[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/fit/ - Fitness

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


Will you be checking if you are obese but the BMI and body fat percentage metrics are misleading you?
>>
File: bmi 1998 verändert.png (32 KB, 949x195)
32 KB PNG
>>77610701
BMI has been faulty since the changes in 1998. Everyone knows this. Nobody really admits it. The bullshit changes continues and by now we're at a point where normal weight is borderline overweight and obvious udnerweight is "healthy".

I still go by the Broca Index, just like the boomer I am: height in cm minus 100 is normal weight. Subtract 10% from that and it's your "ideal" weight. Basically you shouldn't go any lower, ever. That's because it was originally invented for military purposes and that lower limit is the limit they gave for fighting ability. Any lower and you're literally "Victim weight". Or add 10% to your normal weight and get the upper end you should be. And you know, ti checks out prety well if you look at people irl: At the lower limit, a guy is skinny, but still ehalthy-looking. At the upper end, he's definitely "husky", but still looks normal, in shape.

Anyway BMI is bullshit for almost 30 years.
>>
BMI and all metrics are cope. There are two kinds of males.
Men 200lbs and above; these are real men.
"Men" below 200lbs; these are "men" who I could force to "service" me at any point.
>>
>>77610701
I dont care. I love pissing off my fat female coworkers telling them im obese when im way thinner and more muscular than them.
>>
>>77610755
yes, you are gay
>>
that metric? using your eyes
>>
>>77610701
Take off your shirt and use calipers.
>>
BMI is dumb. Take your shirt off. Abs visible? No? You’re fat.
Grab the pull up bar. Can’t even do 10? You’re fat.
It’s literally that easy.
>>
>>77610701
BMI is accurate for 95% of people and 100% of the people who try to avoid it.
Additionally, no matter what body composition you are, part a certain weight it is not good for your heart.
>>
if you got no abs you are fat as fuck and should put down the smoothie
>>
File: IMG_0578.png (390 KB, 840x1024)
390 KB PNG
>>77611543
Pretty much only 12% of men and <5% of women have fat bmi with healthy actual bodyfat
>>
>>77611682
Well I would hope men on a fitness board would be better than 88% of people, considering those 88% probably don't exercise at all.
>>
>>77610701
>Will you be checking if you are obese but the BMI and body fat percentage metrics are misleading you?
my family doctor has had a fancy segmental multi-frequency BIA for ages, which is standard for the yearly check up I do since childhood
and newer also a BOD POD, but that takes a few minutes
admittedly it's a "fancy" private doctor (not public insurance) who's obsessed with longevity research, so they can and want to afford these things

body fat percentage and fat distribution is such a big confounder for many diseases
>>
>>77611727
If you aren't white, you have a higher disease risk at a lower BMI index, especially if you are Asian.
BMI gives you an overall good look, but waist-to-height ratio and body fat % are useful too in context
>>
Fatties have complained about BMI for years and then keep complaining when you suggest alternatives that still class them as fat. They want a system that doesn't call them fat and doesn't tell them they need to change. BMI works fine for most people, bodybuilders and muscular people know what they're doing to seek out the alternatives for themselves.
>>
>>77611749
>If you aren't white, you have a higher disease risk at a lower BMI index
that's because of (missing) muscle mass, not weight / BMI per se
for women there are some interesting correlations (in the weight<->mortality meta study you likely refer to) and it's a lot more complicated

