Does GNU have the right approach here?Should FOSS projects accept contributions made from slavery?
>>110272620already how it works in Japan
On one hand, it would be extremely based.On the other hand, those slaves would probably be jeets, and nobody wants jeet code, so...
I assume this is just a retarded argument against ai that falls apart the moment you point out llms arent humans
>>110272620Sure but US courts have ruled the output of LLMs isn't copyrightable, even by humans. So this analogy isn't exactly right.
>>110272712Yes technically something needs human authorship for it to be eligible for copyright, but what constitutes authorship is incredibly broad.
>>110272620Proprietary software is slavery. I think you are conflating the term "slavery".
>>110272620From GNU's point of view of course the answer must be YES:>Does the code solve a problem? Yes???>Is it correct and working? Yes??>Then we must accept itWhy on earth would they reject perfectly good code on moral grounds?This is why everyone hates extreme leftists. You would rather watch the world burn because slavery is immoral and anything good coming out of it is therefore immoral, therefore should a product of slavery be of good excellence and have the potential to improve anything you must automatically throw it away and say no, you will not take that.
>>110272620Indubitably. Politics has no place in productive work. It's entertainment for the lowest rungs of society, just a clown show. Thus, so long as the work is done in compliance with the law and respecting good technical processes, this is the only correct approach.And yes, I realize that "slavery" here means AI. The problem is that the AI will slop you wholesale-stolen proprietary-code, for example, and of extremely low quality. And absolutely nobody who uses AI, despite claiming otherwise, ever checks the code before hitting send.
>>110272639They are talking about LLMs.
>>110273918Replace jeet with AI and... oh, perfect match!
>>110272620it's just FOSS version of would you buy a pair of Nike if you knew 10 children in Bangladesh died making them in a sweatshop.
>>110272620use case for emancipation?
