[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: carthago.jpg (121 KB, 736x484)
121 KB JPG
How did Carthage of all places prove to be the greatest challenge to the Romans rather than any of the successor kingdoms?
On one side you have a trading empire who mostly relied on foreign mercenaries to fight their battles and on the other are the inheritors of Alexander's conquests. But no the punic wars, at least the first two, are the defining conflicts of the Roman Republic.
The first Macedonian war is barely a footnote during the second Punic war, the Seleucid war is barely brought up either even though Hannibal himself fought in in it too, and Egypt became a province of the empire without even a fight. Pyrrhus too if we want to go back that far was bested by the Romans.
How did the Punes do what the Diadochi couldn't?
>>
I have an intense hatred for carthage and everything about it
>>
File: catosays.png (194 KB, 420x585)
194 KB PNG
>>18788304
>>
>>18788263
>How did Carthage of all places prove to be the greatest challenge to the Romans rather than any of the successor kingdoms?
Dido prophesied it when Aeneas was leaving
>>
>>18788263
The Carthaginians were not only more wealthy, but even despite being mainly mercantile, more militaristic. For decades they had engaged in their own expansion wars in Iberia and had many able commanders willing to take the mantle. They could muster more manpower from their own cities than nearly all the Diadochi, and that's not counting their allies and nearly the entire mercenary population of the western Mediterranean that they could afford indefinitely. The scale of the second Punic War was so massive that there literally wasn't enough men to engage in warfare by the final years, there was nobody left to muster or pay for.
Hannibal might have been the celebrity general for the Punic side, but they have many other generals who could lead competently as in the campaigns in Iberia.
>>
shame they destroyed the city
could have been a cool place in the modern era
>>
>>18788263
I agree with you OP its always confused me. The Punics were weaklings to the core.

If anything it utterly vindicates Great Man Theory. Its literally just Hannibal. Thats it. One man fought Rome. The first punic war was just carthage getting buttraped on land and surviving on sea only because of built up advantage and then somehow getting buttraped on sea which is genuinely embarassing for a naval power with centuries.

But the Second Punic War had Hannibal and he was Built Different. One gigachad. The only semite to vindicate his race.
>>
>>18788263
>How did Carthage of all places prove to be the greatest challenge to the Romans rather than any of the successor kingdoms?
It's actually pretty simple.

Rome's strength wasn't that their soldiers were just better than their contemporaries, although this proved to be true several times. Beyond that however we know that individual troop quality is seldom what wins large wars of attrition. Even back then supply and logistics were more important to long term victory than how often your soldiers trained or what equipment they had. True, modern factories and supply chains weren't as prevalent. But the ability to feed your society, have free hands, supply your soldiers with equipment of uniformly passable quality, and get those men to the battlefield as many times as was necessary, these are what won Rome's wars. And there's two ways to get all that. One way was Rome's way with a large society that was very martial and valued both a warrior mindset and dogged resistance with a large surplus population of idle hands.

The other was Carthage's. With money to hire idle sword hands from your own population, your neighboring population, and everywhere else.

Both solved the problem of raising men to fight quickly and effectively against your enemies and do it again, and again, and yet again if need be. But Rome's was better as it had the structure for the procurement from the bottom all the way up and on top of it could also reinforce its citizen soldiers with mercenaries and allies. Carthage couldn't. At least as far as we know. It dabbled with citizen soldiers for a while and gave it up in favor of more mercenaries.


That and Carthage was also a republic.

