[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/fit/ - Fitness

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: IMG_8839.jpg (99 KB, 712x1093)
99 KB JPG
why do people keep claiming seed oils are bad for you when it clearly states on the bottle that it’s good for heart health?
>>
Because being exposed to propaganda via social media influencers is fun and entertaining and reading scientific studies is dull and boring.
>>
>>77623158
You know what's good for your health?
Just not eating so much fucking oil in the first place.
>>
>>77623163
What studies? There was only a single quality study on seed oils and it showed that seed oil are as bad as smoking. It wasn't published for decades because of that.
>>
>>77623158
It's by far the healthiest seed oil with its high omega 3 content. If you're going to use any, you use that one. Fat relards confused it with corn oil which is the cheap shit they fill deep friers with.
>>
>>77623185
There have been hundreds of observational studies showing consistent results.
Inb4 you start crying about epidemiology:
>explain which variable isn't being controlled for that would influence the data of hundreds of thousands of people all over the world all showing consistent results(reminder they control for age, alcohol, smoking, gender, socio encomic, prior incidents, marriage, exercise, diet, BMI)
>explain why zero epidemiological studies have shown seed oils being bad
>explain why every major cardiovascular organization in the world accepts them as quality
>explain why you continue to claim the Minnesota Coronary, Sydney heart study and Lyon heart study as quality despite them having the obvious flaws that have been discussed for decades (secondary prevention trial, hydrogenated margarine, bad follow up times, participants being able to enter and leave at their leisure) and why their results have never been replicated in the 50 years since they have been done.

Hopefully it will save us some time. Tired of you dishonest fucks repeating the same talking points over and over again despite being dunked on every single time. Oh and then please kill yourself.
>>
>>77623206
are you a seed oil salesman? i use evo (high smokepoint) and avocado oil (very high smokepoint) for everything
why are you malding over corn oil nigga lmao
>>
mmm engine oil, i am a big machine, it just makes sense
>>
>>77623158
Because blaming all your shitty life problems on a random grocery store item is easier than blaming the loser in the mirror.
>>
>>77623169
Nobody is eating large amounts of this.
>>
File: 1788844694220075.jpg (75 KB, 767x440)
75 KB JPG
>>77623239
>>
>>77623206
Right now we have an ongoing study with over a billion participants. Half of india is vegan and consume only seed oils, the other half prefers ghee. Guess which half has a lot of viscral fat, high rates of diabetes, severe arterosclerosis, and lives a decade less?
>>
>>77623206
Amd regarding your points
>explain which variable isn't being controlled for that would influence the data of hundreds of thousands of people all over the world all showing consistent results(reminder they control for age, alcohol, smoking, gender, socio encomic, prior incidents, marriage, exercise, diet, BMI)
Please, provide a single such study that isn't a total bs, made for a specific result.
>explain why zero epidemiological studies have shown seed oils being bad
There is o a single quality study on seed oils and it did show that seed oil are as bad as smoking.
>explain why every major cardiovascular organization in the world accepts them as quality
If you look into history of such cardiovascular societies, the first money they got was from crisco, or whatever that company that produced cotton oil was called.
>explain why you continue to claim the Minnesota Coronary, Sydney heart study and Lyon heart study as quality despite them having the obvious flaws that have been discussed for decades (secondary prevention trial, hydrogenated margarine, bad follow up times, participants being able to enter and leave at their leisure) and why their results have never been replicated in the 50 years since they have been done.
Most seed oils are still hydrogenated. They are just allowed to state that it's zero trans fats, even though it isn't. Omg, participants weren't kept in prison... everything you have listed is just a cope
>>
>>77623253
Sneed oil is healthier than beef tallow or butter which have saturated fat, a known cause of diabetes, obesity, stroke, heart disease, etc. in addition to trace toxins like PUFAs
A low fat plant based diet is the only one shown to reverse and cure heart disease.
>>
>>77623257
Then explain why indians who use ghee, instead of seed oils, are doing much better in all tjose metrics, comparing to vegan indians?
>>
>>77623260
>Then explain why indians who use ghee, instead of seed oils, are doing much better in all tjose metrics, comparing to vegan indians?
That study doesn't exist. You've just been mindlessly repeating it as if it did. There are almost no "vegan" indians lmao. There are no "vegan" regions of India. You are a liar and a hack.
>>
File: 1789853657729292.gif (2.66 MB, 200x250)
2.66 MB GIF
>>77623206
wait, so you are pro seed oil? lmao
>>
>>77623260
Source on this? Or is it just another dumbass meme you’re parroting?
>>
>>77623298
India literaly has stats on which region consumes what kind of food. You can look up coconut and ghee regions that sit at 75years, while mustard oil region at 68. Plant oil regions have adult diabetes rates for adukts at about 25%, while ghee regions at about 10%. It's all publickly available data. You can compare regions with the same income if you wish.
>>
>>77623253
>Please, provide a single such study that isn't a total bs, made for a specific result.
That sounds like a subjective thing that you're deciding before I even post a study and "made for a specific results" just sounds like you're going to start spouting conspiracies. But sure we can start with this one: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8048052/
Please look at the confounders controlled for before replying and provide evidence for any schizo conspiracy claims you will likely make.

