Why did people hate on the AM3 era and FX Series processors so much?
because they were bad
"8" coresits really 4 cores
>"cores" sharing an fpuoh no no no no
the people are retarded
>>110373944>power hungry>slow """cores""">most programs used at most 2 coresterrible back then, still terrible nowenjoy modern celeron's performance at 200W
>>110373944Not as bad as charts and people say, because DIY barely exist anymore so history get revised. There was a lot of performance to be had when tuned, some of them had hit some ridiculous frequencies. Can't remember exactly which one, but there was one FX that aged better if not equally well to the 4790K.That being said, power efficiency is really important. There isn't really any use case where you don't care about high idle power usage, unless you're running some service that is constantly uses compute. Intels low idle efficiency then becomes the ultimate futureproofing because it goes into your homelab hobby. Once you get to the wake on lan, it gets too indepth for people to matter.
>>110373952fpbpThey fucking sucked, period. They weren't "ahead of times" or whatever bullshit some shills try to push. It was an inherently flawed architecture and to add insult to injury it was built on hilariously bad silicon node.
>>110373944Some guys from DEC were thinking about that CMT design instead of EV8 and for some reason AMD actually built it 8 years laterOdd fluke of history, really
>>110373944Back then its only redeeming features were lower price and high core counts >inb4 b-but muh FPU, however back then all software and desktop operating systems were designed to work on 1, or at most 2 cores so software running on them was slower than Intel's equivalents. However nowadays all serious software use as many cores as possible by default, and operating systems' schedulers now know how to effectively handle CPUs with multiple or weirdo cores, so AMD FX-9590 would have been more viable today than its Intel contemporaries.To put it another way, it was way ahead of its time, but mostly by accident because AMD CPUs were shit before the Zen days, and putting tons of semi-neutered cores was the only way they could find to compete with Intel's offerings.
>>110375895>muh ahead of its time>muh better than comtenporariesAhh, classics. Both completely untrue, I don't even get these attempts at revisionism just to convince a person or two that complete and utter garbage in all measurable aspects was not complete and utter garbage somehow.
because they were shit and nearly bankrupted the company lol you think the people that work on ryzen and saved AMD think those chips were good at all LMAOOOOOOonly fucking poorfags retards on /g/ even talk about this ewaste
One guys amd pc kept overheating an shutting down at a lan match so they had a shit reputation around most parts for a while
No-one wanted to "upgrade" to a more expensive CPU that ran programs slower than the previous generation. The FX processors had more cores and ran much cooler than the previous AMD ones, but single-core performance was the issue. My memory is probably exhaggerating how bad it was back then but the FX-processors were basically for office PC's in stead of for gamers. The previous generation was Phenom II and they were beautiful, still the gold standard in my mind. What I remember is that the AMD Phenom 2's were really good but probably hit the limits on what could be achieved with the architecture. I say this because you needed a massive cooler just to keep the PC running, not to have a quiet PC like people do now. They could pull 150W under load and barely consume less when idling. But the AMD Phenom II X3 was awesome. The original i7-920 was already available and much more powerful but you didn't need anything that good to play video games. The meta at the time was to get a Phenom II processor and sink the money you saved into a better graphics card.
Overclocking was a normal thing to try and a normal thing for a mobo bios to support. And you could unlock extra cores if you were lucky. They didn't restrict this, it was a different time. CPUs come out of the fab and too many of them end up as 6-core chips to sell? Disable some cores, sell as a dual-core or whatever. So a consumer buying a dual-core could potentially have a quad-core if they were willing to experiment. This is the context that tell you why the FX-processors sucked and the reason they sucked is that the new product was worse than the old product. They just used lots less power and had more cores. But even now the performance of most programs rests on the single-core performance and having enough ram.AMD had obviously hit the limits with regard to power consumption so they couldn't release an even faster Phenom II. They were done. It's a shame their newer product wasn't yet better than Phenom II. I just asked in a prompt and the fastest Phenom II came out in 2011 and only in 2014 the FX chips were 10%-15% faster. Trump was probably already in office before AMD made anything worth upgrading to from Phenom II but all this time if you wanted to upgrade you would just upgrade to Intel and stay put. A sad fate for AM3.I've found another reason to hate the FX chips: That Intel didn't need to innovate and we didn't see anything interesting for 10 years. Intel even switched to cheaper heat spreaders so the thermals became worse starting at the 3000-series. Apple users obviously also screwed and all their macbooks/imacs overheating, but I digress. The end.
