[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: Auguste_Comte.jpg (413 KB, 1280x1644)
413 KB JPG
>"Facts over your feelings"
>"13/50"
>"271K"
>"The statistics don't lie"
>"You've been redpilled"
Why are so many right wingers obsessed with positivism? Do you genuinely think political victory is achieved by repeating statistics and empirical observations until everyone acknowledges them?
Think about how ridiculous this looks from a historical perspective: Imagine telling a 19th-century man that women are intellectually inferior to men, or presenting him with statistics about racial criminality, as if you're revealing some groundbreaking discovery. Do you think Hegel didn't already know about this? These weren't exactly novel ideas to the people of his time.
The same goes for the Jewish Question. It had been discussed for centuries. Henry Ford, Rockwell and countless others circulated the same info about Jewish influence. Rothschild, Goldman Sachs, Lehman Brothers and the concentration of financial power were discussed, written about and depicted in political posters long before the internet.
What did endlessly repeating these claims and observations achieve? What makes you think reposting the same statistics today is going to accomplish something fundamentally different?
People have known about these things for generations. They didn't need your fucking infographic.
At some point you have to ask yourself whether you're actually doing politics or just collecting statistics and congratulating yourself for being redpilled. Positivitism never works. If facts and statistics alone were enough to change society, obesity and smoking would've disappeared decades ago, and nuclear energy wouldn't still be such a contested issue.
>>
>>18787332
The entire reason these things ceased to exist is because there was no “positivism” (nonsense word) in the first place
If they had an empirical basis then for these things at the time they would have had a legal basis to prevent feminism, mass immigration etc permanently
>>
>>18787332
Not /his/ but antiwhite mods will probably leave it up anyway
>>
>What did endlessly repeating these claims and observations achieve?
To identify the root cause of greater social misery. The reason you keep hearing it is because people are unwilling to accept certain conclusions, regardless of the data, due to the severe social and political implications.

It's rhetoric to give your ideology legitimacy, like anything else. Especially when an enormous component of post-WW2 western ideologies is the idea that comforting lies are institutionally propped up in order to prevent nativist movements and white/male self-advocacy.

>What makes you think reposting the same statistics today is going to accomplish something fundamentally different?
Seems to work from what I can tell.

>At some point you have to ask yourself whether you're actually doing politics or just collecting statistics and congratulating yourself for being redpilled
Data and empirical truth are effective ways of persuading people to your cause.

>If facts and statistics alone were enough to change society, obesity and smoking would've disappeared decades ago, and nuclear energy wouldn't still be such a contested issue.
False dichotomy. These things are currently trending downwards particularly because decades of data is slowly convincing people just how harmful these things are. It's naive to insist that this data hasn't had any meaningful effect on public perception just because some people continue to smoke and overeat despite knowing it's not good.
>>
>>18787332
It's an attempt to depoliticize their ideas and opinions and give them the invulnerability of scientific fact. To have their preferred political program be considered 'scientific' and thus unideological. It's an attempt to wash-off the stigma normally associated with those positions.
And desu in the 19th century modern statistics about racial criminality would have been groundbreaking. Mostly because statistics was only barely taking the form we know today back then. Affirming blacks were dumber than Whites, not so much.
The Jewish question is actually really new. Hating the Jews is old, but the specific framing of the Jewish question (what is to be done about the Jews as a people?) comes after Jewish emancipation in the early 19th century and the rise of romantic nationalism. From this time we also get the term 'anti-semite', which has racial connotations in opposition to older forms of Jew-hating that were (ideologically) motivated primarily by religious reasons.

