[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


>academics admit schizohaplochuds on /his/ are more knowledgeable than them
Kino
>>
In short, science does not agree with the (((die-versity))) narrative.
>>
>>18738255
Lazaridis bros? Our answer? Haploautism won, again
>>
File: Haplogwh.jpg (629 KB, 1080x2103)
629 KB JPG
>>18738276
Incels always win in the end
>>
The truth is that the Chuds are the civilizers. Those Indo-Europeans who left Ukraine and went as far away as western China and India were composed of Chuds. those Spanish colonists were a bunch of Chuds under 30 years old in the media. The Chud won, but the world despises them. Total Chud adoration.
>>
>>18738284
>>18738283
>>18738276
Why do the Chuds keep winning??? Why? Normoids BTFO
>>
>>18738286
Stalin's incel chud bolsheviks always rape academic nazi trannies
>>
>>18738284
I've always thought about that. That Koryos is what happens when young Chuds have full freedom to act in society.
>>
>>18738255
>be BBC
>hear about Palaeolithic people of Britain having dark skin
>make a documentary on the prehistoric Britain
>show its inhabitants as negroes
>...
>chuds see your film
>chuds point out the prehistoric Brittons' skin was swarthy but not black
>chuds also point out that they had the blue eyes mutation
>and that they were of the Caucasian race
>...
>REEEEE!!!! Racism!!!!
>>
File: 20260827_213012.png (2.63 MB, 3264x3264)
2.63 MB PNG
>>18738283
>>18738276
No, not anymore, because the haplo-autistic community is being infiltrated by Indians and literal feminist women, it has become too mainstream...
>>
>>18738255
Cuckademics
>>
>>18738303
>breeding fetish
>breeding
>the most natural thing
>fetish
Why are foids like this? Also, "moid" merely mimics the term "foid". Feminists once again prove they can only corrupt what others created.
>>
>>18738284
>Those Indo-Europeans who left Ukraine and went as far away as western China and India were composed of Chuds
>>
>>18738350
The worst part is that she poses as a haploautistic person while throwing trash at men. She only talks about haplogroups and pre-made models and the appearance of ancient peoples being ugly or beautiful. A robot.
>>
>>18738255
Okay, but any European nation is made of various different tribes mixed together. Some of them didn't even originate in Europe. So why is it okay for angles and saxons and normans to go to England but not for everyone else?
>>
>>18738364
That’s a shitty reconstruction
>>
>>18738367
Because of aesthetics. It's just depressing as hell if there's browns everywhere on the entire planet
>>
>>18738367
>Some of them didn't even originate in Europe.
>>
>>18738367
Once there was a technologically and culturally developed world. Then the Bronze collapse happened. The civilization died under the strikes of the Sea Peoples, including the Proto-Greeks.

Then there were several centuries of darkness.

Then the former barbarians found a new great civilization we know as the Greco-Roman civilization. The civilization died under the strikes of the barbarians, including the Germanic tribes.

Then there were several centuries of darkness.

Then the former barbarians found a new great civilization, the ours. Currently it is going through several crises, including waves of new barbarians. What will happen if the civilization falls? Several centuries of darkness, during which the natural selection will slowly work. And then a new great civilization will rise. But do you really want to lose several centuries?
>>
>>18738367
Why do you want niggers everywhere in the world?
>>
>>18738372
Not chuddy enough, eh?
Don't worry, he was likely under 170cm.
>>
File: archaic.png (539 KB, 1115x629)
539 KB PNG
>>18738255
It was literally over when we learned blacks are part monkey.
>>
>>18738255
Cite your full academic source, OP.