>If you look into history of such cardiovascular societies, the first money they got was from crisco, or whatever that company that produced cotton oil was called.
There it is. Conspiracies. Yes I'm sure every single one all over the world are all bought out and all of the cardiologists are all in on it as well. I don't know why I bother .

>Most seed oils are still hydrogenated. They are just allowed to state that it's zero trans fats, even though it isn't
Miniscule amounts that are not enough to effect health. They used to be much larger and did impact health.
>Omg, participants weren't kept in prison... everything you have listed is just a cope
Being able to leave and enter a study is a horrible study design. Has nothing to do with where they are living. Trans fats is not a cope, they are proven to cause cardiovascular disease. Being able to leave and enter a study at will is not a cope as the scientists have no idea what they are eating while they are not participating. Secondary prevention trial is not a cope as people who have had previous CVD events are several times more likely to have a second one independent of diet. Bad follow up time is not a cope as CVD can take decades to develop.
What is a cope is saying " hurrrr the American Heart Association was secretly bought out by all of the jews and all of these studies actually have secret agendas to them even though I can't prove it"
>>
>>77623310
But it was and they are. You have to be an imbicile not to see through it.
>>
>>77623257
this dude said FAT causes diabetes LMAO either you are a really bad troll or you are disgustingly misinformed, either way thanks i needed a laugh
>>
>>77623313
Type 2 diabetes is characterized by defects in both insulin secretion and insulin action, and saturated fat appears to impair both. Researchers showed saturated fat ingestion reduces insulin sensitivity within hours, but these were non-diabetics, so their pancreas should have been able to boost insulin secretion to match. But insulin secretion failed to compensate for insulin resistance in subjects who ingested the saturated fat. This implies the saturated fat impaired beta cell function as well, again within just hours after going into our mouth.

So increased consumption of saturated fats has a powerful short- and long-term effect on insulin action, contributing to the dysfunction and death of pancreatic beta cells in diabetes.

And saturated fat isn’t just toxic to the pancreas. The fats, found predominantly in meat and dairy—chicken and cheese are the two main sources in the American diet—are almost universally toxic, whereas the fats found in olives, nuts, and avocados are not. Saturated fat has been found to be particularly toxic to liver cells in the formation of fatty liver disease. You expose human liver cells to plant fat, and nothing happens. Expose liver cells to animal fat, and a third of them die. This may explain why higher intakes of saturated fat and cholesterol are associated with nonalcoholic fatty liver disease.

Saturated fats, independently of any role they have of making us fat, may contribute to the development of insulin resistance and all its clinical consequences. After controlling for weight, and alcohol, and smoking, and exercise, and family history, diabetes incidence was significantly associated with the proportion of saturated fat in our blood.

So what causes diabetes? The consumption of too many calories rich in saturated fats.
https://nutritionfacts.org/video/what-causes-diabetes/
>>
>>77623310
>People with higher circulating linoleic acid often eat more nuts, seeds, vegetables, and home-cooked meals while consuming less fast food, refined carbohydrates, and saturated animal fats.
So I don't use seed oils for cooking at all. Only ghee, butter, coconut oil, depends on what ai'm cooking. But I do eat a lot of nits, penut butter, etc. According to all those studies I would end up in a high linoleic acid group...
So basically all those studies are comparing those who cook their own food and consume a lot of nuts, coconut oil, olive oil, etc. (Which is me), to those who eat a lot of processed foods...
And the conclusion is that a heavily oxidised cooking vegetavle oil is healthy? We are discussibg wheather OP's pic attached is healthy, not nuts and veggies.
I couldn't find a single study that specifically looks up into processed foods and cooking oil. Can you provide me a single one?
>>
>>77623158
I think moderate amounts of whatever oil is fine, the problem is when your entire diet is a few types of oil because companies will use the cheapest oil possible which are only a few types. Just don't eat nothing but processed food that use the same three types of oil and cook with a variety of oils if possible
>>
>>77623318
yeah bro, when you go to the doctor for insulin sensitivity they hand you a LOLlipop
>>
>>77623343
Not an argument. Read the science and get back to me champ.
>>
>>77623348
i dont argue with the disingenuous. you are a clown. you seem to want to convince people that fat somehow creates insulin resistance and i want you to think that honestly, i dont need to convince anyone but you do apparently and i think its funny so please keep going
>>
File: dg-15691301-3.jpg (91 KB, 860x860)
91 KB JPG
>>77623318
health food
>>
File: GbbuCBRbMAA1Ae7.jpg (194 KB, 1210x1572)
194 KB JPG
>>77623158
Omega 6 oils cause higher inflammation than omega 3s. Most cultures used/consumed high Omega 3 fats in the past. High omega 3 fats are superior.
>>
>>77623335
I have no idea where you are quoting that. The study I posted is an observational study of people who eat more seed oils/butter and their outcomes. It's also a replacement study where butter/margarine was replace with vegetable oil and had a decreased all cause mortality risk.

