Was George Washington a bum and if not does he deserve to be in the GOAT consideration?He lost a 70% or 9/13 of his battles during the US Rev war , especially when he didn’t have the numerical advantage.He didn’t come from complete poverty like Genghis Khan but instead inherited a powerful American army and infrastructure like Napoleon.How is George Washington even in contention with people like Napoleon, Alexander and Khan?
>>18789562Who thinks Washington was a general primarily?
He held the continental army together despite losing repeatedly to a vastly superior fighting force. He was good at organizing retreats that kept his forces intact and part of that is luck and British commanders fumbling their opportunities but it still counts. His personal gravitas was also important for morale purposes since his army had jackshit in terms of supply for most of the war.
>>18789562What caused this melty? What are you?
>>18789562A lot of his positive reputation is that he didn't try to do an Iturbide and make himself monarch or a Bolivar and make himself ultrasupergigadictator-for-life, and instead voluntarily left power for John Adams. They say often with revolutionaries that you're either a good general and a bad leader (e.g Mao) or a bad general and a good leader (e.g Washington)
also he won while those other guys lost
>had no money to pay his troops>had not enough guns, powder, shot, or even shoes to equip all his men>his "troops" were citizen militias who had never served in a real army, and had their own local loyalties and chains of command he had to somehow stitch together into a cohesive force>most of his men had only ever fought Indians, and not even in any of the major conflicts against them, just low level skirmishes, if they had any experience at all>and he was up against veteran British soldiers fully equipped from British armories and led by a competent officer corps >somehow, despite losing several engagements, he avoided being defeated decisively and held his army together>even when they were starving, freezing, and mutinying due to no pay, he got them to stay together and hold out>wins the most important battles when the chips are down>wins the war, despite everythingIf you don't get it after this explanation you simply don't comprehend how many times Washington should have been completely defeated, yet somehow miraculously wasn't. I guess it just shows he is the General's General. He doesn't have an undefeated winning streak like Alexander, he didn't revolutionize war like Napoleon, he didn't pull of insane strategies on the fly like Caesar, he didn't brilliantly outfight a numerically superior enemy with incredible genius like Hannibal. He just stayed in the fight, managed his men, managed his meager resources, and got them to the finish line.
>>18789694I always find it silly how people praise him for not declaring himself king when doing so would have been a death sentence. Jefferson, Madison, Franklin, Adams, etc would have all lost their shit if he tried that.
>>18789571All of his contemporaries. He was referred to as "General Washington" as his most commonly used term of address.
>>18789703Fair enough, being a dictator was the more logically sensible option. We probably would have ended up with a French Revolution situation but with fewer random atrocities on the public and more Sword of Damocles bullshit with many quickly succeeding strongmen until one finally emerged, whether through ruthlessness or through mercy
>>18789562>but instead inherited a powerful American armyIs this a joke? There was no "American army". The US literally did not have a standing army of any kind when it was founded, all it had were state and local militias, which were not standing armies, but part-time citizen soldier forces. Washington basically cobbled together the Continental Army from scratch in 1 year. Which is why it was so badly supplied, under-trained, and poorly paid.
>>18789703Washington was immensely popular in a way that is hard for modern people to imagine because of how generally unpopular US politicians are. It's been decades since we had a president that was actually liked by most of the country.By contrast, George Washington was universally hailed as a war hero, credited with saving the country in the crisis of its formation, and was unanimously elected to office, twice, without giving a single campaign speech or indeed actually running for office at all. Of course, part of the reason for his popularity was being a champion for the republic. So being a dictator or monarch likely would have decreased his popularity from "unanimous" to "overwhelming". He could've made it happen, if he had an ounce of ambition.
>>18789719Most of the Founding Fathers were quite driven towards their new political experiment. The only one I can see really going along with a King Washinton is Hamilton, maybe Adams too if Washington made it very clear that he would be a constitutional monarch. The rest would have been strongly opposed to it, Federalists and Anti-Federalists alike. Washington would had to have purged them before any attempt could have been made, which would mean emptying his entire Cabinet.
>>18789562>this imageWashington was constantly pissed/stressing explicitly because his army of farmers and hillbillies was *not* defeating the British and they desperately needed a Prussian career officer to come in and professionalize this adhoc mob into a real standing army.Washington continued hating militias for the rest of his life and was, by 1790s standards, a diehard militarist in favor of a full-time professional army.
>>18789754all the same the American distrust of a professional standing army held for many generations. after every war the army and navy would be pared down to a bare minimum. there was no prestige involved in peacetime service, which was usually seen as being for losers or ex-cons. this was true all the way until the Korean War.
>>18789562Your kang was kept as a pet by the BritishWashington beated them
>>18789571everyone