[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Ali_Sistani_edit1.jpg (585 KB, 1000x1327)
585 KB JPG
It's time to wake up and smell the coffee.

If the Shias are "real Muslims" and Shia Islam is based then why are all the "ex-Muslims" Iranian Shia and not Wahhabi Sunni?

Why do the Shia have no explanation for this?

>"everyone is free to do what he wants bro, We Shia don't care about apostates, we are not headchoppers"

So in that case then how can you claim Shia is "true Islam" if it's shedding adherents by the thousands each year? Obviously the Iranians themselves are not convinced that your religion is true if they are prepared to drop it for a green card or to get residency in the West.

Furthermore, the Shi'ites are even abandoning it in their homeland. The vast majority of those Iranians IN Iran are atheists and Zoriastrians and Christians. That's why your Shia temples are closed down and burned down by the Iranians themselves.

So this is a fundamental problem for Shias and not for Wahhabis. The Wahhabis have full conviction and full confidence that the truth is with them while the Shi'ites drop out of their version of Islam by the hundreds of thousands every single year.
>>
>>18548253
>The vast majority of those Iranians IN Iran are atheists and Zoriastrians and Christians
Holy based. I welcome our Iranian Christian brothers.
>>
>>18548253
By that logic Mormonism would be the true Christianity.
>>
>>18548254
>I welcome our Iranian Christian brothers.
In that case. Hallo, my name iz Ranjeet Poopmishra. Me from the slums of Delhi. I lov Christ, now let me pregnant ur wife, daughter and sister or I'll leavings this bloody bastard faith!
>>
File: Aryan islamists.jpg (81 KB, 686x386)
81 KB JPG
>>18548253
>Shiite pilgrimage: 20 Millions
>Sunni pilgrimage(90% of Muslims): barely 2 Millions
If these Indian-Euro persian fags are more smart open minded and less inbred than Turks and Arabs like these so-called ex-Muzzies claim why are they more Fanatical?
>>
>>18548656
You can't accommodate everyone in Mecca.
>>18548253
>Zoriastrians
Lol
>>
File: Abrahamic Aryan cult.png (514 KB, 638x448)
514 KB PNG
>>18548672
>You can't accommodate everyone in Mecca.
Kek. The biggest Dawah team in the whole world are Indian-Eurofag persian fanatics in fact the whole prophetic Abrahamic cult comes from them, the only reason they push this meme about them being less islamist than other ethnic groups in MENA is because they want to appeal to the Western Indian-Eurofag racialist.
>>
>>18548701
I have no idea what mental illness you bestowed this thread with.
I said you physically cannot fit a lot of people there.
>>
>>18548722
Kek. Retarded fag explain why the Indian-Euro persians who are said to be the most liberal islamist and prone to Atheism don't have 2 Million fanatics then instead of you hypothetical Saudi Arabia pilgrimage limit.
>>
>>18548732
Crawl on all fours to me, and beg me for my attention first.
If you want your weekly spanking.
>>
>>18548253
Shiism is a lot more centralized than Sunni Islam, akin to Catholicism. Because of this, there aren't that many clerics who can explicitly oppose Khomeinist theology. Most of the Iranian clerics who opposed vilayat-e-faqih are dead. And even many Iraqi-clerics (including Sistani) often accomodate Khomeinist influence. When young Shias see Shia clergy enabling the worst vices (from child prostitution to rampant corruption and gunning down protesters for wanting proper democracy) the lack of dissent fuels antitheism in Iran and Iraq. Its much like how the scumbaggery of the Catholic Church fueled rampant anti-clericalism and secularization in France, Spain, Italy, and Ireland. Whereas a Sunni can just say that the Taliban and al-Qaeda don't represent true Islam. And Protestant churches have been more successful in opposing liberalization (ex: the rise of evangelism in Brazil). But even those denominations aren't necessarily immune to secularization (just look at Saudi/UAE or the secularization of American Protestants), but they are less vulnerable than the more centralized.
>>
>>18548747
Kek. The people who claim Sunni or Islam isn't centralized like Christianity or Shiite don't kknow what they talking about. Sunni/Islam is the the most centralized of the Abrahamic cult and probably of all cults, you are not even allowed to pray in your own mother tongue let alone a random direction.
>>
>>18548762
Why aren't you doing tricks for me dancing boy?
learn to communicate with people in english. I've no idea what qualifies as education for a slumdog, but steal a book next time.
>>
>>18548762
I am>>18548747 not >>18548788

There absolutely is more theological diversity in Sunnism compared to Shiism (just look at the squabbles between Deobandis and Barelvis on the Indian subcontinent, not to mention how the Deobandi Taliban persecutes Salafis.)
Islam is a lot like Orthodox Judaism in how it emphasizes adherence to strict religious practice and legalism. Christianity was less emphasizing on legalism and strictness which is why it has so many interpretations (from Calvinism, or the woke Christianity of the Anglicans, or MAGA/MIGA Christianity), and why it is was a lot more accomodating to secularism.
>>
>>18548808
That's is exactly my point, the fact that Sunni islam has many diverting sects doesn't mean it's not centralized what these people are using to make the claim that Islam isn't centralized is nothing but locals mixing their culture with Islam not telling you that even Islam itself is nothing but Arabs mixing their paganism with Judaism and Christianity. So the fact many islamist claim that Islam isn't Arab supremacy because they have their own culture and don't want to be Arabized is cope. Islam isn't from the GOD of the Universe it's from the Arabs, as for it having retarded rituals like Judaism yeah I agree but I disagree with those who say it's less centralized than Christianity or even Judaism.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.