[a / b / c / d / e / f / g / gif / h / hr / k / m / o / p / s / t / u / v / vg / vm / vmg / vr / vrpg / vst / w / wg] [i / ic] [r9k / s4s / vip] [cm / hm / lgbt / y] [3 / aco / adv / an / bant / biz / cgl / ck / co / diy / fa / fit / gd / hc / his / int / jp / lit / mlp / mu / n / news / out / po / pol / pw / qst / sci / soc / sp / tg / toy / trv / tv / vp / vt / wsg / wsr / x / xs] [Settings] [Search] [Mobile] [Home]
Board
▼ Settings Mobile Home
/his/ - History & Humanities

Name
Options
Comment
Verification
4chan Pass users can bypass this verification. [Learn More] [Login]
File
  • Please read the Rules and FAQ before posting.

08/21/20New boards added: /vrpg/, /vmg/, /vst/ and /vm/
05/04/17New trial board added: /bant/ - International/Random
10/04/16New board for 4chan Pass users: /vip/ - Very Important Posts
[Hide] [Show All]


[Advertise on 4chan]


We had that 2024 article, and it seems another article on the subject will be published. I don't know if it's accurate. First, that these Roman accounts were, in general, pure fantasy, also why would a society be matrilineal, matrifocal and matrifocal? The 2024 study even used some strange expressions and jargon, saying that men and women could rise to power equally and something of that nature. Isn't it a long way to say that this was a widespread phenomenon in Britain? I used this user only as an example.
>>
>>18793137
Could you send a link to the preprint? This disgusting bald guy you mentioned is biased.
>>
>>18793137
I wrote matrifocal twice. My bad. I meant matrilocal.
>>18793149
https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/evolutionary-human-sciences/article/exploring-matrilocality-in-history-insights-from-ancient-dna/0BB706D43BA41891626D6C02A96FC66D
>>
File: 558.jpg (39 KB, 480x640)
39 KB JPG
>>18793153
>Open the preprint
>Written by a woman
>Red flag
>Thinks that you might be exaggerating and that not all women project their feminist ideology onto their articles >Starts reading and then we see
>"Here, we draw on these three studies to explore past social organisation forms in light of new evidence and reconsider preconceptions that continue to endure over time."