>BMI gives you an overall good look, but waist-to-height ratio and body fat % are useful too in context
waist to height ratio is mostly a proxy for BF% and fat distribution
body fat % generally is more relevant than BMI for most health outcomes

the main problem with BF% is that it's hard to measure accurately and consistently
and the measurement deviations by some methods during the day can be high enough to make it almost useless (like for all BIA methods you ideally measure in the morning after waking up, after peeing, but before eating / drinking, which is hard to replicated for a doctor)
whereas BMI barely moves during the day and all measurement error is within a normal uncertainty margin you have to consider anyway
>>
>>77611828
>that's because of (missing) muscle mass, not weight / BMI per se
True, but some races have a higher visceral fat %, like Asians and Indians, and this lead to higher outcomes of metabolic diseases.
>for women there are some interesting correlations (in the weight<->mortality meta study you likely refer to) and it's a lot more complicated
Care to explain more? I have no idea about it
>the main problem with BF% is that it's hard to measure accurately and consistently
Yeah, BMI and waist-to-height are far simpler for everyone
>>
>>77611837
>Care to explain more? I have no idea about it
motherhood is probably the most relevant one
body composition during pregnancy changes to a higher bodyfat "baseline"
for some that vanishes after the first 2-3years, for others (majority) it stays, even if you control for exercise and diet (aka the will to actually lose that fat), suspected genetic
now, for women
>having 1 up to ~3-4 kids increases their life expectancy (after 5+ kids it decreases slightly)

so in these higher BMI women (keep in mind we're talking about overweight / 25, not obesity / 30 here)
there are perfectly healthy, lower mortality and higher healthspan than the general population, mothers
mixed in with overweight non-mothers that unequivocally have worse health outcomes
in the past, mothers significantly outnumbered non-mothers
so that's why the uncontrolled statics show higher BMI -> healthier

second one is (bad) estrogen regulation
which is suspected as a cause or by-factor for many illnesses
well regulated, overweight doesn't seem to much of an issue (at least much less than with men)
but the probability of derailing it goes up with being heavier
>>
>>77610701
Been trying for years, but there's no way to find out. DEXA gave me only my bone mineral density. Doctors tell me whatever bullshit they think I want to hear and say I'm skinny. The Navy method puts me at 3% bf. BIA at 11-13%. I eyeball it to 22-25%.

BMI 16.3
>>
>>77611994
The navy method has always underestimated my bf% too, if you're slim it's very sensitive to small changes in neck & waist measurements
I think the target group for this regression line is those that are more muscly or chunky to begin with
Also if you don't exercise or move much your fat will accumulate around the middle instead of being distributed around muscle
Your bmi is rather low so according to your fat estimates you're definitely in the skinnyfat range
>>
>>77610701
No, because my BMI is 28 with a waist-to-height ratio of 0.45 and 10% body fat; the new obesity guidelines don't tell you what an optimal body composition is, and I'm fairly close.
>>
>>77611994
You sound like you have an eating disorder. Objectively severely underweight, with body fat measurements placing you a low body fat (even margin of error wouldn't send you into a normal range), yet you think that your bordering on excessive body fat. I bet you're really restrictive in your diet and exercise pretty much everyday plus "getting your steps in" (except you target 15-20k steps). You need food and therapy, things can get better.
>>
File: dawg.png (4 KB, 148x123)
4 KB PNG
>>77611553
It's really this simple
>abs = not fat
>no abs = fat
>>
>>77610701
good
>>
>>77610744
This doesn't take lankaloids into account.
I look like I was meant to be 5'10, but stretched out to 6'2
71kg at around 13% bf, I'd need Tennyson legs to reach the ideal weight and I'm not sure I even could on my lanky bongaloid frame
>>
I don't need equations. The mirror says I'm fat.
>>
Pure cope.
>>
File: 1669131734957791.jpg (248 KB, 900x955)
248 KB JPG
>>77610701
The Nature podcast breakdown of this study said it actually increased the number of participants who were classified as obese. Apparently super-skinnyfats were being missed.
>>
Reminder that it's imposible to not be a fat fuck as a natty if the BMI says you're obesse.
>>
File: 1280.png (161 KB, 1200x1200)
161 KB PNG
>>77610701
>look at a person's body
>see that they have a fat gut
>unhealthy body identified
>no BMI testing required
>>
File: 9619486727331.jpg (151 KB, 937x1171)
151 KB JPG
the worst thing about BMI is that it's too generous in putting people into the normal range, which is the opposite of what normies assume
>>77611481
it's that easy, but fatties cope and claim that they need muh hard proof that they are overweight, as if their rolls and their melted shape weren't good enough indicators
>>
File: images (63).jpg (34 KB, 407x491)
34 KB JPG
>>77614661
>>
>>77614633
Armpit-flab is a good one as well. If its flabby you a fatty and/or dyel.
>>
Length times Girth over Angle of the Shaft divided by mass over WIDTH
>>
>>77614296
assuming 6'2 is 188cm this puts you at a BMI of 20 which is within the low range of healthy weight?
Though some on this board might argue, that you need to lift to post here, but don't let those detractors scare you off.
>>
>>77611514
>Implying calipers are even remotely accurate
>>
File: fnut-10-1173488-g002.jpg (101 KB, 767x512)
101 KB JPG
BMI is epidemiologically assessed. The cutoffs for overweight and underweight were determined by analyzing hazard ratios and all cause mortalities. The minimum risks came from a range of BMIs identified as normal weight. The significant and sharp increase in death rates in the overweight category is identified as obese. Because of the scale at which these studies were conducted, yes it includes all you fat roiders. There will always be exceptions to these norms, however for every person it fails to describe accurately there are 10-20 whom it does describe accurately.

