for themselves.The "prince" in this case might be the son of the dean of admissions the step-family is trying to schmooze if we are still going with that, and his affection can more or less guarantee admission. Perhaps in the end Cinderella secures a spot for all three of them which causes the step-sisters to break down because of how poorly they treated her and yet she was still trying to help them. Thus they all get the spot in the college but only Cinderella gets the boyfriend in the form of the son of the dean of admissions.
What a lively, spirited discussion. This movie must be pretty good. I'll check it out.
>>156371501he's moving the goalposts after you obliterated his whole argument
>>156362400> they make a joke about how Cinderella isn't a real nameThe only thing I need to know. Trash
>>156357694You can just tell from the dogshit ads that this was written by some insufferable Asian American woman
>>156371802This is true really again we've had good subversions like the sequel where they did make the sister redeemed. An she wasn't secretly a good person or the cool bad girl vibe they've been pushing hard. Literally all subversion female villains are now secretly girl boss girls that just aren't typical "submissive female". It's sad as we've had better subversion of this recently in a silly slice of life/comedy anime called "My step sisters aren't that evil" iirc. Watched the first eps not for me but the humor is there basically a new set of characters also showing the whole evil step family is always around/format. Even in other cultures but ironically they call out elements of the trope and joke about "why would I hate you, your our little sister or you aren't responsible for relationship problems with me and my husband" etc. It's a fun little show and it's more just a joke subversion than a full on trying to be cinderella itself seems like it's probably based on a eastern version of the story I probably don't know.
Watched it yesterday>>156374089 is right, the first third of the movie is such a blatant self-insert «this was my childhood as an Asian immigrant» it made even my wife roll her eyes. It’s so heavy handed you can hear the scenarist going AND EVERYBODY CLAPPED during the ball scene.It gets much better after the ball, has a few interesting ideas (the prince, Cinderella’s song, climbing out of the sewers, the dolls, the frog transformation scared my daughter) and a lot of bad ideas (Pris music scene, the trolls, the interracial romance with Gef, and mixed opinions about the godmother)In the end, it’s the bastard child of Shrek and Red Alert.It made for a nice movie for pizza night, but I would rather have the kids ask for KPDH again.
>>156373097I enjoyed it, kinda makes me sad it'll be relegated exclusively to streaming, but oh well. Hopefully it does good numbers at least
>>156369071yes, she ends up with the prince. We see it. There's a whole three-second shot of them standing together at the end, her hand in his, the music swelling, the narrator saying something about happily ever after. Obligation satisfied. The censors can go home. The straights have been fed. Everyone clap.The prince dances with her for maybe ten seconds. The stepsisters get the rest of the night.The show writers knew what they were doing
Just finished it. I didn't like it but it wasn't nearly as bad as I thought it was going to be. The movie is a victim of horrible marketing. The trailer makes it look far more obnoxious than it is. Blatant self insert energy throughout, but that's like going to see Jurassic Park and complaining about seeing dinosaurs. Favorite character was the Butler/Henchman/Dad guy. I like a hyper competent henchman.
>>156374615One of the things I realised after watching this, is that it actually has good male characters.They're decent, compentent and the film doesn't shit on them or belittle them. The henchman even gets the best ending he could have, a happy daughter that loves him. It's a big contrast to how Disney Animation films have been treating them.
>>156357694Did eyeballtank made this?
Movie was okay. Very gay.Why the fairy godmother so ridiculously horny tho?
>>156357694Did anyone see the gay couple that were two guys dancing together in the backdrop of the ball in the film?
>>156374668Yeah, I like that prince wasn't a total dumbass too and was actively suspicious after the ball. He also had the line that made me laugh the most.>The old person's orphanage? But that... doesn't even open until noon!It felt like a classic Simpsons misdirection joke.
>>156374684Kinda hard to miss. There's a shot that lingers on them front and center for several seconds where they're the only characters on screen and the camera actively pans to keep them in focus for longer.
The greatest sin a movie can do is break true love.
>>156366818>JUST
>>156374235This... this feel like a shot like a shot from some weird foreign cgi movie that got Dubbed from some reason. The like old Don Quixote movie that the fat snow white Korean movie
>>156371325They turned Cinderella into some ditzy rich girl that doesn't understand why her step sisters don't like her
>>156357694May god all of you are just fucking horny for the fucking, that's why any of you are defending this shit.Intellectuals my fucking ass, three-quarters of you shouldn't get your opinions out of your mouth.
>>156375906>>156375931Wrong
>>156374725That made me lol too.I didn't hate the movie, it was cute.
>>156371325I feel like if you get rid of the fact that Cinderella was abused by her stepfamily you kinda fundamentally change Cinderella, both the character and the story.But maybe that's just me.Not saying the movie is inherently bad, it seems good from what I've seen, but it does seem pretty removed from the classic Cinderella stuff.Apparently the stepmother barely even plays a role.
I really love the song that plays over the credits https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbr271qnviI
>>156373798It wasn't as snappy and smug as you would think
>>156374922They could've add "as sisters" but decided not to, I'm pretty sure a shot of them kissing during the time travel scene exists within one of the animator's PC but were too afraid to cross that line, also lilith simping for Gef kinda killed the yuri mood.
>>156376759
>born too late to find a rococo style girlI don't need itI don't need itI don't need itI NEEEEEEEEEED IT
I need this guy, carnallyHe needs to whimper and cry while I handle his man tits
>>156378472
>>156378497giwtwm
>>156359833>>156361001>>156361094I wasn't even mad, I just laughed at how these chinese american creators can't help themselves
>>156368044This. I love how she's the perfectly balanced one of the trio but damn do they punish her for it
>>156368119Ironic that a brown guy is saying this
>>156366859Your attitude validates John Kricfalusi seeing Shrek as a blight on popular cultureHe was mentored by Ralph Bakshi, and Bakshi adapted Lord of the Rings, so he was directly influenced by Tolkien’s reverence for fairy talesIronic Tumblr-crafted movies are a desecration of Tolkien’s Catholic values>>156357694This film depicts latinas inserting themselves into the past of white culture and acting smug as if they, themselves, the crew and their artist friends have any new fairy tales to offer (I do)
>>156378612>this is how your asian gf views you
>>156378828Symbolically the non-white girl imagines herself, even in her fantasy, as the step-sister to the white girlWhile the white girl gets a prince she gets a ... trollGiven her acknowledged roll as this intrusion into the white girl's life, she has to defend he concept of the step-sister after she has recognized that this is who she is, and importantly all she ever could be, so her only recourse is to make the step-sister actually the good guy.She resents the white girl because the white girl fails to resuce them after they are kept in a cage. In order to repair this relationship she has to go into the past to release them from this cage.Thus the reason the non-white step sisters claim to hate the white girl is because they were at some point detained by another white girl and she didn't help them.Given that it is impossible to do that they are essentially justifying their hatred of their white step sister in perpetuity.Every time these stories come out it is always some diasporoid psychological grievance."The asian american woman experience" is the bane of all cartoons
>>156378828And here you are, biggest faggot of the whole board
>>156379193awesome scene
>>156378472>>156378497>>156378612Is there a "troll" love interest sub-plot?Because if so, why?
>>156379618white girls get the princesasian girls get the trollswhat's more to get?
>>156379125Upon reflection, given the extremely low bar set for media made for the asian-american woman experience. I actually think this is the best one out of all the media asian women have produced to "speak to their experiences"
>>156363095It't just the dress right?
>>156376759>Model a 3D character based on the singer>She's not in the movieWeird
>>156357694There's something very sadistic about taking the story of an abused poor girl and then having the rich step sister go "No, it's actually about ME!"