>What did endlessly repeating these claims and observations achieve?
The systematic reinforcement of those beliefs in culture, politics, etcetera. Which lead to tangible policies, institutions, actions, and cultural productions. But these beliefs were established and accepted well before anyone bothered to create a scientific justification for them.
>What makes you think reposting the same statistics today is going to accomplish something fundamentally different?
The aim is to break the concensus and influence society at large to inch toward the desired ideological positions. Though it depends. Not all of them have the same goals.
>>
>>18787372
I never said it wasn't effective at all, I just it was ineffective if you're attempting to change society to adopt your ideology.
>>
>>18787332
Loliberts aren't right wing
>>
I'm right-wing, that means I'm a progressive interested in the future of the human race. Why would I care what someone from the 19th century would think of my politics? They're all dead and gone.
>>
>>18787332
And a 17th century absolutist would have laughed a 19th century nationalist or communist out of the room, and a 15th century Florentian republican would have thought a 17th century absolutist was a completely backwards faggot, and a 13th century feudalist would have wondered why the republican was so keen on banking and poisoning his family members, and....

Notice how all of them just did what they felt right at the time and had courage in their convictions and weren't swayed by some retarded appeal to Having a Normal One
>>
>>18787372
holy schizophrenia
>>
File: 1785849036895532.png (116 KB, 2312x772)
116 KB PNG
>>18787392
this never works because chuddies opinions are not scientific so they are rejected and common men don't care about science anyway so they are getting the worst out of two outcomes
>>
File: transfolx.png (219 KB, 1494x750)
219 KB PNG
>>18787332
It's more of a statement than a naive attempt to convince a deranged troon he isn't a real woman. The media depicts us as a bunch of doofus rednecks, but when they see us talking about biology and the XX/XY chromosome it throws them off, it wasn't what they were expecting. They will cope, they will seethe, they will use their emotional appeals and logical fallacies, but deep down it kills them inside, deep down it gradually dawns on them that we are actually right. It might take years, but we planted the seeds.
>>
>>18787332
its something they just say to make themselves feel superior, similiar to how a bunch of teens will tell their family some pop history/science fact that they think only they and a handful of other people know, except in this case its extremely edgy shit and shit they will never actually try to seriously argue in public due to a combination of social backlash and the ever real threat somebody gets bored and challenges their views in which case they often can't argue for long since they really don't have that much knowledge on said subject that holds up hence why they stick with arguing with internet communists since they are pretty much in the exact same scenario but red
>>
>>18788606
obsessing over trans people is also a big part of why nobody takes altrighters seriously anymore
>>
>>18787332
Comte isn't that kind of positivism though. Whatever really happened there from philosophical standpoint I don't know, but Comte is sort of the world will turn into scientific utopia through the power of progress, later logical positivists also believed this but developed tools that allowed to deconstruct progress in a non-continental fashion(if you're serious about Popper then you have to assume that progressive historiography for instance is pseudoscience by his definitions, Popper would've probably disagreed but who cares about him).
A lot of the statistical arguments are good way of gaining valuable members who actually do arrive to their beliefs by reasons. They will not be fanatics who will die for ideology but it will chip away at the foundational myths of the society.
I for instance was redpilled by race and IQ stuff. It was obvious that at the time when I got into it(circa 2014) every reasonable person must have simply concluded that the hereditarians were right and the I fucking love science there is one race people were just morons repeating slogans, and guess what I don't like repeating slogans.

Ever since I've got a lot of more solid foundations for my belief so the psychometry stuff doesn't concern me that much but here's how right wingers gained top 5% income dude who just wanted to follow what was true.
>>
>>18787392
> The systematic reinforcement of those beliefs in culture, politics, etcetera. Which lead to tangible policies, institutions, actions, and cultural productions. But these beliefs were established and accepted well before anyone bothered to create a scientific justification for them.
What’s the basis behind the 271K? To make a point that if Jewish people can lie about such a well known statistic then you can shift that into being that they’ve lied about everything?

I’ve never seen this debated coherently by chuds btw.
>>
File: HUYX1XsXMAAqnKO.jpg (94 KB, 900x891)
94 KB JPG
>>18788692
We grew up in an environment where we were force-fed the fairy tales of the holohoax gas chambers and cremation ovens as well as jew-made lampshade skin and soap through hollywood holohoax sad opera films by (((spielberg)))
Sorry shlomo but americans are noticing and waking up and in the next decade or two, a major revolution will occur against the jews and we will win



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.