[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


>If we lose this war, the Germans will take over Europe and destroy our empire!
>If we win this war, the Americans and Russians will take over Europe and destroy our civilization!
Was their anything more nihilistic than being a British soldier in the 1940s? No wonder all their literature from this time is so depressing
>>
>>18721919
>Was their anything more nihilistic than being a British soldier in the 1940s?
Being a Jewish inmate at a labor camp in Germany after allies cut off Germany's supply lines and learning that it's about to be converted into a death camp
>>
British civilization was not destroyed, what absolute bollocks.
>>
>>18721919
Yeah neither Britain or France was super excited about pulverizing a second generation because the Germans are sperging out again, the only difference is the British stuck to their guns.
>>
>the UK has the highest number of arrests for internet speech than any nation in the world
>is also the same nation that gave us Belle Delphine and Bonnie Blue

Oi, a' Leas we ain't speaking German mate.
>>
>>18721919
>Just let the insane fascist neopagan cultist invade whoever he wants with no consequences.
>If you don't, in 80 years you will have a bunch of Muslim immigrants in your country and it will be le bad.
>>
>>18722060
I mean yeah, those were the two choices. Becoming a German or American satellite
>>
>>18721919
>Was their anything more nihilistic than being a British soldier in the 1940s?
being a German soldier on the front lines of Barbarossa being raped by Soviets while your logistics train consists of literal horses must've been a pretty massive reality check for most Germans at that point
>>
>>18722064
There is a third option which is Hitler not being retarded and permanently destroying the European continent.
>>
>>18721919
Great Britain was already a German satellite in the early 19th century. It had a German-speaking noble household based in Hanover that openly despised the Britbong prole class.
The British just switched from being German golem to being Jewish/American golem. They were never a sovereign people. This is why the British elite have always treated their lower classes like disposable slaves.
Honestly I just feel sorry for them. They'll never escape from either the German or American yoke
>>
>>18722060
>you will have a bunch of Muslim immigrants who cause things like the 2024 Southport stabbing incident and Henry Nowak and Derry stabbing in Ireland

this is better than the neopagans......?
>>
>>18722071
And how would Britain mind control Hitler to prevent him from doing so? In your hypothetical option 3 would you assassinate Hitler or what?
>>
>>18722077
He's telling you to get Hitler's cock out of your asshole and just admit that he was ultimately the cause of all this.
>>
>>18722077
I'm just pointing out your pathetic blame shifting. Hitler destroyed Europe. If baby Hitler was tossed into a wood chipper Euorpe would still be European and the world would objectively be a better place.
>>
>>18722080
But I'm not defending Hitler? Neither is the OP
The claim being made is that the British were fucked no matter what they did in WW2, which it seems like you're implicitly agreeing with.
>>
>>18722082
Ok? I think you just have poor reading comprehension
>>
>>18722082
Probably not because some identical German chud regime would take power.
If not Hitler then it would have been the neo-Kaiserists invading Poland. The British still would have bankrupted themselves and America would end up as the hegemon.
>>
>>18722083
>>18722085
You are demanding that the British magically know 21st century politics because Hitler was retarded at international relations. This is entirely unreasonable and indicative of Nazi apologism.
>>
>>18722091
>British magically know 21st century politics
America's rise to hegemony occurred in the 21st century? A very bizarre statement to make.
No, I'm expecting the British to understand the geopolitics of their time which clearly they didn't.
>>
>>18722094
You are being retarded on purpose.
>>
>>18722095
Did America's rise to hegemony occur in the 20th or 21st century? Give a simple answer and then we can proceed in good faith.
>>
>>18722097
You were never arguing in good faith in the first place. You have completely dropped your original "America will destroy le civilization" argument because it's inconvenient for your current line of reasoning and hoped I wouldn't notice.
>>
>>18722091
>British magically know 21st century politics
>such as