>Source: Page 131, chapter “Changing People, Changing Content: New Perspectives on Past Peoples” by Rebecca Redfern and Thomas Booth, in the book The Routledge Handbook of Museums, Heritage, and Death (Routledge, 2023; 1st edition)

>Publisher: Routledge (imprint of Taylor & Francis), one of the world's leading academic publishers. The Routledge Handbooks on Museums, Galleries and Heritage series is the standard in the field of museology and heritage

>Editors: Trish Biers and Katie Stringer Clary — professionals and academics in the field of museums, death studies and heritage (Biers linked to Cambridge institutions/museums; Clary with a PhD and work in public engagement and deathscapes)

>Rebecca Redfern: Senior Curator of Human Osteology / Roman London at the Museum of London (now London Museum). Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries. He has published widely on bioarchaeology, palaeopathology, ethics of human remains and Roman/medieval populations of London. He is a leading expert in the field

>Thomas Booth: Senior Laboratory Research Scientist at the Ancient Genomics Laboratory at the Francis Crick Institute (one of the largest biomedical research centers in Europe). Co-author of important aDNA papers in Nature and Nature Ecology & Evolution (including the classic study of the Beaker phenomenon and genomic transformations in Neolithic/Bronze Britain). Central figure in British archaeogenetics

>Published in 2023, with revised contributions from academics and professionals from museums, archaeology, anthropology, etc. It is a reference handbook (not a loose opinion essay)
>>
>>18738390
>The individual from Qumsai (Kumsay) Kurgan 1, Grave 3 was estimated to be about 2 meters tall (roughly 6 feet 6 inches).
It's actually not Yamnaya, but the ANE-heavy giant from Kazakhstan.
>>
Remember, friends, the Brazilian above is a pedophile.
>>
>>18738414
This is the brazil spammer who was banned for posting cp and banned repeatedly for spamming. cp bans are permanent. Anyone can report him since he's ban evading and avatarfagging again.
>>
>>18738414
>Footnotes:

>11 BBC News, “Migrant crisis: One million enter Europe in 2015.” Accessed October 28, 2021, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-35158769; BBC News, “Brexit: What you need to know about the UK leaving the EU” (2020). Accessed October 28, 2021, https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-32810887

>12 See Chris Manias, Race, Science, and the Nation: Reconstructing the Ancient Past in Britain, France and Germany (Oxford: Routledge, 2013)

>13 See Chris Manias, Race, Science, and the Nation: Reconstructing the Ancient Past in Britain, France and Germany (Oxford: Routledge, 2013)

>14 Peter Bull and Anne-Marie Simon-Vandenbergen, “Equivocation and doublespeak in far right-wing discourse: An analysis of Nick Griffin’s performance on BBC’s Question Time,” Text & Talk 34, no. 1 (2014): 1–22; Lorna-Jane Richardson and Thomas Booth, “Response to ‘Brexit, Archaeology and Heritage: Reflections and Agendas,’” Papers from the Institute of Archaeology 27, no. 1 (2017): 25, http://www.diva-portal.org/smash/get/ diva2:1252352/FULLTEXT01.pdf; Tom J. Booth, “Exploring your inner hades: DNA as mortuary archaeology,” AP Online Journal in Public Archaeology 8, no. 2 (2018): 221

>PDF:

https://z-library.biz/book/1rpA0Y6AKe/the-routledge-handbook-of-museums-heritage-and-death.html

I'm going to post the entire chapter here for context.
>>
>>18738421
And remember, he also has pedophilic tendencies.
>>
>>18738421
In the other thread, he also literally revealed all of his intimate personal data. Now he's ruining this thread.
>>
>>18738255
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
>>
>>18738425
>>
>>18738434
>>
>>18738429
NTA, wasn't he the guy who kept posting interracial crap, female domination stuff, and whatever else here, even though it was against the rules? There are literal studies that link the use of pornography and homosexual tendencies too. Consuming pedo anime is no surprise
>>
>>18738435
>>
>>18738438
>>
>>18738439
>>
>>18738437
>interracial crap, female domination stuff, and whatever else here, even though it was against the rules?
Yeah that's him. He also posts pornographic images of naked women and strangely nothing happened, but those who criticized him received a "punishment", if you know what I mean. We theorize that this guy has some high-ranking acquaintance here. This pedophile was also caught copying and pasting texts from defunct Blogspot blogs and using them as arguments
>>
>>18738432
There you go. If any jannies give a fuck this retarded schizo is admitting to posting cp again. What he calls "exposing snuff films" somehow entitles him to post porn of underage boys in diseased little schizophrenic mind.
>>
>>18738441
>>
>>18738444
>>18738442
>pedophile
This worm is even filthier and more disgusting than I thought...
>>
File: deport1.jpg (1.04 MB, 900x6400)
1.04 MB JPG
>>18738255
IMPORT SHIT