>>110376179I'm glad someone corrects this. FX chips were so bad and most programs still run on single-core performance (and having enough ram)
>>110379348they did because at that time most software was made for intel. the AMD fine wine comes from shit like these where most amd processors, specially fx3850 were getting better and better with time due improvements on multiprocessor based software. also 1st gen fx is really bad compared to 2nd gen which mostly had the heat issue.
>>110373944I'm not a mindreader, of all things to hate a CPU would be way down on my list. AMD has always been the budget alternative so probably that, we'd call it jeetcoded today if it wasn't also extremely competitive
It kept me warm at night
AMD FX CPUs handled SCPU voltage differently from the start, and they vary their clock speed and voltage much, much more than the Phenom II, Phenom I, or Nehalem-Westmere, which were already far more advanced in terms of technology and parallelism back then than AMD’s new offerings. The FX was designed around 2006, though I assume the concept was started as early as late 2005, and it was actually intended to be a processor for FX servers. It had many cores that could fit into a small space and relatively few manufacturing defects, making it worth producing. Fast forward a bit: AMD was stunned by the ATI acquisition, and by the time they realized that Intel was actually keeping pace with the aforementioned architectures after the Core 2 and, more importantly, that AMD would only be lagging behind Intel with the Phenom (I and II), so, working with a tight budget, they revisited the Bulldozer cores and drew on their experience with the Phenom II: the higher the clock speed, the more instructions, the lower the heat generation, and power consumption should be either extremely low or high and this should be adjustable depending on clock speed and voltage. Everything the Phenom simply couldn’t do at that point.
Also everyone here seems to forget that GloFo originally promised 2 trillion transistors at 32 nm, which ultimately didn’t happen; THAT’S WHY they had to cut back on the FPU, since along with the instruction sets it takes up the most space in a CPU. That’s why they pushed the clock speed so high. Originally, the FX series was indeed supposed to peak at around 4 GHz, but not because the architecture was particularly well-suited to that speed. IN THAT CASE, the FX8350 would have been the top-of-the-line model, a position now held by the FX9590 in terms of clock speed. When they realized the problem, AMD’s blunder was more that it failed to regulate the motherboard manufacturers. Crap 4+1-phase motherboards were released with top-of-the-line chipsets, which obviously couldn’t handle the FX’s frequent clock and voltage fluctuations (as I mentioned at the beginning) and thus easily overheated -> throttling. Many people on a tight budget who wanted a “NASA-grade” computer didn’t understand why it wasn’t a good idea to cool the world’s worst motherboard with a heatsink the size of an Asian woman’s fist. By the way, around 2014, the FX processors were already performing on par with a locked 3770, or in the worst case, a 2600 or 2500, depending on how well the game was optimized. Before the Intel shills jump in, I’m using an ASUS ROG MAXIMUS V FORMULA with an i7-2600K running at 4.5 GHz, and a 2017 FX-8350 in a Sabertooth 990FX.
if you look at Zen 5, it also has two independent decoders sharing a single FPUbut 0. that FPU is much, much better1. they also share integer scheduling and execution2. they correctly only call it a single core
>>110373944I ran an overclocked FX-6100 on the stock cooler for about 4 years. No idea how it never melted itself. Did a great job for what it was.
>>110373944huge benchmark disappointmentsmobos without heatsinks that overheated vrm'samd misleading about number of cores
>>110380004you were indeed very lucky or you accidentally had the APM on. (TDP limiter), or even, you had luck with voltages. One thing also to be mentioned, the Bulldozer (v1 design FX) CPUs were actually "colder" than the Vishera (v2 design on BD) CPUs, ironically the BD used more pw consumption while the Vishera used less but it was hotter.
>>110373944Cause the Phenom II mogged it in every way.
>>110380337I moved from a 955BE to a fx8350. it was a big improvement to me.
>>110380337lying nigger.
>>110380337this>>110380413unless you were very poor and had to use it till extra instruction set mattered, you would've had better time with phenom 2 x6
>>110380548a lot of problems I had were because of instructions. the fx8350 is still doing fine. I was about to move so something new but AI fucked my budget. I got a faster laptop with 64gb of before that. I'll just wait. Is not like a need a faster pc anyway. all I do i browse internet, code, draw and All fighting games run fine.
>>110380548X6 consumed more, it was overall slower than the fx8350 and it was much pricier than the fx whil being 5-10% better in single core. it just didnt worth it. Those who already owned one, they didnt needed to switch ofc
>>110380632I got 960t for 100$ new in december 2011, unlocked it to 6 cores and overclocked to 4ghz. Dunno how real x6 was priced but there is no way it was more expensive than fx.I bought a good mobo expecting to get a big upgrade down the line...
In the end they did beat i5-2500K in gaming too when multithreading became a thing.
>>110373944Reporting in.