>hyper sexual porn culture
1920s Berlin
>sex reassignment surgery
1920s Berlin
>race mixing
Several German propaganda magazines talked about this
>immigration
again mentioned several times by Germans
>consumer culture
yes, germans once again talked about this by pointing the fixation on things like jazz music
>>
>>18722104
I have not dropped any arguments. America replacing the UK as the world power necessarily results in the end of British civilization, since it will become culturally and economically dependent on the US.
>>
>>18722106
Wow it really sounds like Hitler shouldn't have fucked around and destroyed Europe then.
>>
>>18722082
Hindenburg's cabinet were planning to remilitarize and annex Poland before they even appointed Hitler as chancellor. Practically all conservative Prussian nationalists wanted that.
You'd have to at the very minimum kill Hindenburg in order to change the timeline
>>
>>18722107
>"But I'm not defending Hitler"
>keeps implicitly giving Hitler's Germany a free pass
>>
germshits always get raped and genocided by the unstoppable Anglo-Slavic alliance
>>
>>18722120
>"But I'm not defending America"
>keeps implicitly giving America a free pass
Hope the McNuggets are worth it bro
>>
>>18722114
>You'd have to at the very minimum kill Hindenburg in order to change the timeline
Honestly, at that point you'd have to kill Napoleon before he got a chance to redraw Europe in the first place. The reality is that Germany was never a real nation, they were originally tribal hordes untied by the Catholic Church, and when Napoleon tore down the HRE, it left them running around like headless chickens and they could never properly define the German Nation or unify, hence the German Question, both World Wars etc
>>
>>18722123
You're the one who made this about
>why would Britain side with America against Germany?
while refusing to even entertain any reason a person might not want to choose Germany.
>>
>>18722109
okay, so why didnt Europe just let Germany and USSR fight each and stay out of it? Instead of supplying the evil communists anything at all, just have both the Nazis and Soviets both run out of resources and manpower and then the allies swoop in

????
>>
File: 1776706657507983.jpg (473 KB, 2048x1536)
473 KB JPG
>>18721919
germshits always get raped by Polish warriors. Poland will always be England's greatest ally
>>
>>18722128
Uh . . because slavs are our greatest ally o algo
>>
>>18722128
>okay, so why didnt Europe just let Germany
Sorry Adolf but that's not how this works. Better luck next time. Thanks for playing.
>>
File: 1754981027584442.jpg (523 KB, 987x741)
523 KB JPG
>>18722126
>The reality is that Germany was never a real nation, they were originally tribal hordes untied by the Catholic Church, and when Napoleon tore down the HRE, it left them running around like headless chickens and they could never properly define the German Nation or unify, hence the German Question, both World Wars etc
Wehraboo are not ready for this TRVKE
>>
>>18722139
no seriously. imagine if the Soviets weren't given any endorsement, supplies, or anything at all and just told hitler
>we stay out of the war
>you retard nations settle it out

?
>>
>>18722127
That's not true at all. I'm perfectly sympathetic to why you prefer McNuggets over Sauerkraut. I'm merely pointing out it was a choice between one and the other
>>
>>18722145
>no seriously.
No seriously, imagine if Hitler didn't utterly rape the post-WW1 international order and then the most predictable outcome ever didn't happen.
>>
>>18722145
Russians will always be England's greatest ally against the savage germshit ape hordes. Stop posting division, Berlin agent.
>>
Soviet and British GODS always win and rape germs
>>
>>18722153
But if Soviets werent supplied at all, made it impossible mode for them to make it Berlin, both the Nazishits and Communists would have completely depleted each other and then the West moves in
>>
>>18722160
The Russians have always been England's ally. Germans are the enemy of European civilization and they must be destroyed without mercy.
>>
>>18722160
>But if
But if the moon was made of cheese why didn't France land on it first?
>>
>>18722166
>Germany invades East
France and England
>this is completely about us! we are 100% involved in this for some reason

>Germany goes further East towards Russia
France and England
>thats it Germany. We wanted nothing to do with this, which it doesn't but we are going in and giving the psychotic dictator Stalin billions of dollars


