[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/g/ - Technology

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.
  • You may highlight syntax and preserve whitespace by using [code] tags.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


Xorg might as well not exist as a dedicated display server. Basically all of what made X11 into what it is has been abstracted to the point of meaninglessness. Mouse input is shared with Wayland through libinput. Keyboard input is shared with Wayland through XKB. Video output is shared with Wayland through DRM. Rasterization is shared with Wayland through EGL. All that remains is a bunch of thin wrapping separating the two.
X11 is already dead, we just don't know it yet.
>>
Wayland is perhaps even more niggerlicious than systemd.
>>
File: blue.png (616 KB, 726x792)
616 KB PNG
>>110361347
gayland
use tinyx,xlibre
fbdev will live forever in embedded
or go deepthroat fagdesktop consortium
>>
>>110361356
Niggerlicious is voodoo
Xorg is voodoo, it's a mudhut skyscraper of engineering
>>
File: cw.jpg (41 KB, 800x450)
41 KB JPG
>>110361928
it just works
>>
for me it's whatever comes with my distro by default (x11)
>>
Wayland and X both suck
>>
>>110361347
You're describing why wayland might as well not exist
>>
Wayland sessions support basic modern features.
>>
>>110361347
Isn't the mouse (cursor) support on Wayland still much worse due to a stupid design that can't be changed?
>>
>>110361347
Wayland has mandatory compositing, x11 does not.
>>
X11 is trash engineering-wise and kwin-wayland already outperforms anything X11 ever had. More than half the people shitting on Wayland probably are clinging to their autismo WMs. Wayland isn't perfect but it's poised to be faster and much simpler
>>
>>110361356
Because it just works?
>>110361938
Except for sometimes.
>>
>>110362842
It can't be "faster" because of compositing and it can't be "simpler" because its design that enforces diversification and fragmentation.
>>
what is window maker
>>
>>110362878

You don't want compositing? What year is this? There's a protocol for toggling VSYNC. You can still run like embedded stuff straight on DRM/KMS for those cases.

Fragmentation, yes, but that will be solved with a library a bit more generic than wlroots. Right now it's 95% (wlroots, kde, gnome)
>>
File: 1788024010252897.png (61 KB, 475x382)
61 KB PNG
>>110361347
ok but im still using it hehe
>>
>>110362842
Why should I switch WMs for some nebulous bullshit?
>>
>>110362909
>You don't want compositing?
No
>>
>>110362935
WMs are for people new to Linux, or tistics
>>
>>110362909
I don't care about compositing. I would rather not have it. I don't want some zesty program going transparent or whatever other stupid shit compositing enables.
>>110362947
Yes, I'm autistic.
>>
>>110362963
>Yes, I'm autistic.
Might want to get some meds for that, buddy.
>>
>>110362974
No thanks. My WM soothes my soul however.
>>
>>110362982
You realize autism is a disorder, right? It's not a "difference", it's a problem.
>>
>>110362992
So what?
>>
>>110362799
At this point just reverse engineer WDDM
>>
>I want tearing
lmfao
>>
>>110365249
Its not about the tearing its about the latency. vsync = lag
>>
File: 9k=.jpg (119 KB, 500x500)
119 KB JPG
>>110361347
x11 is a network centric desktop bus enabling personal distributed computing
>>
File: do-nothing-group.jpg (2.86 MB, 2752x1536)
2.86 MB JPG
>>110362842
>clinging to their autismo WMs
wndow management policy belongs in specialized daemons the users write in their snowflake languages
>>
Wayland has been "replacing" X11 for 15 years now. In that time they could have done a full code audit of X11 and bring it up to scratch and had a decade to spare.
>>
>>110366324
No tearing is better than tearing on your desktop. There is no scenario on your desktop where a buffered frame is meaningfully affecting your usage unlike tearing.
This isn't anything to do with x11 or Wayland either.
>>
>>110361347
You know that AI is dying because we are going back to Wayland vs X slapfights.
>>
On wayland if 1 of your program runs at 3fps your whole desktop runs at 3fps
>>
>>110366473
When I click my mouse of type a letter on my keyboard I don't want the computer waiting around to draw it sometime later. I want it on the screen as soon as possible. Compositing is an abomination, if my application executes a drawing command in response to my input I want that drawing command executed immediately. Vsync something an application should ask for, not something forced upon it.
>>
>>110361938
This.
I'll switch to Wayland when everything just works no matter which WM I'm using.
>>
>>110362842
Go open Libreoffice or Kicad in Wayland. It's fucking unusable.

