[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: erfonedcoijwe.png (111 KB, 1500x1500)
111 KB PNG
how do you starve on a island surrounded by bleedin fishes?
>>
>>18785023
white people are not very smart as everyone can see nowadays
>>
>>18785048
fuck off dem loser
>>
>>18785023
>live 200 miles inland
>have a household of 5 people to feed
>no boat
>no nets
>no bait or tackle
>no port infrastructure
>no infrastructure to salt/freeze fish and move it inland
>laws giving landlords exclusive right to coastal water and rivers, patrolled by baliffs and guards
What's you're plan? You basically have 2-3 weeks before your children begin starving to death.
>>
>>18785023
They were forced to rely on lumper potatoes because they had the highest yield and most farmers owned very little land.
>>
File: 1754588051936_png(1).png (174 KB, 1228x1184)
174 KB PNG
Really glad I made this thread fucking forever ago.

Here's why, anon. Of course the actual answer is because Irish Americans kept taking the bait
>>
>>18785053
Ireland doesn't have a radius of 200 miles, idiot
>>
>>18785130
Change it to 100 and see if you can then understand the point.
>>
>>18785098
>screencapping your own post that got 0 (zero) replies
grim
>>
>>18785023
In case anyone wants a real answer to this meme, asking "why didn't they just fish" shows a fundamental misunderstanding about the nature of the famine. Ireland never ran out of food, causing people to starve while teeming seas were there for the taking. Crop failures just made the price of the remaining food significantly increase. During famine people would trade down to cheaper lower quality grains, like eating millet instead of wheat. However potatoes had been the cheapest food available, and prior to the famine the desperately poor were essentially eating only potatoes because it was all they could afford. So they had nothing to trade down to. Those who were desperately poor but able bodied went into workhouses, but if you got sick and couldn't work or were disabled then you were shit out of luck. These were the people who starved to death during the famine. Not people who could have just gone out and caught some fish.

The vast majority of the deaths during the famine were of people who were hungry but not starving, because food was too expensive to get enough of, so they became malnourished and died from disease. Malnourished people have weakened immune systems. This was also worsened by the fact that people were moving around a lot looking for work. Which meant they were not bathing or cleaning their clothes as much which helped foster sickness, and coming into contact with people from different areas which helped spread disease faster.
>>
>>18785145
In the thread itself I believe I literally posted saying that I specifically made it to screencap it to post in these faggy spammed meme threads.
>>
>>18785130
Are you a moron? Has more.
>>
>>18785048
I thought Irish weren't white till the 1960s or something though
>>
>>18785048
LMAO

The irish are not White
>>
>>18785023
So a farmer who has never seen the ocean before needs to learn to travel to the ocean, build a boat, learn to fish, and catch enough to feed his family all while having no food?
>>
>>18785623
Nobody thought this except a handful of Yanks and Brits. Most of the "muh Irish brute" propaganda was about the Fenian Movement (as it was very violent) and the only other real claim was by some American fella who says they only became white by joining the police and becoming raycist.

In reality, the Irish enjoyed privileged and often top-level military and political positions in France, Austria, Spain, and various of their new-world colonies or the nations that followed them (Mexico, Chile, Argentina, etc). Picrel, for example, is the Irishman William Brown from County Mayo who is considered the father of the Argentinian Navy+is one of the country's national heroes.
>>18785626
See above.
>>
>>18786451
Brown, the famous Irish Surname. As Irish as Doherty and Joyce and O'Neill.
>>
>>18786518
For an Irish Catholic, Brown is more likely to be a translation of Ó Duinn which is usually anglicised as Dunne than the English surname with the exact same meaning. Ironically though Joyce or Seoige isn't originally Gaelic, its Anglo-Norman
>>
>>18785626
Modern genetics have completely put this idea to bed. If you're going to argue that such a thing as a "white" race exists, there's no logical way to definite without including Irish people within it. They cluster completely with other Northwestern European populations have have no ancestry that isn't typical of that. In fact, Irish people have some of the highest rates of Western Steppe Herder ancestry in all of Europe.
>>
>>18785148
I read that potatoes were considered higher class food and many sold their fishing gear to buy bags of potatoes. Also the british took control of the fishing fleets and prohibited independent fishermen from going out to fish. Could be bullshit, i probably read it here years ago.
>>
>>18786556
Of course the white race exists, retard. There's nothing to argue. Hating the Irish was a national pastime for many a country so they were downgraded to pale cro-magnons, which isn't official. Phillipinos are considered the trash Asians and mud hut ooga booga Africans the trash blacks, but they're still Asian and black.
>>
>>18786644
So are the Irish white or not? And if not, how not?And if so, what makes them functionally distinct from other whites?
>>
>>18785623
Libtards and sh!tskins only do this bit when its convenient
>>
>>18785023
Ireland is proof race doesn't determine shit