BECOME SHIT

WHO KNEW ???
>>
File: deport2.jpg (3.75 MB, 3300x8700)
3.75 MB JPG
>>18738451
MOAR SHIT
>>
>>18738445
>>
>>18738456
>>
>>18738434
>yeah, these autistic incels often know more than our expert
>no, their views are spurious and harmful! don't listen!!
God damn it's all so tiresome.
>>
>>18738459
>>
>>18738456
>we know that the facial recreations we make are always wrong
Man. The absolute state of 'left-wing' academics. It almost makes me want to show them mercy.
>>
File: maxresdefault.jpg (176 KB, 1280x720)
176 KB JPG
>>18738432
Jannies and the retard circlejerk here bit the bait.

>Abenis Roberto Vieira da Silva is a fake name, and parody of Thomas Roberto Vieira da Silva, which is itself another fake name used by Thomas from the YouTube channel Menino Thomas in the video "O Iceberg dos Chans" (https://youtu.be/xp7t9XWSSOM)

>The address Rua Huberto Rodhem, 423 – Bela Vista, São Ludgero - SC corresponds to the location of an automotive detailing business registered under the business name Luciano Henrique Bagio Bianco. The establishment operates under the trade name Nigga Estética Lavacars (or Lavagem e Polimento Luciano Bianco)

>The Cadastro de Pessoas Físicas (CPF) number 070.680.938-68 officially belongs to Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva, the current President of the Federative Republic of Brazil. This personal document is registered in his name and appears publicly in various official records of the Electoral Court, public candidacy filings, and government transparency portals throughout his political career

>The number (48) 93028-6313 belongs to the PT (Partido dos Trabalhadores) National Directory in Santa Catarina

Picrel is proof of this (video's thumbnail):

https://youtu.be/6MqjIkcWYR4?is=tGToStFT7pgVJ7sa
>>
>>18738534
In any case, my criminal record is clean (https://files.catbox.moe/bx5kxn.jpg), and the two months I was away from /his/ were spent registering to enter a law school to become a lawyer specializing in Digital Law and later a Federal Police Delegate.

I can take legal action against you by obtaining your IP addresses through a court order for claims of insult, defamation, and threats. Although you may believe you are protected by anonymity, 4chan maintains a strict data log retention policy and actively cooperates with judicial and law enforcement authorities, complying with formal orders (subpoenas), in cases involving legal violations. Once a court order is issued, the forum's administration will provide your IP addresses and timestamps. With this data, telecommunications carriers and Internet Service Providers (ISPs) are legally required to cross-reference traffic information and identify the account holder and physical address associated with the connection at the exact time of the post, effectively stripping away your anonymity for the purposes of civil and criminal liability.

By the way, do us a favor, keep posting these insults and cheap attacks against me, don't stop. Keep feeding this forum your daily dose of frustration, the more you type, thinking you're safe behind a screen on the other side of the world, the more precious material you hand me for free. I have all the patience in the universe to spend the coming months or years gathering, cataloging, and structuring every piece of evidence against you, building an absolutely flawless and irrefutable criminal dossier, right up until the day the bill for your keyboard courage finally arrives at your doorstep in an official capacity.
>>
>>18738255
They belligerentky Gish-gallop you with information they have spent a decade mono-maniacally researching and you haven't.
Everything else is propaganda around that.
>>
File: 1725545726160.gif (1.75 MB, 205x255)
1.75 MB GIF
>>18738554
And in case you don't yet grasp the depth of the hole you are digging for yourself, know that this pathetic attempt of yours to falsely accuse me of pedophilia crosses every legal boundary. Under international and comparative law, this is not merely ordinary defamation, it constitutes grave slander and malicious false accusation, among the worst forms of false representation and perjury in legal systems worldwide.