>And the conclusion is that a heavily oxidised cooking vegetavle oil is healthy?
Really depends on what you mean. Store bought canola oil is healthy compared to saturated fat based fats. Yes. Heavily re-heated oils used in frying are not healthy. Nobody is claiming fried food is healthy.

>I couldn't find a single study that specifically looks up into processed foods and cooking oil. Can you provide me a single one?
They included processed food in that study. The food frequency questionnaire(National Cancer Institute (NCI) Diet History Questionnaire) includes processed foods. They mention this in the methods on how they use the CSFII to find the portion sizes. Meaning including processed food the higher vegetable oil individuals still did much better.
https://epi.grants.cancer.gov/dhq3/dhq3-past-month-with-serving-sizes-questionnaire.pdf
>>
>>77623190
>healthiest seed oil
>high omega 3 content
OP picrel is corn oil
>>
>>77623441
Men talking about "inflammation" is the same as dumb women talking about "toxins".
I never had "inflammation" from cooking oil and neither have you.
>>
>>77623245
so some fraction of the 100g of fats is cooking oil.
What's your point?
>>
File: science4chan.jpg (186 KB, 928x1024)
186 KB JPG
>>77623348
>>
>>77623206
ain't reading that shit ai shit nigga. it's over for you, sounds like you chugged a couple hundred gallons of that shit
>>
>>77623257
Jamie pull up them keto studies
>>
>>77623520
This nigga really do be parroting whatever his ai shits out and then with a smug face he's like >come back when you read the science®™ bro
>>
>>77623497
You realize that most "science" being wrong is actually how science works right?

If science was never wrong, we'd still think the plague was caused by miasma, or that women naturally had less teeth than men.
>>
File: 1792224790753420.png (2.09 MB, 1122x1402)
2.09 MB PNG
>>77623158
>linoleic acid stars integrating where there used to be other, more stable fatty acids, and those can auto oxidize and break the literal membrane of the mitochondria. this can render the whole electron transport chain inefficient

now the question is how does one excrete all this from the body
>>
>>77623536
naive take i daresay. it's far worse!
the majority of science that determines which drugs get approved, which treatments become standard, and what doctors prescribe is funded by the ((companies)) that profit from the outcome.
science? no! its about producing a document that makes a predetermined conclusion look like science. then the media, ((((their))) media, covers it as fact and then the public accepts it bc it came from "experts" with funding with credentials with years of experience and research behind it.

"scientism", which people here, on plebdit, and in everyday life constantly engage in, is when you replace ontology with the scientific method and treat the whole thing like a new pseudo-religion. dare to think outside the box, and you're automatically labeled a heretic.

>You realize that most "science" being wrong is actually how science works, right?

there's a good book about this called Human Accomplishment. It makes it clear that the absolute top tier of scientific innovators were all people who challenged deeply entrenched orthodoxies and mainstream scientific consensus.
>>
Nutrition and food science are unserious fields so i'll trust my senses and all seed oils smell and taste like trash. They're supposed to be an odorless tasteless alternative yet they violate all your senses.
Fruit oils like coconut oil and olive oil are the best
>>
>>77623536
Or that seed oils were healthy
>>
>>77623206
>>explain why zero epidemiological studies have shown seed oils being bad
because the studies only used uncooked oil. AKA the use the it's NEVER USED FOR!!
>>
>>77623239
It's literally in every food product you eat. All bread, like hamburger and hot dog buns, all pizzas, tortillas, muffins, and all snacks. It's used in every frozen dinner. It's used in deli meats and all skin-cased meats. and no, i'm not talking, COOKED IN OILS. Basically everything in the super markets besides the meat case and produce section. Salad dressings, canned foods, SOUP, so on and so on.
>>
>>77623158
good for heart health =/= good for body health.
animal fats are liver protecting.
>>
Its the verbose vegan promoting eating engine oil and paint thinner again. Top kek
>>
>>77623163
This. I don't even like seed oils except olive oil, it's the truth.
>>
>>77623741
Bro olives are fruit
>>
>>77623206
If you learn about seeds you'll find that they contain protective poisons in them to prevent bacterial fungus or pests form eating them. On its own a few seeds won't do shit. But if you press tens of thousands of seeds to get a concentrated oil out of them. I imagine that shit accumulates bad stuff.
>>
>>77623520
Yeah AI famously green texts and tells you to kill yourself.

Keep coping your entire ideology is based on social media influencers and memes
>>
>>77623605
See
>>77623452
The FFQ they use include processed and cooked oil.
>>
>>77624401
>I imagine that shit accumulates bad stuff.
Thank god we have human trials that actually show us there isn't a harm and don't have to go off of your imagination.
>>
>>77624564
He is right you're obviously copy pasting whatever ai shits out and then acting smug about it
>>
I don't think seed oils are good or bad for you, I don't think about the healthiness of cooking oils at all to be honest. I believe the amount of oil is a bigger factor anyways. I prefer the taste of olive oil and animal fat like lard so I mainly cook with those. I use avocado and canola as well since they are neutral.
>>
File: 1788601726869961.png (854 KB, 1172x994)
854 KB PNG
>>77623158
I lost weight as soon as I stopped using seed oil and used real butter instead



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.