Republics tend to get buffs towards war procurement .
>>
>>18788388
we have New York. that's close enough.
>>
>>18788263
The gayreek kingdoms also suffered from a demographic collapse due to decades of immigration within the hellenistic world (some even ended up so far east they were fighting wars in india or with han dynasty china) thus they did not have the power to raise new armies after losing one like carthage did.
>>
>>18788263
Other posters have correctly explained how they were very rich and had a massive population they could draw from, especially in their satellite cities. The other big edge was that they were REALLY good at boats. Super good at boat and boat accessories. While later the Romans would somewhat catch up, Carthage not only had a massive population of skilled sailors to draw on, but they had this absolutely insane thing that was more or less liberty ships but well made.
>get a bunch of craftsmen
>everyone makes one piece of a ship, and then puts a number on it
>other guys assemble the complete kit like some kind of Iron Age IKEA coffee table
I also like their harbor.
>>
>>18788263
I think - and this is more an educated guess rather than research - that the Greeks were just very bad at empire building because they lacked central authority or a will to build actual unity. they were too busy keeping a hold on their territories and fighting among themselves instead of supporting each other and building strong realms. What made the greeks bad at ruling is an interesting question. Was it something cultural?
If you think of Carthage's strength instead of the diadochii weakness, then it is sea power. they had great naval tech and bases everywhere. And even on land they were an enemy that Rome had to adapt to. Rome's land tactics were evolutions of greek tactics. Carthage was good at logistics, brought wildly different troops to the battlefield and Hannibal was a great general who used stratagems and tactics the Roman's just never heard of. Interesting question for that would be: where did he get that from? was he just good at visualizing the battlefield and imagining what his enemy would do (as Alexander was) or was there a military tradition he learned from where ambushes, ruse de guerre and stratagems were taught to him?
>>
>>18788263
Carthage was republic too and have access to comparable manpower reserves. Successor states have rather small manpower pool and was monarchies that lacked resilience on the face of defeat
>>
>>18788584
they were the Americans of the classical world but of course in their timeline they lost against the equivalent of Nazi Germany (Rome).
>>
>>18788587
Yup. Hell, the 20th century fascist states all liked looking to Rome for inspiration. You can argue to what extent they executed it faithfully, but Rome was a land power with good technology, a fetish for very impressive infrastructure projects, highly militaristic, with an extremely capable professional army. Carthage was very rich, had trade connections everywhere, could draw upon a shockingly broad gaggle of mercenaries, and was very good at boat. So in short, yes. I agree.
>>
>>18788587
With this setting, who would Timoleon be
>>
>>18788263
>How did Carthage of all places prove to be the greatest challenge to the Romans rather than any of the successor kingdoms?
Great men can accomplish great things
>>
>>18788263
When Carthage and Rome were relatively equal all the way up until the end of the second punic wars. Rome at the time could best be described as a regional power not quite the sprawling empire it would later become. Carthage would have won if they actually supported Hannibal and didn't chicken out.
>>
>>18788594
Yeah America leading up to the world wars was really a Republic of Venice type place. No land power, no technology, no infrastructure projects, no capability to marshal up a large army. Just money and trade connections and mercenaries. You sound very smart.
>>
>>18789069
Its probably the biggest proof of great man theory.
All these nerds discussing structural explaations for why carthage and rome were equal can you honestly say tht without hannibal tht carthage woud have lasted even half the time. Hell even a tenth of a time in the second punic war?

Heres what would have happened without the barcids. Rome would have landed on africa nearly unopposed and defeated whatever retard punic general they sent out. They then would have put it under siege. Meanwhile spain would have fallen when some retard guy probably named "Hanno" would have lost against Scipio the elder. And they would have ran away to Carthago Nova and then that would be put under siege. Probably within months the carthaginian senate would be begging for terms from rome.

So much for structural advantages.
>>
That's because many people forget that rome was not an empire at the time but barely a regional power expanding in southern italy
>>
>>18789182
Hannibal was definitely a great man, but he clearly lacked the political ability to wrangle the elite power brokers at home to sustain his army and provide the necessary support to win the war. Hannibal lost because his own home cut off his supplies more than any battlefield loss.
>>
>>18788263
They did it by being a rival while Rome was still small. By the time the legions are heading to the East, Rome got big.
>>
>>18789182
>Its probably the biggest proof of great man theory.

You keep saying this like you want to wear a *debate me bro* hat or something.

Things are almost always grey and then there's the case of the chicken and the egg.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.