Notwithstanding, obesity is also being assessed through body fat percentage often in addition to BMI. Though it's a moot point for the aforementioned reasons given the strong correlation, that is, that BMI is an exceptionally powerful predictor for body fat percentage. Funnily enough shifting obesity metrics to body fat percentage identifies even MORE people as obese including all the natty lifters with BMI over 30 in addition to many DYELs who have BMIs in the optimal range and even below 17 (I.e., skinny fat).
>>
File: fnut-10-1173488-g003.jpg (64 KB, 767x493)
64 KB JPG
>>77616175
Nearly all obese people by BMI are obese by adiposity measurements.
>>
>>77616175
>>77616179
In the exceptionally rare case someone has low body fat percentage while being obese by BMI, the authors conclude that such individuals are at higher risk of cardiovascular events (heart attacks) and all cause mortality, which is exactly why BMI labels them as obese as an epidemiological category whether it's natural through genes or through steroids.
>The complementary population to NWO individuals comprise those with “metabolically healthy obesity” (MHO), whose BMI at ≥30kg/m2 would classify them as obese, but who display no other elements of metabolic syndrome. Rey-López et al. (36) reported a prevalence of MHO of between 6–74%, depending on different criteria. Longitudinal studies suggest that this phenotype may not be benign and suggest that clinicians should regard MHO as a temporary or intermediary state with the potential for individuals develop a higher risk for increased cardiovascular events and all-cause mortality over time
>>
>>77616179
>5% of underweight or anorexic females are clinically obese
>>
>>77610701
Ultimately BMI is accurate for 90% of the population

Its only really incorrect for athletes with good genetics or guys who have been lifting for like 10 years, pic related - obese BMI but clearly not fat

But for 90% of the population, who don't life for fitness, they're always gonna have a belly if their BMI is over 25, and would benefit from losing weight
>>
>>77616365
>>5% of underweight or anorexic females are clinically obese
No wonder, if you starve yourself and eat like shit afterward, you're going to nuke your muscle mass
Especially with no exercisebitches
>>
>>77616544
Pretty much.
It only doesn't apply to hardcore atheles, roiders or freaks of nature.
If you are none of those 3 and BMI says you're fat then you are fat, stop coping.
>>
>>77616544
>Its only really incorrect for athletes with good genetics or guys who have been lifting for like 10 years, pic related - obese BMI but clearly not fat
Wrong. See
>>77616183
>Longitudinal studies suggest that this phenotype may not be benign and suggest that clinicians should regard MHO as a temporary or intermediary state with the potential for individuals develop a higher risk for increased cardiovascular events and all-cause mortality over time
BMI, the metric designed to predict mortality risk, works even for these obese athletes whose excess mass is lean tissue.
>>
>>77616604
>BMI, the metric designed to predict mortality risk, works even for these obese athletes whose excess mass is lean tissue.
Try explaining...
>Body mass index, waist circumference and the association with all-cause and cause-specific mortality: a 7.2-year follow-up cohort study in Shanghai, China
>https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s12889-025-25147-0
>restricted cubic spline showed a U-shaped association between BMI and overall (lowest mortality risk at 27.4 kg/m2) and CVD mortality (lowest mortality risk at 27.5 kg/m2)
...because BMI lookin' BTFO when "overweight" is really the healthiest instead of the "healthy" range.