Same genetics basically as master race anglos but only known for potatoes
>>
>>18787049
If Irish were in mesopotamia or the aegean even we would be on mars by now
>>
>>18785048
Haha
>>
>>18786518
What >>18786518 said. But if you're going to be a sperg about it, here are some others;
>Ambrosio O'Higgins
Captain General and later Viceroy of Peru.
>Bernardo O'Higgins
Son of the above, first leader of an independent Chile.
>Daniel O'Leary
Aide-de-camp of Simón Bolivar (and one of the main reasons papers detailing his life survived)
>Patrice de MacMahon
President of France. Descdended from the Uí Briain dynasty in Ireland, his family emigrated to France after Cromwell confiscated their lands.
>Leopold O'Donnell
Prime Minister of Spain, one of many O'Donnells who became prominent in the military or government in the generations following the Flight of the Earls.
>Alejandro O'Reilly
Born in Ireland, he was Inspector-General of the Spanish Infantry and Governor of Spanish Louisiana.
>Ricardo Wall
Secretary of State of Spain under Ferdinand VI and Charles III.
>Maximilian Ulysses Brown
Descended from the FitzGeralds (Hiberno-Normans exiled following their role in the Irish Alliance against England), he was an Austrian Field Marshal.
>Andreas O'Reilly
Governor of Vienna in 1809.
>Charles Edward Jennings
Origins in the Burkes who supported the Irish Alliance in Tyrone's Rebellion, he was famed for his charisma and for Napoleon's personal fondness for him; he was known as "Brave Kilmaine."
>Thomas Arthur, comte de Lally
Brigadier and Marshal of France.
>Peter Lacy
Hiberno-Norman origins and part of the Wild Geese, he reached General-Feldmarshal-one of the highest ranks in the Russian Empire's Military and had an incredibly famous military career across several decades.
>Joseph Cornelius O'Rourke
Lieutenant-General in Russia famous for his campaigns against the Ottomans.
>Maximilian Karl Lamoral O'Donnell
Austrian officer who saved the life of Emperor Franz Josef I after he cut down an assassin with his sabre.

The list goes on and on. Like I said, the idea of the Irish as some backwards apes is a cope by England who needed justification to conquer them.
>>
>>18786568
>potatoes were considered higher class food
Nah. Started off in a that sort of way like many imports of new world crops but by the 19th Century they had become a staple food of the poor because of how easy they were to grow in abundance.
>many sold their fishing gear to buy bags of potatoes
Yes, because when crops failed people were instantly facing starving to death in the winter. It wasn't some sort of "we love potatoes" but rather "we have *nothing* to eat and need money now."
>the british took control of the fishing fleets and prohibited independent fishermen from going out to fish
Sort of but this wasn't really non-standard practice. The real problem was that Irish Fisheries were horrifically underfunded and under-developed and there existed no real infrastructure to allow for a sudden enormous increase in the number of fish either being caught, or stored, or transported. The thing these memethreads miss is that many DID fish; most people in Ireland did not die or emigrate, but many did.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.