???
>>
>>18721919
The destruction of Germany created a power vaccuum in the centre of Europe that was filled with New York finance. In retrospect this is obvious but at the time no one could have predicted the outcome of the war would be total American hegemony over the world. Sadly the white race will probably go extinct as a result.
I'm Chinese so none of this matters to me thankfully
>>
>>18721919
Churchill and Stalin were heroes who saved the White race from savage german orcs
It's thanks to them europe was liberated from the pagan nazitranny menace
>>
>>18722002
Belle Delphine is Bri’ish?
>>
>>18722172
It's almost hilarious how dumb white people are. They get outmaneuvered by Jews and Slavs at every turn.
And of all the whites, the anglos are probably the stupidest.
I look forward to the Chinese Millennium
>>
File: 1780529287588356.png (13 KB, 158x151)
13 KB PNG
Can we ban Chinese IP addresses? None of them seem to be capable of actually engaging in threads without being completely off-topic or spamming/flooding them to death
>>
>>18722214
youre a jeet, but out of all the white countries, the UK is the literal anus of the world. I have no idea why Shitler preferred nglan'ers over French. I never even liked their culture before Tony Blair autism.
>>
>>18722064
These are sort of after the fact kind of choices, not really options people could pick between at the time. Also there are WAY more possible outcomes than American or German hegemony in Europe, like Soviet hegemony for example.
>>
>>18722060
>If you don't, in 80 years you will have a bunch of Muslim immigrants in your country and it will be le bad.
This isnt automatically cancelled just because Britain decides to kiss Hitlers ring.
Remember that Britain was 90% white up until the 1980s. The decision to make it multicultural happened long after ww2, as it did with many other countries, some whom were neutral in ww2 such as Sweden.
And many countries who resisted the Germans has decided not to follow this path, such as Poland and Czechia.
>>
>>18721926
Fairly high survival rate.
>>
>>18722060
>insane fascist neopagan
Poland?
>>18722418
Yes it is actually because the current state of Britain is a result of policy not magic and the policies were created by people that Germany would have otherwise kept out of power.
>>18722214
>he was conquered by dumb people
Why? Is your race that weak that some White BVLLs took your pusi?
>>
>>18722421
2/3rd of the European Jewish population is terrible survival rate, only 1/3 survived
>>
>>18722425
>only 1/3 survived
Really? Was there a pre-war census of all Jews in Europe done by Germany?
We know Russia pasted over Ukrainians and poles with Russians ethnically in censuses, we also know they did it with Jews living in the Baltic.
What’s your evidence?
>>
File: 1777939978948817.png (441 KB, 500x575)
441 KB PNG
>>18722431
The prewar European statistics come from the American Jewish Yearbook.
https://ajcarchives.org/Portal/Yearbooks/en-US/RecordView/Index/2520

>Of that number, 7,363,000 reside in a group of adjacent countries located in the center of the continent of Europe, which region may be designated as the "Jewish" Central Europe. This region includes Poland, Danzig, Lithuania, Latvia; Austria, Czechoslovakia, Hungary; Roumania, Russia (Crimea, Ukraine, and White Russia).
>In all other regions the Jews constitute less than 1% of the total population. Of these, nearly 1,600,000 reside in western and southern Europe; nearly 200,000 in northern and eastern Europe (Russia and the Baltic countries);

This puts Europe's total prewar population at around 9.5 million, minus the 6 million that died during the Holocaust and the survival rate is about 1/3rd
>>
>>18722164
Is this European Civilization in the room with us right now? It's your side that won lassie.
>>
>>18722442
>American Jewish committee
I said German. Your source is unreliable. It’s like asking Bibi if he knew about Oct7.
>you’re just a chud denying the Shoah
Nah. I don’t believe extraordinary claims without extraordinary evidence
>>
>>18722002
let's be real Nazi Germany would absolutely arrest people over internet speech just as much if not more than the brits
>>
>>18722128
maybe they would've supported Germany and Poland against the Soviets but why would they, 2 years into the war btw, suddenly switch sides and join the Germans just because they invaded the Soviets?
>>
>>18722064
Why are you pretending like America was in charge?
>>
>>18722097
Did it happen before or after Britian had chosen their side? And did that happen before or after America joined?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.