I think the real answer is no BMI doesn't "work" very well and you need to autistically track many metrics from waist circumference to bodyfat to bone mass.
>>
>>77616680
>i'm defending obesity by citing a paper saying obesity is unhealthy
lol. lmao. even taking your chinese paper seriously, all it says is one of two things: either medical advances are keeping the large, aging, overweight population alive OR the healthy range of bmi is a little larger than previously determined, likely for the previous reason. most likely BOTH are true. but what is also invariably true is that OBESE BMIS ARE UNHEALTHY REGARDLESS OF IF IT'S LEAN TISSUE. besides, in order to have a narrow waist with obese bmi like you're citing YOU NEED TO BE ON STEROIDS. which itself is unhealthy as fuck.
>>
>>77616680
>>77616706
in addition, that journal has a dogshit impact factor of 4.4. it's chinese slop, and you should be embarrassed to seriously use this garbage to support your wrong, uneducated opinion. then again, you're too fucking stupid to understand how dumb you are.
>>
bmi is already only used as an indicator (in combination with other tools) and not a diagnosis tool...
>>
>>77616706
>>77616712
I'd agree that a 39.9+ BMI is *categorically* unhealthy, but I'm less sure about a 30.1 in light of >>77616680, and research like...
>https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/s13690-026-01920-4
>L-shaped association of skeletal muscle mass with all-cause mortality among US adults: a population-based cohort study
>>
>>77610744
By this metric midgets shouldn't exist so I am all for it.
>>
>>77611686
90% of fit is fat, but picks up a heavything at least once a month or a skeleton who struggles picking up a water bottle.
>>
>>77610701
BMI extremists have conspired to prevent the introduction of the waist-to-height ratio, which is far superior because it doesn't need a scale and just length measuring devices and can also correctly identify skinny fat and otherwise unhealthy people, which BMI fails to do.

Waist to height is far superior, but normies still love BMI because it tells them that they are normal.
>>
BMI was outclassed by body roundness index ages ago, but BRI will never prevail for a number of reasons. Most people know their height and weight off the top of their head, which are a lot harder to fake than a waist measurement, and the math is a lot simpler.
>>
It's not that BMI is outdated
People just got fatter and get very anal when doctors point it out, because according to their [current year] perception, they are normal or just a bit overweight.
The todays normal looking person used to be overweight, the overweight obesse and the obesse hyper obesse.
>>
File: chio puter.png (42 KB, 271x235)
42 KB PNG
Joe Rogan is obese according to BMI
>>
>>77617927
Joe Rogan is obese thobeit
>>
You are either fat or you are not, it is self evident. Fatties will cope any way they can.
>>
>>77617927
>>77617964
Joe Rogan is a grotesque manlet, I thought we were talking about people among which being fat or not might be contentious. Do you want to bring up JD Vance and his BMI while you’re at it too maybe
>>
>>77614296
William yes, there will always be outliers, doesnt mean it doesnt Word Ford most people
>>
>>77617007
These days this board is mostly looksmaxing incel types who have lots of 'theories' about lifting but never, ever actually take part in it.

>>77617110
Is there an official chart or anything for that?

>>77617964
>writes "thobeit"
>is a stupid moron
wow how surprising
>>
File: 7_608207-1905246804.jpg (17 KB, 240x320)
17 KB JPG
>>77611553
I don't get abs even when I get lean. Your metric is stupid and you type like an idiot.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.