[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


DNA shows Jewish roots in the ancient Levant, but that region had dozens of tribes and creeds. What’s the strongest evidence connecting today's Jews to the actual Israelites of the Old Testament?

I find it hard to believe that after thousand of years of every nigger pretending to be the real Jews that the real Jews actually held out...

And if these guys aren't the real Jews who the fuck are they?
>>
>>18665701
>Are modern Jews literally descended from the Jews of the Old Testament?
Correct. Occam's razor. Stop JAQing off
>>
>>18665701
Who are the Jews of the Old Testament? The idea that there were twelve patriarchs who founded twelve tribes and ten of them were lost and Jews are descended from the other ones - all of that is a myth/legend and there’s not much controversy about that. But the idea that modern day Jews are descended from the ancient Jews is relatively uncontroversial. Things like the Khazar theory are fringe.
>>
File: IMG_0580.jpg (217 KB, 1284x949)
217 KB JPG
>>18665701
No, native Palestinians show more genetic lineage to ancient Hebrews than modern Ashkenazi squatters
>>
>>18665701
>Are modern Jews literally descended from the Jews of the Old Testament?
Askhenazi jews are ~50% descended from 2nd century BC levant inhabitants and ~50% from Europeans. (Palestinians are about 80% descended and Lebanese 90%). So technically palestinians and lebanese are more jewish. And Samaritans are also 90%.
>>
>>18666140
Crazy how one ethnic group with less biological claim to the region can massacre those with deeper roots
>>
>>18666146
In their defence, this wasnt known until the last 5-10 years. But of course the Israeli right-wing and their leadership dont want to deal or acknowledge this reality because it's a bad look that the "arabs" are more biologically jewish than the leader of the ultra-nationalist party
>>
>>18665701
Genetic studies show that Ashkenazim are descendants of Italian women and Hebrew men, so probably yeah they are descendants of them
HOWEVER it's also still retarded for anyone to care about ancestry from 3000 years ago cause at that point it's gonna be so diluted and mixed, regardless of your ethnicity, that it may as well be irrelevant entirely. It's akin to being a descendant of royalty in Europe, like okay so what? It doesn't actually matter, everyone has the same ancestors due to pedigree collapse and the mathematics involved
>>
>>18665701
Obviously not. Hadrian exterminated the Tribe of Judah.
>>
>>18666184
This isn't really a "problem" or anything in Israel because most Israeli chuds aren't Ashkenazi to begin with. Ben Gvir's family is from Iraq and the guy who assisted Rabin was from a Yemenite family iirc. It's not white pasty Ashkenazim from Poland chudding out, it's the Middle Eastern ones.
>>
>>18666011
>relatively uncontroversial
All Ashkenazi descend from 300 unknown individuals who lived somewhere in Central Europe in the 9th century AD.
>>
>>18665701
They aren’t the real Jews.
It doesn’t matter if they aren’t, they can still believe they are Jews following their jew religion.
They need witnessed the gospel so that they accept Jesus Christ to be saved.
If they are blind and reject him and don’t listen, to leave them alone and let God deal with their future now. Just like it is your duty to do this with gentiles. Because God is the one who sent Jesus and said to share the gospel to them, detailing their futures whatever they choose.
Items your job to stop being a gentile or a Jew depending on who you are.
And believe in Jesus Christ.
If you are saved then it is your duty to live your life in peace, purity, humility, and working on your own race to the finish line. Like Paul talked about. It doesn’t matter who you are or your circumstance. God is now the judge of your life and if you got truly saved then you are going to Heaven and you should still read the Bible to know them as best you can. Even if you took an oath to be a Jew because of spiritual reasons or something as a secret Christian.
Because of this, that means we have a giant mess of chaos going on in the world and we can’t stop it till sin manifests as the robot sex bot death that is coming to all humanity in the form of man merging with machine and Jesu Christ comes to stop it. People like Elon Musk said “I have to become the Antichrist myself that way I can try to stop the evil” when he came out with neuralink. You’ll be able to hook up to AI VR in the future and your mind will be able to merge with the matrix basically and have cyber consciousness having heroic adventures and sex unendlessly. Do you really think humanity has a chance?
>>
>>18666203
It’s a problem globally because even the most irreligious liberal western Ashkenazi turns into a blood and soil lebensraum advocate when it comes to Israel.
>>
>>18666203
These people are picking up a tradition of Jewish chuddism laid by Avraham Stern and Ze'ev Jabotinsky who were Ashkenazi.
>>
>>18666248
Except you know, all the Communist Jews who founded the USSR, which is the only superpower who trained and armed and supported Palestine
>>
>>18666260
No, they're picking up the tradition of "I don't wanna get sent to fucking YEMEN bro". Middle Eastern Jews getting exiled to Israel was a blessing, literally their one way ticket to a country with a 0.9+ HDI, it's obviously NOT in their interests to reverse that and get themselves deported to some hell scapes like Iraq and Yemen
>>
>>18665701
Yes modern Jews are related to Jews of the past, khazar hypothesis is false.

Jews are basically canaanites, there was also never an exodus out of Egypt.
>>
>>18666203
As I recall it those diasporas are even lower percentage levantine heritage and are almost completely local converts. The Syrian diaspora are the only ones that have really high percentage levantine ancestry.
>>
>>18666286

If there's no exodus out of Egypt, then what the fuck were those old Jews so bent out of shape about?
>>
>>18666316
I checked it and Iraqi jews are similar level levantine ancestry as askhenazis, ~50%. Yemeni jews are pretty much no levantine ancestry at all and instead cluster with Yemenis of other religions (=Islam). So yemeni jews are literally arabs
>>
>>18666320
It’s all a plagiarized revenge fantasy, and it’s also the reason why the word Babylon is interchangeable with Rome in their ahistorical scriptures.
>>
>>18666316
The Iraqi diaspora is probably actually the legit descendant of the Babylonian Exile one, but ofc contrary to the Biblical Narrative they kinda just chilled and had normal assimilated lives in the region and didn't really feel compelled to "RETVRN" or anything
>>
>>18666274
Stalin killed those fuckers
>>
>>18666353
With what, a time machine? The Soviet Union was obviously supporting Palestine after WW2 and after Stalin died, you stupid cunt.
>>
>>18666940
The Communist Jews who founded the Soviet Union moron, Stalin purged almost all of them. Most of the old guard Bolsheviks were dead before the 50’s.
>>
>>18666205
I still have absolutely no clue why Jews would be allowed to live in Europe during that time. Is it just because they were allowed to lend money?
>>
File: 1760448941420311.png (1.6 MB, 1668x955)
1.6 MB PNG
>>18665701
Aren't modern Israelis technically the banished or ran-away tribes while the others stayed and died?
>>
>>18667080
Modern Israelis are squatters who stole the land from people who ironically have a greater genetic connection to the region than them
>>
File: 1784154624830333.jpg (71 KB, 500x712)
71 KB JPG
>>18667112
Well, yes. But I like the Rabbinical reason to throw in their faces that they were the disgraced tribes who left and consequently exiled from returning to the Holy Land.
>>
>>18665701
There is proof that Judea and Israel existed in some kind of form but there is no proof for the 12 tribes.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.