[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


Why didn't he just stopped after annexing the Sudetenland?

He was already the most popular politician in the world. Germans fucking worshipped him and the rest of the world feared and respected him.

He could have stayed in power until he was 80 and just enjoyed life, luxury and an obscenely high status. Was he a victim of his own ideological obsessions?
>>
>>18541464
Gaydolf Shekelgrabber was a British spy working for international Rothschild capitalists
>>
>>18541464
>Why did an expansionist imperialist who wanted autarky do expansionist imperialist things
I wish there was a way to filter posts below a certain IQ
>>
>>18541464
He was universally hated outside of Germany and his country was on track to be a North Korea pariah state if he didn't rapidly expand. Also, he just really hated Poles and wanted to genocide them
>>
File: 1643112726089.jpg (642 KB, 817x4829)
642 KB JPG
>>18541484
>Also, he just really hated Poles and wanted to genocide them
Wrong
>>
>>18541464
>He could have stayed in power until he was 80 and just enjoyed life
False. By 1945 Hitler had developed a (then) incurable heart diseseas. His days were numbered regardless of the outcome of the war.
>>
>>18541464
He was the Great Deceiver, an avatar of the Prince of Darkness. Spreading great evil and suffering was always his design
>>
File: 433485394851.png (385 KB, 1381x1071)
385 KB PNG
>>18541497
Nazis considered Poles 'untermensch,' same as Russians
>>
>>18541464
>Why didn't he just stopped after annexing the Sudetenland?
Because you can't just watch a country burn into flames, when it descends into a civil war. Any Great Power would intervene. Germany just acted like any other Great Power.

>He was already the most popular politician in the world. Germans fucking worshipped him and the rest of the world feared and respected him.
The rest of the world barely understood the German mindset. The British always kept offering the Germans to just "lol, why do you care about Poland? we will give you back all of your Colonies on a trust system, if you just let them genocide your people" lmao
Any kind of understanding with them is impossible, since they had no interesting in understanding Germany.

>He could have stayed in power until he was 80 and just enjoyed life, luxury and an obscenely high status. Was he a victim of his own ideological obsessions?
He had a terminal heart disease and knew he would never reach such an old age and die either in the 1950s or at the latest in the 1960s.
>>
>>18541502
>man who has to endure the stress of fighting a war, develops health complications
No shit, but there is no proof he would have gotten that disease in comfortable peace times
>>
>>18541514
Its genetic.
>>
>>18541464
He was doing God's work by sending Satan's synagogue to hell, involuntarily expelling jews to the middle east, and turning europe into a white ethnostate so that the children of God would enjoy another thousand year reign.

