[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


>be a nation of millions of people
>50 white dudes arrive on a rotting ship from halfway across the globe
>they immediately conquer everything in sight
>Savage warlords convert to Christianity at the mere sight of The Cross
>50 years later the entire continent is Christian and is speaking Spanish
How did they do it? It feels like nowadays we can't force 3rd worlders to do shit with all the modern technology at our disposal when I am pretty sure we could convince 3rd worlders to worship an AI if we wanted to. By comparison the arrival of 1 beefy American ship completely rapefucked Japan's economy and sparked the civil war which ended the Tokugawa shogunate. What the fuck?
>>
File: IMG_3015.jpg (23 KB, 250x376)
23 KB JPG
They say some of these men are still going around conquering fresh fertile land to this day.
>>
File: IMG_2263.jpg (195 KB, 1170x2109)
195 KB JPG
>>18786262
>What really happened

>White guys beat some shitty islands natives. Went to the land now known as Mexico all cocky, then got their ass kicked by Aztecs. Had to partner with Natives next door that had a massive fighting force of tens of thousands. They were the key to winning war against Aztecs.

The Spanish then split the spoils with those natives who helped. The king granted those Natives Royal titles and grants as long as they agreed to he Catholic which they did. The Spanish then mixed with them and now that is the elites of Mexico city that run the country.

Also along the way diseases from Spain rampaged through Mexico and both North and South America. Which had population loses of up to 90%. So it was easy for the mixed Spanish/Native people called Mestizoz to unify Mexico into one country.


Its unreal how lucky the Spanish got
>>
>>18786262
The Philippines are not a continent
>>
>>18786273
Reminder Aztecs collapsed due to a coalition led by ~300 Spaniards
Imagine how much easier if an armada had landed there
>>
Be white dude, circumnavigate the world. Lose 70% of your crew. Finally arrive at destination. Behave like a fucking hooligan and dont even survive for 1 month.

Pathetic.
>>
>>18786262
If your idea of conversion is to just have the chief do a ritual for Christ it's really easy to spread a religion.
>>
>>18787006
When the circumnavigation was complete and they arrived at their destination they were back in Spain numbnuts
>>
File: images (45).jpg (8 KB, 225x225)
8 KB JPG
>>18786273
I get that the Spanish partnered with different native groups who had been subdued and forced to pay tribute by the Aztecs. What I do not understand is why did these same natives who were key to the war effort eventually just become an opressed group under the caste system.

Like why? did they just accept that? there is this faggot in Mexico who basically just tries to say Mexico wasnt conquered by the Spanish and actually it was this super wholesome egalitarian spanish catholic partnership between natives and spaniards and that the founding fathers of latin america were members of English masonic lodges and that anglos just wanted to split to empire so that it would be easier for America to take land from Mexico.

But yeah that is obviously at least partially bullshit.

TLDR: why did natives who were key to the conquest effort eventually become a lower caste than the Spaniards, why did they accept or why were they forced to accept that.
>>
>>18787144
Spoiler: The victorious one didn't, at least on paper. Many were betrayed though.
Tlaxcallans, the guys who won against the Aztecs, got to settle scross all of the Spanish North America during the 16th century. There were large waves of tlaxcallans migrating into what is today Guatemala and Texas. Tlaxcala to this day is still a Mexican state and it pretty much was its thing up until Mexico became independent and they had to absorb the Tlaxcallans, framing them as "traitors" by the way.
What happened is simply demographics got in the way.
Disease killed most of the natives and latinx simply multiply non stop. So eventually Tlaxcala just became mestizo.
That's not the full tale though. Other groups like the Kaqchikel Maya who were initial allies to the Spanish were later betrayed by them (Pedro de Alvarado's antics), and they fought a 6 year long guerrilla war. Mayans were simply overwhelmed by the sheer amount of Tlaxcallans and Spanish gunpowder. There's a reason you see a lot of Nahuatl names in Mayan soil.
>>
>>18786847
A total.of over 3000 Spaniards participated in the conquest of the Aztec Empire, an entire half of whom died, including most of Cortez' few hundred initial men that gave rise to that myth in the first place

>>18787144
Because these were not jungle tribals. The native allies of the Spanish were also "civilized" natives who had cities and a nobility. Said nobility did in fact often receive many privileges and even get integrated into the ruling Spanish nobility, or at the very least were able to live comfortably, and those who didn't were used to the idea of being vassals to a foreign ruling, as were the peasants, in virtue of the fact everybody in the region was already conquering one another
>>
>>18787109
As goes the quote form the classic Bulgarian movie (also known as that one movie where every censoring agency across the world for some reason ignores the boy cocks featured at 8:18:
https://youtu.be/n5LPdV-V3xM?si=oZhx-ON0dpva7BSH)

"I know you won't carry the faith in your hearts but your grandchildren will be more righteous than the Imams of Mecca"
1:20:18

