[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities


Thread archived.
You cannot reply anymore.


[Advertise on 4chan]


File: HIjDgwIXsAAVp6F.jpg (967 KB, 3850x2809)
967 KB JPG
Thoughts on mixed-member majoritarian representation parallel voting single-vote variant?

>cube root law automated scaling to determine size in unicameral legislature rounded up to nearest even whole number
>50/50 FPTP/PR seat allocation
>electoral districts are relatively equally sized by population
>voter votes 1 time for electoral district leader
>FPTP winner-takes-all district election
>total votes allocated using the Sainte-Laguë method for PR seats
>3 - 5% threshold
>>
>>18788936
Voting for a party instead of a direct representative is anti-democratic and leads to a political class that is rootless and removed from actual concerns to the people. All proportional representation is garbage.

If you must choose something other than FTP, then ranked choice of some form is the only one that makes sense.
>inb4 but what about some ideology that has 5% support distributed all over the place
If an idea is rejected by 95% of the people, then it has no business in running anything. Also, those proportionally awarded seats aren't beholden to any electorate, and so are rootless bureaucratics. The purpose of elections is to construct a community consensus and make decisions as a community. Not to give voice to every schismatic idiot and social reject.
>>
>>18789372
I have literally no representation on any level going from city, county, both state level chambers, as well as the house, senate, and electoral college.
Having only direct representation going all the way up is completely retarded, even ranked choice isn't enough to alleviate it though controlling minorities.
Lower houses should be PR, upper houses should have districts, that way both locations and populations are both represented.
>If an idea is rejected by 95% of the people, then it has no business in running anything. Also, those proportionally awarded seats aren't beholden to any electorate, and so are rootless bureaucratics.
COMPLETELY WRONG
They are more at threat to their voters abandoning them, whole parties have been wiped out in single election many times
They are even more beholden to their voters, as their are other similar factions for their voters to jump too.
Meanwhile direct representation often leads to hated longstanding rulers who can stay in place because people don't want to switch in fears of giving their rivals a plurality win. And ranked choice tends to collapse anyway beyond 5 options at most.
>>
>>18789579
>I have literally no representation
Good. Your ideas are stupid if you can't convince anyone to rally around them. Elections take place in the public sphere and if you have nobody beside you, its because you refused to engage with your community and bring people along with you. That's your fault for being a social reject and shut in, not the systems for failing to coddle you in the safety of your own home. Your social atomism is predicated on the delusion that you're an island not beholden to the society around you. It's juvenile.

>They are more at threat to their voters abandoning them
That isn't the function of elections or elected representatives. Throwing more schizophrenic ideologies into the driver seat actively hinders decision making, which is the purpose of elections. Your 3-5% cut off is totally arbitrary. If some random group of retards at 3% get in, then why not 2%? Why not 1%? Why not .001% Why shouldn't each and every person have their myriad of ideas represented in the legislative body? Representatives are chosen from districts because they are that communities chosen compromise. At-large representatives chosen via proportionality have no community and are therefore beholden to nobody.

>direct representation often leads to
And proportional representation leads to fractured bodies that are unable to function. The value of a process isn't measured in the flaws that might happen.
>>
>>18789838
I don't support any cutoffs, if there are 100 seats, 1% is the "threshold"
>The value of a process isn't measured in the flaws that might happen.
they always happen, direct districts always cause gerrymandering and tyranny of "majorities"
>Good. Your ideas are stupid if you can't convince anyone to rally around them. Elections take place in the public sphere and if you have nobody beside you, its because you refused to engage with your community and bring people along with you. That's your fault for being a social reject and shut in, not the systems for failing to coddle you in the safety of your own home. Your social atomism is predicated on the delusion that you're an island not beholden to
what a way to make assumptions retard
a pure district system is retarded, cause all it leads to is heavy fighting over every level to enforce gerrymandering
any 90% of every election is just parties battling it out, "independent politicians" aren't a real thing, they are always more one party than another
at least PR voting is more honest, and if you want one candidate over another, vote for the candidate on that list, like the dutch do
>>
>>18789995
You are so far up your own ass about parties you can't comprehend politics as anything outside of them as real things. Parties are just organizational tools and what their platforms are always being revised as the membership changes. You're still approaching elections and government as something that gets you what *you* want and not a social process to make decisions and find consensus. That's the idiotic social atomism that you subscribe to. The body politic is not made up of parties, it's made up of widening rings of communities. Those districts represent communities. Your ideas don't find representation because of some voting system, but because their stupid and rejected by the community.

>muh gerrymandering
Once again, the merits of a system aren't the ways it can be hypothetically abused, but the actual merits of it. Proportional representation is just bowing to party bureaucracy as some sort of misconstrued virtue. It's dumb.

>I don't support any cutoffs
>3-5% threshold
>inb4 that isn't me
If you're going to be a child about this, then there's no point in talking.
>>
>>18790013
>You're still approaching elections and government as something that gets you what *you* want
That's what politics is, you vote for who and what you want.
>social process to make decisions and find consensus
I.e voting for what you want
So pr and districts are just two different systems trying to answer the same thing
>Those districts represent communities. Your ideas don't find representation because of some voting system, but because their stupid and rejected by the community.
Lmao, my ideas are held by other people, just not by the majority in the immediate area around me.
Which is the main problem with districts as all you need is a plurality to have all the power
By what right does a "community" have if only a plurality or a slightly majority holds all the power, denying the opposition even just a voice?
Anyways pure pr systems are dead outside of Canada and the US.



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.