Sadly he was opposed by retarded people and now we all suffer the consequences
>>
>>18541464
He explicitly lays out in his book that germany needs to become a continent sized country by conquering Poland and Russia, exterminating its inhabitants, and repopulating those lands with Germans. He saw this as the only way to avoid the British Empire from starving Germany out like happened in WW1. So the goal was never just "taking back what's really ours" but about creating a new empire.
>>
>>18541513
>He had a terminal heart disease and knew he would never reach such an old age
False. Hitler was unaware of his condition.
It was something that historians with the help of modern medical experts were able to identify
>>
>>18541522
That's false.
>>
>>18541513
>Because you can't just watch a country burn into flames, when it descends into a civil war
This is true. It's strange people don't understand the German ultimatum to Hacha was due to Czechoslovakia literally collapsing
>>
>>18541518
>Sadly he was opposed by retarded people
Not retarded, just ruled by Jews.
>>
>>18541503
Even if what you say was true and his blunder intentional. A facsimile of purity is purity itself, it doesn't change the validity of the ideals he espoused.
>>
File: ww2.png (1.23 MB, 1024x1024)
1.23 MB PNG
>>18541464
He had a greater calling.
>>
>>18541516
Do genetic diseases usually take until your 50s to manifest
>>
>>18541567
Yes.
>>
>>18541464
poland was genocding over 6 million germans o algo. check out this bitchute video for the truth they don't teach you in jewish schools
>>
Like with most big wars, the leaders of the time (Hitler and his goons) believed that their enemies weren't REALLY willing to fight them, or that they would give up once it became clear that Germany was serious, and accept terms extremely favorable to Germany. This has happened hundreds of times. By the time they realized that the British and Americans were sick of their shit and that the Russians wouldn't just collapse immediately, it was already too late, and everyone was set on war.
>>
>>18541508
the NSDAP was a big party. Is this based on a specific document?
>>
>>18541464
He wanted to invade the east
That was his political goal
>>
>>18541464
they thought a decisive european war would come sooner or later. I think that's probably right. However it maybe wasn't necessary for Germany to fight western Europe. A smart leader with a bit of luck could have went to war against the Soviet Union with support from the west
>>
>>18541583
Germany was strong enough that nobody wanted to fight them, but they mistook this to mean that nobody could defeat them. They could defeat Germany, it was just a price nobody wanted to have to pay. Reluctance to go to war is so often mistaken for weakness in chauvinistic cultures.
>>
>>18541920
He didn't want war with the west, It was Britain who declared war on them. This is reflected in that he made multiple appeals for peace during the war to them, and before invading poland he made various attempts to diplomatically settle the alleged issue with danzig by consulting those who oversaw free danzig after negotiations with poland fell through. Also more minorly, prior to their declaration in his speeches he called the notion foolish and misled. Obviusly one can argue that he brought it upon himself, but the point of this is that there was no way Western Europe would support his expanse into Eastern Europe because their opposotion of such was the entire implicit basis for war being declared.
>>
>>18541910
Except there is no evidence for this and historians usually spit on those who blindly reference Mein Kampf as an answer to everything without actually anazlysing what was said and done once Hitler came to power.
Nelson Mandela was a stone cold communist that wrote lots of revolutionary stuff but once he became head of state he become much more moderate.
There is no proof that Hitler had "always planned" to go east. Your first burden is the fact that no plans to invade Poland ever existed until 1939 when negotiations failed. If the plan was "always" to go east as you say, then why hadnt a plan been carefully tailored over the years instead of drawn up on a whim based on reactionary circumstances?
>>
>>18541521
Can you post the page where he said that?
>>
>>18542034
>said that he wants to invade east
>writes a book about invading east
>invades east
idk those are some solid evidences mate
>>
>>18542034
The plan was to invade Russia, not necessarily Poland. This is geographically unintuitive but Germany did hope to come to an arrangement with Poland and ally with them against Russia.
>>
>>18542345
Nah, they never seriously considered them as allies. Their land is too close and too similar to Germany to be left alone.
>>
>>18542370
They very much did and expected Poland to accept the corridor demands, Russia would provide so much living space that there is no need to colonise Poland in the near future
>>
>>18541464
Ignore the meme answers. Here are the three mayor reasons:

1. Consolidation of power within the german army:
After the night of the long knives a majority of officer corps representing the old elites was extemly anti Hitler. Von Schleichers assasination wasnt popular among his friends and colleagues while successfully restoring Prussia (by destroying poland) was.

2. Economic reasons
In 1939 the german empire was broke, had no more international credit, a huge trade gap and a very expensive welfare state. Invading poland was the first step of the nazis raid through europe. The fist thing they went for were the gold reserves of the occupied countries. Local elites were often compensated with formerly jewish property

3. Ideology
Hitler belived existence was a permanent mortal combat and that war was only natural and inevitable. That germany had to rule or perish, no in between. Chose by fate to fight
>>
File: images.jpg (14 KB, 258x195)
14 KB JPG
>>18542394
Russia was supposed to be a colony which would provide slaves and endless ressources. Poland was supposed to become a part of Germany directly, expanding the homeland.

Stop being retarded, retard. Sure, if Poland bended over backwards, they would have been genocided slower. Maybe even kept as pets for a while. Long term nothing would have changed.
>>
>>18542277
Except most of his reasoning for invading east were reactionary to unfolding events so again, historians spit on those who blindly cites Mein Kampf because it only reinforces the "madman Hitler" myth without actually properly respect ww2 as it was. How things happened and why it happened.
>>
>>18542418
>Poland was supposed to become a part of Germany directly, expanding the homeland.
There isn't any reference to this intention before 1939, it was an ad hoc decision made based on the circumstances.
>>
>>18542425
If Germans really liked Poland so much, why didn't Poland try to get closer to them instead of anglos?
>>
>>18542438
They didn't particularly like them, Poland liked them even less
>>
>>18542438
Germany never liked Poland but Germany never had plans on destroying Poland from the very beginning.
One thing does not exclude the other so stop trying to pretend like there is some sort of syntax error.
>>
>>18541464
Because Lithuania illegally invaded and annexed Memelland?
>>
>>18542424
eactionary to unfolding events like gaytler taking power and wanting to invade the east
>>
>>18542578
The main point is that Britain and France did nothing when Lithuania seized Klaipeda, so it gave Germany the incentive that "if they can do it, why cant we?". After all, Klaipeda had a substantial German population (ethnic majority in the city itself).
When Germany annexed Klaipeda, the allies likewise did nothing, and this after all came mere days after Germany had seized the rest of the Czech state, which had previously caused outrage in Britain. The bottom line seems to be that if war was going to start somewhere, it certainly wasnt going to be over Memel.
>>
>>18542615
Are you here to debate history or just to shitpost?
>>
>>18542626
you are the one who shitposts tho, im stating the truth
>>
>>18542453
Taylor is a German shill. He is incredibly biased. Poland would either join Germany as its ally (more like a vassal really) or would be conquered. There were no other options. And Poland was too proud to do the first.
>>
>>18542644
Then explain why not a single draft or even a word of invading Poland existed until spring 1939?
If war was so determinstic to Hitler, why wasnt a plan crafted well in advance instead of on a whim under a very narrow time frame. The Germans were trying to negotiate with Poland to be on their playing field, it wasnt until the Poles said no (also after the British guarantee albeit Hitler had exptress desires for a campaign a month before that)?