In the United States and international courts, falsely imputing a heinous crime of this magnitude to an innocent person is classified as Defamation Per Se, in such cases, moral damages and reputational destruction are presumed by law and require no effort to prove. The price you will pay for this stunt in a transnational civil lawsuit could easily run into the tens of thousands of dollars in punitive damages, court costs, and international legal fees.

That is not to mention the criminal implications, as a false accusation of this nature carries severe prison sentences that could see you incarcerated for years in a maximum-security facility.

Therefore, I repeat: Keep posting. Every new line you type adds to your financial liability and tacks on more months to your future criminal record.
>>
>>18738560
Seriously, myth-making is one of the things the dissident right excelled at and people pretend they wouldn't transmute shouting some mild-mannered redditors on twitter into submission as a total victory of their theories.
One of the instances where they use the ZOG-imposed information blackout on them to their advantage.
>>
File: haBenis.jpg (35 KB, 500x500)
35 KB JPG
>>18738534
>>18738554
>A Benis
kek :D
>>
>>18738276
Lazaridis be like:
>"we've solved the riddle of the aryan homeland and community and it looks absolutely nothing like those white supremacist chuds imagine"
>look at map of corded ware
>exactly like the white supremacist chuds imagined
>>
>>18738798
Well, it did change a bit. Chuds used to glorify Yamnaya, but now it seems, that the expansion started with a small group of people living in the Sredniy Stog culture. Which itself was one of CLV's daughter cultures. Still, I don't see how it could refute chuds.
>>
>>18738798
>Aggressively revise history to pretend some flanderized version of current concensus is what you believed all along.
>>
>>18738920
>but now it seems, that the expansion started with a small group of people living in the Sredniy Stog culture.
no it doesn't. The PIE language and culture are all about wheels and wagons, which Stog didn't have. Stog certainly had horse domestication, and possibly riding, but no wheels. There would be no reason for the PIE languages to have all the fundamental wheel vocabulary - kwekwlo, roteh, etc. - so deeply entrenched if they split off at Stog.

People just cling to Stog because Yamnaya kurgan burials don't have R1a and R1b-L151, but that could be easily explained as just saying the first generation of Yamnaya men who split off, crossed into Europe, and formed Corded Ware came from lineages that didn't get kurgan burials. They then got a bunch of Yamnaya women to join them, so that they became autosomally 80% Yamnaya.

There's no reason to push it back to Stog because R1a and R1b-L151 don't appear at Stog either! And the CLV stuff is just complete retardation from Lazaridis, a Pontic Greek open ethno-nationalist whose politics would coincidentally benefit hugely from CLV.
There are never any J haplogroups anywhere in Yamnaya or Corded Ware, it's all R and a tiny bit of Q.

The Proto-Anatolians, who did break off from Sredny Stog before Yamnaya and the wheel, obviously could have just ridden their horses along the Balkan route to get to Anatolia. We have pure steppe burials all the way through the Danubian valley and Moldova from the 5th century BC, it would have been a tiny hop (by PIE standards) for them to cross the Bosphorus into Anatolia. The CLV samples Lazaridis claims carried Hittite culture are just random stragglers who passed through the Caucasus.
>>
>>18738928
Corded Ware coalesced in temperate, forested Europe, not the steppe. Its men were all steppe men, and most of its women were steppe women, but their culture developed in forested Europe.

And they were the vector for the spread of 99% of modern Indo-European language, they were the reproductively successful ones, and their descendants replaced Yamnaya on the steppe to form Srubnaya.

Yamnaya has the sole claim to Greek, Albanian, and Armenian, but nothing else. Something significant happened when steppe men, who were not Core Yamnaya, left the steppe and entered Europe that lead to Rome, Britain, France, Germany, the Aryans, etc. Even modern Hindus carry a small trace of Western Hunter Gatherer DNA, because their ancestors lived in forested Europe, not just the European steppe.
>>
>>18738928
My personal favourite proposed IE homelands from the 19th century:
>The artic circle
> The Himalayan Foothills in India (India are wonned saar).
>Mesopotamia
>>
>>18738936
Doesn't actually adresss anything I said.
>>
>>18738948
I just presented you with the current academic consensus, which, in brief, is that Europe, including both the European steppe, but also crucially temperate forested Europe, is the Proto-Indo-European homeland.

