Learning about the CLV cline and how they mixed with anatolian neolithic farmers is eye-opening. It means anatolia was genetically identical to europe because the ancestral components in both regions were the same. Only turkic invasions created a new population disconnected from european genetics.But this is talked about very little in the mainstream
>>18787810>CLV clineNot even a real thing. The narrative created by Lazaridis et al. that the Caucasus-Lower Volga gradient is closely linked to the "Indo-Anatolian" and Proto-Anatolian expansions is not very convincing. The CLV gradient is just an artifact of isolation caused by distance, acting with much chronological overlap over thousands of years in a vast and culturally and linguistically diverse landscape, and of course it includes a wide range of populations that generally have no relation to each other and that did not even spoke Indo-European.Yediay's preprint presents a very weak PCA and low-quality visualization, but it appears that the ancestry of the steppes in northwestern Anatolia comes from something close to Barcin_C, which is not surprising considering kurgans and migratory routes already proposed by some archaeologists. Central Anatolia seems to receive an influx of something in the middle of this cline to the Kulluoba samples. One of the samples with steppe influence is also I-L699, a steppe clade obviously. In Kalehoyuk we find I-S1295.
>>18787832So.. Balkan theory confirmed after all?!>>18787810Your point is?
>>18787838Cernavoda, yes. But there's a catch here. There are two A/B clusters of Cernavoda I. Their origin in the steppes wasn't homogeneous because cluster B shows that groups from the North Caucasus must have participated in their origin. Cluster A obviously formed from both the "Sredni Stog" (not really a homogeneous belt, by the way) proper and an influence from the lower Volga.
>>18787844>>18787832>Cernavoda>Proto-Anatolian Kek no
>>18787846no arguments here. Do you want to continue the discussion or are you going to keep babbling? Suvorovo is a derivative of the early Serednii Stih, or Skelya phase. There is also a direct connection between Cernavoda and Usatove with Yamnaya in a rather harmonious way, anyway. Proto-Anatolian is not as mysterious as you guys make it seem. This would coincide with the movement of Copper from the Balkans into the Steppe according to Rassamakin.
>>18787853Yeah anon, sure. "Proto-Anatolian" pops with less than 20% steppe! would be responsible for spreading the culture and language. Nice theory bro. Just say, Anatolia is a nighmare for the steppe hypothesis
>>18787857>no arguments againSo, what are you talking about? What "nightmare"? The objection was the supposed lack of steppe ancestry in Anatolia, but since Lazaridis, not only have traces of this ancestry been found, but also steppe markers. This is without mentioning the clear archaeological presence in areas of Anatolia, including with kurgans. How about stopping trolling? Cernavoda remains the main candidate for the origin of Proto-Anatolian until proven otherwise.The eastern route for the migration of Proto-Anatolians to Anatolia is much less likely if we consider that all the intermingling with the southern Caucasus in the steppe was not involved in the formation of Indo-Anatolian, as Lazaridis erroneously claims. Maikop groups and those related to them were not speakers of Indo-Anatolian languages. There are no alternatives. Before you say anything, Berezhnovka is not a suitable either.
>>18787857>south Caucasus homeland >in 2026LMAO
>>18787866>>18787864Ah yes, the schizophrenic Italian strikes again with his unfounded delusions based solely on "trust me, bro." After that thread where you did mental gymnastics with Andronovo and random materaj cultures and linked them to generic samples, it's already been proven that you're a storyteller. How are you so sure that Cernavoda is PA? Are you literally using two low-quality SNP samples that aren't homogeneous to create a retarded theory? The Western hypothesis is far from proven, and a migration to the South Caucasus isn't out of the question.
uh oh lots of melties
>>18787950You lost