>>18542647
Nothing wrong with Taylor and many prominent ww2 historians often cite him as their inspiration, such as Richard Overy.
And yes, Taylors argument was that Germany wanted Poland in leauge with them like Slovakia and Hungary for the intention of creating a German-dominated hegemony. When the Poles refused Hitler instead opted to reduce Poland to a puppet state like Czechia. They were going to fall into line, one way or another. The situation very much mirrors Russias relations with Ukraine which started, and ended, roughly the same way.
>>
>>18542681
>why not a single draft or even a word of invading Poland existed until spring 1939?
I think it's because you need to bulid an army to invade other countries first
>>
>>18542736
And invasion plans cannot be drafted simultaniously with rearmament?
Not to mention they had over a year after completion of rearmament when no draft or word or any plans at all being mapped out.

Why do you maintain your position when you yourself realise that it is difficult to defend? Why dont you listen to what historians say about this instead of stomping on your normie myth that ww2 was just one-dimensional?
>>
>>18542759
what's the point in drafting detailed invasion plans when the war itself is still years away? situation can change, new units will be formed, you might be braindead or just coping super hard, propb both
>>
>>18541482
>expansionist imperialist
Define this without including every other power in WWII
>>
>>18541484
He was on time magazine. Walt Disney attended pro-Hitler rallies in America.
Ford and Coca Cola redoubled their investments in Germany.
>Hitler was propped up by international capital
>also he was hated internationally by capitalist countries
Which way bunkertroon?

>wanted to genocide poles
So why didnt he?
He had a ton of ethnic Poles in Germany before 1939, why not start with them?
When Poland was under total axis control for the entirety of 1942, why didn’t he kill 100% of Poles, like Poles removed 100% of Germans?
>>
>>18542438
You didn’t address his statement.
You are peddling another black legend. You are wrong
>>
>>18542736
They had an army you retard. Compared to Poland their greatest strength was immediately after re-nationalizing Skoda in 1938.
>>
File: maxresdefault3.jpg (99 KB, 1280x720)
99 KB JPG
>>18541464
swarthy germs were envious of blonde-haired Polish Bvlls for being more White than them
>>
>>18542793
1939*
>>18542763
>what’s the point
They had invasion plans of France and Belgium 30 fucking years prior to the war with France and Belgium LOOOOOL
if the invasion wasn’t drawn up until months before it occurred, it is provably not a long term plan.

Potatoheaded pig faced polish morons will claim “DA WORLD IS CONSPIRING AGIANST US KURWAAAH WAHHH” but polish foreign policy was completely irrational and insane.
You’re surrounded by two hostile revisionist powers, your sole “ally” cannot physically reach you, and your first instinct is to piss off everyone of your neighbors by invading Czechoslovakia, fucking with Romania, fucking with Hungary, fucking Lithuania, and then snubbing your nose at the two military giants whom you share the other 90% of your border with.
Poles are fucking morons.
Sorry you had to hear it from me. A race that stupid doesn’t deserve to live.
>>
>>18542793
>They had an army you retard
which was smaller than Poland's pre 1938
>>18542800
>incoherent angry rambling
im sorry that your vermin nation got raped in 1945 and had to hand over 1/3 of their country to Polish Chads
>>
File: 1773291947464884.png (333 KB, 925x718)
333 KB PNG
>>18541464
For Polish Gods, it's the white man burden to colonise and bring order to the swarthy germutts lands
>>
>>18541464
He wanted Germany to be food and energy independent (remember WWI) and establish it as a power bloc that could compete with the other world empires. One required the other. He believed that it would be their only chance before the power balance shifted out of their favor.
>>
The German cannot stop wanting to destroy Europe. It's like asking the eagle to stop flying.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.