It addressed what you said because your implication was that saying "Europe is PIE homeland and the white supremacists were right" was flanderizing the consensus
>>
no
>>
>>18738949
I'm also not revising history because Kossinna identified Corded Ware as the PIE homeland in 1902, and he was right.
>>
>>18738934
>Yamnaya kurgan burials don't have R1a and R1b-L151,
That premise is false and would only be held by people posing as genetics experts. L51 was present in Yamnaya, and the oldest CWC sample was L151 (a descendant of Yamnaya); the L52>BY44535 variant found in Yamnaya proves that L51 and its subclades were present there. See samples I1838 (Krasnosamarskoe-4, Volga), I12823 (Smeeni, RO [Catacomb?]), I6884 (Krestovyi, Rostov), and I12893 (Idzhil-2, Kalmykia) I20499 L52/P310 Zabalj-Medisova-humka (2880–2633 BC) = L51 (common)
- Oldest: SHT001 Afanasievo Shatar Chuluu (3112–2918 BCE), P310/L51, non-Z2103 L23, early Yamnaya grave(3333–3028 BC.
>hey then got a bunch of Yamnaya women to join them
This is no longer correct, as we now know that the Corded Ware culture possessed Yamnaya paternal lineages. It's time for you to stop spreading misinformation to people
>>18738936
>Corded Ware coalesced in temperate, forested Europe, not the steppe
CWC-X represents the transition from Yamnaya to early Corded Ware
Before the emergence of the Corded Ware Culture (CWC) around 2800 BCE, the Yamnaya already occupied western Ukraine and Hungary between 3100 and 3000 BCE, directly transmitting their steppe ritual traits—such as the use of ochre and pit burials—to CWC kurgans in Podolia, Volhynia, and Polish sites like Hubinek and Złota. There is no way to dissociate Corded Ware from the steppe.e R1b genetic lineage (L23 > L51 > L151) did not originate in Western Europe but rather on the steppe itself between 3300 and 3100 BCE
>>
>>18738949
The Huwhite supremacists were claiming a bit more than that. And you know it.
>>18738951
Corded Ware is not PIE though. You yourself said it when you said Greek, Albanian and Armenian were of Yamnaya descent. Further, the Anatolians and Tocharians are also part of separate groups that are neither Yamnaya or CW.
And obviously you know better than I that Kossinna's opinion is far from what we believe today. His Indo-Germanics find their origin in the North-Gemran plain, centered around Jutland, and not in the Eurasian steppe (where they actually come from, as you affirm) and the bordering woodlands, in his mind, the Ertebølle culture was Indo-european, and from the Mesolithic onward they would spread and begin building megalithic constructions. Which we now know it was not.
You are glossing over the incorrect particulars and focus on the generalities they got somewhat right. Plus you are confounding PIE and CW.
>>
>>18738928
>flanderized
BRAIN ROT ALERT!
>>
>spread of 99% of modern Indo-European language
I have never understood that argument. It almost sounds like a personal declaration of superiority lol Taken literally, the Bell Beaker culture would be responsible for the Italic and Celtic languages, while Andronovo would account for the Indo-Iranian ones—not CWC directly... so what? This is because the Bell Beaker culture replaced the CWC in the Rhine region and expanded across Northern Europe and even into Poland, leaving the CWC directly linked only to branches that did not survive, such as the Battle Axe culture. Furthermore, people are sometimes quite simplistic in their views. the presence of the Yamnaya paternal lineage R1b-Z2103 at Pepkino Hill (Abashevo) and the role of the Catacomb culture in the formation of the Srubnaya culture prove the survival and genetic continuity of these steppe lineages. The simplistic notion that the Yamnaya were simply wiped out must be discarded.
https://www.researchgate.net/publication/370414570_Ancient_DNA_of_the_Bearers_of_the_Fatyanovo_and_Abashevo_Cultures_Concerning_Migrations_of_the_Bronze_Age_people_in_the_Forest_Belt_on_the_Russian_Plain
>>
>>18738987
>>18738976
also meant to>>18738936
sorry
>>18738980
>Huwhite supremacists
you lost.
>tocharians are also part of separate groups that are neither Yamnaya
No. Afanasievo is the most promising candidate for the spread of Tocharian—or a related proto-language—and it derives directly from Yamnaya. Stop lying. Incidentally, Proto-Anatolian likely derives from the Cernavodă culture. The rest of his points are just delusions caused by imaginary evil white people.
>>
and the sperg has arrived to ruin the thread
>>
>>18738367
Pretty sure where I'm from we're just all slavs destined to wage attrition warfare forever.
>>
>>18739002
It appears our friend has ran out of erudite tirades and has reverted back to pretending he won and lol lmao.
>Afanasievo is the most promising candidate for the spread of Tocharian—or a related proto-language—and it derives directly from Yamnaya.
Huh, you are right. Thanks for correcting me. I was confused.
>Incidentally, Proto-Anatolian likely derives from the Cernavodă culture.
I thought the Jury was still out on that? How did the whole Caucasus-Lower-Volga thing resolve?
Anyway, none of this changes that if both Corded Ware and Yamnaya spawned branches of Indo-European, by definition, neither of the can be Proto-Indo-European (PIE), which means Kossinna was not correct.
>>
>>18739002
>The rest of his points are just delusions caused by imaginary evil white people.
Yeah, Kossinna's actual stated opinions he published are delusions because I hate Whitey (as illustrated by the fact I used an old /pol/ meme about how Jared Taylor speaks). I found a resume of his theory in english for us to enjoy. But I have unfortunately not been able to find a copy of the book.
https://www.academia.edu/143874307/Kossinna_the_Nordische_Gedanke_and_Swedish_Archaeology_Discourse_and_politics_in_German_and_Swedish_archaeology_1900_1950

