[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


“Tradcaths”: the US is going to become a catholic country!!!
Reality:
>>
>>18651785
They're mostly misled by that one map showing US counties by largest denomination, not realizing that in the vast majority of counties Evangelicals still outnumber Catholics but because they don't have a united church Catholics are the "largest" one. When you add mainliners it becomes even more lopsided in favor of Protestants.
>>
File: IMG_2577.png (57 KB, 498x498)
57 KB PNG
Almost all of the growth in unaffiliated is in the bottom third of income. It’s ending up as an embarrassment for both sides - Christianity as a religion for the elite that preaches only the poor enter into heaven, and atheism becoming synonymous with trailer park dysfunction, transexuals, and 4chan posters.
>>
Gold gets purified by burning off impurities
>>
>>18651785
Conversion rates are meaningless. Birthrates are what determine the future. The Amish will inherit the Earth.
>>
>>18651801
>uh people leaving are religion doesn't matter since uh we will just pop out more babies (ignore the fact its said babies we keep popping out that end up leaving the moment they grow up)
>>
>>18651822
>ignore the fact its said babies we keep popping out that end up leaving the moment they grow up
The population becomes genetically resilient to people leaving eventually. Far more people are born into the Amish community than leave it.
>>
>>18651822
Biological reproduction is inherently more reliable than social contagion, unless the 2 competing groups are both above replacement anyway. The Puritans had huge fertility rates but the groups who outcompeted them were still reproducing at healthy rates. Atheists and LGBTQIA+'s meanwhile are a historical aberration, as is all of mass industrial abundance.
>>
>>18651841
>becomes geneticially resistant
being x religion isn't some magical gene no matter how much you want to think it is
>>
>>18651785
TradCaths being anti immigrant but also gleeful about the rise of Catholicism in the US is so funny, like bro you guys are the wapo dago immigrants, this place was literally founded by Puritans and Presbyterians
>>
>>18651848
>TradCaths being anti immigrant
They aren't lol. There's a tradcath on /his/ who says that JD Vance is not a faithful Catholic because he doesn't open the floodgates to help Catholics take over the US. Yes, he said "take over" verbatim. They're pro-immigration.
>>
>>18651846
No, it is polygenic.
>>
File: wow.png (77 KB, 640x421)
77 KB PNG
>>18651801
>>
>>18651850
Christians in general have always been a national security threat to every nation. If you put your loyalty to Christ above loyalty to your country, then leave and never come back
>>
>>18651842
Atheists and LGBTQIA+s are descended from those high birth rate populations.

>as is all of mass industrial abundance
How long do you think a non-violent religious sect like the amish would survive in whatever post-industrial dark age succeeds us lol
>>
>>18651848
I don't think I've ever seen a anti-immigration tradcath, normally they're cheering on the (ostensible) great replacement of the anglo protters with based latinx catholics
>>
>>18651901
>Atheists and LGBTQIA+s are descended from those high birth rate populations.
Correct, they don't have their own group, they're born and then abandon their group for the social contagion. When the social contagion dies, they die. This is also why troons and their enablers like to say that refusal to affirm troon delusions is 'genocide' even when there's no violence being advocated for at all, because they know they know killing the social contagion would eradicate their group.
>How long do you think a non-violent religious sect like the amish would survive in whatever post-industrial dark age succeeds us lol
I don't know why you think I'm specifically referring to the Amish here. It's not like those atheists and LGBTQIA+'s you mentioned all descend from the Amish. White conservative religious communities in the US today have above replacement fertility, even as their total numbers are declining due to the social contagion. The vast majority of them are not pacifists.
>>
>>18651890
Interesting. But the Amish are self sufficient. Ortho jews and somalis rely on welfare provided by the low fertility normies.
>>
>>18651901
> How long do you think a non-violent religious sect like the amish would survive in whatever post-industrial dark age succeeds us lol

The Amish are armed, and if hordes of deranged faggots descended on their farms to sexually molest their horses, they would shoot them.
>>
File: IMG_0434.png (560 KB, 800x800)
560 KB PNG
This is evidence that godjak posting is working
>>
I grew up catholic, my parents were protestants who started going to a catholic church because of an issue with their preacher. I haven’t been catholic for 15 years but when I went to a mass in a bigger city there were about 10 old people and a hispanic priest who did the mass in broken english I barely understood
>>
>>18651789
non-religious doesn't mean atheist you absolute fucking retard
>>
>>18651785
Catholicism has a lot of people who are just 'culturally Catholic'. If you're raised in that community, you nominally identify as a Catholic even when you're pretty inactive.

