[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: lrh-photo.jpg (45 KB, 500x590)
45 KB JPG
>You are an immortal spiritual being in a temporary body
Fact check: true
>Negative experiences cause irrational behaviour, emotional pain, and physical distress
Fact check: true
>You can learn to overcome these experiences and achieve rationality, inner peace and spiritual consciousness
Fact check: true
>The world we inhabit is only a flawed simulation of the true reality, that we have been trapped in by a malevolent being
Fact check: true
>All other religions are false
Fact check: true
>>
>>18740176
LMAO gtfo
>>
>>18740194
You are a suppressive person. You are not worth talking to, and you are not interested in the truth. But know that healing is possible, and this pain does not need to define you.
>>
>>18740197
Seek God
>>
>>18740221
Before you can understand the 8th dynamic, you must contend with the foundations, starting with yourself. My SP friend, you are not even close to finding yourself let alone finding God.
>>
>>18740223
Because I reject Scientology? God isn’t complicated, He incarnated as a peasant that taught people to be like children, you don’t need all this satanic machinery to be we
>>
>>18740227
Only that is not true, and deep down you know that isn’t true. But more importantly than that, is the philosophy promoted by Christianity is itself suppressive, as it is with ancient religions in general. It perpetuates the trauma that created it, which is why you see such suppressive behaviour by its members.
>>
>>18740176
Because Xenu never existed. He did not blow up volcanos 75 million years ago
>>
>>18740245
Tis but a metaphor to describe our earthly bondage in a way 20th century people can understand
>>
>>18740176
Anon that’s Gnosticism not Scientology
>>
>>18740251
Scientology is basically a kind of modern Gnosticism and it does teach all of the above
>>
>>18740254
NTA yeah but it's modern gnosticism for chumps
>>
>>18740176
>You can learn to overcome these experiences and achieve rationality, inner peace and spiritual consciousness
Yes, but the way that you try to do it is often harmful, abusive, and absurd.
>Only that is not true, and deep down you know that isn’t true.
Deep down, I know that it is.
>>
>>18740269
Gnosticism is for chumps. Its literally satan's last card if you didn't fall for any of his other bullcrap. All he's got is making you think you're in the heckin' wholesome rick and morty simulation
>>
>>18740281
>Its literally satan's last card if you didn't fall for any of his other bullcrap
First of all, it's Lucifer, Chud
Second of all, God is evil
>>
File: valentinus-1kiu29x.jpg (30 KB, 386x525)
30 KB JPG
>>18740281
Satan is the master of this world. Jesus will tell you the same thing.
>>
>>18740279
At that point though you’re not critiquing Scientology, the religion. You’re critiquing the church of Scientology. There are Protestant Scientologists in 2026
>>
>>18740297
sophistry
>>
>>18740298
Is it though?
You are not a member of the medieval Catholic Church.
>>
>>18740313
false equivalence
>>
>>18740321
How?
>>
>>18740289
that's because he's been deputized by God, not because he created anything, moloch
>>
>>18740323
Explain how the church of scientology is as different from what you call Scientology as the medieval Catholic Church is from Christianity.
>>
>>18740176
Your EO won't be pleased about you engaging in debate on Scientology online. Go to Ethics and do your conditions.
>>
>>18740328
Well scientology is a belief system and the church of scientology is an organisation. If you were a Christian in medieval times that does not necessarily mean belonging to or supporting the medieval Catholic church.
>>
>>18740251
The shortcut to a successful cult seems to be to just reskin some variety of Christianity.