LMAO Why are women like that? the bald guy in the OP's photo probably has some kind of dom fetish or something. He's one of the main proponents of this culture, and unlike what this imbecile makes it seem, they didn't discover a new matrilocal tribe or anything like that. It's just a garbage article that reuses the same old examples: the Celts of southern Brittany, ANF, and Neolithic China. Three cultures separated by time and space. And look at number 3. How do you "debunk" a "preconceived idea" with three examples? And in the case of the Celts, the men could have been killed in battle, and then nobles from other tribes came to marry the remaining women.
>>
File: 1733601549729 (1).jpg (1.1 MB, 3264x3264)
1.1 MB JPG
Patriarchal bros? Our answer?
>>
>>18793174
>OP's photo probably has some kind of dom fetish or something. He's one of the main proponents of this culture
What do you mean?
>>
>>18793174
Considering that the study's based on genetic data, you can consider yourself... wounded by facts.
>>
>>18793189
>Discoursing on the power of women he (Cato the Elder) said: “All other men rule their wives; we rule all other men, and our wives rule us.”
You can't escape gynocracy by means of patriarchy either...
>>
>>18793137
Oh yeah, wasn’t there all that Astronomy stuff and Druids and like Stonehenge and like Apothecaries that were going on around Britannia & the hot news at that time, is that a thing that happened
>>
>Matrilocality means longhoused feminism o Algo
Just a reminder that the society described in the Odyssey (hardly a feminist one) is matrilocal.
>>
>>18793231
did you even read the preprint? Dumb fool. First, as I said, they didn't prove that matrilocality or any other bullshit term you wanted to use was as common as patrilocality. They use three examples as an argument to refute the "prejudice" that societies are always patrilocal. But that's the problem, they didn't refute this pattern by citing three examples separated by space and time. On the European continent (such as Gaul, Central Europe, and the Iberian Peninsula), ancient Iron Age DNA studies show predominantly patrilocal and patrilineal societies, where the male lineage predominated. And this was no different even in Anatolia or East Asia. Eleni Seferidou's preprint, in fact, only cites one tribe, the Durotriges. And the OP's photo is distorting everything.
>>
>>18793259
>Matrilocality means longhoused feminism o Algo
Yes. It does. Next?
>>
>>18793276
Was Odysseus a longhoused feminist?
>>
>>18793259
>is matrilocal
Source my ass
>>18793196
I'm saying that the bald guy you posted, he frequently spams about the Celts being matrilocal and matrilineal based solely on that crappy article about the Durotriges, and that's what the feminist you posted did. This guy is so delusional in his personal theories that he frequently distorts insular Celtic mythology, citing the symbolic marriage of the king with the earth as an example of matrilocality or matrilineality, and that the earth symbolized the feminine. But it's obvious that mythology doesn't tell us much about Celtic society
>>
>>18793288
He is a feminist supposed "white nationalist".
>>
>>18793290
Exactly. Sometimes I find it strange how he's obsessed with proving that Celtic women had "power" in the Celtic world and distorts mythology to construct this narrative. We don't know for sure what happened in the day-to-day life of that society. Ancient DNA only shows who was buried where and with whom they were biologically related, but it doesn't tell the whole story or explain the exact social causes behind it. Extrapolating limited samples from local cemeteries, from a local tribe, to claim that a practice was widespread is, in fact, a very large logical leap.
>>
>>18793290
For example
>>
>>18793302
I see being a feminist as not thinking long term about the survival of your own tribe, nation. Therefore being a feminist nationalist as being dumb.
>>
>>18793288
It is Penelope's husband who gets to inherit the kingship and his property, not Odysseus' biological son.
>>
>>18793308
Yes.
>>18793311
Wtf are you really citing a single example where Odysseus (who didn't exist, by the way) and Penelope, during the 20 years he was away, were pursued by suitors to choose a new husband and assume the throne? are you retarded or something? Their plan was literally for her to leave Odysseus' palace to live in her new husband's house, or for the chosen one to assume direct control of the property. Power in Ithaca wasn't inherited through the female line. The suitors sought to marry her because of the absence of a legitimate king, and Telamachus was practically a child. In Homeric Greece, the norm required a woman to leave her father's house to live in her husband's region. Liar. Fuck, Penelope was born in Sparta and moved to Ithaca to be with Odysseus. How is that compared? That's not the norm, nor was it ever in Greece or the Celtic world. This usually happens when a king doesn't have sons to inherit. I presume something similar occurred in that Celtic tribe. Perhaps this succession issue is due to a crisis.
>>
>>18793329
Was***
>>
>>18793302
Robert Graves is so much worse a lot of the time, so much talk about ‘The Imagination’ & ‘the white goddess’ this & ‘the white goddess’ that
>>
>>18793137
This is a fairly old claim, going back to the late 19th century, it was especially popular between the 30s-60s, and continues to pop up occasionally since.
The arguement mostly hinges on the Roman accounts about Queen Cartimandua and recent DNA studies of graves purporting to show the origins of the inhabitants.
There's not really enough evidence to either confirm or outright dismiss the theory. Though IMO the Romans would have wrote more about it if it were true, they loved writing about that sort of stuff
>>
>>18793336
>The Imagination’ & ‘the white goddess’ this & ‘the white goddess’ that
Awful
>>
There are many people who literally do not give a shit what the truth is, they see it as a tool to further their pet causes while being quick to accuse any criticism of being a remnant of eurocentrism which they have to decolonize or something. They form cliques in universities and among journalists and the media. Careers are made this way.
>>
>>18793337
My biggest problem with the study in question is that it is based on a tribe in the south of Britain, and based on this evidence from uniparental markers, it is concluded that this practice was supposedly common in the Celtic world. But again, as has been posted here several other times, when peoples of the La Tène culture and the Gauls themselves were analyzed, it was shown that it was a patrilineal and patriarchal culture, the same with the Picts who were supposedly said to be matrilineal, except that the few studies we have had on them showed that the social structure was also patrilineal. So what really makes me wonder is whether this case in the south of Britain was not an isolated case or a very specific case, perhaps due to a succession crisis here. I don't know. Quickly, people have been posting this article as conclusive proof that in pre-Roman Britain Celtic queens and women held great political and social power, but there is a small problem with this claim

The same thing happened recently a Celtic king was said to be a woman, based on inscriptions on coins.What the authors and these people forget is that in various cultures, such as Germanic cultures and even among the Romans, several men had names that had feminine suffixes — as is the case with Verica, king of the Atrebates — and there is no other evidence to corroborate the fact that he was a queen
>>
>>18793376
Its over??



[Advertise on 4chan]

Delete Post: [File Only] Style:
[Disable Mobile View / Use Desktop Site]

[Enable Mobile View / Use Mobile Site]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.