It's not hard for the Protestants to poach off those adherents that were only really limping along to begin with.
>>
>>18651787
israel be praised!!
>>
>>18652011
You will find more Evangelicals in favor of repealing the Civil Rights Act than Catholics.
>>
>>18651785
People shouldn't convert because of demographic reasons. If anything it means Calvinist soteriology is sort of correct in that most people are going to hell.
>>
>>18651954
They wouldn't. If they did, they would cease to be Amish.
>>
>>18651901
They will simply undergo a religious reformation and have some leader proclaim that "violence against our enemies is totally ok to use right now guys, Jesus whispered it into my ears", and the people will just follow along.
>>
>>18652151
That would allow them to become atheists
>>
By both birthrates and REVERTS Muslims beat judeochristians in general

Korea and Japan will become Muslim nations in the future
>>
>>18652257
They transitioned from violent terrorists to pacifists before, but atp their identity is too solidified and they're too decentralized to change quickly. They haven't been led by an individual charismatic leader in a long time. JWs (and some other pacifist cults) absolutely would turn violent in a heartbeat if their leadership told them to though.
>>
File: IMG_0641.jpg (40 KB, 250x375)
40 KB JPG
>>18651901
It’s funny when people loudly proclaim how ignorant they are of something
>>
Lets not forget that Roman Catholism is a version of Christianity that was basically hijacked by the Romans in a desperate attempt to prevent their empire from being annihilated by Christians that were salty about Romans killing the son of God after being betrayed by jewish inbreds.

And it was most likely these jewish inbreds that infiltrated the Roman empire and ran the show from behind the scenes. Much like they run America today. There is a logical reason behind this theory because the Romans needed a constant flow of fresh meat for their amfitheaters. Jews had a global trading network but normal jews wouldn't work together with those sadistic monsters. Jewish inbreds did and made a shitload of money by shipping slaves and wild animals. Obviously many normal people in occupied territory started to protest against the sadistic practises in those amfitheaters and some were closed. When jewish inbreds got wind of this development they feared that the romans would decide to close all amfitheaters and by that close the moneytap.

And so they infiltrated, corrupted and at some point basically ruled the Roman empire like they rule America today. Instead of emperors they now use presidents as their spuritual scapegoats since its them that are technically responsible for the evil shit that the inbreds are doing and intentionally causing. The inbreds seem to be aware of some kind of hell you can end up and perhaps hope to avoid it by outsourcing their evil deeds and throw scapegoats in front of the bus by claiming they just followed orders with the commander in chief being responsible.

Sure, its just a theory but it would explain a lot when it comes to all that pedo stuff in the catholic church. After all, peadophelia is an inbred related disorder.
>>
>>18651997
>can’t decide if the unaffiliated are atheist or not until you know why I asking

Kek. Anyway, don’t think I’m celebrating about it. Retards and perverts probably need the church more than anyone else. But there is no such thing as “true democracy”, in all societies the few command and the many obey, and atheism is becoming the faith of NEETs, welfare cases, criminals, marijuana addicts, etc.
>>
>>18652668
Is that where the amish leaders will be hanging after the nog warbands ravage the countryside in search of food
>>
>>18653058
>homo communists fantasizing about their pet groids terrorizing white people

Sis, the nogs won’t even leave the cities. Best case scenario is they give your prolapsed anus a vigorous pump before killing themselves trying to strip copper from a transformer.
>>
>>18653058
>>18653099
blacks tfr is so low in america now its only over asians, and that while being carried hard by immigrants from somalia and haiti
>>
>>18651901
They literally have the best chance of survival out of anyone except billionaires in bunkers.

Maybe even better long term.
It's because they're almost entirely self sufficient and have strong communities, unlike everyone else.

They are more ready for post industrial life than anyone.
Like, they can still build cisterns out of stone and shit.
>>
>>18651901
>violence is th only way to survive
no, it's the people who can't survive who will resort to violence and cannibalism first
these are the ones the Amish have to look out for, all they have to do is outlast or avoid them long enough for these hordes to eat each other and die of thirst or whatever else
might not take more than a few weeks after the lights go out and the grocery stores are emptied

and let's say the teeming subhuman masses of worthless eaters streaming out of the suburbs and cities by the millions do actually wipe out the Amish and other hardy folk like so many locusts
basically you just flushed your last beat hope for civilization down the toilet, these people have generations worth of accumulated knowledge on how to actually do sustainable agriculture, among other things like making clothing and animal husbandry, etc

if not for them, whoever survived will have to learn basically everything from scratch again
they could end up being lower than neolithic man, losing the capability to smelt iron or forge tools, total systems collapse would result in something far worse than what you saw after the fall of WRE because startlingly few actually have knowledge of what was extremely basic for medieval people

maybe there are still enough books around, good ones with detailed instructions on how to do a myriad number of basic things necessary for survival and rebuilding, but without communication systems they'll have a hard time getting around

sure, you might have pockets of technological holdouts here and there
people who can keep oil well pumpjacks working and know generators, or continuity of government types
they would have a big incentive to ensure these people in particular stay among the living
>>
This is driven pretty hard by second generation hispanics realizing they don't have to do the Catholic bullshit their parents do in this country.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.