It's designed for running Android apps and nothing else.
>>
>>110362842
Test Wayland vs Xorg on a 20 year old laptop and your "Wayland is faster" lie falls apart immediately. You need absurd levels of parallel compute power run Wayland.
>>
>>110366555
>uses 20 year old laptop
You need help
>>
>>110366587
>it's not slow buy a new computer
>>
>>110366555
I think Gnome used to be slower on Wayland if that is your benchmark.
>>
>>110366521
You aren't affected by a buffered frames worth of latency when using your desktop. There are zero tasks in existence where this is impacting you in any humanly observable way.
Tearing however is immediately perceptible and isn't beneficial to anyone.
If you can think of some scenarios you're welcome to demonstrate it.
>>
>>110362909
> You don't want compositing?
Exactly.
> What year is this?
2026. Compositing is still useless eye-candy, yes.
> There's a protocol for toggling VSYNC.
Tearfree in xorg.conf. Bye.
>>
>>110366973
>Tearfree in xorg.conf. Bye.
Mom cancel my meetings.
>>
>>110361347
What you are describing sounds more like wayland issue than xorg issue.
>>
>>110362799
use xorg until arcan is ready (two more years)
>>
>>110366383
>Wayland has been "replacing" X11 for 15 years now.
18 years, so actually it’s closer to 20 years failing to do so
>>110366383
>There is no scenario on your desktop where a buffered frame is meaningfully affecting your usage unlike tearing.
you say that because you never need your latency to be lower
>>110366777
>You aren't affected by a buffered frames worth of latency when using your desktop.
you aren’t me so you don’t know that
and I don’t need to justify what I want my computer to do
MY COMPUTER SHOULD DO WHAT I WANT AND I DONT WANT IT TO COMPOSITE ANYTHING PERIOD
X allows me to control my computer the way I want
Wayland does not
>Tearing however is immediately perceptible and isn't beneficial to anyone.
LMAO go play some FPS games unc
anything that benefits from faster output benefits from tearing, because tearing means having the image displayed to you at the same time it’s being drawn
>>
>>110367090
>you aren’t me so you don’t know that
Post some results from human benchmark and demonstrate that to me.
>LMAO go play some FPS games unc
You can play games with complete frames without tearing and buffering frames you tech illiterate retard.
>>If you can think of some scenarios you're welcome to demonstrate it.
I explicitly asked you for some examples where having buffered frames on a desktop has some perceptible impact and you couldn't think of a single one.
You may now continue your spergout.
>>
>MOOM CANCEL MY MEETINGS
>XORG BROKE AGAIN
>IN THE END IT DOESNT EVEN MATTER
>>
>>110362799
wayland is 18 years old, we need to start from scratch
>>
>>110362799
Mir
>>
110367153
110367024
samefag making shit up like a trans woman from india
>>
>>110362842
X11 without a compositor is still smoother than any wayland compositor, even in fullscreen games
>>
>>110365249
The xorg server enabled TearFree option by default 4 years ago
>>
>>110371336
There is zero difference between Xorg and Gamescope from all the testing I have done. All other Wayland compositors do have flaws, though.
>>
>>110361347
When Wayland can restore windows where I left them in the previous (right screen and position), which X has been able to do for at least 10 years, I'll consider switching
>>
>>110372293
>There is zero difference between Xorg and Gamescope from all the testing I have done.
Proof?
Also isn't gamescope just DRM/KMS, that doesn't use Wayland at all. In theory it has lower latency than Wayland and X11.
>>
>>110367153
>*mpc still playing linking_park.flac in console because it doesn't need graphics*
>>
>>110372564
this one is so fucking annoying, holy shit
>>
>>110366479
Fucking finally
>>
>>110361356
fpbp
>>110361900
Unfortunately Xlibre has failed. The Tango-Artix debacle was the final nail in the coffin.
I'm setting my sights on Phoenix. His only mistake so far is being autistic enough to host the code on a personal cgit instance.
https://git.dec05eba.com/phoenix/about/
>>
>>110361928
>implying wayland isn't voodoo despite being fully dependent in freedesktop's garbage software and systemd to properly work
>>
>>110373505
what about
https://github.com/joske/yserver
>>
>>110371347
TearFree and Wayland both flip on vblank. There is no difference.
>>
>>110361347
yep. it's just inferior wayland at this point.
why waste the indirection?
>>
>>110376074
Yep, thats what im saying.
>>
>>110372600
>Proof?
I have a Pixel 8 that can record 240 FPS and accurately measure latency from mouse click to photons.
>that doesn't use Wayland at all
You can force Wayland, but it uses XWayland by default.
>>
>>110373505
>The Tango-Artix debacle was the final nail in the coffin.
I didn't even know Artix existed until that happened.
>>
>>110378258
Which shit hole is this?
>>
>>110378357
That's a weird way to say SOVL.
>>
>>110378393
>>110378357
But to answer your question, it's a country in the Mediterranean with a blue and white flag whose people historically underwent a genocide that is estimated to reach a kill count of 7 digits.
>>
literally developed by the same niggas
stop with the retarded tribalism
>>
>>110362842
> outperforms
It’s the opposite. Wayland doesn’t outperform anything.
>>
>>110378258
Vgh... Soul
>>
>>110361347
having switched to wayland a year ago, it's much better for my gaymen. however, i'm still incredibly disappointed in how (((freedesktop))) deliberately held back development in favor of wayland in an attempt to silently kill Xorg off. for people that need it and want to keep supporting Xorg, I think Y Server and XLibre are great projects. I may even switch back someday depending on how some of the modernized rewrites go.
>>
>>110378913
> much better for my gaymen
You’re not a gamer. You’re also illiterate.
What does “better” mean? Both wayland and X11 expose rectangular areas on the screen which GPUs use to display graphics. Wayland does no compositing here and is unaware and uninvolved in this process. Just like X11.
>>
>>110375840
Honestly my kneejerk reaction would be to spit on this garbage but if it promotes alternative X11 implementations I'm all for it.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.