Christianity imagines a worldwide flood sent by God to dramatically lower the population thousands of years ago, a disaster that may have left behind demons that possess people and need to be removed by exorcism (if you accept the Enoch expansion pack)? Uh... Let's say there was a *cosmic dictator named Xenu* *millions of years ago* who tried to dramatically lower the population by setting off bombs in volcanoes across earth, a disaster that left behind invisible "body thetans" who grab onto people, making them mentally and physically sick, and need to be removed by "auditing."
>>
>>18740342
>a disaster that left behind invisible "body thetans"
Not the belief. You are the Thetan, that is your real spiritual self, the MEST body is just a vehicle.
The lasting impact of Xenu’s genocide attempt is that we were brainwashed to forget our divinity.
>>
>>18740339
Scientology has yet to produce offshoots seeking to purify its doctrines - the church is effectively its belief system and vice versa. Thus anything that can be attributed to the church can be attributed to its beliefs.
>>
>>18740350
I'm just going off https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Body_thetan
>>
>>18740297
>Protestant Scientologists

Those are called Squirrels and LRH absolutely despised them.
>>
>>18740353
Wrong
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Zone_(Scientology)
>>
>>18740350
If it's all a metaphor, why do you think people need to be told that the spaceships looked identical to Douglas DC-8 aeroplanes? Why can't they just look like spaceships?
>>
>>18740355
If LRH was alive today he himself would be excommunicated because half the shit that is taught today is nowhere in the original teachings and certain things that were in the original teachings have been abandoned because it wasn't kosher enough.
>>
>>18740360
Is that who you represent?
>>
>>18740361
A functional spaceship does look like an aeroplane.
>>
>>18740366
That's not an organisation, there's just the general term for independent scientology.
>>
>>18740360
If you think these people are heretical, then it's a moot point anyway. Now, tell me, why do you think a belief system cannot be judged on the actions of the organisation that forms and disseminates that system?
>>
>>18740367
You said it's all metaphor here >>18740246 so what's the significance of the Douglas DC-8?
>>
>>18740176
>why does the religion explicitly made up as a con by it's founder, whose own sales pitch doesn't work, and has concentration camps for members who try to leave, get so much hate?
>>
>>18740380
It’s a vivid way to describe it to a contemporary imagination. Your point?
>>
>>18740373
Well you’re a Christian and you already said you don’t support the medieval Catholic Church so you tell me
>>
>>18740389
Where did I say that?
>>
Regular reminder that if you're Clear you should have perfect recall and therefore can say what's the 12th word on the 9th line of page 93 of Dianetics.
>>
>>18740391
You do support the medieval Catholic Church?
>>
>>18740393
Which edition?
>>
>>18740395
The comparison is ridiculous. The Catholic Church is a millennia old institution that spans the entire globe and has had billions of members historically. Its size and extent are a large part of why people do not judge Christianity itself when members of the Catholic Church commit heinous acts.

The same cannot be said for the Church of Scientology - it's a comparatively miniscule organisation, with little in the way of real development or innovation thanks to its youth. Corruption and abuse happen at all levels of the Church of Scientology, and Scientologists are a small enough set that they cannot simply plead ignorance.

As such, yes, your belief system can obviously be judged by the behaviour of your organisation as a whole, since that's what most influences its decision making.
>>
>>18740413
Okay so if scientology was literally the exact same organisation but it was older and bigger then the exact same belief system would be justified?
Do you see why that's retarded?
>>
>>18740419
>then the exact same belief system would be justified?
Not if the percentage of abusers remained the same as membership increased, no.
>>
>>18740422
At that point you’re just making the same argument about suppressive persons that LRH’s philosophy does. Which legitimises the whole point that Scientology is a belief system that can be discussed on the merits or failings of its philosophy itself.
Problem is people just want to discuss the church drama or the sci fi jargon. Which completely misses the point of why people actually join Scientology and persist in Scientologist beliefs even after leaving the church
>>
>>18740428
>we actually agree with you!
Uh huh.
>>
>>18740429
>completely does not engage with the point
>>
>>18740176
It's a scam and it's followers are retards who fell for the grift.
>>
>>18740519
That's every religion
>>
>>18740176
Scientology was originally just a parody religion started by a science fiction writer because parody religions were in-vogue in the mid 20th century (SubGenius et al) only he realized he could use it to launder money
>>
>>18740532
No proof of this btw



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.