[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: IMG_4898.jpg (361 KB, 2000x1333)
361 KB JPG
Did America deserve 9/11?
>>
No because it ultimately ruined things
>>
Yes because it ultimately ruined America
>>
>>18684170
It was genuinely a work of art as Karlheinz stockhausen said. It’s like a tiny fraction of the US capitalist Nazis getting a taste of their own medicine and the world never has forgotten it. The US destroyed the planet’s environments, created mass famines and pollution and slaughtered many but a handful of accountant Jews burning in a fire is their greatest tragedy.
>>
>>18684170
No, but I say this only because it ended up affecting me despite not being American.
>>
>>18684170
Kinda. For once, they got a taste of their own medicine.
>>
>>18684225
>US capitalist Nazis getting a taste of their own medicine
Why are commielarpers so corny?
>>
>>18684170
>Did America deserve 9/11?
Short answer, yes.

Long answer, no because the death toll was far too low. Multiply it by a factor of 100 and we'd enter the sphere where one could very cautiously talk about deservedness.
>>
no. We in western world need to end this third-world mentality where we support goat fucking terrorists, meanwhile expect Americans do be perfect at everything and best at everything or else we whinge in our mediocre countries.
>>
America? No.
New York? Yes.
>>
>>18684170
The people who say "America deserved 9/11" get extremely angry when you suggest that any middle-eastern terrorist cell deserves to be annihilated for their terrorism.
>>
>>18684170
Search up banana republic and other controversial thing US did in the past
>>
>>18684170
No and America’s involvement in the Middle East prior to 9/11 is vastly overstated in modern popular memory.

Also the terrorists really did hate us for our freedom. Osama essentially says this in his manifesto and the “degeneracy” of the US was a common point of seethe amongst radical sunnis since Qutb.
>>
>>18684421
>The people who say "Germany deserved Dresden" get extremely angry when you suggest that any RAF squadron deserves to be annihilated for their terror bombing.
Curious.
>>
>>18684440
Trvke
>>
>>18684446
Their WW2 vet regret it
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cM2Ae-iAb-c
>>
>>18684446
That's a great example that demonstrates how idiotic this line of thinking is, thank you.
>>
File: 1788537148102810.jpg (95 KB, 764x900)
95 KB JPG
YESM I will celebrate today like you have no idea. The usa is the most evil nation in history, this board discusses humanities, and the usa and its white populace has none. A disgusting nation. I am not Muslim, I live in the usa myself even, but the usa and its people deserve the most atrocious suffering as justice, not the minorities tho, they haven't done shit to hurt the rest of the planet.

whites, remember that, when people joke and meme about your super "sad" 9/11 date. We aren't being sarcastic, we are all celebrating, and a lot of your population in the usa right now is working towards your destruction. I am not Muslim, fuck Mohammed and Allah, that's how you know even random civilians and not ragheads are also celebrating and working towards your end.
>>
'Deserved' in the sense that they should of whiped out all the goat fucking shitskins responsible years prior to this, and it was the natural conclusion of not doing so. There was like 10 major terrorist attacks in the years leading up to 9/11, with even more foiled and the US continued trying to be diplomatic with turd worlders who wanted them dead instead of just turning them all into smouldering ashes
>>
>>18684446
Wrong, a better comparison would be
>The people who say "Britain deserved bombing" get extremely angry when you suggest that any German squadron deserves to be annihilated for their terror bombing.
>>
>>18684440
>Osama essentially says this in his manifesto and the “degeneracy” of the US was a common point of seethe amongst radical sunnis since Qutb.
Anyone who complains about the US is discredited if they complain about "degeneracy" or subscribe to the belief that religion should influence politics
>>
>>18684170
No. And the fact that there are dysgenic brown midgets saying otherwise makes me think America didn't go far enough with the GWOT and should have incinerated the entirety of the Middle East and gone in a world wide crusade to exterminate Pisslam.
>>
>>18684532
Secularism, alongside feminism and western progressivism generally, will be a mocked footnote in history as its host societies flicker away from negative birthrates.
>>
>>18684170
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change
you tell me
>>
>>18684170
of course not
>>
>>18684539
classic bully mentality
it's fine for you to attack smaller, weaker countries whenever you like
but if one of them dares to attack you back, it's a huge crisis you need to cry about for decades on end

the u.s. has killed far more innocent iranian civilians in the past few months than people who died on 9/11
if anything you should be grateful that it's been such a rare occurrence for one of your victims to hit you back

