It is quite curious how when you read Irenaeus and then read the Gnostic Gospels, you’ll find that nearly all of Irenaeus’ arguments are already addressed in them. So in other words, it’s not even a matter of debate, Irenaeus either misunderstood Gnosticism or he intentionally created a strawman.Furthermore, core Gnostic beliefs are already detailed in the works of Plato, so to reject Gnosticism is to throw away centuries of Greek philosophy.
>>18786183Even better, the Manichaeism pill
>>18786183>Furthermore, core Gnostic beliefs are already detailed in the works of Plato, so to reject Gnosticism is to throw away centuries of Greek philosophy.Good, Plato was a retard who said retarded shit.
>>18786318what's life in fujian like, anon?
>>18786183The thing about Gnosticism is it was part of an explosion of writings related to the Christ Cult that could kind of say anything.The persons and writings who ultimately won out were the ones in favor of, or at least compatible with, centralizing authority.It basically doesn't matter if Irenaeus was right or wrong in various details, but that he was effective in building a popular coalition.Also the whole reason that the Christ Cult was so influential was that it got past all the bullshit theology that came out of Hellenism, so in that way it was coherent to reject Gnosticism as much as possible.
>>18786543Idk. Maybe warmer than here
>gnostic pill>posts a hermetic picthe absolute state of the gnostic charade
>>18786828The Corpus Hermeticum was found amongst the Nag Hammadi codex