[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Frog_stare.jpg (96 KB, 976x761)
96 KB JPG
>"Fascist regimes are le epic third way!"
>*looks inside*
>its just opportunistic bonapartist regimes that gets obliterated if they stop being lapdogs for banksters
>>
>>18787323

Socialism-Communism are Feudalism/Monarchism in decay.
>>
>>18787323
>bonapartist regimes
nonsensical marxist twaddle
>>
>>18787415
>Opportunist military leader presents himself in troubled times and present himself as the arbitral figure between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie
>Actually brought to power by the bourgeoisie who gives him political power to preserve their ownership
>military leader sees the global capitalistic hegemony prevents him from developping too much and forces him to stay a lapdog
>tries to break free and gets obliterated by hostile forces

The same pattern can be applied to any bonapartist/fascist regime, from Napoleon the first to Hitler, the only fascist countries that survived were the ones that were lapdogs to bankers, such as Franco, Pinochet or Salazar
>>
>>18787425
>>Opportunist military leader presents himself in troubled times and present himself as the arbitral figure between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie
literally no fascist leaders were like this. None of them came as high-ranking military leaders leading a military coup of the state. Fascism is basically just Marxist heresy. You're also repeating this normie retarded "fascism is capitalism in decay" slop when Fascism very clearly comes out of the left wing socialist circles.

youre clearly some historically illiterate lelddit dork with the most lukewarm, surface level takes you got from your douchebag community college history professor. You're using buzzwords you clearly dont know the meaning of. Do yourself a favor and just google who Giovannie Gentile was.
>>
>>18787413
Class antagonisms didn't wait feudalism to exist, the optimates and populares war lasted a century from gracchus reforms to caesar coup and Augustus reign, roman empire corporatism lasted for four centuries because it could extend itself infinitely to the east and north, and crumbled because it could not go further past parthian/persian territory
>>
>>18787435
>literally no fascist leaders were like this. None of them came as high-ranking military leaders leading a military coup of the state
Franco?
>>
>>18787435
The difference between bonapartists and fascists is that fascists comes from the bottom to the top, but both are funded by capitalist funds and the relation of productions building their access to power are the same, fascists pretend to be anticapitalists then destroy the anticapitalist wing of their organization by a coup (night of the long knives, pact of the vidoni palace)

>Giovanni Gentile
He was considered as a meme even in his own party
>>
>>18787438
not a Fascist, neither was Salazar either who dismissed the ideology as "Pagan Ceaserism"
>>
>>18787445
youre just spouting bullshit derived from hackfrauds like Ecco. Leftist trying to scrub their clear and obvious connection to Fascism. Mussolini was a socialist and ardent leftist, not some capitalist. His Italy held the most industry ownership in the world at the time save only the Soviet Union. Fascism is just an offshoot of socialism.
>>
>>18787452
also, Italy under Mussolini was the first country in the world to recognize the Bolshevik government
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italo-Soviet_Pact
>>
>>18787452
Mussolini was a social-chauvinist opportunist, its like calling Bismarck a socialist because he established the first welfare system

>His Italy held the most industry ownership in the world
Mussolini massively privatized the industry until 1929, he just bailed out these industries after that, and turned the economy to an economy of war
>>
>>18787463
>its like calling Bismarck a socialist because he established the first welfare system
no it not. Mussolini was literally part of the socialist party, worked as a publisher of socialist newspapers, and was a very high-profile figure in the Italian left. He was named by his parents, also socialist, after Benito Juarez, the socialist president of Mexico.

And once again, other than the Soviet Union, Fascist Italy held the highest percentage of state-owned industry in the world. The entire civil structure of government of Fasicst Italy to the Soviet Union to the time was nearly identical. In operation, Fascism and Communism are the same thing, even down to workers unions. In both communist and fascist states, independent workers unions are banned, and all workers must join the state and therefore party vanguard union instead. The All-Union Central Council of Trade Unions in the USSR and Fascist Syndicates in Italy. Both also poured massive resources into their military as well, the Soviet Union mainted the highest amount of GDP allocated to the military after the war until its collapse. Before WW2, only Nazi Germany and Japan outpaced them in this area, but the Soviets were in third place but Stalin ramped it up to like 30% in 1940, when he was allied with Germany.

Again, you have no fucking clue what youre talking about. Youre just repeating lelddit tier normie takes.
>>
>>18787458
Mussolini tried to break free from capitalist hegemony that prevented him from taking conquering already taken territories such as Corsica, Tunisia or Ethiopia, he was isolated from the league of nations after the Ethiopian invasion and he made a pact with USSR, so did Hitler or even US after operation barbarossa, ideology has very little to do with realpolitik and class alliances
>>
>>18787323
The promise of fascism and fascist-adjacent ideologies tends to be that a strongman will cut through all the inertia imposed on the country and its people by a decadent and ideologically compromised bureaucratic oligarchy. The idea is that by cutting through that inertia, the country will either reach new heights or rediscover old ones. This is often a very attractive proposition because that critique of the bureaucratic oligarchy is typically grounded in reality.

What tends to happen with time though once they gain power is that the country gets taken over and looted by the strongman's cronies; corruption caused by cronyism stifles growth and innovation; and institutional competency collapses because the strongman values loyalty over merit. The strongman crushes anything that could be a popular alternative in order to preserve his rule. He consolidates power over private capital in his country - going after anyone who doesn't submit, seizing their assets, and passing them on to his cronies.

While the old bureaucratic oligarchy is indeed smashed in this situation, it typically gets replaced by a new one that is even more compromised and dysfunctional than what it replaced. The state's creditworthiness tanks because it devolves into a gangster economy where your investments are never truly secure. The economy then ends up getting wrecked but if the fascist has sufficient authoritarian control, there's no way for the public to turn the situation around and dislodge him.

All of this is to say that "being lapdogs for banksters" isn't really what saves you as a fascist. Your ability to exert authoritarian control is.
>>
>>18787473
>economy of war is communism
The fascist economy of war still had a vertical distribution, from the exploited people to the core national (or racial) people from top to down, starting with the rich industrial to the basic worker citizen, the USSR economy only redistributed the wealth from the nomenklatura loyal to stalin and the party, then distributed the rest of the wealth to the population without intermediary class such as industrials or bankers, fascist regimes maintained the capitalistic structures, it was just under a planified war economy which goal was to create a giant autosuffisant territory like the US



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.