And isn't that so - today the Phillipines is on of the most radical catholic nations on the globe. Art imitates life and all that.
>>
File: Bernal Diaz del Castillo.jpg (268 KB, 1200x1200)
268 KB JPG
>>18786262
>How did they do it?
The natives in america already believed whites were a holy people that represent God, so when some showed back up again they immediately submitted to their rule.
>>
>>18787543
Except the first contact between europeans and mesoamericans consisted of the Maya enslaving two shipwrecked Spaniards and subsequently wiping out the first proper expedition to the mainland, and after that the contact between the Spaniards and natives continued being quite violent, which y'know is why the conquest of the Aztec Empire was famously a big war, as were all the subsequent wars of conquest people don't talk about as much
>>
After winning it's independence in 1821, first under Iturbide's empire and later as a republic, two political camps arose on how to govern Mexico. The conservatives wanted to preserve the old viceroyal era social order with the Military and the Church at the top with the indios at the bottom, each with their own legal fueros, rights and priviledges, all under a european monarch. The Liberals wanted to enforce secularism, compulsory education, equality under the law, and abolish all colonial era legal distinctions and priviledges to create a nation-state under a single Mexican identity.

The Liberals under Juarez would win over the conservatives, and later Porfirio and the Revolutionary Caudillos would create the basis for the modern

In 1810, just before independence, Mexico was 60% indigenous, a century later just before the revolution, it was 39%, today it's only around 10%
>>
>>18787655
*Modern Mexican nation
>>
>>18787576
thats a bunch of bullshit, american civilization was built by whites that basically went extinct which caused their civilization there to collapse into degenerate savagery.
>>
>>18787661
Even if that were true, it would be irrelevant to the conversation at hand, which is about the Spanish conquest of the Americas, which did objectively feature a whole lot of war in virtue of the fact that the natives did not immediately submit to their rule as you claimed
>>
File: 1731456406348207.png (219 KB, 546x404)
219 KB PNG
>>18787694
Yeah they did, the brown king of the south americans bowed down to the whites from europe without a fight and the only reason there was any bloodshed at all is that the spanish didn't know how to accept the crown being offered
>>
>>18787655
>Liberals under Juarez
Cuck to U.S. interest
>>
>>18787715
I assume that you're talking about Montezuma's supposed surrenfer to Cortez. In which case... you're still wrong

First of all, Montezuma wasn't "king of the south americans", for one because Mesoamerica sits entirely within North America and not South America, and most importantly because he was actually the king of what was ultimately nothing more than a powerful city-state that held a loose alliance and hegemony over a relatively large but definitely not absolute portion of Mesoamerica. He was certainly powerful, but didn't even have absolute power outside Tenochtitlan's immediate limits, let alone the whole region and continent. That also means that you're ignoring the many conflicts between the Spanish and other natives both before and after the conquest of the Aztecs. The Tlaxcaltecs attacked the Spaniards on sight, as did the Maya during the Hernandez de Cordoba expedition, and many other groups during the conquests of Oaxaca, Colima, Guatemala, the Huaxteca, etc. The Conquest of the Aztec Empire was not the conquest of Mexico, which was not the conquest of New Spain, which was of course not the conquest of the New World as a whole

And secondly, the surrender itself is, for obvious reasons, a topic of hot debate. It was likely just Cortez' embellishment and fabricated legal background to justify the conquest in the eyes of Spanish authorities, and even if it did happen, Montezuma's welcoming attitude towards the Spaniards enraged a large part of the Mexica population enough for them to have supposedly killed him themselves, and again, Montezuma did not have authority anywhere outside the Triple Alliance's hegemony, so it's not as if he was speaking on behalf of anyone but himself
>>
>>18787740
>a topic of hot debate
you mean a topic of endless seethe and cope from brownoids who can't accept reality, like you
>>
>>18787759
>who can't accept reality
Ironic accusation coming from the guy who refuses to acknowledge the well-documented history of the Spanish Conquest of the Americas from before and after the Fall of Tenochtitlan and seems to think that Montezuma II held absolute power over a continent whose existence he didn't even know of
>>
>>18787766
All I expect from you is what I know you'll provide, endless cope and seethe because your brown ass can't accept reality.
>>
>>18787773
No, please, do explain to me in detail how the Spanish accounts of wars against native americans in and out of Mexico that happened before and after Montezuma's meeting with Cortez actually didn't happen, or if they did, how they resulted from the Spanish not knowing how to accept submission properly

Did the Aztecs psychically communicate with the Mapuches over in Patagonia and tell them about how the Spanish "didn't know how to accept the crown being offered"? How come the Maya chieftain who killed Hernando de Cordoba did what he did years before Montezuma met Cortez, did he predict the future? Why didn't he offer the crown himself? I'm genuinely curious

Also, i can't help but notice the first picture you posted itt is named after Bernal Diaz de Castillo, a guy who describes in his account several skirmishes and battles against natives before they ever got to Tenochtitlan, so what was up with that?



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.