>>18684507
do you think you taught them their lesson?
>Soon after NATO troops began withdrawing, the Taliban launched an offensive against the Afghan government and quickly advanced in front of collapsing Afghan government forces. The Taliban captured the capital city of Kabul on 15 August 2021, after regaining control over a vast majority of Afghanistan.
>>
>International Jewry's Top Golem
Yes and same goes for anyone that served, serves, or will serve the Synagogue of Satan
>>
>>18684553
I don't think it's possible to teach brown turd worlders any lesson because they are 80IQ, the Taliban retaking Afghanistan is proof they don't want help. But yes, America should've turned Afghanistan, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan into parking lots instead of trying to do 'nation building' in places where most of the population marries their 14 year old cousin and thinks a pedophile warlord was the perfect human
>>
>>18684535
You are brown
>>
>>18684576
premium /k/ope
>>
>>18684535
Religion is dying out everywhere.
>muh birthrates
Fertility rates are declining everywhere, the only places that are still above replacement level are third world shitholes that will never be significant.
>>
>>18684580
>i-it doesn't count
Those will be the only places to still exist as the so called first world dies out.
>>
>>18684507
>they should of whiped out all the goat fucking shitskins
>>18684574
>they don't want help
lmao
i wish you guys could see how you look from the outside
you're living inside a propaganda bubble that would put the ussr to shame

do you honestly think that's what the u.s. was doing in afghanistan? trying to "help"?
>>
No there were some innocent people who died
>>
>>18684170
America as a whole? No.
The financiers? The ones who assumed direct control of the economy in the 1970s and destroyed everything? The government? The ones who allowed the corporate raiders to tear this country to shreds? They deserved it.
>>
>>18684170
The answer is that those Muslims didn’t deserve any kind of retribution. They were just as the Bible calls them wild ass donkeys of men, a type of monkey that wears a rag on his head and thinks he is worshiping God. Everyone has faults but no , no one is high enough to judge America as the terrorists thought they are. All people are going to hell. The Bible is about how Jews are going to hell. From the very start of the Bible to the very end of it. Christians are only not going to hell because they accepted their savior dying on the cross for their sins which is open to everyone who receives his blood for their sins. You don’t have to be born into it. However the more you are, the better it will be for you.
>>
>>18684170
Yes
>>
>>18684421
>>18684446
>my side deserves to win
>>
>>18684603
There is not a single instance ever in which it's justified for 'people' with skin the colour of literal shit to harm whites.
>>
itt safe edgy
>>
>>18684535
Imagine getting so upset you commit acts of terror because a country on the other side of the world has casual sex and women voting. Brown people are certainly something
>>
>>18684170
No. Attacking civilians on purpose is never justified.
>>
>>18684170
yes
>>
>>18684492
You are brown
>>
>>18684170
it's not justified to kill civilians unless that killing is a part of an action that leads to the achievement of moral goals with a high degree of probability. it doesn't matter whether the nation those civilians are part of is evil or not.
america is far more moral than other powerful countries have been throughout history.
>>
>>18684170
any nation that fails to learn from history deserves to be "allies" of the jews.
>>
>>18684170
Americans have a hard time getting off the fact that muslims visciously killed them
>>
>>18684170
No, because it gave cia nigger and mossad kikes total control
>>
>>18684170
Did brown people deserve the timurids? French algeria or romans?
>>
>>18684415
Best answer ITT
>>
>>18684170
No and people who say they deserved it are the same people who would cut their nose to spite their face. The ramifications of this day were a net negative for everyone and I would do anything to have prevented it.
>>
>>18684421
I don't
>>
>>18684170
No.
>>
>>18684170

No.
>>
>>18684535
>>18684440
This is nonsense. Third-worldists view the devout Christian population of the west with the same bloodthirst as they view the seculars; invoking their own religious devotion is just effective rhetorically to farm their own support base.
They want all white people dead, religious or not.
>>
>>18684535
>implying third worlders will be writing books with footnotes
>>
>>18684225
Wow the Nazis must have won WWII rather decisively if they became common place in New York elite society.
>>
File: 1759742439220710.png (468 KB, 888x498)
468 KB PNG
>>18684440
>No and America’s involvement in the Middle East prior to 9/11 is vastly overstated in modern popular memory.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.