>First, there is, in the north, a primitive hunter-gatherer population, which is replaced by an Indogermanic population, with a centre in Jutland (present-day Denmark) and Schleswig-Holstein, but eventually expanding into parts of southern and western Sweden and into Germany. This Indogerman population appears at the end of what we today call the Mesolithic period (the so-called Ertebölle phase), and they eventually start building megalithic monuments. In Kossinna's archaeology, migrations are a main element, and according to Kossinna the Indogermans made several migratory movements in various waves, including far down in present-day Germany.
Do note Indo-Germanic is an old term for Indo-european. And Kossinna is affirming they are to be found in Mesolithic Denmark.
This is part one, it's a long few paragraphs.
>>
>>18739223
>Then, there arrives from the far north an "Arctic Dobbertinner pre-Finn" culture, survivors of the old hunting-gathering population. This arctic population is particularly well adapted to cold climates, and they are very tough and good warriors. This population settles in Jutland and southern Scandinavia, and eventually mingles with the Indogermans of these areas. From this mix, the Finno-Indogermans emerge (1928:216), and come to dominate in southern Scandinavia and Denmark, while "pure" (previously migrated) Indogermans survived in Germany, for example in the region of Halle. The Finno-Indogermans used Boat Axes and Corded Ware ceramics, and buried their dead in individual burials of relatively simple construction (as compared to the megaliths). These Finno-Indogermans eventually migrate to Germany and there is a second mix, between Finno-Indogermans and pure Indogermans, in Germany. From this mix the Germans emerge, a culturally unified people, in 2000 BC, shortly before the beginning of the Bronze Age (Kossinna 1928:297).

All of this is, as my friend
>>
>>18738255
>are more knowledgable than them
they said you were more knowledgeable than archaeologists and museum professionals, not more knowledgeable than genetics
in other words, they're using you guys to throw shade at related fields for not studying genetics enough
>>
>>18739224
said, entirely in line modern day archeological and genetic concensus, I am sure.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.